CYOA Discussion

>>29862712
First for Crystal Symphony: Final Session.
Was waiting for a new thread to announce.

File: 1482607310243.png (451KB, 703x745px) Image search: [Google]

451KB, 703x745px

nth for big griffs

>>29863235
Fucking bastard.

File: 1492193204300.jpg (59KB, 676x896px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 676x896px

>>29863235
Presented for heroism and bravery in the face of autism.

>>29863247
Where?

File: when people say 3.5 isn't bloated.jpg (3MB, 1500x2603px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1500x2603px

Again, for those that missed it last thread.

Age of Strife thread tomorrow at around 10-ish EST. And hopefully, every Sunday thereafter.


On a slightly related note, any wandering drawfags taking requests? It would be nice to have
original art to post

I miss Curwhibbles.

File: 1492194784777.jpg (80KB, 650x934px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 650x934px

>>29863242

>>29863305
What's the medal actually of? I can't quite see it.

File: dotX9Uw.png (90KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 900x900px

>>29863371
here

File: 170.png (16KB, 170x144px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 170x144px

>>29863436
It's a transparency of the rebel medal of honor from starwars, I was going with the theme

File: CYOAG apr 12-14 2017.png (120KB, 812x526px) Image search: [Google]

120KB, 812x526px

>last thread

>>29863471
>want cyoa pone love
;_;

>>29863471
>edgy Doxel

>>29863406

I could maybe take a crack at doing something. Been meaning to try and do more community art/contributions.

>>29863471

>fuck Lis CYOAs

>>29863443
>vore
On second thought, keep your griffons.

File: 1492195562230.jpg (5KB, 194x70px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 194x70px

>>29863471
hmmm

>>29863471

>Doxel edgy

>>29863471
>everything people make fucking little shitty
>life CYOA work
>post something fun
>cyoa pone love
I have mixed feelings about this cloud.

>>29863506
Cool. Have you read AoS yet? If you're offering, I'm not picky on what you want to do.

File: ATWT.png (90KB, 876x1116px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 876x1116px

>>29863461
But anon, she's not rebel scum

>>29863601

I have not, sorry. So descriptions would help. And I'm open to anything that isn't overly complex, like a 10 character full color/rendered epic battle scene or anything like that.

>>29863688
So I'm hearing that a 9.5 character full colored/rendered epic battle scene is up for grabs?

File: fair Winds.png (144KB, 900x800px) Image search: [Google]

144KB, 900x800px

Here's Fair Wind, whom I said I'd draw. Since nobody told me the secrets of this pone, I used a generic pony position.

On another note, Shattered Planes should return around monday, but there might be some delay. I'll tell you when I know. See you there!

>>29863758
Primed and ready. And cute, don't forget cute.

>>29863758
You nailed his personality right on the head.

>>29863777
Did it hurt?

>>29863814
Nah, he's experienced.

>>29863688
Perhaps just one of the player character, then? Would request a simple one of the party but we still have two party members yet to be revealed Got a general color pallet here.

The character, Pocket Knife, is an eighteen year-old unicorn Rogue with a short-cut mane that goes to about his neck and a tail cut similarly. As for buffness, Most of the quest he's in leather armor that doesn't impede his movement, dyed either black or a dark brown, and primarily uses a rapier that looks similarly to pic related. (Note that he fights by levitating it, his magic horn aura thingy is the same color of his eyes) His Cutie Mark is a lockpick crossed with a dagger.

I'm not looking for an overcomplicated pose or background. One of him walking through a forest or in a dark dungeon with his rapier out would be great. Whatever tickles your fancy, man.

File: color combo.png (41KB, 1511x428px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 1511x428px

>>29863846
hurr hurr forgot pic

>>29863846
>>29863851

Alright, I'll see what I can do.

Active threads

Slave: >>29838403
Miracle: >>29858584
RePony: >>29841266
Crystal Symphony: >>29862712
Dirty Work: >>29775567
Give and Take: >>29845758
Fair Winds: >>29854647
Nebula: >>29857918
EWE: >>29703954
Kingdom Hearts: >>29724765
A Historical Perspective: >>29839309
Do No Harm: >>29860861

>>29863471
Did we ever get one for 2 threads ago?

File: 1430249109776.png (87KB, 500x405px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 500x405px

>>29863846

Actually if you could give me a better idea of what "short cut" means for the manestyle it'd help, having trouble visualizing it. Like, an even cut kinda like Twilight, or just short scruffy, or what?

File: rich.png (208KB, 900x1214px) Image search: [Google]

208KB, 900x1214px

>>29864154
Er, kind of like a swept back look where it doesn't hang over his forehead. Kind of like Filthy Rich but a little more scraggly

>>29863471
>People fucking wanted something fun

File: snip.png (249KB, 773x357px) Image search: [Google]

249KB, 773x357px

>>29864141
I didn't make one. Didn't seem like it would yield anything interesting.

>>29861432
Did he say if having his art removed from derpi was a I am not good enough thing or a fuck iFag thing.

File: how to be a changeling diplomat in three simple steps.png (125KB, 500x255px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 500x255px

What did Soft Serve tell you about broken glass?! Find out as Give and Take continues!
>>29864372

File: Far&Coti by Bath.png (960KB, 1200x909px) Image search: [Google]

960KB, 1200x909px

Did you know the Psychic sections of the Equestrian army, known coloquially as Spooks, train the magic of their cutie marks directly and because of it are able to far exceed the abilities of a normal pony or even summon avatars made of their willpower?
In another note, resuming Hail: >>29864407
-----------------------------------------------------
Resuming Miracle, or, patricidal boogaloo:
>>29863396
>>29864063

>>29864346
Which word cloud was the most lopsided? Was it the eldritch pudding one?

>>29861801
You know anybody can just go to sekrit and tell you are lying right.

File: CYOAG apr 14-15 16.png (132KB, 812x526px) Image search: [Google]

132KB, 812x526px

>>29864650
The pudding one wasn't bad, but I think the most "lopsided" would still be the Inept one.

>>29864692
>exactly 1 year ago
My, my. Time flies.

>>29864650
What is this about pudding.

>>29864692
typical grill, trying to be the center of attention

>>29864779
Wait inept is a girl.

>>29863846
>leather armor
kinky

>>29864811
anon where have you been the last 3 years?

>>29864811
That's just what he wants you to think.

>>29864811
No, we are just being shitlords and assuming her gender.

>>29864839

New Captain's CYOA, and my head hurts too much to come up with something witty to put here.

>>29864811
Male (female)

Running.
>>29864871

File: CYOAG jan 26-27 16 wordcloud.png (116KB, 812x526px) Image search: [Google]

116KB, 812x526px

>>29864776

>>29864901
Why.

>>29864912
Because Anon and I started talking about the deliciousness of pudding and it kinda sorta escalated a bit.

I sometimes think I would be happier with cyoa if I used the catalogue instead of the front page. I would see less things that disgust me in quests I don't play.

>>29865022
Why would you ever use the front page?

So everyone talks about the popular quests, what about the ones that have been shit?

>>29865124
Training's over, time for lunch!

>>29865125
nobody reads them because they're shit, ergo little to talk about.

>>29865022
>not using the catalog 24/7
Literally why?

>>29865108
So I can see if anything interesting is happening in threads I would otherwise not read.
But it may not be worth the cost. I am fucking sick of seeing people shooting down suggestions to ask people questions just because it is unlikely to work.

I heard we are bringing back Eldritch Pudding?!?

>>29865022
>using the front page in 2017

I want to push my degenerate fetishes onto the MC

>>29865237
What if the degenerate fetishes of the mc already line up with yours.

>>29865280
Then I'll just consider them a self insert

Is Potion Quest dead?

>>29865237
Like what, oviposition?

>>29865454
Marecock oviposition quest when?

>>29865454
been done

>tfw no simple slice of life quests
i like all the creative shit but why arent there comfy quests once in awhile

>>29865506
>what is lyraquest

>>29865506
>What is Hail

>>29865486
That's why I bring it up. I'm still mad about it.

>>29865539
Hail is like Phew. Slice of life but not really simple.

File: Drug injection.jpg (191KB, 2048x2048px) Image search: [Google]

191KB, 2048x2048px

>>29865556

>>29865461
When _I_ make it.

Who would win in a fight between Angel Wings and Holiday Special.

Angel is a mare with tude in all the right places and Holiday is Inept's genderbent self-insert .

>>29865572
owo

>>29865548
How so?

>>29865642
>genderbent

>>29865563
>Getting a doctor to Cath and not just ordering a nurse to do it
lmao

>>29865777
Wasted

>>29865785
>getfaggotry.

>>29865785
lik ur life lmao

>>29865642
Angel. By virtue of coming from a better quest.

File: images (1).jpg (19KB, 395x372px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 395x372px

>>29865879

>>29865949
>better quest

Elaborate.
No, seriously. I've never really gotten a good comparative of review about any of my games. As different as my games are from Spicy, I'm sure there's some pros and cons that could be made that'd be really helpful for me to know.

>>29865949
Wow friendship is tragic must be really shit to be worse then spicy.

>>29865975
He is a fag.

>>29865949
>>29865975

I wouldn't say better but FiT really fell apart after we got evil eyes. I just totally went into completely different direction and threw away all investment and potential moments/development with Pup. The whole voice in her head thing is, I say unironically, perhaps THE worst qm decision I have ever seen right underneath Vince not listening to the majority but you can argue that was an accident. The ending just left me feeling bad. I still feel bad about it. We listened to that fucker and abandoned what was basically our adoptive son Pup and hastily made friends with an autist bat. It was shit.

Not to say that I don't like Inept as a QM tho.

New (6 hours ago) cyoa.
>>29863473

>>29866123
>you can argue that was an accident
Considering just before that the guy lied and said his idea was in the majority I am pretty sure that is the case.

>>29866140
Disregard it. 1-2 Anons are making it their personal lewd greentext. There's no recovery from that, even if you add more players.

>>29866265
That's one of the reasons why I stopped playing the CYOAs. I don't like rape and torture in my games. If you want to sex then watch pornos, keep it out of the games we play online.

>>29865949
oof

>>29866363
But DUDE, he could totally rape everyone and then kill them lol. And then he goes home and beats up his stupid stepdad Richard who thinks that just because he fucks your mom totally owns your life, but he's just a stupid jerk who works an office job and is a total loser with thinning hair. What's wrong with that?

So, pony shelter?
Reminds me of sweetheart

>>29866570
RePony goes again with some fun with quills and sofa.

>>29866363
>Don't have the kind of fun that I don't like

>>29864666
Uh huh, I'm real scared they'll see your "truth".

>>29866885
Watch out! Big mean sekrit might make fun of you next!

>>29866265
It appears to be about helping zecora to stop feeling useless now.

>>29866952
They're busy playing cards against humanity and doxxing a sparkledog artist.

>>29867068
Doxeling? What did he do to deserve being Doxel'd?

File: pocket knife.png (1MB, 2000x1200px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2000x1200px

>>29863846

Sorry for the delay and any potential wonkiness of the image, I sort of used it as an excuse to try some new things. Hope it came out alright anyway.

I also cannot into armor

Let me know if you want a version without the 10 second lighting effects, by the way.

Literally who cares about Sekrit Club.

>>29866959
From rape quest to feelsfest in about 70 posts

>>29867243
Noice.

>>29867328
Sekrit investigator.

File: ScenesFromAHat6.png (501KB, 629x464px) Image search: [Google]

501KB, 629x464px

>Thing's that will never be in a character creation prompt

>>29867351
What you masturbated to as a kid

>>29867351
>Anal circumference?

File: file.png (33KB, 837x87px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 837x87px

>>29867243

>>29867351
>Do you want to be normal?

File: Jacket.jpg (59KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 1280x720px

>>29867351
>Do you like hurting other people?

>>29867351
Mottled dick? Or solid color?

>>29867363
I want this in chargen now so bad.

File: Guardian pre.png (798KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

798KB, 1200x1200px

Sorry about being a lazy fuck for half a month, then following it up with a late start....
>>29867620
>>29867623
Let's do this I guess.

>>29867640
So when will the mares tag team mammoth dusty dick?

>>29867674
moms*

>>29867674
That's the victory celebration.

>>29867674
>your school filly crush will never sit on your sack and full body hug your shaft

>>29867640
Time to see if we can continue to be combat geniuses.

>>29867640
I distinctly recall a large amount of discussion last thread on how to open the fight. Why not use that imput?

>>29866342
>I will be back but hijack it anyway.
When has multi qm ever worked.

>>29866265
That's hardly fair. Some qms simply like to give a lot of control over the details of a sex scene.

I will say this guy overdoes it in a way though. He will half use a command then stop halfway through it so the scenes drag on a little longer then they should.

>>29867674
Two pregnant mares wrestling with Dusty's mammoth cock.

File: ScenesFromAHat4.jpg (14KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 480x360px

>/cyoa/ but as a cartoon/anime intro

>>29868645
I wanna be the very best.
Like Lis never was.
To billy them is my real.
Critque them is my cause.
Cyoa
I will shitpost across the board.
>Rapeing far and wide

And that is all I can remember of the song. I will look it up and write more later.

>>29868691
*To billy them is my real test.
We have ruskies and argentinens here I better clarify what I meant to say.

>>29868691
Oh I have more.
Teach qms to understand.
The edge that is inside.

I want to hug a QM pone. Which one is the cuddliest?

>>29868830
me

>>29868832

Okay...
What does Cammy pone look like?

>>29868839
Pretty sure he's a blue manlet griffon. Like actually small.

>>29868844

Griffon huh? Exotic, and maybe not the cuddliest. I'll pass. What other QM pones are for cuddles?

>>29864356
I really wanna know. I need to know if I should pity him or laugh at him. I will leave it to you to decide which answer gives which result.

>>29868890
Oh that gives me an idea.
>>29868870
Is there a Cainpone? He probably needs a hug even more then you do right now.

>>29868870
You didn't hear this from me, but Inept is a total cuddleslut.

>>29865237
Rude.

>>29868900
Inept, it's late, get some sleep...
I should sleep too. Nobody try to cuddle me as I sleep.

>>29867243
ayyyyy real nice, thanks.
Did fulgy's qt mark look like a video game controller directional pad on purpose?

File: 1451902086810.png (117KB, 467x570px) Image search: [Google]

117KB, 467x570px

>>29868645
Oooooh skin stone cold!
We break the mold!
Seeing the aftermaaaaaath!
We venture forth!
But go off course!
For there's chaos in our paaaaaath!

Over mountains we fly!
In mists we cry!
Facing the very woooooorst
But we'll get through!
Our friendship true!
We'll break Canterlot's cuuuuuurse!

GENEROSITY ALWAYS GIVES TWICE!
KINDNESS CUTS TO BE NICE!
LOYALTY BREAKS BUT NEVER BENDS!
HONESTY GOES DEEPER FOR A FRIEND!
LAUGHTER STARTS THINGS WITH A BANG!
AND MAGIC LEADS THEM LIKE ONLY IT CAN!

>>29868830
Do you want two pones at once, Anon?

>>29868645
I won't forget the promise we made
I'll close my eyes and ascertain it
Shaking off the darkness that closed in on me, I advance on
When can I see again here
the cyoa that is on hiatus?
Again and again, I'll tear apart the shadow of distress that spilled out
and post on in this thread
The time that ticked away ceaselessly now announces the beginning
Putting my unchanging feelings into it
I'll open the new thread
The qm has started to run, in order to draw the future
Even if I come to a standstill on a difficult road
The sky is always waiting for me in a beautiful blue
So I'm not scared
By now, no matter what happens, I won't get disheartened

>>29868968
That would also work. Who are these cuddle cuties?

>>29868970
Fuck off ifag.

>>29868983
Amp pon and RADIOACTIVE! pon

>>29868899
Cain does not deserve a poner.

>>29869002
If he deserves a poner comes down to
>>29864356

>>29869002
y tho

>>29868990
The fuck makes you think that is ifag.

File: servoskull.jpg (98KB, 699x748px) Image search: [Google]

98KB, 699x748px

>>29869002
Cain can have a pony servo skull.

>>29869013
Only ifag cares enough about madoka to write a fucking parody of the theme song

>>29869017
E D G E Q U E S T
D
G
E

Q
U
E
S
T

>>29869030
I am normaly the one saying this. Does that make this a meme now that somebody else did it.

>>29869029
You clearly care enough about madoka to recognize the english translation of a Japanese song for a show that has not been relevant in almost 5 years.

>>29869040
I watched the show so I could learn to recognize that faggot better.

>>29869044
That is fucking barneyfag tier dude.

ignore ifag screechers.
Do not engage ifag screechers.
Filter any post containing the word "ifag"

>>29869048
>Filter any post containing the word "ifag"
Imagine if >>29869044 had used the word. You would miss out on some prime cringe.

File: 1485493479105.png (12KB, 440x620px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 440x620px

>>29868990
>>29869013
>>29869029
>>29869048
>>29869079

New Captain's CYOA! Good, shit's fixed, but now the Princess wants to have a heart to heart. Again.

This can only end well I'm sure. >>29869157

>>29869211
let's continue our currently drunk adventures

>>29869218
Did you say drunk? Count me in.

>>29869218
Let's not.

>>29869044
Are you lee goldsons ponyfag brother.>>29869047

>>29869474
Kek I did not mean to quote that second post but it is pretty fitting.

>>29867243
That's fucking perfect. Thanks a ton. Now I don't have to use generic shit from Derpiboiru as my OP.

Any qm running during the episode is a retard.

>>29869112
>Still posting this stale ass meme horse

>>29869584
>Watching the show

>>29869605
>Not watching the show

>>29869584
Any Qm who runs at all is a retard.

>>29869629
Good thing I run only short fuckexcuses of quests here now.

>>29868970
So many quests I want back.
I think I understand homuras pain a little better now.

File: habbening.gif (973KB, 312x213px) Image search: [Google]

973KB, 312x213px

>>29869584
I... completely forgot about that.
I'm busy tomorrow so fuck it. New episode should mean /mlp/ gets MORE traffic.

On a related note, Age of Strife going up within an hour or so.

>>29868645
*obnoxious music and events that never occur for two and a half minutes*

What is it about blue ponis that makes them so shit?

>>29869849
Blue ponies are great.

File: Castle_of_the_Two_Sisters_S5E26.png (1MB, 1905x1075px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1905x1075px

>>29869784
>>29869887

>>29869784
>>29869887

>>29869784
>>29869887

Live from /mlp/, it's Saturday morning!

another season
another chance of new things to put into CYOAs

>>29869898
That observatory is precariously placed.

Did you know you're all my very best FRAAAAAAAAAANNNCE

Ffffuuuuuuccck. Do No Harm was Archieved. Could have sworn I bumped that.

>>29871962
Must be because of season 7.

>>29872047
>still takes an hour to get to page 10
not really

>>29872129
It's normally 3-4 hours. The only reason more haven't been falling off is because I'm bumping them all.

>>29872213
>It's normally 3-4 hours.

oh
I guess I'm used to when it was 1:30

File: Aurora Flare.png (915KB, 511x458px) Image search: [Google]

915KB, 511x458px

Crystal Symphony is alive.
>>29873634

Running.
>>29874710

>>29867640
Crap Landfall died in the season 7 rush.

>>29874862
I know right?

>Describe the last quest you played in one word
>Describe /cyoa/ in one word
>Describe your life in one word

Got that? Then:
Those three words in that order are the title of your metal album

>>29875331
fuck fuck fuck

>>29875331
Alien Fuck Mess

>>29875331
cute
shit
shit

>>29875331
big notageneral I'mnottelling

>>29875331
Good shit man
It's metalcore but in major scale

>>29875331
Kaiju undead autopilot

>>29875913
That's definitely some power metal.

>>29875913
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZO6giM9UAv0

i cant even be bothered to resume my quest. fuck im so bored.

>>29876048
>blocked
ok

>>29876319
I am so, so sorry, Anon. The song is fucking great, one of my favorites
Look for Aces High by Iron Maiden, I am sure you'll find something

Fuck you!

>>29875331
This is going to skew the word cloud so far in favor of shit.

>>29876885
u2

>>29875331
Fascinating
Inconsistent
Satisfying

File: c86.gif (71KB, 416x490px) Image search: [Google]

71KB, 416x490px

>>29875331
Consistent
Circlejerk
Despair

>>29875331
Existence
Is
Suffering

We are meating the humans in Nebula. I am so excited.

>>29877095
>We are meating the humans
>Meating
That was fast

>>29877095
>We are meating the humans
kinky

>>29877095
Are they going to realign your moral fiber.

File: 1464144699329.png (99KB, 425x375px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 425x375px

>>29877095

>>29877119
Or, terrifying, depending on how you wanna look at it.

>>29877210
In a sexual way of course.

>>29877224
Well I guess, if you find the possible idea of turning people into meat, sexual. Then yeah.

>>29877210
Judging by the banners I think it might be a red cross station. Which we kind of need right now.

>>29875331
Mob Trash Hell

>>29877245
The robes make me wonder if it a religious station.
Oh looks like it is indeed.

>>29877242
What about "meating = giving them the meat = dicking"

>>29877367
I do like that interpretation anon. But I was just being cheeky about the morbid interpretation of killing and turning people into meat.

But dicking sounds like it'd be much, much, more fun.

>>29877190
They are templers so maybe.

>>29877445
They are going to rip out our central nervous systems in rightous anger.

I just watched celestial advice.
Did it give anypony a cyoa idea.

Are there any 720p+ YT or Dailymotion links yet?

>>29877650
Sekrit has the link, yes :^)

>>29877674
Okay, gonna wait until yayponies has it tomorrow.

>>29877650
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x5iegvn

>>29877710
Thanks m8

>>29877650
>720p+
Who fucking needs that many p

>>29875331
Crystal Madness Mistake.

>>29875331
Adventure retarded ok.

Do you like Vincent's portrayal of sombrero?

>>29878402
He needs more dick in his add. Then he'll be golden.

>>29878402
I don't play his CYOA

>>29877198
Hype why so concerned?

>>29878787
He is concerned because he is a pathetic excuse for a man.

File: Pinkie_Pie.png (657KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

657KB, 1280x720px

Tell me it's not true.

File: 1457485228953.png (64KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 900x900px

>>29878892
Don't talk to me or my horsebando ever again.

>>29878892
Why do you tell lie?
There are no proofs.
Who benefits?

Zenith has a little wenis

File: Not so L-Lewd.png (96KB, 1042x1000px) Image search: [Google]

96KB, 1042x1000px

Resuming Miracle, or, 404 boogaloo: >>29879103


>>29879097
I will cut you.

>>29877662
>voyager 1 is only 3,558 years old.
I get the feeling the distance between star systems is massivly condensed in Nebula compared to real life and pony ftl is not quite as impressive as I first thought.

File: [empty].jpg (83KB, 574x551px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 574x551px

Pick an image you think describes a quest, guess other's responses.

File: 1448597235303.jpg (148KB, 452x807px) Image search: [Google]

148KB, 452x807px

>>29879154
Frostbitten

File: 1390174294351.gif (739KB, 400x225px) Image search: [Google]

739KB, 400x225px

>>29879154

>>29878893
It's not true.

>>29879116
Little caterpillar sized

File: Bismuth_crystals_and_1cm3_cube.jpg (72KB, 800x540px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 800x540px

>>29879154

File: 4158864-charybdis-percy_jackson-sea_of_monsters-concept_art_by_sebastian_meyers-final.jpg (308KB, 1440x764px) Image search: [Google]

308KB, 1440x764px

>>29879154
Cirquesque

File: Far&Coti by Bath.png (1MB, 1200x909px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1200x909px

Did you know the material the Crystal Heart and all species of crystaline trees is an organic material with many traits normally associated to ceramics, such as resistance to sudden change in temperatures?
In another note, resuming Hail: >>29879330
There'll be a small pause while I buy something and take a bath.


>>29879276
I will summon EA's executive chairmen onto your household.

File: motherfucking bismuth.jpg (240KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

240KB, 1000x1000px

>>29879293
There is no quest as awesome as motherfucking bismuth. Not even every quest that has ever been posted on /mlp/ combined would come near.
FUCK YOU. FUCKING HERESY.

>>29879364
This might be my favorite image from Bath.

>>29879293
Darkest Hour

>>29879341
I think your image is Cirquesque as well.

If that is what you meant when you said Cirquesque you missed the point of the exercise

>>29879293
A hint.
It was a bad choice of image.

The cyoa in question does not have many edges but the single edge it did have was the edgiest thing I have ever seen in cyoa.

>>29879374
His ponies look kinda like garbage, but the composition and atmosphere/lighting actually look pretty nice.

>>29879396
>cyoa in question does not have many edges
>post an image depicting a mineral known for having many edges
You're stupid, and I hate you.

File: I'M BISMUTH, BITCH.jpg (32KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 300x300px

>>29879419
>mineral
It's post-transition metal, you stupid prick. Do you want me to fuck your shit up?

File: shield with shields on it.png (3KB, 185x250px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 185x250px

>>29869493

No problem, glad to be of service.

>>29868935
>Did fulgy's qt mark look like a video game controller directional pad on purpose?

During her design phase I was trying REALLY hard to not just make her female Shining Armor, so I wanted to avoid a single shield for the CM. It's supposed to be four kite shields arranged in a plus, for reasons that I don't think I really ever thought too had about.

>>29851507
Sorry about that. I was caring for a friend in the hospital. She insisted I keep up with the cyoa I am already playing but I could not find the time to read up.

I would consolidate it now especialy considering the one guy who said he would have probably read it if I had done so but as several anons tried to explain the crititicism was always going to slow down, it was mostly about new characters and how well you handled differing expectations of morality, motivations and goals. It just sped back up again because I got to the drama part.

However I am spending easter with my family so I will not be able to make the final session anyway. As such I can take my time and put all the rest of it into a few posts.

>>29879433
Sorry, anon. I apologize for using the wrong word to refer to bismuth. I hope we can still be friends.

File: BismuthCrystal_big.jpg (364KB, 1500x1129px) Image search: [Google]

364KB, 1500x1129px

>>29879488
Friends have no value, only bismuth.

>>29879419
I said it was a bad image.

>>29879504
That's fine, I didn't actually want to be your friend anyway. Friends are for nerds, and so is shitty minerals like bismuth.

>>29879516
This certainly wasn't the only bad choice in your life, was it?

File: yes I mad.gif (2MB, 350x197px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 350x197px

>>29879526

>>29879458
perhaps ponies aren't your thing if you can't design cutie marks
oh wait :^)

>>29879364
Microscopic organism sized

>>29879707
Getting pretty pleonastic there, bruh.

>>29879735
Vagina sized

>>29879396
>only one piece of edge
Not Darkest Hour then.

File: Darkest Hour.png (560KB, 974x788px) Image search: [Google]

560KB, 974x788px

>>29879805

>>29879805
No DH only had a single piece of genuine edge as well. Unlike the single piece in Custos though it was mild.

File: 1417997250054.gif (305KB, 500x319px) Image search: [Google]

305KB, 500x319px

>Dankest Edge defense force

>>29879866
I... what? Anon, what piece are you exactly referring to, because I am pretty sure I know the quest but can't remember what part is supposed to be edgy

>>29879908
I can no longer get mad about people who swear it is not an edge quest. Look how many anons swore off the movie over a unicorn with a broken horn.

>>29879866
>if I repeat it often enough people will get tired of correcting me and I'll win!

>>29879941
Didn't the very first thread start with blowing up a monster, splattering its guts all over the cave and later stabbing a pony in the throat or somthing like that?

>>29879945
what like three?

>>29879941
The really bad edge in Custos Luna was that not giving the new recruits enough food shit. The mild edge in Darkest Hour was the kid getting locked up because his father was a Celestia sympathizer. In the kids case though it served the story well and most of the edge was drained out because the mc did not approve.

There has to have been a less edgy way to establish that guy was an arsehole in Custos though.

File: tied up and raped.gif (274KB, 250x141px) Image search: [Google]

274KB, 250x141px

>>29880003
>>>>

>>29879974
>stabbing a pony in the throat
I think somebody said most combat in that quest involved exploiting gaps in armor so that is to be expected.

>>29880030
And it's not edgy if it "is to be expected"?

>>29880047

Anon, you're arguing with another (Anon) who insists that the quest that contains: rape, murder, torture, and takes inspiration from Warhammer 40k, is just misunderstood and not edgy. Just stop replying.

>>29879002
Raven why so angry?

>>29880072
>murder.
A couple of attempts on our life right at the start. After that everything was war.

>>29880072
Good point, actually.

Guys, is Arc ded?

>>29880228
Very

>>29880257
Did they ever say why?

>>29879379
Oh. Woops.

>>29880262
Because he's a bitch

>>29879401
Is it because my lineart is sketchy messy bullshit, or is there something wrong with the anatomy or style?

>>29880047
>combat is edgy

>>29879974
If you are gonna complain about gore complain about big mare hero.

>>29880311
I haven't been around, would you care to explain what happened if you happen to know?

>>29880444
Ripping the arms off giant lobstermen is not edgy; it's the culinary tradition of the bigpone people.

>>29880469
IRC He decided QMing was harming him as a writer because it wasn't the right medium for him and decided to step down. He wrote a few pastebins to finish his stories, tho.

>>29880469
Nope

>>29880136
Because it's war.

>>29880491
Is he going to write anymore? Does he have a page for any future stories? Do you know where I could find the said pastebin links?

>>29880515
Arc wants to become a full-fledged writer, I think. But you'd be better off actually asking him, he's in the klub so PMing him would take a second.

Is edge a bad thing?

>>29880548
It's not inherently bad, but most people grow out of it with the end of puberty.

>>29880548
Edge is a tool that is often used badly.
Guns don't kill people, its people who aim it at each other.

>>29880548
Not nesecarily. We have never had a true edge quest but many of our quests have benifted from a tiny bit of edge.

>>29880527
I see, i'll have to go poke him a bit. Thanks for the answers anon.

>>29880548
No, of course not. Many tools would be mostly useless without an edge. Drills or axes might not work as well if the pointy sharp edge bits weren't pointy or sharp.

>>29880527
Not-writing isnt a better way to learn writing and he's far from good enough to be picky.

>>29880548
It's not a bad song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC3JwHbp7ro

>>29880601
You don't get to be up your ass and tell writers what to do, anon.

>>29880610
Who are you? The don't-be-up-your-ass-and tell-writers-what-to-do police?
I'm going to find a writer and tell him what to do right now, and you can't stop me.

>>29880628
Anon eat your veggies and go to bed right fucking now goddammit.

>>29880633
Make me. You can't stop me.

File: 1423027299400.jpg (88KB, 960x720px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 960x720px

>>29880640
If you don't, wizpider will find you.

>>29880571
I'm pretty sure a couple of Bath's quests have been actual edge quests. Also Unique has some edge in it too, not enough to be an edge quest though.

>>29880649
Go ahead and try, wizpider. You'll never find me. The road will be filled with peril, like restrooms with no toilet paper, and hot dog stands that charge slightly too much for a hot dog that doesn't taste very good, and might also be undercooked. Also it might rain sometimes too, and I bet you don't have a wizpider sized umbrella.
You'll probably give up within a day, and I'll be free to not eat my veggies and not go to bed at a reasonable time for all eternity.

Breaktime, Princesses Orders!

>>29880759

Captain's CYOA continues!

>>29880491
I don't remember him actually ever writing any of those pastebins. He left all his quests to die, including one that was on the last thread.

>>29880566
Yes, after puberty wars and rape stop to exist.

>>29865975
I liked FiT slightly better, but I loved both. FiT topped Spicy in character development so it gets nudged ahead of Spicy on my list of Super All-time Greatest and Objectively Best CYOAs.

Also, luring in pokemon players before revealing an autistic character was brilliant.

Which edge quest is the edgiest.

>>29881446

Lyra quest

>>29880571
>We have never had a true edge quest
Planeswalker. But sorry in advance, I don't want to argue about what you consider "true edge" to be.

I think that's what that CYOA was called anyways.

>>29881511
You mean Surfacesprinter?

File: Z1r-0ykcpEx_.jpg (42KB, 450x450px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 450x450px

>>29881521
I told you, I don't want to argue about it, but no, I meant Poletrimmer.

>>29881511
It's funny. Planeswalker was an edge quest but we called it that before it got edgy. I also find it ammusing that people thought it was going to be a mechanicly heavy quest.

File: 1492312679638.png (212KB, 297x588px) Image search: [Google]

212KB, 297x588px

Anyone else finding these guys progressively more tolerable as time goes on?

I almost want one in a CYOA. Almost.

>>29881585
>we called it that before it got edgy
Come to think of it that is every edge quest.
>Darkest Hour before the traitor sacrifice.
>Planeswalker before the mother death.

>>29881678
I want to see a changeling gorefest.

>>29881678
There was one in a CYOA.

>>29881678

>YOU ARE BRIGHT SHINY PRETTY BUG
>YOU SELL SO MANY TOYS
>YOU ARE ADAPTING TO YOUR NEW LIFE IN THE SPARKLE CRYSTAL HIVE OF FRIENDSHIP™
>WHAT DO?

>>29881731
Go ask king Thorax what we will do if Chrysalis comes back.

>>29881731
Pony does not have exact change.
Fight?

>>29881731
Suggest we paint the hive new colors to match our new look.

>>29881731
Make a petition to king thorax to rebuild the old give to acomedate our new race.

>>29881731
What color are we? This is important.

>>29881731
What's are name? I think it should be Capicola.

File: 1482911238219-1.png (161KB, 986x565px) Image search: [Google]

161KB, 986x565px

>>29881728
And she was delicious.

>>29881712
It's almost like we are influencing the adventures.

>>29881744
What if she was already back, how would we know!?