1. Crystal 2. Y 3. Fire Red 4. Ruby 5.Red/Blue

File: be strong for mother.gif (762KB, 225x400px) Image search: [Google]

762KB, 225x400px

>>32624703
>Y
Explain further.

As for my own tasted,
1. Crystal (mainly due to nostalgia)
2. HGSS (objectively better than Crystal except for the music and graphics, which I prefer Crystal's out of aforementioned nostalgia)
3. Emerald
4. White 2
5. Platinum

File: 1495952401954.gif (391KB, 180x297px) Image search: [Google]

391KB, 180x297px

>>32624703
1. BW
2. HGSS/Crystal
3. BW2
4. Emerald
5. Platinum

>>32624746
>hey guys, am I cool: the post

>>32624746
Good taste. If I lumped Crystal and HGSS together in my post >>32624732 BW1 would've been the new #5.

>>32624749
Wat

1. Black/White
2. HeartGold/SoulSilver
3.Black 2/White 2
4.Platinum
5. Crystal

Maybe its just me, but for me
1.hgss
2.frlg
3.rse
4.bw1/2
5.dp&platinum

>>32624703
1: Pearl
2: Black
3: Moon
4: Alpha Sapphire
5: Soul Silver

>>32624749
Toad-tully

>>32624751
Wat dunt u get the post is oozing tryhard to please

>>32624775
>Pearl
Is there a reason you picked Pearl over Platinum?

1. B2W2
2. HGSS
3. Platinum
4. FRLG
5. BW/SM, it's a tie

>>32624787
Simple really, because I haven't played Platinum.

1. HGSS
2. Emerald
3. Platinum
4. B2W2
5. BW

>>32624817
I was the same for a while with Diamond. I hadn't played any of my gen 4 games since gen 5 came out so when I decided to revisit Sinnoh I went with platinum. Definitely recommend it if you ever feel like playing gen4 again

>>32624749
>hey guys, no fun allowed: the reply

1: Gale of Darkness
2: Colosseum
3: Stadium 2
4: Battle Revolution
5: Stadium 1

from the ones i've played

1. ranger
2. pmd2
3. b/w
4. platinum
5. emerald

File: platinum.gif (451KB, 256x191px) Image search: [Google]

451KB, 256x191px

1. Platinum
2. HGSS
3. B2W2
4. FRLG
5. SM

>>32624703
1. B2/W2
2. Emerald
3. FR/LG
4. HG/SS
5. R/B

>>32624703
that's some pretty shit taste

>>32624703
1. BW/BW2
2. Platinum
3. XY
4. Emerald/ORAS
5. FRLG

>>32624703

1. Platinum
2. HG/SS
3. Emerald
4. FR/LG
5. B2/W2

>>32624732
Fully agree with everything except I'd replace Platinum with Y. Other than that, top tier taste anon.

1. Blue
2. SoulSilver
3. Diamond (and I played Platinum)
4. LeafGreen
5. Y

I'm considering how much fun I had playing it back in their days and the good memories they bring to me.

>>32626218
>no hg/ss
>XY
>FRLG in top 5
wew

>>32624732
You know there's an item in HGSS that lets you change the music to the OG soundtrack, right?

Not saying you can't like Crystal better but c'mon

>>32626784
GB Sounds is fantastic in concept but it's really, really bad in execution. It's quite inaccurate, especially with regards to the Gameboy's waveform channel, which they just turned into a third pulse channel, ruining any song that used the waveform's unique sounds for its melody like the National Park theme.
When I first played HGSS I didn't notice anything wrong at all, but then I got into hacking, spent a LOT of time with Gen 2's audio capabilities, decided to replay HGSS (specifically the Drayano hack, which gives you the GB Sounds at the start of the game), turned it on, and was immediately horrified at what I was hearing. It was like going to Disney World and seeing Mickey Mouse take off his head revealing a man in a suit.
Again, it was fantastic in concept, just executed really bad. I imagine a GBA Sounds in ORAS would've worked a lot better because DirectSound is a lot closer to MIDI and the GBC channels don't play a very large role in most songs, but then ORAS half-assed a lot of things so they didn't bother putting a GBA Sounds in the game.

File: 1495864129838.jpg (24KB, 446x320px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 446x320px

1. B2/W2
2. S/M
3. HG/SS
4. OR/AS
5. Emerald

>>32624703

1.Y/X
2.Alpha Sapphire
3.Sapphire
4.Diamond
5.White/White 2

>>32626897
Cool to know, thanks for the insight anon.

Personally I thought HGSS had one of the best soundtracks of any Pokemon game. If anything, FRLG needed GB Sounds.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O2Hs4s9LLVg

Crystal
Y
White 2
Omega Ruby
Fire Red

>>32624703
1. B2/W2
2. Platinum
3. HG/SS
4. Emerald
5. S/M

Generic af taste, I'm aware.

File: 1394504142142.png (680KB, 600x570px) Image search: [Google]

680KB, 600x570px

>>32629852
>Generic af taste

so is mine. who cares.
1. Emerald
2. HG/SS
3. OR/AS
4. BW2
5. S/M

>>32629829
I've seen a hack somewhere that implements GB Sounds (multiple actually, but one of them was Liquid Crystal and Liquid Crystal's GB Sounds is somehow just as flawed as HGSS's despite the GBA's hardware having everything needed for a 100% accurate GB Sounds), I'll have to try and find it again and see how accurate it is.
And Ho-Oh's theme is pretty fucking great. It's even better ported to the GBC.
https://pigu-a.bandcamp.com/track/ho-oh-battle
Lugia's theme is also good but it's a bit less catchy, which is a shame because I grew up with Silver.

>>32624703
Ranger 2
Platinum
BW
BW 2
Emerald

File: GetTheFuckOuttaMyFace.gif (499KB, 400x306px) Image search: [Google]

499KB, 400x306px

>There are people on this board right now who count XY among their top five favourite Pokémon games

>>32630305
I had more fun playing Y than any game from Gen V and Gen VII. So it is easy to end up at my top 5.

>>32630305
I like XY more for what they could've been than what they are. Most of the pieces for a beautiful picture are there, but several key pieces are missing, and it leaves the puzzle unfinished with even many pieces that are there unable to come together. Simply imagining that completed puzzle, for me, is a greater experience than some other completed ones.

>>32629990
Pretty cool bandcamp. Nostalgia aside I have to agree there was something special about the gameboy music. What are some of the tracks you liked better in GSC?

Here's one from Red that I like a lot better than in FRLG: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMCYDDZrAlA

>>32624817
Platinum is a vastly superior version, you should absolutely try it.