Now that the dust has settled, are we all in agreement?

>X and Y
>good tier
no

>>29969009
>le xy are bad meme
>being this much of a /vp/ parrot

>>29968980
BW2 belongs to top tier. No reason for it being below Platinum.

>>29969042
Unova being a mediocre region, mostly.

>>29968980
fr/lg and emerald are on the same level of quality, put them in good. Swap ORAS with XY.

File: 1478532207486.png (56KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 1000x1000px

>>29968980
>>29969022
>X and Y
>good
Fuck off, they're worse than ORAS.

>>29969068
imagine having taste this shit

>>29969051
Unova is a better region than Sinnoh.
Sinnoh's main campaign is the second worst after Gen 3's

File: 1437020015509.jpg (42KB, 625x626px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 625x626px

>>29968980
>great tier
>SM

>>29969051
Unova is a diverse region with cool cites seasons and good music.

>>29968980
Where is Diamond and Pearl?

>>29969053
>fr/lg and emerald are on the same level of quality

'no'

Kanto is easily the worst region. Kanto is so boring that I honestly never want to play in that region again, unless it gets a revamp in a sequel or something.

File: underage will deny this.png (2MB, 1588x1484px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1588x1484px

>>29968980
If your first reaction to this is to scramble for your bait.jpg, you're probably underage and lack the perspective to understand why it's true

Emerald was good not great, XY deserve an OK tier not bottom not good, plat I can't speak on haven't played it since its release and all I can remember is not liking it much but I may replay it soon.

>>29969022
What about it is a meme?

>>29969117
Holy fuck this is actually great bait. I will be using this in the future. Thanks, anon.

>>29968980
when will this shitty fucking meme die

>>29969117
>I'm an underaged because I like the 2nd games that came out

File: 50880692_p31.png (505KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

505KB, 1200x1200px

>>29969042
BW2 were great but they had tiny flaws.
Like >>29969051 said, Unova is linear and a shit.
It forced some shitty side quests (Hey kid, wanna be a movie star?).
And sometimes I forget about Hugh's existence despite how good the game is.

>>29969081
By "it", do you mean yours?
I couldn't even begin to imagine. You poor thing.

>>29969096
Redundant because Platinum exists.

How about

TOP TEIR (in no particular order)
S/M
ORAS
XY
B2W2
BW
HGSS
DPPt
FRLG
RSE
GSC
RBY

>>29969154
Not him

Those are respectable flaws, but Unova has just as much to explore as Johto does

>>29968980
I'm convinced the only reason people love HGSS is because they're underage and it was their first experience with Johto.

>>29969131
XY is objectively good. It's a meme to hate it because the meme only really exists on /vp/, where it's repeated until everyone just accepts it as fact. ORAS only goes in bottom tier because it manages to be worse than the game it's based on.

>>29969154
>Unova is linear and a shit
Like literally every gen after 1.
>It forced some shitty side quests (Hey kid, wanna be a movie star?)
You don't have to do the quest
>And sometimes I forget about Hugh's existence despite how good the game is

Every rival who isn't called Blue or Silver is forgettable. Who the fuck was even your rival in D/P/P?

>>29969107
pleb

>>29969285
t. kantonigger

Shouldn't you be getting a drink for your security guards right now?

>>29969086
This
Sinnoh's towns and cities are pretty forgettable, definitely not better than Unova.
I'll agree Unova is nos exactly good, but I appreciate the intent of having "realistic" cities based on New York and the idea of Gyms being something else beside just Gyms was actually pretty cool

>>29968980

>dust has settled
>game hasn't even officially come out yet

What? You know some of us actually have patience and/or jobs to occupy their time other than pokemon and don't download the CIA immediately, right?

The dust hasn't even been fucking kicked up yet.

>>29969324
hello newfag, please fuck off.

>>29969117
if youre going to flaunt your shit taste, master chief, the least you could do is explain yourself

File: 1439771422971.jpg (29KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 600x600px

Anyone who post 3d pokemon games are good is underage or turning 18 this year

File: 1478358343548.jpg (43KB, 350x499px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 350x499px

>>29969222
>Like literally every gen after 1.
Hoenn, and Sinnoh are designed like actual territories and not like some shape.

Johto is sort of linear.
It just has a dead end that forces you to turn around, the middle city that has at least two roads connected to it, and a spot that puts you right back at the start.

>You don't have to do the quest
Play the game again.
It literally pulls you by the arm just to show you the studio and there's nothing you can do about it.

>Every rival who isn't called Blue or Silver is forgettable.
>Who the fuck was even your rival in D/P/P?
Barry, the guy who's always fining my and the son of the Frontier Bran Whatshisface.

>>29968980
Perfect top tier.

>>29969401
actually it's underage people that tend to hate new pokemon games

hello 14 year old

File: image.jpg (88KB, 750x405px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 750x405px

>>29969206
If you think GF tried in Kalos I feel bad for you, but this is just bait and I'm too autistic to let it go

>>29969438
holy shit you're retarded

File: HE40Nsbk.jpg (55KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 512x512px

>>29969401
Anyone who can't accept the fact that people like stuff one may not like is definitely underage and autstic.

File: enraged man-bat.jpg (97KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

97KB, 640x480px

>>29969401
>Colosseum and Gate of Darkness weren't good

File: 1374669838636.png (30KB, 864x594px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 864x594px

>>29968980

>HG/SS in top
>B/W only in Good

The Johto remakes fixed nothing but Kanto.

File: 1478966157804.jpg (9KB, 324x270px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 324x270px

>>29969206
I really hope you're just baiting for (you)s.

ITT: people pretending that they enjoyed XY

>>29969500
How am I wrong? XY only gets hate on /vp/. When XY came out, it was liked on /vp/. As time went on people just started hating on it.

That's the definition of a meme. You faggots literally just kept repeating it over and over until you adopted it as your own opinion.

>>29969438
Oh wow. I remember the rival battles being easy but holy shit this is ridiculous.

Is there ANY reason to give these Pokemon less than four moves? They're level 50. The fight is close to victory road. It's supposed to be hard. What were they thinking?

>>29969512
>pretending

stay mad, unovanigger

>>29969453
Ok, show me where XY was "good" like you say

>>29969420
Is that a real doujin? I need more delinquent-chan in my life. I want to kiss her

>>29969521
People only liked XY because it was kanto and lucario bait, anon. Other than that, it was a breeze to complete and no post-game.

>>29969420
>Hoenn, and Sinnoh are designed like actual territories and not like some shape.
Lmao, no. Stop sugarcoating Sinnoh and especially Hoenn. They are as linear as every other fucking game post Kanto. And linearity aside, Hoenn is by far the worst designed region.
>It literally pulls you by the arm just to show you the studio and there's nothing you can do about it.
Yeah, some dude shows you the studio, but you are not forced to shoot a film.
>Barry
Sorry, who?

>>29969572
No you're retarded for posting that image of Tierno, as if anyone on /vp/ will fall for your shitt "Tierno was the rival" meme.

Also dumb iphone poster.

>>29969580
Post-game is a meme. You faggots won't be satisfied until half the game is post-game.

GF should just have the E4 and Champion at the beginning of the game so you post-game autists will be happy.

>>29969521
Kalos had the worst game breaking bug on release in the main attraction of the region that you travel through 3 times

XY didn't have effort

File: cripplingdepression.jpg (13KB, 211x211px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 211x211px

>There are people on this board right now who are unironically defending X and Y

>>29969616
literally every pokemon game to date has been riddled with bugs one way or another

>>29969492
HGSS has Pokeathlón, Battle frontier, and a lot of story events like the Giovanni Flashback and Red in Mt Silver. Literally more than any game after that (except maybe BW2)

>>29969637
>Why doesn't literally 100% of /vp/ subscribe to my XY hate meme???? JUST UGH!!!!!!!!!

>>29969641
You don't just lose your save and call it small bug

It's the place they supposedly worked the most on too

>>29969641
>save ruining glitch
>bugs

>>29969675
good thing i didn't call it a small bug you illiterate bumblefuck

>>29969702
>he's one of those retards that thinks glitches and bugs are different things

>>29968980
I'm suprised OP I wholeheartedly agree with your list. I'd probably just swap X&Y with B&W but everything else is spot on.

File: image.jpg (69KB, 659x683px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 659x683px

>>29969529
Tierno is a joke character, he loves to dance and he wants his Pokemon to be dancing along side him, hence why every Pokemon had at least one dance move. It's not hard to understand if you paid an ounce of attention when playing the fucking game.

File: 1479350453555.png (2MB, 1308x1484px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1308x1484px

>>29969117
That's not bait, this is bait.

>>29969837
But what does he add as a character?

Drop XY a tier and I completely agree

>>29969837
That doesn't explain why his Pokemon don't have four moves each.

>>29969872
comedy relief

>>29969926
i assume GF only used his pokemon as a way to teach the player how useful dance moves can be, and giving them 4 moves would mean they'd use dance moves less often

>>29969616
That was patched in the first week and players were likely to encounter it very early on so even if it happened to you, you didn't really lose all that much progress.

>>29968980
The dust has never settled OP. Can't answer this rn.

>>29970016
Tell that to my save file after the 4th gym

>HGSS
>great
this is bait

>>29969086
>>29969306
Fuck off fags

>>29969454
nice LIJ edit

>>29968980
S/M are the games ever made.

File: image.png (228KB, 394x370px) Image search: [Google]

228KB, 394x370px

>>29971121

>>29970050
you

>>29969203
>revamped nostalgia doesn't exist

>>29969588
>you are not forced to shoot a film

Confirmed for not even playing the game. Are unovabortions really just a meme?

Pokemon Red, Blue, Yellow, Gold, Silver and Crystal should be in some sort of special category at this point.

They're way too old and suffer from technical issues later gens stopped having. Plus they have remakes.

>>29969117
I'd shit on your opinion, but it's shit enough as it is.

>>29972318
0/10

>>29972318
bait/10

>>29972318
im sorry wut. fire red leaf green are literal remakes with some added features of your precious genwun. and how does G/S/C not make it into the second tier at least when the were the good kind of sequel where they leap off from what the originals did and tried to make it better.

File: 1468008949111.png (722KB, 1103x856px) Image search: [Google]

722KB, 1103x856px

>>29968980
complete with a projected SM score

>>29972606
Literally me

>>29972337
By that logic, RSE should be in that category as well. Their mechanics are notably outdated, and they have remakes.

>>29972606
Agree.

>>29972656
>>29972714
good taste lads

>>29972318
Holy shit, saved.

>>29972606
I'd move ORAS to the same tier as XY but other than that, literally me

>>29972606
Literally me except I'd move BW down a tier. They were good games and all, but they were almost as disappointing as XY.

>>29968980

Fuck no, HGSS fucking sucked

>>29968980

Horrible lists like this make me so glad /vp/ is both a minority and not in charge of Pokemon

>>29968980
>are we all in agreement?
Every single person here will never, EVER 100% agree on this ever.

And that's completely fine.

>>29969359
Not that anon but fuck you. Dust has settled was always a shitty meme

>>29969117
>Crystal
>bad


REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>>29968980
Top Tier
>B2W2 / HGSS / Platinum / Emerald

Average Tier: Most of the remaining games, except for:

Bottom Tier: XY

>>29973900
For me, ORAS was a bigger letdown but still a better game. A few parts were shit, but huge swaths of XY ended up being shit

>>29973955
I dont think i'd mind them in B tier. I really enjoyed the experience but probably couldnt tell you why. Though I prefer my placement

>>29968980
HGSS is overrated as hell
>muh two regions
>muh following Pokemon

Literally all it's got going for it

>>29968980
I would personally switch Platinum with B2W2 but I otherwise agree with this chart. SM miiight just belong in Good Tier but it's shaping up to be enjoyable regardless

>>29972606
ORAS and D/P need to be at the fucking bottom but I agree

>>29968980
>gen 4 games are top tier.
let me guess... you were born in 98?

>>29969973

Give them all the dance moves, then.

> Add Featherdance to Talonflame
> Add literally any other move to Roserade
> Add Rain Dance to Crawdaunt

>>29968980
The dust has not settled the games arent out for people with patience and self control.

>>29975826
This anon knows.

>>29969401
>accusing others of being underage
>posts anime
go die in a hole

BW2 has nice content but the Gen 5 mons are among the worst designed and the region is linear shit.

>>29976598
That isn't Sinnoh. Sinnoh had about three good designs, the worst starters of all time and the worst region.

where the fuck is dp

>>29969117

>GSC
>Bad

You are objectively wrong, even if This is bait.

Pokemon Snap > Pokemon Red >>>>> Everything else.

>>29977876
Too slow to show up at the ranking

>>29977876
DP would be in the trash tier

>>29968980
>game isn't even out
>already judged
Never change /vp/

>>29978112
kek

>>29977777

>>29968980
No.

>>29969096
D/P are probably the worst games in the franchise overall along with R/S. Weird when Emerald and Platinum are both top tier as fuck.

>>29969222
>literally forgetting Barry

He's one of the best rivals you get. You just have shit taste.

>>29968980
Sure, I'd say bump Emeral down a tier but I'm strongly biased.

>>29979447
Barry is gay as fuck

>>29976966
You are objectively wrong. Gen 5 mons have extremely polarizing designs, while Gen 4 had mediocre at worst. And don't even try to say Sinnoh is the worst region when Hoenn and Unova exist.

>>29979552
not nearly as epic as gary or silver I agree xD

>>29978185
>implying people haven't played it