Well, /vr/? http://www.strawpoll.me/10065724

Mismatch Doomguy stomps
Should have made Ranger vs Doomguy

>>3171889
Ranger is the Quake 3 bot based on the Quake guy. The Quake guy is unnamed. You don't go around calling Doomguy 'Doom' do you?

>>3171876
>Who would win in a fistfight
Gonna have to go for the one who actually fights with his fists, here.

>>3173110
YMBFAP

File: Isra.gif (479KB, 217x216px) Image search: [Google]

479KB, 217x216px

>>3173110
No, I call him Reaper

>>3173117

But what about who fights with their feet?

Douk

Am I retarded? I've never seen the doom marine use his legs in zdoom
or is everyone else only using brewtal dum

File: alloutofgum.jpg (120KB, 500x500px)

120KB, 500x500px

Eat shit and die.

>>3171876
Doomguy

>skilled hand-to-hand fighter
>berserk punches monsters without destroying his fists

>cheats (uses knuckledusters)
>weak opposition

Quake Ranger

>strong enough to hack eldritch monsters apart with only axe, elbow grease
>strong opponents, suggesting Quake Ranger is probably stronger by default

>doesn't use fists, no idea if he has the skills Doomguy has

At best, this is skill vs strength, which usually falls in favour of skill. I'd say Doomguy unless someone can prove that Quake Marine has any hand-to-hand skill.

File: spiderdemon.jpg (30KB, 797x444px)

30KB, 797x444px

>>3174497

>>3171876
Unfair match up, Doomguy is superior in every way. The only thing the Wolf3d dude can do over him is get a health up from dog food.

Better match up would have been Duke Nukem or Caleb vs Doomguy.

>>3173743
Quakeguy can also jump.

>>3173110
You could say the same for doom, However it doesn't work since there was only one guy in operation counter strike.

>>3173110

Ranger is the Quake guy. The DOOM guy is also in Q3, and his name IS literally "DOOM"

File: q3 manual.png (2MB, 1122x800px)

2MB, 1122x800px

>>3175005
>>3173110

Forgot pic

>>3175010
>Height 6'5" Weight 230 lbs.
>Height 6' Weight 180 lbs.
well that does swing the odds a bit.

also, http://wolfenstein.wikia.com/wiki/William_J._Blazkowicz
>Height 191 cm (6'3") Weight 111 kg (245 lbs)

>>3175010
>exposed abs
...id knows that in the doom cover art it was torn fabric, right?

File: BJ_Wolfenstein_3D.png (3KB, 240x160px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 240x160px

There hasn't been a proper assessment of wolf3d guy, only brusque dismissal.

Pros:
> Yes, can grow back limbs by eating dog food
> Foes, the Nazis, absurdly stronger than demons or aliens. The whole internet put together cannot defeat them

Cons:
> No, doesn't know how to melee. Can stab at air with knife and it makes a "doink" sound, but that's it.
> Polish

I do not know if he is stronger by overcoming the hardest opposition with such serious personal handicaps. But it should be considered.

>>3174619
>the spiderdemon has tiny arms
Huh. never noticed this, i always thought it was just a big brain thing on robot legs.

>>3176273
The nazis do have demons and some other crazy shit in the expansion though.

And if you count that phone rpg, then wolf3d guy kicked pre-cyborg cyberdemon's ass back to hell.

>>3176438
I'd be willing to count it if there wasn't multiple cyberdemons.

>>3173110
Of course not, his name is Flynn Taggart!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C4yIxUOWrtw

File: Quake2-Athena-02.jpg (64KB, 768x1024px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 768x1024px

>>3171889
There really is no dilemma of that sort, you were able to face off between all three of them, AND the trio and whoever else from quake2.