Do we all agree that this is the best America?

The stubborn fucks refused to industrialize when it was taking the world by storm, and eventually fought a war over it. Their decisions are one of the biggest reasons the South is an underdeveloped pit today.

>>71066254
If they were the best, they'd exist.

lol it's the shittiest fucking america. only idolized by people on this board, the people that actually live there aswell.

The south sucks. Texas is cool but they aren't even the real south. The rest is a shithole. Except maybe Louisiana

They are DEFINITELY not.

>>71066254
I agree. WASP are the bests, piss off niggers.

File: William Tecumseh Sherman.jpg (908KB, 2364x3000px) Image search: [Google]

908KB, 2364x3000px

>>71066254
No

>>71066772


this a thousand times.

>>71069282
>Except maybe Louisiana
No.

>>71066772
Smart post

>>71069318
thatis the most niggerish region though

>>71066254
The South is actually not that bad. And I say this as someone from the "civilized" Northeast. There are definitely plenty of things that are better down there.

>>71069362
haven't been there desu but i love me gumbo

>>71066772
>>71069360
>>71069388
He's obviously not referring to the actual historical CSA you fucking idiots

holy autism

>>71069644
Fuck off limey.
It's the shittest region in our country this is coming from a midwesterner.

>>71069731
don't care

>>71069644

Fuck off limey.
It's the shittest region in our country this is coming from a midwesterner

>>71069760
Fuck off limey.
It's the shittest region in our country this is coming from a midwesterner

>>71066254
Yes, anyone who says otherwise is a non-white subhuman.

>>71069989
of course a bogan in the desert would appreciate the absolute nothingness that is the south

>>71070023
We have a perfectly decent population density and many major cities, I'm sure what you're so butthurt about.

You should kill yourself if you think the south ISN'T the worst part of the US. Absolute garbage filled with subhuman rednecks. Inb4 >a fucking leaf

>>71069644
Fuck off limey.
It's the shittest region in our country this is coming from a midwesterner.

>>71070186
>demands not to be called a fucking leaf
>has generic shitty leaf opinions

>>71069769
>>71069820
>>71070222
Sometimes I forget that this place is full of literal teenagers, thanks for reminding me.

>>71070155
Sure
If you think an entire country can run solely on producing cotton :^)


>>71070186
A
FUCKING
LEAF

>>71070295
What does that even mean? Why does everybody always act like it's the mid-19th century in these threads?

>>71070245
I actually love America, contrary to other leafs, not generic opinion at all. I just acknowledge that the south is Brazil tier trash.

>>71070291
Oh I'm sorry. You expected a stimulating and mature discussion on a website made for weebs and manchildren.

Well keep up the good fight Internet soldier. Don't let some shitposting derail your need for intellectual discussion

>>71070377
Okay

>>71070488
>it's okay that I'm a stupid fucking shitposter that doesn't contribute anything to discussions because this is le anime website
Just fucking no. Fuck off, go back to /b/ or wherever it is you came from.

>>71070559
>>71070291
t. riggered

The premise of this thread was a meme anyway. The CSA lasted what, 4 years and got totally fucked.

>>71070559

I'm sorry but you don't have the power to decide who posts here or the amount of interest that we put in our replies.

>>71070559
Seems you have derailed the discussion. I'm wondering who should really reevaluate their end game

>>71070377
have you ever been there, or are you basing your opinion on hearsay?

No.

It was never even an America, the American government never legitimized their efforts and they lost the war so they never earned legitimacy.

And even if they were an "America" they still would be the fucking worst.

Holy shit what a nigger

Go back to fucking /pol/

>>71070623
This thread isn't about the fucking CSA. What is with this fucking northern obsession with making everything Dixie-related about the Civil War? If I posted the flag of Bavaria and asked if people thought it was best Germany would people start rattling off about how shit they think the historical Kingdom of Bavaria was? What is it with fucking Yankeee and being utterly unable to advance any discourse with us beyond the 1860s?

>>71070773
>posts Confederate battle flag
>says this isn't about the Confederacy

This is why everyone calls racists conservatives fucking retarded.

Because you're all fucking retarded.

>>71070719
>the American government never legitimized their efforts
Forcing the states that seceded to be "re-admitted" to the Union wasn't acknowledging the legitimacy of their secession? Why would they need to be re-admitted if secession wasn't legitimate?

>>71070773
The original image is the CSA's flag. The country that existed for all of 4 years during the American civil war. How is it not about the civil war? You need to kill yourself TODAY buddy.

File: Pepe Packs a Punch.png (123KB, 785x757px) Image search: [Google]

123KB, 785x757px

>>71066772
Holy shit Nigeria bringing the heat.

The only not shitty parts of the south are Virginia and North Carolina. Even then, both of these states are actually Mid-Atlantic, not southern.

>>71070819
It's not the flag of the Confederacy, it's the flag of the South. It may have origins in the Civil War but that doesn't mean that it solely represents a historical state that existed two centuries ago. Do you also think that a German waving their city's flag at a soccer game is displaying patriotism for a historical city state in the Holy Roman Empire? I'm genuinely curious how deep this cultural ignorance goes.

>>71070835
"re-admitted"

"re-admitted" he says

Holy shit guy, who handled your education, the fucking Klan? The states that made up the Confederacy were never removed from the Union. Shit, they still had congressmen serving in the House and Senate during the war.

Holy fuck you're dumb.

>>71070835
Because it was a measure forcing them to accept the amendments to the current Constitution and punishment for treason

>>71066772
nigeria is on speed again :D

File: Flag_of_the_Confederate_States_of_America_(July_1861_–_November_1861).svg.png (14KB, 810x450px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 810x450px

>>71070864
The original image is the battle flag of the army of northern Virginia, this was the national flag of the Confederate States of America, retard

>>71071016
Mid-Atlantic is a made up fairy tale region pushed by Northern transplants, it's not a thing. Dixie doesn't stop being Dixie just because a few government workers decide to move here.

>>71071020
No. No it isn't. This is the battle flag for the Confederate Army of Tennessee you uneducated fucking mong.

Here, some source:

http://www.moc.org/collections-archives/flags-confederacy

>>71070864
see
>>71070864

>>71071112
Autism.

>>71071119
Which is commonly accepted by the people of the South to be its symbol. There you go again with being hung up on shit that happened in the 1800s.

File: ok fucknob.jpg (82KB, 1185x628px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 1185x628px

>>71071031
see filename

File: 1200px-Census-2000-Data-Top-US-Ancestries-by-County.svg.png (656KB, 1200x890px) Image search: [Google]

656KB, 1200x890px

>>71066254
Wether you like it or not, it is objectively true that Dixie is the best part of America, on the principle that it is the most American.

The North is made of a mass of "Cuckistani-Americans" (no ethnically-identified Americans, just immigrant groups) and no culture that they truly credit to their own soil.

Sure, claim that the South is poor (which then can't be used against Texans, Floridians, Virginians, and such) but wealth will ebb and flow. The American Southerner has the most American heart.

>>71071020
If the origin of the South's symbol is the flag of a shameful government and used for decades as the symbol of racist organizations than the South chooses to associate itself with that.

The flag of Bavaria doesn't carry that baggage while the Nazi flag does.

>>71069282
>The south sucks. Texas is cool but they aren't even the real south.
Lies, we are Southern.

>>71071190
He's totally correct, if you want to represent the CSA, choose at least one of the three National Banners, if you want the South as a cultural identity, choose the Dixie Cross or Bonnie Blue.

>>71071218
>some taiwanese OP is supposed to make a distinction between things Americans themselves disagree about

This thread is obviously talking about the CSA, that is the only thing people around the world will think when they see that flag. Even some Americans only think about it.

>>71071226
Stop this shit. We're not "the most American", that doesn't mean anything and it downplays the unique nature of our own culture. We're Southern, Yankees are Yankees, and whatever you call people from the West are that.

>>71066254
Yes. The south is my favourite.

>>71071031
your wifes boyfriend voted for bernie, didn't he?

>>71071335
Thank you for invoking Godwin's Law this early, this discussion wasn't going anywhere anyway.

>>71071226
>"""AMERICAN CULTURE"""

The Appalachia is basically Scot-Irish migrants.

>>71071370
Our unique brand is the most American out of them all.
Stop being an absolutist who can't understand the dynamic, if your culture followed the most straight and true path with the least foreign influence, you'd be the most American, this doesn't make you less Southern.

>>71071335
>If the origin of the South's symbol is the flag of a shameful government and used for decades as the symbol of racist organizations than the South chooses to associate itself with that.
reality check: this is true with literally every western national flag in existence. Stop being so butthurt about cloth you fucking child.

>>71071428
>Brings up comparison to Germany to invite
>Attempts to delegitimize an argument because one of the more appropriate comparisons to Nazi Germany

Kek, try again idiot

>>71066254
No, and taiwan is false rebels

>>71071435
That's the point, the Scotch-Irish came and evolved, their Second Person Plural "ye aw" turned into "y'all", the accent morphed into Southern American Dialect, and they didn't just stay "Scotch-Irish-Americans" they developed their own unique identity and a identifiable "American".

>>71071584
There is no such thing as an "appropriate comparison to Nazi Germany", in fact it's basically just shorthand for a retard that can't argue with anything but emotive ignorant bullshit.

YEEHAWW BUCKLE UP BUCKAROOS THE SOUTHS GONNA RISE AGAIN

File: 1457877480649.jpg (41KB, 510x320px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 510x320px

>>71071584
>appropriate comparisons to Nazi Germany
do you really think this? Sort yourself out, lad.

>>71071528
Least, it's mostly just trying to pass of foods invented by slaves and Scots as American and your ignorance to this is pathetic

>>71071550
No, real national flags are used continuously by all groups of a society yet the Confederate flag has persisted as a symbol of white supremacists first and foremost and is controversial in the region it's supposedly representing.

>>71071712
*Proceeds to die from diabetes

>>71069282
russian expert

>>71069282
>Except maybe Louisiana

>muh hurricane gibs me dat
>muh French ancestry
>muh swamps

Autism: The thread

>>71071682
>>71071739
The shameful history of the South stands on its own. Your call of Godwin's law is like Trump's whines of fake news. Go drown in a swamp

The south is so fucking based

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYnBzC7YhNg

>>71071759
>the Confederate flag has persisted as a symbol of white supremacists first and foremost and is controversial in the region it's supposedly representing.
yeah but where's your argument, all you're doing is saying "I DON'T LIKE THING". Why should anybody in the South care if you don't like thing, if the flag represents their culture and identity to them then why should they care what you, an outsider decides to tell them what it actually represents? There are loads of people here who think the English flag is a racist symbol, does that actually mean it is? No.

File: kkkdc3.jpg (45KB, 480x320px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 480x320px

>>71071759
The battle flag is a symbol of defiance. When the Klan was at its peak in the 1920s, they waved the stars and stripes, not the battle flag
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5u1QARlCph0

>>71071884
>I hate Southerners because I think they are ignorant people who hate cultures different from their own and hating other cultures is wrong
>go fucking die
Do you realize how fucking ass-backwards your entire worldview is?

>>71071759
>Least, it's mostly just trying to pass of foods invented by slaves and Scots as American and your ignorance to this is pathetic
And you speak a language coming from 3,500 BC from modern-day Ukraine, and call it English.
You say I'm ignorant, but I live this. I think culture is too foreign a concept for you.

>>71071911
Because a significant portion Southerners do not accept the symbol as their symbol, so it's not truly a symbol of the South.

Can we all agree with what we know know that the South was actually right all along? The mud races are barbaric and should have stayed slaves.

>>71072023
Yeah no, fuck off
http://www.cnn.com/2015/07/02/politics/confederate-flag-poll-racism-southern-pride/
and this is AFTER the Charleston tragedy and subsequent media shilling.

>>71072023
If I type "flag of the South" into Google all I get is Confederate Battle Flags and South African flags, so it doesn't really seem like that matters.

absolutely, they are actual normal people who could form a country of their own as opposed to spoiled bitches in high horses who ride on the back of the empire

in a couple of centuries when the american empire falls, the american southeast will be all that remains

File: 1444720290853.jpg (8KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 250x250px

>The South wants Jim crow
>The left attacks state rights

>California wants sanctuary cities
>The left supports state rights

Make up your mind lefties

>>71072132
Excellent post

Have a (y'all), my friend

File: 1483254113462.jpg (66KB, 689x600px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 689x600px

>>71071884
Holy shit you come off as a retard.

File: 2000px-Flag_of_Cascadia.svg.png (86KB, 2000x1200px) Image search: [Google]

86KB, 2000x1200px

>>71066254
No

>>71071759
nigger

>>71072181
Jim Crow was clearly unconstitutional and the federal government was completely right to put a stop to it.

t. Possibly the most militantly pro-South person ITT

File: 1484438705678.png (3MB, 1911x1080px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1911x1080px

>>71072247
found the cuck

File: 10045600033450.jpg (91KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]

91KB, 800x600px

Look at my license plate and fuck off plebs.

>>71072181
You ought not to defend Jim Crow, that's not exactly our most defensible position.

>>71066254
Definitely the best flag at least.

File: OVER THE LINE.jpg (6KB, 166x231px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 166x231px

>>71072288
>Unconstitutional

"separate but equal"

>>71072406
There is literally nothing wrong with segregation of the races

>>71072331
kek

File: 1484581940066.gif (147KB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]

147KB, 480x270px

>>71072181
>>71072485
>>71072519

The south shall rise again!

File: 1485104777798.jpg (65KB, 626x626px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 626x626px

>>71072485
>Separate but equal
>wasn't equal
Sorry but this wasn't going to be something we would win. Not to mention forcing nigs to go to exclusively nig schools keeps the few good ones from being successful.

File: 1439950878018.gif (93KB, 100x132px) Image search: [Google]

93KB, 100x132px

>>71072618

>>71071031
>gets BTFO by purely logical argument
>U R DUMB!!!!!

>>71066254
This is the part of the country that 90% of negative American stereotypes come from. If they were their own shithole of a country it would make my day.

File: South_Carolina_Sovereignty-Secession_Flag.svg.png (44KB, 700x418px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 700x418px

Fuck Virginia. Virginian cowardice kept us from marching on DC and forcing Lincoln to recognize our independence after we whipped yankee tail at Bull Run.

>>71071057
Readmitting them acknowledges that they did, in fact, leave the union

>>71072618
And we never would have gotten the most based SCOTUS judge of all time after Scalia.

>>71071984
>Waved the stars and stripes
And so did their opponents, notice the distinction?

>>71072106
That supports his argument. If only 57% can accept "their" symbol than its not a very good symbol.

>>71072201
>>71071989
The retards are the ones that invite comparisons to Nazi Germany intentionally by bringing up Germany city flags at soccer games then act as though they magically win an argument because they have "Godwin's law". It's a hollow bait tactic similar to the ones used by Russians in Crimea need "proofs". The propaganda attempts are hollow and pathetic.

File: confederate pepe.jpg (125KB, 899x889px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 899x889px

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YAfHigPsC_s

>>71073134
Wow, I had no idea that using Germany in literally any example is intentionally baiting people to sperg out about Nazis, really makes you think. It just so happens that Germany has always had a strong regionalist streak, and regional flags are extremely common there even today, which made them a good example when speaking of regional flags. You know what just kill yourself, I'm fine with opposing views on the rebel flag but you shouldn't be backing up that ignorant dumbshit.

>>71072891
Fuck you, the war would have been over in a year without us.

File: CSA are our mates.jpg (140KB, 314x903px) Image search: [Google]

140KB, 314x903px

They're our lads.

>>71073625
>I'm fine with opposing views on the rebel flag but you shouldn't be backing up that ignorant dumbshit.
See
>>71071989

File: 1447501312032.png (100KB, 251x238px) Image search: [Google]

100KB, 251x238px

>>71073134
>the ones that invite comparisons to Nazi Germany intentionally by bringing up Germany city flags at soccer games
>It's a hollow bait tactic similar to the ones used by Russians in Crimea need "proofs".
>propaganda attempts
what the fuck am I reading, are you literally insane?

File: Seriouslookingblackguyholdinga_phone.jpg (21KB, 384x384px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 384x384px

>>71073699
Anon, he was telling me to go drown in a swamp and calling me a racist, not disagreeing with me about a flag.

>>71073819
And I was told off myself for defending a transparent derailment of an argument so you guys could attack the character of the arguer instead.

>>71073697
What the fuck. I don't know what is more surprising, that France and Mexico fought a war or that there were Dixiefags fighting under Napoleon III.

>>71073940
>seriously continuing with this "mentioning Germans waving city flags at soccer games is an invitation to call people Nazis" line of argument
Take your meds you fucking spastic. Jesus christ this is retarded.

>>71073940
yeah, because that's retarded and you're obviously a complete nutter

>>71074119
>>71073749
It's not, it is was transparent bait. It wasn't a sensible argument for it being the southern flag because no one argued against regionalism represented by historic entities. The point was specifically about who it was used by and why and most German city states weren't controversial entities.

>>71073940
Don't defend severely retarded people then?

>>71074306
>>71074196
Name calling children
>>>/out/

>>71074407
Name calling children? You're defending calling people Nazis in online discussions because somehow mentioning Germany in any context is "transparent bait" to do so. If you don't want to be called names don't act like such a trousers-on-head, running around in the classroom making firetruck noises, eating paste full-on paranoid illogical retard.

>>71074589
>The flag of Bavaria doesn't carry that baggage while the Nazi flag does.
Is
>Calling people Nazis

You really need better reading comprehension.

>>71074290
>it was transparent bait
No it wasn't, not even in the slightest. It was a sincere argument about the South's right to regional symbols based on another country I have visited and have personal experience in. These are the sort of arguments that people tend to make on fucking international culture boards. if you've really progressed so far down the path of being an obnoxious shitposter that you actually think people that even mention other countries are somehow baiting you then please go back to /b/ and act like a faggot there. Now fuck off, I shan't be giving you anymore (You)s

>>71074741
Why the fuck would you ever even contemplate comparing the Confederate flag to the flag of the Third Reich though? Why is Nazi Germany even involved in this discussion at all? What the actual fuck is wrong with you?

>>71074844
>people tend to make on fucking international culture boards
If you can not see how making a comparison such as

Confederate battle flag is to German city flag

directly invites things like:

Republic of West Florida Flag is to Confederate Battle as
Bavaria is to Nazi Germany

Than I don't see you being involved in many highbrow arguments they don't eventually derail.

>>71066254

A rogue state that got its shit kicked in? I don't think so.

File: 14823941689.jpg (30KB, 500x375px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 500x375px

>>71075130
>Republic of West Florida Flag is to Confederate Battle as Bavaria is to Nazi Germany

>>71075273
See
>>71074407

File: 16602601_212636465875679_2008352168917238498_n.jpg (19KB, 465x401px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 465x401px

>>71074589
>don't act like such a trousers-on-head, running around in the classroom making firetruck noises, eating paste full-on paranoid illogical retard.
British banter is the best

File: 1484759924536.png (371KB, 700x518px) Image search: [Google]

371KB, 700x518px

This thread is even worse of a shitpile than I thought it would be. Literally every post is either some Civil War LARPer or triggered commie crying about the OP image. I would love to actually discuss my culture with people so it's a shame that you can't even mention this place on /int/ without a gorillion people getting butthurt. I can't believe Americans make fun of yuros for being hung up on history and then are able to turn around a create the awful stream of fucking stupid diarrhea that is this thread. Amazing.

The deep south is absolute trash

>>71075702
>>71075825
Kill yourselves Yankee scum

>>71075702
What kind of pickup truck do you own?

File: 012.png (89KB, 500x573px) Image search: [Google]

89KB, 500x573px

>>71075702
I made a relevant post here >>71072132
but you ignored it because of my flag, like everyone else

>>71075971
I just have a crappy used car at the moment but in the future I will definitely save up for a Ford F-150 so that I can be a true aristocratic Southern gentleman.
>inb4 somebody tells me it's shit
I don't know anything about cars.

>>71076036
Thank you, Colombiabro. This place would just be hot Poland if it was ever independent, but yes I think we will outlive everybody else though sheer stubbornness.

>>71066772
Based Nigeria.