Left or right?

both

File: 1493569396300.jpg (350KB, 500x647px) Image search: [Google]

350KB, 500x647px

buns

Right's body with left's personality

the only patrician answer

>>32706961
Either one, honestly. They are about equal in my mind. Hilda is slightly better for breeding, Rosa is slightly better for cuddlng.

>>32707236
I'm not trying to call you out here, but what even is Hilda's personality?

File: C71eeCt.jpg (13KB, 207x193px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 207x193px

>>32707236
>going after a modest rack
>when the left has the rump of a goddess, the more important area in procreation
ain't no patrician in that.

left always delicious hilda

>>32707462
I dunno. General cuteness has Rosa winning out.
This is a tough one. Don't kneejerk it. Think on it carefully.

File: 2146.jpg (341KB, 900x1200px) Image search: [Google]

341KB, 900x1200px

yes

>>32706961

Hilda. Rosa's design is disgusting.

File: 1495143153025.png (783KB, 1134x1134px) Image search: [Google]

783KB, 1134x1134px

>>32707487
What cuteness? the obvious Leia buns, the 'dress like I just got out of bed five minutes ago' outfit, the colors clash horribly against each other

Hilda's got a cute ponytail, and can take her shorts off to reveal a lovely summer dress, she's combined two possible outfits into one.

one of these two obviously has better fashion sense.

File: 1383186816547.jpg (1MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1920x1080px

>>32707548
Hilda literally dresses like trailer trash
>trucker hat
>wife beater
>torn booty shorts
>ugly ill fitting vest

I've always liked how simple Hilda's outfit is. It looks like something you'd wear for trekking around outside, all roughed up and stuff. Also, long, wavy brown hair is amazing.

File: 1474311788872.png (986KB, 800x960px) Image search: [Google]

986KB, 800x960px

>>32706961
>Rosa
Better tits
Better outfit
Better face
Spats

>Hilda
Better hair

>>32708006
Don't mention her outfit. Hildafags don't get it. They think it's actually good.

File: 1382860711671.jpg (270KB, 1200x845px) Image search: [Google]

270KB, 1200x845px

>>32708140
>spats
they're tights or leggings. spats are short.

File: 1495150185005.png (480KB, 800x886px) Image search: [Google]

480KB, 800x886px

>>32708006
it's moreso about function, while still having the luxury of elegance with a quick strip down

>hat keeps hair in place and out of the way
it's a tucked in summer dress not a fucking wifebeater - but hey a lot of people get that wrong too, even fan artist.
>shorts keep the dress from getting snagged in underbrush
>also keeps delicate fabric dress from getting torn

Rosa dresses like she's color blind and taking a stroll in the park, not going on a pokemon journey. If she at least had an ounce of color co-ordination, I'd give it a second thought.

>>32708121
exactly Hilda is ready for adventure, and can easily change in the bathroom for an ice cream social in the nearest town.

>>32708140
>better outfit
are you color blind too?

File: 1368043364003.jpg (369KB, 1200x960px) Image search: [Google]

369KB, 1200x960px

>>32708161
>while still having the luxury of elegance with a quick strip down

Its a fucking wifebeater. her shorts are so torn up the pockets are visible. it is not a dress tucked into the shorts.

the only female protag that dresses worse than hilda is original recipe chicken chan.

>>32708161
>function
Function doesn't please my dick. It doesn't please anyone's dicks. If you want functionality, shave her head and give her even more generic clothes. That's function. But that looks shit. And that's the point. Functionality can fuck itself if it doesn't look good. Which Hilda's outfit doesn't.

>>32708244
even if it is a wifebeater, at least she follows a logical color palate, every time I look at rosa's outfit my eyes scream, it would have been fine otherwise.

>>32708252
you act like practical and aesthetic are mutually exclusive, I assure you they're not

those donuts on rosa's head are neither aesthetic or functional, so there's that.

maybe I'm just desensitized to hilda's outfit coming from a part of the US literally no woman ever wears a dress. I can count the number of times I've seen a woman in a dress outside of formal occasions on one hand.

I don't have a doughnut fetish and Hilda is the best female protagonist design so left

>>32708373
>>32708161
>Rosa dresses like she's color blind
>every time I look at rosa's outfit my eyes scream
Explain this. Since when did blue/white and black/yellow start hurting eyes? Aren't those among the most popular choices? Something frequently used in not just clothing, but also in Pokemon design?

File: 9931a3fc61360b5e343f451c9797caee.jpg (757KB, 889x888px) Image search: [Google]

757KB, 889x888px

I say both.

>>32708431
alright fine, give me a minute to get a crash course in color theory

you had it coming.

File: Crash-Course-in-Color-Theor.jpg (3MB, 3000x2850px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 3000x2850px

>>32708431
>>32708703

it took longer than I expected because things came up, but here, the gist of it

>>32706961
Right, I like boobs and kawaii feminine girls
I'm not much for tomboy and asses, that's not to say Hilda is bad

File: 1492888260071.jpg (181KB, 626x885px) Image search: [Google]

181KB, 626x885px

>>32706961

Right

>>32706961
Left.
>Bare legs.
>Better hair.

>>32709349
>notice how even with black and yellow this one is nice than the one above?
No, I don't. Because it looks fucking shit.
Instead of trying wasting you time making so many shit looking versions of Rosa to somehow prove you point, I would recommend trying a google search next time. 3 seconds on google got me "Black, white, and yellow can create a glamorous, high-contrast look" and "Blue and yellow are surprisingly flexible; they work with modern or country styles". Surprise, surprise! Those are the four main colors of Rosa's dress.

File: 1401091549043.jpg (50KB, 464x444px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 464x444px

>>32708006
>>32708158
>rosafags calling out Hilda for her style
Oh, the fucking irony.

>>32706961
Ponytail > Buns

>>32708140
Hilda has the better outfit and face though.

File: IMG_2443.jpg (358KB, 1706x2048px) Image search: [Google]

358KB, 1706x2048px

I want to fuck Rosa and Nate!

File: 1474304812843.jpg (260KB, 1308x1131px) Image search: [Google]

260KB, 1308x1131px

>>32706961
Obviously right.

File: CMYK___A_Minimal_Wallpaper_by_keylocker.jpg (223KB, 1920x1200px) Image search: [Google]

223KB, 1920x1200px

>>32709429
>Black, white, and yellow can create a glamorous, high-contrast look
>Blue and yellow are surprisingly flexible; they work with modern or country styles

You fail to notice how black and blue are distinctly separate and not together in either suggestion, that's because too many colors cause fights for attention, which is exactly what's happening in the clusterfuck that is rosa's wardrobe.

What's next? Brown, green, red and white? If you're going to throw so many different contrasting colors, you have to have buffers - transition colors. the problem with black in yellow particularly in her case is they're bunched together in the instinctive warning pattern, then it abruptly goes to white, blue and a bit too much pink. Neither of your 3-second google search grasps this, there's colors here not accounted for in their advice.

the color palate planned was without a doubt CMYK, the execution was poor. All these colors could have worked, they just put them in the wrong places that it just becomes distracting.

3 seconds of google is not a substitute for actual knowledge in color theory.

File: 1367211498133.jpg (1MB, 1500x1157px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1500x1157px

>>32709349
5 and 3 look like shit. 4 is pretty good, but its basically pastel Supergirl, hard to fuck up. They all look better than Hilda though, because Hilda looks like she got her clothes out of a a literal dumpster fire.

>>32709700
5 is perfectly in line with
>Blue and yellow are surprisingly flexible; they work with modern or country styles
so I don't follow you on that one, maybe without the black leggings because it loses the 'chic' coloring.

4 could have been improved with a yellow bow and visor

3 would have been better with a blue bow and visor

I'm going to go back at real quick to better balance the CMYK aspect

>>32706961
Right, but probably just because I have a tights fetish.

>>32709800
pale yellow arms on a white shirt make it look like hard water, tons of cigarette smoke, or piss stains. It's just ugly.

File: efe34969acb18c4d7c8fab82ba6d9413.jpg (188KB, 1020x1378px) Image search: [Google]

188KB, 1020x1378px

>>32706961
>Left or right?
>implying Left is an option when she is my wife, you dick

The fuck is this shit? Hilda is mine only, you cannot choose her.

>>32709349
Well, what you're saying makes sense on paper, but the execution is what made it work for Rosa. You ignored that, which is why 3 and 5 look pretty bad. Especially 5. The yellow sleeves are just jutting out, not contrasting or blending in properly. 4 looks good, but having the skirt be pink is just boring. It gets too little attention now. The yellow contrasted with her black stockings and was a lot more visually interesting. As you mentioned, it immediately grabs your attention, I don't think that's an inherently a bad thing.

Now, too many bright colors fighting for attention is could be a problem. But here, the blue and white are complementary colors. Instead of fighting for attention, they blend in and simply let your attention flow from one to another. And the color meeting yellow is white, which, as the other anon brought it up, "can create a glamorous, high-contrast look". The blue doesn't meet the yellow or black and isn't fighting anything for attention. This is a bunch of different, but nice ideas in a single design. Now, if you want call it a clusterfuck, go ahead. I prefer to call it interesting.

If you want something that lets your eyes move anywhere you want, with no part attracting any extra attention, Rosa's outfit isn't for you. I don't. Her shorts attract attention to her legs, and her legs are pretty good looking, so I prefer it this way. With her shorts being the first thing to attract your attention, the surrounding colors are black and white. You're free to let your eyes flow either way. If you look at the white, your eyes are smoothly taken all the way to the face with, and if you look at the black, well, you see her legs.

This is just how I see it. I'm not going to pretend everyone thinks the same. I doubt other Rosafags even think the same, much less non-Rosafags.

File: CMYK-V2-.jpg (3MB, 3000x2850px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 3000x2850px

>>32709866
here's a quick repaint

when blue and yellow are dominate, flesh legs work better as it keeps a 'chic' cooring

although I think 4 is the best in this batch.

File: screams geometrically.jpg (271KB, 1440x1080px) Image search: [Google]

271KB, 1440x1080px

>>32710117
>flesh legs work better
DROPPED, FUCKING WRONG on all counts! What the HELL is your problem? How can one anon be SO FUCKING WRONG!?

>>32710184
I get the Zettai ryōiki aspect, but she doesn't even have a zone, I'm merely speculating on a color matchup, black kills a 'chic' feel when you got blue, yellow and white going.

>>32710211
>get the Zettai ryōiki aspect
You really dont get what is appealing about Rosas design at all if thats what you thought at first. It's not about what colors are there in which proportions, she looks good in the clothes she is wearing.

Anyone have that clothing swap with Hilda? you know the one. with the hips. She looks loads better, because her normal clothes are actual trash tier.

File: CMYK-V3.jpg (3MB, 3000x2850px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 3000x2850px

somehow I didn't think of pink shirt, yellow skirt until now

File: 1404949274178.jpg (334KB, 810x570px) Image search: [Google]

334KB, 810x570px

>>32710322
Original is still the best, pastel Supergirl and number 4 here are passable.

File: 1491771835374.jpg (84KB, 312x321px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 312x321px

>>32710117
>flesh legs work better as it keeps a 'chic' cooring
Now that's just wrong. The pantyhose just accentuates her legs, one of the most appealing parts of a female body. I was almost following you until now. But now I'm convinced you have no idea what you're talking about.

>>32710358
>>32710184

black interrupts a pastel color palate aka 'chic', but this just affirms something I was wondering for the past 2 hours - the black stockings are necessitated from a stocking fetish, not that there's anything wrong with it, but it's obviously going to chuck a wrench into entirely acceptable coloring palates that only work without black.

if we had just established that from square one, it'd save the effort of making swaps that you'll never appreciate on principal, even when the coloring is acceptable otherwise.

>>32710452
It's not a stocking fetish, it's an absolute definitive character design point. Same thing with the hair buns. They can not go.

To put in terms of other costume design, go ask /co/ if Superman should have the trunks or not.

You just dont understand costuming and focus on color. likely a painter/colorist of some sort.

File: 1360807990467.png (39KB, 225x283px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 225x283px

>>32706961
Both
I'm jumping on those Artfx-J figure preorders as soon as they show up
Though I still wish the boy protags got more attention besides just RBY Red.

>>32710579
Brendan is the only visually interesting one, and May simply commands too much of the gen 3 attention.

>>32707236
>Right's body
This.
Traps are hot.

File: 1487483119305.jpg (65KB, 560x1024px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 560x1024px

>>32710653
>male Rosa

>>32710482
graphic design, not too far off. if we keep the stockings somethings gotta be done about the yellow skirt as it pulls the eyes down where it's not even the main focus of her.

hilda is focused on her ponytail, booty shorts, and bare legs, although I think she could do well with some thigh highs, then there's too much black with the jacket.

rosa is focused on her more feminine face, bustier chest, and hair buns.

the colors she has work, it's a matter of placement, possibly a striped or dotted skirt with white to make it less loud.

a pink skirt is a bit tacky I'll admit

a blue skirt doesn't work too well right next to black, that'd have to blue/white striped or dotted.

a white skirt would be too plain.

with the yellow skirt still standing as a solid yellow, a white/pink shirt draws enough attention up to even it out. swap the bow, hat and logo colors until you find a nice balance.
>>32710322
1 does pretty much that.

>>32710735
White skirt with a single blue stripe, low near the hemline.

File: stripped skirt.png (1MB, 1503x928px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1503x928px

>>32710747
so something like this?

>>32710579
Brendan's design in Emerald is the best male protagonist design yet.

File: 1495208019534.png (841KB, 1952x2704px) Image search: [Google]

841KB, 1952x2704px

Left. Always left

>>32710994
now with blue sleeves, yellow hat and logo. Then I will find your redesign acceptable.

>>32711020
hadnt noticed the bow was blue, make that pink instead as well.

File: 1373821508655.jpg (171KB, 1340x1075px) Image search: [Google]

171KB, 1340x1075px

>>32711096
unrecognizable, could be any smug animu grill.

File: blue stripe gold acc.png (1MB, 1503x928px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1503x928px

>>32711033
kind of underwhelming in the pink department, but pink is a rather loud color. I might actually do a proper vector recolor, I used to have fun doing that on /w/ before I did professional work. since it's not a paid job I'd definitely take my sweet time, the thread would 404 before that no doubt. I do hate the paint bucket 3 step shading, but it's fine for a quick prototype.

>>32707462
>the more important area in procreation
Yes but a more supple breast means a more well fed offspring

>>32707548
I'm pretty sure she's just wearing a tank top in the white things coming out of her shorts are actually the pockets

File: great job.jpg (144KB, 1024x768px) Image search: [Google]

144KB, 1024x768px

>>32706961
>better ass
>doesn't dress like trailer trash
right easily, why is this even a question?

File: 1493160730705.png (350KB, 733x550px) Image search: [Google]

350KB, 733x550px

>>32711209
One can dream right?

File: pokemon_bw__may_trainer_back_by_luckygirl88-d3ilnaj.png (10KB, 303x255px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 303x255px

>>32711193
https://www.babycenter.com/404_is-it-true-that-moms-with-small-breasts-produce-less-milk_10310185.bc

patently false

>>32711210
hilda's got the better rump, this is also a fact.

pokemon ass or pokemon tits are the options here.

File: Best girl and best girl.jpg (161KB, 800x1132px) Image search: [Google]

161KB, 800x1132px

>>32706961
Both

>>32709700
meanwhile rosa looks like a doughnut shop's dumpster

>>32711753
>doughnut shop's
that is a weird way to spell cum.

File: 1488068766623.jpg (166KB, 550x566px) Image search: [Google]

166KB, 550x566px

I love them both but I like Rosa slightly more

File: smug rosa.jpg (417KB, 500x564px) Image search: [Google]

417KB, 500x564px

Rosa's my type

File: 1338638663510.jpg (61KB, 490x539px) Image search: [Google]

61KB, 490x539px

Tough to say.
Rosa is generally more cuter, and I'm a sucker for pantyhoes.
Hilda looks like a girl that's a fairly chill slut that will eat pizza and play video games before or after sex. She also has an amazing ass.

Gen 5 as a whole had some nice girls. Gen 7 beats it by a hair because of Lusamine.

>>32706961
I choose the one that wears the cutest panties.