CYOA DIscussion

>>30116797
First for nowhere is safe, everything is pain.

File: no hope 61.jpg (18KB, 456x198px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 456x198px

>>30116803

File: 1437118664069.png (289KB, 1080x768px) Image search: [Google]

289KB, 1080x768px

>>30116803
Whispen protects us, anon.

I'm sorry if the lewd I wrote bothered anybody. I didn't mean for it to get so... rapey. It just kinda turned out that way.

File: 1495073208231-1.gif (4MB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 600x600px

Good mares eat all thier cheese and don't complain about the swirling torrent of pain and loneliness at the bottom of their soul.

>>30116797
How the fuck do you "scrunch" loudly?

>>30116833

How many of these are there

>>30116826
She can't protect us from ourselves. Not forever, anyway.

>>30116797
>DIscussion
>I
triggered

>>30116852
I may be biased as he is a good friend of mine but for somebody whos life basically ended at 15 he is absurdly upbeat.

>>30116866
Don't drag that shit into the new thread, the other thread is still alive, you fag.

>>30116866
>he shitposts to hide the pain.
Why do you do this to me anon. Stop making me feel sympathy for the people I hate.

>>30116866
*I may be biased as he is a good friend of mine COMMA BEFORE CONJUNCTION, but for someone WHOSE life basically ended at fifteen he is absurdly upbeat.

>>30116830
It did got pretty rapey, especially towards the end.

>>30116830
It creeped me right the fuck out and now I am concerned about what fetishes you might have. Now I'm extra glad you promised not to lewd Cuddle.

>>30116901
You know, I knew I had the wrong word with who but could not for the life of me remember what the correct one is. I think I may be getting stupid in my old age.

>>30116910
I swear rape isn't my fetish. I was just trying to play to the characters and I fucked up.
I probably won't be trying another one of these, I'm not capable of making an enjoyable one.

>>30116910
It's still railroading. I agree with the decision as rails are needed sometimes but for him to say it is not railroading is extremely dishonest.

>>30116920
Well if that's what the characters would do write it that way.

You don't need to make every sex scene fapable. I think that is what made Cain give up on sex as well.

>>30116930
I wasn't trying to make it fapable either, but it wasn't meant to be uncomfortable to even read. I don't know how that happened, but I'm not sure I like what I did.

>>30116938
>I wasn't trying to make it fapable either
That is fair enough then. Disregard my complaints. I just really hate when writers think sex needs to work as porn and tend to jump to conclusions over it.

>>30116938
Just try different characters at a later date. If the result consistently makes you uncomfortable, then stop.

>>30115407
Look at this happy family and tell me they don't look adorable.

>>30116972
it's pretty shit

>>30116987
ur shit

>>30116972
I only see half the bugs that family should have.

>>30116972
>>30116987
>>30116995
ur all shit

File: 1495150752661.png (142KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

142KB, 800x800px

AlchemyAnon draws cute families.

>>30117017
It's pretty cute.

File: 1361960.jpg (1MB, 2560x1920px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2560x1920px

>>30117017
Warlock draws awesome warriors.

I just wish he would fucking accept that and stop beating himself up about it. At this point it is not even about getting art. It hurts me to see him claim his fantastic art is shit.

>>30117017
incorrect

>>30117051
We know that, thank you.

>>30117090
I regret to inform you that you have pretty terrible taste anon. I also don't think you belong here because it looks to me that you don't like ponies.

>>30117051
>It hurts me to see him claim his fantastic art is shit.
It's a thing drawfags have in common
''This is dogshit, I'll make sure next time it wont be dogshit!''

>>30117051
>sketchy as shit
>weak anatomy
What part is awesome to you?

>>30117135
>that abomination
>cute family
lmao no

>>30117154
And what exactly is it you don't like?

File: This.png (123KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

123KB, 800x800px

>>30117199

>>30117148
The detail.

>>30117217
Opinion discarded due to no effort being made to explain. Continue being what I assume to be jealous.

>>30117232
I posted what I didn't like. I met your criteria.

>>30117145
None of the other artists completely give up on art then when they are finally ready refuse to post in the general because they are talking about something they don't like instead of just fucking posting in their cyoa instead.

I have never hated a person as much as I hate Cain.

>>30117251
Wait what?

>>30117260
He is a bitch ass nigga who cannot handle praise, refuses to reconsider his stance on anything in light of new evidence, won't give straight answers to anything and is an all around terrible fucking person.

I am incredibly glad Darkest Hour never interested me. I don't think I could live with myself if I had ever played anything that piece of shit made.

>>30117251
I don't even know what you said but the first ten words are already wrong.

>>30117271
It hurts.

Reminder, personal attacks are a reportable violation.

>>30117288
nice dubs

>>30117270
>Can't handle praise
True.
>refuse to reconsider his stance
If it is about that argument about demonic possession - someone had already explained it before, otherwise I would be glad to hear about it
>won't give straight answers
Please remind me of questions I did not answer straightly without giving a reason for doing so(e.g. it would spoil some quest-related info).
>terrible person
Wow, judgmental. We haven't even talked personally

>>30117251
>none of the other artists post their art in Secret Club's #art channel instead of here because it's a shitheap now
I've got bad news for you, anon.

>>30117322
Don't worry. You're not actually a terrible person. You just have a shitty temper. You're Cammy.

>>30117326
Most art gets mirrored here and/or in the threads like usual.

>>30117333
>throwing accusations
>refusing to back them up
>ad hominem attacks instead

I admit that I have issues and unhealthy attitude towards certain questions, but I always was and still am open for criticizms and discussion.

>>30117353

Well you see Cain, you are a decent person, no matter what anyone else says. Never forget that.

>>30117322
Well I mean to be fair you were acting like a total cunt about the demonic possession stuff and also to a lesser extent the missed detail on the letter. The only unforgivably stupid thing iFag ever really did was the wall thing, especially when you consider most of the other stuff was just missed details due to sleep deprivation and even he admitted that the wall thing was stupid. I don't hate you though.

>>30117366
>is an all around terrible fucking person.
>anything that piece of shit made.
>I don't hate you though.
Wew.

>>30117373
I am not
>>30117270
I just think Cain acted like a cunt about the demon possetion and the letter

>>30117353
Looking at the demon thing I can understand where he was coming from. You said that the general was possessed. After it was clarified that it was not in fact the harbinger that was a demon peoples minds wandered elsewhere. He must have assumed that maybe a demon possessing another party member took hold of the general.

And when you think about it the hollows are demons idea was not that far fetched. From a meta perspective we know that is not the case but in character for Rime who barely understands this stuff why not wonder if maybe it is all a ruse by a demon. I know I would not be surprised to see a lord of change posses somebody and make them seem like a blank.

>>30117385
Also as a tyranid player he understands better then most that a blank is not the only way to nullify psychic powers. When you or I think anti psyker we think blank, iFag thinks shadow in the wrap.

>>30117385
Thank you so much anon. Thinking about it you are right, that is exactly why I said the Word demon stuff. I was never able to really work it out myself in the past.

>>30117385
My issue, as it was pointed out before, was the lack of attention. The fact that I only reacted violeny about the wall does not mean that I did not shot down hundred more stupid suggestions in silence. Maybe they were not AS stupid, but they still failed to take in attention something mentioned before/basics of human behavior.

This topic I consider being dealt with. So, I still wait for questions I need to answer to.

As long as we are talking about Warlock I have something to say. He considers sexual stuff in his quest a mistake.

As far as I am concerned the only mistake he made was trying to use the filthy unicorn whore part of https://desuarchive.org/mlp/thread/29072784/#29122273 as a piece of dialogue. I doubt the suggester meant it in that manner and was simply exaggerating for comedic affect or something. Other then that all sexual aspects have been handled incredibly well, it is hard to write a rape in a way that does not come across as stupid and pointless but you made it work.

>>30117394
Shadow in the warp is in fact even stronger psychical presense, but it is completely irrelevant now.
If you are really using meta arguments here.
>30k
>tyranids

>>30117405
Well that's the thing. It has since come to light that he only missed all those details because of sleep deprivation. It seems incredibly unfair to hate a person because of that. You should have just clarified points instead.

>basics of human behavior.
Your players are sheogorath. Deal with it. It certainty does not help that with the behavioral stuff in particular you were likely attributing things to him that were not him.

>>30117413
I am saying he considers the possibility that somebody who seems like a blank may just be a powerful psyker.

Anyone knows what happened to Alycornanon (QM of Captain's CYOA)? They disappeared without a word for almost two weeks now, and hasn't been posting in other threads they frequent.

>>30117433
maybe he had a sudden heart attack.
Why spoiler that though?

>>30117417
>It has since come to light that he only missed all those details because of sleep deprivation. It seems incredibly unfair to hate a person because of that.
That is in fact why I hate him so much. I had to work 3 jobs at once to support my family a few years back.
I have an immense respect for how badly sleep deprivation fucks you up. all my other complaints about Cain are just window dressing.

>>30117421
Then he has scaling issues. Don't attribute to him your thoughts, please.
>>30117417
If you have missed it, I haven't brought him up during the last several months. Except for the filter thing, but I have not expressed my hate or any other personal thing there too.
So you are making assumptions about my opinion based on outdated info. This is wrong.

>>30117433
Hi, sorry, I'm in the middle of a move from my old base to a new one, so I haven't had time to talk/write, and it was a bit of a shit-show 'last moment' call, so it completely slipped my mind to pass-along a 'hey, I'm gonna be MIA for a week or two.'

>>30117446
Having a reason for why you're acting like a cunt does not magically invalidate the fact that you're being a cunt.

>>30117450
If you no longer hate him why do you still allow his opinion on your art to affect you so much?

>>30116784
>Buddy is the least crybaby
Do those other characters you mentioned cry every post?

>>30117455
Ok I have tried to stay out of this autism but how the hell does missing details make you a cunt?

>>30117437
Just felt like it.

>>30117454
Oh cool. I was kinda concerned for a moment there.

>>30117450
>Except for the filter thing
I don't hate you but I came really fucking close after that. Telling people they should not share opinions with iFag is a fucking faggoty thing to do.

>>30117469
That doesn't, his behavior made him a cunt.

>>30117462
>why do you have crippling self-esteem issues?
Because of certain things that happened in my life.

>>30117477
All the interactions I ever had with him were positive

>>30117469
What >>30117477 said. Cain acting like a jerk doesn't mean that iFag wasn't also.

>>30117486
Good for you.

>>30117486
Well then you never talked to him in Secret Club.

>>30117484
I still refuse to belive the deletion did not have anything to do with the uploader. Even iFag himself regreted not doing it anonymously the moment he finished uploading.

>>30117486
Are you by any chance an Australian?

File: shut up.png (29KB, 387x370px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 387x370px

@30117486
He acted like a dick. Cain also being a dick or not being a dick doesn't change that.

>>30117499
Nobody has ever been able to provide evidence of him acting bad in the klub other then that stuff just before he got banned. All I have ever seen in the general is iFag arguing circles around people and said people getting buthurt about it.

>>30117513
That just looks like hugboxing to me.

>>30117503
I cannot deny that it played its role in the decision, but it was far from being the main reason.

>>30117514
>Nobody has ever been able to provide evidence of him acting bad except for the time he acted bad and they banned him
Gee.

>>30117508
Nope. U.S.A U.S.A

>>30117525
>you're both irritating and need to shut up
>hugboxing

>>30117514
>iFag arguing circles around people
I don't care that you're going to say oh not this meme again. I have a hard time believing that you could be anyone other than him and actually think that looking at the logs.

>>30117531
>wanting to censor certain discussions
>not hugboxing
The fuck do you consider hugboxing.

>>30117545
Being excessively nice or soft with people. Telling them to fuck off is the opposite of hugboxing.

File: 283350939681947648.png (28KB, 128x128px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 128x128px

>>30117468

>>30117545
Nah that is just reddit. Which is even fucking worse.

>>30117545
Thats not what hugboxing is at all

You know I sometimes wonder if maybe people started to go out of their way to recognize iFag as he started to fix his grammar.

>>30117531
Sounds like hugboxing to me.

>>30117568
Look, I'm not proud of trying to shut down the conversation but you have to understand that he had been going at this with Cain for days straight before it came to a head.

>>30117545
The fuck do you think hugboxing is? "Fuck off, no one cares, you're both retarded" is the exact opposite.

>>30117560
That doesn't really answer my question. Buddy cries every two or three posts.

>>30117513
Does discord have logs? I would like to see what happened for myself.

>>30117580
Oh they absolutely did.

File: Fairwinds_Animsmol.gif (2MB, 500x495px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 500x495px

>>30117472
I appreciate that there were some folks legit worried, though I'm sorry I caused such worry.

Yeah, once I get to my new base and settle a bit I should get right back too it.

Fuck all this bullshit. I just want to know what would have happened had Cain not misunderstood the (poorly written) command to ask about demon behavior.

>>30117618
I think that gif would actually look better if the sword cut out frame instead of leaving all that white space.

>>30117605
He argued his case against Cain for a solid week slowly driving Cain mad as we all begged them to stop talking to each other. Eventually Cain lost his shit and ran away and iFag got banned for not letting it go even after that. Cain has never been the same since. Sometimes he bites random anons now and we don't know why.

>>30117635
Well I mean is it bad to defend your position? Given just how many sticking points they seemed to have it seems likely a week would have been needed to work through it all.

>>30117628
And I want to know what would have happened if iFag shut up after he explained what he actually meant and Cain said he still thought it was stupid. Don't put it all on Cain. They both suck.

I think the hilarious thing about all this is just how much the other australian agrees with iFag on stuff related to Darkest Hour.

>>30117643
>Cain said he still thought it was stupid
Could you link me to the post where he did that.
iFag was also not the only one curious about that shit. I would likely have asked the same question.

>>30117641
>Well I mean is it bad to defend your position?
If it is making everyone else unhappy it is at very least inconsiderate. Do it in DM. Do it in a side channel. Do it some time when it wasn't causing everyone present pain. Better yet, accept that two people will have different opinions and stop trying to push over and over again.

>>30117656
Nothing you could possibly offer me would be sufficient incentive to make me wade into the week of discussions of asshole one and asshole two arguing with each other.

>>30117646
It is true. It is nice. As much as I rail against hugboxing in all its forms it is nice to discuss stuff with somebody who agrees with me on most things, it makes the things we disagree on stand out even more.

>>30117667
Well Cain probably should have mentioned it in the thread. Multiple people asked about it if I recall correctly.

>>30117683
Multiple people asked for an end to ifag discussions in the thread also. It looks like neither of you are going to get what you want.

>>30116866
This honestly makes me really sad to hear.

One Hiji post per day in /cyoad/ soon

Why don't we just split the threads, have a CYOAD and an iFag geneal?

>>30117733
I tried that already. I've tried everything I can possibly think off.

>>30117733
That's a nice dream.

>>30117733
It wouldn't work. They know that we never want to hear about him again. They just don't care.

>>30117733
We do. It's on the 4+4chan.
The real one not the replacement after it got removed from all the search engines

>>30117733
That's what filters are for senpai. That already exists.

I have never said that I am at least partially responsible for that mess, but constantly bringing up the old issues will not fix anyhing.

I just wish we all could if not make peace with each other, then at least move along and do not bring up old controversies.

>>30117733
https://4ch.net/pone/res/288183.html

replace 4 with 8

>>30117769
You mean never said that you are not?
Also new session when? Do you by any chance think your art is good enough yet?

>>30117772
Awww a foals adventure died.

File: poly weh 2.png (44KB, 412x438px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 412x438px

>>30117590

>>30117780
*am not at least partially responsible
Yeah, my mistake.
Don't know. Finals and stuff.
Still not good enough.

>>30117791
Cain is willing to move on and stop talking about the demon shit. I suggest everyone else do so too.

>>30117791
Can Can we at least have some sort of character refrence for the party members?

>>30117772
You could also just derpy.me it.
http://derpy.me/DaBpN

>>30117788
You know this would be a lot faster if you just told me how many times she cried so it could be measured against how often Buddy has, right?

File: unknown.png (39KB, 238x346px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 238x346px

>>30117819

>>30117785
It didn't fall of the board amusingly enough. 8ch got hacked a month or two back and lost a ton of threads.

>>30117824
Shame.

>>30117811
I'm pretty sure there are one or two for Arcane on anonpone.
Concerning other characters - much later.

>>30117838
Nah arcanes one was a generic lunar mage.

>>30117822
Alright I didn't realize there were this many of those. I'm starting to wonder if you might be right.

So If I am understanding this right warlock drew a bunch of side characters or something before he drew the main party members?

Get cucked edgefags, your qm giving up on art is exactly what you faggots deserve.

>>30117853
Still although we have that fortunate situation keeping fanart of one edge quest from getting made people still keep making art for the other edge quests. Why do you do this to me /cyoa/

File: file.png (102KB, 872x556px) Image search: [Google]

102KB, 872x556px

>>30117850

>>30116891
I don't think I should sorry. He is pretty open about his part but when he told me about this it seemed really personal, I probably should not have even mentioned it.

>>30117857
How does Warlock giving up stop people from making fanart?

>>30117874
Well I get the feeling none of the artists have a good enough idea what the party looks like.
It's fucking glorious.

I want dwk to psychoanalyze antiedgeanon

>>30117476
Why exactly did that bother you so much?

>>30117824
I didn't know it was still there, holy shit.

>>30117857
...Is longname an edge qeust? I mean, it seems to have some pretty fucking tragic backstories and even has suicide attempts in it.

>>30117928
>suicide attempts
Then yes

>>30117805
Perseveration isn't something you can reason with.

>>30117930
Unfortunatly almost every quest is an edge quest right now. I have to focus my scorn on the worst ones. With symphony finished that leaves Darkest Hour at the top of the list.

>>30117939
I don't even care about Cainart (although it is kind of nice) and I want him to do detailed images of all the party members so we can flood you with fanart of Darkest Hour.

>>30117930
I'd... actually disagree with you. I never thought I'd disagree with the idea that suicide is always edge but... I dunno. It wasn't just generic angst about being lonely, but actually set up to be a believably suicide induced mental breakdown.

What constitutes edge for you? Is it the act, or the act being hamfisted?

>>30114580
Is this our bath? I forget his trip.

File: file.png (339KB, 1037x864px) Image search: [Google]

339KB, 1037x864px

I don't know that much about DH

>>30117955
Bath has a trip?

>>30117950
>What constitutes edge for you
Ponies are not meant to be put in bad situations. death is right out.
>inb4 Trixie suicide
That was a show must go on deal.

>>30117963
>>inb4 Trixie suicide
>That was a show must go on deal.

So no death unless the plot demands it?

>>30117956
That's fucking hawt

>>30117956
>I don't know that much about DH
Clearly not. It is 30k, although at least two of the players initially thought it was set after the show.

Still nice art. Not as good as Cain himself but still pretty good.

>>30117956
Actually this gives me an idea.
A challenge
Draw a piece of art for a quest you know fuck all about and players of that quest can tell you how accurate is is.

>>30117973
Dude that's miles ahead of Cain in quality

Post some me your best Cain art and I'll explain you why

>>30117973
Apparently you don't know much about DH, since you clearly don't know the character.

>>30117956
Definitely considered to be tagged as grotesque, but I kind of find this to be very sweet.

>>30117987
Oh shit it's Ram. I missed the dress.

>>30117973
Now consider that this pic took less than an hour to draw while Cain usually spends several days on his pics.

>>30118021
but muh detail, muh advanced out of focus pencil texture

>>30117985
I just really like the detail Cain puts into his art. I know I am not the only one.

>>30117956
now kiss

>>30117956
I'm so happy Ram found a special somepony after all these years.

>>30118033
Kek

>>30118027
Detail doesn't make up for improper anatomy and weak overall skills. detail isn't a talent, it's just a time consumer. A child can hdraw a picture rich in detail if they give it enough time, but that doesn't make the detail well made.

>>30118026
My main focuses in art are better then yours.
Kill yourself.
>>30117985
I would say they are about equal. I think it depends on how much value you place on detail compared to other traits

Don't feed the troll you guys.

>>30118112
Fuck I forgot my meme arrow on the first line there

>>30118115
What? We are discussing what art we prefer. Do you really think somebody would fake an opinion on art to troll?

Remember there are even people who prefer 3d/sfm porn to drawn porn.

At the very least I am sure all but that one autist can agree that Warlocks art is good enough to post and he is retarded to think otherwise.

>>30118112
>I would say they are about equal
Are you for fucking real?
Subjectivity of art aside there ARE objective measures of skill in art, and Cain's technique is OBJECTIVELY lesser.
Now there's nothing wrong with that because we all start somewhere, but telling him his art is perfect isn't helping him to improve. It's an artist's job to see the issues in his work and aim to fix them.
And also fuck you, you come here shouting your opinion around without a care but when someone gives you a contrary opinion you get all defensive? Cunt move.
If you're gonna share an opinion anywhere you can't expect people to not share theirs back.

>>30118131
Oh absolutely.

>>30118140
see:
>>30118115

Do you really think this guy is being honest here? We're in real Australian hours remember. They thrive on (you)'s.

>>30118140
Can you not fucking read. I know Cains art has issues. The question is do you value technical skill more then his strengths. For some people the answer is no. Others it is yes. For me it is half and half to come out to a resounding average.

>>30118171
Read
>>30118093

Detail is hardly a strength, that's be like saying picasso's strength is "blue". detail is just a use of the medium as much as minimalism is and is hampered and elevated by, say it with me, the artist's TECHNICAL skills.

File: tumblr_o0xxrlWgL81sbjmddo1_1280.png (255KB, 600x800px) Image search: [Google]

255KB, 600x800px

>>30118171
Cain doesn't have strengths. You haven't been able to say anything but 'detail' and that's meaningless shit that just breaks down to 'his armor has a few more pieces'. That's a timesink. I cant think of a single regular artist in CYOA who couldn't replicate a Cain.

There's no topic for conversation here, he's objectively not good and you're grasping at vague bullshit because you're an attention whore.

Fuck it I may as well have my say

What I think of Cain art.
>His technical skills are not fantastic but people exaggerate that because cyoa art is generaly so high quality.
>on the other hand people also exagerate the details
>both sides are claiming absurd extremes.
>it was really fucking useful during the deer and demon fights to have those images so we knew where to aim
>it is absolutely fucking good enough to post
>he cannot except to get better if only sekrit is able to help him

His art is fucking average. Not great but not fantastic either.

>>30118206
>Not great but not fantastic either.
So why did you say 'but'?
>he cannot except to get better if only sekrit is able to help him
Remind me, when was the last time you managed to give him any critique which he craves?

>>30118212
He asked constantly for critque of his near flawless cyoa. He rarely asked for critque of his heavily flawed art.

WOW look at this detail.

Truly a god among men.

I remember those robots I used to draw in my school books. I thought they were just scribbles, but I put a lot of guns on them so I guess they were great.

File: bllooop.png (97KB, 383x598px) Image search: [Google]

97KB, 383x598px

>>30118217
Forgot the picture

Do you argue with the crazy guy on the street spouting gibberish?

Do you try to reason with the developmentally disabled guy who works at the grocery store?

You don't do it in real life, don't do it here.

>>30118228
Hey, that one's a lot better than his usual notebook doodles.

>>30118206
>both sides
Fuck your shit faggot I wasn't saying he was garbage I said he needed work.
My only claim was that he wasn't on par with fucking Hij "furry booty is my civic duty" Jacker.
I know i've seen worse but he needs. WORK.
And he will always NEED work because that's what mastering a craft IS for god's sake,you NEVER STOP TRYING TO IMPROVE.
And people treating him like he's the russian jesus christ for drawing a 4/10 at best pone is not fucking helping.
And fuck, for that guy to come in and go "well that's fine but this other guy's so much better" in the first place is a dick fucking move, all fanart has a place.

>>30118231
Do you let the crazy guy hang out in your living room?
Do you let the disabled guy take a shit on your couch?

Not doing anything will not better the situation in any way.

>>30118228
Oh neat this is new. Can you please leak more Cainart from sekrit.
Also how about you actualy post one of his really detailed drawings so people can decide for themselves.

Or how about the image that shows he has really good hair effects.

>>30118242
That's an Alch pone you dunce.

>>30118242
Have you considered killing yourself?

>>30118245
Well how could I possibly fucking know. He has locked himself away and only shows sekrit his art. How can anybody not in sekrit possibly know in what manner he has improved.

>>30118242
>He can't even recognize Cains work
Is THAT enough for you guys to agree with me that he's a troll?

>>30118238
I don't argue with him about things, I tell him to get out. If he won't leave I call the police or yell at him till he leaves.

>>30118249
>Well how could I possibly fucking know.
By actually recognizing art styles, retard.

>>30118252
No he is just wrong. See
>>30118249
Only sekritfags have any idea what his new stuff looks like.

>>30118249
>Well how could I possibly fucking know.
Fuck you, now you're getting defensive for being a retard instead of just letting it go.
You MIGHT be able to know by recognizing the art style of one of the longest standing members of this rinky dink community.
Or maybe just look at the cain-shekles you DO have and realize they're radically different.

>>30118257
Only sekritfags and literally anyone with eyes who has seen a cain drawing ever. Like for example, the one in this very thread.

What is it about Cain that he draws the retards to him like light draws in Moths.

>>30118258
It has been fucking months. For all I know alch has been tutoring him. People barely even fucking post alch art.

>>30118263
Is that a rhetorical question?

>>30118264
STOP
DEFENDING
STUPID
BEHAVIOR
F A G G O T
Why can't you just accept when you've made a mistake and fucking LEARN from it instead of fighting and making excuses like a fucking child?

File: PonyHorror1.png (23KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 1920x1080px

>>30118264

>>30118264
What?
Why did this thought come to your mind?

>>30118264
Other than the ones in this thread, you mean.
Again.

>>30118263
He gave his players something then yanked it out from under them. Of course they are going to react badly. Although with how the anti-Cain fags are actimg I am half tempted to pretend to be a Cainfag just to spite them.

>>30118238
>>30118253
That was more personal advice anyways. We've tried all this anyways. Though I really wish "calling the police" was done more often, it does work. But really ignoring it until it leaves is all we have left.

Oh Fuck me I can't even take my own advice

>>30118264
I posted an alchemy picture in every thread. It became a meme. There is one in every thread that announces who the artist is.

>>30118270
Fine I admit I made a mistake. I should not even have to fucking say that for an objective mistake.

>>30118285
>I should not even have to fucking say that for an objective mistake
No, you shouldn't. Hence why me and other people are getting angry at you for DEFENDING your mistakes.
Just don't do that in the future and you'll attract less ire.
Recognize where you go wrong when you do and LEARN from that.

>>30118287
But he was fucking right. Nobody can be expected to know the style of an artist who has not posted anything in fucking months.

Cain art is bad. It will never get better at a decent rate until he fucking posts it outside of Discord.

>>30118295
That's completely insane, and it's painfully obvious you just want to see it. Stop posting.

>>30118295
>But he was fucking right.
>
I disagree, I think he was very wrong. But I have the sneaking suspicion there's little I can say to convince you.
Regardless the advice I gave was good advice for him because he's done this kind've thing before. It's childish to hold onto your arguments like that, trying to save face by making excuses only makes you look worse.

>>30118297
>double the criticism is a bad thing.
Fucking kill yourself. Sekrit is a fucking cancer that has killed cyoa.

>>30118299
It's childish because he's disabled. He doesn't learn because he's disabled. It's both cruel and naive to continue to keep trying.

>>30118304
That would be you, pal.

>>30118299
>everything I don't like is one person.

>>30118304
Sekrit is cyoa, at least half of active QMs are regulars there. Meanwhile iFag has literally, not figuratively, killed a lot of discussion and pleasantries this place used to have.
If any one's to blame it's iFag and you know it.

>>30118308
Half the reason iFag is such a problem is Cain overreacted.
So if anything has killed cyoa it is Cain.
Need I remind you iFag barely fucking posts here anymore.

>>30118310
>iFag barely fucking posts here anymore
>
Even if he didn't it doesn't matter, it was him, and only him that has had this lasting, permeating effect on cyoag.
I really don't see how you can deny that.

GAS THE DH PLAYERS.
CYOA WAR NOW!

>>30118310
Yeah, but you've replaced him as a problem, so nothing got better. In fact, you're worse than he ever was. You're probably the worse member this community has ever had. Worse than Shiny. Worse than RITS. Truly a cancer to surpass all cancers.

>>30118314
Hey fuck you. I have not even fucking said anything about this stupid argument past. >>30118206

>>30118317
There are at least two of us sick of this bullshit. iFag was never just one person and us defenders are not either.

>>30118321
Why do you think that makes you any better? Cancer spreads. That's why it's so bad.

>>30118324
You you are the cancer.

>>30118304
Took you long enough to get there, but we all saw it coming.

>>30118327
A stirring argument, but having been here far longer than you without issue, I must question your logic, if indeed you have any.

>>30116797
Oh how fitting, just when I contemplate suicide again. My world is gone, barely a thing holds me here anymore.

>>30118368
I'm still here other anon.

>>30118317
This

Every anon that wants to see this shit end needs to right now, find 3 off topic threads (anything not discussing a CYOA) and report them. We got scruffed once, but no bans were handed out. If we keep at it, it will work.

>>30118385
I appreciate your presence, internet stranger.

File: 101 chocolate.png (382KB, 637x471px) Image search: [Google]

382KB, 637x471px

>>30117956

File: 1494101044519-1.png (1KB, 128x128px) Image search: [Google]

1KB, 128x128px

Rarr

File: windrider_by_soursketches-d9afh7z[1].jpg (59KB, 894x894px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 894x894px

I feel like I'm up for running another CYOA, lads - a short rest was all I needed it seems. My schedule is still a fuck up, sadly, so I'll probably be only able to run on Fridays and Saturdays unless something hopefully changes. The thing is: I would like to run a CYOA about Wind Rider and his last attempt at a race but I'm not sure how many people will be interested in this concept or playing as this character, the poll I did some time ago had nobody vote for it, unlike the breezie and western idea, but it's a story that I'd really like to do and have other players play through.

Active threads

Big Mare Hero: >>30102500
Custos Luna: >>30095207
Semantic Error: >>30040220
Give and Take: >>30097692
Kingdom Hearts: >>29890052
Nebula: >>30103451
Cirquesque: >>30064061
Alchemy: >>29899886
Slave: >>30117550
Shittily: >>30080350
Night Delivery: >>30104855
Long Name: >>30066784
EWE: >>30048900

>>30118317
I cannot THIS hard enough.

>>30118707
meh

>>30118707
Well they were all good ideas. Some were just more good then others so run whatever you want to run.

>>30118728
This

>>30118707
I'm fine with that. It'll be cool to play with you again.

Lenna, or Gilded Lily?
Just out of curiosity.

>>30118860
Orich, and those big, strong hooves of his that could easily wrap around Scribe.
If you're asking which should Scribe pursue, Lenna. Mostly because I believe what Lily needs now is more friends, more social interaction with others.
If you're asking which character I like more, Captain Lily.

>>30118860
neither

I had a dream I had a horse penis, it was actually very disturbing. This is all your fault CYOA.

>>30118973
>Disturbing
>Not arousing
Maybe you're in the wrong place anon

>>30118973
Pleb.

>>30118976
>not arousing
I didn't say that.

File: Sad Spice.png (33KB, 1300x1300px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 1300x1300px

Poners with tine dicks

>>30119008
But that's wrong.

File: Jet.png (1KB, 128x128px) Image search: [Google]

1KB, 128x128px

>>30119008

>>30118707
So long as we eventually do the Breezie stories some time in the future, I'm up for this cyoa.

File: packsapunch.png (59KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 640x600px

>>30119021
equal in size to the pepper

>>30119051
Bigger dick good?

>>30118124
We don't call them "people".

>>30118860
I want to fuck Lenna but I want to marry Lily. Make sense?

>>30116833
There are 125 unique Whispens in this gif. It is the most Whispen-dense post man has ever created.

>>30117956
Look at the pretty poner on a date. The bate is fine too.

>>30119105
Truly a marvel.

File: CYOAG may 17-19 2017.png (131KB, 812x526px) Image search: [Google]

131KB, 812x526px

>last thread

>>30119051
Reminder that Angel was fully prepared to pee all over Horsey

>>30119245
>without good combat bad

How would you describe a main theme of a quest in five words or less?

>>30119465
>It's total shit, don't read

>>30119465
I would think about what the premise of the quest is and its most prominent feature and try to sum it up in a funny way with five words.

File: 1495215266780.jpg (43KB, 472x472px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 472x472px

Flap flap flap flap flap flap flap flap.

I fucking hate myself for doing this, but I'm just not in any kind of mood to run.
I won't say tomorrow, or even a week from now, because if I do I'll probably break that date like and wind up in a cycle of perpetual "tomorrow."
So in lieu of being a massive faggot, which I am, let's just say I'll run when I'm not feeling like a colossal pile of shit.

>>30119514
Works for me, but who are you?

>>30119514
Don't worry, nobody ever expected anything from you in the first place.

>>30119514

!brushie Mora

Just like, run when you can bro. We can wait for you to be ready. Just don't pull a Lis and die completely.

>>30119546
>!brushie Mora
Oh, so just another secuckrit club member.

>>30119514
>>30119546
Oh, Mora is nice person and not a massive faggot at all, it's okay to have bad days, just run when you feel like it.

>>30119553

I mean.
If you want to treat QMs differently because they talk to other QMs, then you do you.
I'll just be enjoying his quests without you then.

>>30118287
> Defending yourself on an anonymous board

People need to stop taking this so personally. It's an anonymous board, no one will know who you are so if you just drop a bad argument then it no longer haunts you. You don't have to try and resolve it. Let people hate the post because they can't hate the person behind it.

Also why do people give such a shit about art anyways? Some cyoas don't even HAVE art.

>>30119571
>why do people give such a shit about art anyways?
Because Cain started drawing for some other people instead of them, so they are angry and feel cheated.

File: 1495216963366.jpg (44KB, 496x496px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 496x496px

>>30119505

File: 2.8.png (228KB, 2560x2120px) Image search: [Google]

228KB, 2560x2120px

>>30115166
Holy kek, anon, this gave me a hearty chuckle. Thanks a lot for that! More abridged ever?

>>30119681
On that note: MOOOOOOOOOOOoooooooon

>>30119624
choos

>>30119709
glad you liked it. Mayyybe, probably not though. I'd like to, but have been working crazy hours. Hopefully another anon will pick it up if I don't

Through the Shattered Planes:

No new OP this time, but I made a really D E T A I L L E D in-quest drawing instead.
Well, sorta... It's more like a regular drawing but with more things going on at once.
Also characters are smaller so the individual qulity is actually less good than usual.
...
Fuck!

Returns!

>>30119907
>>30119904
>>30119897
>>30119891
>>30119885

File: 5-4.png (13KB, 123x116px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 123x116px

Big Mare Hero continues, gelrgelrglergleg edition:
>>30120124

File: Seaweed.png (130KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

130KB, 1200x1200px

Have another disembodied head. Maybe next time I'll make a body

>>30120130
Alright, who's the hothead who played 10 murlocs in a row?

>>30120137
DUDE

File: file.png (225KB, 679x538px) Image search: [Google]

225KB, 679x538px

Running a Hail miniquest in a minute and thought I'd ask if you guys prefered first or second person. I don't have a strong opinion on either.

>>30120162
Mrrrggllll

>>30120629
Second

File: 1492608510418.jpg (1MB, 3724x1283px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 3724x1283px

Affirmation that I'm still not dead and I'm looking to pick back up Sunday. I'm no longer going to promise a halfway consistent schedule, because at this point it's not going to happen. Uncle Sam has a way with getting in the way. But, at least this once, I can say SUNDAY SUNDAY SUNDAY.

>>30120662
Oh also that sounds like a neat premise.

Running.
>>30120716

>>30120629
Summit is the father right?

>>30120669
>filly's mane and tail are different colors
Ree

File: 048 - MEEP MEEP HERE COMES THE SPACE BUS TO WRECK YO SHIT.png (203KB, 1280x871px) Image search: [Google]

203KB, 1280x871px

Did you know that, of all pets, cats are the one that better adapted to low gravity conditions?
And that, at the point of history Hail minus twenty takes place, small ships still didn't have artificial gravity?
On another note, resuming Hail for a miniquest: >>30121046

>>30120137
A deadpanning Sea is a good Sea.
>>30120771
Yup yup.

Morgan quest when?
https://youtu.be/NYtQXtUMWvQ?list=PLv3TTBr1W_9tpgsEZEf3RY1GwJR9lDTni

>>30121456
____ ___ ____ __

>>30121487
I'm way to hammered to make anything.

>>30121501
Are you me?

>>30121520
I'm not sure. I haven't thought about it. But it would certainly explain so fucking much.
I'll get us some snacks, brb.

>>30121501
I don't believe you. You can make posts just fine. You're just a pansy.

>>30121543
I've beein making posts for almost ten years now. It comes naturally to me like eating pistachios absentmindedly for hours.

>All that autism
Holy shit guys Cain's art has issues but screeching autistically any time somebody likes it in spite of that is not going to fix anything.
>Inb4 ausfag.
Aloha faggots.

>>30121612
>bringing it back up so autists have an excuse to argue for four more hours and another 200 posts

>>30121619
I should not be locked out of conversations just because I am at work.
I know some artists and although they can take criticism fine what they cannot handle is their fans getting shat on.

Remember there are even people who like fucking sundowner.

>>30121683
Ok.

>>30121683
Whats wrong with sundowner?

>>30121612
This is 4chan, we don't have to tolerate the shitty opinion of some retards.

File: approval.gif (2MB, 235x240px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 235x240px

>>30121703
You. I like you.
Thought I'd never hear that around here anymore.

>>30121695
They can't handle the golden rays of the glorious sunshine.

>>30121683
Somehow I doubt Cain minds us shitting on australians.

>>30121836
It's still pretty retarded to call somebody a troll for liking art you don't like.
>>30121695
I may be thinking of somebody else. Excessivly oversized asses.

>>30121912
you aren't
https://www.derpibooru.org/tags/artist-colon-sundown

>>30121959
I rest my case then. If people can like that it is not far fetched that they can like Cain art. It might not be exactly the same thing as Sundowner fans as they like him for his issues. Cain fans like the art in spite of them. But it still shows people have differing tastes.

I honestly feel like people exagerate the anatomy issues just to spite people who don't care about them. Or it might have something to do with /cyoa/ having a warped idea of what is average. Point is it is not fair on his players to act like it is worse then it is.

>>30122001
That's nice.

>Hiji is garbage compared to Cain
>You're full of shit
>WHY ARE YOU SHITTING ON ME FOR MY OPINION

>>30122019
Nobody ever said that. I think >>30122001 might be right. People are just trying to spite people at this point.

>>30122030
>Not as good as Cain himself
lmao

Look, guys, the solution is to let everyone express their opinions unless they contradict someone else's. If they contradict someone else's they're not allowed to say it because that's just being mean to the poor guys that posted first. Here, I'll start:

Lewd quests are always better than non-lewd quests.

>>30122048
Yes.

>>30122048
Everything is shit.

File: I disagree.png (112KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

112KB, 600x600px

>>30122048

>>30122069
Wow, I feel attacked right now.

>>30122048
This shitpost does not really work because the people who posted their opinion second are the ones who got mad first.

>>30122069
>>30122077
I think we may have to ban ponks if they're being used to attack other people's opinions. Disagreements are just not ok on 4chan.

>>30122100
I agree. Ponks are too friendly, and hurt my feelings.

I am not even sure what side people are on right now.

>>30122124
I'm making fun of the idiot that came home from work to screech autistically about people disagreeing, pretty mundanely, with the guy that jack's off to Cain's art. The majority of that conversation wasn't even about Cain art, it was making fun of the guy that mistook art that was obviously not Cain as Cain's.

File: alicorn pinch.png (3MB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1200x1200px

>>30122146
Night Delivery is running.
I hope this fight hasn't been going on too long. I just didn't want her to be a push-over and she has probably the most powerful Mark in the CYOA.

>>30122124
Stop being autistic.
Terminate yourself and re-roll for a less shit build.

File: 1461816234345.png (3MB, 400x4000px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 400x4000px

>>30122154

How long until our next beanie bate?

>>30122244
RePony is back up and running again! Friday, Saturday, then probably Monday through Friday next week.

>>30121912
I didn't call him a troll for liking art, I called him a troll because he was disingenuously arguing something to stir shit.

File: UaRio.png (94KB, 830x712px) Image search: [Google]

94KB, 830x712px

>>30122154
>Her face is now as red as her cloak, even if her expression is seeing red
>You emerge from the claustrophobic depths behind her, and finally have access to behind her.
>red red
>behind behind
Triggered triggered.

>>30122281
How could you possibly know that? People have strange tastes sometimes.

>>30122321
I'm sorry it's not up to the exact standards that you're paying me for.

This is a consistent problem in my writing and I'm not getting anyone to proofread this. I don't even parse it myself.

File: aint we getting too peacefull.jpg (29KB, 391x350px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 391x350px

>>30121683
>Sundown will never draw a picture of Sundowner

>>30122423
You should get your friend to proofread it. You know the one I mean. The hot one.

post characters you want to see more or first art of

File: angry_princess_twilight_sparkle_by_flowerlovesyou-d84lsqg.png (1MB, 4643x5936px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 4643x5936px

Just what the hell is wrong with you anon? Seriously, what the hell is your problem? Why are you like this? What do even think you're doing?

>>30122846
It's called a fetish Twilight, there's no bad way to fantasize.

File: 0b134c119f8e62937ff36e5519584ebc.png (320KB, 621x604px) Image search: [Google]

320KB, 621x604px

>>30122844

>>30122844
carrot cog from Repony would be nice.

>>30122865
Describe him for Pixel Anon and he'll make a sprite that other people can base art on.

>>30122915
>The door creaks open as an Earth mare walks through, humming distractedly and carrying a bucket of water with a few rags hanging off of the side.
>She’s on the short side, but with the hips to make up for it, and her blue coat contrasts nicely with her orange mane. She’s got a bandana on her head, carefully tied to keep her curly mane out of her face.

That's the description from the first thread.

>>30122947
Smol short, or just slightly shorter than average short?

>>30122962
I think "on the short side" implies just a bit below average.

>>30122947
>>30122962
>>30122979
Yeah, this about sums it up. She's well built but a little shorter than the average mare.

Hey paper pone anon, could you alter the AHP paper pones slightly, since we have official sizes now?
I wanna see dat smol Goldheart.

>>30122141
Well I mean to be fair I almost made the same mistake myself. Given the context you would assume the art was Cain before you looked at it and most of his art is armored ponies.