CYOA Discussion

>>25616388
First for nothing.

>>25616398
'Nothing: The CYOA' when?

>>25616388
Third for suffering and despair.

>>25616413
Right now.

>>25616388
third for PROFESSIONAL CONTACTS

>>25616413
but anon, we can't choose what you do with your life

new thread when

>>25616430
Never.

>>25616430
Looks like it's time to kill this thread.

>>25616388
>420th frame
i saw that you bugger

>1 page
CYOA is truly dead

>>25616430
Now.

File: 24322566_p2.png (2MB, 1280x1042px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x1042px

>>25616428

We are all the MCs of our own CYOAs.

Why aren't all of you reading alchemy right now?

>>25616480
Because it's shit.

>>25616480
Because I don't care.

>>25616480
>Reading a non-nips CYOA
L M A O
M
A
O

Xth for Coltshan's adorable!

>>25616473
I want to find and kill my QM then.

I wonder if my MC would feel the same about me.

>>25616500
There's a button to delete your posts at the bottom of the page
Remove yourself immediately

>>25616484
have you read it?

>>25616480
Actually I was thinking about catching up when I'm done with Unique.

>>25616480
Is there lewd?

>>25616512
yes, it's shit

>>25616540
kek

>>25616526
Yes.

>>25616547
With who?
No names please

>>25616553
Your mother.

>>25616553
a bat and a breezie

>>25616558
Reading it right now
Thanks senpai

File: 1418096321841.jpg (65KB, 563x542px)

65KB, 563x542px

>>25616492
>entry level cyoas

>>25616566
>a breezie
Seriously?

File: 1441318694918.png (326KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

326KB, 800x800px

>>25616553
breezie waifu multiple times.
changeling side-waifu.
batpony exhibitionist who wanted pegasus babies, twice.

probably more I'm forgetting. unicorn childhood friend is an ongoing goal but she's a lazy romantic.

File: 1411842085351.gif (302KB, 307x281px) Image search: [Google]

302KB, 307x281px

>>25616566
>a bat
Is it the daughter?

>>25616592
sounds like shit

File: efwdkBs.png (280KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

280KB, 800x800px

>>25616606
Kay.

>>25616586
Yes. A way was found.

>>25616592
That's all.

>>25616586
Ever heard of cock vore?

File: image.jpg (19KB, 251x211px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 251x211px

What time is it?
CONFESSION TIME

>>25616676
I'm mad.

>>25616676
I'm mad too.

>>25616676
I'm glad

>>25616676
CYOA died after GC left.
I'm a fan of the CYOA fandom.

>>25616676
I simultaneously really enjoy running a quest, using imagination and all that, but cry myself to sleep whenever I realize how shitty I am.

And not pony related one: I just don't want to live anymore.

>>25616676
I think Shade is worst pony and I hope Gar gets to kick his ass at least once

File: I LIKE WHAT YOU'VE DONE TO THE PLACE.jpg (53KB, 1008x567px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 1008x567px

>Gis is confirmed for Jack The Ripper

>>25616676
Been trying to work on a CYOA but I've never actually pitched the premise before.

>>25616748
Pitch it faget

>>25616676
The knowledge i might have killed a cyoa before it started will always haunt me

>>25616676
I want to make a cyoa where you're anon and you've been summoned by a magically gifted filly to be her friend and she lets you do whatever you want because it entertains her. She has complete and total control over you though.

>>25616676
I've come to hate bat horses thanks to these threads.

>>25616784
Me too, anon.

>>25616676
I think i've turned into a batfag because of this thread.

>>25616676
i think you're all wonderful people, and that when I have large swaths of time where I can't do my questing due to irl stuff, I feel really bad because I feel like I'm fucking you all over and you deserve better. But I'm always grateful for how wonderful you all are.

>>25616808
Me too, =.

>>25616764
No

>>25616676
I think
>JAD is perfect
>faggots taking over again
>>batfags
and the such are mainly one person.

>>25616676

I'm planning a new CYOA, but I'm shit at long-term thinking from everything needing to fit just right and I kind of just want to junk the whole thing and plan for the other one have in the back of my head.

>>25616825
probably.

>>25616825
Most likely actually started by someone else, but the resident shitposter latched on.

>>25616825
I'm >>25616784, and I'm not the >batfags guy. I'm just sick of seeing them now because of the shitposters drawing them here like a magnet.

File: _20151130_192309.jpg (68KB, 477x856px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 477x856px

Confirmed that Sundance would totally dominate Sunny Days in bed.
Makes sense Sunny Days was a very small filly and Sundance is a rater big mare.

>>25616676
I'm only here for the porn

>>25616887
can you think of many times batposting ever cropped up without the shitposter starting it?

The problem with batposters is not that they're actually here but rather that they can't resist poking shiny.

>>25616896
Where was this posted?

>>25616676
I think this has been said many times before
Finish a damn quest Nips.
Hell, drop a long forgotten one to make it easier
also never NEVER, wave around a new idea saying "I would love to, but my hands are full" cause anons will want that cyoa right away
example: pumpkin panic

>>25616887
Oh no, people can think bat suck or that JAD is overblown and whatnot. I'm talking about the guy that responds with the same tripe every time any of those subjects are brought up.

>>25616896
I'd have voted for sunny D.
Sundance needs someone to take the edge away and Sunny is perfect for the job.

>>25616676
yes

>>25616896
>anyone Domming Sunny D
Pffft, she'd wreck that big mare so hard all her edges would fall off.

>>25616982
>Implying that Sunny wasn't on the receiving end when some pony started panicking over a dragon attack that never happened.

>>25617085
What, you mean when she seduced that guy so hard he was going to kill his old friend when he put her at risk?

>>25617103
>tfw never got to rape the giant pegasus
That poor guy looked like he had an abusive owner, he needed a little filly in his life.

>>25617215
He'd have been good on the farm.

>>25616815
Are you me?

File: small celestia demands lewd.png (449KB, 724x1024px) Image search: [Google]

449KB, 724x1024px

What do we want?

>>25616808
>>25616676
I was neutral on bats before. I figured they were canon since Lauren said so but I'd never paid attention to any fanon about them. But seeing someone sperg out that hard about "stop liking what I don't like" makes me want to like it even more.
So now I love Tara's stupid ugly face. It's cute, like a pug or a bulldog.

>>25617419
ponies

File: 1446186476313~2.jpg (25KB, 365x374px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 365x374px

>>25617455
>So now I love Tara's stupid ugly face.
Every time.

File: tara face smug.png (35KB, 216x246px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 216x246px

>>25617455
Tara is the best.
Except for sweet-ass
But everyone hates my waifu.

>>25616676
RGS was the last CYOA that was riveting and that I really enjoyed.

>>25617455
>I like something cus someone else hates it

How does that even work?

>>25617497
Schadenfreude: to take enjoyment from someone elses suffering.

>>25617455
Don't forget she is as stupid as one too

>>25617494
Urban has cargo planes too.

And memes.

>>25617585
urban doesn't have that 'oh god I hope they make it, I hope they're all safe' feeling that RGS had though.

>>25616504
>Off in an alternate universe a poor little pony can't catch a break because of sadistic QMs

>>25617706
I just want to see Nadine happy damnit.

>>25617491
Essy needs to spend the rest of her life in pone prison.

>>25617765
and only get one ice cream sandwich at dessert time.

>>25617770
Late start

>>25616676

I really want to take a break from running my current game, and try something new, but I'm worried I won't be able to top my current project and I'll just annoy anons by taking time away from something they already enjoy.

>>25616825

JAD may not be perfect (nothing is), but you don't have to be perfect to be wonderful. And JAD is certainly that.

>>25616776
shut up Panzer

>>25616776
PuzzleAnon was shit anyway.

>>25617918
>You haven't even seen what my composite-rigid is like yet!

>>25617918
>>25617934
wew

>>25617936
I still fucking cringe when I think of that rant

>>25617918
>>25617934

You know what the Hell of it is? >>25616776 isn't actually me. Although it does make me curious as to what that anon is referring to since it does sound eerily like what happened with PuzzleAnon.

>>25617965
Were you seriously planning on having THREE IN EVERY FIVE...

>>25617967
Maybe he's talking about that Arkquest faggot.

>>25618004
What happened to make him quit?

That princess daughter quest was a shit idea and I'm not apologizing for that, but Arkquest looked interesting and fun.

Aborting a CYOA before birth is just wrong

Active threads

M&M: >>25601723
Hijack: >>25591290
Sunset: >>25612666
Maximum Overedge: >>25603307
Alchemy: >>25611490
Trottingham: >>25613430
Urban Survival: >>25617770
Space: >>25553699
Archipelago: >>25612611
Vampony: >>25568958
Semantic Error: >>25592329
FOE: >>25587642

>>25618012
Every Coltshan cyoa should be aborted.

>>25618037
Coltshan doesn't believe in abortion, but he can't afford to keep the babies either.

So they get dumped in the trash. Don't even have enough potential to get adopted out to a more loving QM.

File: 1412796458169.gif (64KB, 329x262px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 329x262px

>>25618031
>maximum overedge
>:C

What was this famous rant by Coltshan?

This man intrigues me in this horrific sort of way.

>>25618031
>FOE
>didn't know that was running!
>it's the general
oh

>>25618149
>by Coltshan

File: Untitled.png (46KB, 1862x227px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 1862x227px

>>25618009
We were beating him over the head because of his hot opinions. Apparently he just buzzed off.

>>25618153
Radioactive Horse Quest is FOE 2.

>>25618149
It was by Panzermane. Here you go, read it in all its glory.

https://desustorage.org/mlp/thread/23499613/#23503760

>>25618004

Arkquest? Haven't heard of it. Did that happen while GS was on hiatus?

>>25618183

Not my best work, I'll grant.

>>25618067

I'm kinda hoping Coltshan will improve and eventually produce a worthwhile CYOA.

>>25618067
That's because I don't give a fuck about Fire Emblem or it's story.

>>25618167
oh right, that asshole. Completely forgot about him.

>>25618206
ArkQuest has been 'happening' since March.

>>25618206
It certainly made my composite rigid.

>>25618206
Seen here >>25618167 the last time that guy showed up was early September. Looking at your thread dates, yes it happened when GS wasn't up.

>>25618223
If its not on the pineapple, its not happening.

>>25618167
I can't speak broadly, but it seems like a good number. of /tg/ natives come over here and generally fuck up because they don't learn what's popular on /mlp/

>>25618206
Arkquest was a medieval adventure kind of quest. Never actually happened, but the QM had a really neat idea for garnering players.

Basically, he needed a bunch of background characters, but instead of going to the deviantart pony maker or whatever, he asked Anons to post their OCs and they'll show up as characters that'll probably die.

File: 132546471055.png (254KB, 624x352px) Image search: [Google]

254KB, 624x352px

>>25618228

>>25618252
How many people have actually come here from /tg/ though?

>>25618291
/tg/ and /mlp/ have a fair amount of crossover if you look at the 'what boards do you frequent' threads.

>>25617967
it allows the wearer to see the world as a bird does

>>25618315
Oh, I remember that dude.

Worst magical artifact I've ever heard of.

>>25618217

I could've taken over Coltshan's Fire Emblem-inspired quest, but as much as I like that series, it doesn't seem like the best fit for CYOA. Too much math and interlocking numerical stats. I have been pondering doing something Valkyria Chronicles or XCOM-inspired for a long time, but knowing me it would (at best) turn into a lighter and softer RGS where I'd be too pussy to let ponies die except in the most extreme of circumstances, and I don't think there's much clamor for that.

>>25618252

Hmm, I do seem to vaguely remember that whole "post your OCs" thing, now that you mention...

Salient point about the /tg/ migrants, though. There was someone not so long ago who was going on about how all our quests star anon, not realizing that there hasn't been an /mlp/ quest starring anon for ages.

>>25618308
Yeah but actual GMs?

>>25618329
>>25618315
Explain.

>>25618308
Yeah, but all the horsefuckers are quiet about it on /tg/ because everyone on /tg/ who's not a horsefuckers HATES them.

>>25618331
>Salient point about the /tg/ migrants, though. There was someone not so long ago who was going on about how all our quests star anon, not realizing that there hasn't been an /mlp/ quest starring anon for ages.
To be fair, most of the board thinks that too. I've seen that thought echoed in SiM.

>>25618335
Basically, the quest was centered around acquiring an artifact that allows the holder to see like a bird.

Basically, you know how you can only really focus on one thing with your eyes? The artifact would allow you to focus on your whole field of vision.
Also you could see colors more brightly or something.

One anon said accurately - if it were real, I wouldn't drive twenty minutes to go pick it up, let alone go on an adventure to get it.
Magical artifacts worth finding need to be magical, not mundane.

>>25618385
When was this?

>>25618331
>>25618361

Not to be that guy, but >>25612666 stars Anon.

>>25618361
Perhaps this is why/pone/ has such a militant aversion to both quests and CYOAs.

>>25618413

True, but I'm pretty sure the post about all our quests starring anon was made before that got started.

>>25618404
Few months? Coupled with a lot of grammatical issues, it never actually had a thread.

The idea got pretty much laughed out of /cyoag/

iirc, Hijacker was one of the main people making fun of him.

>>25618431
They don't though. There's two long term ones active and have been three that died quietly from lack of QM activity over the last couple months. If you compare their amount of users to ours they're probably over-represented in quests.

>>25618335
The guy had a single, mundane trinket and hijacker told him no one would ever go for such a shitty item

>>25618453
>Quest for trinkets?
>Hey, what if someone had already done this!

>>25618453
>>25618460
This is like when Rocketeer posted his concept art. I don't remember this happening and I have no idea why.

>>25618413
Fair enough, but that's still one anon quest out of however many.

>>25618477
>>25618413
Two technically. SiM is running an Anon quest.

>>25618468
He was told to step his game up.

>>25618510
Wait, Olibird is the QM?

Fuck, I remember when he wrote for /moon/ and /sun/.
He was a decent writer, wondered what happened to him.

>>25618453
>Hijacker decided to crush the competition preemptively and steal the idea
>Currently making millions of memebux knowing full well that it's dirty money

>>25618563
He started writing a CYOA obviously.

>>25618563
Yeah.
>>25552804
is the start. Apparently he's doing pretty good.

>>25618566
Hijackler did nothing wrong.

The railroads are there for instracture purposes only.

>>25618599
Open your eyes man, you know as well as I do that he laid the railraods to send his competition to concentration camps

>>25618649
Only the filthy memers who were ruining CYOA. Hijacker is stimulating CYOA's economy! His plans to retake the ponyland via war is brilliant.

>went from conductor
>to literally cyoaHilter

W E W
E
W

>>25618788
The torch has passed from Res to Hijacker. Who will be the next cyoa hitler?

>>25618810
So if Hijacker's Hitler now, who's the new Nips?

File: 1442055223461.png (4KB, 304x319px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 304x319px

>>25618735
You're batshit insane

>>25618810
This seems like a good idea to tell everyone that I'm starting up a short CYOA tomorrow to celebrate my three days off work. It shouldn't take too much long than that.

>>25618838
RULES OF RAILROAD
AND THEY BOARD WHEN THE THREAD COME UP
WITH WAIFUS ON THE LINE

What happened to that anon who was making long posts de-constructing the flaws in cyoas?

>>25618903
I stabbed him for unrelated reasons, he's in the hospital.

>>25618903
Yeah, about dat.
He had a load mouth, ya know?
Had.

>>25618903
I bought him a nice new pair of shoes and told him to talk a long walk off a short pier.

>>25618903
Slathered in mango and sent into the hood

>>25618903
I gave him to Inept.

>>25618903
I'm still here. I'll probably have a critique up for Heat before the end of the week.

I haven't been posting recently because I'm too busy practicing my art and writing. I want to actually start my CYOA sometime soon, instead of just complaining about others like an annoying whiner.

I'm hoping to start a shitty lewd text CYOA sometime in the next couple of days. That'll be a short episodic quest, just to experiment and test the waters.

I need to put up or shut up.

>>25619176
No, you need to put out.

File: 1448912937138.jpg (129KB, 600x772px) Image search: [Google]

129KB, 600x772px

show me those cyoa waifus homeslices

>>25619176
>Heat
I thought you were reading M&M

File: Silver.png (866KB, 1543x1452px) Image search: [Google]

866KB, 1543x1452px

>>25619276

File: 1438675609977.png (24KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 600x600px

>>25619276

Fucking Pen that piece of catbird shit REEEE

File: brown-poly-tarps_8210_500x500.jpg (49KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 500x500px

>>25619276

File: Esmerelda in a box.jpg (65KB, 687x506px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 687x506px

>>25619276

File: 1444149012356.png (588KB, 1000x1000px)

588KB, 1000x1000px

>>25619276

>>25619282
If I remember correctly, the Heat QM asked for critique personally, but with M&M it was just a random player.
I'm going to prioritize Heat because I'm not sure if Hero actually wants to hear my opinion at all.

>>25619355
Hero has his fort prepared.

File: I'll be safe from them here.jpg (254KB, 1600x1067px) Image search: [Google]

254KB, 1600x1067px

>>25619355
He'll survive.

>>25619326
Wat

>>25619355
I-I'm down.
I'm willing to check out what you have to say about my quest.

>>25619409
It was a very useful tarp, and it did not deserve the death it was given.
RIP in pieces tarpy.

>>25619482
What is it from?

>>25619498
Pony's quest 3.

File: What happened to Timeline Anon.png (230KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

230KB, 600x600px

I don't remember where, but someone asked where Timeline Anon was. Then I had an idea to do a thing.

>>25619868
How long did he last before getting brutally raped murdered by ayylmaos?

>>25619932
About four minutes.

>>25619868
>>25619944
F

>>25619932
>raped murdered
That sounds painful.

>>25619299
Who is that artist/pone and where can I get more? I think i'm in love

>>25619299
>I think i'm in love
Probably just lonely.

So anons, if /mlp/ gets nuked (and some people think it might) do we find a new board or migrate sites entirely?

>>25620030
it won't.
the fear has no substance behind it. /mlp/ will exist until atleast s6 and the movie is done with.

>>25620030
Why would that ever happen? We're like the 12th fastest board or something.

>>25620030
>guys I heard they're going to nuke /vp/ until the next game comes out!

File: CUTIEMARKS FOR CUTIEMARKS.png (156KB, 4359x3000px) Image search: [Google]

156KB, 4359x3000px

Unique may or may not return. Probably the former but I will admit that I'm having trouble running it. I almost feel like the best way to get it off the group is to do a quasi-reboot at this point.

On the plus side my art friend is back so hopefully I can get some decent pictures here and there.

As for my thoughts on the finale I fucking loved how Starlight acted as a villain in the finale. Her banter with Twilight and the way she outwitted her was great. But yeah, her motivation was kinda shitty and not really explained properly. It's really silly to think that she got this crazy super radical viewpoint and egomania just because some friend of hers moved away, that just doesn't make any sense.

They really should have done two things: Focus more time on it and cut out some of the extraneous timelines (maybe Spike entirely too, he had no real purpose being there. And I'm not just saying that as a 'lel spike's a fag way'.) OR keep it vague as fuck as then expand on her backstory in an episode in S6. She was already breaking down after she saw the consequences of her actions, a little bit of philosophical debate probably would have been enough to break her will fully.

She's still my waifu

>>25620176
What's the problem with running it as is?

>>25620176
S L O T H P L S
Why a reboot?

>>25620247
>>25620263
I think I said this before without going into great detail: kept all my notes in a journal for Unique. House got flooded, notebook among the things damaged. I only have a few digital notes here and there but not enough to piece together what I had. So I'm debating whether pressing on and trying to just re-write everything would be the best.

>>25620030
>listening to /pone/ propaganda
Please nigga.

>Moot is going to turn 4chan into a Tumblr SJW safespace!
>Moot is going to delete /pol/!
>Moot is going to sell 4chan to Gawker or some other shitty company!
>Hiroyuki is going to monetize 4chan and sell our data!
>/mlp/ is going to be deleted!
When are you faggots going to stop buying into this bullshit?
It's fear mongering for the sole purpose of tricking people into migrating to 8gag. None of their doomsday predictions have come true. Ignore their Jewish tactics and underhanded sales pitch.

Thank fuck they're not spamming those shitty infographics anymore.

Polite sage for off topic.

>>25620294
Oh. Well, whatever you thinks best.

>>25620294
And this is why digital notes with a cloud sync backup is best. Just in general. General art and stuff for college as well.

File: 1415576922952.png (5KB, 210x214px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 210x214px

>>25620333
>8gag

>>25617765
Crossover CYOA now? There is a pony prison CYOA after all

I bet that pumpkin panic will not finish this year.
any takers?

File: file is driving.png (749KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

749KB, 1200x1200px

I should probably stop creating threads on saturdays when I have no time on Sundays to run.
Anyway, we're up.
>>25620463

Also, Yes The car in the title card is an AW11.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5whGoNQK6I

>>25620471
I honestly think that Nips should just postpone it.

But hell naw, not taking that bet.

>>25620404
Considering it.

File: Pumpkin_comparison.png (480KB, 896x338px) Image search: [Google]

480KB, 896x338px

>>25620483
Don't worry, he's pretty close to the ending.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IBkF8g2XxWA

>>25620479
My chance for Eurobeat will come.

>>25620509
He is?

>>25620509
Yeah, but consider that there is only one month left before the year ends. Nips updates his CYOAs (outside of summer) about three days every month. Pumpkin Patch has been even more sporadic and also slow.

The money just isn't there.

>>25620556
I hope he can finish it, but he's always doing shit irl that I think he's going to burn out
this will give away my irl identity to him, but dammit nips I know you do that "if others are happy i'm happy" thing but if you don't do stuff for yourself you're gonna have a bad time.
I'm not saying that he should drop the volunteer stuff he does so that he can pone it up here, but c'mon. Do stuff for yourself once in a while. And also pone with us

>>25620811
Did he clean your house again?

>>25620828
I don't let him in my house for that very reason. It is my mess. There are many like it but my mess is mine.
I meant more of the fact that he gets like, no fucking sleep and he spends his free time on mondays and wednesdays quite literally pushing homeless people who are in wheelchairs around to where they want to go (among other things). His reasoning was that he has legs that work so why not use them to be kind. I get wanting to help people, but the guy is getting bags under his eyes that even my father doesn't have. He's gonna burn out if he doesn't do something about it.

>>25620877
I remember an episode of House where being excessively nice was a symptom of something.

>>25620877
Nips
Pls
Be nice to yourself.

>>25620877
I've never understood the mindset of running yourself into the ground for others' benefit. It's less efficient and you end up helping less people.

>>25620877
Could a person be addicted to helping others?

>>25616676
It's going to take longer than I thought. I don't know if I should just get practice now by delivering shittiness, or waiting until I acquire a bit more know-how/a better understanding before trying again.

>>25621028
Best way to learn is to do.

>>25620294
That sucks.

Unique is/was my favorite quest, so I really hope you decide to continue it.

>>25621028
Deliver shittiness and improve, be the inspiration for the other mealy-mouthed faggots

File: letter.png (413KB, 600x600px)

413KB, 600x600px

>>25620811
>>25620556
>>25620877
I'm being caught up in a slew of classwork right now, but I will get PP done soon. I want to finish it, and I want to get to the schedule.
>>25620924
I am tho
Also, the letter came in Hijack
Thanks a ton!
'll have to get used to not drawing with a stub that scratches my tablet

>>25621127
10/10 hijacker.

>>25621127
you have no idea how releived i am that wasnt lost in the mail

>>25621127
>>25621136
Yoo, I didn't know about those other two drawings. I thought it was just going to be broken-legged Nikita refusing kindness.

Patches poledancing is great and I need more of it.

Reminder that bat fags has ruined many CYOAs and the CYOA Discussion general by shoving their autistic batcancer and retarded batmemes into it.

>>25621189
I gotta agree Shiny, the more you hate batponies the more I want to like them.

I used to have zero interest in them but your salt just makes me want to shove bats right down your retarded throat.

>>25621127
now for your repayment
you have to ponepone

>mfw i shot my load on plotlines for the prologue chapters of my Quest and I have one more character who I don't have shit for

God fucking dammit. The first I have needs an actual ending besides "MC gets the power and goes off because he needs to figure this out." Or it just needs to be more than "errands and sidequests that determine plot shit that I'll ultimately improvise for less major details."

Speaking of, how much should be improvised and how much should I sit down and work on? How do I expand a plot point? How much expansion is too much? Should I just keep reading instead of asking?

File: 1382579056029.jpg (32KB, 333x308px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 333x308px

>>25621255
Forgot picture but hey, dubs.

>>25621255
>what should be worked on
characterization, major plot points, and worldbuilding

>What should you improvise
everything else.

>>25621255
can you provide some context?

You should improvise most things and work on establishing the setting and characters to fit into those improvisation. Have the widest possible assortment of tools that can be open-ended enough to be slotted in easily in reaction to what your players want.

build a world that doesn't just exist for the sake of the plot you had planned because odds are, you'll end up doing something completely different from what you expect.

>>25621255
Your world-building should mostly be creating a list of things that are independent of player influence that can colour your world and a list of rules that govern how your characters behave and how you will QM. Then you can improvise under those constraints.

oh, also make notes on the small details you improv on. You can call back to them later and make it all look like part of a plan and it helps keep your world consistent.

>>25621263
So build on things that the players won't have too much influence on as they would other, more physical things, such as whether a side character has to avoid using her time manipulation power to help the MC, due to a potential sexual encounter that may have taken place if the players, well, played their cards (in?) correctly.

I made that vague on purpose, sorry. But you get the idea.

>>25621277
So strive for possibilities, then?

Also, what context do you need?

>>25621304
>Also, what context do you need?
Well your complaining about a lack of plotlines beyond "MC wanders off for a while"
Now I could very well suggest he takes up a night class in knitting but that probably wouldn't fit with whatever character or theme you're aiming for.

Narrow the scope for us, are you an existing QM? What quest? If not, what type of quest are you trying to make?

>>25621354
Night class in knitting is something I will work in the untouched character's story, it's official. That said, I mostly wanted general "one size fits all plotlines" advice as a foundation, but alright. Here goes.

I am not a QM right now. This not even started Quest is about 4 playable characters, living in a period that is about 50-80 years before Season 1 Episode 1. No it won't be a multiplayer quest like that one fag suggested, it will be more like Wild ARMs with multiple protagonists, one will be chosen at the start of a new thread and will be used until either a plot point requires another MC, or we get a new thread. They all are gifted with a special power and a lot of the story involves fighting, friendship, and striking poses. I have a mechanic written up for how poses work, that's how vital they are.

After the prologues, which range from adventures to mystery, the characters all end up in Ponyville for various reasons, like "hey buttmunch, i have a friend who knows why you have weird powers now, he's in some redneck town called ponyville, talk to him while I go through your porn stash" and "hey its time to get a scholarship, let's go help with construction in this town." The main plot revolves around another mystery, action, and is most likely going to be somewhat dark. Not "oh shit its time to be evil, hold on guys i gotta emasculate a colt and rape him to show how edgy i am up in this bitch" dark, but "aw fuck he was killed just like that" dark.

I can't think of what else I should say, because I'm nervous about spoilers and I'm hitting a blank. What else do you need?

File: road_warrior_humungus_1.jpg (219KB, 712x535px) Image search: [Google]

219KB, 712x535px

>>25621443
>Thought you were talking about Sunset Riders because I forgot what Sunset Riders was called.
>Looked up Wild Arms.
>Pretty much the same advice applies.
>Honestly, the best way to come up with good plot-lines for stuff like this is to take example from other media that carries the same themes.
So Like 'True Grit', 'Desperado', 'Gun Smoke' or 'The Three Amigos'.
Like, you could have the characters hired as mercenaries to clear some bandits out of a town, or you could have one of the characters hunting down a someone who killed his family member and the other three tag along, and stuff could happen along the way, or you could go the opposite direction and have the main cast planning bank and train robberies or acting as some sort of frontier mob and slowly extorting all of the small towns for "Protection Money".

I mean, these ideas are terrible, but you know what I mean right?

>>25621443
Okay, so did you need help with an ending to the prologue that's bringing all these characters together or did you need ideas for quests to provide to the players once the group has formed?

>>25621498
The latter. I know how to get them in the same place. Well, same city. I got plans for their encounters.

>>25621496
Sunset Riders is fucking kickass.

But yeah, I getcha. It's not a cowboy story though, sorry. I picked Wild ARMs because of the multi-perspective story and it's a badass game. But now I want to make a Western quest later.

Though, why would the other three tag along with a vengeful protagonist, aside from "you kicked my ass so I gotta join you?"

>>25621550
Well, then my first idea is to introduce a lore dump NPC, like a librarian. This serves the dual purpose of fansperging because you get to visit the treehouse before twilights time and it gives the players somewhere to go if they need help.

My second idea in addition to the npc would be to have the un-used player characters be the source of quest ideas to help establish their motivations and character. Players will listen to their squad mates and consider their needs, it will also colour how that character is played in the future.

Your players have strange powers they don't fully understand? Have them hear about a trinket related to their powers. Your characters could be frightened by their power and want something that could inhibit or remove it, or they could embrace their new skill and look for ways to expand it. Freaky time control powers? Turns out the princesses long ago controlled the seasons with the solstice hourglass and you the player want to find that.

You could have a character be a regular adventurer who only came to ponyville because it's close to the rail-hub but with less guard oversight, such a character could be motivated to tag along with the others interests by the promise of wealth or just plain old adventure, depending on how you write him. He could also be the one to suggest adventures.

You could have a disgraced guard angle where he see's the power as a new lease on his ability to help others and he would suggest quests that orient around helping people.

You could just have the plot bash their door in and have something attack ponyville and your characters react to protect it. Maybe the four of them save the town from a Hydra and their kinship and reputation stems from that? They could come to enjoy their fame and reap further rewards by helping other towns. Maybe hollow shades comes to them about a mysterious monster in their woods. etc.

given more time i could probably think of something more coherent.

>havin a good time
>spot >>>/trash/305152

Cyoa sure gets around, don't it?

>>25621618
>Have them hear about a trinket related to their powers.
now you've done it

>>25621669
>Willow is in the Trash

Sounds about right.

I dunno why anons didn't like Willows character. I found her way more enjoyable to play as than Steel or Tara.

>>25621791
Because she's a silly action burd doing silly action burd things and there's only so much fun you can draw from that concept before you're left with a caricature instead of a character. Be happy we left while she was still fun so we can revisit her from time to time and have fond moments

>>25621810
Flaming is against Global Rule 3

>>25621810
But nobody is roleplaying in this thread.

>>25621810
Racism is against GR3

>>25621803
If I wanted to read something with good characters I wouldn't be reading CYOA's

how would you go about starting and running a Cyoa? thinking of maybe having a go with one as something to do in my downtime

>>25621825
Being underage is against Global Rule 2

>>25621829

never mentioned my age.

GET TROLLED AGAIN, KEK

>>25621822
Post something. Ask for input. Post something again based on that input.

>>25621833
Lack of post quality is against Global Rule 6

>>25621836
okay.

>>25621852
You got a quality 'hiatus' going on right now. :^)

>>25621822
From nothing? Talk to people. Talk to QMs.
Post in here, join the secret club and ask some questions, etc. Effort is rewarded as well as a willingness to learn.

Hell we've had people run tests here, so start with that.

>>25621791
Oh so I'm not the only one.

File: hqdefault (1).jpg (9KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 480x360px

>Urban Survival has a literal black weeaboo
>hasn't made one reference to Gar Iceon and GARcher's relation

Why, Res? You punched my immersion in the slightly below average-sized dick.

>>25622224
To be fair, the one time we saw Shade in combat he dropped everyone like bad news and it was over too soon for him to strut.

>>25621945
I'm not that Anon, but how do you join the secret club?

>>25622503
Here is how you join it:
Lurk more.

>>25622503
By gitting gud

Seriously though, I wish the sekrit club happened at more reasonable hours rather than the dead of night.

It's not really accessible to normie scum.

>>25622600
I slept for 12 hours yesterday because three sekrit clubs in a row devastated my sleeping over the weekend.

I was thinking about doing a normie hour stream today, but I'm typically not the one people want to watch.

>>25622600
I'm slightly triggered that there's discussion going on that I can very rarely see.

File: 1448453536497.jpg (69KB, 1228x845px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 1228x845px

>>25622612
Pls do it.

>>25622618
It really is unfortunate, watching hijacker, spes and Hero discussing combat in cyoas [the roll of dice, what players should impact, narrative combat vs turn based, use of random elements] was amazingly informative.
The back and forth of the chat makes it very easy for conversations to take place but unfortunately it's all lost a few hours later.

>>25622634

Dang...I could really use that sort of information right about now...

>>25622634
4chan is only slightly less temporal. There's been nothing discussed there that hasn't been gone over several times here.

>>25622682
I can't say I agree. Things here are up far longer, and stored permanently elsewhere.

>>25622693
Then people can go find the other more detailed discussions of of narrative combat vs turn based, use of random elements, what players should impact, and the roll of the dice.

The livestream lasts hours, the thread lasts a couple days. Unless someone wants to start pastebinning our detailed discussions.

>>25622716
Uh, okay?
I didn't say otherwise. Doesn't change the fact it's a shame people miss out on it. Every discussion isn't exactly the same.

>>25622671
well then join the club and ask them. :^)
I've seen !1P, bathwater, spes, hijacker, nips, alchemyanon, ressurrected & hero there. lots of qm's to ask about just about anything.

>>25622693
While true, longevity is only a factor if the posts can be found and read. It's hard to find topics of discussion that exist solely as a subset to a thread. I've searched for conversations I've taken part of and still had trouble getting the right keyword strings to actually find the posts efficiently.

Plus, valid advice can be less based on facts then they are on trends and trends expire.

>>25622742
I think the three of us might agree but have found a way to all talk around each other.

>>25622742
Right, it's an issue of exposure, not really the time limit it exists on.

>>25622745
>well then join the club and ask them. :^)
I take issue with that. He's free to ask his questions here and now.

>>25621816
Time to ban Urban threads

>>25622745

I should get around to that...especially considering I've been running my cyoa for a few months now.

>>25622771

Not really any specific questions at the moment, hence why I was more curious about the aforementioned chat about combat and such so that I could read what's there and find out what would work best for me.

I'm mostly just trying to refine on my cutequestria war game idea for when I eventually need to take a break from innkeeping.

>>25622771
Well, I'd say the exposure problem was compounded by the time limit. I mean if you joined a stream ten minutes after the discussion you won't even know it happened.

>>25622771
of course he is? How did you come to the conclusion i was suggesting otherwise?

>>25622802
You may have inadvertently implied he would be better off going to streams than asking here.

>>25622802
It's a matter of unintentionally discouraging conversation here by presenting another place as if that is the proper location to do it.

>>25622796
Ah, so more viewing of a conversation. Well, from what I recall of your war games it'll be very different mechanically from the average cyoa, so it wouldn't necessarily help as much. Amusingly, the way your handling the inkeeping is a very good example of how I would think it's best to do it. It's descriptive, but everything has a mechanical effect in the background that players can't exactly see, but know the general degree of. It's obfuscated.

Speaking of mechanics, I wonder where the dice pool and degrees of success guy went.

The last character in a Quest that made you laugh is now voiced. You must pick his/her/xir/its/nigger voice.

Hypostome is now voiced by Timmy Williams. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K69AyDJqZso

>>25622809
I'd probably argue that yes, any individuals are better off there but that it's worse for the community. The simple fact that you have a captive audience addressing your topic in real-time is an incomparable advantage over discussions that might need to span over several hours or days to cover the same breadth of detail.

Unfortunately the lack of permanence makes these discussions only useful to whoever happened to be there. That's not particularly healthy when that information would probably still be useful on a general basis. Ideally discussions spawned there would crop up and be reapplied here, or discussions truncated into a more useful format. Even though they're all advertised here when they happen, its not healthy to have a burden of knowledge where you'd be best served going somewhere you didn't even know about especially for something pertinent to this thread.

That said, if for whatever reason you're not comfortable airing things here, the chat exists. I definitely think it's a good thing to have but I agree it shouldn't be presented as the 'place' to have such discussions, just one venue where they can happen and also videogames and art and shit.

>>25622834

Yeah, I do intend on keeping the mechanics strictly under the hood. I don't want to bore people with fine details, nor embarrass myself by revealing how shoddy they might be. So at best you might wind up with something like:

>Lancer (Foam-tipped lance) - fast attack unit that excels that striking fast and hard, then getting out before the enemy can retaliate. Their mobility is their main defense, which means getting bogged down by terrain or combat will turn battles against them.

The main obstacle I'm trying to avoid is making the battles feel too much like a board game, but still at the same time have the players feel like they're contributing to its outcomes before and during.

>>25622600
I would stream, but no one would want to watch me draw anyway.

>>25622896
Nonsense

You are not bound to succeed.

>>25622896
Do. It.

>>25622896
If they'll watch me they'll watch anyone.
Go for it.

>post about how people wouldn't like to watch you streaming
>???
>profit

>>25622915
craft pls

>>25622869
A large part of classic warfare is that largely after things are set up, things play out without a ton of control. You could take advantage of this by having the set up be the primary managing and the actual combat involve making the MC a special unit that takes direct part. Lead from the front as it were. You'd have a mixture of described board game preparation and descriptive fighting.

>>25622949
Its true though, on my best day I'm a dollar store version of Fins or Alchemy. I'm trying to get better but lets be real, if a list was made we all know where i'd be.

>>25622849
>Hypostome
Literally who

>>25622974
Craft, pls.

File: 9d8c51a2d0900a2c.png (442KB, 1000x1152px) Image search: [Google]

442KB, 1000x1152px

>>25622982

>>25622974
>crippling self-doubt
Must be a good QM.

>>25622994
>happy with current situation and abilities
>only regret is not being able to improve faster
No wonder I'm such a bottom barrel QM.

File: 1445044725670.png (110KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 900x900px

>>25622974
craft bby we love you. we wouldn't have this fat bat if not for you

>>25622994
>crippling self-doubt and not even a QM
unlimited suffering

>>25623033
What are you waiting for?

>>25623013
Start hating yourself more and watch yourself shoot up. Take that flail to your back, get compliments for it.

File: 1445608023395.jpg (50KB, 712x528px)

50KB, 712x528px

>>25623037
No ideas
No writing experience
Too inefficient at drawing
Wouldn't be able to take the pressure

>>25622896

I should nut up and confess: I honestly want to stream too sometimes. But I'm too scared and inept to try and figure it out.

>>25623069
Sounds good.
What are you waiting for?

>>25623069
You sound perfect.
You could be the next nips, why do you deny us?

>>25623076
1. Check your upload speeds.
2. if >1500, download obs
3. set upstream to <1500
4. copy and paste your stream key
5. press stream button.

>>25618563
I didn't think anyone actually gave a shit about my stuff in /moon/. I mean...that's where REAL writers write. I'll come back to those threads someday, I promise. I'm not going anywhere until the ride ends.

>>25623076
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8NX4sDHHN1w

Stream is up.

https://picarto.tv/HappyHorseAdventures

File: 1447053336111.png (169KB, 587x523px) Image search: [Google]

169KB, 587x523px

Treads is a dirty, greasy pone.

>>25623249
:(

File: file.png (228KB, 540x648px) Image search: [Google]

228KB, 540x648px

>>25623249
She needs to be punished.

>>25623069
I was the exact same way when I started out. I felt like I was going to have a heart attack when I made my first thread. But I kept going and did my best. And even though I still don't think I'm much good, I found players who truly enjoyed my CYOA for what it was.
If I can do it, you can do it too!

>>25623249
She's too far into her delusions to do anything about it.

CYOA

SUCKS

Pone

BALLS

>>25623449
>>25623458
>>25623468
>>25623469

That being said, which CYOA pone would you suck the balls of?

>>25623490
All of them.
I would keep them all clean and unburdened.

Not everybody likes dicks you know

>>25623490
Better question is which ones wouldn't I suck.

>>25623490
Any of them.
CYOA ponies need some loving for once, so they can forget about their troubles for a good hour.
Five minutes if you are Gar

>>25623507
Can't wait for the gayfags to bombard this with ironic shitposting responses because fuck being creative.

>>25623521
What about the mares then? Suck their teats?

>>25623592
Suck their clits

>>25623592
if horsland was fem-dominant then woulod this be a common phrase?
>"come help me with thing"
>"oh suck my teats bitch"

>>25623592
or rail them.
CYOA pones are for sexual, because they really need the stress relief

Alchemy continues >>25623661

Nips apparently spends all his time helping the less fortunate, except for when he's updating CYOA, won't open up a patreon, doesn't take comissions, states he doesn't get a ton of sleep...

Anyone else gettin' really concerned about him?

>>25623740
No, he's a grown up boy and he can take his own decisions.

>>25623740
does he have a tumblr? ill give him shekels

>>25623769
He has a tumblr, but no way to give him shekels.

He barely opens commissions.

>>25623769
Newfriend pls

>>25623769
>not knowing he has a tumblr

>>25623769
mcsweezy.tumblr.com

Got the best lewds in the fandom. No anthro, all of the non-shit-tier fetishes there are.

>>25623805
>all this implying

>>25623805
Uhh...

File: thanks for helping me open that mayonnaise bro.png (56KB, 541x238px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 541x238px

>>25623525
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________heh

>>25623091
>>25623146

Okay, currently screwing around with the settings and trying to figure out complex advanced problems like "Why does the color white show up as black?" and "How do I get rid of the infinite recursive windows when checking the stream?", but for now I guess I'm ready to take a crack at this.

https://picarto.tv/FailureCentral

>>25622517
>implying I don't waste my days in front of computer screen

>>25623069
Numerous ideas.
Utter shit at everything.
I keep my CYOA to improve and because I still have fun running it. I desperately need fun.

Try, bro.

File: shiggy in 2015.png (257KB, 367x338px) Image search: [Google]

257KB, 367x338px

>>25623805
>no anthro
>best lewds
calm down shilly

>>25624065
he drew anthro a few times

>>25624080
exactly

>>25623884
>FailureCentral
Oh that is hysterical

>>25623844
>Their dicks are almost the same size
Poor Blitz

>>25624248
This is after they meet back up. That's Gar's bat dick.

>>25624270
>Blitz's dick is the size of a bat's
wew. Bet Eve is happy

>>25623740
>Let's circlejerk over him guys :(

i'm >>25621822
which of these concepts sounds better?
>Earth quest- you along with several other equestrian abductees must survive a hostile alien landscape and find a way to return to your homeland, hounded at every turn by your captors, bizarre monsters and mad machinery.

or

>Shard search- you are a newborn homonculus, survive the wild, escape your maker, evade the guards and tangle with a centuries old conspiracy against the nation to collect the legendary philosophers shards to reforge the one item capable of restoring your memories and true form. The Philosophers Stone.

>>25624422
yes