Which artstyle models do you prefer for Pokemon switch game

sun and moon upscale

>>33423436
upscale S/M>Ga Ole>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>anything else>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>pokken shit.

>>33423436
gen 5

>>33423436

Upscale SM

Pokemon with realistic textures looks wrong, and they also look "off" without the black outlines.

>>33423459
look at decidueye in pokken.
they gave it "fur" on its wings

Yeah, an upscaled version of what we have now will do just fine
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M5CFKKrSt24

File: Magikarp_-_Pokken_Tournament.png (3MB, 2374x2826px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2374x2826px

>>33423436
Pokken

Gen 5 obviously, i'll take right as fuck tho.

Ga Ole > S/M upscale >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Pokken
(Pokken works for Pokken, obviously, but not for all Pokémon games)

I love the models for Pokken. I think there's a really nice compromise between realism and the original appearance of the Pokemon. Right down to small design details, like Garchomp having gills, or Mega Lucario's aura pouring out of the markings on its body. It also helps that each of the Pokken models were made with dynamic movement in mind, bringing them to further life.

The SM models are alright, but please fix Xatu, Swellow, Tropius, etc...

>>33423436
S/M sugi toonshading artstyle for me. Only improvement needed is realistic pokemon sizes, But I suppose that's not possible until the switch game. And for the love of god there are so many models that need fixing

Ga Ole >>> SM upscale >>>>>>> Shit > Pokken

>>33423493
>>33423820
This. I'm a huge fan of the plastic figure look of Ga Ole. Marvelous did a great job replicating the Takara Tomy figures for their models.

None of them. Make new better models and animations instead of the shit ones we have.

>>33423459
/thread

>>33423476
Holy fuck that is weird. Honestly, the arcade stuff looks nice enough. Still can't get into the Pokken style.

>>33423839

The models themselves don't need any changing, they're already extremely high-poly and future-proofed.

The animations and poses though for some Pokemon could use a little work.

>>33423853
The proportions are off for several Pokemon. It's nothing very obvious, but it's enough to trigger my autism and so it needs to be changed.

File: 1485821368075[1].png (538KB, 800x480px) Image search: [Google]

538KB, 800x480px

>>33423886

Are they really? They fixed Glameow in SM.

What other mons are "off"?

A natural evolution of the style of the 3DS games and not just an upscale or generic CGI cartoon aesthetics or ugly ass Pokken

sm4sh desu

File: Spr_6x_468.png (3KB, 240x240px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 240x240px

>>33423895
Togekiss is too fucking fat

>>33423895
Any more cases of that? I never noticed

Also Glameow's legs are longer than ever aren't they?

File: 20160[1].png (404KB, 750x650px) Image search: [Google]

404KB, 750x650px

Cubone's Pokken model

>>33424344
>Togekiss is too fucking fat
Or..... is it not fat enough???

File: Togekiss.png (29KB, 260x240px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 260x240px

>>33424344
he is

File: 01f5fd8767d984390d0114f883296a20.jpg (705KB, 3840x3840px) Image search: [Google]

705KB, 3840x3840px

>>33423436
Pokken is too detailed, but it looks good on certain mons that aren't already really detailed, pic related

>>33423436
>Pokemon sun and moon upscale
This doesn't even exist. The models already are HD for future use since Gen 6. That's why they tank the fps on the 3DS. Well, some of the why. Most of the why being that they could have used scaled down versions of them and kept these in the back for something like the Switch but didn't.

>>33423459
>they also look "off" without the black outlines.
Indeed. The current models could use being darkened a little more because of them are WAY too pale but they're fine as is otherwise.

>>33424460
This looks terrible

File: 20161[1].png (131KB, 750x650px) Image search: [Google]

131KB, 750x650px

Low-poly Hex Maniac model used in the background of the Haunted Mansion stage

File: hqdefault.jpg (12KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 480x360px

>>33424344
what it should be

File: 20153[1].png (440KB, 750x650px) Image search: [Google]

440KB, 750x650px

Furry Diglett

File: gen8.jpg (47KB, 457x272px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 457x272px

This desu

>>33423436
SM models, hate those weird hairy Pokken models.

>>33424489
Fan art lied to me.

>>33423436
Ga-ole>SM>>>>>Pokken

it will be sun moon models since they are apparently very detailed and future proof. so maybe we can expect more detailed textures.

>>33423436
SM is the best, only problem is 240p

File: dq11_new2.jpg (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1280x720px

Ga-ole

But I definitely wouldn't mind something like DQXI in terms of graphical style

>>33424894
Is that really what it looks like? dayum

>>33423436
As long as it isn't in the same vein as Pokken I'm fine.

File: dq11monsternori2_d9qh.jpg (242KB, 1198x649px) Image search: [Google]

242KB, 1198x649px

>>33424931
Yeah. There are some places where the textures look choppy but overall the game looks pretty good, especially the characters and monsters.

>>33423476
It's just like with anime, for some reason the japs are great at rendering detailed food.

>>33423436
S/M models, definitely.
Ga-Ole looks too plastic-y, but it works for the game. Just wouldn't for a main series.
Same for Pokken. The models look good, but only in the context of Pokken. Wouldn't be a good direction for the main series of Pokemon.

>>33423456
the only correct answer

(but upscaled SM is still pretty nice)

Pokken. Not perfect but it's better than the toy look of those cheap looking arcade games.

>>33423436
Pokèmon Sun and Moon models.
Everything else is trash.

File: 0mo.gif (2MB, 450x750px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 450x750px

>>33423436
Pokken looks too real and would just take time out of creating enough new Pokemon. Plus I'm getting sick of Gen 6 and 7's cell shading/outlines. Ga ole is just right

Throw all the animations and most of the models in the trash and get HAL Laboratories to remake them all.

>>33426006
People need to realize

Ga ole is Tomy game. The models are based off of Tomy figurines

>>33426043
>The models are based off of Tomy figurines
They're just the 3DS models with higher res textures tho.

>>33426042

There's a reason we don't have Stadium-esque animations, it's because they slow the game down too much.

The animations we do have are sped-up to maintain the pace of the battle.

>>33423436
Ga Ole because the textures are higher resolution to begin with.

Pokken's style should just stay for Pokken.

>>33423853
That only applies for the Pokemon and even then Creatures is diligent enough to give another crack at them if needed.

Trainer models would probably be done from GameFreak themselves.

Also rescaling textures isn't something that happens at the push of a button. It would be retarded to recycle texture sheets as they were on 3DS on a higher resolution display.

>>33424489
You could have told me this was an NPC for Shadow Hearts or a SMT spinoff and I would have believed you.

>>33426043
You fucking idiot, the Tomy figures are just fucking Pokemon figures, the models Ga ole uses are just the SM models with better resolution and shading

>>33426043
They're the same damn models Creatures always provides. The only difference is the hardware's throwing more shit at it.

Just go back to sprites desu senpai.

>>33423436
>>33423448
>>33423459
>>33423476
>>33423846
>>33425221
>>33426006
Pokken's models look good in game but the renders make them look awful

File: toe tappin.gif (3MB, 330x330px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 330x330px

Sprites are much better than the current "future proof" 3D models because of the dynamic poses that could bring a Pokémon to life, while also remaining future proof, as well as only having to be accurate to the model from one viewpoint angle, while also using vibrant colours and shading to stand out. HGSS sprites were astounding for this reason.

Colosseum/GoD models tried to tap into this with Pokémon with unique, vibrant and fun idle poses and animations, but that was completely thrown out the window for XY onwards, that decided Pokémon now has to be realisticly boring for some reason, and just has Pokémon standing around like they just had a lobotomy, or worse, gliding idly. Worse yet, with washed out colour palettes. It's fucking awful.

Take Delphox as a fine example, a Pokémon which looks fantastic in sketch and design, but becoming a 3D model has made it look like absolute garbage, because it's not an animal made for idle posing 3D, it's a Pokémon. Let it pose, let it be individual.

If they overhauled current gen 3D models to have a little life, that'd be great, but we all know that isn't going to happen. The move to 3D was an inevitable change, but holy shit if it wasn't done in the worst way possible.

>>33428782
Fucking Amen. Black and White was the peak of battles, cause as well as having vibrant sprites and interesting poses, they also had intro animations, exaggerated idle movement and occasional quirky actions to break up the idle animation.

Then X and Y happened and we got laggy, washed out 3D models.

>all these retards itt don't realize ga-ole uses the same fucking models as GO, which are upscaled SM models without outlines.

File: 009.png (11KB, 120x120px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 120x120px

>>33423895
Blastoise looks like shit, its cannons look like narrow pipes

>>33423436
2d sprites

>>33428782
>>33428820
This negros right here. Sad but true

>>33428839
>which are upscaled SM models without outlines.
Wrong.

"Upscaled" implies the textures are the exact same as they were in SM. Pay attention to the words you're parroting.

File: 3d 2.gif (374KB, 426x145px) Image search: [Google]

374KB, 426x145px

I'd be down for animations like this.

were not going back to sprites

>>33423436
Right obviously. It's the same as the 3ds except without outlines, which would also look good upscaled. Pokken would require them to remodel and possibly reanimate EVERY Pokemon, again. Do you really want them to do that or do you want them to focus on making a game? The 3ds models are super hi-poly and they all have hi-res textures. They did this for a reason.

>>33424475
It really doesn't, autist.

>>33423436

Sun and Moon without the outlines

There's a mod out there that shows how much better it looks

>>33424551
No detail, no contrast, looks awful.

>>33429447
So they're completely different then? Learn the difference between a texture and a model, you fucking retard.