CYOA Discussion

>>28885919
>that first comma placement
Pls

>>28885919

>Shit pic

>Edition and Quote about unrealated meme pushed by one or two autistic trolls

Even if no one cares about the OP, I'd like you to know you're being so bad at it that it made me care

Active threads

Persona: >>28858812
War in the North: >>28723740
11-54: >>28812360
Miracle: >>28880978
Warrant: >>28816805
Dirty Work: >>28863976
SIM: >>28752923
Across the Ocean: >>28845271
Outcasts: >>28868907
Bard Quest: >>28774196
Boatquest: >>28851178

DANK MEMES

>>28885919
>dat OP pic

good choice

>>28885937
The guy who made that pic here. I'm not a native speaker and in my first language it's basically "when in doubt, jam in a few more commas".

>>28886386
That's, like, so stupid, like, for real.

>>28886463
Aye.

File: CYOA.png (495KB, 432x576px) Image search: [Google]

495KB, 432x576px

>>28885937
>>28886463
Thanks for pointing it out though.

>>28886485
well now it doesn't matter because you fucked up and it's forever enshrined in the OP because you didn't fix it sooner

File: 1469691985237.jpg (65KB, 784x452px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 784x452px

This is the end.

>>28886512

I miss Hipsanon. He hasn't been here for a fair while.

>>28886512
Those dice aren't the same.

>>28886501
Kinda fitting for this general, don't you think?

>>28886532
True, the 2 and the 5 are switched.

>>28886512
Angel beat her to death

None of your waifus are good.
Why would ever ever waifu a shitty fan character or OC.

Canon waifus are the only good ones.

>>28886608
Shut up nerd

>>28886608

>Wanting to waifu a character who will inevitably be paired up with someone else, ala Fluttercord, and TwilightxFlash Sentry,
>Being a cuck

Shut up dweeb

>>28886613
>Fluttercord
>Flashlight
lmao

>>28886619
shut up dork

>>28886619
You're just mad cause your waifu isn't pure

So shut up doofus

I want gilda to leave

>>28886632
Can it, dweebenheimer

>>28886638

Shut it, Birdbrain.

>>28886645
You first, dunderbluss.

>>28886608
This is true

>>28886628
>implying there are pure CYOA waifus

>>28886666
Nice try Satan, but Angel a purest.

>>28886666
Shit, gotta watch out for crashing airplanes now.

>>28886648

Will you shut up first if I give you all my catnip?

>>28886681
Drugs are for losers, loser.

Nice try. But I'll, uh, take that catnip so you don't do something stupid with it.

Later days, dorkus maximus.

>>28886690

Jokes on her that nip was poisoned.

About as poisonus as the rpfagging being thrown around.
Please stop that.

>>28886722
>No fun allowed

K

>>28886730

>My erps are fun so I should spread them everywhere, including the general made for discussion.

This place doesn't have to be shitpost central. We actually could discuss cyoas here you know.

Here, I'll start: What do you all think of WitN so far? Would you prefer it over a different Fins quest, such as Nine lands?

File: 1273579.jpg (90KB, 531x668px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 531x668px

>>28886747
>Still haven't read it

>>28886747
I think it didn't catch my attention and it's probably at least okay but I don't feel like reading it.

>>28886747
>implying some stupid fun started by calling some guy a dork is erotic in any way.

Whatever.

As for WitN, I don't read it. I haven't had the time to catch up on a few quests, but will be spending my day doing so, so that I can properly discuss them.

Miracle's back though, so that's something I can participate in, if you wanna talk about it.

File: mmfr.jpg (18KB, 325x183px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 325x183px

>>28886747
>WitN

>>28886747
But WitN is Nine Lands.

Also for those wanting to read WitN it's nearly over.

File: 1479277706357.png (294KB, 1400x1100px) Image search: [Google]

294KB, 1400x1100px

Reminder to brushie your Basil.

File: 1273579.jpg (100KB, 696x690px) Image search: [Google]

100KB, 696x690px

>>28886818

>>28886747
>What do you all think of WitN so far?
I reached thread 7 recently, I feel like the speed is picking up and there is more action. I like it. A bit less party interaction maybe, but it doesn't feel like it's lacking, so it's good.
I like that there's interaction between the other members of the party in the background. Not many quests do it.

>Would you prefer it over a different Fins quest, such as Nine lands?
TNL had a great party and great characters. WitN is a bit weaker in that aspect. Don't get me wrong, they're all fleshed out properly and all, but I liked the characters in TNL or in Trottingham more than in WitN.
They're still good characters and a pleasure to read. I think it's at least as good as the end of TNL in terms of adventure.

>>28886818
>But WitN is Nine Lands
I'm fairly sure if you ask about "TNL:TSM", nobody will know what you're talking about.
The actual name of the first chapter is "Tales of the Shovel Mare", right?

File: pinkie popcorn.jpg (27KB, 385x360px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 385x360px

What are some great characters that were wasted? Either on subpar quests or simply underused/killed off too quickly etc.

>>28887011
Shade.

File: 1470875699135.jpg (179KB, 1280x751px) Image search: [Google]

179KB, 1280x751px

>>28887011
Nadine.

We're still getting stuff about her though so that's alright.

>>28887055
That's Silver Spoon, right?

>>28886830
Why is Lis art so qt and why can't we have more

>>28887091
Lis has abandoned us because we were unworthy and also kind of annoying.

Angel Wings is the ideal big mare

File: 1468294737387.png (585KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

585KB, 1200x1200px

>>28887117
Oh

>>28887091

What would you like to see Lis draw Anon?
Not that he is likely to ever draw it.
Maybe if sekrit bugs him enough he will do something nice.

File: 1479323022304.jpg (112KB, 1199x800px) Image search: [Google]

112KB, 1199x800px

>>28886840

>>28887141
Lis pls.

>>28887141
Some DW art would be neat.
Like Tally and Sharpie booping nose to nose

>>28887168

Anon pls.
If I were Lis I would be drawing things and not wasting my talent.

>>28887141
Give and Take's Bowie Bug.

>>28886842
I completely agree. For whatever reason I can't put my finger on I just don't like it as much as previous Fins quests.

That being said I can spend hours coming up with characters and stories within Fins' setting. The entire setting has so much potential it blows my mind. My only complaint is that I don't know enough about the Nine Lands and my greatest fear is that I will never see it all.

>>28887240
Well why don't you ask him to do a spin off if you're so good at it.

>my greatest fear
Calm down a little there

>>28887175
rude

File: 0ccaa45e787a296b27ceb19c3eefe205.jpg (79KB, 640x421px) Image search: [Google]

79KB, 640x421px

>>28887342
Dude, the man was just saying TNL stimulated his imagination, and that it'd be a shame if so much lore was left unexplored

Bard Quest: never forget to appreciates the small pleasures in life, like repeating digits: returns!

>>28887488

File: 8CA4CDF8-28AD-48B4-A09C-ED79F2D93C11-210-0000017E080F1368_tmp.jpg (6KB, 168x168px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 168x168px

What kind of quests do you prefer? Image? Text? Hybridized image and text? Do you like them to be lewd or should sexuality take a backseat to adventure?

And what quest best exemplifies what you look for in one?

>>28887757
Image/text is irrelevent to whether I like a quest or not

>>28887757
Yes

>>28887757
>>28887765
So is lewd v. wholsome. I'm not into lewd pone but if it pops up in a good quest I won't complain.

You got to stop with these which do you perfer questions ponk, I honestly appreciate you trying, but he answer is always the same.

>>28887924
Well all right, then answer me this.

Which QMs are the biggest buttsluts?

File: 9EC618B8-73D9-40C9-A5F3-260BA2F6044E-210-00000186D891C730_tmp.png (6KB, 150x141px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 150x141px

>>28887967
Sorry, forgot to show myself!

Resuming Miracle: Snapping boogaloo.
>>28887974


After deliberation with theother QMs, I decided to run each quest until it 404s. Hail soon (tm)

>>28887757
>What kind of quests do you prefer? Image? Text? Hybridized image and text?
Whatever works best for the quest. Any kind can work, any kind can be shit or detrimental to the quest.

Don't get me wrong, I love lewdness, but lewdness has to be earned. The harder it was to achieve the better. Not every mare should automatically lust for your cock just because you're the protagonist. Also quests focused around lewdness at the core tend to get boring pretty fast. When lewd happens, players should be excited to finally be able to do it. Lurkernon handled it pretty well in RGS in my opinion. Threads upon threads building the tension and then- well you know. I also like it when lewd scenes have some feel to them and are not just "brazzers".

Daily reminder that your creator is always watching you.

>>28887757
Could you do 1/1 quests? A private quest where only 1 person tells you where to lead the story into.

>>28888042
I like this idea

File: CMCC.png (2MB, 1023x1000px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1023x1000px

>>28888037
Daily reminder that CMcC is always watching YOU.

File: Lewdness rating system.png (21KB, 804x295px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 804x295px

>>28887757
>pic related

>>28887757
Satyrs.

File: 12.png (109KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 800x800px

>>28882372
>>28882373
>>28882451
>>28884687
>>28884700
“Hey this is my house! And those are my dicks!”
Did you really just say that?
>“Your house? Don’t you have to spend another day in here before it is yours? Not that I object, you seem to treat the inventory like it should be. And about those dicks,” she says as she fondles a little more with the book “without me there would be no dicks here anyway.”
“Wait, so you're my great aunt?”
Good thing you didn’t call her cute.
>”Yes, I’m the good ol aunty Song Bird. You like the spell I put on the inventory? A little something for fun and make the life easier.”
The books flies back to the rest of the swarm.
>”Admittedly I increased their activity a little.
>”You know, just to make sure the new owner would be able to handle them.”

>”This book here,” she points at the one that she just let go, “It contains everything you need to know about the spell that keeps them alive.”
>”If you want to end the spell there is a magical circle in a small hidden attic. The books can show you the way there.”
>”For me, I can finally move on, as I know the house is in the hooves of someone who can keep up my legacy. Both as independent mare and pervert.”

>>28888206
knowing how to turn it on and off might be good.or at least turn down the output to live your daily life here if it can't be turned off. check it out that book.

>>28888037
I get the feeling that Lauren would really like Across the Ocean, and maybe Honor Serve Cuddle.

>>28888206
Aww. Goodbye aunty, we'll take good care of the place.

>>28888206
Ask if she wants to have some fun before she's gone for good.

>>28888206
Could she tell us more about herself? Before she leaves? Can she come back sometime?

>>28888274
>turning it down
>not turning it up and coming home to bukake every night

>>28887441
>>28887342
Shut up nerd. "He" said he didn't like it as much and then said he could spend hours coming up with charecters and stories, and that the setting has so much potential which he was afraid would go to waste.

And I was serious anyways. He should ask to do a spin off quest that takes place in the same world.

>>28888415
I'm afraid I have neither the time nor ability to run a CYOA. If I did fuck yes I would run a TNL spinoff.

>>28888206
Aww, you mean we don't get a chance to know you better before you leave?

File: 1476421232370.png (93KB, 640x402px) Image search: [Google]

93KB, 640x402px

>>28888447

File: tartarus153.png (14KB, 640x400px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 640x400px

>>28887011
Was just thinking about this earlier, actually.

>>28888592
More boats and more motivation.
More or less.

Running.
>>28888615

File: latest-2.png (895KB, 1260x630px) Image search: [Google]

895KB, 1260x630px

>>28888603
>>28888626
RUN THOSE QUESTS!
GO QMs GO!

File: bump 32.png (696KB, 800x692px) Image search: [Google]

696KB, 800x692px

>>28888676

>>28888676
>>28888790
>They'll never give you a hoofjob with their pompoms still on.

File: 0*HIkNNJkRFzb9CoPG-1.jpg (2MB, 620x7325px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 620x7325px

Dirty Work is longer than A Tale of Two Cities and To Kill a Mockingbird combined

File: file.png (634KB, 1170x727px) Image search: [Google]

634KB, 1170x727px

>>28888852
Really puts our horsewords into perspective doesn't it?

File: 1434095375914.png (56KB, 530x582px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 530x582px

>>28888886
>Bicorn

>>28888990
It may be dumb and narcissistic, but I feel a little tiny bit of pride seeing this.

File: twilight typing.gif (329KB, 233x226px) Image search: [Google]

329KB, 233x226px

>>28888990

>>28889037
We're half a million from 10 million horsewords on the archive.

>>28888990
>Urban is the longest cyoa after Persona
wew

>>28889058
Single persona is already more than half a million. Add all of the quests from that image.

>>28888990
My Little Persona is longer than War and Peace!

>>28888990
I kind of want an infograph of our own now, but I don't have excel on my new laptop yet, which is the only way I know how to do it.

Amm can you pull word count and the CYOA name into a table or csv or something?

File: alcoholism is the only option.jpg (523KB, 3226x2095px) Image search: [Google]

523KB, 3226x2095px

>>28889303
>AtO has a new thread
>you are still on like thread three

Aw shit wrong link.

File: She Can't get up because they have only been laying there for 37 minutes.png (274KB, 1200x900px) Image search: [Google]

274KB, 1200x900px

>>28887172

File: Untitled.png (11KB, 680x337px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 680x337px

>>28889303
Here, a bar graph of the top 10 horsewords

>>28889340
>>28889349
But you were right!

>>28889349
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4CV5UgInnzQ

>>28889367
L-lis
Thanks

>>28889367
Awww Yeaaa. Lispones.

File: 1478971055009.png (37KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 640x480px

>>28816805

>>28889368
That work, thanks.
Wew, look at all them horsewords.

What quests need more fanart?

>>28889407
>>28888603

>>28889407

All of them.
All horses deserve nice things.

>>28889407
Give and Take dosn't have any yet.

File: 1438748153142.png (1MB, 1270x815px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1270x815px

>>28889407

>>28889428

There are enough Whispens in the world Anon. Let the old mare rest. She's had her time.

>>28889368
has anyone started putting a paperponer on top of these yet, just thought I'd ask the hive first before I start this time

>>28889303
http://pastebin.com/r2WGT9Ac

Have fun with that.

>>28889407
landfall.

>>28889424
It has a couple paperpones, but that's all.

>>28889446
Oh nice. I will. Thanks.
>>28889445
Nevermind, I've got new plans.

>>28889407
WitN, Frostbitten, Bardquest, and AtO.

>>28889368
Dirty Work now as much words as Heat? Is it near a conclusion at all? I played Heat and dropped DW early on.

>>28889368
>5th most verbose quest was written by a slav
Gotta respect that determination

File: 1475782814327.jpg (52KB, 426x466px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 426x466px

VAMPONY
WHEN
H
E
N

>>28889494
DW is reaching a point where everything is collapsing around the MC, which is feeling very late 2nd act-ish.

So decently close.

>>28889499
Thanks dubs. I wish it could be better than it was.

>>28889476
http://pastebin.com/kPqa7L3P

Have all the other stats too. It's reformatted into CSV via regex parsing, so some of it might have fucked up.

File: 13.png (161KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

161KB, 800x800px

>>28888274
>>28888318
>>28888352
>>28888362
>>28888372
>>28888447
Man you finally meet this mysterious aunty, and now she has to leave already?
This SUCKS.
“Can you not stay for a little longer? I want to know you a little better. Maybe we could have some fun.”
>”I mean I could stay a little longer. What do you want to do?”
How about.. Board games.
No to childish.
Hmm, poker?
No, you never were good at that.
You could of course try to lewd her…
>”I know what your thinking, and I let you know that as ghost I’m not really able to do kinky stuff.”
Well, that’s that.
“Uh, okay. Not that I would have thought about that…”
“Hahaha”
You try to hide your discomfort with the laughter.

“Well for once you could tell me a little more about yourself.”
>”Sure. In life I was a very reclusive magician. Mostly stuck to myself and studied. My research led me to the point where I managed to bind a animation spell into a transmutation circle. And that is how I got a house full of living furniture that follows my will. Lived a happy life, grew old and passed away.”

“So about that spell, is there a way to tone it down? Or maybe even up, you know for special occasions.”
>”The book contains everything you need to know. Once I have passed on the furniture will completely follow you, so if you don’t want them to give you a good rutting just tell them so.”

>”If you want I can stick around for the next couple of weeks till you fully moved in... So if you still want to have some fun,” she seductively whispers in your ear as she puts a hoof on your shoulder, “say why don’t we join together and ‘explore’ the rest of the home.”

>>28889407
Outcasts and An Historical could use some art

>>28889503
Has Sharp FUCKING FINALLY realized that she is a bad poner?

>>28889570
explore the house with her and learn about it.

>>28889570
Alright. Also, you look A LOT younger than I thought you would.

>>28889570
>So if you still want to have some fun,” she seductively whispers in your ear as she puts a hoof on your shoulder, “say why don’t we join together and ‘explore’ the rest of the home.”

Sure, I'd love to.

Also what inspired you to become a magician?

File: other.png (15KB, 878x337px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 878x337px

Extra crap because I'm feeling generous.
Please note that this isn't complete.

>>28889570
Th-that sounds like it would be nice.

>>28889640
What are all the colors for?

>>28889734
quests

>>28889734
Different quests.

>>28889513
Oh man, thanks again, i wanted to ask for image stats too but then I come back and here this is.

That's okay, fixing and reformatting deliminated text is my thing. This also gives me the excuse I needed to get my laptop setup right.

>>28889864
If you're big on stats there's always this: https://www.anonpone.com/api/cyoa

As long as you can parse JSON you have all the data Anonpone uses as up to date as you want.

File: 14.png (130KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

130KB, 800x800px

>>28889619
>>28889619
>>28889621
>>28889688
“Alright, sounds like fun. So can I ask what inspired you to become a magician?”
>”The books series about Starswirl the bearded. I always liked that as kid.”
“Oh nice, you know, you look a lot younger than I thought you would.”
>”Yeah, seems like your ghost looks like you want it to look. See I never had to many self esteem issues, so I look fine.”

And so you spend the rest of the day having some fun in the house.
You made sure to give the shower a good scrubbing.
It even can put out ectoplasma in addition to warm or cold water, very fascinating.

Then your make way to the pillows.
They had it coming.
You make sure to show them who’s boss in here.
Oh and the mattress was actually alive too.
It just was a little shy.
You work your hooves the best you can to make sure it overcums that.

After that your aunty suggest to play 3 minutes in heaven in the closet.
A little dark, but filled with a of drillers.
It made sure to take care of all the good holes, and even gave you a little shower.

Ghost pony even shows you a new way to learn.
You know that some ponies consider learning to be like hammering knowledge into your head.
But you never heard about sucking it in.

In the living room you ride it out for the rest of the day, until you pass out on the couch in there.

The next morning you're woken by knocking from the door.
It’s the executor of will who is checking if your still in the house.
Now with your deed done you can sign the ownership documents.
Ah you can’t wait for all the fun you will have in your new home.

I realized we never gave our good smelling drill mare a proper name. With what name do you want to sign the documents?

The end.
Thanks for playing.

>>28889935
I vote Potpourri as the name of the pony.

>>28889935
Spiral Growth

Alchemy will continue on the 28th.

>>28889935
Musty Flowers

>>28889935
You just blasted through everything else that happened without any player input and absolutely no lewds. That's what, one or two days of nothing? UNACCEPTABLE!!!

>>28889976
Shut up perv.

>>28889935
Cork Screw

>>28889935
>Then your make way to the pillows.
>They had it coming.
>You make sure to show them who’s boss in here.
>Oh and the mattress was actually alive too.
>It just was a little shy.
>You work your hooves the best you can to make sure it overcums that.
>After that your aunty suggest to play 3 minutes in heaven in the closet.
>A little dark, but filled with a of drillers.
>It made sure to take care of all the good holes, and even gave you a little shower.
>Ghost pony even shows you a new way to learn.
>You know that some ponies consider learning to be like hammering knowledge into your head.
>But you never heard about sucking it in.
>In the living room you ride it out for the rest of the day, until you pass out on the couch in there.
>The next morning you're woken by knocking from the door.
>It’s the executor of will who is checking if your still in the house.
>Now with your deed done you can sign the ownership documents.
>Ah you can’t wait for all the fun you will have in your new home.

Shame there are no pics for this epilogue.

>>28889982
Even ignoring the lewds, that's a lot of time and potential actions that were completely ignored. this was a terrible place to put an epilogue. Although having our aunt's ghost show up[ and give us a guided tour does kinda rob the possibility of anything interesting happening. We had most of the house we hadn't explored and we haven't interacted with most of the furniture. We weren't given a chance to figure out anything about our aunt (other than her being a huge pervert) or to find out why everything in the house was so perverse. So much lost potential, and lewds.

That thread has been up for 2 hours and I only just noticed it
>>28889059

It's called "welcome to detrot CYOA", it has simple images, and it updates every 20-30 minutes.

>>28889971
Yay.

>>28890022
Just fill in the blank spaces with your own lewd fanart.

You do know how to draw, don't you? Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm?

>>28890033
I do stick figures badly.

File: Capture.png (29KB, 305x58px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 305x58px

>>28890042
Prove it. Give me the sexiest stick figure you possibly can.

What are you waiting for? DO IT!

File: unknown160.png (76KB, 584x668px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 584x668px

What CYOAs have made fun of other CYOAs in a funny/meaningful way

>>28890059
Nothing by res that's for sure

>>28889971
Finally.how was the break?

>>28889935
I'm satisfied. Thanks for the fun little Halloween quest, you draw great poners, I really like your style. In case you were curious, my question was if this was based on an old story that horror lit nerds like me would know called "The Haunter and the Haunted or The House and The Brain" I've since figured out that it wasn't, since we never found a horny brain in a jar

>>28889976
>>28890022
You jerked of one piece of furniture and fucked another.
You uncovered the reason behind the strange furniture.
Beyond this point everything is just repeating to fuck whatever furniture comes your way, and going through the motions.

Also this was announced as a short quest.
I'm sorry, but what you seem to have expected goes over the boarder of what I consider to be a short quest.
I ended it here because from my point of view there would not be much more to uncover or any major new events.

>>28890206
>Although having our aunt's ghost show up and give us a guided tour does kinda rob the possibility of anything interesting happening.
I did acknowledge that there was no point in continuing, but it still is a bit annoying that the event that essentially ended the quest occurred so quickly.

>>28890206
I felt like we could've learned a bit more about the aunt and of the house.

>>28890256
>>28890266
You anons suck, It was supposed to be fun little thing that the QM did for us for Halloween that they needed to wrap up. You're acting like entitled strokes.

>>28890291
Those guys are the reason cyoa is dead.

Lets shun them!

>>28890042
You have yet to deliver on those stick figures anon.

I'm disappointed.

File: Untitled.png (23KB, 1050x676px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 1050x676px

>>28890328
As a different anon, here is your sexy stick figure horse.
She's wearing socks.

>>28890416
Wew, looks good. Thanks anon.

She got a name?

>>28890438
No, I just picked colors that were in the ms paint quickbar.

>>28890438
How about Sticky Socks.

>>28890567
That's a good one. Everyone that stick poners name is Sticky Socks now.

Do with her what you will.

File: sketch1479354616500.png (320KB, 800x1280px) Image search: [Google]

320KB, 800x1280px

>>28890576
>Do with her what you will.
You're ok with tasteful nudes then, right?

>>28890788
Ooh, yeah, that's tasteful.
If you've got anymore tasteful stuff, feel free to post.

File: sketch1479355940886.png (183KB, 800x1280px) Image search: [Google]

183KB, 800x1280px

>>28890801
I wasn't going to post this one because it's pretty explicit, but as long as you understand the artistic value it's OK.

>>28890947
W E W

Might wanna spoiler that next time bud, this is a blue board.

Good stuff though, keep it up.

>>28890059
Two words:
Animal control

>>28890956
Oh shit, I thought that was spoilered.

I wish I could keep it up but I started having pains in my wrist from all the intensive drawing of Sticky I've been doing. I just got back from the doctor and they said it's carpel tunnel. First schoolwork takes up all my time, then this happens. I'm really sorry to all my fans.

Hopefully another anon can carry on Sticky's legacy.

>>28890981
I don't get it.

>>28891031
Res thinking clever

File: Sticky Socks.png (143KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

143KB, 600x600px

>>28890416
>>28890947
I drew her a little thick. I like a little meat on my mare's bones.

>>28891148
My man. Doing Sticky Socks proud. Careful not to go overboard, there's such a thing as too thicc.

Hey, Cardboardpone anon, If your around you think you could do a Sticky Socks?
She's here to stay, I think.

>>28891148
>I like more flesh to strip.

FTFY.

>>28891194

>Appears four times total.
>Been here less than two hours.
>Only appeared in one thread.
>Immediately pushing that she is here to stay.

Okay Anon. You force those memes. Good luck.

>>28891148
My legacy, ruined! Defiled!

I love it, great interpretation with the markings

>>28891148
I love big assed white chicks

>>28891194
Fuck off.

>>28891246
>>28891265
No u

>>28891281
Go back to running that quest no one reads.

>>28891285
...That actually kind of hurt.

Guys, don't fight over stick ponies.

>>28891347
She's stunning.

>>28889935

She's cute, it's too bad she'll probably never end up having sex with another living creature because she'll get too complacent and spoiled by the easy constantly available furniture sex.

>>28889407

Blord

>>28891148
>that lingerie
>them freckles
>them Bath style hooves

Damn that mare hits me right in the fetish. Bath, you're too good at pressing my buttons

File: 32 - epGaYos.jpg (112KB, 960x624px) Image search: [Google]

112KB, 960x624px

oie rules, cyoa drools, kys niggers

>>28891347
>That snootle
>Them ear floofs
>Them Lis style questioning eyes
Damn that poner hits me right in the cute. SWC you're too good at pressing my heart.

>>28891451
I'm too sad to care, but fuck you anyway.

>>28891387
>hoof fetish
Jump off a cliff

>>28891451
You're just using this thread to roleplay in place of oie at this point, aren't you?

File: Fleet Cares.png (115KB, 827x389px) Image search: [Google]

115KB, 827x389px

>>28891480
I like Bath style hooves nonsexually, can I stay?

>>28891480
>t. normo

>>28891559
Poor little thing. I would hug her any time after treating the hangover holy shit

>>28891480
It's odd because nobody but Bath's hooves do that to me. Even then it's a comparatively weak fetish to me.

And with that, the Persona DLC CYOA has been completed and archived.

Who is the best protagonist and why?

>>28892898
Parcel. Interesting, humorous, and forward motivated without stealing any agency from the players.

>>28892898
Sharpie, but that's just my opinion.

>>28892927
I actually find Parcel boring, but that's just my opinion again. He has a bad case of JAD. All the supporting characters are more interesting than him.

>>28892936
I agree with both of these statements.

>>28892898
The best MC is any pony such that they are in possesion of an actual personality comprised of both strengths and flaws, said strengths and flaws providing a framework within which players can operate and have a context for making their decisions, as opposed to just being a generic good-hearted adventure person who is just an empty vehicle for player ambitions.

>>28892952
On that note, would you rather choose those strengths and flaws yourself during character creation, or do you only care that they're there a la premade.

>>28892898
I would pick either Chalk Dust or Treads.

>>28892996
Oh you poor bastard.

>>28892952
Agreed.

>>28892986
Both is fine, but when building a character from scratch or modifying a "base model", there should be a good point system. Like "choosing a flaw gives you more skill points you can choose other strengths from". Doesn't have to be points though, it should just even out.

>>28892986
Either, and they don't even have to be balanced. It can be fun to play a character with more flaws than good points. Sharpie comes to mind.

Where the mares with altitude at?

>>28889640
Oh wow, I'm up there with the greats!

>>28893195
Cloudsdale.

>>28893195
Their QM's couldn't handle them so they left to hang out with cooler dudes.

>>28890567
More like stinky socks lmao

>>28893456
wow, uncalled for.

File: sigmund-freud-photo.jpg (52KB, 330x363px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 330x363px

>>28892796
They're cleft, it's not hard to figure out why.

File: Fleet cares 3.png (120KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

120KB, 600x600px

>>28892668
It's ok, she's up and fighting these days.

>>28893542
I'd still hug her drunk.

>>28892863
Is it? I don't see it on anonpone.

>>28893565
He probably means the last thread died.

>>28893670
I never had the slightest idea what was going on in those threads, and that includes the first one. I think you had to have played the game.

File: Sticky Socks.png (1KB, 128x128px) Image search: [Google]

1KB, 128x128px

>>28891194

>>28893772
Oh my god, how did you make a paperponer so lewd.

>>28893699
Even the original quest? I didn't think it was that hard to understand. I know some of the players hadn't played a single Persona game, so they mostly just stayed quiet during combat and posted during the SoL sections.

>>28893805
Step one: Add socks
>tfw no art of CYOA pones in socks

>>28893850
I find that hard to believe. hold on.

File: Chooser_trying_on_500_socks.png (336KB, 1200x1000px) Image search: [Google]

336KB, 1200x1000px

>>28893868
I know there probably is, but even still it's not enough.

File: 1476811087558.png (1MB, 853x1024px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 853x1024px

Do bloody leg bandages count?

File: 1459204919605.gif (34KB, 250x223px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 250x223px

>>28893850
What about Flo?

File: 1459128825285.jpg (67KB, 755x379px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 755x379px

>>28893882
My god, you're right.

The only one I had was flo, and I can't remember if those are socks or just what her legs look like.

>>28893882
Share your socks Choosie.

Actually nevermind, I bet she just turns them inside out instead of washing them.

>>28893850

>Tfw SWC died right before he was going to draw his pones in socks and scarves.

>>28894007
quiet, you'll spook him, you have to be more subtle

>>28894040

[Spooked Lis sounds]

Sometimes I worry that I am the only one left who is not in sekrit club and everyone who once talked to me is gone.

>>28894148
I don't go to sekrit club, but I don't really like you, so avoid talking to you.

>>28894148
I''m there drunk feel free to talk to me

>>28894148
>>28894173
>>28894183
It's pretty much just us four.

>>28894148
I don't go to the klub either.

>>28893699
ive played the games and that quest still doesnt make sense.

>>28894183
You ever talk to a drunk person when you're sober, it sucks. No offense.

File: 1479414110895.jpg (134KB, 827x1096px) Image search: [Google]

134KB, 827x1096px

I think this dancing pony is really cute, not much to talk about though. Just QM appreciation posting.

>>28894148
Club is becoming a new breed of OiE over time, I'd rather not go there

>>28894274

What do you mean by this? What do they do in there?

>>28893812
>>28894206
I think I just lost patience after the first thread, I remember there being namefagging and hijacking going on and I gave up because the OP didn't seem very committed and I expected it to disappear. Then when I revisited it I was completely lost.

>>28894289
Ungodly things

>>28894251
AtO Basil is best basil.

>>28894289
talk

>>28894305

How dare they.

>>28894300
Lis pls

>>28894300

Objectively true.
Seeing as there are no other alive Basils.

>>28894319
Hi yes? It wasn't me this time.

>>28894295
Oh. I think you're confusing it with the other short-lived Persona quest some completely unrelated person did this year. Igor's Persona Quest started 2 years ago and finished last year, then some people made a reunion thread this halloween so he decided to write a "bonus DLC" story for it.

>>28894330
Ohhh, I was.

>>28894323
>Not loving the dead

Also Hi

>>28894236
The thing is to never be sober.

>>28894330
To clarify, people made a reunion thread because idea of it was suggested in one of the "post game" threads year ago. For both start and end of story anniversary. Everyone waited for it, apparently

File: 9-19.png (30KB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 200x200px

War in the North continues. This super old pic will do the trick to announce the session:
>>28894412

>>28894423

Did you really put the word 'super' right in the announcement?
F-Fins please, this isn't like you. Are you okay?

File: 1479416656588.jpg (11KB, 321x114px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 321x114px

Since it's been asked a few times:

These are my two favorite quests right now. Either I'm weird or it just goes to show that people will follow quests from opposite ends of the edgy spectrum Having art helps in my case but that varies

>>28894423
I would be following this too if I was caught up.

>>28894449
Sometimes I just bait a little. I can't really affect anything, I'm just a pawn. Besides, I've always liked using it, long before memes.

>>28894476
Think you can give my edgy quest a try?

>>28894500
Which one?

>>28894449
>>28894498

>>28881607
>>28881618
>>28881624

>>28894507
Crystal one.

>>28894509

>>28894550
Fuck off

>>28894566

>Still falling for the Coltquest hating meme
Don't you know? Coltquest is good now. Everyone loves it.

>>28894566
Stop being a rude faggot.

>>28894525
Oh, yea, I've always planned on reading that. I was in the first threads but quit when I realized it was a continuation, it's on my shortlist of CYOAs to catch up on.

File: where do you think we are.png (54KB, 300x100px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 300x100px

>>28894575

>>28894573
>>28894550
Just fucking go to the other chan for christs sake. There is literally no reason not to.

I'm 100 percent confident not only will your players follow you there, but you will gain new ones.

>>28894605

Well that's silly.
Coltquest started on this board, and belongs here. Why should it have to move?
Why don't you leave instead Anon, if you don't like it so much, when it is an integral part of CYOA by now.

>>28894703
>Coltquest started on this board
So did fluffy ponies

File: 1465616463857.png (19KB, 125x206px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 125x206px

>>28894703
>integral part of CYOA

>>28894703
it takes some balls to type a flat out lie like that.

>>28894703
>it is an integral part of CYOA
I don't think you know what integral means.

Bard Quest: Who needs pacifism when you can have a +5 beheading wooden stick? Returns!

>>28894736

File: RIP.jpg (114KB, 800x775px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 800x775px

Remember best girl

>>28894575
>>>/s4s/

File: Nest.jpg (77KB, 628x329px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 628x329px

>>28894760
This edit made me sad after I made it

File: 130063464762.png (77KB, 1024x768px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 1024x768px

>>28894703

>>28894577
One anon did a reacap of the first quest but it might be a good idea to read it first, true.

Running.
>>28894978

>>28889971
woo!

>>28894423
SUPER

>>28895096
OLD

>>28894703
>a
>foal's
>adventure

File: Untitled.gif (2MB, 1500x1500px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1500x1500px

Resuming Miracle: Blinking boogaloo.
>>28895117

File: 1469146952944.png (15KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 400x400px

>>28895063
That's pretty neat yo.

>>28895113
MEME

>>28895171
Wow, forgot that image was there. I was going to ask what happened to that quest.

Wheres DITA?

>>28895188
>>28895208

Ded. Both ded.

>>28895208
Dead.

>>28895208
Didn't DitA have a tumblr or something?

>>28895215
>>28895221

Where have all the good QMs gone and where are all our gods?

>>28895250
Dead.

>>28895262
What are we going to do with all these dead bodies?

>>28895305
Use science to resurrect them and force them to do basic manual labour for us for free.

File: ICanAlmostTasteIt.gif (309KB, 480x320px) Image search: [Google]

309KB, 480x320px

>>28895305
We fuck them

>>28895305
Join them.

File: KIMG0183.jpg (665KB, 2560x1440px) Image search: [Google]

665KB, 2560x1440px

I might not run tonight because I'm stuck in traffic in a blizzard and I'll probably end up getting home pretty late.

>>28895569
Okay. Be safe Bath!

>>28895569
blizzards are for snow bath.

>>28895569

This could have been avoided if you had taken pony form like the rest of the QMs.
Everyone knows that pony fur coats are immune to snow.

>>28895618
Not him, but if I were a pony I'd still use a car.
It goes faster with no effort and you don't feel the cold at all.

>>28895569
Blizzard? Where do yo..actually just drive.

>>28895683

I'm pretty sure Bath is somewhere around Colorado.

>>28895758
Oh mountains, right. I live in the midwest so I forget that those are a thing.

>>28895765

>Tfw live near coastal mountains but never get pretty snowstorms.

>>28895758
So, will Trump outlaw weed again? Or will he legalize it to pay for his wall?

A mini, kind of a CYOA thread, is going on over here
>>28894648

>>28895797
A mini, kind of penis, is going on over here
>>yourpants →

Does it feel like a trial?
Did you fall for the same empty answers again?

>>28895994
?

>>28895994
Vilify
Don't even try

>>28896021
Ballerina on the coffee table cock in hand?

>>28896056
It's a common fetish, for a doting man.

>>28896081
Got it, i won't fuck us over.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qzhNdCxhK28

File: hqdefault.jpg (14KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 480x360px

All they want for Christmas is

>>28896445
(you)

>>28896445
their two front teeth.

>>28896445
A miracle.

>>28896445
Irradiated Windigoes.

>>28896445
A nuclear winter.

>>28896445
for someone to care.

>>28896445
A reason to live

>>28896445
a dreidel.

>>28896717
>>28896741
I have bad news for the both of you.

>>28896756
It's a Christmas wish. It doesn't have to be realistic.

>>28896445
The answer was...

A Pony

>>28895250
Where's the streetwise Angel wings to fight the rising odds?
Isn't there an anon guard upon a waifu steed?
It's gonna take a bottle cap to sweep me off my feet.
I need an MC.
I'm holding out for an MC till the end of this board.
He's gotta have loot and he's gotta be cool and he's gotta have all the fresh memes.

>>28896813
6/10