I'm tired please just behave yourselves no shitflinging
Previous: >>174920624
NEWS
>New game domains registered: http://personacentral.com/potential-persona-5-spin-off-website-domains-registered-including-p5d-p5u/
>English P5 DLC schedule: http://personacentral.com/persona-5-dlc-scheduled-announced-english-release/
>Next major event announced for August 2nd: http://personacentral.com/large-scale-persona-live-event-announced-august-2-2017/
>New Persona games to be announced 2017: http://personacentral.com/atlus-to-announce-several-games-in-2017-includes-the-persona-series/
>New Atlus studio "Studio 0" to create new RPG named Project Re Fantasy: http://personacentral.com/atlus-project-re-fantasy-concept-video-site-update/
>Persona 20th Anniversary radio CD announced: http://personacentral.com/persona-20th-anniversary-radio-cd-detailed/
INFO
>P5 Info
pastebin.com/MJuR9h0S
GUIDES
>General Guide
pastebin.com/eCHRjKCZ
>PQ Guide
pastebin.com/Bq16HvJh
>P4U2 Guide/Resources
pastebin.com/M3MPepKb
DOWNLOADS
>Art, Guides, Music, etc.
pastebin.com/Vh0CdRit
>P4 Dengeki Comic Anthology
mediafire.com/?4kjjaf0jtw2jyj3
>Persona Image Collection
mediafire.com/?9j3us2v34coua
>Persona 5 Resources
pastebin.com/CZEvEgiE
MANGA
>Scans
personascans.tumblr.com
mediafire.com/personascans#unst48ukbu457
pastebin.com/L3WXvsf3
>Send calling card
>See this
What do?
>>174937578
Destroy everything
I've never actually traversed much of the Palace on calling card day with 99% security, are there any actual changes other than the music?
>tfw you'll never romance the twins
I'd rather have the early Makotofag then a fucking Ryuji thread
>>174943520
Mooks spot you easier and Chase you farther. Haven't noticed a huge change in what spawns on you.
Phantom is from Sumaru City!
Moonlight Fuuka.
>>174943791
become prime minister plz!!
>>174944081
i can still enjoy them regardless
>severe lack of get smoked hat memes
What are /pg/'s favourite non-vocal P5 tracks?
I loved Kaneshiro's palace music
https://youtu.be/MnHqMeGR-rE
>>174944098
>>174944098
>>174944098
Go to an actually fresh thread and not one that's been autosaged to hell
>>174944314
Who do I stay faithful to in 2nd play through? I chose Makoto first time around.
>>174944360
We're not autosaged
>>174944342
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MtQfg5ktK6M
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ql9FDMNWJeE
>>174944397
this one is ridiculously well made
I ASK THAT YOU CAST YOUR VOTES FOR ME
>>174944342
Layer Cake (Airsoft Shop Music)
https://youtu.be/IwPZWVEDZxk
Ultimax edgemaster clothes when
>>174944098
>>174944098
>>174944098
Leave this thread. It should've been deleted ages ago but he just kept it alive.
Why does Lone Prayer fit P5 battles so much better than it does P1
>>174944314
It finally hit me anons...
Why I dont like Ann aside as a bro.
>shit acting
>not really funny
>sorta annoying
>blond
>airhead
She's fucking Dee the bird girl from Sunny in Philadelphia.
So when are they going to actually top Battle for Everyone's Souls? Is it just impossible to match it for a final boss?
What Confidantes/SL would (You) be able to max with your IRL proficiency/charm/knowledge/kindness/guts?
Do you have enough kindness for Futaba? Do you have the guts to ask Tae out and make Iwai your bro? Are you knowledgeable for hifumi or Makoto?
Go watch Gundam 0079 y'all
Shido did nothing wrong.
Lets do somesubjectiverating
>Plot
3>5>4
>Mechanics
5>4>3
>Music
3>4>5
>Main party
5>4>3
>Social Links
5>4>3
>Final boss
3>5>4
Adachi>Ikutski>Goro
Ichiko Ohya is the Mike Conley Jr. of Persona General. All of the talent but none of the credit. If any of you fucking disasters of human beings had a fraction of the heart or class that Ichiko has she'd be topping the polls and getting her own "Get Smoked" hat edits.
Doesn't matter though. I'll spend my whole life repping for the low life. Take that for data.
>>174944728
>Are you knowledgeable for hifumi or Makoto?
Not even once which is sad because I love Makoto
>>174944728
>What Confidantes/SL would (You) be able to max with your IRL proficiency/charm/knowledge/kindness/guts?
whatever ones dont have some sort of gate
>>174944750
>Music
>3>4>5
I DIDN'T KNOW PEOPLE HAD TASTE THIS SHIT
>>174944721
I demand Charlie and Mack as MC and Ryuji and the other one can be autism boy.
>>174944725
H I P S
>>174944314
>>174944728
Sojiro, Futaba, Yusuke, Iwai, and Taro.
Perfect.
I never felt like
>>174944406
Need more edits like this.
>>174944314
>>174944750
Agreed with all but I'd switch music 3>5>4 and social links 5>3>4
>>174944750
I agree with everything you posted except
>Plot
4>5>>3. P3 plot was absolute dogshit until like the last quarter of the game.
>>174944750
Lets do some subjective rating
>Plot
4>5>3
>Mechanics
5>4>3
>Music
5>4>3
>Main party
5>4>3
>Social Links
4>5>3
>Final boss
3>4>5
Adachi>Ikutski>Goro (Agreed)
>>174944681
thread wars are stupid anon, just accept defeat
>>174944728
Apparently Haru, being Proficient in tango lost me my v-card back in high school
The collectors edition is fucking shit
Gonna repost this in hopes that someone has the English files for this part:
It's in ps3.cpk/field/f002_010/init/fini_002_010.bf
https://pastebin.com/qMQBparZ
>>174944729
Already watched. Go watch Unicorn.
What kind of manga do you think Makoto likes?
>>174944948
>OP wants to keep his thread for maymays
I've already reported you for rule violations
>>174944935
The only good part of P3 was the final boss
>>174944314
I want that hat
>>174944908
>social links 5>3>4
I always find it hard to place 3's social links in the rankings because there's a small number that are GOAT (Hermit, Sun, Devil for example) and then the bulk of them are so forgettable and dull. It throws off the curve.
I searched... makes no sense.
>>174945005
>24/7 wet for justice
do you have to ask?
So about these Goro events that happen around town. I had heard about the one at the bread shop in the station, and I was able to get that one (I'm on NG+ and in the timeframe for Kaneshiro's dungeon).
I've also heard about the one where some fangirls are stalking him or something and I'm sure there are others. Does anyone know details as to any of these events (timeframe, what happens, etc.)?
>>174945005
Hotblooded shit.
>>174944750
>Opening theme
5>P3P>P3>P4>3FES
>Battle theme
5>3=4>4G
>Boss theme
4>5>3
>Final boss theme
3>>>>5>4
>City bgms and calm music
5>4>3
>>174945005
Makoto would be a jojofag
What if you got back from Ryuji's house one day with Mona, and go back up to your comfy attic home, and Anne is.. just sitting there?
You try to get her to say something, or do something, but she just stares at you. She's like a statue.
So after you realize that there's no way you're getting her out of your house, you go to bed. You figure you might as well deal with it in the morning.
So you lie down, turn off the lights, and you just hear sobbing.
>Joker... Why is Ryuji more popular than me?
What do?
>>174944728
Despite really liking Hifumi and Makoto, I consider myself actually a moron so I think I wouldn't be able to tread those waters.
I'm not a mongoloid, so I think I'm kind enough for Ann, maybe? And my proficiency ain't too shabby, so Haru's an OK.
>>174944750
>Plot
5>3>4
>Mechanics
5>4>3
>Music
5>3>4
>Main party
5>3>4
>Social Links
5>4>3
>Final boss
3>5>4
Goro>Adachi>Ikutsuki
>>174945060
>there's a small number that are GOAT
that and the fact that majority of p4 s.links are booty imo place it higher by default. all of 5's were god tier though
>>174944314
>>174945091
>goro events
Elaborate
So what is /pg/'s opinion on writefaggotry? I kinda want to defictionalize Mishima's hypothetical book on the Phantom Thieves. Shit like Ace Combat Zero has made me really love the whole documentary/recollection format for stories.
>>174945005
Baribari Densetsu because motorcycles.
>>174945005
Hajime no Ippo, JoJo, Boku no Hero
And cheesy shoujo romance that she's really embarrassed about
>>174944314
>>174945113
This anon gets it.
>>174945156
Battle for Everyone's Souls is overrated as fuck
>>174945182
Events where you can see him around town, talk to him and then he leaves. For the breadshop one I mentioned, he basically just talks to Joker about the stuff that's been going on lately, tells him to be careful and asks if he needs anything, you get to reply to him and then some fangirls see him and he leaves.
>>174944750
>Plot
2>5>3>1>4
>Mechanics
5>4>3>1>2
>Music
3>1>5>2>4
>Main Party
2>5>3>1>4
>Social links
5>4>3
>Final Boss
2>3>5>4>1
Goro> Kandori > Ikutsuki > Adachi
>>174945214
Makoto would probably love it when Deku goes full Madman.
>>174945214
She has pretty good taste
Is there any way to raise charm during the daytime besides the 1 point fruit drink thing at the diner? ohya is night only and the bath too
Threadly claim
>>174945060
Hermit was garbage. People only like it because it's Toriumi but it doesn't change the fact that fucking nothing happens in it and you just sit and watch her type like a retard for 10 ranks.
>>174944728
I have enough of a few stats to befriend my waifus but not to ask them out
I have enough cash for Chihaya I guess
>Other thread deleted
Looks like making a thread early as shit was right all along. I'll be sure to make one right when we hit 700 next time.
>>174945365
You can go to the miedo cafe in Akihabara
>>174944925
>P3 plot was absolute dogshit until like the last quarter of the game
I felt that way about 4 more than 3, even with 5 to an extent. Most of those you're dealing with individual palaces/dungeons while kind of getting close to the main problem then you hit the last one and its PLOT PLOT PLOT.
3 had the benefit of weaving the SEES members stories rather than sequestering them away in SLinks though, so that helped fill up the dead space a bit. Mostly I liked that you knew well in advance what your final challenge would be, rather than having the final boss revealed in the very closing hours. 5 was for sure better about it than 4 though.
>>174945060
I still wanna fuck Toriumi
>>174945365
Movies, games, books
>>174945371
>the most significant thing that happened in the entirety of Toriumi's SL was the flag for Tanaka
>>174945405
Check to see if we already have thread next time, autismo. It's not a contest.
>>174945405
Since this one wasn't deleted there was no point in making one.
it's ok anon
>>174944314
>>174945437
She's hotter than Kawakami.
>>174945353
The question will wich jojo is her favourite favourite villain and favourite part
>>174944797
>>174945145
Same. Makoto motivated me to start studying more.
>>174945461
>>174945484
No, it just shows me that rules are enforced on an inconsistent basis. Thus, I have no reason to follow them if they're going to be applied unequally.
>>174945160
>Plot
2>5>1>3>4
>Mechanics
5>4>2>3>1
>Main Party
2>5>3>1>4
>Social Links
5>4>3
>Final Boss
3>2>5>4>1
Jun>Goro>Ikutsuki>Adachi.
>>174945365
Books, movies and DVDs, the answer is always book movies and DVDs.
>>174945060
I liked Hanged Man and her divorce plot, I forgot what Arcana the old couple was but they're great. I kinda liked Pharos and Ryoji too
Liz is great as honorable social link along with aigis
>>174945405
This isn't a contest you utter retard.
>>174944314
>>174945659
Ok OP
:^)
>>174945365
Buy books
Rent DVDs
Borrow Books from the library (you can read them in there too)
>>174944725
Can't be topped since that final boss uses the leitmotif of the best track in the entire series.
>>174945618
>Persona 1 and 2
Stop making things up
>>174945306
i didn't really like goro overall but i really did enjoy every time he came into the cafe and you get to talk to him a little. if there's more idle talk time in it then i'm game.
>>174945685
>tfw Makoto will never give you an attitude adjustment
>>174945113
Mostly agree, except P3's Iwatodai dorm theme is GOAT. Worth ranking up just for that alone.Also Burn My Dread along with its remixes is the best song in the series in general
>>174945715
>>174945608
>>174945405
Go to sleep anon
>>174944314
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-hxN7HXsSGk
>>174945685
>tfw someone saved my shit
I need more fivehead Haru images.
>>174945608
This is literal child's tantrum material anon, grow the fuck up.
>>174944876
DA DA DA DA DA
>>174945091
respondwhenyouseethis.jpeg
>>174945893
hottest bae
>>174944314
>>174945815
FUCK OFF MORGANA
do you agree, /pg/?
So in terms of boobs:
>P3
Mitsuru> Yukari>Fuuka
If you count Aigis, then behind Mitsuru
>P4
Naoto>Rise>Yukiko>Chie
>P5
Haru>Ann>Makoto>Futaba
Im not sure about Yukiko/Rise and Haru/Ann though
>>174945643
The only things I remember about Aeon is how they tried to stack homosexuality fears on top of Aigis being a robot in P3P which ended up being hilarious when it really shouldn't have
>>174945807
>Burn My Dread along with its remixes is the best song in the series in general
It was, right up until we got Life Will Change. I defy any of you to get into the last day of a palace run and not bob your head to that shit
>>174945837
It was a good pic
>>174945949
You said this in the last thread, fuck off
>Party member dies
>Fight carries on normally
>Can use a revival item or just wait for the end of the battle and he's right as rain again
>Main character dies
>GAME OVER MAN GAME OVER
Someone explain this to me.
>>174945815
>>174945870
>Hurr durr I was okay with Makoto threads posted early
Makotofags everyone
>no one has made an edit of the 'wow queen you're so beautiful' meme with Makoto yet
I'm disappointed in you /pg/
>>174944876
>P3 was first Persona game
>Play P4 and Arena afterwards
>Decide to play P1 and P2
>Go back to playing P3
>Wind up disappointed the pharmacy's son isn't the Satomi Tadashi Pharmacy song
Did anyone else experience this?
>>174945091
The only one I remember was talking to him at the bread shop just a bit before Kaneshiros change of heart. He mused about the case and abruptly left because girls were starting to gather. Is that the scene you meant?
As for indirect Goro events, the gay dudes in the red light district are in love with him and after medjed pretty much every young person in town talks shit about him.
>>174945943
I don't agree with cutting Makoto or Haru, but the rest of that I agree with.
I think Haru also should have had more time for development. She was pretty much the only teammate I felt I knew almost nothing about by the end of the game.
>>174945989
Because the party members since P3 are so dumb that they can't fight for themselves till someone uses Revival Bead/Balm of Life at the MC.
This dind't happen with P1/P2 tho
>>174944738
he had a rolly polly principal close enough to his inner circle that Kobayakawa knew who to rat out when he finally got squarely
the fuck was his importance to the whole scheme? Even if it's just covering your bases, it should be someone in the department of education, not a random head master
>>174944667
Soon anon, "today" some time I think
What's the best way to farm money. I'm at the end of the game and want to go into new game + with a good amount
>>174945989
The game would be fucking outrageously easy if you needed a party wipe to lose.
Like, what if something spammed Maziodyne to slay your party, but you have Ryuji so you're just invincible?
It's on YOU to equip yourself with the resistances and immunities you need to survive.
>>174945949
>Yukiko/Rise
I'd say it's correct judging by tgeir P4D models
>Haru/Ann
Ann's bigger, someone actually ripped female models to compare all sizes
>>174946004
No one ever said that idiot
now go before you make yourself look even more autistic
>>174945943
Haru definitely didn't need to exist
She was the definition of filler
>>174945989
Futaba can actually swap out characters as they die and send them to the back grow with 1 HP
>>174945989
At least there was a reason behind it in P3, no idea why they've retained it since. Or at least given us an excuse.
>>174945989
Didn't happen in P1 or P2.
>>174944314
>no MAGA hat memes
>>174945943
>cut two best girls for one gigantic faggot
>there are people who unironically think Persona 4 is the best Persona
>>174946124
That sounds like a fault of the game 2bh.
>>174945956
I was suprised about it actually
>>174946228
It's not the best but the relationship between p4 cast is just better than 5 and 3
>>174946004
>implying every one of you early thread spamming retards hasn't been the subject of scorn
no discrimination here, you're all fucking duncesyour waifu a shit
>>174946089
Agreed. I didn't even know how to initiate her SL until a week after I beat Shido.
What happens when normies try to play Persona?
Koromaru>>>>>>>Morgana=Teddie
>>174945957
Mmh, I admit, it's good. On par with Burn My Dread, though, not surpassing it.
Though it also might just have to do with my taste in music in general.
>>174946347
They'll become ironic weebs
>>174946228
It's first game bias. Persona 4 was the first Persona for a lot of people so they look back on it fondly.
That said 5>4>3
>>174946347
morgana sleep memes
>>174945949
>If you count Aigis, then behind Mitsuru
Aigis canonically has the same bust as Yukari, confirmed in P3 drama CD.
>>174946349
Absolutely.
>>174946347
They generally enjoy it, its a pretty newbie friendly series, at least from 3 onwards. Especially 5.
>>174946089
>>174946335
not to mention if you don't go deep enough into her confidant plot, it really seems like in the end she's destined to be married to a scum bag. She was even still with him during that suicide cutscene
Best weapons gotten from itemizing
Joker - Satanael (dagger), Metatron/Lucifer (gun, Metatron gives +5 to all stats but is 30 points weaker than Lucy which gives +10 to magic)
Morgana - Mother Harlot (sword), Kohryu (gun)
Ryuji - Either Thor or Hanuman, same stats but Hanuman is auto-Tarukaja and Thor gives elec attacks to melee hits. Shiva for gun
Anne - Skadi (whip), Odin (gun)
Yusuke - Yoshitsune (sword), Vasuki (gun)
Makoto - Cybele (fists), Michael (gun)
Haru - Beelzebub (axe), Baal (gun)
>>174944728
I think i'd only pass the kindness checks.
>>174946347
They get bothered by the honorifics.
>>174946487
>Beelzebub (axe)
I thought I was going to be disappointed if it wasn't the staff axe from P3 but that thing is fucking metal
>>174946089
The should have showed her more around the school. It's weird that she goes to the same school wearing a unique outfit and she doesn't exist until the end. The game felt like it ended a month too soon and she was introduced too late.
Will you buy Ann's scale?
>>174946457
Isn't that because the point where she can call it off is impossible to reach by that time?
>all the funny dialogue in P5 is clustered into one-liners in Mementos
Lame
Sub or Dub?
>>174946628
The Dub is better than P4.
>>174946628
I like Dub
>>174946626
>dialogue triggers just as I open the next gate and gets cut off
every fucking time
I was really dissapointed when the Twins GATTAI'd. Their combined form isn't nearly as good as either of them.
>>174946608
Are the boobs squishy?
>>174946608
Tempted, really like Futaba'swhich also seems to have optional parts to have her holding cat form morganathough, and we haven't even seen the prototype for Makoto's scale yet.
>>174946628
Dub was good outside of Haru and Shinya. I'm doing Jap for NG+
>>174946608
I'd definitely by Makoto's
So subjectively speaking, how would you rate the palaces/palace arcs only based on STORY alone?
For me...
Kamoshida > Futaba > Shido > Sae > Madarame > Okumura > Kaneshiro
I thought Kamoshida was the strongest as I felt like the game really began with a huge bang, and the absolute build-up of this sick fuck just made you want to take him out more and more. The atmosphere here also felt the darkest in the entire game IMO, and Ryuji and Ann (moreso Ryuji) are incredibly strong characters that are perfect as your first teammates.
As for Kaneshiro being last, his story felt too weak to me. It didn't really have a personal connection like some of the others, it just felt like you were going after some random guy with no real relevance to any of the other characters.
>>174945943
It was too obvious he was evil, should've put in some fake confidant passives like how Shinji in P3 had god hand if you ranked him up to like level 90
>>174945181
quality
>>174944994
It almost sounds like Ryuji is the Reiji except for that old man comment? Maybe that's referring to Ryuji distracting the teacher?
Though the Takashi eludes me.
>>174946608
no
>>174946757
I want them to make a scale of her hiding behind a book.
>>174946720
Sadly, no
>>174946628
I fail to comprehend why anyone would play the dub of this game. Not only it fits the narrative and thematic better to have people speaking in Japanese but the quality is also a lot better. Dub actors didn't even bother learning how to say the character's names right, enjoy having to hear "YOOUUSUUKE" for the rest of the game. Anyone who unironically prefers the dub is probably an American who just can't get the idea of having to listen to a language that isn't English into their heads.
>>174946820
Maybe in the future as afigma
>>174946608
I have figures from eroges that look less sexed up than that one does. I don't think I could display that shit.
How do I do a pre-emptive strike without raising the security level? Without doing an ambush I mean
>>174946628
Dub isn't bad. Not as good as 4, better than 3, but I'm honestly pretty tolerant of these things so if you're the type to get upset over differences you might have issues.
>>174946628
Dub, simply for Ryuji's voice actor alone. That dude is fucking fantastic.
>>174946820
why is there a blue ghost behind her
>>174946921
I think you mean EFFING fantastic.
>>174946872
Actors were told to pronounce names like these
>>174946628
Sub, obviously. What the fuck is happening in these threads? Where are all of these dubfags coming from?
>>174946769
I'd at least switch Kaneshiro with Okumura
I know he's super one note in his themeing but I think his treasure being locked in the center of a massive room that's just on big tumbler lock was a much more striking image than Okumura's space world and -NOT-Vader shadow analogue
>>174946628
I played through the dub without realizing that the Japanese audio was available as free DLC, and still enjoyed it.
Why is she so perfect?
>>174946608
if it ever goes on fucking sale I would definitely consider it
So, do the skill names mean anything? Garu, Agi, Bufu and whatnot, Hama and so on - did the devs just made those up for SMT, or do they have some meaning, or relationship to the elements?
>>174946872
I've heard that the dub pronunciations ar intentionally bad to make them flow better with the rest of the dialogue. I have no idea if it's true though and don't know phonetics to judge.
That said I like some of the meme answers and the use of kek. The localizing wasn't all that bad.
>>174946769
I'll definitely agree that Kamoshida had one of the better build ups, even stuff like being able to interact with him randomly walking the halls after class if you didn't rush to finish the palace early were nice.
>>174946769
Kamoshida > Futaba > Madarame > Sae > Shido > Okumura > Kaneshiro
I felt Sae and Madarame's arcs were more compelling than Shido's since his palace is mostly getting invitations from people important to Shido. He's just a huge asshole compared to Madarame and Sae who show traces of humanity despite having a fucked up perspective.
>>174947087
I always thought they were the japanese spell names pronounced aloud, and what they sound like in english
>>174946991
>>174947101
Why? Did the person who was in charge of the dub just decide to make it as bad as possible for no reason? Now there's someone who needs to be fired.
>>174946921
>Japanese dub is filled with great VAs
>but no play the dub for this one guy who manages to be on par with one of the Jap VAs
>FOR THE FIRST TIME SINCE THE FIRST PALACE I DON'T HAVE MAKOUGA
>EVERY SINGLE FUCKING ENCOUNTER IS TRIPLE BAPHOMETS
JUST
U
S
T
>>174947087
Elements are from Sanskrit
Megido is from bible
Can't remember Hama and Mudo
>>174947087
A lot of it is based on Sanskrit.
Megido is based on Mount Meggido.
>>174946628
I'm going dub just in case the eventual barrage of spinoffs doesn't have japanese options. I watched the P4 anime subbed before playing it and even though the english voices were ok, getting used to it was annoying.
>>174947215
I wish they'd do full white figs of them all.
Makoto x Joker
Anne x Ryuji
Futaba x Yusuke
Haru x Goro
Daily reminder that this is the optimal pairing in P5
>>174946114
Funneling talented young people towards organizations under Shido's control.
>>174947215
Can I have Justice alone?
>there are people in this thread RIGHT NOW who will date a different girl in their second playthrough
>>174947163
>Use the original which is gibberish
>Use the dub which is understandable
>>174947163
Don't get me wrong, I think all of the english VA's were amazing. I just thought Ryuji's VA stood out in particular as giving it 220% with every line he spoke.
I haven't played the jap version of the game yet, but I highly recommend the english dub. It's quite good.
>>174947215
This smells like a garage kit
>>174947251
>not Kawakami x Akira
Fuck off reddit.
>>174947289
I do full harem every game to see all the content.
>>174947317
Dude don't fucking bother there's no reasoning with these subfag weeb cocksuckers
>>174947317
>Don't get me wrong, I think all of the english VA's were amazing
Come on now.
>>174947301
But what if I know Japanese tho.
>>174944792
I guarantee the reason no one likes her is entirely because her haircut makes her head look like a fucking coconut
>>174947346
>Akira
Fuck off /v/.
>>174947317
It doesn't help your case that Ryuji's jap voice is the best in the jap version.
>>174947301
If you're here you probably understand enough that it shouldn't be gibberish to you.
>no Kaneshiro x Haru
>>174946819
>Phat! company
>1/7 scale
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>174947380
Yeah, people have opinions, isn't that crazy?
I don't even understand the big deal with the dub vs sub argument, be it video games, anime, or whatever else.
It made sense in the past as dubbing companies were atrocious, but nowadays the western VA industry has caught up to the japs, and there really is no "better" one, just preference.
>>174947435
What's wrong with that name? It's the most "official" name out there right now, although I'm sure it'll be changed in a year or so. I dunno, it's what I named my MC at least in my playthrough. Still not really sure how you pronounce that last name though.
>>174947289
>>174946067
Yeah that is the one I meant. I heard there are others like it though.
>>174945989
The whole plot is a game Yaldy set up between Goro and Joker. Joker dies, that means he loses the game and Yaldy can go ahead with fucking humanity over.
>>174946315
>It's not the best but the relationship between p4 cast is just better than 5 and 3
4 benefited from giving you plenty of time dedicated to the IT hanging out together, but while I think its exaggerated on here how bad it is it definitely devolved into stereotypical cliche anime shit way too often, mostly of the "Girls punish the boys for something they didn't do" or "Look they can't cook ha ha" variety.
5 stooped to that level a lot less (barring Ryuji and the boat) but didn't really get as much bonding either. Ann/Joker/Ryuji/Morgana get a bit in the early game, but the more people join the less we see, so poor Haru hardly get anything. Its probably better done overall than 4 but not perfect.
3 is a bit harder to judge because no one ever said SEES should be best of friends, they're thrown together by obligation and circumstance more than anything. It breaks down into little groups and pairings more than being a unified whole. I don't think this is bad actually, and wouldn't mind a dynamic like this in a future game, but it certainly not as friendly and welcoming as the others.
Persona 5 rerelease with romanceable male characters when?
>>174944725
Which DLC pack is this, and when does it come out in america?
>>174947619
hah
that's actually a good way of looking at it
>>174947592
>the western VA industry has caught up to the japs
But it's not even close. The English VA industry is fucking terrible compared to almost every other major VA industry in the world. It's embarrassing how little effort we put in.
>Does one of your Personas have telepathic abilities? This is quite a memorable gift...
>>174946628
I played first playthrough with Dub, then the second with original voices. Sae, Ryuji and Akechi were better in ENG, Sojiro on par. Rest are decent, but JPN voices just fit some characters better (Like Futaba and Haru, for example).
Either one is good, really, it's up to your preference. JPN is a bit better for atmosphere, but ENG is nice if you want to get comfy and watch cutscenes with text on auto without having to read.
Also Morgana's ENG voice doesn't sound manly or boyish at all. Coupled with the name, it was hard for me to even think of him as male. Then again, he's neither male nor female - he's cat.
>>174947123
That makes sense. I just wish they went a bit more into Madarame. Felt like he was ousted as an evil asshole too quickly without us really seeing much of what he had done, at least in comparison to coming right off of Kamoshida who we witnessed all the shit he'd been doing.
>>174947289
I actually wonder if anyone has ever completed the games without romancing someone. Maybe it even unlocks some special scene.
>>174947592
for some reason retards hate it and think joker is his name
>>174947540
Better then 1/8 and griffon or FREEing anon
>>174947671
hopefully never, fag
Why do people date Naoto in P4? It feels wrong, you're stealing Kanji's waifu.
>>174947671
Never. Unless you want to romance the rapey fag character thats in every game
>>174947251
Haru x Makoto is better t b h
>>174947289
>there are people in this thread RIGHT NOW who picked Haru Okuforheadma
>>174947705
are you fucking stupid
>>174947741
Joker is his codename, so it's the easiest unifying moniker to use.
>>174944750
>Plot
5>4>3
>Mechanics
5>4>3
>Music
4>5>3
>Main party
4>5>3
>Social Links
5>4>3
>Final boss
3>5>4
Goro>Ikutski>Adachi
>>174946705
agreed
>>174947841
Are you a delusional idiot with pathetically low standards?
>>174947705
That's just not true whatsoever. It's improved remarkably over the years. It's just up to preference at this point.
>>174947741
No one thinks that's his name. It's just his canon nickname/moniker. Manga is never canon. /pg/ doesn't call the protagonists by their manga names ever. Even P1 protag is Piercy over Naoya.
>>174947717
I'd like to imagine Sojiro chastises you for not having a girlfriend.
>>174947758
that doesn't mean it couldn't have been quality
>>174947909
>>174947284
i'll take caroline if you dont mind
>>174947785
because I'm not going to stop myself from being with the person I love only because my friend she doesn't care about has a crush on her
>>174947785
Same reason people date Mitsuru in P3 and Ann in P5. They forget about Bros before Hoes
>>174947967
I'd argue that the manga is canon until a different, official name is given forth like in P4's case. Sure there's no "true" canon name right now, but Akira happens to be the closest to canon, so I don't really see the problem in referring to him as that for now.
>>174947705
>>174947785
The is literally the only time you're legit cucking your bro in a Persona game is if you go for Naoto
>>174948042
Fucking kill yourself
>>174948071
when will people lern the difference between "official" and "canon", I wonder
>>174948071
What's wrong with Joker?
>>174948042
>Mitsuru in P3 and Ann in P5
Who was after Mitsuru?
Ann I normally wouldn't go for but that cat was getting pretty fucking creepy about it so maybe someone needs to break him out of his delusion
>>174947714
True, his crimes weren't visible but him having a palace set off a red flag to the PT. Madarame not being as obviously evil as Kamoshida is part of the strength of his arc imo because Yusuke had more reason to defend Madarame than the people at the school did for Kamoshida.
>>174948150
>>174948014
>>174948150
Ok. What's the difference?
>>174948163
Nothing at all. Joker is less of a real name and more of a code-name though. I guess some people would see it weird to call him by his PT codename, but not others?
Anybody have the picture of YHVH from SMTIVA with all the hats on?
>>174948227
>>174948014
>>174948274
>>174948083
If I was just talking about Jap VAs I would've specified the Jap industry m8. Go back to /v/
>>174948254
I request Haru fivehead pictures in return.
>>174948071
Why would you say it's canon when manga names have never been canon? Persona manga are given permission to be made but elsewise the content is done by the artist.
>>174948178
I always felt Akihiko and Mitsuru was something I didnt want to get between. Even more so than Naoto and Kanji
>>174948274
this triggers me
>>174948317
this is the best I can do
>>174948317
>no GET SMOTE
>not having each of the heads wear a different hat like autism hat and Junpei's hat
>>174948336
I never got that vibe; if anything I bet they already dated but realised it wasn't going to work out.
>>174948042
Akihiko doesn't see Mitsuru that way and vice versa.
>>174948327
Because he's a newfag who probably read his name on the wiki.
>>174948327
Because it's the closest thing to canon. It has more precedence over anything else right now because it's given permission to be made.
Is it his true name? No, probably not. It'll be just like P4 who had a different manga name before "Yu" officially came along. I suspect the same thing will happen in P5, but until then the manga name is the closest "official" name right now.
>>174947592
> but nowadays the western VA industry has caught up to the japs, and there really is no "better" one, just preference.
This isn't your opinion, it's just objectively untrue. This game's Japanese voices have industry veterans like Aoi Yuuki, Nakata Jouji and Jun Fukuyama giving their best performances, while the english one has some no name middle aged fucks trying to sound like Japanese teenagers. Japan has voice acting academies, it's a huge industry there are years ahead of anything in the West. There is some good english voice acting, sure like the ones in the Souls series for example, but if a game is originally in Japanese if will ALWAYS be better than the dub. In fact, this rule can be applied to any language in any type of media. The original voices in their original language will always be more fitting and more faithful than any dub.
>these new faggots shitting their garbage opinions all over like they own the place
>>174948480
That's a lot of elitism. Almost reads like a copy-pasta.
>>174948547
Yeah, actual discussion going on in a video game general. Quite rare huh?
Reminder to not give attention to dubfags, they are mostly dumb Americans who get offended when they have to hear any language that's not english because it offends their freedumbs. Either that or they can't read subtitles because they don't have any practice since they only listened to english their whole lives.
>>174948480
Now you get called a weeb for preferring original voices with actual effort put into them over lazy dub cash-ins.
>>174948547
>all these dumb weebs getting triggered over the English language
>>174948586
All memes aside the shit is delicious.
Why did this girl warrant a portrait? Are there any other bit characters aside from the teachers andShihothat don't really have much screen time but get one?
>>174947785
>Kanji's waifu
He has no chance with her
>>174948232
something being official doesn't make it canon
adaptations are not canon, they're official
fan anthologies released by Atlus are not canon, they are official
Manga is not canon, Akira isn't "closest to canon" , it's official and Akira isn't any closer to canon than a name you got on a site that randomly generates names until it's included in a work that is actually canon, like the next spin-off.
>>174948586
i suggested asking morgana
i want that relationship to get real weird
>>174948637
the guy from the first Mementos mission
>>174948584
Elitism is the foundation in which 4chan is built on, newfag. Maybe it's because i mostly browse /a/, one of the last boards that seems to remember this.
>>174948637
She'll be the true final boss in the remake.
>>174948584
>wanting to view a product as it was originally intended is elitism
I bet you watch foreign films dubbed too you fuck.
>>174948564
>>174948650
I still don't really see what you're trying to say. "official" and "canon" are exactly the same to me.
>>174947785
Do we really need to keep beating this dead horse?
Leave the fucking horse alone
>>174948729
The P3 movies are official, they're just not canon.
That should make sense
>>174948650
who cares as long as people still know what character you're talking about
>>174947785
You mean Rise's waifu
Regardless of it being canon or not, i think Akira is a good name for Joker. It fits him in my opinion.
>>174948374
>Update
GENIUS
>>174948817
good bland name for his clark kent glasses schtick
>>174948729
Think of it like the old Star Wars EU. All the old stuff is still official. It's just not canon anymore.
>>174948703
/a/ is fucking garbage, there's nothing "elite" about it
>>174948729
Not that guy but they are different in the context we're talking about. Official just means sanctioned but doesn't mean the people behind the actual product made it.
>>174948817
Akira's too damn common. May as well give him Yamada or Tanaka as his surname.
>>174948374
Is blue hair supposed to be Mishima?
>>174948814
At least Rise would share
>>174948921
Yeah, it's Mishima.
Don't trust people that dislike Morgana.
How many Gorofags post just because they want to fugg him
>>174948727
Make me.
>>174948724
Then play the JP version, you faggot, specially since allowing for Jap auduo wasn't so we could play the game "as it was intended" it was to appease weebs too ignorant to learn japanese but also too elitist to not listen to JP audio
The fact that so many people shit on the dub makes it look like you haven't heard the dub at all. The only truly bad voice acting is Shinya, Ann and sometimes Morgana.
>>174948897
For someone to say this on /vg/ of all places is simply laughable. /a/ is BY FAR the best board on 4chan from a discussion quality standpoint. It's the only board that still upholds what Moot's idea of 4chan was.
>>174948886
But the way I would see it as is that the old Star Wars EU WAS canon, and now it's not. It was replaced.
I see it the same way with Akira. He's canon, or the closest thing to canon right now, but soon he will probably be replaced with a real, canon name.
We're really just arguing semantics, whether you want to call it official, or canon, or whatever, the point is it is the most official/canon name that currently exists. That's not to say you have to accept it as truth or something (since it'll be replaced anyway) but I don't see the problem with people calling him that given how, like I said, it's the closest to official/canon out there.
>>174948817
I personally like 暁, it's a fitting name, but not reading it as Akira.
>>174949054
What the fuck? Ann's voice is fine.
>>174948586
WOw...Haru is into SCAT porn
>>174949064
>/a/
>quality discussion
Here's your (you)
>>174948864
>>174948905
I mean yeah it's pretty common and that's why i think it fits him. When he's not in a palace he's a pretty bland looking guy who covers his face with his bangs and huge glasses. But at the same time it's a cool enough name to fit him when he goes full Lelouche inside the palaces.
>>174948995
true waifuhusbandofags would rather their favourite character be fugged by an in universe character, because wanting to fuck them yourself is a dishonor to your waifuhusbando.
>>174946705
Fuck you Lavenza is my wife
>>174949112
among the females in the main cast Ann's is the best desu
and this is coming from a Makotofag
>>174948995
I mostly just save fanart but yeah I would fuck.
>>174949054
>The only truly bad voice acting is Shinya, Ann and sometimes Morgana
Not that guy, but the argument also gets muddied cause a lot of this shit is so subjective. For example I liked dub Ann and felt she made a lot of sense for the character, whereas Futaba could be a bit grating at times.
>>174949145
I bet you're one of those faggots who will say that there isn't quality discussion anywhere on 4chan. Back to whatever shithole you came from, newfag.
>>174948729
Official is just something the company looked at for 5 minutes, said it's good enough and allowed it to be published. It was acknowledged byt the people in charge but that's all.
Canon is something that is actually a part of the work and exists in story's universe.
P5 manga , and any adaptation, are basically fanfictions released under Atlus' name and their allowance. Most of the time they don't even have a look into what's actually happening and people working on them don't actually work for Atlus and rarely even have a chance to consult the main team.
>>174949225
Yeah I really don't understand how you can defend the dub and then shit on Ann's voice.
She's probably the 2nd best voice actor behind Ryuji.
Don't worry, in a couple weeks the normies will leave to their next fotm game and leave us be to discuss why Goro is shit in peace
>>174948636
This, there's really nothing wrong with it.
I mean, people eat pig buttholes every day in a lot of processed meat.
>>174948817
I agree, I think it's a good name for him. 'Kurusu' might need some changing up though.
>>174949054
I watch everything with the original audio. It has nothing to do with it being Japanese.
Why should you feel sympathetic for an autistic mass murdering sociopath who's endgame was literally the incarnation of pettiness and childishness
>>174949225
But JP has Rina Sato as Makoto
>>174949292
But the fact that it's released and allowed under Atlus' name gives it precedence over a name you put in the random name generator. It's the most official or canon or whatever word you want to use until something more official/canon/whatever comes along.
>>174949307
>leave /pg/ long ago around the time DAN came out to avoid leaks/news/spoilers for P5, wanted to go into it as fresh and blind as possible
>finish it off and come back here to discuss, place is a mess
am I part of the problem?
>>174949435
because he wouldn't be that way if you'd be nice to him and be his friend, anon! his life sucks!
I want to put "it" inside Haru.
why did goro bother joining with the phantom thieves to change saes heart? was that month of "rusing" necessary on his end?
>>174949186
but she's worse than C&J
>>174949552
Delicious home grown vegetables?
LET'S GO, CAPTAIN!
>>174949552
trust? faith?
>>174949452
>gives it precedence over a name you put in the random name generator.
sure, but that doesn't make it any more canon than the randomly generated name
it is the most official one right now, but it's not canon in any way until Atlus decides it is
>>174947197
>GET INTO ENGINE ROOM
>LMAO 4 BAPHOMETS
>>174949305
>>174949270
>>174949112
I guess it is subjective, but personally I think Ann's lines are overdone to fuck. It's probably a mistake on the director too. Come to think of it, the times Ann put me off were mostly during the banter in Mementos, everything else was ok, but I did spend a fuck long time in Mementos trying to fill the Compendium
I agree about Futaba, too
BONA FIDE, MONAFIED
Persona 5 really does have a great bunch of eng voice actors put in awkward situations though. It's hard for me to go back and listen to Troy Baker's performance on Persona 4 now, for example
>>174949570
I disagree with your opinion.
Though she does seem a lot more Justine-like than both of them together.
>>174949452
Not if historically those names don't ever become canon. For all we know, Joker has a kira kira name and is pronounced as "Lucius."
>>174949597
>>174949623
"It."
>>174949701
>not instantly killing all of them with hama
>>174949435
Because he's cute.And he's still better than Adachi.
>>174949707
Well clearly it's subjective. I really liked her English voice and it's part of the reason why she's my favorite girl.
>>174949761
Morgana's poop coffee?
goro > ikutsuki > adachi
>>174949761
Morgana shit coffee?
Can you see a movie with Goro?
>>174949748
>For all we know, Joker has a kira kira name and is pronounced as "Lucius."
perfect
>>174949701
>>174949764
SAMSARA THOSE SHITS INTO HEAVEN
>>174947317
>WOOAH LOOKING COOL JOKER
>BONA FIDE, MONAFIED
These two lines makes me want to download the JP dub sometimes.
>>174949737
indeed
She also lacks personality, like Margaret
Anyone else kinda disappointed Morgana was still able to talk after returning? It would have been a nice and poignant way to wrap up all the fantastical elements of the story if he lost the ability to speak to humans, but still recognized and remembered the PT.
>>174949668
>>174949748
I think we're both agreeing to the same point, but getting tied in semantics.
>>174949707
I think Ann's voice actor is very good, although maybe a little inconsistent at times? Like I feel like when she says "Dance Carmen!" it's not really said in a way like she normally would sound.
I thought Futaba's voice actor was good too, but wasn't entirely sure she fit the character. She didn't really sound like a tiny 15 year old should.
>>174949884
I loved cheesy shit like that. I especially love when Morgana is inflicted with hunger and starts screaming about sushi. So much better than Teddy, too. Fuck that thing was annoying.
>>174949884
>>174949707
Why the fuck are you using Morgana anyway? Most worthless party member by far.
>>174949834
>>174949864
>Phantom will open a cafe and get flithy rich selling coffee made from his magical cat's shit
>>174950008
>most worthless
That's Ann.
>>174949236
I wish I was Joker so I could enjoy Goro's sweet boi pussy too
What is going on with me? I've never felt the need to fuck a fictional character before
>>174949846
nanako face
>>174949884
>not downloading the JP so you can hear Futaba's hissatsu waza when she full buffs you
Full pleb
>>174950021
Morgana will come to hate the things it does.
>>174950008
that miracle punch and heals 2 good
>>174949979
That sounds kinda sad, especially when you consider how much that fucker loves talking. Sorta like an "I have no mouth but I must scream"
>>174949964
I feel like she suffers from a lack of screen time, she doesn't get to develop much of a personality compared to her split forms.
Margaret is fine though, its just that she's so reserved in comparison to her immediate predecessor Liz its a little jarring. Again she suffers from not getting to do that much too.
>>174949737
can you get multiple divine pillar?
speaking of official vs. canon and shit
Shitty scans of an adaptation that is 100% more canon than the game; some pretty Mitsuru and infodump on Sho editionhttp://sillyfudgemonkeys.tumblr.com/post/159942884914/persona-4-ultimax-manga-chapter-22-parts
http://sillyfudgemonkeys.tumblr.com/post/159942894759/persona-4-ultimax-manga-chapter-22-parts-1
>>174950054
Ann does a shitload of damage with Concentrate
all Morgana does is heal which you should just use Makoto for anyway since she can also give Marakukaja
>>174950124
Yeah just kill him multiple times
Anyone try taking Akechi to the confessional?
>>174950008
>Best healer.
>Literally carries your entire party at Okumura's palace
>Best Ultimate Persona Desing.
???
>>174949979
I was disappointed Morgana came back at all. I wasn't expecting full P3 levels of sadness, but again it felt like we saved the world without any real sacrifice or repercussions.
>>174950119
this is pretty much lavenza's answer to the meaning of life
>>174950178
yeah it's kinda funny knowing he's toting a kill count of more than a few people going in
>>174950119
delet
>>174950008
Miracle punch is really useful on trash mobs for clutch downing enemies without weaknesses, and keeps you healed up while doing so. Not so good against bosses but sometimes you just gotta swap out
Basically required for treasure demons
>>174950178
yes, nothing interesting happens
>>174950119
Can you not sexually harass my wife please
So how many of you actually caught on to the pancakes shit in the beginning?
>>174950245
don't need it for treasure demons when you've got Tower's gun skill
Lavenza is kinda lame.
Caroline > Lavenza > Justince tbdesu
>>174950178
https://youtu.be/MUdQbuWDUqg
>>174950060
It's because Goro is too good.
>>174950324
How cute!I want to put her in a mating press
Can you still double the amount of exp and money you get in NG+? I'm at the end and don't have enough money to do all the fusions I want. And I really dont feel like grinding this close to the end
Okay get this, I have the perfect villain for P6.
Okay, he's a goofy, joking guy who gets along with the group somewhat and then betrays them near the end!
>>174950178
If you take Goro to the confessional every day then you unlock the true true end where he doesn't betray you, and stops being an unrepentant idiot.
>>174950324
>that scene where Elizabeth was sperging out about manhole covers being constant temptations to man
deep lore
>>174950459
"Cough" Akechi "Cough"
>>174950324
I want Caroline back...i miss that snarky espression on her face
>>174950480
This is true, my cousin's cousin told me.
>>174950339
I did. Even went back through the log to confirm.
Was satisfied to find that it really was an important moment and not just a translation issue or smth; then again, Akechi was sketchy as fuck the entire time so it's not even a twist when he turns.
Though, playing again through NG+ I realized that pancakes was actually the very first direct interaction with him. He was fucked from the start.
>>174950459
No, the Akech/Adachii next game should actually be a bro while the Ryuji/Yosuke is a villain
>>174950459
If they do decide we need traitor Mk4 (or are we higher than that now?) I really hope they make it someone really early on and a major team member.
Like having the equivalent of Yosuke or Ryuji be the traitor, possibly out of jealousy for how great MC is.
>>174950459
Love it.
>>174950206
It's weird how P5 starts with you getting your ass beat in a prison cell, and ends with P4 levels of lightheartedness.
>>174949452
>It's the most official or canon or whatever word you want to use until something more official/canon/whatever comes along.
Similar to how we called the P4 Protag 'Soji' (from the manga), until the anime and later spinoffs called him Yu?
>>174950459
we'll never see it coming. good idea anon.
>>174950505
Persona truly has the deepest lore
>>174950324
>>174950505
>>174950459
What ifthere is no traitor at all, and the villain is clearly established at the beginning of the game?
>>174945006
>>174944681
I forgot I made this thread and sure didn't expect you guys to use it. Please stop being mean to me
the biggest twist would bethere is no traitor for once and we just get a good villain that plays his role well for the entirety of the game
Can you go full harem mode in P5 or are there any drawbacks?
>>174950825
no drawbacks whatsoever
Is the Tsukiyoki DLC out yet?
>>174950825
>Boldly accept
Shadow Sae x Sae x Makoto x Joker doujins when
SHU
JIN
>>174950719
That actually sounds pretty good.
Only, what if the villain ends up not being the actual main villain and in reality there's a god who affects the collective unconsciousness, and also a guy affiliated with the police who you get along with initially but ends up being a traitor?
GENIUS
>>174950719
>>174950806
What if the traitor is the MC and the final bosses are all your ex-party?
anyone have the makoto "respond when you see this" pic
Where and how do you rent DVD's?
Went the whole game without knowing this shit and had like one video game
Wait, so why didn't Goro try to kill Shido through his palace on his own? Or did Shido's palace not exist until then?
>>174950641
Yes
>>174950865
How would that even work? Would Joker just fuck all of them?Or would Shadow Sae have a dick?
>>174951007
girls aren't supposed to have dicks reeeeeeee
>>174950339
When he said pancakes I opened up the log to check if anyone besides morgana had mentioned them. Instantly knew he'd be a party member and obviously be the traitor. Though since it was so obvious and tipped off so early I was hoping it would be a fakeout, and when the Okumura arc started I was suspecting the actual traitor would be Haru selling out the team for killing her dad.
But then Akechi lied about having only recently entered the metaverse for the first time.
>>174950953
The place across from the bookstore at Shibuya central street. You have to return the DVD within a week, or you have to pay a fee. They wave it the first time, though
ALL YOU DO IS EAT AWAY AT MY LIFE
>>174950953
As soon as you load in to central street, it's right across from the bookstore. Just look right.
>I am NOTHING like you
>A psychopath that BAKES for money
Did any of the other movies compete with this?
>>174951007
Shadow Sae, Sae, and joker would fug Makoto, the Sae's would use strap ons that the artist accidently turns into real dicks for the money shot then they go back to strap ons the next panel
>>174950967
Because Shido's palace is heavily fortified and his shadow is crazy strong. Also Shido would have committed sudoku with that pill.
>>174951054
they waived it for me like ten times on my first playthrough, i never paid. last late fee was like 100K
I just want to protect her
>>174951007
She'd be in her Leviathan form and the guns on her right arm would be replaced by dildos.
>>174950967
he wasn't trying to kill shido, he was trying to set him up and then ruin his reputation because it's a fate worse than death for someone who cares as much about his rep as shido does
also shido's palace is abnormal because of his familiarity with cognitive research (even before he gets his hands on wakaba's research), his palace's got safeguards against intruders (like the cognitive yakuza guy), and shadow shido's tough, he probably couldn't deal with his shadow even if he tried to
>>174951147
whos that
if haru likes shit she must be a good girl
>>174950967
Because he's a dumbass who had a plan about letting Shido reach the peak of his power before trying to take him down. Goro was not smart.
>>174950948
>>174951086
what a fucking cunt
i thought sisters were supposed to do nothing but cuddle and make out
>>174950459
Main villain is a patsy, its the only guy who can save everyone. The traitor is the one who tricks you all into killing the "villain"
The traitor isdemiurgepretending to take the form of a highschooler to be with your crew and is your best friend from childhood. The "villain" isphilemonsomehow
You kill the "traitor" but it turns out the "traitor" really was your best friend but was possessed thus you also killed your best friend
And somehow half way into the game you kill most of your other friends and you go full sasuke revenge mode on the leaf village to killdemiurgewhich sends the world into neutral route true end for the cycle to continue
>>174951147
We know, Ann. You failed miserably.
>>174951132
Hm, maybe the waiver might have to do with the days you're forced to skip, then.
>>174951147
you failed
>>174950457
I know one of you fuckers can answer this question
>>174951239
Philemon was always the villain. It was implied he was the one that started the bet with Nyarly in the first place.
>>174950967
He doesn't want to kill Shido, he wants to propel him to the top and then ruin him.
BIKINIS WHEN
SWIMSUITS WHEN
FREE DLC WHEN
REEEEEE
Can Philemon show up in p6 fatlus
>>174950457
You mean like in P4? No, you can't.
>>174951306
Thats the twist. No one is good, you are always manipulated
>>174951337
>no goro swimsuit
What's the point of buying it?
>clicking through the fusion shit and interrupting the twins actually pisses them off
Made me chuckle
>>174951247
>>174951281
D-delete this
>>174951384
what? fucking why?
>>174951147
When Kamoshida pushed his throbbing, olympian cock in Shiho as she was pinned down to the floor and under a lot of stress, is it possible she also bled from her vagina and Suguru cleaned that up for her against her will?
In fact, he cleaned up his whole mess against her will. Including the ripped sweatshirt, skirt, blood, before sending her home.
Is there any way to get outfits in game like in P4, or is it all DLC now?
>>174951502
It's all dlc
>>174951502
all DLC now
>>174951468
STOP IT
>>174951468
The first time he raped her yeah, the one right before she tried to commit suicide no.
>>174951502
who is this slut?
I want to look up porn of her
>>174951539
>>174951543
Man, fuck Atlus.
>>174950848
wont be available for me until i wake up around 12pm
>>174951565tsuchinoko a best
>>174951502
It's all DLC but some are free.
Persona 5 is a PS3 game...when will we get a PS4 persona?
messiah when
>>174951712
2021
>>174951569
first time?
You mean he's raped her more than once?
>>174951748
when PS5 will be out
>>174951468
Did he have sex with Ann?
In one of her confidant scenes, she says something like "When Kamoshida threatened to take Shiho off the team if I didn't sleep with him, I should have just said no".
>>174951712
P6
Prob all the P5 dance fighting shit and the P1 2 and 3 remakes. And P4 re release HD whatever if they do it
>>174951748
>>174951806
that's too early, isn't it? PS5 would have to be out for at least a year
Guys.
What if WE are the Shadows?
>>174951831
She didn't
I was driving to work today when I started humming the Mementos theme
Fucking hell
>>174951831
No, they didn't sleep together, she just came up with excuses to get out of it constantly instead of telling him to fuck off.
yo, akechi is fun as hell to use. traitor or not, his battle quotes and animations are great. loving his skills too. wish i could reserve a permanent spot for him.
>>174951831
She does mention at some point that she hadn't done anything with him. The sense I get is that she flirted and lead him on, perhaps some groping and such, but came short of intercourse.
>>174951950
I'm still mad Atlus killed off the bless/curse user.
>>174945671
so what happens after, does the AoA screen just show the default image?
>>174951909
DUN DUN DU
DUDUN DUN DU
DUDUN DUN DU
DUDUN DUN DU
Best team:
Joker
Akechi
Yusuke
Makoto
>>174951950
How do you determine a character is fun to use?
>>174952060
swap akechi with Morgana and Yusuke with Ryuji
What did you name your teams?
I named mine The Big Guys because they wear masks and removing them looks extremely painful.
What do you think she fantasizes about when she watches Joker work?
>>174951831
She'd flirt and tease him, but would always make an excuse about needing to get to her job or something before he could cross the line.
This was not a sustainable plan to keep him from doing anything to Shiho or herself, but she didn't know anyway of stopping him other than stalling.
>>174951147
Don't worry. We'll get to bring her smile back in Persona Crimson when we get her SLink
>>174952043
stop
How come people find the idea of Kamoshida and Ann horrifying but don't mind another some 30 year old teacher banging and massaging her 16 year old student?
>>174952013
yeah it's shit. had a blast using him.
>>174952060
i honestly could and would roll this the whole game if they'd let me, swapping yusuke for ryuji late game
>>174952094
i like his skills, all of his battle animations and quotes, and his all out attack portrait?
>>174951975
She did everything he wanted short of having sex. She tells you this when she talks about the scene where she refused to go to his house because she knew what that meant.
Do you guys think P6 will cater to SJW's or does atlus still not care
>>174952169
Potter is cute
Kamoshida isn't
>>174952060
best team
Joker
Morgana - healer
Ryuji - tank
Anybody else
>>174952060
Lack of Morgana/10
>>174952169
Have you heard of the word consensual?
>Casino
>Hear that the level background music has lyrics
>Immediately get 'Heaven' flashbacks
bad times incoming
>>174952169
Pretty sure consent in that sort of relationship is legal in Japan. Rape is illegal everywhere, though. It's not that difficult.
characters in terms of story arc/depth to them
1. Futaba
2. Akechi
3. Makoto
4. Sae
5. Morgana
6. Yusuke
7. Ann
8. Ryuji
9. Sojiro
10. Mishima
Hmmmmmm...feels like something is missing
>>174952169
Assuming you're not memeing, one is sexual blackmail where the guy involved raped her friend.
The other is a teacher who is legitimately in a happy loving relationship with her student.
>>174952265
Joker?
>>174952230
Makoto is a better healer by the end of the game since she has better hp, better sp, better persona stats and a less common weakness.
>>174952169
Kamoshida was coercing her under threat of violence and/or expulsion.
Kawakami x Joker is fully consensual, and she tries to tell you it's wrong before accepting it when you don't back down.
>>174952169
Consent is everything
>>174952169
Kawakami wants it as much as Joker does, they like each other. Ann doesn't like Kamoshida at all, if she did then it's another story.
Joker
Ryuji
Ann
Makoto
Objectively the most optimal team.
>>174952265
You mean like, Joker?
>>174952134
>>174952230
>>174952235
>using worst character
Go to bed.
>>174952169
Wanting to bone your teach is completely normal.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TpLzW7fm1c0
Are the P3 movies good? I've only watched the first one and enjoyed it a lot.
I went MC Ann Makoto Morgana the whole game and I steamrolled everything
Ambushing is OP
>>174952150
Thanks for showing me that anon, this actually cheered me up
>itemize Thor into Mjolnir for Ryuuji
>its a giant ugly mace
>>174952310
Makoto is the only party member to have two summoning poses. The first is when she has Johanna, where she "rides" her Persona, while her second is with Anat, which unlike Johanna has a humanoid form.
I love Sojiro but one thing that bothered me was how he seemed to give almost zero fucks after finding out you're a phantom thief, knows that you're into some insanely dangerous shit, and knows that you're taking his daughter with you, and he just...doesn't really seem to mind.
Hell, even when blood is falling from the sky and a giant demon god is threatening to kill everyone, he's just casually strolling through the streets, striking up a casual conversation with Mishima.
I think that dude puts something else in his curry.
>>174952375
>tfw I almost boned my hot Chinese TA in university
I thought we established that the best team is
Joker
Makoto
Ryuji
Haru
>>174952340
Lol hilarious meme, anon!
>>174952409
how much do you like Aigis
>>174952213
>japanese
>caring about western trends
Not_fucking_likely.jpg
>>174952519
this would be my favorite team if akechi was never playable. it stands as my favorite since he's not after a single dungeon.
>>174952519
Why would you take Haru over Ann? Haru does less damage
>>174952265
Mishima deserves to be bullied even more than Akechi does.
And I'm saying that after having reloaded a save from 4 days ago after accidentally being friendly to Akechi when he came to Leblanc just so I can tell him to leave
>>174952519
Swap forehead for Ann and you're solid
>>174952340
>Morgana
>Worst character
You're the one who needs bedrest
>>174952409
Overall meh
They did the final scene beautifully though. Also they shilled the fuck out of Aigis.
>>174952409
>Are the P3 movies good? I watched one of them and it was good.
>>174952612
Anns a lot better for bosses but Harus gun skills do a lot of damage, have a high critical rate and don't take any sp which is pretty good for going through palaces.
I got Baal and Yoshitsune to max Str even though I know Yoshitsune is stronger, I just think Baal is cool and I want to try out his unique attack
I don't know what else to do, /pg/. I think I'm depressed. Once I platinum this, I'm done. What do I do from there? Can I easily jump into P1 or P2 after this? Will it be a jarring transition?
>>174952612
Haru has better buffs and still does a lot of damage.
>Final confrontation with Goro
>Goes into excruciating detail explaining how he's a psychotic murderer
>Entire team starts sympathizing with him
Dude... What?
>>174952496
No worries. There's a pretty good chance she gets her own SLink since she was relatively popular given her short appearance.After all, I'm the one who wrote it. I dunno if I should write more like dates and stuff
>>174952612
She's my Heat Riser Slut
>Never change party
>Ever
>Kept Joker, Ann, Ryuji, and Morgana the entire game because I was used to p4 and p3 where people you don't use stay underleveled
squad
>>174952612
But she's cuter.
>>174952707
incredibly jarring, might as well be a different series
So how moddable is TYH edition bag so it can actually be usable? Using it as is is just making my head hurt.
I never thought I'd see the day /pg/ dislike Aigis.
She was the only good thing from P3.
If Akechi and Naoto switched games, how would Persona 4 and 5 differ?
>>174952742
>>174952712
What the hell do you need Heat Riser for? It's a useless single target buff when sukukaja is worthless and you already have Makoto and Ryuji for team wide attack and defense buffs.
>>174952737
Fuck I should've watched the full cutscene before posting.
>Sacrifices himself for no fucking reason
>"I AM THOU, THOU ART I..."
>>174951364
Shit that sucks. I have like 800k but the amount they charge you for higher personas is insane. Especially since levels dont carry over.
>>174952737
>sympathizing with a person that would've never made the choices he did if he had some sort of guidance or love of any kind in his life
i know it's weird
honestly, anon, they're not saying murder is okay. they were giving him the option to settle things with shido with them and use his powers for good for once.
>>174952670
there is literally nothing wrong with aigis
>>174952737
Oh neat, I wasn't alone in thinking this.
>guy who personally killed the sole parent of two different party members
>guy who planned to murder MC
>everyone starts sympathising with him
I'd understand for Haru since her dad was a dick. But Futaba didn't deserve this.
>>174952519
That's actually an optimal setup for late game. Ryuji for matarukaja and his physicals, Makoto for heals and occasional marakukaja, and Haru to cast makarakarn and tetrakarn. MC to deal damage, Ryuji helps, the other two keep the team alive
>get to school trip in P4
>Highschool and music from P3
neat
Persona 4 was Scooby Doo
Persona 5 was Death Note
what cartoon does atlus steal for 6?
>>174952512
Tell us the story, anon
>>174952612
tetra/makarakarn+amrita shower
>>174952819
Akechi comes to Inaba to "solve" the case but since he didn't set it up himself, he can't do anything. If he still hangs out with IT, he probably grows attached to Nanako too and wants to kill Namatame just like Naoto.
Naoto is as uselesss as she was in P4, it's just one boss fight less.
>>174952984
Wacky Races
http://vocaroo.com/i/s14L8qLzR8S6
>>174952875
Look, I'm not gonna go into a "woe is me" rant but speaking as someone who also had a pretty fucked up childhood, at NO POINT would I become a psychotic serial killer if suddenly given Persona powers.
>>174952984
Code Geass
>>174952927
not only high school, there's the club and love hotel too
>>174953060
pssst
keep playing, there's another factor involved
Am i the only one that didnt romance anyone on purpose and did all the events with Ryuji?
>>174948374
>Projecting this hard
>>174953060
I would like to hear your rant
>>174953108
Yeah I'm sitting here listening to the music in the club right now. I didn't think the club was the same one though.
>>174952984
> Persona 5 was Death Note
Reminds me, why did they get Light Yagami to voice this retard and not the psychopath ace detective that uses L's idea of justice for publicity.
>>174952984
wtf there is no similarities between death note and p5
moron
>>174952875
Everyone is the way they are because of their upbringing, whats the point of sympathising with some people but not others.
>>174952845
playing on Safety multiplies your money gains by 5x, but you can't switch out of it, and there's no cutsom modifiers like P4G
If you want a bunch of money for NG+ it's best to switch to safety at the end of the first playthrough(or reload a previous save after you've beaten the final boss normally) and do some farming. Your money will carry over to NG+ and you can reset the difficulty level to something else at the start of it.
>>174953150
it is, the vip room they go to was even the same the monk would hang out at and the event Rise talks about was the full moon boss battle
>>174952984
Pokemon...wait
>>174952875
From the moment the phantom thieves existed, he would have known that his powers could be used for other purposes, but he killed anyways.
>>174952984
Persona 5 is Scooby Doo too. They even have a mystery machine.
>>174952984
Yu-Gi-Oh!
>>174953060
i'm glad you held things together and managed to remain far less compromised emotionally, but if you consider your life through akechi's shoes,where he grew up as a bastard child in a society that otracizes the likes of you, then your mom dies, then you grow up with no friends, devote your life to excelling at everything since it's the only way you can feel you're contributing anything, etc. and then you meet the man that was solely responsible for the position you're in, AND he's a shithead, then you're given power to do something about it from the gods? you also have to realize akechi was like 15 when all of this was going on, and he had no idea you could change hearts. by the time all of that came up, he was too deep and too far gone.
and even if you are going to say "i could've handled that" not all people are the same and he was a fucked up teen in a fucked up position. sympathizing with his situation is perfectly understandable, even if you don't necessarily think he should be forgiven.
>>174952984
Space Dandy
>>174953028
I wish
>Yukari and Mitsuru spend months at each others throats
>Ann and Makoto resolver their differences after a day.
Post your doujin ideas
The horseshoe theory is fucking strong in this gameWhen Shido was giving the speech while everyone was in the attic, I thought that was Yoshida because I didn't memorize either of their voices yet.
It just reminded me how easy it is to make people side with you in just a few generic phrases.
>>174953389
also he didn't use his powers to kill until shido manipulated him into using them that way
and shido threatens him (same threat the pt get, clearly a death threat in that case) just for trying to put off one of his orders for after the election
he's not innocent but it's not hard to see why the party sympathizes with him and tries to give him a chance to join them against shido even though they make it clear they don't forgive him
I'm still a devoted foreheadfag but holy fuck Sadayo's hawaii date
>>174953535
How do the other Hawaii dates compare?
>>174953389
Sounds a lot like my life, except replace "dead mom" with "mom who loved to beat the shit out of me and tear down my self confidence".
If Goro had regretfully killed a couple people, honestly okay that's one thing. But he was a raving lunatic openly bragging about how psychotic he was. You reach a point where "m- muh shit childhood" stops being a good excuse.
>>174953378
If you really think about, Yu-Gi-Oh is basically SMT/Persona with literal cards instead of mostly metaphorical ones
>>174953479
It's not like Ann and Makoto had a particularly big grudge against each other, though.
>>174953002
Well, okay.
>started to get along with this cute Chinese TA
>started to see each other in our spare time
>she had a pretty thick accent and had just moved here from China
>she was raised in a rural Chinese town but later moved to a bigger city
>we would go on walks and she would stop to talk to the tree spirits and water spirits to thank them in Chinese (don't remember which dialect she spoke)
>her cooking was fucking amazing, too
>soon, she started talking about her boss in China and how he didn't want her to leave for here
>she said that she'd be in huge trouble when she went back
>she follows that up later with talking about how she can't wait for us to go to China together
>not really sure what all of this means, but I start to get the feeling I'm being used for a green card or something, not to mention that if I went back with her that I'd probably be pulled into something that's way over my head
>eventually tell her that we can't see each other anymore and break it off
>>174953514
Sae, frustrated at Joker's refusal to sell out his teammates, resorts to more sexual interrogation methods.
>>174953514
Sae visits Joker while he's in juvyand has him fuck her.
So did Yaldy learn programming so he could make that app?
>>174953618
>she would stop to talk to the tree spirits and water spirits to thank them in Chinese
Cute!
>>174953692
God I want this so bad
>>174953514
The twins use their personas to rape Potter. They don't actually touch the him themselves, but let their personas do all the work.
>>174953528
>it's not hard to see why the party sympathizes with him and tries to give him a chance to join them
it kind of is when all of this happens in the space of about five minutes out of nowhere. their first reaction should have been anger, then coming around to the idea of teaming up with him to fight shido.
definitive dungeon rank
1. casino
2. castle
3. pyramid
4. museum
5. ship
--
6. depths of mementos
7. destroyed shibuya
--
8. bank
--
9. spaceship
if you disagree youre wrong
>>174953569
>and even if you are going to say "i could've handled that" not all people are the same
he also states he's envious of joker because he's not bound by past atrocities. like i said before, he was in too deep before he even knew there was another way to get at his dad, to change his heart. i'm not trying to excuse him, i'm telling you how someone might sympathize with the means that led him to make his shitty decisions. also, i'm really sorry about the shit you've been through anon, and i'm glad you're well off enough to call akechi's emotional situation bs.
Is the swimsuit dlc out yet?
Makoto and Tatsuya Suou from Persona 2 share some similarities.
Both of them have older siblings that work in within the police force, Katsuya is a police officer and Sae is a prosecutor, and have strained relationships with them.
Both are well versed in riding motorcycles and are strongly associated with them.
Both had fathers in the police force, Makoto's was killed in the line of duty while Tatsuya's was framed for a crime he didn't commit and was thrown in prison.
Both are third year students.
Both feel like they can't measure up to their seemingly better older siblings.
Tatsuya pushes away his brother and doesn't care what he thinks while Makoto wants to please her sister and live up to Sae's expectations.
Makoto is a honors student while Tatsuya often skips his classes.
>>174952984
That would explain why I dislike the last part of the story. Light wasn't remotely as smart as the writer thought he was and having all that exposition that explained each plan was retarded. I couldn't even finish it because it was annoying. Thankfully, it ws only 30 minutes in persona.
>>174953765
It really was adorable.
i don't know what to play now that i finished persona. why did this game have to end.
pls anyone vote in this poll, i'll play whatever is winning within 30-60 minutes
http://www.strawpoll.me/12821742
http://www.strawpoll.me/12821742
Who did you send the calling card to again?
>>174952340
Worst character is Ann, anon
>>174953823
it doesn't start at that scene though
futaba already heard about part of his background during his rank 3 event and reacted to it there
the party as a whole recognized goro's motivations are similar to them in that scene where they talk about wanting to change sae's heart, 10/28 iirc
they got definitive confirmation he's the traitor and acting as an assassin for shido at some point after securing the path to the treasure in sae's palace, so the party already had a while to stew on that
all the boss fight exposition does is give them even more context for his actions
>>174952519
Why is Yusuke so useless ;_;
>>174953990
Can't really pick just one since a lot of them are different.
Steins;Gate if you're still craving the character driven kind of story, Shadow Hearts if you're craving an RPG but want a more unique battle system (seriously, no other system is like it, it's amazing), and Ys if you want something totally different and are up for a fast paced hack and slash with challenging boss fights.
Joker > P4 MC
Ryuji < Yosuke
Yusuke > Kanji
Morgana < Teddie
Futaba > Rise
Makoto > Chie
Haru and Yukiko are equally useless
Akechi >> Naoto
Sojiro >>>>>>> Dojima
>>174954013
http://www.amiami.com/top/detail/detail?gcode=FIGURE-02984
Joker is up for preorders
>>174953528
It is when he's directly responsible for killing people. He had no problem killing people and it was clear he was doing really twisted shit before shido since he could make persona's psychotic. Forgiving him was not an answer. Asking him to join was not an answer. MUH FATHER stops being an excuse when he's a fucking mass murderer.
>>174954189
Haru's cuter though.
>>174954189
>Haru and Yukiko are equally useless
>>174954198
http://www.amiami.com/top/detail/detail?gcode=FIGURE-029846
oops
>>174954202
>it was clear he was doing really twisted shit before shido since he could make persona's psychotic
where was it clear he was doing shit before shido? it's to my understanding all of those cases were under shido's orders, including shooting joker, correct?
>>174954189
>yosuke better than ryuji
>Yusuke better than kanji
>Haru useless
this list is shit.
>>174954258
Anyone is cuter than Yukiko.
>>174954198
>>174954285
Call me when they have Makoto of Futaba ready
>>174954057
Wrong.
>>174954362
Just because she's a slutty gaijin in japan doesnt mean she needs respect
>mfw fused a Thor with Enduring Soul, Rebellion, and Dodge Psy
He's unstoppable.
>>174954316
He was using his powers to become a popular so shido would need him.
Guys Haru is real!
>>174954404
Where are you in the game right now?
If you haven't beaten the seventh palace yet... keep that Thor. You'll get into a pretty fitting boss fight soon.
>>174954285
>>174954198
Ann when?
>>174954189
>Yosuke better than anyone
This confuses me to no end. He's so bad I don't understand how anyone likes him. He has to be the second worst character behind Ken.
>>174954404
>No Reflect Physical
>>174954463
They'll release her early 2018 so the preorders should start soon
maybe after summer
>>174954432
EWWWWWWWWWWWWWW
>>174954432
0/10 forehead isn't big enough
>>174954537
>Early 2018
Jesus fuck. I know nothing about figures what is the fucking hold up?
>>174954409
i'm rusty on the exact details, but if this is true it's contradicted by his hesitant response when told to kill the rest of the phantom thieves. are we certain he didn't just approach his father with these powers to earn his respect?
i really hate how persona 5 promotes sexual harassment
ryuji tries to peak at ann's underwear while sleeping
also futaba is like 12 years old. its disgusting youre allowed to date her when you are 17.
>>174954437
I'm waiting to send the calling card to Sae. I maxed out Strength so I payed the money to fuse Thor early. Are you talking about the Thor fight in the arena?
>>174954545
>>174953514
Shiho and Joker haveloving and consensual sexwhere Shiho cries into Joker's arms as he climaxes and impregnates her
Fast forward to a few months later where Joker is placing his head on Shiho's belly and feels his cute daughter kicking from inside
>>174954571
they have to make them
it's always like that
>>174954584
how did he know what his powers do before that?
>>174954571
Most of the figures are handmade of course it will take some time
>>174954624
Yeah, there was a Thor fight in the arena so it's always fun having a Thor vs. Thor showdown.You fight Loki in the seventh palace.
>>174954619
Did you hit your head a forget the whole first palace?
>>174954061
>they got definitive confirmation he's the traitor and acting as an assassin for shido at some point after securing the path to the treasure in sae's palace, so the party already had a while to stew on that
do they ever have a conversation about it before his boss fight?
>>174954645
I'm with >>174954543 now
>>174954649
this is a good point. i still find the means that drove him over the edge sympathetic, however. he's a piece of shit but i couldn't help but feel for him a bit after his fight.
Sup brah, I heard you wanted to get some bitches right?
Well I got just the thing. Here's some Mutant Mass. My secret is that I took 5 scoops, not that pussy ass 3 or 4 scoops. 5 scoops.
>>174954667
Yeah I knew about the Loki thing just wasn't sure when. That Thor got cucked though when I brought in Arahabaki and I reflected a charged up Megaton Raid.
>>174946404
5>2>3>4>1
Anything else is wrong
>>174954938
Perfect.
My favorite part of Persona is ending up with shit like this. Thank god for being able to pick the inherited skills.
you are able to trade one character from p5 for an equally important character in persona 4
who do you switch and how does that affect the story?
>>174954202
he wasn't doing anything before approaching shido, though
the only thing we know he did before that was berserk the guys responsible for getting shido into a scandal, and berserking just makes people act without restraint
shadow shido openly brags about being the one to make him use his powers to kill
>Forgiving him was not an answer.
they don't do that
>Asking him to join was not an answer.
they don't ask him to join in the sense of rejoining their team, they suggest teaming up and dealing with shido together (and only that) because they have the same enemy anyway
they would've probably tried to get him to testify against shido after that
>MUH FATHER stops being an excuse when he's a fucking mass murderer.
it's never been an excuse
the "excuse", if there is one, is shido threatening him with death if he so much as tries to disobey
but even then he's still held responsible for his actions (like he should be), shido just gets MORE of the blame for being the mastermind responsible
>>174954409
no he didn't, he only used his powers to help shido out of a scandal
the popularity thing wasn't even a factor until after that and it's more a side effect of finding ways to make sure shido can't be connected to the cases he's responsible for
>>174954689
about the traitor thing? like three or four iirc, joker just doesn't remember the first few until the drugs he got injected with for the interrogation wear off
>>174955146
yusuke with naoto
it doesnt affect the story much but away with fujobait and hello waifu
もう一回日本をすばらしいになろ!
>>174955146
naoto for haru.
naoto begins a rivalry with akechi. comes to fall in love with him. is devastated when she figures out he is the traitor.
game adds another smart character that can make akechi an even more complex character
game loses nothing without haru
>>174955202
you explain it much better than i do, thank you. these are good points as well. i've never been super great at conveying my messages properly.
i also forgot entirely shido does say he was the one that made him use the powers for murder.
holy shit persona 4 (vanilla because pstv costs way too much in my country) is fucking killing me, I played 3fes so that's probably why I'm feeling it more but
>shadows can now FLY which makes them slower but also teleport behind you
>save points are fucked, only get one per dungeon at the very end
>can't leave without getting to that point either unless you want to go all the way back down again (yeah you can buy goho-m but it's still dumb)
>you can only use one weapon type, and it's the one that takes the longest to swing so ambushing shadows is infinitely harder
I know I'm complaining a lot and I bet golden fixes most of this but seriously fucking hell
Pretty sure she's reading the manga of Persona 3
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8QW6VTPUWuU
>>174955146
Trade haru for nanako
>>174945181
Better version
>>174955445
>shadows can now FLY which makes them slower but also teleport behind you
they sometimes get stuck in a loop where they just fly around your party until you hit them
I always thought it was cute
>>174945091
plsrespond.png
How do I make Mementos less boring
When does the PSN store update? I could at least buy new DLC and have something different to look at.
>>174947215
I have a M I G H T Y N E E D to be imprisoned.
>>174955814
where's all the sweet and cute caroline art
>>174955805
>How do I make Mementos less boring
you can't
if you are a yuropoor, it's already out
>>174955202
That entire situation is still retarded. He choose to kill them. He choose to do anything just to kill his father. That scene should not have been treated with any sorrow like it was. He was a monster before shido if he wasn't than the plot wouldn't have happened. Japanese have this issue with children getting away with murder because they think children murderers have a lack of personal responsibility. so I didn't expect it to go any other way but it still makes me mad.
>>174955848
I didn't save any, all I have is porn.
Everything up until Shido was so good. The whole Akechi reversal was really well done and built up nicely.
So why the fuck did we need another fucking "stop god from destroying the world" bullshit? The end game with Yaldy was such a chore and finishes with such a cringey theme of "muh hope." It doesn't even make sense Satanel uses the embodiment of sins to destroy Yaldy when the Phantom Thieves were putting an end to the seven sins corrupting people in the first place.
Last fight should have been just Akechi. Akechi fucking over Shido and your group, having orchestrated everything, even the idea that you tricked him. Not another fucking "humanity wants to die, but they actually don't" shit. It was well done in P3, stop rehashing it over and over.
>>174956068
you are very clearly set on downplaying the character, even with answers and evidence right there in front of you. if you still think it's "retarded" then you just aren't going to like akechi, and that's fine. some people are going to like him as a character and sympathize though.
>>174956272
I like him as a character. But this is just like forgiving adachi. It's morally bankrupt and it doesn't make sense.
>>174956214
because it's a megaten game
>>174956357
No, it's not.
Persona is no longer SMT/Megaten. It's why it no longer bears the logo, to distance itself from that shit.
>>174956214
agreed
the whole plot was akechi/shido vs joker and crew and their differing views of justice. akechi should have been the final boss.
holy grail/fake igor could stay but be the mid-boss to akechi.
fuck, let holy grail take over akechi
i dunno why persona needs every final battle to be vs a giant demon thing
>>174956343
nobody is forgiving him, that's what you keep getting wrong. they sympathize with him. there's a difference.
>>174956392
you do realize megaten and SMT are different things, right
it is a megaten game, it never was a SMT game
P5 has spoiled me, after looking into past games, no way I want to trudge through random-ass dungeons
>>174956425
Persona 5 is Persona 5, go to /smtg/ for that nonsense you're spewing
What would have Akechi's Palace been and where?
>>174956418
No they forgave him I just got to that part again. They completely abandon the notion of fighting him or even talk about him paying for his crime after he talks about his backstory. It's all shido forgetting that without him shido would never have gotten this far.
>>174954332
say that to my face faggot
>>174954514
I mentioned this a few days ago, but Yosuke for some reason it a lot more likeable in spinoffs like PQ, probably be his charactersation is the straight man to everyone elses weirdness, as opposed to P4 proper where he's there to suck up to Yu.
>>174956520
pancake dome
tv studio
>>174953535
My favorite date in the game hands down. She gets a really shitty school festival date though.
>>174953559
They don't. Ann's is pretty cute but Hifumi and Makoto are pretty eh since you can go with them even if you don't romance them. Babewatch is funny at least.
>>174954938
What's her palace?
>>174956543
Haru, for one, literally says "I have no intention of forgiving you for what you did to my father, but.... I sympathize with you."
In the P5 anime, what girl has best chance to be canon romantic with Joker?
Makoto >> Futaba > Ann >>> Haru is my guess
>>174956690
They won't have a canon, but if they ever did, it's obviously Makoto. The writers already put her in a pedestal and all the shit taste faggots have her outplacing all the other girls in popularity polls.
>>174956690
If they front bring out some OC donut steel character, most likely Makoto.
>yfw Sadayo out of left field
>>174956595
>for some reason
it's because we're getting more "S.Link Yosuke" than "story Yosuke"
kinda like with how Ryuji is fine in his S.Link but outside of it he's annoying more often than not
Did anyone else think that Ryuji was a secondary traitor when he said"we got him" at the end of the cutscene following Joker getting shot in the head?
I thought I had just picked the wrong choices and got the bad ending cutscene or something. I feel like I got rused.
>>174955087
What if Shiho can be the replacement for Mishima in the next game for the Moon Confident.
>>174956690
I'd say Futuba is the strongest candidate, what with her ties to Sojiro/Cognition stuff/Joker fixing her in general. After that is Ann mostly because of first/most advertised girl principle.
Makoto and Haru are equally unlikely.
Of course the real answer is none of the above, he'll go the friendzone route with all of them and only get an anime romance in the tie in to the rerelease of P5RIt'll be Shiho
>>174956520
Desolated Carnival
Small park near Goro's apartment, where he used to be there alone by the swing.
nippon had fan vote on fav p5 character online
24,000 votes
results
1. goro
2. joker
3. makoto
4. futaba
5. sae
6. morgana
7. yusuke
8. ann
9. shido
10. ann
>>174956897
>no source
come on now
>>174956897
>Source: my ass
>>174956897
>8. ann
>9. shido
>10. ann
kek
>>174956897
How can Groo be the first one???? Nips are really nips
Also Ann 8 and 10?
>>174956690
If Atlus had any balls they'd make Sadayo canon, but they don't so it'll probably be Makoto.
Also
>mfw dude illustrating gundam iron blooded orphans manga is a fellow Sadayofag.
>>174956897
Coincidentally we all had a vote and agreed that you're a fag.
>>174956897
source
>5.sae
doubt
>>174956863
Impossible.
Mishima is skilled at least with pc
>>174956690
Makoto shilling on the same level as Aigis/Marie were in their respective adaptation
>>174956864
>Ann
Not a chance. She doesn't even have anything going for her ingame
It's Makoto and Futaba for most likely candidates to shill, if not both.
actual japan fan vote
1. MC - 2173
2. Makoto - 1725
3. Ryuji - 1036
4. Kawakami - 895
5. Morgana - 577
6. Futaba - 572
7. Akechi - 564
8. Lavenza - 301
9. Haru - 213
10. Yusuke - 211
11. Takemi - 198
12. Ann - 193
13. Hifumi - 139
14. Justine - 31
15. Chihaya - 27
16. Sojiro and Sae - 22
17. Caroline and Iwai - 16
18. No-Good Tora - 12
19. Mishima - 10
20. Lala Escargot - 6
http://spwiki.net/persona5/
http://wikibbs1.com/votec/a224.html
how is their taste, boys?
>>174956834
Yeah, that seems about right. I wish we'd go back to P3 style character development, or a composite of that style and 4/5s.
I decided to wear panties tonight and my dick has been rock hard
post sadayo to help me
>>174957060
How would a composite of that work?
Maybe if the Social Link/Confidant ties into the character development in the story? Like it gets locked at certain ranks until certain parts of the story or something?
>>174956978
>If Atlus had any balls they'd make Sadayo canon
Kawakami is nice an all, but she'd never be canon regardless of how big Atlus' balls might be
>>174957079
>>174957052
i dunno about this poll. i don't buy that ryuji went from one of the last placers to 3rd place, and goro dropped that much. some of these placements are like exact reversals of the first polls after release.
>>174957129
Yeah, even Soejima and Sega are Makotofags
>>174957129
Let me dream in vain anon.
Clearly Atlus needs like 2 or 3 pairs of balls to make it happen.
>>174957052
Yusuke and Sojiro hould be higher but that's a pretty good list. I'm surprised they like Kawakami that much.
>>174957124
>Like it gets locked at certain ranks until certain parts of the story or something?
Like Sojiro's?
Honestly I hate how gated his SLink was. First you stonewall me with bullshit slow increases and then I have to wait for the plot. And immediately thereafter I need Max Kindness? Fuck off.
>>174957079
>>174957154
Maybe it's just different people voting in different polls?
>>174957124
>Maybe if the Social Link/Confidant ties into the character development in the story? Like it gets locked at certain ranks until certain parts of the story or something?
Thats a possibilty. They'd have to write around the potential that you haven't touched someones link at all, but its nothing that couldn't be handled by good writing.
Alternately something like P3Ps FeMC routes for the guys, where they still have their mandatory plot drama but also learn some lessons and grow a little through their time with MC. Junpei's is a particular good example, as both Chidori and FeMC give him some growth but in different ways. Its not like people only learn or grow in one way or about one thing and then they're perfect, after all.
>>174957275
>its nothing that couldn't be handled by good writing
don't hold your breath then
>>174957079
>panties
>dick
What?
>>174957079
>>174957368
are you dense
>>174957052
Caroline ;___;
>>174957347
Hope springs eternal anon
Besides, its more fun to post "Wouldn't it be great if they do X in future game" than it is "THIS IS SHIT. SHIT" all the time
>>174957242
At least you have a bunch of other Confidants to do but yeah, his was gated for quite a while, especially since he's one of the first you start. An unsuspecting player could keep trying to bond with him even though it'd be fruitless.
>>174957275
>something like P3P FeMC's route for the guys
I think that could work. I hear that her Social Links changed so that she could S Link with her entire team (including Koromaru), but the characters still have their development in story so I'm guessing you just get to learn more about them in a different light. If they ever do revisit P3 I really wish they do the same with the male MC. This does mean that a lot of the already established Social Links would have to be dropped or be reduced to cameos but who's going to really miss say, Kenji?
>>174956068
you're downplaying his situation a lot
>He choose to do anything just to kill his father
he wasn't trying to kill shido, he was trying to set him up to eventually ruin his reputation and take responsibility for him by thrusting him into a living hell
>He was a monster before shido if he wasn't than the plot wouldn't have happened.
he wasn't? the game blames shido's manipulations for him turning into a killer, if it hadn't been for that he wouldn't be like that
the game never absolves him of responsibility either, the party doesn't forgive him and he's still considered the perpetrator of the incidents, shido just gets more of the blame for being responsible for ordering the incidents in the first place/offering hits in exchange for support/manipulating goro into using his powers to kill in the first place (while planning to off him once he served his purpose the whole time)
>>174956214
obligatory megaten twist
serious answer: yaldy's not just a god, he's the treasure born from humanity's sloth turned into a manmade god because of humanity's wish for someone to guide them so they can be sheep and don't have to think for themselves because it's easier that way
that whole part's basically a super anime take on how japan's society has gotten super complacent and keeps clinging to old norms and rules and the like just because it's easier, instead of trying to improve the state of their country
similar to p3's theme but not the same
reading up on japan makes a lot of the bigger story elements work better imo, there's a lot of cultural commentary involved
>>1749565
no they don't? haru, ryuji and makoto say they won't forgive him, the rest still admonish him
mona's line after the chat's a mistranslation
Only thing I want is a new theme for Yaldy.
japan's top 3 fav characters are goro, joker, makoto
then its teacher, yusuke, ryuji, futaba, and morgana
ann is most disliked main crew member
>>174957491
Persona seems pretty selective about which parts of society it challenges, though. It doesn't deal with burakumin or the Ainu, for one thing.
>>174957491
this is pretty based
>>174953535
>fucked up the question about what girls I'm into because I thought smart girl would correlate with the fucking teacher that I'm already in a relationship with
>mfw Makoto texted me
Why does Joker die for real in the bad ending?
>>174957706
i think he doesn't get sae's help and therefore akechi never gets put into the metaverse
>>174956272
saying that he shouldn't be treated with sympathy for the things he did isn't "downplaying" anything just because the PT and you, personally, sympathize with him. considering nobody has shut up about him since september i'm intimately familiar with his backstory and motivations more than i want to be, and yeah, he's still evil and cowardly for doing what shido wanted despite everything. the solution to his problems was to realize that his mess of a life wasn't worth murdering innocent people. he's a tragic character but i don't find him sympathetic at all, and it's fine if other people do, but you've got to stop accusing people of not being able to follow the character properly every time they disagree with you.
>>174957680
Makoto texts you anyway, game pushes her hard on you.
>>174957748
Right, that makes sense. Sae just gives up, Joker believes he failed his friends (because he doesn't remember it properly because the player messed up) and they're unable to enact the ruse cruise on Akechi so the Metaverse doesn't become active.
Fuck, that's a lot riding on this.
>>174956651
A slaughterhouse.Beef or chicken?
>>174957680
it doesn't change anything
>>174957768
alright. like i said, your mind isn't changing so i don't see a point in running in circles with this. you are entitled to your opinion.
>>174957586
>Ainu
does Teddie count
burakumins are still way off limits
>>174957794
>first come first serve edition
now youre just being a child because youre mad you didnt get your last thread
>>174957772
>>174957820
Wait then how the fuck do I date the teacher in Hawaii?
>>174957928
you need to be on rank 10
>>174957768
shido threatens him with death for trying to go against him
>the solution to his problems was to realize that his mess of a life wasn't worth murdering innocent people
but he... does? he gets upset about not realizing changing hearts was a thing sooner, he gets upset when he realizes there's no way he could've figured the method for that out on his own, he envies joker because unlike him he's NOT imprisoned by his past self/past actions (!) or his relations to others, he wishes they could've met a few years sooner (aka before he approached shido), he talks about taking responsibility for shido by thrusting him into a living hell, and he never planned past his revenge and knew once shido was outed his reputation was fucked too (since it'd out him too)
his problem's that he made a dumb decision when he was 15 years old and getting himself trapped in a "kill for shido or be killed for disobeying" situation, and not realizing there was another option any sooner, and he acknowledges both
dude fucked up and shouldn't be forgiven but don't write off half the circumstances involved here, anon
>>174958076
i know what shido threatened him with, i know that he regrets his actions later, i'm not writing off any circumstances when i say that the solution to his problems was to come to that realization before he murdered people and not afterwards.
>>174954189
>Morgana < Teddie
In what fucking way
>>174958214
that's fair
remember he's 15 at the time though, all he actually approached shido for was using his berserk powers to help him, not to kill people for him
and from what we know atm shido probably already started threatening to off him if he tried to disobey his orders after that
>>174958076
His dad should've just given him the dick he clearly wanted in his ass.
>>174958315
At least you can fuck Teddie.
>>174958331
sure, and the fact that he was so young is part of what makes it tragic. i still don't think he's deserving of actual sympathy, though.
>>174957052
I guess it really does vary depending on where they do the voting. Ryuji was very low in one, then suddenly he's high here. Akechi was the top in one, then now he's 7 here. Nice to see Kawakami on high and Lala-chan hilariously always making an appearance.
>>174958315
>>174958350
Neverever
wasnt Morgana a girl at one point?
>>174944314
>>174958958
4 > 3 = 5.
>>174944314
>>174958958
Happy Shiho!
Could you possibly do one with her hair down?
>>174959165
kek she got smoked
>>174959705
>>174949517
Need the original image Anon
>>174952143
Joker fucks Makoto while Futaba watches.
>>174949517
same