Just what defines a "good" Pokémon game to you?

Gen 5/sun and moons characters and story
BW2 like postgame full of a lot of side junk to keep me happy for ages
Gen 6/7 Breeding
Dexnav

>>30910205
Sacred Gold & Storm Silver

>>30910205
Do everything Platinum did except use a different regional dex and don't put it in Sinnoh or Unova.

>>30910205
>Pokemon
>good

>>30910205
Does it have Pokemon? If yes then it is good.

>>30910205
Whatever SM was

>>30910228
This. Add in Gen 5 species diversity (new pokemon fucking everywhere, and older ones available after the story is done.)

>>30910572
This. Just make the majority of the designs actually good though, or else it'll just turn off people all over again.

Pretty much just being Pokemon.

>>30910655
>vague fucking answer
there are only two genders ya relativist

>>30910689
>current year
>still replying to tripfags
>not filtering them
What are you even doing?

Post game (bf)
150+ new pokemon
Attractive girls
Badass psuedo legendary
Walking pokemon
2+ regions
Unique new region
Fan service

The title has "red" or "blue" in it.

>>30910205
Lots of content, including new content

Non eye rolling story

Not asking for much tbqh

>>30910772
Grandpa, what did we say about leaving the home without permission?


But it's nice to hear you liked fire red... shame about leaf green though. and yellow

>>30910205
New pokemon or least one new feature

>>30910772
So Diamond and EaRl?

Every Mystery Pokémon Mystery Dungeon game

Pokémon Trading Card game

Pokémon Pinball Ruby & Sapphire

Pokémon Ranger Guardian Signs

Pokémon Rumble U

And Art Academy?

>mystery dungeon
>platinum
>bw but not the shitty sequels
>red and blue
All set.

>>30910642
>Implying a majority of BWs designs were bad

Boy, are we gonna turn this thread into another Genwar?

>>30910205
SM but with battle frontier

>>30910205
A combination of a good story, a good in-game Pokemon selection, and an extensive post-game.

File: AAAAAAAAH.jpg (18KB, 310x250px)

18KB, 310x250px

>>30912043
>ANYONE WHO DISAGREES WITH ME ON HOW PERFECT GEN 5 WAS WANTS TO START A GENWAR

>>30912106
Anyone who outright mentions a generation is bad wants to start a genwar, period.

>Generation whatever is bad
You want to incite a genwar.

>I don't like generation whatever
You're being reasonable by stating an opinion.

>>30912165
>Just make the majority of the designs actually good though, or else it'll just turn off people all over again.

it's a genuine opinion anon, it's the reason it didn't sell as good for normies

>>30910228
>story
Muh Nebby

>>30912210
It sold almost as much as DP though

They were the 6th and 7th highest selling games on the ds

>>30912210
Stating that something is bad is far from an opinion, because you're saying that it's inherently so, a fact. And it's not.

>I think that the designs weren't appealing for people in general
This is more of an opinion.

Why the fuck do I have to educate you little shits about what are facts and opinions, shit, it's almost like you failed kindergarten

>>30910205

> Did the area and ambience feel unique compared to other games?

> Was there new unique pokemon who had large ties to the areas they were found in solidifying relations in my mind?

>Could i relate to the motives of the antagonists or friends of the player?

>Was the cast full of 1 dimensional stereotypes?

>Did they actually manage to flesh out any one character this time around?

>Was there a satisfactory amount of normal animals for me to collect added compared to all the legendary/mega/beasts/other elementary schooler porn in the gen?

>were there puzzles satisfying to beat in the overworld?

>Did i feel connected to nature in the game

>ARE THE BATTLE SEQUENCES ABLE TO BE SPED THROUGH FASTER THAN EVER BEFORE

>>30910205
Without gen 1 reference.

File: laugh.jpg (259KB, 800x600px)

259KB, 800x600px

>>30912334

Improved EV training.
Ridding the series of the awfulness of Blue and Red.
I mean, Sleep makes you lose a turn COME ON PEOPLE GET WITH IT.

New evolution lines from Gen IV.
Delicious Yuri yuum~
A healthy metagame to grow from NO MORE TALONFLAME GAME FREAK LISTEN TO YOUR REAL FANS.

A mature and well written story like Game of Thrones, I repeat, POKEMON IS NOT JUST FOR CHILDREN.

Post-game content is all that really matters, forget about the journey.
More Otome~ to bring more women to the series, yes ladies, I'm talking to you ;) I know what you like.

QUALITY OF LIFE IMPORVEMENTS NINTENDO.
God, why do I have to go into a menu and do this when it did the other thing like this in Ruby why nintendo why

Remember guys, Gen 1 is the worst Pokemon game even though it laid out the foundations for everything.

>>30910228
FPBP

>>30912647
>I mean, Sleep makes you lose a turn COME ON PEOPLE GET WITH IT.
>WAAAH GF GRASS TYPES SUCK NOW YOU RETARDS CAN'T BALANCE SHIT WAAAH

>>30912334
Yes, it's an opinion. And you thinking that they're not is also an opinion. However, it is a fact that people were turned off by a lot Unova's Pokémon. Seriously, this is am undisputed fact, you can argue that they're wrong of course, but it doesn't change that most people hates designs such as the monkeys and the genies. Perhaps you should go back to kindergarten, seeing as how you don't know when a statement is an opinion or a fact.

It's fun.

>>30912989
>However, it is a fact that people were turned off by a lot Unova's Pokémon
Yes this is a fact. But it's irrelevant for a very simple reason: not everybody were turned off by the unovan mons. And saying that "most people hate designs such as the monkeys and the genies" is still opinion unless backed by data showing otherwise.

If you don't like the mons, fine, that's okay. But don't push your own opinions and make it look as if everyone shares it.

Why the fuck do I even fall for bait.

>>30910205
Baramons and husbandos everywhere. Pokemon Refresh included for both.

>>30910205
comfy region
comfy music
cool mons
postgame
exploration
basically Platinum but with less/no HMs and not slow

>>30910228
Gen 4 tier music

>>30910205
That I enjoyed playing it.

Despite its flaws I still enjoyed playing ORAS, but vanilla B/W and D/P can be a bit of a slog.

>>30910205
Comfiness, consistency, and freedom.
Three things that Sun and Moon didn't have.

Literally anything that isnt gen6

>>30914871
nice way to ruin a good post

>>30914493
this

>>30914871
Gen 4 had shit tier music

A good villain, story, and OST.
A satisfactory ending also helps.

BW1 and SM are the best games for me.

>>30915147
>>30915030
I agree with them. There were some tracks I disliked but a lot were good.

>>30910205
I have fun when I play it.