Did they fuck it up?

idk if my opinion is a popular one or not but i actually like most, if not all of these guys

>>29520178
No.
Fuck (You).

File: 124235325.jpg (213KB, 1024x819px) Image search: [Google]

213KB, 1024x819px

That's one of the few things that gen 4 did right though.

Only these evos are ass by the away

It's mostly all the annoying things you need to do to get them to evolve that I hate
>Learn a certain move, go to place X at night and trade it while holding a certain item
Fuck that shit

>>29520213
I like tangrowth

>>29520213
>>29520254
Me too. What the fuck has Tagnrowth ever done to you?

Magmortar, Electivire, Rhyperior, Tangrowth and Probopass are ugly

The rest are passable or good

File: 1477742615134.jpg (281KB, 1024x890px) Image search: [Google]

281KB, 1024x890px

>>29520178
kinda

>>29520267
>>29520254
Not enough tentacles. Seriously, just look at that belly

>>29520178
No they didn't. The only ones I don't particularly like are Lickilicky and Probopass, but they still aren't completely terrible.

>great looking evo for a great looking mon that needed a boost
Gliscor
Weavile
Mismagius
Porygon-Z
Honchkrow
Gallade

>great looking evo for a dumb shitmon no-one cared about anyway
Mamoswine
Yanmega
Froslass

>not great, but good
Magnzone
Roserade
Togekiss

>eh
Dusknoir
Electivire

>ugly but the original was already dumb anyway so who cares
Tangrowth
Lickilicy
Ambipom
Probopass
Magmortar

>actually ruined it
Rhyperior

Overall, no they didn't, but Rhyperior still hurts

>>29520277
>Don't
What did he mean by this?

>>29520300
Don't put eggs on them.

I like them all aside from Phyperior and Magmorter. Electivire and Roserade are some of my favorite Pokemon as well. I never got the hate for Lickilicky.

>>29520178
Some of the ugliest monsters.

I like Magmortar. Rhyperior and Froslass look shit, though.

File: mismagius_by_fanart_freak.png (15KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 400x400px

>>29520313
Mismagius has a scarf not an egg.
I don't know why gallade has such a thicc waist though.

>>29520277
>J.G.B

what?

>>29520389
It says IGB. I think you can figure out what it means.

I like all of those bar Magmortar. It just reminds me of that shit show Butt Ugly Martians

File: 1475112230135.png (48KB, 146x170px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 146x170px

Only the top row and Mamoswine and Probopass are shit. rest are solid designs

>>29520409
You're the first person I see who likes Magmorter but not Electivire.

>>29520350
>scarf

It's a fucking oval.

Not really. Most of them look fine, some of them look fantastic. It's just the ones that look bad are really fucking bad. Magnezone is fucking god-tier and the best of the bunch, with Porygon-Z a close second.

>>29520213
You've got the shittiest of tastes.

>>29520389
Just gets bigger.

>yanmega
>not mega

I love all of them, even Rhyperior which many seem to hate.

>>29520443
>yanmega-mega
>dragoniteite

>>29520213

Disgusting.

Rhyperior and Magmortar are the biggest offenders. The latter looks like a fucking Darkwing Duck villian. I mean of course Magmar already looks like a turd, so what can you expect, but still...

File: file.png (746KB, 1024x819px) Image search: [Google]

746KB, 1024x819px

Overall pretty good

Also
>Thought Blissey was a Gen 4 evolution

Silly me

>>29520178
The ones that are fucked up are really just the ones that are hard to believe are actually evolutions and not entirely new pokemon.

You're gonna tell me Rhyperior is an evo of Rhydon when even his entire color palette changes? Mamoswine has a similar issue.

My only complaint is that loads of them are slower than their prevos. What's the point?

>>29520213
Great taste anon

>>29520178
Nah, cross gen evos was one of the few things the worst generation (4) did right. They did a good job attempting to fix Johto and Kanto's shitmons.

No but they obviously could be better. They need to do this again.

>>29520178
Most of these are perfect. I miss cross gen evos, I can't believe 4th gen was the last gen to have them. Sylveon barely counts, that little faggot eevee always gets a free pass.

>>29520178
Only Rhyperior is shit.
Gallade, Honchkrow, Mismagius and Frosslass is top-tier. Other are at least appropriate.

We haven't gotten cross generation evos in the last ten year. Let that sink in. Let the hate consume you, Anonkin. Feel the rage. FEEL IT.

File: be6.jpg (13KB, 224x216px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 224x216px

>>29520213
You didn't even cross out Dusknoir when Evolite Dusclops is so much better.

>>29521050
They're both pu shitmons. Eviolite dusclops hasn't been good since knock off became viable.

>>29521013
I want to clarify that "Anonkin" was a play on Anakin, not Tumblrkin.

>>29520178
They gave smongos a 1 inch boner. Self important region was shit and this ass power creep is a major reason. Only saving graces are the new eevees, DP dex evos and froslass.

>>29520178

Rhyperior, Magmortar, Electivire, Lickilicky and Roserade are bad. The rest are pretty good though.

>>29520350
I love Gallade and his cancer tumor

File: 1477742615134.jpg (221KB, 1024x819px) Image search: [Google]

221KB, 1024x819px

>>29520178

File: 1477742615134.jpg (318KB, 1024x819px) Image search: [Google]

318KB, 1024x819px

>>29520178

>>29520178
>>29520201
I could have gone without Lickilicky, Rhyperior, Magnezone, Probopass (not that I really care for Nosepass anyway) and maaaaybe Mismagius (only for the autistic reason that 2nd gen now no longer has any fully evolved ghost types) but I mostly like them. It's an unpopular opinion but Magmortar is on my 5th gen dream team.

>>29521385
Oh and I guess Ambipom is dumb too but literally only because his face looks fucking dumb

>>29521415
His face isn't even that different from Aipom's.

It's the tri-penis balloon tails of doom that get me.

>>29520178
i was never fond of Lickilicky, Porygon-Z, Ambipom, Yanmega, and Dusknoir, and i really like Rhyperior, Mismagius, Weavile, Gallade, and Roserade. the rest i tolerate

>>29521050
If Dusknoir didn't exist then evolite Dusklops wouldn't exist

File: SUMMER SALES.png (154KB, 295x297px) Image search: [Google]

154KB, 295x297px

>if these were introduced later they'd be shit megas
>instead they're based, permanent changes that manage to actually salvage some lines

Hate Ambipom and Lickylicky. Magmortar and Rhyperior are eh. The rest are good/great.

>>29520178
Not at all. In fact I actually really like how they did this!

>>29521050
Eviolite Dusclops is shit actually. It dies from any Knock Off. Meanwhile Dusknoir sticks around longer, does more physical damage, and still has pretty decent bulk.
They're both shit anyway.

>>29521515
The correct taste.

File: Untitled.jpg (213KB, 1173x819px) Image search: [Google]

213KB, 1173x819px

>>29521503
This, also what makes me think megas are a mistake. Even with a mega gallade is more appealing than glalie.

>>29520178

The only thing they fucked up is not doing this again in later generations.

Seriously, the only cross gen evo we've gotten since Gen IV was Sylveon, and that's fucking tragic. They could have easily given Alolan forms to a few pokemon and justified giving those Alolan pokemon an evolution by saying they found a new way to evolve after adjusting to the region.

File: 1472343736613.png (611KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]

611KB, 800x600px

>People hating on based Magnezone >When it pretty much redeemed that entire line.
Granted I never really hated Magnemite or Magneton but I would have never picked them up if it weren't for Magnezone.
Same goes for Crobat.

>>29520178
Yes considering GF never again did another cross-gen evolution. Also, fuck eviolite.

>>29520178
The only one I don't like is probopass. Everyone else is cool. Even lickilicky.

>all this shit taste shitting on based jew
Also the only kind of bad one is Ambipom, and even then it's not horrible.

File: gens4.png (880KB, 1024x1936px) Image search: [Google]

880KB, 1024x1936px

>>29520178

>>29520213
Fuck you, Tangrowth is great

>>29520213
This.

The only bad ones were Rhyperior (Holy shit what the fuck were they thinking), Magmortar (Magmar was already shit though) and arguably Probopass/Ambipom

>>29520252
I wouldn't mind so much if they at least used the evo kinds again. Either use the new ideas, or don't introduce them at all. Leaving a bunch of half realized ideas littered about is just an irritating waste of potential

File: Chatot-1.jpg (44KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 1000x1000px

So now that we've established that GameFreak can do mostly decent cross-evolutions, what mono-stage or two-stage shitmons still need a cross-gen evolution?
pic related desu

>>29521050
Leave it to >muh eviolite shitters to know nothing about anything that they're talking about

>>29521013
Slyveon

>>29520213
except for Tangrowth and Magmortar you're right

>>29523026
Chatot with higher BST would be terrifying. That fucker has STAB Boomburst

>>29520402
>It says IGB
Are you retarded?

Only one I really dont like is Magmortar, other than that, I think these are pretty good

>>29520213
agreed but cannon hands and the dumbass magnet ufo are stupid too.

First attempt at Megas

>>29520201
I agree. Some aren't great but the majority are good.

>>29520178
I like them. GF should do more of these instead of the mega shit we got.

i actually really liked cross gen evolution's and it makes me sad that we haven't gotten any since gen4. I think alot of pokemon could use an evolution

>>29522897
>shit tier

your taste

>>29520178
We need more pokemon like this again. Not alternate forms, not megas, just regular-ass evolutions of older pokemon

File: 1477742615134.jpg (146KB, 862x717px) Image search: [Google]

146KB, 862x717px

>>29520178
fixed

>>29520178
No. Giving much-needed evolutions to old Pokemon was one of the best things about Generation 4. It's a shame GameFreak will never do this again because "muh Megas."

>>29524373
It also helped fill give us a bunch of coolmons as single pokemon in the dex rather than evolutionary lines. And all of those pokemon had relatively unique playstyles for the time and while not all of them are competitively viable they are at least fun to use.

They fucked up with Lickilicky. Magmortar and Rhyperior are shit but not as bad.

The others are okay, good, or even great.

>>29520178
Only honestly bad ones are ambipom and lickilicky. Though magmortar and electivire are kinda dull design wise.

Ambipom turned Aipom from my favorite Pokemon to one I couldn't care less about.

>>29520409
What is wrong with Mamoswine Anin?

>>29520178
Stat wise for most of these yeah they fucked up horribly
Design wise only a few 3 or 4 are bad

Cross-gen evos from both Gen II and Gen IV are almost exclusively GOAT. Never understood the memeing around them.

>>29520178
> Lickillicky
Fucking hell, yes.
> Rhyperior
Yes.
> Tangrowth
Yeah, but not that much.
> Probopass, Magmortar
Sorta, but it's not like their prevos were any good, either.

>>29520273
Wait, you are telling me those monsters are UGLY?

An ugly monster? Who would have ever thought of such a thing?

>>29520277
> plastic?
Yeah, that's my real complaint regarding Roserade and Tangrowth. If they just added in the details on those vines, Tangrowth might actually looks pretty cool.

magnezone was unneeded, but ok
lickilicky is SHIT
rhyperior was unneeded
tangrowth is cool
electivire was unneded and bad
magmortas was unneeded, but ok (if electabuzz got one, magmar should get one too so it's fine)
porygon-z is cool
togekiss is cool
ambipom is shit
yanmega is cool
honchkrow is cool
mismagius is great
gliscor was unneded, but cool
weavile is ok
mamoswine is good
gallade is good
probopass is ok
roserade is cool
dusknoir is not good
froslass is very good

>>29522897
> he thinks Lickitung was shit
Time for you to consider suicide.

>>29520213
jokes on you anon, i like lickilicky.

>>29520178
I like all of them

>>29520178
>Rhyperior
>Electivire
>Mismagius
>Weavile
>Gallade
>Roserade
>Froslass
How is this a question? These are perfection.

Mamoswine is actually my favorite Pokemon, and I actually love a large majority of these.

File: gen 4 cross-gen.png (982KB, 1024x819px) Image search: [Google]

982KB, 1024x819px

I didn't like Rhyperior before I began to raise one in my HG nuzlocke recently. Holy fuck, it is an amazing tank and hits like a truck. Love its cry, and my guy has been a true bro.

Probopass gets a pass thanks to Generations, so I hope I'll get to raise one in either my Sun or Moon nuzlocke.