/who/ - Doctor Who General

ZA IS NO LEADER

File: file.png (219KB, 481x675px) Image search: [Google]

219KB, 481x675px

>>87055753

F

File: d08-7y-501.jpg (105KB, 700x527px) Image search: [Google]

105KB, 700x527px

Does anyone know if there's a download available anywhere for the extras from the blu-ray edition of the tv movie?

File: exploitable 12.jpg (76KB, 720x960px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 720x960px

>>87055703
>thought my post got lost in the sea of facebook posting
>Meltypaldi is the op in the new thread

today is a good day

doctor whomst

>>87056436
Oh shit I just realised you made a trip!

Welcome. You'll get your secret trip discord invite within 3 to 6 working months.

Damn Karen Gillan was such a qt in the season she first appeared in.

File: thoughtful mcgann.png (723KB, 755x725px) Image search: [Google]

723KB, 755x725px

>>87056436
Eh, fuck it. I managed to find and buy a copy of the DVD version, which I'm pretty sure has all the extra features on it anyway.

>>87056845
Thanks, Lym. I figured I might as well; my posts were recognisable enough as is, and this'll make it easier to find certain conversations I'd like to revisit. Plus, now people can filter me if I annoy them.

And I await the invite expectantly - can't wait to secretly plot the downfall of /who/ with the rest of you.

if the doctor showed you the psychic paper, what would it say in your case?

Doctor Who is dead.

File: Peter_Cataldi.jpg (59KB, 640x640px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 640x640px

The 12th Doctor is now a cat.

Introducing Doctor Mew

We ready for the last episode of /jodiekino/ tonight?

File: Amy-pond.png (2MB, 1294x1600px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1294x1600px

>>87057132

Only tangentially related, but the composer for Trust Me is incredible. I really hope there's a soundtrack release of it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Onono

>>87059338
I haven't actually been watching it, kept slipping my mind. How many episodes are there?

>>87060697
Only four! There's a lot of plot conveniences, but Jodie is definitely the best part about it.

>>87060765
Huh, didn't realise it was just a mini-series. I haven't actually watched Jodie in anything yet, so I'll have to give Trust Me a try.

>>87060822
I'd suggest watching Adult Life Skills too. It's a weird little film, but she gets some very quirky Doctory moments.

>>87060225
Why does that picture make it look like she's just been revealed as the new Doctor?

>>87060931
I think it's the coat

How would /who/ rank all of the Robert Holmes stories? Because mine would be from best to worst:

The Deadly Assassin
Talons of Weng-Chiang
The Caves of Androzani
Spearhead from Space
The Ark in Space
Carnival of Monsters
Pyramids of Mars
Terror of the Autons
The Time Warrior
The Ribos Operation
Brain of Morbius
The Sun Makers
That one episode of The Ultimate Foe
The Two Doctors
The Mysterious Planet
The Power of Kroll
The Krotons
The Space Pirates

is jodie whittaker in any comedies?

>>87061376

Adult Life Skills: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RW0B0HvVW4Q

>>87061421
Wait, what? How come I heard of this film before?

File: 12th Doctor eyes.jpg (62KB, 750x358px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 750x358px

>>87058508
Saviour of Felisfrey and Destroyer of Dogleks

>>87061421
We should watch the film on stream some time. Tomorrow maybe?

>>87061421
shes qt

>>87059338
There is no way this is going to satisfyingly resolve in 14 minutes.

File: all13.png (629KB, 1097x613px) Image search: [Google]

629KB, 1097x613px

>>87061541

>>87061918
>everything that just happened
LOL

File: file.png (875KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

875KB, 1280x720px

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=abbgEoOAi08

What did they mean by this?

>HE GOT HIT BY A FUCKING CAR


HAHAHAHA HOLY SHIT

File: 1275057244037.png (393KB, 466x512px) Image search: [Google]

393KB, 466x512px

>>87062054
>>87062496
>that whole ending
I'm glad I didn't actually watch all of this series.

>PLOT CONVENIENCE AFTER PLOT CONVENIENCE AFTER PLOT CONVENIENCE

not even someone as kino as Jodie could save the "I'm sorry,
but daddy died" line

How would you feel if it turns out to be a ruse and Jodie Whittaker was only The 13th Doctor's companion and not the 13th Doctor herself?

>>87063065
I'd feel like it would be pretty dumb to lie about that for no reason

>>87063065
That would be cool because then it would allow for someone like Kris Marchell to take over.

>>87063065
There's so dumb that I can actually see it happening and just plain dumb.

Your statement is the latter.

That was as tense as fuck

File: thinking.png (258KB, 488x521px) Image search: [Google]

258KB, 488x521px

>>87063065
It'd be pretty stupid, but ultimately my feelings on it would depend on who the actual Doctor ended up being.

>>87063107
>kris marchell
what a lad

Do you agree?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mh8xyDlLXfc

>>87063440
Is it wrong of me to find 42 to be completely boring and always making me want to skip it?

File: feral cataldi.png (428KB, 636x700px) Image search: [Google]

428KB, 636x700px

>>87062035
hmm, maybe you would prefer a more antropomorphic cataldi

File: 08-29-17_2-41-57 PM.png (276KB, 1024x768px) Image search: [Google]

276KB, 1024x768px

>>87063332
>>87063109
>>87063107
>>87063086
>>87063065
I started work on the true 13th Doctor. I hope you can see where I am going with this.

It's suppose to be Chris Chibnall.

So was there any nudity in the final episode?

File: paul mcgann sonic screwdriver.jpg (144KB, 720x826px) Image search: [Google]

144KB, 720x826px

>>87063440
He makes some fair enough points, and the sort of... over-use, I suppose, of the sonic screwdriver in new!who (which isn't a Chibnall-exclusive problem) really does irk me. Just because its existence in its current form - i.e. a magic wand that can pretty much do anything - allows them to forgo a lot of potentially interesting plot resolutions. Instead of the Doctor coming up with something legitimately clever or having a more hands-on approach to solving a problem, he just waves his sonic around a bit and it's all good.

An excellent example of that was in 4x01: Partners in Crime. Fun episode, but the overuse of the sonic was blindingly apparent in it. He even used it to untie someone, for fucks sake. Instead of taking a second to unknot the cables around her, he points his sonic at them, they spark and fall apart. It's such a minor thing, but it really demonstrates this idea that the sonic has become regarded as a sort of all-in-one plot solution. It's not a huge deal, and it doesn't always arise as an issue, but it's not as fun or interesting to watch when you get something like the bit in The Power of Three where waving the sonic at a screen is enough to totally undo a villainous plot that was a year in the making. Rest of that ep was comfy, at least.

Sorry, that wandered a little off-topic for a bit. I only mention it because it's a minor problem I'd like to be solved and Chibnall's track record, as highlighted in the video, doesn't give much hope for that.

>>87064236
That's really good, anon. My only recommendation would be to make the hair a bit darker, but other than that I can totally see the resemblance.

>>87064248
Yes. Jodie got her bum and her tits out for an extended sex scene.

>>87064674
kek

>>87063065
I don't think they would use a woman unless the real Doctor choice was also a woman. There would be so much feminist butthurt going on and would be really bad pr. I think this day and age a fake casting would be the only way to do a genuine surprise regeneration but I don't think they would do it.

>>87064565
I gave up on making him. I just didn't care enough.

>>87064695
But then you also risk alienating all of these crybabies who don't like change.

>Fucking humans! Accept these alien races or else!!!
>Get off from Gallifrey you fucks! This is MY planet!

Why was Capaldi such an hypocrite doctor?

File: Stop right there.png (8KB, 576x497px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 576x497px

>>87064882
What the fuck did I just read?

>>87064882
I'm going to ignore the first line of this post since it doesn't relate to the other situation.

The answer is that you're citing an episode in which the whole point is that the Doctor is breaking his moral code and it's a bad thing.

>>87063552
Not at all. The only good parts are the scenes with Martha's mom and The Master's dudes which aren't even important to the main plot

>>87065173
The Master was involved with that story? I honestly do not remember shit from it other than the movie Sunshine.

Why do I have the feeling that regardless of how terrible some of the Chris Chibnall episodes are from his time as showrunner, Jodie Whittaker's Doctor will be the saving grace?

>>87065218
There's a bit where Martha's mom is on the pine with her and she's being watched by Saxon's men

>>87065302
*on the phone with her
Jesus I'm retarded

>>87065273
Any Doctor will 'save' bad episodes, but the episodes will still be bad in all other respects.

>>87063440
I agree, but I'm willing to give him a fair shot to prove me wrong. I just wish that being showrunner for Doctor Who didn't also mean writing a quarter or more of a season's episodes.

>>87065273
Because that's what happens every fucking time.

>>87065302
>>87065377
Was the episode that forgettable that I completely missed this even during the first time I ever viewed it?

>>87065273
Well that's the same with all the showrunners really. I feel like there have been no "bad" doctors so far. Some that are worse than the others, sure, but no one I would say did a bad job and no matter how shitty the script the Doctor always does a great job

File: five-ish-doctors-reboot-steven-moffat-playing-with-dolls_4.png (315KB, 825x464px) Image search: [Google]

315KB, 825x464px

>>87065273
She probably will be. Or maybe Chibnall will really shine when he's got a whole series to work with rather than a random one-off episode. He might end up the opposite of Moffat, in a way, since some of Moffat's best episodes are those with self-contained stories that could theoretically be watched in total isolation and still work well, whereas he stumbles a bit when trying to knit together a coherent series-long plotline.

>>87065424
Blink is a good episode ruined by every moment where Tennant appears.

>>87065447
Probably yeah. I forgot about it until I re watched it a few mounths ago

>>87065504
I kind of want 13 to have a male companion and the two of them have a natural chemistry together much like Diana and Steve in Wonder Woman. Why is this?

File: lungblankrow.png (414KB, 350x576px) Image search: [Google]

414KB, 350x576px

What's the canon Lungbarrow cover art, /who/?

>>87065585
>Why is this?
god I hate this meme

File: 6th doctor.jpg (304KB, 2048x1536px) Image search: [Google]

304KB, 2048x1536px

>>87064007
how about the 6th doctor as a scarlet macaw?

>>87065758
>lungbarrow
>canon
that's a controversial statement you've got there, my friend

File: Hartnell_Loom.jpg (22KB, 271x237px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 271x237px

>>87065758

Hello, /who/. How is everyone?

File: professor-chronofur-issue-1-digital-edition-pdf-63379.jpg (27KB, 350x538px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 350x538px

>>87058508

I support a transgender companion.

>>87066470
meant for >>87065758

File: David 10 Ant.jpg (99KB, 1280x960px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 1280x960px

>>87065799
>>87066321

Not just fur, all animals, this is Doctor Zoo after all

File: lungbarrow cover edit.png (249KB, 350x576px) Image search: [Google]

249KB, 350x576px

>>87065758

>>87066321
Why?

>>87066665
That's funny.

File: war of the cletuses.png (3MB, 1002x6512px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1002x6512px

HOLY SHIT my fake facebook account has unleashed a huge wave of drama. This is the exact reason I made that account.

>>87067301
Whoa. That's a lot of text

>>87067301
Lym, pls stop posting into the abyss. I'm getting scared the abyss will stare back.

>>87067117
Did another story can't say it's great, but at least i finished it.

https://pastebin.com/EFwE4m6N

File: AGSP-Confetti-19.jpg (34KB, 510x596px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 510x596px

>>87067301
bravo

>>87067470
What was the first story you did? Just want to make sure.

>>87063065
I think it's more likely that she would be the Doctor for the Christmas special alone, with another regeneration at the end.

>>87067117
What's the progress on Shit Trips?

Bradley Walsh is still gonna be the companion, right?

File: Screen Shot 2017-08-30 at 00.13.05.png (519KB, 1440x754px) Image search: [Google]

519KB, 1440x754px

So I was searching on facebook for links to the wiki to see if anyone had posted one, and I found... uh... this???

>>87067933
>still
Why, anon, did you think something happened?

>>87067943
/who/'s influence spreads to the most unlikely of places

>>87067943
lel
They probably googled to find the image and used the one hosted on the wiki without caring about the source.

>>87067766
It should be done soon.

>>87067933
Not necessarily.

>>87067569
A Cruel Fate: https://pastebin.com/e0aybQqj

>>87068482
Gotcha. Yeah, I remember that.

>>87067990
I thought it might have been fake news.

File: tve16804-20071225-1628.gif (55KB, 320x240px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 320x240px

Now human beings worship the great god Santa, a creature with fearsome claws and his wife Mary. And every Christmas Eve, the people of UK go to war with the country of Turkey. They then eat the Turkey people for Christmas dinner, like savages!

File: 1409554655804.jpg (267KB, 715x1024px) Image search: [Google]

267KB, 715x1024px

>>87069046
Let's not forget the Clive Swift interview.

>>87067301
I can't believe my stupid suggestion about a Gareth rant caused so much drama hahaha, someone send him a screenshot

Why do so many Shit Trips fic writers write "the Doctor" as "The Doctor"? Even in the middle of the sentence? It's a error I've seen several different independent writers do.

>>87069611
t. Doctor

>>87069611
Probably because when it's said aloud it sounds like a full title, as though "the" is a part of it. I mean, it sort of is (except when referring to him directly) but when it's written down it doesn't flow so well if it's capitalised.

How many hours left for shit trips

>>87070069
Probably drop in another 10 or so if last time's any indication

>>87070069
>>87070248

You have till the end of the 30th.

Also, I'm laughing out loud at the "30 different Doctors" fic.

>>87070248
If I submit one in the next six hours or so am I too late is what I'm wondering

>>87070316
No, you're not.

Also, for Shit Trips 3, would y'all use the Spell-check feature before you send it to me.

>>87070541
lmao, did you run into a minefield of they're/their/there errors or something?

>>87071068
No. It's a lot of paragraph formatting errors.

>>87070541
How does it check? I'm confused.

My intuition is telling me to not let the Adam Orford story in. It's a good story, but I have the feeling it'll lead to more trouble than it's worth for /who/ in the long run.

>>87071661
Weren't you going to change the names?

>>87071203
What kind of paragraph formatting error turns up in spell check?

>>87071661
He's been pissed at us for like two years anyway, not sure what it would really change. And like >>87071695 says you can just do "Madam R. Ford" or something

>>87071712
It wasn't just the paragraphs. It's also some misspelled words.

>>87071695
>>87071787

Yeah, but considering how crazy DWSR can get, I'm not sure I want to even risk it.

>>87071818
If the name is changed what's the issue. Just flatout make it a name that sounds nothing like his if it's an issue.

Anyway, how's /who/ doing?

well i wont be reading shit trips

>>87072216
shit now that you have injected your morality into our anthology

>>87072216
Why didn't you respond to me man
>>87071892
I'm very grateful for your hard work on shit trips, I'd just like everyone's contributions, if all the names are changes then what's the risk

File: 1461438997031.jpg (64KB, 626x574px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 626x574px

I have a bad feeling that the Christmas special is gonna be complete shit we were lucky that the s10 finale ended up being GOAT

Is Zagreus good?

>>87072437
I'm thinking about it. DWSR were willing to sabotage a memorial for Capaldi's era just to get autographs. That's a level of crazy you don't want to mess with.

Thank you for your gratefulness.

>>87072437
it shouldn't be changed
he should respect the author's work
if he wants something uncontroversial he should go somewhere else
this is 4chan

>>87072487
Me too. I want it to be kino so bad but it has to juggle being a good Christmas special, being a good send off to Capaldi and Moffat, and being a good multi-Doctor episode and I'm not sure the Moff can do all that in an hour

>>87072558
fuck those faggots
seriously stop being a pussy

>>87072597
>being a good Christmas special
Literally the only Capaldi special that bothered with that was LC.
>being a good send off to Capaldi and Moffat
Moffat's already said he doesn't care about sending off himself.
>and being a good multi-Doctor episode
Only featuring two Doctors makes this less difficult than it sounds.

>>87072558
Then let them come. Just my opinion, but let artistic integrity win: only when the author wants to change the names, then you should change the names. Otherwise, keep the names intact.

>>87072558
sounds like an even better reason to take the piss

>>87072677
>Literally the only Capaldi special that bothered me was LC
OK, so? It still is one more thing it has to juggle
>Moffat's already said he doesn't care about sending off himself
Well it'll still have to be a proper send off to Capaldi
>Only featuring two Doctors makes this less difficult than it sounds
But a good multi-Doctor story should be about the chemistry between the two (or more) Docs, when this story should be sending off Capaldi. Also, a large part of the fanbase probably hasn't even seen very many Hartnell episodes so they'll have to reintroduce him and his companions

>>87072747
>>87072641
>>87072593
I'm fine with immigrant changing the names , but he's taking about literally not including it at all , that's what I don't want

>>87072747
this
i cant believe censoring it is even an option

>>87072868
Are you the actual author?

honestly whats next?
moderators editing our posts?
fucking trips man

>>87072791
>OK, so? It still is one more thing it has to juggle
I'm saying it doesn't have to "juggle" that to be good, and it probably won't, if Capaldi's previous Christmas episodes are any indication. Mysterio has a Christmas tree in it for like 1 minute. Literally all you need is some minor decoration,

>But a good multi-Doctor story should be about the chemistry between the two (or more) Docs, when this story should be sending off Capaldi.
An episode solely to tribute Capaldi is redundant when Heaven Sent exists. Giving him another character to play off, even a fake Hartnell, doesn't take away from the fact he's the incumbent Doctor and it's his story that is going to be the most important. Dovetailing with the first ever regeneration is also bestowing an even bigger honour on Capaldi's by weaving it into the lore.
>they'll have to reintroduce him and his companions
I seriously do not expect the companions to be relevant beyond ten second cameos when One exits/returns to the plot of The Tenth Planet.

>>87072948
how would you know if it were
you really didn't think this through

I just don't understand the problem if the names are changed. There's no risk if the names are changed. Why still hesitate about including it?

>>87073144
its anon problem if the names are included
gallifrey is just being a faggot

>>87073144
I guess he's afraid Adam will raid us or some shit since it'll still be clear who it's talking about? I think we should stop being pussies and keep it since it sounds like a kek story

The closest /who/ has ever been to 'trouble' is people finding the wiki pages about them on Google and reporting it to the Wikia admins, which has never actually 'caused trouble for /who/' so much as just resulted in the page getting deleted. (This has happened like 4 times now and we're still here.) Something buried in a 200+ page PDF file is guaranteed never to be relevant.

>>87073296
If it's not actually his name then he has no grounds for any action or complaints, we'd be fine

>>87073333
Fwiw I've seen Reddit read the shit trips too

File: run boy run.jpg (368KB, 1024x593px) Image search: [Google]

368KB, 1024x593px

>>87073144
Yeah, the likelihood of Stalkford actually reading Shit Trips in the first place are low, and even if he does there's nothing he can do about it. I could understand being hesitant if it were taking the piss out of someone different, but this guy is a total creeper and bully. Fuck him.

(On a related note, it really doesn't need a "content warning" in the front like last time. We're one click away from boards devoted to trap hentai, a bit of filth is expected.)

File: 1503680078106.jpg (107KB, 878x1158px) Image search: [Google]

107KB, 878x1158px

>Being afraid of some creepy manlet that even the cast of DW hates
wew

>>87073408
Yeah I know, honestly I think it should just have his actual name like what's the worse he could do to us?

What's the longest pre-title sequence in New Who?

motion for someone else to run shit trips next time or assign gallifrey a babysitter

>>87073535
Longest is apparently Doctor Mysterio at 9 minutes.
Runners up include Pandorica and Big Bang both at 7 minutes.

if you must put a disclaimer in front of it
dont fuck with the artist's integrity

>>87073737
I mean, he's put plenty of work into it, and the end product last time was basically good, it's just a couple little things like this that I'd quibble about

>>87072529
If you want a 40th Anniversary, Multi-Doctor spectacle Zagreus is terrible. If you want to hear Big Finish give everything they got no matter the outcome then it kills a few hours. Zagreus is ultimately a mere stepping stone that transitions the Eighth Doctor's audios up to that point to the controversial Divergent Universe arc. It's not nearly as big a deal as it probably should have been. Doesn't help that the very next Eighth Doctor audio is Scherzo which is GOAT tier.

>>87073939
censorship is a big fucking deal man, especially among friends.
the disclaimer in the last one was to far
this is 4chan not some knitting circle where we sit clutching our pearls
i can not believe that every reply to the mere suggestion was not fuck offerino

>>87074124
It should just be something like "It's a collection of writing from 4chan, what do you expect to see?"

gallifrey wont reply to any of those criticisms
spineless

>>87074368
I'm thinking about it, and making a decison.

>>87074309
still goes to far
should just read "a collection of stories from 4chan"
the rest should be inferred and if not its the readers problem

>>87057971
...Long live Doctor Who.

>>87074435
faggot
its not your choice
thats the point
if you change anything strip the name shit trips make no references to /who/ or 4chan and let the authors retract thier works if they wish

>>87074513
The author of that story gave me permission to change the names, actually.

File: paul72.jpg (583KB, 1000x1403px) Image search: [Google]

583KB, 1000x1403px

Putting my EDA knowledge to good use and giving each of the books a wiki page, cus nobody else has done it already, surprisingly. I'll try catch up to where I'm at so far in my read-through, then I'll be able to make a wiki page for each book as I finish them, instead of all at once. Anyways, if anyone's interested in the first one:

http://doctorwhogeneral.wikia.com/wiki/The_Eight_Doctors

I'm gonna have to rewrite the actual EDA page to have a place to put the links, probably, but I'll get round to that when I have a better grasp of wiki formatting.

>white washing scene
>female doctor

Why do you fags still watch this crap? It's not even good.

http://www.strawpoll.me/13819828
put it to a vote /who/
shit trips censorship

>>87074611
oh really
prove it

>>87074621
Because of reasons.

>>87074621
S8 and 10 were better than anything under Smith

File: masterbait.png (15KB, 310x313px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 310x313px

>>87074765

>>87074818
No b8. 8 in particular has most eps above average (Caretaker was a bit dull and Forest of the Night didn't quite work, but that's it.)

shit show for cucks

>>87074655
see the results gallifrey
no one thinks its your decision
most dont want you to change anything
if you do you wil be going against the general's wishes

>immigrant voting with his computer and phone
top kek

>>87075043
Okay. However, I think that link >>87074655 gave my computer a virus.

Are you the same person who got annoyed by me constantly posting about Shit Trips?

christ

>>87074985
Nobody disagrees.

>>87075043
Honestly at this point I think you just have it out for Immigrant.

>>87075166
>gave my computer a virus.
thats really fucking sad mate
we have been using strawpoll.me forever here
suggesting that you got a virus there is just pathetic
any respect i had for you is gone
im not the only one that has a problem with you censoring entries obviously.
man like wow

>>87075344
really?
has anyone ever had a problem with strawpoll?
if you cant see he is completely full of shit this general is dead

>>87075428
All I see is that he is trying to be as cordial as possible with you and you're just looking for new ways to tear him a new one.

is Rick & Morty basically the american Doctor Who?

>>87075428
>>87075363
Why do you type like that?

>>87075497
all i see is him deflecting and power tripping
pun intended
he needs a new ass ripping

censorship goes against everything 4chan stands for
prove me wrong

>>87075428
It's okay, anon. I'm sorry for whatever I did to annoy you but here's an e-hug.

>>87075497
Thanks. I'll think about what to do.

>>87075549
No, Legends of Tomorrow is.

>>87075549
I feel that Legends of Tomorrow fits that description better

Both Cloisters silence speaks volumes

>>87075570
And all I see is you looking for (You)s and looking for more excuses.

Last call, on me.

@Guy and Immigrant, neither of you are actually engaging with the angry anon's points. It's a bad look on you to just ignore and demonize rather than address their arguments.

>>87075649
fuck off tripfag
people like you need to die
fucking tumblrites

>>87075649
how does his dick taste faggot
all im looking for is a little spine

>>87075735
It tastes good

>>87075686
As far as I've read, the original author has given his permission to change the names within his own story at Immigrant's discretion.

If it was about changing the names in all the stories, it would be one thing, but it's not, it's about changing the names in exactly one story, whose author has given permission to do so.

As far as I am concerned, it's already been addressed, and the argument is being dragged out longer than it is.

File: 10masterWHYCANTWEBEFRIENDS.png (190KB, 500x293px) Image search: [Google]

190KB, 500x293px

Wew lads.

I have two questions for you.

>Would you consider Eight to be Classic or Nuwho?

>Do you consider Eight being half human to be canon?

>>87075806
You didn't address him claiming straw poll gave him a virus, when we've all used it for years

>>87075811
Neither. He can't be either.
There is no canon. But he wasn't joking in the movie if that's what you mean. The master noticed it and later the Doctor confirmed it. It was never meant as a lie or a joke.

>>87075806
where?
if it exists how do we not know a random anon isn't just taking the claim to end said argument
or are we just taking gallifrey at his word
i dont think gallifrey has the objectivity to edit anyone's story
there should have never been any question to disclaim or edit anything aside from spelling

>>87075811
Technically Wilderness, though if I had to pick, it would be Classic, as he's closer to that era than modern Who.

On the fence on that.

>>87075686
That's a good point. Part of the issue is that every author I've asked had no issue with me making edits if I wanted to. Even before I made the name-changes, I asked the author, and he said "yes."

/who/'s culture isn't quite the same as 4chan's culture. And "free speech" doesn't give the right to be cruel, or mean. Even Orford, despicable as his actions are, is a person; and I'm not sure Jenna Coleman would appreciate a story where Orford mind-controls her into sex, no matter how admittedly funny the story is.

Also, I don't want Orford to get ammo to unfairly criticize this wonderful community, just for one story's sake. He's already claimed we slandered him, despite that not being true. Some people are too unstable in their reactions to play jokes on--they take the reaction too far. I don't want /who/ to get banned because someone misinterpreted a joke story in /who/.

It's those sort of concerns that made me squeamish. It's not necessarily content--I made almost no edits to a "12 and Clara BDSM dungeon" explicit fic, after all.

>>87076019
I lump him in with Classic

>>87075938
Hrm. Do you think that a trait like that could lie dormant and only show up in a few regenerations?

>>87075895
this too
gallifrey is full of shit
he only claimed this to keep people from viewing it
he is basically a liar interested in saving his own ass

>>87076104
free speach absolutely entitles you to be nasty and mean.
thats the fucking point
how old are you

>>87076108
I think it was retconned away, which is fine, but it's bullshit when people act like it wasn't the intention for 8. When you watch the actual movie it's crystal clear.

>>87076104
So why not just change the names and avoid the issue. Why bring up thinking about not including the story at all in the thread earlier? Do you get that if you do that, someone will just edit it back in and put that version on the wiki instead?

>>87075549
>>87075602
>>87075609
Legends doesn't really have the same spirit as Doctor Who (I still love it though), I would say the original Star Trek is the most similar to it

File: d08-7y-553.jpg (307KB, 1280x903px) Image search: [Google]

307KB, 1280x903px

>>87075811
>Would you consider Eight to be Classic or Nuwho?
Classic, if I had to choose. But he sorta occupies his own niche in between, and imo he's the Doctor whose stories best pushed the boundaries of what the show (or, rather, its universe) could really be, just by virtue of the fact that he existed mostly in mediums that allowed for that sort of creativity without all the restrictions of budgets or technology. So, in a way, he's his own sort of thing: the only true wilderness era Doctor.

>Do you consider Eight being half human to be canon?
I've talked about this before, but yes and no. There's no real canon, so it's whatever one chooses to make of it. Eight himself refers to it throughout his novels and stuff, but it always comes back to this idea that he doesn't really know himself, and his timeline is so twisted and complicated that it's almost as if anything goes. (And, as I've mentioned previously, the half-human thing is a tricky one because of the significance it detracts from the Doctor's willingness to engage with and help humanity. There's a lot more gravitas to it when he doesn't really have a reason for it other than out of the kindness of his own hearts.)

>>87076108
>Do you think that a trait like that could lie dormant and only show up in a few regenerations?
It's kinda implied a few times that that's sorta what happened. Like, all his other regenerations are fully Time Lord, but for some reason Eight has some fundamental genetic differences. But that stance will change depending on which books you read and all.

File: brightred.png (2KB, 167x40px) Image search: [Google]

2KB, 167x40px

What does /who/ feel about the brighter red on YouTube

>>87076187
>edit it back in and put that version on the wiki instead

That's the plan--get 'em to do some of the work for me!

No, but that's a good point. Not sure if they'd go through with it, but it's a good point.

Alright, the story is going in.

Even if I hadn't put in the anthology, I would have left a link to it on the wikia anyway.

>>87076383
blah blah i hate immigrant
blah blah censorship
blah blah ass ripping

>>87076383
Cool. Your heart is obviously in the right place but yeah /who/ is /who/ so that story is getting out one way or another.

>>87076104
I would think that that would be protected under the umbrella of satire and you're over thinking it. Repercussions be damned, and I say this as someone that's personally been attacked and faced a backlash for shit /who/ or a /who/re has pulled in the past. As for my fic personally, after tonight's thread, if you wish to make any changes to my story, please I'd rather it be omitted.

>>87075811
I would say that the eighth Doctor is half human because of how the medicine messed up his regeneration, at least that's how I interpreted it. There is no canon tho so who cares

He's neither really, he's the perfect blend that Classic fans and Nuwho fans can both love

A hybrid, if you will

>>87076454
Hmm. I'm still thinking of just doing a link on the wika.

>>87076521
Cloister, I barely did anything to your story. Why would you want it omitted? :(

Remember that time Faction Paradox showed up on the Muppet Show? https://youtu.be/xe95sn0cN3k

>>87076568
I guess the thread just rubbed me the wrong way. Please remove it.

>>87076521
This. I appreciate immigrant and his caution for protecting /who/ but he's forgetting /who/ is /who/ and he's a custodian of the shit trips, not a leader. You're over thinking it immigrant. It will be fine and if anything bad happens (it won't) nobody would blame you.

Again, if you just add the story as a link, another anon will just edit the pdf to actually include it. If no one else does, I will.

>>87076625
But I haven't changed anything in your story. Please let me keep it. Pls.

Immigrant pls, you're literally driving writers away now. Please stop thinking shit trips is your thing instead of /who/'s thing. Include all the stories. Don't over think it.

>>87076652
The story is staying...in its original form

>>87076672
Look, I had my doubts about it, I didn't want it to be a talking point and I certainly didn't want it used in any justifications or sited in policy. The last thing I wanted it to be was controversial. Take it out.

>>87076722
Cloister asked you to remove it tho. What a mess. Please just relinquish trying to control /who/. We are entitled to our memories.

>>87076762
But it's not controversial. I'll take it out, but I'd rather it be kept in. I'm sorry.

>>87076804
I'm talking about the DWSR story. That will be kept in the original format.

Ironic isn't it.
We all thought the increasing number of trips would lead to drama from a new trip.
How amusing it was actually one of the old ones.

>>87076258
>It's kinda implied a few times that that's sorta what happened. Like, all his other regenerations are fully Time Lord, but for some reason Eight has some fundamental genetic differences.

Huh

I'd accept this desu

>>87075811
>>Would you consider Eight to be Classic or Nuwho?
Neither.
>>Do you consider Eight being half human to be canon?
reeee, no

>>87077074
Yeah, it's not really that far-fetched when you remember that Time Lords can regenerate into other species anyway. I mean, Romana could, if that blue-skinned form she briefly had is anything to go by. Given how regeneration works, it's believable enough that they could change at least partially into species with similar cellular structures. But that's just one theory amongst many, really.

>>87077481
There's always the idea he was contaminated by the surgery somehow, too, like maybe one of Grace's skin cells or something got in the way of the regeneration energy and fused with his DNA (a bit like how Ten gave the Dalek slaves a little bit of his genes through the lightning bolt, in Evolution of the Daleks)

File: Class_HYPE_train.jpg (371KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

371KB, 1920x1080px

Remember these days?

>>87075811
>Would you consider Eight to be Classic or Nuwho?

Neither. He's the wilderness Doctor.

>Do you consider Eight being half human to be canon?

No, since I am pretty sure it got retconned. But I can't say I care one way or the other.

File: d08-7y-028.jpg (125KB, 620x700px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 620x700px

>>87077696
Yeah, that's another possibility, and perfectly viable too. The thing I like about the whole half-human thing is that there's really no right or wrong side to it. It's really representative of Doctor Who's canon in general: it's ultimately what you make of it. With so many conflicting concepts, you really just gotta pick and choose for yourself what you like best of it all.

>>87078277
This is why I adore Doctor Who. There's so much content and it's essentially up to everyone to decide what is or isn't canon. Not to mention the fact that it's almost impossible for one person to run out of Who content to enjoy

>>87077699
It's so barren.

>>87078745
I suppose so...was that foreshadowing?

>>87077481
McGanon, thank you for your Eighth Doctor appreciation.

File: d08-w1267.jpg (90KB, 1181x709px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 1181x709px

God, I was just posting this picture for the sake of sharing it, because it's nice, but it reminded me of how stupid Eight's console design is. Not aesthetically... it's just that weird date/time/era thing you can see in the pic. why

>>87078383
>There's so much content and it's essentially up to everyone to decide what is or isn't canon.
Indeed. As much as people can try to pretend otherwise, there's truly no right or wrong, which means that everyone is free to enjoy what they want and have it be just as valid as everything else. Of course, you could technically feel this way about anything, but at least in Doctor Who that's the official stance. It's comfy!

>it's almost impossible for one person to run out of Who content to enjoy
Yeah, and by the time you've made a significant dent in all the stuff that already exists, there'll be even more waiting for you that's all brand new. Sometimes, I don't think Who fans truly appreciate just how good we've got it.

File: 10-rose-hug.gif (488KB, 376x226px) Image search: [Google]

488KB, 376x226px

>>87079081
'Scuse the double post, didn't catch your comment in time to add it to my previous one. But, aww, no need to thank me, Immigrant. It's what I'm here for! (Well, it's not the ONLY thing, but y'know...)

"Eight appreciation," and here I am absolutely slating his console in my previous post. kek

>>87079174
I feel like Doctor Who is the only show where you can decide what is canon and it doesn't ruin it. Like, if I decide I don't like something in say, Star Wars, it completly changes the rest of the movies and won't fit, where as Doctor Who has this giant mythos like the Greek mythology one single thing doesn't make a big impact

>>87061217
>Krotons worse than Kroll
>The Deadly Assassin being the best

>>87079302
The real redpill is when you do what neo says and apply it to everything, even star wars. Canon is a scam.

>>87064236
I thought you were going for Kris Marshall.

File: eye spy.png (446KB, 748x572px) Image search: [Google]

446KB, 748x572px

>>87079302
>I feel like Doctor Who is the only show where you can decide what is canon and it doesn't ruin it.
Pretty much - at least of all the shows I can think of, anyway. It's just the nature of it all, with the malleability of time itself being such a core concept of the show, it allows so much wiggle room in regards to what may or may not have happened.

>if I decide I don't like something in say, Star Wars, it completly changes the rest of the movies and won't fit
To an extent, yeah. Of everything that's out there, something like Star Wars is probably most comparable to Doctor Who - not just for the space stuff, but because it too has an expanded universe that explores certain concepts in far greater depths than the movies ever could, or would. But it "suffers" (if you could call it that) from having an established canon, so all those SW Legends fans got properly btfo'd when Disney took over. Not that they still can't enjoy the content, but it must feel a bit different to those fans knowing that The Powers That Be essentially declared their favourite stuff non-relevant, and officially non-existent in that fictional universe they love so much. I feel bad for them, and somewhat glad I never allowed myself to get properly into the Star Wars EU, because I know I'd have been pretty dismayed about it all.

But, eh, the whole basic premise of Star Wars is one that leaves room for the possibility of alternate universes, so hope isn't entirely lost. The difference between that and Doctor Who, though, is that with the latter, it's not a case of "there's one singular established line of stories, but everything outside is an alternate universe entirely" because that's as good as saying, "well, this stuff is canon, and that stuff is not, but if you'd like to *pretend*, then go ahead!" which isn't... necessarily good, either. Instead, Doctor Who is more like "listen, who fucking knows? it's a mess. it's too confusing to decide what's canon, so you do that yourself."

how many hours are left to submit a shit trip

>>87079174
>date and time are set to the original airing of AUC
ayy
But yeah, the calendar thing is dumb.

>>87080072
You have till 12:00 AM EST on the 31st.

File: seventh_doctor_by_coconut_cocacola.jpg (230KB, 900x1171px) Image search: [Google]

230KB, 900x1171px

>page 7

File: brain.png (437KB, 600x836px) Image search: [Google]

437KB, 600x836px

generic brain meme to deliver a definitive tier legend of expressing emotion at doctor who related media

>>87081277

McGanon, any way you could get me a short drabble about 8 and a companion of your choice by 11:59 EST tomorrow?

File: d08-w1109.jpg (226KB, 1280x960px) Image search: [Google]

226KB, 1280x960px

>>87081322
I can probably manage it, yeah. I've been in a writing mood lately, so I'll see what I can whip up. Might do a new!who companion meeting Eight, actually. That could be fun. I did submit that long as fuck one with Eight and Sam, but in hindsight it's not very good. I need to work on developing my characterisations a bit so they're more recognisable.

>>87081277
tfw emotionless slab who has never cried to doctor who

>>87081394
I liked your descriptions. You have a nice writerly voice.

>>87081449
This stupid goddamn show is the first TV show that's ever made me cry

File: d08-w0809.jpg (45KB, 604x453px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 604x453px

>>87081529
Thank you, Immigrant! I'm probably strongest with exposition, it's the dialogue I stumble with. I haven't written fiction in years, so I'm pretty rusty, but practice makes perfect.

Gonna type up some ideas for that short fic now, but I haven't decided on a companion yet: any suggestions/preferences?

>>87081449
Heh. That's not a weird thing, don't worry. Some people just don't get overly emotional at stuff - or at least, not enough to cry.

>>87081740
What scene has made you cry the hardest? For me, it's probably Eleven's regeneration - as soon as Amy appears, I just lose all composure.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4F84WapAH7M

>>87081869
Your choice, really. Maybe Martha?

>>87081897
Oh, that'd be interesting. Though, I haven't watched any Martha eps in a while, so no promises but I'll see what I can do!

>>87081869
If I admit what it is /who/ will absolutely rip me to shreds kek

File: magnifying-glass.png (317KB, 352x352px) Image search: [Google]

317KB, 352x352px

>>87081987
Is it, by any chance, Ten not wanting tuggo?

>>87082066
I don't remember crying to that. Maybe the first time, though? I'm not sure.

Weirdly specific things get me all emotional like Cassandra telling herself that she's beautiful before dying in her arms

File: 8.jpg (415KB, 1080x1440px) Image search: [Google]

415KB, 1080x1440px

>>87081897
>Martha meets Eight just after Grace leaves his company

File: beast below.png (807KB, 759x427px) Image search: [Google]

807KB, 759x427px

>>87082184
Interesting... Also, I vaguely remember getting emotional over that back when I first watched it, so don't worry - you're not alone there.

The "smaller" things (if you could call them that) that really get me in the show are all the references to how utterly lonely the Doctor is. Maybe it's just because it hits home or whatever, but even a passing comment about it and I'll end up thinking about it a bunch and making myself sad.

>All that pain, and misery... and loneliness. And it just made it kind.
beast below confirmed kino for this line alone

I cried it journeys end when tennant didn't actually regenerate. Just long woeful tears of frustration.

I weeped when jodie was cast

>>87082462
Yea, I don't understand all the Beast Below hate, I think it's comfy desu

>>87083089
I know someone who hates that episode

Man, Paul McGann's career still baffles me. He did some great stuff over his career and was a big deal for a few years. Now he's doing a soap and not one of the better ones either. Shit agent, the lack of parts for actors his age (especially for those who don't have a few BAFTAs), the curse of sci-fi, failure to network adequetely, or what? He might have done a few duds but you can't really blame the actors for shit direction and wank writing. He's a good actor, especially on stage IMO.

The Muskateers sent out a press release calling him a guest star for a three minute stint, and he just helped give a tiny independent theatre company's national tour press coverage they wouldn't have got without him. Coverage of Ahearne's B&B focuses on his name too. That makes him a good choice for supporting roles at least, surely? Few actors his age still have a name. :-/

I miss capaldo and simmchad

Matt Smith died.

File: d08-w1066.jpg (169KB, 1200x799px) Image search: [Google]

169KB, 1200x799px

>>87083244
He's definitely still a recognisable name with older generations - hell, most of the McGann brothers are. It's kinda surprising that his career has, for want of a better word, stagnated, because he's definitely talented (and as you say, he's particularly good on stage) and he's definitely well known. And he looks exceptionally good for his age, too, so even if there's a lack of roles for actors within that specific age range, he could easily pass for someone younger. There's nothing about him that would suggest he'd struggle to get roles, so I can only assume he's not pursuing them by choice. He's got a net worth of over £5mill - at least according to various websites - so maybe he's just not that much in need of work, and is choosing less intensive roles (like Holby City) out of a desire to continue acting, without getting too heavily into it, at least for now.

But, eh. Who knows? It's a mystery, and the only person who could shed some light on it is McGann himself.

>>87083089
Visually, it's not as good as it could be - except for that hug scene towards the end, that was GOAT. It played with a lot of big ideas that sorta got lost in translation from script to screen (which Moffat himself admitted), but the story is solid enough, and always gets me right in the heart no matter how many times I watch it. It's definitely a comfy ep.

Guys
Guys I'm fucking crying
Turn on BBC 3 right now

>>87083915
oh god. poor matt...

>>87083915
>>87083924
What the fuck its actually real

>>87079372
>Deadly Assassin being the best
That's because it is, anon.

>>87082462
For all his faults I thought RTD's run had a greater amount of small emotional moments during his tenure. While Moffat seemed to have started with good intentions in Season5 there are quite a lot of "this is how you should feel" points that don't quite hit in the seasons that followed.
For example Eccleston's tear when Jabe says how sorry she is about his planet in The End of the World, understated and explained quite clearly how pained he is, not many Moffat moments can touch that.

>>87083915
>Turn on BBC 3
Kek

>>87084035
I couldn't disagree me but I'm so tired of explaining my pov. I respect your opinion. I would die to defend your right to speak it. But I will never, ever share it.

>>87084035
Eh. If anything, Moffat underplays his emotional moments TOO much. I can't count how many times I've seen people not notice hugely powerful moments in the Capaldi finales.

>>87084035
If the main character literally crying clearly in the frame is your idea of understated, I'd hate to see what you consider overstated.

They cast a new "doctor"?
Doctor who?

>>87084076
>I respect your opinion. I would die to defend your right to speak it. But I will never, ever share it.
silly centrist

The discord is inevitable. Deep down we all know it's eventually going to happen. The form I see it taking is a publicly open Discord that either starts off as a joke amongst the trips+regulars, or develops off the GURPS game we eventually do.

PROS
-No captchas
-No post time limits
-No worries about janitors, bans, other 4chan issues
-Built-in stream

CONS
-Some possible drama (no more than we'd have anyway)
-Not everyone comfortable with instantaneous chat
-Leeches off /who/ (not really, if it's public then it's just an offshoot like the stream, /who/ is /who/ regardless of whether it's on 4chan, cytube, or discord)

MORE PROS
-Can use different channels
-Bypasses the whole tripcode debate/drama
-Keeps out boardies

>>87084342
i wouldn't be opposed to a discord where discussion of doctor who and /who/ events was completely banned. so it'd only be used for things considered off topic here

>>87084429
That's...actually a interesting idea. Would bypass people get annoyed at so much off topic talk, but keep /who/ /who/.

>>87084342
>The discord is inevitable.
It's really not, anon. People value the format and anonymity of 4chan too much, and the publicity of it all. I doubt anyone would want to break that up, and even if they did, they'd have a hard job convincing any significant amount to join. It'd be dead pretty quick, if it would ever live at all.

>>87084429
>>87084467
Significantly off-topic stuff is sparse enough that it doesn't really warrant a whole chat for it, imo. It at least keeps /who/ a little bit more active than it otherwise would be during off-season.

>>87084429
>discussion of doctor who and /who/ events was completely banned
I dunno how long that would last

>>87084542
Then why are there so many trips? Obviously the community is morphing into something where anonymity is being valued less.
This is not a bad thing but it's naive to act like there aren't some valid points here.

Just saying...I'd totally join a discord just to not have to deal with captchas and post time limits.

kinda hyped for the discord desu senpaitachi

>>87084342
Why are you so obsessed with this?

>>87084717
Why are you so obsessed with vainly preventing the inevitable?

>>87084771
>we
>Anonymous

hoo dis

File: d08-w1122.jpg (22KB, 812x540px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 812x540px

>>87084623
There's a fair amount of trips, yeah, but it's hardly as though we outnumber anons. I guess it might seem that way sometimes when a lot of us are active and talking at once, but I promise you, we're still in the minority here.

I do understand the points being made, though - by no means am I trying to discredit them. I just don't think a Discord would be well received by the majority on /who/, and if one was made, it would inevitably leech activity away from here, when it's already lacking at times during off-season. I personally don't see any good reason to effectively split the community like that, and alienate certain people who might prefer one format over the other.

Speaking of trips, I forgot clearing my cache and all that shit removes mine. end me

>>87084791
Me. I'm just an idiot.

>>87084841
Good points (whether you're making them as an anon or as a trip!).

I suppose I just don't really agree with the idea that /who/ is inherently tied to 4chan forever. Does that mean the wikia somehow isn't /who/? The streams, maybe you could argue (although I'd disagree), but the wiki, nothing is more /who/ than that. So the leeching activity, I get it, but I see it more as leeching from 4chan rather than leeching from /who/. However there is benefit to the archives on 4chan now I think of it.

Perhaps Cats idea of an offtopic Discord is best, I know some anons and trips get self-concious about talking about offtopic things at length (they shouldn't be, it's only natural for conversations to go different directions).

In any case, I don't think there's a rush or anything, but I do think the fact offseason /who/ is so comfy between the regulars (be they anon or trip) will eventually lead to something changing. Not a bad thing at all, a good thing, but a change, very Doctor Who in spirit.

Also for the record, not all these Discord responses in the thread have been me if it looks that way, I didn't say >>87084745
for instance.

File: paul86.jpg (48KB, 615x409px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 615x409px

>>87084919
>I suppose I just don't really agree with the idea that /who/ is inherently tied to 4chan forever.
In a way, if we're going to get all poetic about it, /who/ is bigger than just the thread on 4chan, yeah. It's a pretty unique community for a general thread, and a comfy one. But ultimately, /who/ was formed here initially, and this thread is at the core of it all, so even if it was agreed - for whatever reason - that a move elsewhere would be beneficial, you'd find people resistant to that just on principle. All the stuff like the streams and the wiki - they're not replacements for the general, just off-shoot little things that provide something 4chan itself cannot; either someplace to watch things together, or a place to document all the memes /who/'s come up with over the years in a form far more coherent than thread archives. Neither of those things leech activity from the general, not truly. You could make an argument for the stream, but it's usually only a small handful in there for at most a couple of hours at a time, and even then they're often still posting here throughout.

Ultimately, as much as we have a lot more trips here than other generals might, the majority do still appreciate the anonymity that 4chan offers. Some don't like the idea of having their opinions permanently tied to an easily searchable username, and that's okay, but in such a case, a Discord would be the antithesis of the sort of thing they come to /who/ for. It's really just inevitable that any sort of external chat would cause a divide in the community. Hell, relocating /who/ has been attempted before, and it just straight-up didn't work. I just don't think it'd be possible, even if the majority were in favour (which they very much are not, as far as I'm aware).

>tfw no more space
I type too much. See next post.

File: paul85.jpg (48KB, 615x409px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 615x409px

>>87085302
>>87084919
>Perhaps Cats idea of an offtopic Discord is best
I didn't have my trip on for my earlier response to Cats' suggestion, but I stand by it: I don't personally feel that non-/who/ related discussion arises enough to warrant a separate chat for it. Given that the off-topic stuff most people dislike (although there haven't been any complaints for a little while) is personal shit, it'd be a pretty weird and sometimes depressing Discord. At least that off-topic stuff is sandwiched between regular /who/ discussions here, so it's not just all the woes of the world concentrated in one place. I also don't think any off-topic chat would manage to remain so for overly long. Intentionally or not, it'd end up gravitating towards who-related conversations eventually, because that interest is ultimately what we all have in common, and then we get right back to my initial point with dividing the community.

I mean, I could always be terribly wrong about all of this and I've completely misjudged /who/ and what they might want, but I do feel like the promotion any sort of external chat would inevitably lead to drama, like it has a number of times in the past.

Okay, there. Done typing.

File: 10blue.png (298KB, 540x308px) Image search: [Google]

298KB, 540x308px

>>87085302
>>87085337
I have nothing really to add to this other than I pretty much agree with everything you've said here

Notice a few regular trips haven't commented on the issue. Their silence speaks volumes.

>>87085302
>>87085337

Also agreed. The only times we really need to chat in that way are the streams.

Well I think it's pretty fucking noticeable neither Cloister has commented.

>>87085422
If you want my opinion, I don't particularly care where the discussion happens because I use both Discord and 4chan regularly.

>>87085422
>>87085447
They're probably just off doing other things at the moment.

>>87085408
>>87085427
thanks for the support, now we can go back to the secret trip discord and continue plotting the death of /who/, come on lads

Immigrant's silence speaks volumes

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

Nilso's silence speaks volumes.

M0ngo's silence speaks volumes

I'm fine with dropping the discord talk if people don't awkwardly screech when anyone has a conversation less than 100% connected to doctor who

I actually am unironically interested in nilso's opinion here

File: bane.jpg (216KB, 686x687px) Image search: [Google]

216KB, 686x687px

>>87086317
I'll drop it next thread, I've only been here for about 10 minutes.

Also interested in the opinions of raxim, atotalcunt, and robmccoy

Could a trip companion work

What trip would you pair up with what doctor

>>87086503
Immigrant and 13

McGanon and 8

>tfw imagining how much more I'd enjoy all the bad/disappointing episodes if I came into them completely blind instead of filled with expectations

Remember Capaldi supports the displacement of the British working classes:

https://twitter.com/GirlyLetters/status/902166807615856640

Does /who/ like Taylor swift

>>87086864
I always tend to enjoy the bad episodes on the first watch
with exception for Kill the Moon and In the Forest of The Night

>>87087068
She has pretty eyes but her music is shit

File: timelash.jpg (251KB, 1000x553px) Image search: [Google]

251KB, 1000x553px

Timelash is on in casualwhostream if anyone fancies wasting 90 minutes.

>>87087067
>using the term 'working classes' to pretend you give two shits about class warfare

>>87087068
Taylor Momsen is the best Taylor
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rHBxJCq99jA

>>87087067
As a working class British man I think supporting refugees is important. The only people who think it'll destroy us are upper class Tories and thick fucks who still vote UKIP.

>>87087197
Hello!

>>87087197
How's your wife's son?

File: basedanon.gif (3MB, 640x320px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 640x320px

>>87087197

>>87086503
Cats and 6

>>87086503
Cloister and 4
FNA and 5
Cats and 6
Rob and 7
McGanon and 8
Lymerence and 9
Edge and 10
Neo and 11
Immigrant and 12
Guy and 13

The rest are paired with 1, 2 and 3, because they're dead.

>>87087545
>>87087545
>>87087545
>>87087545
New

New thread

>>87087554
>>87087554
>>87087554