Sun and Moon

>>32963477
I'm glad you are not a professional reviewer

>>32963477
>Gameplay a 9
>Level Design, Story and Longevity a 1
how does that add up

File: ab8.jpg (38KB, 425x283px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 425x283px

>>32963477
>Visuals
>Gameplay
>Good

>>32963507
>Story
>gameplay

>>32963507
Moving around the world and battling is smooth and convenient. That doesn't mean that the maps or dialogue are good.

File: opp.jpg (31KB, 370x389px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 370x389px

>>32963477

>>32963492
>professional
>reviewer

>>32963555
Yeah they are bad but imagine if they were this bad

>>32963477
>Visuals 9
SM has the worse graphics of the franchise after xy

>>32963572
(You)

>>32963582
t. hothead

File: untitled.png (8KB, 370x389px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 370x389px

>>32963477

>>32963477
>3
>1
>2
>4
>1
>2
>6 (+postgame)
>1

>>32963739
Hgss for comparison
>8
>8
>7
>10
>9
>10 (realistic for a pokemon game)
>10 (+postgame)
>9

>>32963766
>level design 8
>audio 10
No

File: 1499457937983.png (9KB, 370x389px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 370x389px

A good game.

File: 1499359074434.png (58KB, 625x626px) Image search: [Google]

58KB, 625x626px

>>32963477

>>32963911
>the state of this board is so terrible that people unironically screencap and worship a random educated opinion because they can't construct an argument themselves

>>32963911
>>32963922
>pokebarneyfag is so desperate to stay relevant she screencaps her own posts and replies to herself

File: SM rating.png (11KB, 370x389px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 370x389px

>>32963477
Fixed that for you.

>>32963800
I'd make a list but national park alone would be enough to get it to people but retards why this game's stages were god-tier.
And GSC music is considered one pf the best in the franchise, and in hgss you can fully expierence that.

>>32963960
>And GSC music is considered one pf the best in the franchise, and in hgss you can fully expierence that.
No you can't, the music from GB sounds isn't the same as the original you can compare them on youtube. By level design I thought you meant the level curve, which was garbage in the originals and never fixed.

>>32963477
Level Design +1
Pokémon +4
Visuals -4
Story +3
Longevity +3
Overall +3

>>32963972
That's game design, and yes, it was improved a bit from the original, and no, it isn't that bad. Stop memeing for justify your being bad at a kid's game.
And outside the quality of the soundfonts, gsc music is generally better, and more memorable in the first place, while in XY and mostly SM the music has started to become more bland, forgettable and unisprired.

>>32963477
Sun and Moon have great pokemon designs, the problem is the terrible ones are the starters' final stages

>>32964007
By pokemon I perceived dex roster, and for some reason I felt unsatisfied with my SM team, and I still feel so. I think there are few new early interesting mon, boring old ones (alola forms didn't get me at all).
Strange since I've never felt this undatisfaction watching my complete team.

>>32963996
>Stop memeing for justify your being bad at a kid's game.
The final boss being 20 levels more than the previous boss with the only way to get you to that level is by grinding monsters 20 levels below the boss making it tedious is bad game design.

>>32964050
agreed, I like some new designs (mimikyu, cutiefly, roach, the tapus, vikabolt, taunt bait and so on) but it feels like Alola needed more mons, I never used the starters cause I hate them and that made me feel even worse; still, I think some of the new designs are good enough to make SUMO better than 1/10 in that aspect

>>32963950
>she

>>32964126
Everyone on /vp/ is a girl until proven otherwise. I've seen people on her call her a girl so idk.

File: Untitled.png (9KB, 370x389px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 370x389px

>>32963477
Slightly less than average game.

>>32963477
Good, I'm pleased to see that a lot of people dislike sun and moon. It's a Pokémon game that wasn't aimed for long time fans. It felt like a dumbed down version of everything, hell even X and Y had more content than
this, and still manage to also run MUCH more smoothly, (allowing triple battles etc) The only good thing to come out of SM is honestly is the music and some of the new Pokémon, the rest, completely inferior to other games.

There is only one game that will EVER deserve a perfect score in terms of audio.

>>32964455
Pokemon Liquid Crystal

>>32964455
Is it even a Pokemon game?

>>32963477
>Give game high gameplay and visuals, with average audio
>2 overall

>>32964572
Some categories count more than others. Good gameplay and visuals means very little when the level design sucks as much as it does. Level design is the most important aspect for Pokemon.

>>32963894
May as well give my own rating

Gameplay: 7/10
The game runs pretty well, but the engine is a bit on the slow side, and even starting a battle takes a while

Which is why this gen would have been perfect for DPPt remakes. Nostalgic speeds

Level Design: 6/10

The routes are beautiful, and there are some side areas to explore. But it's still pretty linear, and the Pokemon distribution is awful at times

Pokemon: 10/10

The designs have so much personality, it's great to see! Now if only they'd revamp the animations of older Pokemon to give them personality...

The new Pokedex entries are great, too

Audio: 8/10

Bit inappropriate at times, but overall it sounds wonderful

Visuals: 7/10

Looks pretty stunning, but unfortunately loses points both for some textures being low res enough that the pixellation clashes with the models and because CIA showd that they gimped themselves

Story: 4/10

An average story, bit frustrating at times, but... Eh, average

Longevity: 4/10

Better than some games, worse than others. I'm including postgame in this

Overall: 6

An ok game. Reminder that 5 is average, a perfectly ok game. A score of 5 or 6 means the game is still enjoyable to a degree, it just has issues it can work on

File: 1499457937983s.jpg (60KB, 1017x547px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 1017x547px

Here is my rating.

>Pokemon
>1
(u)

>>32964455
Any of the gen 4 games

man, the only thing that impressed me in SM was the story/characters. Hands-down the best story in a pokemon game, I was actually kinda invested in Lilie and her shitty mom, Guzma and the Team Skull retards were fun, and Hau turned out to not be as annoying as I thought he would be.

It's still not even really above average when it compares to other RPGs, but if you give SM a 1 then every other Pokemon game must be in the fucking negatives.

>>32965485
The story is pretty terrible if you aren't a braindead retard who doesn't look past the surface.

>>32965485
No, I actually give other Pokemon games higher story scores for NOT having story because I feel that narrative is detrimental to the experience.

>>32965485
i don't think the story and characters were all that bad, per se, but the implementation of it was so ham fisted.
but even so, the story could of been a lot better.

File: laughing sea maidens.png (189KB, 853x791px) Image search: [Google]

189KB, 853x791px

>>32963477
>looks like one of the kink diagrams I always see going around /d/ and /trash/
why the fuck are you here if pokemon are that much of a turnoff for you?