Fair Game Rankings

>>30001937
X and Y are C

>>30001937
Switch OR/AS and R/S and you have a good list.

>>30001937
I agree, I'd keep RS on B even though.

>>30001958
you already lost op. /thread.

File: 1476933808782.png (171KB, 650x398px) Image search: [Google]

171KB, 650x398px

I like them all for their own reasons and probably enjoyed then equally

>>30001985
I think it's pretty good if people only have very minor changes

>>30001958
I disagree with this, but I dont think C is too unreasonable. Actually, I do think the're too bad for C, but I get why one may disagree.

>>30001971
ORAS has a lot more that gets me angry than RS but the QoL changes alone keep it up that high

Platinum goes in S

HeartGold goes in A

SoulSilver goes in B

>>30001971
I agree with this. Everything else looks good

>>30002000
trips of truth

I feel the same way, anon

I also like all Pokemon this way

>>30001937

>liking Black and White

ah yes. the games that started the cancer that is killing the series.

Good to see Diamond and Pearl are three ranks below plat though, the save times alone justify that choice.

Really, I'd put Plat in S, Black, white, Black2, and Whit2 all in C, bump saphire/ruby up to a B, and make a special F rank for Red/Blue for being buggy as fuck. Beyond that though, looks mostly fine. I'm a little curious what makes you put Crystal above Silver/Gold though, it's just a slight variation on the aforementioned games.

>>30002107
>platinum, emerald, and HG/SS not god tier
>gen 1 games god tier

Nice bait faggot i fell for it

>>30002107

please promise this is ironic anon. I just came here for the first time, I don't want to find out /vp/ is so thoroughly infected by Gen Wunners

File: 12410536_4.jpg (72KB, 865x759px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 865x759px

>>30002107
>tfw I saved this image too

>>30002136
Crystal added the Battle Tower, the female playable character, additions to RUins of Alph, Buena's Password (and in turn, minigames) and made several aesthetic changes to the region to make it better (like putting Ice in Ice Path)

It improves the experience in numerous small ways

>>30002184
Yes /vp/ is filled with genwunners, and yes that is ironic

There's literally a trainer in Sun/Moon who says "I'll put my hips into it when I take you on!" before battling you. Nobody else can top that.

File: bragging rights.png (8KB, 480x320px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 480x320px

>>30002287

>>30001937
ahh, ranking them against each other I see, because in my opinion Red and Blue should be under S

File: 1364923021065.gif (982KB, 320x287px) Image search: [Google]

982KB, 320x287px

>>30002049
>HeartGold goes in A
>SoulSilver goes in B
nigga shut up

>>30002523
literally why

>>30001937
Wow OP that's literally my exact rankings. Had ORAS contained Frontier it would have been instant S, but lack of postgame really killed an otherwise solid remake of my favorite gen.

>>30001937
Have I seen this before

It's good taste

I'd switch the hoenn games and drop B/W down a tier. otherwise good shit m8

>>30003030
Ive posted this once or twice. Though it's tweaked a bit.

Will probably post again after playing SM

>>30002874
This. If Frontier was in it, ORAS would have been killer. Still, the game was fantastic without it even if it was a bit easy.

>>30003108
I disliked more than the frontier, but the stuff I disliked would have been easier to ignore with that huge piece of content right there.