What's the final /tv/ verdict on this show?

>>87323197
Phenomenal up until the last few minutes of episode 17, then full hack job at the end.

Shit. If Lynch wanted to make something new he should have done an original movie

>>87323197
episode 8 is the only good thing that came out of it

>>87323197
LYNCHED/10

point being, regardless of how good it was or wasn't, /tv/ has memed it too hard that a real discussion can't be had

kino as expected

Never seen better

File: 1502733865286.jpg (382KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

382KB, 1920x1080px

>>87323197
Lynchkino

Chads BTFO

>>87323283
>>87323314
>>87323346
Hahahaha
LYNCHED

Garbage. Lynch is a liar. Frost is too stupid to understand it. Julee Cruice is a slut.

pure Kino and the sole dramatic masterpiece of television history. surpassing the wire, the leftovers, the sopranos by lightyears

File: 1504400632774.jpg (65KB, 1268x646px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 1268x646px

>>87323197

It's something I'll be thinking about and revisiting for years. I loved every minute of it and feel so blessed to have been alive to experience it.

>>87323197
thats a ten

eh, Game of Thrones was more entertaining

>>87323464
this, but unironically

Man I would cum if Lynch started a new series

>>87323197
The most important television event of our century.

File: aranking.jpg (333KB, 761x811px) Image search: [Google]

333KB, 761x811px

better than the original seasons

>>87323197
Invigorating. Comfy.

File: 1504562497137.gif (827KB, 518x292px) Image search: [Google]

827KB, 518x292px

>>87323197
10/10 Watch it.
>>87323283
Ignore this. It's the Faggdit opinion.

What's with the split opinions? It's either love or hate.

>>87323197
I can't decide if i liked the finale or not. It's left me with such a weird feeling. I think i need some time to process it all.

File: Judys.jpg (3MB, 3000x1688px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 3000x1688px

best tv in years

>>87323539
>ep12
cmon anon, you don't have to lie to us

File: 1504549057682.jpg (330KB, 761x811px) Image search: [Google]

330KB, 761x811px

>>87323539

Great

7/10 on it's own.
Possibly elevated to 9/10 if we get another season.
8/10 if the continuation occurs in Frost's upcoming Twin Peaks book.

Honestly incredible. Exceeding my expectations ten fold. Unlike anything ever before on television. A unique vision told at the auteurs' pace.

>>87323629
>explanations make kino better
pleb

>>87323645
Genuinely curious. What is it about the show that exceeded your expectations?

>>87323197
Waste of time. Only intellectually insecure hipsters defend it. Just check out /tpg/. Reddit spacing everywhere and people patting themselves on the back for coming up with dumb theories that will never be proven right because Lynch just throws shit at the wall and pretends the bits of corn are metaphors.

TP will go down as one of the greatest series of all time. The Return has redeemed any misgivings over Season 2 and Fire Walk With Me.

so good. it was everything, more lynch, more nonsense, had most of the original cast, enough nostalgia but also so much more new. i know most people i know wont like it as much as i did, but I absolutely loved it. so happy and grateful he came back and gave fans something more

>>87323681
Not that anon but I was expecting it to be a rehash of the old seasons and was surprised how different and fresh it felt.

File: reddit.png (10KB, 882x113px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 882x113px

>>87323688
Reddit hates this season. They have since the start.

>>87323681
never knew what would happen next

>>87323688
Lynch isn't about metaphors at all. He even said that if he wants to show something he shows it up front. You're looking way too far into it.

>>87323197

The best season of any tv show ever made.

waste of time and ruined Lynch's legacy because it showed how much of a hack he is.

10/10

Only thing that could have made it better is if Bowie had appeared, but talking tea kettle was p kino`

It was a truly great sequel

File: The Phenomenon of Floating.jpg (712KB, 2048x1543px) Image search: [Google]

712KB, 2048x1543px

It's good to be one of those who honestly loved The Return and especially the ending.

>>87323411
>haha I know its bad but I'm going to keep saying "Lynched" to pretend he was just pretending to be retarded to mess with the audience the whole time

File: 1481063717143.jpg (35KB, 500x376px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 500x376px

The best piece of television since the original series. Where did it all go so wrong, bros?

>>87323197
if it was made without the thought of continuing to a next season, then it's kino

it was fucking SHIT

>>87323765
>look at my cherrypicked image
Now feel free to try and deny the reddit spacing in every other post in /tpg/. You can't.
>>87323802
Somebody better tell his fans.

File: dougie joe.jpg (73KB, 643x679px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 643x679px

>>87323825
this. bowie dying was the only thing that really sucked. and maybe harry not returning but I ended up liking frank in the end so whatever.

It's a miracle this got made. Greatly surpassed my expectations. The great Part 18 worldwide LYNCHING will be discussed for decades.

Lynch the biggest hack in history of cinema

File: ps.jpg (40KB, 600x485px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 600x485px

>>87323920
>reddit spacing

>>87323920

Wait a second. Hold the phone. Please just slow down. You're saying that the most important thing about art is how other dummies talk about it? Man oh man. That's a fascinating opinion that's going to keep me thinking for a while.

Don't mention the plot with all its loose ends and wanky dream/alternate reality nonsense, and you'll be alright. It's full with daringly brilliant moments of visual storytelling, and the dougie/catatonic coop arc could be a movie unto itself (and is probably the greatest character ever to grace our screens). Giving lynch full creative control was probably not the best idea since the finale makes me wonder if he's going senile, but who gives a shit? I don't go to lynch for narrative coherence, but I loved the fact that it felt like watching a magritte painting in motion.

>>87323562
Because there's two very decisive audiences watching this.

The first group are Lynch lovers who expected the unexpected and surely were rewarded with the final 10 minutes of the show.

The second group are the new watchers, who binge watched the original show and possibly skipped the movie because it's not on Netflix and are getting things explained to them by people on Reddit or in these general threads. They expected a happy ending with all loose ends explained because they've never watched Lynch in their life.

Frankly, I've come to just pass over any "it's shit" comments because they're from people who have no idea what they're talking about.

>>87323962
ding ding ding

>>87323197
Unironically one of the best things to ever been shown on any screen

I stopped watching after episode 7. Not because i thought it was terrible, but i guess i just lost interest. Is it worth finishing? Did the season finish?

>>87323594
same, I really enjoyed everything leading up to it but I have no idea (yet) what to think of the finale

>>87323197
it was excellent television through and through, I got what I wanted: being taken for a fucking ride

>>87323920

>he

>unironically

>fell

>for

>the

>Reddit

>spacing

>meme

>and

>uses

>it

>as

>an

>argument

>>87323348
just like the case with every other show/movie

>>87323976
Couldn't manage to format your post properly even though the site does it for you, eh?

>>87323999
at least watch ep 8, you quit at the worst possible point

>>87323999
Based on the responses here it seems like it.

>>87323645
author*

>>87323680
When I sit down to read The Divine Comedy, or the Aeneid I don't stop reading half way and call it a day. I'm done when the writer ends the epic. Twin Peaks in an unfinished book, hence my irresolute apprehension.

>>87324039
>thinking this is an argument because you come to an anonymous website for validation

>>87323989
hellooooOOOooo

>>87324058

Are you seriously proud that you spend so much time on this website?

>>87324110
>>Twin Peaks in an unfinished book
hah

>>87323981
This. Anyone expecting a normal ending from project written and directed entirely by Lynch was bound to be disappointed.

>>87324165
Couldn't manage to format your post properly even though the site does it for you, eh?

>>87324110
>Twin Peaks in an unfinished book
Wrong, you simply got LYNCHED by its end.

File: Numbuh 1.jpg (41KB, 768x532px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 768x532px

>>87323464
>blocks your path

>>87324110
That's like saying kafka is a fraud for having weird endings. Not every book/tv show needs to follow traditional storytelling.

>>87323197
Unsatisfying. I like the ending but the Audrey stuff was left too much to the imagination imho. Still the show is really sloppy in editing, effects, production designs to be considered a masterpiece. 7/10

I loved it all. Can't wait until next Sunday!!

>>87323197

Awful, incomprehensible gibberish that anyone can claim to understand so it'll be popular with fake patricians.

In other words; reddit.

File: 1467737863831.gif (722KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

722KB, 500x281px

/10

>>87324267

How on earth is it sloppy in editing?

I don't think there is a final verdict yet. People are still trying to figure out what happened and how they feel about it. Could take years, who's to say?

All I know is that when it was the episode ended I had a tremendous feeling of tranquility and well-being as if a great weight had been lifted from my shoulders and my mind was at once clear and alert. I smiled and although I had no idea what I just watched, I knew in my heart that everything was going to work out in the end.

File: 1480370063012.jpg (980KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

980KB, 1920x1080px

It was good until we didn't get any more Dougie.

Can we all appreciate that TV has reached a new level? Fuck movies

Postmodernism and surrealism are for "artists" who aren't able to produce satisfactory conventional art. Then low brows gobble it up simply because it claims to be high art and that makes them feel exclusive.

>>87323645
That's one pretentious opinion if I ever heard one.

10/10
literal perfection

Best thing made on the Video Toaster evar
11/10 Video Toasting

>>87324476
Non-surreal art can barely be considered art.

>>87324417
Dunno, I felt nothing but sadness and a bit terrified. I feel like cooper will go on forever being a pawn in a bigger game never being able to fix anything or go home.

File: 1.jpg (76KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 1280x720px

>>87324467

I thought you got some Dougie at the end

and naomi watts' complete lack of butt.

File: tpr.jpg (21KB, 330x281px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 330x281px

>>87324476

Something really special. 100/10

Filmmaker Quentin Tarantino, who was also in attendance, said in a 2017 interview, "After I saw Twin Peaks The Return episode 18 on TV, David Lynch had disappeared so far up his own ass that I have no desire to see another David Lynch creation until I hear something different. And you know, I loved him. I loved him."[21]

>>87324476
>art should aim to the lowest common denominator and not attempt experimentation.

I bet you think assembly line Marvel movies are art.

>>87324594
Isn't that what he said about FWWM as well?

>>87324476
Lynch has done satisfactory conventional art though and done it well. Even the normal stuff in this season was done really well. Both the drama and comedy.

>>87324560
Fuck off, Duchamp. I'm not buying your slippery slope of snake oil.

>>87324594
wtf I _______ Tarantino now!?

>>87324626
It's the quote about FWWM. He just edited it to be about the finale.

File: image-original.jpg (264KB, 736x875px) Image search: [Google]

264KB, 736x875px

Its enjoyable but nothing to write home about. Its obvious Lynch was using it as kind of a smorgasbord to puke out a bunch of dumb ideas. 8 men getting sick 8 times was a lot better than this crap. He ran out ideas shortly after eraserhead

>>87324628
>says the person who regularly laps up his liquidy shits with a smile

>>87323526
what made you think I was being ironic?

>>87324669
>Tarkovsky image
Opinion discarded

>>87323765
>They have since the start.
>redditor in example image literally said they liked the first 16 episodes
what did he mean by this?

>>87324698
If you think Lynch is better I pity your small brain. Tarkovsky isn't a hack unlike Lynch.

>>87324192

I'm sure he just accidentally keeps hitting the return key because 4chan is so confusing. Way to call out that reddit invader anon!

File: FUCKING IDIOTS.gif (2MB, 500x200px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 500x200px

You know, us at /who/ would've told you to NOT FUCK AROUND WITH THE TIMELINE!!!!! IT WAS A SET POINT IN TIME YOU FOOKIN' WANKERS, THEN HE GOES AND MESSES IT UP!!! FOOKIN' CUNT!!! BLOODY SHOULDA LEARNED, AYE!!!! NOW HE MADE A FOOKIN TIME PARADOX, AYE!!!! NOW THE DOCTOR HAS TO FIX COOPER'S FUCKING IDIOT PARADOX AND MAKE SURE LAURA STAYS DEAD!!!

>>87324684
>projecting his degenerate fetishes onto anonymous strangers
>>>/b/
>>>/gif/

>>87324773
Comparing the two is like comparing an expressionist v surrealist artist.

File: Dags.jpg (224KB, 704x554px) Image search: [Google]

224KB, 704x554px

>>87324773
>Tarkovsky isn't a hack

>>87323688
>redit blocking

go back to redit, real channers put space inbetween ideas to give the reader a comfortable reading experience

only an edgy reditor would look so pretentious by blocking their entire post like some sort of novel. You're on the internet you faggot reditor, you're not charles dickens writing a novel

It was good. I don't think it's Lynch's best work or the best tv show ever, like a lot of people here say, but it was enjoyable. There were some low points, but the highs were well worth it.

>>87324773
>Tarkovsky isn't a hack unlike Lynch.
Have you seen Stalker?

>>87324691
Because the other shows you mentioned are normie meme shows that everyone somehow loves

>>87324994
Stalker is great, you fucking cretin.

File: completed_castiel_eddie_moscone_fbi_badge_prop_by_misstimelord-d64elwa.jpg (87KB, 1024x576px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 1024x576px

>>87323611
Is there a close up of Dale and Richard's lapel pins? They looked different. Richard's didn't look like an FBI pin nor did his badge. They usually have a bill fold style ID. And the fact that he fumbled around for it seems significant. I think he also said, 'I'm ""with"" the fbi" rather than, 'I "am" FBI'

>>87325005
>agrees with me that The Return is better than those normalfag shows
>still thinks I'm being ironic for some reason
the house you grew up in, did it contain a lot of lead paint?

>>87324994
i hate tarkovsky but stalker is kino

Honestly, I'm not sure... As inconclusive as it was I would have been totally fine with it if it wasn't for the way Cooper was acting? Like, we finally have him back but he's just... weird. too quiet and definitely not witty enough. That was the biggest bummer in my opinion

>>87325042
>movie about three autistic LARPers is great
lol

>>87325091
It's because he was being taken over by the persona of Richard from wherever he and Diane went to.

On the whole, I have a positive view on The Return. It lacks coherency and there are times where Lynch opts for laziness, but I think there's too much in the series that I loved for me to dismiss it.

The entire Dougie Jones plot alone made watching it worth it. The finale was also great.

It's not Lynch's best work and it never reaches the heights of the original run, but I enjoyed it a lot more than I thought I would.

>>87325110
>tv show about a retard mulling about for 16 episodes is great
See, I can lower things to their basic elements too

>>87325194
No problem with that whatsoever.
Does not change the fact that Stalker is about three LARPers at all.

How does one start watching this show? Start with the original series or the new showtime one?

>>87325261
Fuck off you clown

File: image.jpg (298KB, 1428x2119px) Image search: [Google]

298KB, 1428x2119px

>>87324631
>thinking duchamp was a urinal only meme-man

i bet you watch paul joseph watson

>>87325261
Watch the latest episode backwards.

>>87325042
dude long takes with nothing happening lmao

>>87325261
In order 12 FWWM 3

>>87325367
>the sweeping scene

File: IMG_0118.jpg (110KB, 440x492px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 440x492px

>>87323197
A ruse of a nostalgia ending with 17 for an ending of ambiguity with 18

Honestly 10/10, thats filmmaking art right there

>>87325451
Yep, Stalker is still shit.

>>87323197
Great except for the ending

>inb4 LYNCHED

>>87324476

Proof of any of this other than you projecting your own insecurities

>>87325463
>ambiguity
There was nothing ambiguous about it. They literally laid out all the clues for you. Fucking reddit normies I swear.

Does the series at least conclude or are they setting up for more?

>>87325504
What did you dislike about it?

>>87325367

sorry about your adhd kiddo

>>87325546
Hack job throwing shit at the wall that doesn't make sense in order to look genius

>>87325521
I know she wakes up dumbass, but cutting to black after a dramatic scream is called an ambiguous ending

>>87323197

fucking kinography of the highest form

>>87324476

Lynch is a great artist then, he made The Elephant Man.

File: image.jpg (21KB, 487x432px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 487x432px

>>87325568
>haha you dont like 10 minute long shots with one angle and nothing happening? go back to transformers!

>>87325602
>seriously thinks she wakes up
How about you wake up first?

>>87323688
Exactly correct anon Lynch has been pulling the same trick for his entire career, it's only the dumb asses that believe of themselves to be intellectual thinkers for liking surrealist art house garbage who get tricked every single time. Lynch just did it again.

>>87324594

Lynch BTFO Tarantio this season, using Tarantino's own actors.

File: comeonnah.jpg (59KB, 960x882px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 960x882px

>>87324110
>implying you've ever sat down and read Dante or Virgil in your life

>>87323197
Brilliant, basically.

>>87325809
Here is another typical modern dead soul who wants explanations instead of feelings from art.

>>87323888
LLLLL
YYYYY
NNNNN
CCCCC
HHHHH
EEEEE
DDDDD

>>87323688
>>87325809
I would actually think the intellectually insecure people are the ones aggressively shitting on it. I'm able to go along for the ride and enjoy stuff even if every little detail isn't revealed. And it's not even like there's no explanation. It's open for sure but there's plenty of ways to interpret the ending and this isn't a bad thing. Everyone though, even the people who end up enjoying it, are likely to have a kneejerk reaction to such an abrupt ending. The difference is between people who stick with that kneejerk reaction and people who are capable of developing a more coherent theory based on other info from the show.

>>87324110
The Aeneid is actually unfinished.

>>87323197
Lynch also isn't about the supernatural at all. The dreamer is obviously as real as the dreamer in Mulholand Drive.

>>87325590
It makes sense for the most part. The finale is a re-examination and further reinforcement of the ideas explored in the Season 2 finale. Cooper is a tragic hero.

Whether it's a dream universe or an alternate reality or some combination of the two is not necessarily as relevant as that.

>>87325809
It's like you can see enough to know what you want to experience but lack the ability to do so. The sublime escapes you, and, left at its doorstep, you hurl your invective at passersby to try to ignore your shortcomings.

Why not focus on that instead of being mad?

>>87326049
So not real at all then? Mulholland Drive is about tulpas and is in the TPEU.

>all these plebs saying LYNCHED or that it was pretentious shit
sometimes emotional catharsis is more important to a work of art than rational conclusion.

>>87323594
Just finished rewatching 17 and 18. I'm still waiting until watching all 18 in a row for an actual opinion. That said, I'm was surprised that watching again there seems to be a lot more exposition and some of the imagery seems to be cryptic instead of surreal.

>>87325542
>Does the series at least conclude or are they setting up for more?

It ends on a bigger cliffhanger than the original show did

I watched Twin Peaks when it originally aired. Season 3 was a travesty on so many levels. Gone was the dark murder mystery juxtaposed against a remote town filled with oddball characters. Gone was the occasional dark and subtle humor. Gone was the sense that progress (either story or character) was being made every episode.

What we were stuck with this season was nuLynch with his long, tedious shots. Characters being le weird for the sake of le weird. Tons of side plots and main plots that went nowhere. A total misuse of a lore that's grown in popularity over 27 years. Having the show take place all over the country with numerous characters we don't care about. The list goes on and on. /tv/ will forget about this in a few weeks.

Good riddance.

>>87324586
>
That's the go to response isn't it 'You simply can't understand my genius'

I understand perfectly, it's just that you're fucking shit at art lol.

>>87326123
I too find myself in the "may the road rise up to meet your wheels" camp. Everybody seems hardwired on the destination yet they're missing the soft message... our journey (together) there.

>>87326309
>i am unfamiliar with the works of david lynch

>>87325110
why would you try this hard?

>>87325886
>literally muh feels!
go back to tumblr faggot
this board is for rational intellectuals only

>>87326309
Did we even watch the same show?

File: frenlo.webm (2MB, 900x506px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 900x506px

Why is frenlo so scary? Isn't he supposed to be my friend

>>87326369
>>i am unfamiliar with the works of david lynch
I've seen them. But I'm not comparing season 3 to the other works of Lynch, I'm comparing it to Twin Peaks season 1 & 2.

That's like you saying "herr derr Star Wars Episode 2 is similar to George Lucas' American Graffiti, so it's okay because you don't know his film style"

>>87325042
Agreed Stalker was captivating, Twin Peaks....hmmm not so much.

>>87326309
Generally, I loved season 3, but I see a few of your points.

Honestly I loved it but Lynch went a bit too far with the whole subversion of expectations thing.

>>87326396
>Did we even watch the same show?
Season 3 has barely anything in common with 1 & 2. And can you be specific about what I said was wrong?

>>87326309
>long, tedious shots. Characters being le weird for the sake of le weird. Tons of side plots and main plots that went nowhere. A total misuse of a lore

you just described the original though

>>87326450
he's not scary
the cameraman was just having a seizure

>>87325367
Muh time travelling, muh alternate dimensions, muh it's all a dream.
Get the fuck out Stalker blows Twin Peaks out the shiter.

Amazing. It will take some time for people to process.

>>87323197
Once again succeeded in absolutely revolutionizing the medium of television. The first true work art in it. It was hilarious, dark, confusing, rewarding. It perfectly balanced subverting expectations and giving payoff. Truly amazing

http://www.esquire.com/entertainment/tv/a57242/kyle-maclachlan-twin-peaks-the-return-2017-interview/

>"David tells me, 'Everything is Twin Peaks. It's all Twin Peaks,'" he says. "These stories continue—that's the whole thing. Everybody kept living and going on and doing their thing. It never stopped. Now we're picking it up again, 25 years later. Who knows if we'll pick them up again down the road, I don't know."

>>87326309
You're right to say that Season 3 is very different to Season 1 and 2, but many of your complaints could easily be leveled at the original run.

>>87326558
>you just described the original though
The original didn't have long, tedious shots.
Characters in the original were quirky, but the quirkiness served a purpose (to advance the plot, humor, being sinister, etc). Here they're just being weird or screaming all the time to no end.
Seasons 1 & 2 had some plots that went nowhere, but certainly not to this extent. Twin Peaks season 2 had a notorious troubled production. Season 3 had no such things.

>>87326526
>>87326309
>Gone was the dark murder mystery juxtaposed against a remote town filled with oddball characters.
The entirety didn't take place in a remote town but we definitely had the dark murder mystery of Briggs/Ruth Davenport and the quirky vegas charcters, cole/albert and the original cast.
>Gone was the occasional dark and subtle humor
There was fucking tons of it. Not even sure where to begin with this one. This season has been hilarious and dark.

>Gone was the sense that progress (either story or character) was being made every episode.

Again, what show were you watching? We had multiple intriguing story arcs that were loosely tied together by a single mysterious murder that over time tightened together.

File: nothing matters.jpg (120KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

120KB, 1920x1080px

This was profoundly saddening. The music during the credit sequence is tearing me apart.

It was and is kino, but Season 4 or a movie needs to happen.

This thread reminds me of how /tv/ loved The Force Awakens the first week it came out, then came to their senses and realized it sucks.

>>87326771
You'll get the final dossier and like it.

>>87326278
No, it doesn't.

>>87323681
a long awaited return to a cult tv show could have been nothing but 18 hours of member berries (which is obviously what some people wanted, judging by the 'muh answers' complaints). Instead, it was a new story with some familiar elements that is just as unique as the original series when it first aired

>>87325886
Anon, anon, anon I used to be a big fan of Lynch and his best work Blue Velvet. I also enjoyed Inland Empire when he was hitting it out the park in terms of style, plotting and story telling. TP season 3 doesn't compare not by a long shot.

File: las-vegas-desert-road-usa.jpg (986KB, 1500x844px) Image search: [Google]

986KB, 1500x844px

>>87324530
Video toaster? Wow, my Dad had one from IBM and could render shit. It took actual weeks to render seconds of animation. Was powered by an Amiga 4000 or something.

lynch clearly only cared about getting revenge for abc forcing him to reveal the murderer when he never intended to, and now he's got it. i was expecting it from the start so the ending was pretty satisfying to me. and i'm not saying that lynch is necessarily a genius for it, but he managed to subvert tv entertainment at it's core and make something unique, whether you think it's good or bad

did Diane's pusy kill coop?
i didnt get that scene

>>87326771
>kino
>Season 4 or a movie needs to happen

Pick one you fucking pleb

>>87327091
That scene took place in 1991.

>>87326792
Comparing TFA to Twin Peaks: The Return
haha

>>87323645
Slow moving, clap trap, nonsense, bad over acting, rng editing, too many over the hill characters, shameful waste of time money

>we meet a strange, new Cooper who is a bit more violent than the old Cooper we knew, but not totally evil like Dopplecooper
>takes "Laura" to her old house, but someone else is living there
>hear someone shouting for "Laura" and then Laura screams, lights go out
>this credits scene plays

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGqVDQ-7u0g

This is the most haunting thing to ever end a season with ever. It gets more haunting, depressing, and a feeling of sounding like "total loss", but also the feeling of discovering a secret, as Laura is whispering something to Cooper. The look on his face.

>>87323197
I actually thought it was even better than the original

File: e75.jpg (5KB, 251x251px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 251x251px

>2017

Wrong

http://grantland.com/features/twenty-things-david-lynch-fire-walk-its-20th-anniversary/

>>87326634
>When I ask him about his favorite scenes, MacLachlan immediately sports a big Dougie Jones smile. His sex scene with Naomi Watts comes to mind, and he imitates the look of perplexed ecstasy on Dougie's face as he sleeps with his wife. He flails his arms about a bit, not noticing that he's drawing some attention from some of the people sitting near us in the restaurant

fucking kek

>>87325256
But they aren't larping. Porcupine clearly got his wish. All three of them are giant pussies though.

File: coop.jpg (12KB, 320x201px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 320x201px

You faggots are a bunch of blind followers of Lynch who won't accept that "Twin Peaks: The Return" is a total disaster. This is the final proof that rebooting old series is a really *really* bad idea, since not even Lynch can do it right.

TPTR is not Twin Peaks: it's a bland, sad, and pathetic attempt of self-celebration in the form of an artificial continuation of an unfinished old work. So old that you, the creator, can't even remember correctly. Ironically, at a metalanguage level, the topics of this reboot perfectly reflect what reboots per se are: concretely, a doppelganger, product of a creative void. It's not Cooper who is lost here, it's David Lynch himself. Maybe this is his unconscientious talking...

I will tell you one thing, /tv/: after watching the first episode I was actually deceived for a moment, as I thought it was going to be great; maybe it was going to be more in the direction of FWWM, but I was OK with that. But then, after episode two I started to realize what was really going on here. At episode three, I started to cry and almost turned off my TV, as I finally understood what was happening here: it was the dead of one of the greatest artists of the 20th century.

File: 1504303843842.png (142KB, 342x342px) Image search: [Google]

142KB, 342x342px

>>87325504
DEHCNYL

File: i6K7p_d.jpg (53KB, 640x400px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 640x400px

>>87326278
Wasn't a cliff hanger at all. Pic semi related

>>87323314

I liked it, it left me with many questions. It left me really having to gather my thoughts. The last shot, honestly it terrified me, it got a real emotional reaction out of me. I don't quite understand what I watched, but I have some idea. I would be fine with Twin Peaks ending like this. The ending almost mirrored the ending of FWWM, but Cooper had a very different fate. I'll probably rewatch the season at some point in the future.

Entertaining and surreal as fuck. A bit hard to follow but definitely entertaining soild 8 for me

>>87323197
The peak of television, surpassing even the work of auteurs such as Kieslowski, Fassbinder and Bergman and rendering the rest of American television obsolete. Up there with the best films of the decade.

File: 1504562669084.jpg (199KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

199KB, 1200x1200px

i thought /tv/ was supposed to be a place for patricians to congregate

the amount of goobers who got /lynched/ last night leads me to a different conclusion however

i feel like i am floundering in a sea of plebs barely able to keep my head above water, gasping for air which is represented as every touch of david lynchs as he painted the now complete canvas that is Twin Peaks over a three decade period.

>>87324039
Have you seen your fucking post nigger? It proves the argument.

>>87323197
So glad that I shared this wonderful show with all of you, my dear fellow anons.

>>87327948
>a place for patricians to congregate
>any 4chan interest board after 2007

File: 1496068874355.jpg (56KB, 802x765px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 802x765px

>>87323197
If we're just talking The Return then I thought it was mostly excellent, but some of it bothered me on a technical level, mostly just the effects, and I thought One Punch Lad vs. BOB was extremely underwhelming for that reason. I also wasn't too fond of Diane being Cooper's main love interest, it felt a bit sudden and I wasn't really invested in their relationship, didn't help that Dern looked like a clown with the red hair. Other than that I loved it, I wouldn't have been opposed to having a couple more moments where Cooper just got to be Cooper, but I don't think it's a bad thing necessarily that that didn't happen.

>>87327645
but FWWM was awful

File: Drunk.jpg (128KB, 1182x1080px) Image search: [Google]

128KB, 1182x1080px

>>87328588
AWFUL

>>87324500
How is that pretentious you mental midget?

File: naido.jpg (940KB, 3600x2400px) Image search: [Google]

940KB, 3600x2400px

>>87328631
*chimp noises*

>>87328760
>auteur
Uh, yeah, i wonder

>>87323197
if youre over 35 you know its one of the greatest shows ever

under 35 plebs whine because it wasnt for them.. its ok plebs, we got a war coming for yah!

>>87328942
obvious false flag

File: maxresdefault.jpg (70KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

70KB, 1280x720px

It isn't fair. When will my Mr. Jackpots come??

File: 1496831277920.jpg (379KB, 1280x718px) Image search: [Google]

379KB, 1280x718px

>>87327648
Why did the fuckers at the Lodge even bother with Laura when Dougie is the nicest thing in the world already?

Had its moments, but jesus this whole season was extremely underwhelming.

I just watched the two final episodes. I might've been biased since I first went to /tv/ and saw a thread titled "disappointing finale" and immediately escaped from here in fear of spoilers. So I might've had time to prepare for fact that answers weren't given and more mysterious shit was about to go down.

Think finale was moody and fitting ending to twin peaks: r. Only thing I had issue with was the fight against bob-ball, surprisingly nothing else really felt pointless. It was two characters meeting again in another time and another place, trying to connect to past without glimmer of hope. Very sad ending which shows that coop fell deeper in the vicious circle in the world that he understands little of

>>87323283
FPBP

>>87329399
I feel like the Bob-ball fight was some kind of wish fulfillment on the part of the dreamer (Laura? or Cooper?).

>tfw I really really liked it but a part of me is still mad that we will probably never know what really happened to Cooper or even Twin Peaks now

>>87323681

its weird to explain but after episode 16 I kinda "feared" it would just reveal everything and cooper would explain how he drifted beyond universes and everything would turn up into more x-files stuff than the surreal horror zone I connect twin peaks with. But instead it threw me deeper into lonely dreamworld like a nightmare would.

File: Sean-Spicer-Trump-Oscars.jpg (59KB, 618x412px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 618x412px

>>87329621
>ever knowing what happened
See, this is why I was honestly pretty content before this just having Season 1 be the only part of the canon for me. It's not about knowing what happened. Forcing that knowledge led to the trainwreck that was Season 2. The lore shit was off the charts in Season 3, I would argue to its detriment, but just because it didn't lay all of its cards out in the table doesn't mean it's better if we know. Hell, they already made Twin Peaks and its world feel small and silly enough by making LITERALLY EVERYTHING WAS OR IS DONE FOR A REASON ACCORDING TO A 25 YEAR PLAN and all of the dumb hooks they decided to hook back on.

Contrary to what was said before, Season 3 was a little too obsessed in dropping in and tying up hooks. Season 3 had a lot of good in it, and I'm glad we got it, but it was at its worst when it was going between threads old and new trying to collect in into some huge meaningful tapestry to show the viewer. That's not what made Twin Peaks work, that's not what makes Lynch's other films work.

They overpromised so many shit. The evil cooper standoff was a fucking joke. And everthing was meaningless even if its the past. This is what happens when you write shit and dont know how to end it. At least they had a plan from the start with Lost

>>87330099
>threads

yea, it was like every episode pulled out another thread, looked at it, then set it aside and pulled out another one. In the end you have a pile of threads.

>>87324594
>>87324659
>implying Tarantino's opinion matters
go suck a foot you plagarizing hack

>>87330129
You have no idea what you're talking about

Last episode was a huge let down

File: iwillnotsoonforget.png (2MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1920x1080px

>>87323197

A brilliant work of art. A magnum opus by a genius at the top of his game

>>87330383
see>>87324500

>>87327948
DESU you just sound like a fag. Keep repeating your Lynch meme and feel smart about your self so at least someone does.

>>87330406
>I know! If I call them pretentious I don't have to actually respond to their opinion!

>>87326792
man what is with these faggots in like every thread that bring up tfa out of nowhere

sorry that most people enjoyed that film and no one liked the prequels you autismal nightmare

>>87329273

Without Laura, Cooper would never visit Twin Peaks, enter the lodge, get tricked and become an innocent lobotomite Dougie Jones.

Possibly a new level above kino if that's possible.

File: IMG_8952.png (169KB, 391x435px) Image search: [Google]

169KB, 391x435px

>>87323197
Masterful. I don't think I've been this affected by an ending since Mulholland Drive.

>>87323614
Doesn't get any bluer

>>87326309
As someone who saw Twin Peaks as a compromised Lynch (until the ending and FWWM) I saw The Return as a David Lynch film with Twin Peaks characters and I couldn't have been more satisfied with the result.

>>87326727
>no electric noises at the Frost/Lynch production card
>tfw you're just going to be left there hanging
>...hanging

LYNCHED

>>87330129

Wow every sentence is completely wrong! Nice work!

>>87324476
Why would you lump post-modernism in with surrealism? They aren't the same thing.

>>87327645
Fire Walk With Me was great because you experience the world through Laura's eyes. At parts the movie feels more like a horror film because she had a horrific experience.

I'm so glad that I enjoyed the whole thing and aren't a pleb.

File: 1488074524057.gif (511KB, 840x488px) Image search: [Google]

511KB, 840x488px

i didn't get it

man twin peaks finale was underwhelming as fuck

I need more time to process everything

right now I'm in the denial stage and I want to believe this is just a cliffhanger and not the end

>>87323888
The true meaning of LYNCHED means doing whatever then having retards desperate for meaning in their own lives stumble over themselves to make something up then call it genius. It's inspired, actually.

File: cream.png (307KB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

307KB, 640x360px

>all these people who specifically asked for no creamed corn with their meals
It was kino.

>>87333673
Don't fucking steal my creamed corn bitch.

I wanted 18 hours of Blue Velvet but got 18 hours of Inland Empire

>>87326727
do you know what the song is called??

>tfw we only got the good coop for a single episode
at least we got badcoop

>>87326309
>nuLynch
Even if this wasn't bait I don't see why you faggots would take this opinion seriously

>>87323614
>>87331335
this must be where good posts come to die

I'll admit I was pretty butt-flustered about the finale last night. After sleeping and thinking about it some more, I'm okay with it.

>>87333983
>Good coop was only in Twin peaks for 6 minutes before going to a different dimension where he wasn't himself anymore.

>>87334347
Evil extradimensional entities don't take time off, buddy.

Why was Jacoby making gold shovels though?

>>87333850
It is much closer to mulholland drive

>>87334809
to help people shovel themselves out of the shit
did you even watch?

Someone edit together all of Twin Peaks the Return so it's one 18 movie

File: markfrostshot.png (294KB, 594x413px) Image search: [Google]

294KB, 594x413px

>>87324187
>project written and directed entirely by Lynch
Excuse me?

>>87335484
Dang, that one went right over my head. As long as you're being so helpful, who killed Laura Palmer? Seemed like a pretty big plot point to leave unanswered.

>>87335575
Cooper did. Since Mike no longer was there to give her the ring.

I haven't watched like 6-7 episodes in the middle of the show and I don't feel like I missed anything, lol.

>>87331122

what should we call it?

>>87335932
Eps. 1,2, 17 and 18 are all you really need to see to understand it.

Flawed but my favourite show of all time. If only TV networks could indulge creatives more often. The entertainment industry is mainly homogenized bullshit.

>>87323197
I liked many bits and pieces of it, but all in all I was disappointed

>>87323197
It's a better swan song to Lynch's career than Inland Empire was. The Return feels like a motion scrapbook of his life's work, you can see each film progress through the season.

>>87326309

Fake and gay. There is no way someone who is in their mid to late 40s now uses the phrase "le" in their online opinions. Go back to le reddit.

>>87323197
10/10 will be talked about for years to come.

>>87323197

what show should I watch now? Everything is going to feel inconsequential and completely lacking after this masterpiece.

>>87336859
X Files

>>87323479
Amen anon. This is an event I'll remember for the rest of my life. All 27 years of this series was a gift to motion picture. David Lynch and Mark Frost are a masterclass of surrealism and spiritual filmmaking the likes of which we have rarely seen in the history of the format, and will rarely see in the future for decades to come.
10/10 it was alright.

>>87336648

If this is the last thing he releases then he's going out with a hell of a streak. Mulholland Dr, Inland Empire, The Return as a director's last works? God damn.

>>87336963
The Return could be Lynch's Blackstar. He's more than earned his time on earth.

>>87323464
>leftovers
Are you implying this garbage is on their level

>>87323999
There is fishing, yes.

>>87323558
this faggot knows whats up

>>87323629
>8/10 if the continuation occurs in Frost's upcoming Twin Peaks book.
He doesn't know the that book is a prequel to Season 3.