[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

Why do Americans dislike Yukiko?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 385
Thread images: 109

File: yuki.png (199KB, 300x450px) Image search: [Google]
yuki.png
199KB, 300x450px
Why do Americans dislike Yukiko?
>>
Nobody dislikes Yukiko except for people who want to shill their waifus. People just hate her stupid blush portrait that looks like her face is caving in. The rest of her is fine and she is a delightful character with a huge ass.
>>
>>383641486
>>>/int/
>>
>>383641486
Yamato Nadeshiko is not a thing in burgerland.
>>
She's boring
>>
File: 1487766746425.jpg (263KB, 638x690px) Image search: [Google]
1487766746425.jpg
263KB, 638x690px
>>383641486
I want to ____ Yukiko
>>
>so boring that Q had to make up a personality since there was nothing to exaggerate
>>
She's boring and when she finally gets a defining personality trait, her laugh, it annoyed the hell out of me
>>
File: appreciation station.jpg (223KB, 1200x503px) Image search: [Google]
appreciation station.jpg
223KB, 1200x503px
>>383641486
I love Yukiko so much though.
>>
>>383642594
I want to bench Yukiko!
but she's the best party member in the game and I'd be handicapping myself
>>
Americans hate femininity and love retards, so they love Chie.
>>
>>383642086
There is its called "Proper lady"
>>
>>383642594
sneeze
>>
>>383641486
Also, is that you, senpai? I've missed your threads lately.
>>
>>383642981
In America Chie would have blue hair and a nose piercing
>>
>>383641486
American here. Yukiko is best girl.
>>
File: EikichiISAngry.png (14KB, 108x176px) Image search: [Google]
EikichiISAngry.png
14KB, 108x176px
It's not that I hate her especially but she's the easiest to point to and explain why the P4 cast are a bunch of whiny spoiled twats.

>Wah my mommy makes me help out the business when I want to go the food court. waaaaah.
>waaaah I don't want to inherit the inn
>OH wait yes I do.

Do we ever even see her mom? Do we see anyone else's perspective on the whole inherit the inn thing beyond her's? We see no one force anything on her beyond what amounts to chores and we're expected to think that creates an interesting character? She's a brat. They all are.

I make this comparison a lot but take Michel from 2. We see he has a dream beyond his family's business, we see his father terrifies and abuses him and we see him actually struggle with it. That's a character.

Yukiko has no goals, she has no dreams. She's just a spoiled princess who gets pissy she has to help her family put food on the table and the only sign we see that she's got her future decided for her is some off hand comment made by a faceless newscaster.

This is how ALL the characters in 4 are. A bunch of shitty douche bag teens whining like the world's out to get them when their problems are less than what most of the players experience daily. There's no bullies, no abuse, not suffering. Kanji makes a dungeon because he's scared people are going to call him a faggot? Big fucking whoop. That's not an arc. Nobody wants to be called a faggot. Naoto is throwing a huff because the adults don't want some stupid teenager walking in on their murder mystery, oh shock and horror. Chie doesn't even get a gungeon and Yosuke is quick to forget the girl he likes got killed.

They're not characters. They're boring and it's infuriating watching them spread this toothless shit over 70 hours
>>
>>383643220
?
>>
>>383641486
I want to fuck and cuck Yukiko!
>>383643220
Fuck off.
>>
>>383641486
She's got great pantyhose.

But it's not as good as Rise's Zettai Ryouiki
>>
She was the slightly more tolerable half of a pair of utterly boring and unremarkable girls.
>>
I like Yukiko probably the best of 4s girls. Pretty much for this >>383643383 reason.
>>
>>383642981
Worst girl in a cast made of worst girls.
>>
File: 1494793122681.jpg (186KB, 414x576px) Image search: [Google]
1494793122681.jpg
186KB, 414x576px
Yukiko looks too Japanese and Japanese people are incredibly ugly
>>
File: 1412722393262.png (343KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
1412722393262.png
343KB, 1280x720px
>>383641486
Because Americans are low IQ and get their opinions from internet memes. Best girl easily.
>>
>>383643383
>tolerable
>retarded laugh
>wahhh the Inn
>>
>>383643352
You're not him, so I don't care.
>>
>>383643609
I said "slightly".
>>
>>383643609
Shut up, it's an endearing character trait.
>>
>>383641486
Because Rise is better
>>
>>383643327
>and Yosuke is quick to forget the girl he likes got killed
Until they need him to be a melodramatic faggot and conveniently bring her up.
>>
File: protag.jpg (307KB, 883x800px) Image search: [Google]
protag.jpg
307KB, 883x800px
>>383641486
Because asshats want to see her cry when you reject her on Valentines Day
>>
@383643327
https://boards.fireden.net/_/search/filename/eikichii%2A/

pfhahaHAHAHAHAHA
here, take this big L
>>
File: avatar-510330.jpg (22KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]
avatar-510330.jpg
22KB, 250x250px
Because Rise is superior
>>
>>383642781
> best party member
Only until Yosuke gets Winds of Youth.
>>
I wanted to like her due to the good design, but there's no personality there. All she has is the inn, and the silly laugh. That's it.
>>
>>383643789
Honestly I've never played Golden, only the original
>>
File: 1498103064476.gif (483KB, 500x325px) Image search: [Google]
1498103064476.gif
483KB, 500x325px
>>383643669
>>383643770
Your completely wrong, but telling you why would be a waste of time since you're just gonna ignore it.
>>
File: 主雪.jpg (164KB, 630x657px) Image search: [Google]
主雪.jpg
164KB, 630x657px
goat newspaper
>>
>>383643770
she says "senpai" with an annoying enunciation.
worst girl, i'm afraid.
>>
>>383643789
He's still a master of none.
>>
>>383643618
>him
lmao
>>
I Love America and I love Yukiko !
>>
>>383641486
Because she's built for femdom.
>>
>>383644041
Shut the fuck up

Laura Bailey made it sound hot.

Come round the corner and say that again.
>>
>>383643789
You get Winds of Youth pretty late to the point that it feels redundant
>>
>>383644096
Damn son.
>>
File: 1399692140187.jpg (25KB, 159x205px) Image search: [Google]
1399692140187.jpg
25KB, 159x205px
>Be Chang Thunderwang
>Hang out with a creeper, a boring unappealing dork with an inferiority complex, a boring spoiled girl, a slut, and a ballbusting NARC who's secretly Buffalo Bill
>Want to just to ditch these losers and hang out with Kanji and my bros in the sports clubs
>Can't ditch them because need people who can use stands to solve murder mystery
>mfw
>>
>>383644402
>wahh let me be gay
>>
>>383644215
Depends on which e-mail you're talking about though. The Konata one?
>>
>>383644157
I'm coming round the corner right now sch*lurrp*enn pay
>>
>character has incredibly simple and straightforward arc
>retards still misunderstand it
Her problem was never the inn itself. It was feeling trapped and like her future was already decided for her. It's the same "struggle against fate" bullshit every Japanese game uses. But unlike other instances of the trope where the characters inexplicably are able to defy or rewrite fate, Yukiko comes to terms with and accepts that there's limits to what she can change.
>>
File: 1483065377301.jpg (15KB, 285x249px) Image search: [Google]
1483065377301.jpg
15KB, 285x249px
>>383644578
>Being too low-test to have any standards in women
Shut up and do my homework, nerd.
>>
File: 4.jpg (955KB, 1256x1800px) Image search: [Google]
4.jpg
955KB, 1256x1800px
>>383641486

I love Yukiko. I just love Chie and Rise more.
>>
File: 1495742479245.jpg (47KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]
1495742479245.jpg
47KB, 512x512px
Step aside, plebs. Best girl is here
>>
>>383645103
>Chang Thunderwang
>not getting as much pussy as he can get his hands on
Nah fuck that I want to hang out with 3 gay dudes.
>>
>>383644835
>e-mail
Never mind. I never did that. OP send vibes.
>>
File: 420_ayy_lmao.jpg (24KB, 480x480px) Image search: [Google]
420_ayy_lmao.jpg
24KB, 480x480px
>>383641486
Yukiko is boring just like the other P4
They're all stupid and emotionally act like weird impossible to empathise with aliens.

They don't seem to care or have any stake in anything at alll, their entire world and lackluster development revolves around the protagonist.

If you were the average Joe in Inaba you might not have noticed a problem at all.

Compare this to Persona 3 , which is no masterpiece but executed where p4 stumbled.

The main cast, while playing into stereotypes also subverts these stereotypes to make a character that isn't as 2 dimensional or more accurately 1 dimensional like P4 cast.

Unlike persona 4 your feet are not kissed as soon as you arrive , and the characters all have their own worlds and hardships to overcome.

The city of P3 also changes over time , degrading as the story progresses with nameless inhabitants expressing a range of emotion.
It's obvious a lot more love and thought went into P3, which is shame because as we see in P4 all you have to so is have static stereotypical characters that tell the player he's doing good and need the player to do anything in their lives
>>
File: gsdx_20170529161811.jpg (416KB, 2560x2048px) Image search: [Google]
gsdx_20170529161811.jpg
416KB, 2560x2048px
I went with Yukiko my first playthrough because she seemed the most relatable out of the cast. She's not extroverted and pretty reserved, and that's completely okay.
>>
>>383645730
>Compare this to Persona 3
stopped reading
>>
File: Reina Tanaka.jpg (535KB, 1200x1722px) Image search: [Google]
Reina Tanaka.jpg
535KB, 1200x1722px
>>383645286
>That feel when you gravitated towards Rise because she looks like an idol you had a crush on way back when.
>>
>>383641486
She's as boring as Fuuka
>>
File: 1499819102122.png (200KB, 606x563px) Image search: [Google]
1499819102122.png
200KB, 606x563px
Fuck you Alex
>>
Shout out to P5 for mentioning that it's worth to visit the Amagi Inn just to see the hot and sexy young lady that owns it.
>>
>>383645781
She acts like someone with a broken brain
>>
Do you think Akira faps to the Rise poster in his room haha
>>
File: gsdx_20170624185412.png (2MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
gsdx_20170624185412.png
2MB, 1920x1080px
>>383645884
Take that back
>>
>if it's not a walking cesspool of tropes and meme potential, it doesn't have a personality
When will this end?
>>
File: 1472351893740.jpg (182KB, 500x711px) Image search: [Google]
1472351893740.jpg
182KB, 500x711px
>>383641486
This was taken right after Golden came out, so all of P4 girls should have been sitting on top since they were fresh in peoples minds. The Japs don't even like her that much and ignore the guys sitting on top becuases shitty fujo's vote going by what guys are the most shippable.
>>
File: gsdx_20170520152444.jpg (343KB, 2560x2048px) Image search: [Google]
gsdx_20170520152444.jpg
343KB, 2560x2048px
Her shadow's design is my favourite of all the party members.
>>
>>383646479
you might as well ignore the whole list then
>>
>>383646670
Fujo's don't give a flying fuck about that girls, but do what you like.
>>
>>383646479
>Adachi right below Koro
>Koro even being in he top 20
What the fuck even is this list?
>>
File: 1498669212785.jpg (165KB, 1280x960px) Image search: [Google]
1498669212785.jpg
165KB, 1280x960px
>>383646613
If this keeps up, she'll cum?
>>
>>383646845
God she's so gorgeous.
>>
File: gsdx_20170530145853.jpg (463KB, 2560x2048px) Image search: [Google]
gsdx_20170530145853.jpg
463KB, 2560x2048px
>>383646845
>>
>>383646821
>Not like Koro
How does it feel to be a huge faggot?
>>
>>383644041
>Insulting literally the sexiest female voice in all of video games
When they recasted Rise I wanted to never play a Persona game again
>>
>>383643130
Southern belle?
>>
>>383647187
She already recasted, Bailey not doing her voice anymore
>>
File: 2365392_p0.png (80KB, 350x500px) Image search: [Google]
2365392_p0.png
80KB, 350x500px
>>383646479
I am impressed Aigis somehow manged to stay relevant to the polls after 10 years
>>
File: IMG_0006.jpg (771KB, 1200x1720px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_0006.jpg
771KB, 1200x1720px
>>383647310
Burch also quit. Hopefully we can get Bailey back or at least the world's greatest imitation for best girl.
>>
>>383647428
Enjoy Marisha Ray.
>>
>>383647402
Aigis is their favorite character because she's low maintenance and in love with you forever no matter what
>>
>>383647125
It's just a dog. His presence added nothing to the game.
>>
>>383647402
You have no idea how popular she is anon. Look what happens when she is actually in the game.
>>
File: Fuuka Playstation.jpg (182KB, 481x700px) Image search: [Google]
Fuuka Playstation.jpg
182KB, 481x700px
>>383645884
There is no one more pleasant to be with than Fuuka
>>
>>383647485
She sounds nothing like Bailey though
I just want my Rise back
>>
>>383647547
Same can be said for Yukiko, but she got a bunch of votes and I would say the dog did even more then her since he stopped them all from dying to Ikutsuki
>>
>>383643672

There's a lot of inconsistency general lack of tension and overall plot in 4
>>
File: 1499226093317.png (342KB, 794x473px) Image search: [Google]
1499226093317.png
342KB, 794x473px
>>383647564
PQ Aigis was the best character in the game, so that one is pretty fair
>>
>>383647778
To be honest it's not like any of these games, except for maybe P2 (which would be a much better VN because it's a super shitty JRPG) have particularly good writing.
>>
File: 1497356590918.jpg (1MB, 800x1199px) Image search: [Google]
1497356590918.jpg
1MB, 800x1199px
>>383647917
>Almost all of the characters are flanderized AND unfunny
>Aigis is flanderized and actually funny
How does she do it bros
>>
Public blowjobs from Rise
>>
File: 1498876468381.jpg (107KB, 960x544px) Image search: [Google]
1498876468381.jpg
107KB, 960x544px
>>383648041
Only for Senpai
>>
>>383647919
P3 characters are pretty well written besides a few that just sort of didn't do much and the story is pretty well done, but my god it had pacing issues.
>>
>>383641486
Personality of a brick. I was gonna choose her but she doesn't grow through her social link until the end. She's useful for Fire and Heals. About it. Chie was better desu and I thought people were memeing she was best girl. Ryse 2nd.
>>
>>383647564
What an odd five-way tie
>>
>>383648132
P3 is probably the best plot with the worst possible pacing, like it's genuinely painful. Even the movies suffered it.
>>
>>383647428
sadpanda
>>
>>383641486
Modern Westerners are Nu male Betas so they want a whore who will NTR them instead of a pure maiden who will never leave their side.
>>
>>383641486
She's stupid.
>>
>>383648016
They made her like really snarky and a dick to people without meaning to be and it made a lot of things said really funny.
>>
>>383648246
It's not a tie, it's

MC > Aigis > Corndog slut > Narukami > Naoto
>>
>>383648285

Honestly I blame the whole calendar system. I bet you could shave off at least a good third of the games run time if you where allowed to move at a decent clip
>>
>>383648371
I meant Shinji, Elizabeth, Teddie, Yosuke, and Zen all in 7th
>>
>>383641486
Fuck off, I'm from freedomland and Yukiko is best p4 girl
>>
File: IMG_0007.jpg (675KB, 1200x1777px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_0007.jpg
675KB, 1200x1777px
>>383648342
....you mean you want the link to the doujin?

https://e-hentai.org/g/739222/f97525a9bc
>>
>>383648285
Both P2's and P3 had the best character development and characters overall. I think P3 had a better and more well written story, but the pacing was bad so I think P2 handled theirs better overall becuase of this.
>>
>>383648520
What the fuck
>>
>>383644114
>Yukiko
>femdom
doubt.tif
>>
>>383648520
>>383648640
If I rememebr right Aigis and MC got like 85% of the votes all together or something, so there wasn't that much for other people and it just ended up this way.
>>
>>383648546
I'm still mad that we never got a third one with Naoto
>>
>>383648753
Yukiko is so devoid of personality you can project anything unto her and it isn't out of character
>>
>>383646845
It would be extremely painful
>>
>>383648546
Thank you, this artist is like the only one that does persona's artstyle justice and doesn't give all the girls cowtits.
>>
>>383648805
>fitting in: the post
>>
>>383648948
Am I wrong?
>>
>>383648781
Would it be Naoto being NTR'd by Rise? Both of them fucking Narukami?
>>
>>383648948
You're the one misusing greentext here, buddy.
>>
>>383648983
Threesome
>>
>>383641486
i actually love yukiko and her dressing style. it inspired me to try wearing black pantyhose with some of my outfits
>>
>>383648939
>Their is a guy that does the style well, but he only ever draws Aigis and her sisters sometimes
Aigis is cute at least, but come on.
>>
>>383649001
>buddy
gotem good
>>
File: 1486800064842.jpg (870KB, 960x2720px) Image search: [Google]
1486800064842.jpg
870KB, 960x2720px
wh*t d*d sh* m**n b* th*s
>>
>>383648960
Of course
>>
>>383649154
The only like lewder in the entire franchise is when Yukari worries that if she gets too excited she'll wake up the neighbors
>>
>>383649229
That doesn't sound very convincing
>>
>>383649341
>>
>>383649578
Christ my dick
That's almost as hot as the line that must not be spoken.
>>
>>383649615
Coming from a boygirl, it wasn't that hot though
>>
File: rb.jpg (814KB, 1536x1738px) Image search: [Google]
rb.jpg
814KB, 1536x1738px
>>383649115
The Yukiko Aesthetic
>>
File: 1499465099136.jpg (89KB, 720x712px) Image search: [Google]
1499465099136.jpg
89KB, 720x712px
>>383649662
>>
File: 1478492011589.jpg (889KB, 2560x2764px) Image search: [Google]
1478492011589.jpg
889KB, 2560x2764px
>>383649341
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PP6ZplZlWkA
I still don't think I have seen anything that I found as lewd as Aigis's max Slink. Something about this is so damn lewd.
>>
>>383649737
I meant for "the line that must not be spoken."
>>
>>383649790
It's better when there's build up to it
>>
>>383641486

Shit taste
>>
>>383645428
I'm just trying to make sure nobody else is lusting after my Yukiko ERPer. And that you're not them either.
>>
Persona 4 was a mistake
>>
>>383646256
Why is she so ugly?
>>
File: obvcg80q7h1vnmhkyo1_540.gif (799KB, 540x304px) Image search: [Google]
obvcg80q7h1vnmhkyo1_540.gif
799KB, 540x304px
>>383649737
Everyone in that movie looked so pretty. It was great.
>>
>>383650058
I'm not.
>>
File: 1472406115829.png (1MB, 2504x3118px) Image search: [Google]
1472406115829.png
1MB, 2504x3118px
Am I shallow since I keep finding the prettiest girl the best? Like Yukiko
>>
>>383650086
Humanity was a mistake.
>>
>>383650365
OK then. There goes any chance of them being alive out the window then.
>>
>>383649517
I will love my dorky Snow Black forever
>>
>>383650058
>my Yukiko ERPer
Sometimes I forget how pathetic anon's life can be.
>>
File: 1498919183265.gif (844KB, 500x400px) Image search: [Google]
1498919183265.gif
844KB, 500x400px
>>383650373
Rise is the prettiest girl.
>>
>>383650702
no
>>
>>383650515
What the
>>
>>383650767
just ignore it anon, it's best to leave degenerates be
>>
>>383649737
Still a whore though
>>
File: ochqncvGf21unzdwso2_540.gif (1MB, 540x250px) Image search: [Google]
ochqncvGf21unzdwso2_540.gif
1MB, 540x250px
>>383650135
I think Aigis got like 60% more budget then all of the girls, so that is why she looked pretty
>>
>>383651101
stale meme, friend
>>
>>383651101
She's pure for Door
>>
>>383649679
yep pretty much how I dress on occasion
>>
>>383650135
I agree
>>
>>383650681
>>383650767
Grill who liked Yukiko. Probably got beaten to death.
>>
>>383651272
She started dating a bunch of guy later and Junpei complained about her saying she keep pumping and dumping guys and then coming bitching to him when she broke up with them in P4U
>>
>>383650681
Where do you think you are, Reddit?
>>
File: IMG_0214.png (4MB, 2208x1242px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_0214.png
4MB, 2208x1242px
>>383651462
Literally never happened. Junpei doesn't know shit about Yukari's love life
>>
>>383651248
>>383651272
>miniskirt
>pure
>>
>>383650373
What's up with the right foot?
>>
c-can I post my waifu who just happens to be from P5?
>>
>>383651631
Oh shit, I didn't know we had Arabs here. Hello foreigner friend!
>>
>>383651568
Pretty sure she gave up on because she can't really wait forever like Aigis or Liz can and she sort of got forced to admit during The Answer that Aigis loved him more, but who knows I guess.
>>
>>383641486
YUKIKO BEST GIRL
>>
Help, the Persona franchise is really big and I don't know where to continue after beating P3 and P4.
>>
>>383651812
It was probably not drawn fully, you can see there's no outline and the likely cause is that the artist thought it would be cut off by the image border
>>
>>383651896
As long as it isn't Futaba
>>
File: Thundercunt.jpg (231KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
Thundercunt.jpg
231KB, 1920x1080px
>>383651915
>miniskirts in dark alleys full of criminals
>pure
>>
>>383652094
Have you played P5 yet? If so play P2.
>>
File: 1481480224477.jpg (106KB, 632x891px) Image search: [Google]
1481480224477.jpg
106KB, 632x891px
>>383649737
I still haven't found out how you're supposed to legallywatch the movies. They don't seem have been fully released in the west.

And since nyaa went down, not sure how to pirate them, either.
>>
File: 1499483260392.png (365KB, 797x596px) Image search: [Google]
1499483260392.png
365KB, 797x596px
>>383652119
Definitely not.
>>
File: 1493610738863.png (523KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]
1493610738863.png
523KB, 1000x1000px
>>383652119
>>
>>383652156
>what is summer weather
>>
File: Bzx_gYFIcAEJdgN.jpg (54KB, 600x887px) Image search: [Google]
Bzx_gYFIcAEJdgN.jpg
54KB, 600x887px
>>383646479
I just realized that Fuuka and Maire didn't even make it into the top 10 even though they are two best girls form each of their games. What is wrong with peoples shit taste?
>>
>>383652303
I don't think you can legally watch them because they were never brought over, just subbed.

You could get the DVDs so you could have physical copies.
>>
>>383652381
Have you SEEN her winter outfit?
>>
File: da_pression.jpg (28KB, 417x326px) Image search: [Google]
da_pression.jpg
28KB, 417x326px
>>383646479
Where... Where is Junpei?
>>
>>383652595
Right there next to Fuuka
>>
>>383652374
Skeletons aren't allowed in this thread
>>
File: 1494021625356.jpg (75KB, 500x561px) Image search: [Google]
1494021625356.jpg
75KB, 500x561px
>>383652595
The Nips have no love for DA MAN. Just another showing of how shitty their taste in everything is.
>>
>>383652595
He has a girlfriend and can't be used by the Fujo's to ship with, so he gets no votes from the girls and guys all votes of the girls. He is shit out of luck.
>>
File: 1480306740358.png (339KB, 1172x1000px) Image search: [Google]
1480306740358.png
339KB, 1172x1000px
>>383652517
I just wanna watch them after beating 3.

It seems the only official thing is netflix, and for some reason, they only have the second movie on there.

Like I said, since nyaa exploded I really don't know what to do. It was the only torrent site I trusted to not give my pc aids
>>
>>383652930
9anime
>>
>>383652006
It wasn't that Aigis loved him more, it was that she had a stronger sense of protecting him, which makes sense since she's reason MC got into that mess in the first place
>>
>>383652930
/a/ made a new site that everyone uploading everything that was lost from nyaa that is running right now and I even helped uploading a 100 or so VNs to it, but I don't know if I should link it on /v/.
>>
>>383653216
is it .si
>>
>>383652523
I have and it's retarded because her non school summer outfit has her wearing pants while her non school winter outfit is with a skirt.
>>
>>383652160
I should have mentioned I don't have a PS3/4 for P5. Will play P2 next.
What about the spinoffs? Is Persona Q good? What about the animes? Mange?
>>
>>383653476
I think you should find a cheap PS3 and play P5 because it's fucking amazing.
>>
>>383653426
>it's retarded
perfectly fitting for her then
>>
>>383653476
PQ is mediocre but if you liked P3 and P4 you'll like it. Only anime that's worth it is the original P4 and the P3 movies, ignore Trinity Soul and Golden.
>>
File: THE man.png (42KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]
THE man.png
42KB, 500x500px
>>383652595
Where he'll always be, anon. In our hearts
>>
>>383653596
Golden had its moment with the Adachi backstory. Other than that it was shit.
>>
>>383653384
No
>>383653476
Persona Q is sort of fun just as a fanservice game is pretty fun if you liked P4 and P3. The P4 anime is pretty ok and the P3 movies are pretty good outside of the 3rd one is pretty eh.
>>
File: YHVHStanza.png (40KB, 228x316px) Image search: [Google]
YHVHStanza.png
40KB, 228x316px
>>383646479
>1451 votes

Look Im not really qualified who's actually popular but the only thing these magazine polls prove is whose fans are autistic enough to vote.

When the most popular entrant doesn't even hit 155 it's flat out stupid to call this a decent consensus when the games sell millions
>>
>>383653809
stop making sense anon
>>
>>383653809
>When the most popular entrant doesn't even hit 155
>When the most popular
Literally no one that is popular in Japan is sub 155 votes here and they use these to see who they should make merch for most times.
>>
>>383652930
http://kissanime.ru/Anime/Persona-3-the-Movie-1-Spring-of-Birth
This is where I watched the movies. Not sure if it'll give you aids but I haven't noticed anything on my PC so far
>>
>>383652595
For some reason I mistook him for a black guy in the game
>>
>>383654076
>.ru
>Not sure if it'll give you aids
>>
>>383654070

Typo. Shitty keyboard. But seriously learn to recognize typos you tard. Fucking context man.
>>
>>383654136
Oh shit, is that bad?
>>
>>383654076
Thanks, but I'd rather download it instead of streaming.
>>
File: SMT_Deep-StrangeJourney.jpg (332KB, 1280x545px) Image search: [Google]
SMT_Deep-StrangeJourney.jpg
332KB, 1280x545px
>>383641486
Be careful who you call nice in high school.
>>
>>383654351
Yukiko's Strange Journey
>>
>>383654287
.ru is Russia.

Should be fine. Just run Malwarebytes or something.
>>
File: 123457784776.png (23KB, 256x256px) Image search: [Google]
123457784776.png
23KB, 256x256px
>>383654281
Is this post a joke becuase honestly these polls mean everything in Japan and you are so wrong it hurts even if you think this. These polls pretty much tell them who should get more screentime in spinoffs and who should get merch, so I have no idea how you try to act like they don't count.
>>
File: 1499820953184.jpg (65KB, 322x308px) Image search: [Google]
1499820953184.jpg
65KB, 322x308px
>>383654540
What do you know about development?
>>
>>383654281
>Make a typo
>Blame the other guy
Why is everyone on /v/ so fucking retarded?
>>
File: Sad Fuuka.png (37KB, 400x330px) Image search: [Google]
Sad Fuuka.png
37KB, 400x330px
Don't fight
>>
>>383654626
>What do you know about development?
What the fuck did he mean by this?
>>
Chie is my girlfriend
Glad to see no one here loves her. She's off limits :^)
>>
>>383654702
BABY COME BACK
>>
>>383641486
burger reporting, i like yukiko
i also like rise
having trouble deciding, this is my first time playing p4
also leaving this thread before faggots attempt to spoil it for me
>>
>>383654540

only because those 1500 retards are the only ones buying any of this shit because it costs like 80 bucks for 2 episodes of anime. The market is fucked. Most people have their favorites but don't care because the game is enough.

>>383654651

Context.
>>
File: 1280px-Yucatan_peninsula_250m.jpg (492KB, 1280x1707px) Image search: [Google]
1280px-Yucatan_peninsula_250m.jpg
492KB, 1280x1707px
>>383654746
I was making fun of you using Yuka-tan as a image
>>
>>383654852
How do you like it?
>>
>>383654847
I'll fight you to the death for her
>>
>>383647229

That's probably the closest thing to a Nadeshiko, yes.

>ywn come home to your plantation house after a long day of whipping your nigger in the fields and receive sweet tea and sex from your qt Southern Belle waifu
>>
>>383654854
Your vote don't count for shit if you don't vote, so I have no idea where the fuck you are coming from. That is like saying Xperson would have won if their true fans votes, but really when it comes down to it they're not popular becuase if they were they would have at least got some votes.
>>
>>383655145
Why live
>>
File: 1491513126302.png (443KB, 552x700px) Image search: [Google]
1491513126302.png
443KB, 552x700px
>>383652450
i want to marry those socks!
>>
>>383654540
Yet they barely have any merch haha
>>
>>383655570
I know taht and it sucks a little because Aigis absorbed all of P3's merch for herself becuase her popularity just dwarfs all of the other P3 girls in comparison. It could be worst and you could like Fuuka and have literally nothing.
>>
File: j3btqonytjcy.jpg (72KB, 624x434px) Image search: [Google]
j3btqonytjcy.jpg
72KB, 624x434px
>>383647229
>>383655145
>>383655271
Is this a stealth Dixie thread?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D3IJ05QntXQ
>>
All these girls are super hot. Why not just harem 'em?
>>
>>383642594

fatten
>>
File: Fuuka Bed.jpg (132KB, 740x568px) Image search: [Google]
Fuuka Bed.jpg
132KB, 740x568px
>>383655752
Most of the merch is figures or keychains anyway, I would rather have a Fuuka plushie or Dakimakura to hug at night.
>>
File: 1499829333127.png (29KB, 428x274px) Image search: [Google]
1499829333127.png
29KB, 428x274px
>>383655965
Because Narukami is exclusively for Rise
>>
File: 1491520198476.jpg (93KB, 960x540px) Image search: [Google]
1491520198476.jpg
93KB, 960x540px
where are my marie bros at?
>>
>>383657137
There's literally two of you. You, and the writefag avatarfagging fucker who got banned.
>>
>>383656329
Rise is a whore. Yu deserves Chie.
>>
File: 1491521452203.png (830KB, 1115x1983px) Image search: [Google]
1491521452203.png
830KB, 1115x1983px
>>383657351
the who in the what?
>>
File: Elipses.png (178KB, 367x563px) Image search: [Google]
Elipses.png
178KB, 367x563px
>>383657351
You should really keep /pg/ in /pg/
>>
>>383657515
He's not just on /pg/, he's everywhere. He just has a deeper root there.
>>
>>383641486
>Implying i could hate the healer
>>
>>383643327
Don't forget how bullshit Rise's case is. She's supposed to hate her whole Rise personality, yet she easily jumps at the chance to do it during the pageant, and goes around trying to be the center of attention (especially with the MC) throughout the entire game. How does this work? When she first appeared to be this tired and quiet chick it made sense, but what happened after her dungeon? Her normal personality throughout the game is just Risette.
>>
>>383657137
Hi
>>
>>383646189
>Fapping
>With Morgana in the room constantly and urging him to sleep
Looking cool, Joker!
>>
>>383657731
It only makes sense in her SL where she talks about how she wants everyone to know every part of her, not just some of it. That was her issue.
>>
File: 1491512294906.jpg (136KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
1491512294906.jpg
136KB, 1280x720px
>>383657742
hello
>>
File: junpei.jpg (18KB, 580x326px) Image search: [Google]
junpei.jpg
18KB, 580x326px
>>383657883

The social links are a huge part of the problem. No one has any consistent character growth or stakes. Everything is cordoned off to the side and even there it's just reiterating the same non problems we don't care about with episodic bullshit. The cast exists only the orbit the MC and it's annoying how no one has any relationships outside of you.

P3 wasn't ideal either but characters like Junpei had plot threads that existed solely for them that weren't resolved faster than this sentence. He had a real relationship with a character we see and get to know.

Im not sure how accurate it is because Im to lazy to check but someone once posted that there's maybe one or two scenes in 4 that the MC isn't present for.
>>
>>383658228
>hey, I met this girl
>she draws shit
>wtf I love her so much
'''real relationship'''
>>
File: Persona_4_investigation_team_2.jpg (2MB, 3495x1741px) Image search: [Google]
Persona_4_investigation_team_2.jpg
2MB, 3495x1741px
>>383658228
3 had some great character, but something about the IT I can't come to hate. When it came to slice of life stuff, 4 had some comfy scenes where everyone's poking fun at each other, and they really came off as a group of friends. While 4 lacked in individual character growth, it made up for with the team dynamic.
Both are fantastic games, though
>>
>>383658228
I wouldn't blame social links at all. Persona 3 handled it really well by dedicating parts in the plot for each character's issue and then their resolution. Junpei had this almost inferiority complex in comparison to the MC, found a girl and the other BS. Yukari's isn't as detailed with her parents as her S.link but we hear enough about her situation in the main story, and we get the whole reveal stuff later. The issue is just how P4 handles it. In P3 and P5 we are shown a character's conflict before their dungeon starts. The only person we got that with in P3 was Rise. We're just info dumped about Naoto's trans BS, Kanji's faggotry, and everything else.
>>
>>383658228
I agree with everything you've written, by the way.
>>
>>383658531
You don't choose who you fall in love with.
>>
>>383658612
I can choose to ignore it and not entangle myself with an emo fuck, but the game needed its cheap drama, just like forgetting about the dark hour only to remember it right before the ends.
>>
>>383658531
Well it's not like we're shown how much of a smuck Junpei is. I mean, the guy made it a point to butt in and talk to people just to stay relevant. The whole thing about him feeling like he was finally someone important when he got his powers and then hating the MC because he overshadowed him was literally them beating you upside the head that this guy was on the low end of the high school popularity poll and just wanted to be "somebody" for once. It makes sense that he'd fall for a cute girl so easily. Their meanings were supposed to span for at least a month or two, so that helps.
>>
post cute yukis
>>
>>383658228
P3 has a few good ones manly Aigis, Aki, Yuakri and Junpei and they all has development outside of the MC being there or needing to say anything and it was very noticeable just going up and talking to the charcter or even in battle with some. Aigis's more intertwined with the MC unlike the others, but worked pretty well and her development was shown alot as her voice and lines became more and more human so well done that way.
>>
File: 1499713417143.jpg (288KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
1499713417143.jpg
288KB, 1280x720px
>>383658813
>>
File: 1491513520813.jpg (144KB, 472x750px) Image search: [Google]
1491513520813.jpg
144KB, 472x750px
>>383658813
why not post cute marie's instead?
>>
>>383658780
But we don't get to see shit. I would understand it if it was Junpei being a retard and going mai eaifu for laifu because that's Junpei for you, but nope, they're suddenly so in love with each other that it's gross. And it all happens off screen.
>>
>>383654306
kissanime normally has a download option.
that or just get a chrome extension.
>>
>>383641486
But I love Yukiko. She is best girl.
>>
File: nzk2k5fON1rmed8jo1_1280.jpg (115KB, 850x687px) Image search: [Google]
nzk2k5fON1rmed8jo1_1280.jpg
115KB, 850x687px
>>
File: 1478056775856.png (1MB, 1320x841px) Image search: [Google]
1478056775856.png
1MB, 1320x841px
>>383658813
>>
>>383658531

Look I agree it's not perfect or even especially GOOD but it's at least something. How often do we even see a 4 character interact solely with someone who's not you. We're supposed to see Yukiko and Chie as BFFs but they don't act that way. Hell the most we get out of anyone is them either collectively agreeing or Yosuke being retarded to Kanji
>>
File: 1457736298682.png (82KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
1457736298682.png
82KB, 1920x1080px
>>383658813
>>
>>383659313
The entire thing spans for around a month or two. Maybe you don't have much real life interactions but it's normal for people to start dating within two months of meeting eachother. They weren't dating but both of them were fucking weirdos and goth girl probably didn't have much friends outside of Strega, so it makes sense they got hit with petty puppy love just by having someone show more interest in them than usual. That's the whole meaning of puppy love for humans. Someone who's never been in love before or been in a relationship getting easily attached to someone showing interest in them.
>>
File: 2O1D1v6bs4y.gif (962KB, 250x265px) Image search: [Google]
2O1D1v6bs4y.gif
962KB, 250x265px
where's my naotofags
>>
>>383647428
For what? There are no more games with the IT and the Golden anime is never being dubbed
>>
File: 1499199339520.jpg (144KB, 350x780px) Image search: [Google]
1499199339520.jpg
144KB, 350x780px
>>383659594
right here, my dude. Made sure Yu lovingly pounded that sweet reverse trap in my most recent playthrough
>>
>>383659578
This. The entire P4's cast act like their lives revolve around the MC and his decisions. You don't see them shooting the shit with eachother when the MC isn't around or acting like they've hung out without you like they do in P3/P5. There's this sense that everything in the game that isn't around the MC freezes until he arrives there. The only time they fixed this was during Marie's S.link in P4G, where you meet other chars hanging out together.
>>
>>383652930
But nyaa is back up, anon.
>>
File: 1496624797198.gif (3MB, 557x310px) Image search: [Google]
1496624797198.gif
3MB, 557x310px
>>383659719
I love naoto too much to let a blank slate like yu have her. I get that waifu life simulators is to insert yourself into the MC but I just can't do it.

Albeit funny enough I closely resemble P5 in looks and messy black hair so Akira is the exception of getting matched with haru
>>
>>383659693
>No more games with the IT
>What is spin offs
>>
>>383659594
>>
File: ...lame.jpg (44KB, 500x434px) Image search: [Google]
...lame.jpg
44KB, 500x434px
>>383642725
>tfw no Larry altar of my own
>>
>>383641486
>ywn feel Yukiko's titties
why live
>>
>>383659578
They're both pretty bad imo. I couldn't take their love seriously at all.

>>383659586
>they're weirdos so it's okay
It didn't feel real at all. They're both willing to die for each other after two months, and to make things worse we didn't get to see what happened during those months.
It's as bad as Mitsuru coming with a new overpowered evoker when the plot needs it and excusing it 'well, she's damn rich and the first evoker had to cone from somewhere! I mean it's been x months since she's fighting dem shadows'
>>
File: bunny.png (203KB, 460x640px) Image search: [Google]
bunny.png
203KB, 460x640px
>>383659753

And it's not that I don't understand that as a game the MC needs to have a certain amount of heightened importance but the P4 casts has literally nothing.

Okay example. Devil Survivor 2. The MC here is effectively essential to solving his parties problems but typically he stumbles into them the implication is that events are happening with him not present. He stumbles into an argument between Airi and Hinako, finds Daichi or Io lost in thought somewhere and offers advice that either helps to see things differently or (and refreshingly) pisses them the hell off.

One of the cooler aspects of the game is that at one point all the characters reach an irreconcilable impasse and it leads to them actually going to war with each other. You can eventually turn them to your team by maxing their fates and power of friendship and blah blah but that's more a reward for actually being a good friend and winning them over via effort convincing them and you cannot avoid the fight and if you don't max them out they're gone. Persona wouldn't do that. You can ignore a social link entirely and they're still gonna be on your knob
>>
File: dah6hgw.jpg (137KB, 894x894px) Image search: [Google]
dah6hgw.jpg
137KB, 894x894px
>>383660086
Make one, it took me forever to find all of Aigis's Merch and make an Aigis shrine. I am still looking for this new kit of Orgea mode Aigis I can't fine too. The daki is still the best thing I own.
>>
>>383660205
But that's exactly why it makes sense. Chidori clearly has problems, so her getting attached to the first boy who shows real interest in her easily makes sense that this lonely chick went that far. Junpei's may be a little out there, but the whole thing about him feeling like the main character and wanting to be that kind of hero just adds onto this. It's only really weird for Junpei's case, not Chidori's.
>>
File: Yukari_Takeba_render.png (503KB, 711x1759px) Image search: [Google]
Yukari_Takeba_render.png
503KB, 711x1759px
>>383660205

well, again. Im not really making an argument of quality so much as I am effort being made to differentiate individual character as members of the cast.

It's not just Junpei. For instance Yukari is a turbo bitch because she's hurt over losing her dad and is driven to explore the mystery surrounding his demise. Is her story good? Not especially but it's something unique. It's not like Yosuke who forgets about Saki the next dungeon her baggage lasts A LONG TIME.

Characters don't need to be complex but they need to be, well, characters. P4 characters have one or two traits they repeat every conversation and exist only to remind you they're there. It's not Hyperbole to say that if you remove any one of them the changes it would make to the narrative are minimal.
>>
>>383660436
>they just happen to met
>and be the kind of broken people that will fall deeply in love
>you will miss all of this and have xero attachment to this whole thing
>oh, and the love interest happens to be one of the bad guys
>here have some life & death drama
It's super dumb.
>>
>>383660327
>Persona wouldn't do that. You can ignore a social link entirely and they're still gonna be on your knob

This is why people who don't love Rise as their number one P4 girl hate her instead. You have to deal with her constantly flirting with you after you've already chosen another girl, and it gets annoying fast. It feels even more awkward when she does it right in front of someone you're dating and they don't even react to it. They could have easily added a random response from the person you're dating to make it more bearable. For example, Let's say you're dating Naoto and Rise comes on strong like she usually does; all they have to do is give naoto a "..." line with her grumbling or something as a sound effect and it would at least feel these things actually existed.
>>
>>383660629
I understand, but it's some of them are so badly paced due to the calendar system being shit that it either takes ages for something to happen, or that if you blink you will end up missing it.
DeSu2 has more developed characters despite most of them being p4 tier.
>>
>>383660782
Yeah I went with Rise and I thought the game was adapting to that by having her flirt with me so much but I guess it just does it regardless of what you do.

One of the big disappointments of P5 is that it didn't fix this problem of the main game not recognizing the progress in your social links outside of those social links.
>>
>>383660629
>It's not just Junpei. For instance Yukari is a turbo bitch because she's hurt over losing her dad and is driven to explore the mystery surrounding his demise. Is her story good? Not especially but it's something unique.

I think this is the biggest thing P4 fans who want to shit on other persona games or pretend that the lack of unique things and character development isn't a problem. Take Yukari for example, she has issues and acts like she does. P4fags only see girls as potentional waifus that need to do the generic trope shit to be cute. If they act like a bitch for even a second or have some flaw that prevents them from being 100% perfect, they're automatically deemed to be shit regardless of reasons. This is why Yukari is outlawed by them. This why Marie is considered shit simply because oftalkinglikethis. This is why even Nozomi is considered ass by any Persona playing trying out SMTIVA for the first time because of that one instance where she justifiably spoke out about the Dagda situation. To them, waifus must be willing to noose up before acting against them in even the most minor ways.
>>
>>383661071
>One of the big disappointments of P5 is that it didn't fix this problem of the main game not recognizing the progress in your social links outside of those social links.

I'm still in the middle of finishing P5 myself, but that was kind of expected. It's a shame Atlus won't just add a single extra like for girl's you're dating in necessary scenes or stuff like that.
>>
>>383661076
>This why Marie is considered shit simply because oftalkinglikethis
Marie is considered shit for more reasons than just that
>>
>>383661219
There's a scene before the last month where you're studying for exams and they bring up the topic of marriage.
If you say you're interested in marriage and you're dating a party member they react positively.
>>
>Fuuka is best girl in P3
>Yukiko is best girl in P4
>Makoto is best girl in P5

So can just assume that the Priestess Arcana is just best overall in the series.
>>
>>383661226
>Marie is considered shit for more reasons than just that

There are legit reasons why Marie isn't that good but many of them were just faggots nitpicking from day one. I mean, people hated her before the game was even release because they didn't like her outfit. There were memes about hot topic going around, but look at how much people loved Tae's style in P5. It just goes to show how critical P4fags are over their waifus.
>>
>>383661372
My P5 waifu also made me retroactively like the previous girls of her arcana more than I originally did.
>>
>>383661372
But if I assume that people will think I'm even more autistic
>>
>>383661372
>Fuuka
I give you that.
>Yukiko
Rise is my number 1 but Larry is a real close second.
>Makoto
Beep Boop
>>
>>383661372
>The 3 most boring girls in the game
I won't judge if you like them plain anon.
>>
File: Click to make Fuuka smile.jpg (70KB, 580x544px) Image search: [Google]
Click to make Fuuka smile.jpg
70KB, 580x544px
>>383661372
There is no such thing as "best girl" anon.
Just girls you like more than others.

Why don't you talk about what you like about Fuuka and the others?
>>
>>383642725
holy fuck
>>
>>383661564
So you don't think Fuuka is best girl? It's like you don't really love her then.
>>
>>383661538
>character so good she is in smt now
I do admit the others are pretty damn plain tho
>>
File: 40515865.jpg (103KB, 955x1395px) Image search: [Google]
40515865.jpg
103KB, 955x1395px
I love Aigis, that is all.
>>
File: Staring Fuuka.jpg (214KB, 999x1383px) Image search: [Google]
Staring Fuuka.jpg
214KB, 999x1383px
>>383661603
Your mind games won't work on me anon.
Fuuka's my love, but she's not "best girl" because there's no such thing
>>
>>383644402
who's the creeper and who's the dork?
>>
File: makoto 242.jpg (244KB, 707x1000px) Image search: [Google]
makoto 242.jpg
244KB, 707x1000px
>>383660920
>I understand, but it's some of them are so badly paced due to the calendar system being shit that it either takes ages for something to happen, or that if you blink you will end up missing it.

To which I wholly agree. In every game you're basically waiting for a specific day to hit so the game can plot dump on you before another 20 days of grinding stats and links. A normal RPG doesn't stray from dumps either but because the game moves at your pace it can sprinkle things along better through it's pacing even if it is just town, dungeon, town, dungeon.

>DeSu2 has more developed characters despite most of them being p4 tier.

Well that's what happens when you take the time to actually develop them. You learn their way of thinking how they react to things what their goals are and what they do. Not to mention when you write your game with the group in mind over the MC you get stronger scenarios or at least ones that actually feel more genuine.

I think Persona 5 was a few steps forward in this regard despite still having a lot of the same hangups. Makoto is hardly an especially complex character but we do see her interact with Sae. We do see her family issues play more into the plot to create flaws that lead to actual problems. Plus the game actually takes time to step away from the heroes perspective to show you what the antagonists are doing to remind you there's bigger shit happening if even the characters aren't complicated.
>>
>>383661941
bee boo
>>
>>383661708
What's wrong with thinking your waifu is the best girl?
>>
>>383661986
Oh you can think that, but saying that in these threads is pretty pointless, why not discuss what you like about the characters instead?
>>
>>383649737
Cutscene Yukari is a gift
>>
>>383661226

The thing about Marie is that everything she does that's bad everyone else kind of does worse.

I mean the big thing is she's tsundere but the worst she does is say some halfhearted embarrassed insults when you look through her personal shit. Mean while what do Chie and Yukiko do? Push you off a mountain because of a retarded COMPLIMENT Yosuke gives them and it's all LOL LOL SO FUNNY!

Ill agree Marie has a lot of problems as a character mechanically but at the same time as a character she actually has problems that constitute a story (Amnesia leading a sense of abandonment and a search for identity) and frankly put having her around makes the actual end boss feel a bit less out of the blue.

But holy fuck is the end boss just completely out of nowhere. I mean Jesus Fuck even the identity of the killer feels less like a properly foreshadowed twist and more like they forgot to write an actual villain and ran out of named characters
>>
Nanako coming back to life magically was the worst cop out I have seen and everything after that felt like nothing becuase I can just magically fucking bring someone back from the dead, so how should anything beyond that impressive me?
It felt like they were going going for a more helpless dark turn with the fog and everyone freaking out about it and magically like that all tone and everything was gone. I don't mind it staying lighthearted, but don't try to go one way and half ass it.
>>
>>383662440
Marie is perfect hate fuck material, that's about all she's good for.
>>
>>383662440
>I mean the big thing is she's tsundere but the worst she does is say some halfhearted embarrassed insults when you look through her personal shit. Mean while what do Chie and Yukiko do? Push you off a mountain because of a retarded COMPLIMENT Yosuke gives them and it's all LOL LOL SO FUNNY!

You're trying to use logic with the waifufag breed of Persona. You can't make nonsensical conversations with them that would compare their waifu or shine them in a lower light. If anything, P4fags are the whole reason why the SMT vs Persona community thing kind of exists. Most arguments from the SMT side have always been about the P4 mentality of not caring about character development so long as they have good waifus, and most of the Persona side of arguments come from P4fags. I mean, when was the last time you saw people comparing P1-3 with SMT or using it for arguments? P5 has been out for a while and I haven't seen a single person from the fanbases try to argue about it, except for point out flaws people generically agree on.

Well, the point I'm trying to make is that these people are cancerous and you can't really converse with them when in comes to waifus. Just look at >>383662767 for example... this is all you'll get.
>>
>>383662683
It touched me because I got emotional when Yukiko was so happy.
Lame, I know.
>>
>>383662683
Everyone remembering about the dark hour magically was the worst cop out I have seen
It felt like they were going going for a more helpless dark turn with them forgetting about MC but magically like that all tone and everything was gone. I don't mind it staying lighthearted, but don't try to go one way and half ass it.
>>
>>383662767
>Marie is perfect hate fuck material
Why do I keep seeing this meme?
>>
>>383662440
>But holy fuck is the end boss just completely out of nowhere. I mean Jesus Fuck even the identity of the killer feels less like a properly foreshadowed twist and more like they forgot to write an actual villain and ran out of named characters

Because it was out of the blue. Persona 4 had this giant boner for red herrings and plot twists, which is why we get it, what...4 fucking times if we can't Sagiri? Izanami's position in the whole thing doesn't even make sense. Why give her protag the power if she clearly intended to fuck the world with shadows regardless? The story makes more sense without her.
>>
>>383662967
>Everyone remembering about the dark hour magically was the worst cop out I have seen
That's got nothing a person literally fucking magically coming back to life. I don't see how can even compare these two things.
Is this a joke?
>>
>>383662967
>I don't mind it staying lighthearted
>P3
>lighthearted
I know your made and your tried to copy paste his post, but holy fuck
>>
>>383662967
>magically like that all tone and everything was gone
But it wasn't and fit the tone though?
>>
File: Okamura_s.png (125KB, 350x344px) Image search: [Google]
Okamura_s.png
125KB, 350x344px
>>383662683

Yeah P4 had a distinct lack of balls. Killing Nanako may be a bit extreme but the characters generally face very little hardship. There's never a sense of failure or loss. They magic and rainbow their way through the whole game. There's one guy they fail to save and it's a literal who nobody cares about in a dungeon that's bluntly, pure filler.

Plus it makes the villain seem generally nonthreatening. Only two people get killed? P5 doesn't have a HUGE body count either but at least one of the people who does die has a strong connection to the party. And even the death aside it's a sign that the villains out played them and you where put on the defensive immediately after you where starting to feel super badass. P3 is a constant loss train.

The sad part is it's actually really easy to fix this in Persona 4. Instead of just having one teenager kidnapped at a time you fill the town with actual faced NPC who get kidnapped along side your party as the game goes on. Your party is of course limited so you have to focus on you focus on saving the people you personally care about but now every party member has to live with the fact that every time one of them are saved it means someone else wasn't. And as more and more NPCs vanish and die the whole mood of the city gets darker and grayer as the survivors become increasingly distrustful of each other.
>>
>>383663060
>why kill x only to bring it back
>why forget x only to remember it 5 minutes later
Both sucked ass and are only there for cheap drama.
>>
>>383663294
>5 minutes

They passed MONTHS without their memories
>>
>>383663358
And it changed ducking nothing. I mean sure, the dark hour is one and with it their memories,about the whole thing but why suddenly remember everything just right before the ending for no fucking reason? I mean they had MONTHS to remember shit.
>>
>>383663294
What cheap drama?
The MC literally fucking died and they didn't even make it there to see him anyhow. It makes sense that your strong memories of fucking death made them remember, like Mitsuru only remember when she thought about how her father died Why are you talking out your ass so hard?
This nothing like bringing someone back to life after they die with no explanation how this happened.
>>
>>383647428
If Fire Emblem has taught me anything, Laura Bailey has already been replaced with a sound-a-like. The original Lucina in Heroes is still voice by Bailey (uncredited), but every new Lucina release is now voiced by Alexis Tipton.

She'll likely be your new Rise going forward.
>>
Why doesn't Persona have cutscenes like this anymore?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SE1wXchmE50
>>
>>383654489
>>383654287
If you have ublock and kissanime essentials, it'll be fine. They just keep moving their domain because they keep getting in trouble. They're currently the most popular illegal streaming site in the US.
>>
File: 1497282515300.jpg (8KB, 192x191px) Image search: [Google]
1497282515300.jpg
8KB, 192x191px
>>383663549
>ducking
>>
>>383663743
Not an argument.
>>
File: 1497767139419.png (27KB, 735x541px) Image search: [Google]
1497767139419.png
27KB, 735x541px
>>383663815
>>
>>383663549
Ya they only remember after they thought about how some of there close loved ones died. Doesn't a fucking jeuis to figure out why the strong emotion of their loved dying let them remember how they fucking died and
>ducking
Please leave and never ever fucking come back to 4chan.
>>
File: new-kid.jpg (339KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
new-kid.jpg
339KB, 1920x1080px
>you join the good guys halfway into the game
>they dont mind how you decimated their forces in the beginning
>>
File: JOKER sudou.jpg (18KB, 273x444px) Image search: [Google]
JOKER sudou.jpg
18KB, 273x444px
>>383663643

You know what I want to see again? Actual real world terror. None of this dark hour, TV world, or mementos crap. I want to see actual monsters, demons, badguys and shit roaming the streets spreading fear and panic in their wake. I want to see the heroes taking completely out of their comfort zone and forced to fight for their damn lives. No going to the beach. The beach is on fucking fire.
>>
>>383663291
If Nanako dies then Dojima would go down in history as the most reviled character in the series.

And don't talk about balls, both P5 and P4's bad endings are pretty rough. Nocturne just gives you free passage to heaven.
>>
>>383663915
And that just had to happen right as MC dies. If that's no chap drama then nothing is.
>>
>>383664034
>Hasn't gotten to the last palace yet
>>
>>383664034
Not everything has to be dark and edgy to be enjoyable, Anon
>>
>>383664034
Otaku culture is one big hugbox right now. Do you really expect them to accept their world has mean things?
>>
>>383663643
>fmv cg
Never again.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VIBbdYTnN8U
>>
>>383664049
>P5 and P4's bad endings
>Mattering ever
Is this some kind of joke?
>>
>>383664221
are you some kind of joke?
>>
File: 1452549271078.png (160KB, 568x1023px) Image search: [Google]
1452549271078.png
160KB, 568x1023px
>>383664245
Is this you right now?
>>
>>383664352
I wasnt the guy you replied to, retard
>>
File: Maya_attack.png (167KB, 368x576px) Image search: [Google]
Maya_attack.png
167KB, 368x576px
>>383664049
>both P5 and P4's bad endings are pretty rough
>bad endings

see that's optimum word isn't. In the BAD ENDING of course shit is rough. It's the Bad Ending. If the only time you have balls is the bad ending then you're basically just pretending to be tough.

You know what happens in Persona 2's NORMAL ending? Maya gets stabbed in the tits and bleeds to death, the world fucking blows up and the only way to fix any of this shit is to rewind time and for you to sacrifice your memories and friendships and NEVER EVER even look at your old pals again. Even in EP which builds off of that Tatsuya is forced to go back to his side and never be allowed to be near them.
>>
File: shinji.jpg (82KB, 464x536px) Image search: [Google]
shinji.jpg
82KB, 464x536px
In Persona 3's GOOD ending Shinjiro dies no matter what and stays dead, Mitsuru's dad dies no matter what and stays dead and YOU die no matter what and you're staying dead.

>>383664134

Bitch this isn't about being grimdark. Stories have a flow. They need highs and lows. Failure makes you appreciate triumph and triumph makes failure sting all the more. You have to run the whole gambit of emotions not steam roll everything with a rainbow bulldozer
>>
>>383664383
That's not rough at all, it's too out-there. The world exploding, yeah, what a thrill.

P4 and P5 are much more grounded for such a strange game - One has you shot in the fucking face while in custody and the other ends with your ragtag group of mystery solvers straight up murdering an innocent person, which clearly haunts everyone to the point where they can't stand to look at each other anymore.

>>383664571
>Hasn't played Portable
>>
>>383664642

You mean the game that's not cannon
>>
>>383664708
P3's canon isn't respected at all since every other game brings back the MC, so that's not really a valid argument. The team didn't shoot themselves in the foot again at least, Akechi "dies" offscreen so his return in Dance Dance Revolution doesn't seen that jarring.
>>
>>383664642
Why the fuck are you even talking about bad end?
They never fucking happened. It is like saying "Well it could have been dark if the MC did X thing instead and X thing happened instead" This mean literally nothing, but saying these things.
>>
>>383664973
>P3's canon isn't respected at all since every other game brings back the MC, so that's not really a valid argument.
Literally all of PQ
>>
>>383665291
>P3's canon isn't respected at all since every other game brings back the MC, so that's not really a valid argument.
>other game brings back the MC,
>brings back the MC
>brings back
He didn't get brought back back becuase he still is fucking dead.
>>
>>383665401
I think you responded to the wrong person
>>
>>383665290
Someone never played Space Quest. Bad ends are arguably superior to good ends.
>>
>>383664973
Even Arena maintains Door-kun's door status.
Only PQ brings him back.
>>
File: 2940877-marie_alt+(4).jpg (190KB, 960x544px) Image search: [Google]
2940877-marie_alt+(4).jpg
190KB, 960x544px
>>383665734
Because the MC in 3 is shit and is easily replaceable by Yu
>>
>>383658942
This image got cuter the more I looked at it.
>>
>>383665867

I really cannot stand Yu. He's just so frustratingly...bland.
>>
P3 was so fucking tryhard edgy at every single point that the whole thing end sup being ridiculous. The very few dark moments in P4 and P5 worked so much better because the game spends most of its time lulling you into a false sense of security.
>>
>>383665867
>A blank slate being better than a blank slate
>>
File: joker grin.jpg (40KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
joker grin.jpg
40KB, 1280x720px
>>383666207

I mean at least guys like Joker and Bunny give you the chance to a glib motherfucker. Hell Joker is even pretty expressive when he's being Joker
>>
>>383666207
Minato is a worthless piece of shit who breaks social links left and right, had to be saved as a baby and dies like a fucking bitch. Comparing him to a magnificent motherfucker like Joker is an affront to YHVH
>>
>>383666515
This post is so factually wrong it hurts
>>
>>383666515
Respond to me again when you actually play P3
>>
>>383662370
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TeT1WwPR0U
>>
File: 1435995185485.gif (2MB, 459x512px) Image search: [Google]
1435995185485.gif
2MB, 459x512px
>>383642594
I want to be hypnotized by Yukiko
>>
>>383666574

Well you really shut the door on his argument
>>
>>383641486
The stupid laughing shit
>>
>>383667556
Nah, I just don't respond to people with no argument. I beat P3 long before the P4fags came in and pretended to be oldfags.
>>
>>383666515
ow the edge
>>
File: MayaEPSurprised.png (17KB, 119x151px) Image search: [Google]
MayaEPSurprised.png
17KB, 119x151px
>>383667653

You're not really HIP to the whole IRONY thing are you.
>>
>>383641486
worst girl
worst persona
>>
>>383643327
>complaining about animu scooby-doo vidya characters
>"hurr durr why they have normal teen problems"
Seriously, I'm sucker for heavy plots with difficult problems for characters, but even I am not this autistic to complain about it.
>>
>>383667653
>breaks social links left and right
That's only if your autistic and can't manage your schedule correctly

>had to be saved as a baby
This doesn't happen at all. He survives a car crash that his parents didn't and soon after gets the avatar of death put inside him. He was seven when this happened. I have no fucking clue where you got baby or him being saved from

>dies like a fucking bitch
He gives his soul up to act as a barrier to prevent Nyx from destroying the world because unlike Yabadabadoo Nyx wasn't a pussy punk bitch and he didn't have Japan backing him up either

You made it very clear you either didn't pay attention or play the game at all
>>
>>383667170
yes please right on my face
>>
>>383668207

Just autistic enough to miss the point entirely
>>
>>383641486
Lisa best girl
>>
File: eriko.jpg (445KB, 550x550px) Image search: [Google]
eriko.jpg
445KB, 550x550px
>>383670453

I prefer eriko. She's just insane enough to work.
>>
I think Yukiko was my favorite just because she's the most generic girl of the 4, at least look wise. I mean dark long hair, how can you be even more generic physically? But honestly that's exactly what I like so there.

(I went with the teacher in P5 though although I REALLY liked Hifumi)
>>
File: 24cc329a82f06bb7dd9eee8b4cc7c11b.jpg (142KB, 534x1252px) Image search: [Google]
24cc329a82f06bb7dd9eee8b4cc7c11b.jpg
142KB, 534x1252px
>>383641486
How could I possibly dislike my wife?
>>
>>383672395

Well she's so devoid of personality you could slowly come to resent all those years wasted on her but are too deep in it now to cut it off you just bitterly count the days until one of you dies
>>
>>383672395
Where did you get that pic of our wedding?
You guys are creeps
>>
>>383672760

I am literally a wedding photographer
>>
>>383652303
Nyaa is fine:

https://nyaa.si/
>>
>>383672916
Okay cool
But don't go saying things about my wife, dude
>>
File: 1461509457756.jpg (32KB, 343x314px) Image search: [Google]
1461509457756.jpg
32KB, 343x314px
>>
>>383672395
Plenty of men dislike their wives after some time passes.
>>
>>383649115
I really do wish more women would wear black pantyhose instead of short shorts or bare yoga pants. When done right, it's elegantly beautiful and sexy put together.
Thread posts: 385
Thread images: 109


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.