Post, argue, rinse, repeat.
>>27848541
good taste
What's with the ayylmao on his collar
>>27848541
>>27848566
Great taste anon
Good taste
>>27848610
very good taste anon
So far this thread is fine. I'm just waiting for that one faggot to post something genuinely awful.
>>27848566
>>27848585
>>27848651
10/10
>>27848610
Nope/10
>>27848611
>>27848619
>>27848642
Not bad, but not quite 10/10.
>>27848541
Ribcage on back makes it look less agile. Not sure about the alien symbol on its neck either.
>>27848566
Actually disturbingly thin if you remove the fur.
Also, idk about the lines around the forelegs.
>>27848585
Best one so far.
Probably because you're not using official art.
>>27848610
Generic.
>>27848611
Pretty okay.
Not sure why it has nippleyes.
>>27848619
It does this weird hunched thing where it's a quadruped sometimes and a biped at other times. Also, that tail is awkward.
>>27848642
Too many bracelets. Tries too hard to look punk-y.
>>27848651
Hard to complain about this one.
>>27848541
9/10
>>27848566
7/10
>>27848585
7/10
>>27848610
7/10
>>27848611
10/10
>>27848619
9/10
Fight me.
Cyndaquil and Oddish for GenII/GenI. I'd have to go through all the Pokemon to find more I actually think deserve a ten based off different merits.
entire line is perfection
despite having evolution spanning multiple gens none of them feel out of place
>>27848541
My personal favourite mon. Nice to see Houndoom getting some love.
So is Scyther.
>>27848663
He's just okay but Golduck is 10/10 for sure.
>>27848667
Mediocre. The body shape isn't streamlined enough for a shark or a torpedo.
>>27848674
Uggo.
>>27848680
I want to like cyndaquil, but his eyes ruin it. Quilava is 10/10. Typhlosion is somewhere in the middle.
>>27848690
He's great, but there are some easy fixes like his teeth and weird fin things.
>>27848694
>>27848724
>>27848775
10/10
>>27848663
I really like Psyduck but its "hair" is overly cartoony IMO.
>>27848667
Cool concept but it'll always be just a half-shark.
>>27848680
Looks very awkward when its back-flame isn't lit. Also nub-hands.
>>27848690
CHECKERBOARD TEETH
>>27848694
I wish Porygon-Z's colours became highly saturated or had some kind of drastic colour-scheme change but I guess Electric Soldier Porygon scared the designers.
>>27848724
Way too fat to be graceful.
>>27848775
Ooh, good pick.
Hourglass figure makes it look feminine?
Fite me
>>27848541
>>27848610
>>27848619
>>27848694
>>27848775
Top tier designs, all others go from good to bad
Perfection
>>27848814
Best bird of its gen
>>27848853
Wish it was faster for such a sleek design
>>27848808
Not really a criticism but is Glaceon's "hair + ears" supposed to look like a snow hat or something?
>>27848814
Bald spot.
>>27848853
Has to float to move. For something with the armour/exoskeleton combo it really shouldn't be as free with its hands.
>>27848876
Claw is 2cartoony4me
>>27848885
Probably should be taller if it's gonna be hunched over like that.
>>27848915
I really like Sneasel!
Weavile doesn't add enough to the design to be a proper evolution IMO but it's not bad either.
>>27848938
Too many circles.
>>27848796
>>27848814
>>27848808
Good, but not perfect. Glaceon is nice, but we all know Eevee deserved an ice evo without pigtails.
>>27848853
>>27848938
Ew/10
>>27848876
>>27848885
>>27848915
10/10
>>27848541
>>27848611
>>27848642
>>27848651
>>27848680
>>27848690
>>27848694
>>27848775
>>27848808
>>27848885
>>27848915
These.
its perfect, best ghost
>>27848566
>>27848619
>>27848667
>>27848674
>>27848680
>>27848724
>>27848853
>>27848885
>>27848915
>>27848938
You're all correct
Nominating Empoleon
The entire line is beautiful.
>>27848983
>shits on magmortar
>gives 10/10 to clawitzer
bait
a
i
t
>>27849033
Forgot picture.
sheis perfect...for me
>>27849026
i can agree with this
>>27849019
Great mega
>>27849038
But he's right
The only way to make a genie a top tier design.
>>27848981
>>27849006
>>27849052
>>27849061
>>27849064
10/10, Dewgong-bro has great taste.
>>27849019
>>27848987
Meh.
>>27849026
>>27849075
Overdesigned trash.
>>27849038
Maybe I should've given it a soft 10/10. I'd never use it. I just respect the design. I have a weakness for animal mons, I guess.
>it's a /vp/ forgot to hate gen 1/2 thread
>>27849089
>Hoopa
>Overdesigned trash
What? its a demon genie, as plain as the design can be, what's wrong with it?
>>27849097
People hate gen 1/2 the best gens?
>>27848987
Feels too complicated. It's still kind of a cyclops/yamawarabe but now it's dressed up with ruffles, has a mouth-belly, and is a radio? Huh?
>>27849006
Just kind of bland, I guess.
>>27849019
Look at its back.
>>27849026
Good choice!
I don't like the little "claws" on its wings, not sure what they're supposed to be.
>>27849033
>>27849052
Controversial opinion alert: Mareep is great, Flaaffy is fine, but Ampharos really isn't great. I guess I can appreciate that it looks so drastically different and it reminds me that Mareep was never really a sheep anyways.
>>27849061
I like it, but teeny-tiny waist/arms make it less menacing. That might be the point.
>>27849064
It's a cute beanbag bat that tries to be angry and menacing~
>>27849075
Keeps spitting out balls at me. Still better than Rag Man, I guess.
>>27849126
Big fan of Froslass, really hard for me to insult it so I won't!
>>27849170
>Keep spitting out balls at me.
wait, what?
Been my favorite since the very beginning. It's pretty crap overall, but it has a nice simple design and was a total bro in the anime.
So good
>>27849164
I think the weird disk-hips are actually supposed to mimic clothing - like Gardevoir's dress, but manlier. The arms are also a little strange, but this really is an excellent design.
>>27849263
Lol, just a little joke.
I honestly don't have much to say about Hoopa's design - other than that it's an interesting one.
If I had any complaint it'd be that it has a little too much going on.
>>27849286
Never been a fan of the little hands but it's a fine design - really like the wings.
>>27849289
I like this bird! The talons always looked a little strange to me, though.
>>27849295
Just slightly impractical.
>>27849319
Just a little too simple.
It's adorable, though!
>>27849164
Wish its pants didnt look so stupid. Inferior to medicham too.
>>27849295
samurott will always be the biggest let down for me, could've been so much better designed/in line with the rest of the evolution line
with that said, i love dewott. clean, simple, and the use of colour is top notch
>>27849600
t. passive-aggresive dewottfag
>>27849170
>>27849430
Why didn't you post Alomomola?
>>27849430
I like the concept a lot, but I just think it's ugly especially if you don't understand the point of the moustache. It's very clever though
>>27849295
My biggest problem is the legs. Quadra pedal I can handle, but just LOOK at them! They're round, fat, the feet have no stability to them, not even any back toes to them, it's terrible. There's no way this thing isn't clumsy. I like the sword handles on its arms, but it's the legs. I just can't like them, I've tried so hard.
>>27849075
It's grown on me. Only issue is that there's a lot going on on such a small body, it seems crowded
>>27849026
Don't hate it, but the fins are awkward.i don't know if you could've made them not awkward, though.
>>27848938
I don't even know where to begin. Granted I hate magmar's design as well. I like magby though.
>>27848667
GIVE ME A REAL SHARK, PLEASE GF, PLEASE
>>27848651
Should've been named rhydon since it's the one you fucking ride on and the second evolution has the horn as its focal point
2bh i think the nidoking has the coolest name out of any pokemon
Eternally based pokemon. Mischievous little demon.
>>27849703
0/10
>>27849600
Dewott is just a typical samurai kid when compared to it's evo though. Who literally an seashell armored warrior. Get some taste.
>>27849689
Thankfully it's back legs posses joints to function. No different from a bear's legs.
>>27848541
I get what you're saying, OP, but how can Houndour is a better, more perfect design, and since Houndoom is not as good as Houndour, Houndoom cannot be 10/10.
Undeniable.
>>27849430
They were looking for you in the fish thread b0SS
A common complaint is that Darmanitan is too spherical or has a weird body shape. I disagree. I feel like its round shape makes it like a living fireball, and its long forearms (as opposed to its stubby hind legs) are perfect for vaulting itself around and into opponents.
Also, just look at that winning smile!
>>27848585
Would have been better evolving from metapod. Also shit typing
>>27848642
10/10 booty, that's about it
It's so cute!
Hypno's alright but Drowzee is pure pokekino.
>>27850594
>A common complaint is that Darmanitan is too spherical or has a weird body shape.
>Literally another case of "lets ignore the design's concept despite the design trying to look like it's concept!"
Those kinds of people have NO business judging monster design at all. Might as well complain about a cat pokemon being shaped like a cat.
When I heard about Alolan Marowak, I was thinking, "How could they possibly improve on one of my favorite designs?"
Well, they found a way.
>>27848541
Only thing i don't like about the design is the fact that instead of a skull below it's face they put an ayy lmao on it instead. Also the mega evolution was so fucking disappointing. Was expecting it to look like Cerberus.
>>27848541
>tfw ice type
If it had aerilate..
>>27850800
I would've preferred a Parental Bond mega using the ghost of Marowak's mother, but this design is alright.
Why is A-Marowak a ghost anyway? I can understand Fire due to regional adaptation, but why Ghost?
Sheer perfection
>>27850970
>Why is A-Marowak a ghost anyway? I can understand Fire due to regional adaptation, but why Ghost?
Because it's cool as hell, that's why.
Fuck. A physical attacker immune to Burn, immune to (the most common form of) Paralysis, and evidently capable of outspeeding a Haunter. I'm so goddamn hype to use this thing.
>>27851049
looks stupid
>>27851074
Your face looks stupid
Only contrarians and insincere anti-nostalgia people will claim to dislike any of these.
Finally a good looking fish
Love it
>>27851146
I'm not the biggest fan of Lugia's hand wings but other than that pretty great
>>27851146
Love both Lugia and Ho-Ho, but I've never been a fan of the beasts.
Just my opinion
>>27850758
great taste, mah boy.
>>27851146
gen 2 is my favorite and i don't like most of those. the beasts mostly look bad and lugia is a shit design with cartoonish feet and mouth and dumb finger-wings. only ho-oh is good.
>>27851202
Lugia is not a bird anyway.
>>27851146
I don't like entei or raikou. I love the shit out of lugia and ho-oh
>>27848610
Ducklett and purrloin are top-tier designs but their evolutions are just awful. Swanna is the goofiest-looking thing to come out of gen V (yes, goofier than stunfisk) and liepard's yellow coloring is terrible.
He's a total bro.
>>27851241
11/10 taste
Surprised to have not seen this beast yet.
>>27851342
>>27851342
>>27851421
This. Interesting concept and flawless execution.
>>27851399
Whoops, was already posted.
Second favorite design then.
>inb4 hurr theres just more of them
Yeah, except it actually makes sense for magnets to attract together to become more powerful.
The colors of its fur go together so well. The ears, tail, and bottom feet are perfect. It's cute and cool at the same time. Just a pretty solid design overall.
I only wish he wasn't pretty much useless cause I fucking love the design.
Dragged one through Heart Gold for this reason alone
>>27851525
Used this fucker in my playthrough of Gale of Darkness. He's far from useless.
>>27848541
Yes, Hell hound is good.
>>27848566
7/10. Could be simplified imo. Less stripes.
>>27848585
Mothra/10 (8/10)
>>27848610
5/10-kinda cute but we had a cute yellow ducky and he looked like duckling. This does not.
>>27848611
Kinda cool but only 7/10. I'll be honest, I can't put my finger on what would improve it.
>>27848619
8/10. Mega is 10/10. It looks better with huge arms trying to crush things.
>>27848642
9.5/10. Plates could look a bit more natural
>>27848651
9.5/10. Simplicity does wonders.
>>27848663
9/10. See above, cute ducky.
>>27848667
10/10-if it gets it's other half, until then 6/10.
>>27848674
4/10 for num, 6/10, 7 mega cam. Num is an ugly color
>>27848680
8.5/10. Chico was the only bad johto starter. Cute pre evo, based on a cool animal.
>>27848690
I like it, but people are right, teeth holds it back. 8/10
>>27848694
8/10. Colors are nice. Another simple but good.
>>27848724
10/10. Not too excessive, wings look really nice.
>>27848775
10/10. , just really slick
>>27848796
5/10. Simple can work but it's kinda ugly. If it was a blend of colours that could fit the chameleon thing.
>>27848808
6.5/10. Thing in it's head a bit much. Kinda pales compared to other eeveelutions.
>>27848814
Best bird you get in early game, period. 10/10. Looks like the bad ass predator it is A's white and black is sweet colour combo.
>>27848853
3/10. Floating armor as a bug is bad. The way it comes into existence is also dumb.
>>27851557
I remember finding it tough having my only STAB move being a 5PP silver wind.
Then again I was like 14 so I could have just been shit
>>27850970
A Ghost-type Marowak. I think it's a throwback to Cubone's mother's ghost back in RBY.
>>27851060
HOLY FUCKING SHIT DOES A GODDAMN THICK CLUB WORK WITH THIS THING?!?!!?!? HOLY FUCKING SHIT!?!@?! <333 I JUST CAME BUCKETS
>>27851903
I hope so, I hope all they do is buff its HP and switch speed with defense. It would become an abzolutely amazing sweeper.
Just imagine thick club rock head STAB Flare Blitz coming from this thing
>>27851060
>most common form of paralysis
But it's not immune to Thunder Wave...?
>>27850594
This is hilarious to me because my Darmanitan is female (I played White without knowing all the pokemon/evos, so I evolved her blindly).
>>27850776
Every time I almost get bothered by the body shape, I remember this. If it was shaped differently it wouldn't be the same. Darmanitan is a 10/10 for me.
>>27851146
In hindsight I'm not big on Raikou or Suicune (colour palettes/patterns, etc.). But I've always adored Ho-Oh and Entei, and Lugia has a very classic look.
>>27851202
I think it works well in contrast to Ho-Oh. After all, it's meant to swim in the sea.
>>27851241
Best gen 1 starter evolution. I can't bring myself to evolve Squirtle or Charmander because I don't like Blastoise and Charazard as much, but Venusaur is golden so I always get him. Also it's weirdly cute sometimes.
>>27851371
Good taste, all of Slowpoke's line is cute and useful. Kind of a shame about the mega, but I'm getting used to it.
Here are some favourites of mine that I haven't seen mentioned yet.
>>27852082
I think he means body slam
Bow down to the ultimate life form.
>>27852111
I want to add that I used older art of Hoppip on purpose. I liked it better when it was wider and shorter - now it looks too spherical and the long tail sticks out too much. I also preferred the warmer reddish-pink to the berry pink they use now.
>>27852082
One of its abilities is Lightning Rod.
>>27852082
Lightingrod you colossal faggot.
>>27851974
My dick is literally wet right now, but it doesn't get Rock Head does it? I thought it got Lightning Rod and Cursed Body?
Regardless I'm in love with the design of Marrowak's new form. It's definitely getting used during my playthrough.
>>27848885
How the monster mons should be done. 10/10
>>27848915
9.5/10. Slick and mostly simple. Colors go well together.
>>27848938
7.5/10. I like it but that clown face
>>27848981
5/10. Looks like the ghost of Groot + Charlie Brown. Ttevenant is a solid 9/10 though.
>>27848987
Take away the neck things. 7/10.
>>27849006
8/10. I'll give that since it's a sea lion the color and cuteness work. A little too pain for a, higher score.
>>27849019
Good, not best ghost. Best hoenn ghost. 8.5/10
>>27849026
10/10. 4th gen starter evolutions fit well. Emperor penguin with a crown? Yes
>>27849052
6/10. Like the pre evo better.
>>27849061
10/10. Flying scorpion is nice. Another example of a fairly simple design being good.
>>27852138
>mfw I forgot about the Body Slam immunity ONTOP of the sweet Lightning Rod ability.
>>27852347
>Wanting lightning rod instead of rock head for unlimited flare blitz
Because the physical ghost STAB is much better
>>27852448
Great concept, flawed execution.
Will probably use it anyway.
Don't lie
I know they're pretty weird, but I really like these guys. It's also cool that we got a toad pokemon (I keep forgetting it isn't a frog).
I only wish that Seismitoad kept the cream colour in its design somewhere. But it's still an awesome pokemon.
>>27849064
8.5/10. If it gets a mega with wings that look a bit bigger it'll be perfect.
>>27849075
6.5/10. unbound is better.
>>27849126
Give it normal arms and it goes from 8 to 9
>>27849164
8.5/10. Agree with other comment, "pants" are kinda weird
>>27849170
God tier. 10/10, as are it's pre evos.
>>27849286
Acceptable but not 10/10
>>27849289
Murica. 7/10. 5th gen birds were a bit lackluster.
>>27849295
>>27849600
Agree wholeheartedly. Dewott was pretty good. It's evo is just sinfully ugly and goes from bipedal to all fours.
>>27849689
Better than the coral in sixth gen but not it's evolution. 6/10. This is one of few that could use more colour.
>>27849703
8/10. Better than clef and cute, but kinda silly. Cheeks honestly don't feel like they fit.
>>27849772
Yes. Evil, complete, and ghostly.
>>27849824
Yes, good eeveelution.
>>27850350
Mega luvdisk/10
>>27850508
About as good as it's evo
>>27850594
Good but not quite 10/10. It's little stump tail needs to go. Looks quite excited though.
>>27850758
After finding out these are based on Baku/tapir, it's really awesome.
>>27850671
Better than the pre evo, 6/10. Idk, looks a bit generic for grass type.
>>27850800
>>27850970
>>27851060
Like both a lot, 10/10 (even if the mega isn't real). Wish the original was ghost. Will admit, am hyped for this, very based.
>>27848541
I just love her so much /vp/...
>>27852488
In what way is the execution flawed?
Not that guy and not attacking you, I would just like to know.
>>27852641
>unbound is better
You like digimon hoopa mora than hoopa?
>>27852448
10/10
>>27852677
Not that anon but I prefer unbound Hoopa as well. I'm not even that into humanoid pokemon, but for some reason regular Hoopa feels too similar to the stuff we've gotten before.
Unbound Hoopa feels more new to me. The teeth, face, and body make it look genuinely intimidating, I love the floating forearms, and the darker colour palette is much easier on the eyes than normal Hoopa's bright magenta + yellow on flat grey combo.
>>27852950
Interesting. I don't hate unbound hoopa by any means, its a great design, but hoopa just feels more like a pokemon to me. Its color scheme actual appeals to me more than unbound's, and the smaller body and more simple design seem better to me.
I just like little hoopa more, I even like the typing more than unbound's.
>>27850856
I I like it, 8/10.
>>27850899
Really good. I wish its typing wasn't a death sentence.
>>27850966
Best new Dragon.
>>27851146
Agreed. Lugia is probably least cool of these and still really good.
>>27851180
Aero's less cool cousin.
>>27851241
Obv top tier.
>>27851342
Ditch the stripes.
>>27851371
Pink hippo is the best senpai.
>>27851410
I think people didn't post a lot of mutually very loved ones.
>>27851457
Not 10/10, but agreed, the common criticism is kinda dumb. 9/10. Evo is 10/10.
>>27851524
See pika
>>27851525
Kinda liked the pre evo more. Rather forgettable.
>>27852149
So silly it's kinda cool
>>27852347
Best of a bad trio of starters still makes it only 7/10.
my dude
Why hasn't anybody posted the balkest birb? she's amazing.
>no Bisharp
Best steel type.
>>27853014
I see what you mean. It is a little hard for me to remember that unbound Hoopa is meant to be a pokemon, but then we had stuff like Machamp and Hitmonchan back in gen 1.
I think Confined Hoopa (just looked up the name) would look better if it had a more purplish base colour like in the fanart you posted, instead of grey. The warmer shade of yellow for the hoops also looks much nicer.
I think both typings are really fitting for each form. I'm not sure how the heck I'd use either in battle, though.
>>27852641
>MegaLuvdisc/10
I-is that good, or bad?
Best legendary, absolutely based
>>27853142
Well, fanart always makes pokemon look better than they really are, completely agree with those aesthetic changes, it'd look much nicer and cuter. And I'm not saying unbound isnt a pokemon, I'm just saying confined is more like what you think of when you think of pokemon.
You use them the same, as special or mixed sweepers with amazing STAB and scarf/specs depending on your preference, the only difference is unbound is stronger and isn't rendered dead by pursuit or sucker punch
>>27853147
I think they're saying that it's kind of a waste of a design if it has no connection to Luvdisc, which is just too similar in concept.
>>27853147
>>27853238
Pretty much. Both are a little plain but not ugly. If they were linked it'd at least feel better. I'd say about average.
>>27853095
One of the best in its gen. Credit where it's due, this was a success.
>>27853161
Excellent. Also, this thread made me realize that a lot of mons got a hunch problem.
>>27848541
>>27848566
>>27848585
>>27848610
>>27848611
>>27848619
>>27848663
>>27848674
>>27848694
>>27848724
>>27848775
>>27848796
>>27848808
>>27848814
>>27848885
>>27849019
>>27849026
>>27849052
>>27849061
>>27849064
>>27849600
>>27849687
>>27850758
>>27850800
>>27850966
>>27851226
>>27851410
>>27852523
>>27853082
Absolutely amazing tastes
>>27853412
Love it. Too bad you can't use it in comp except low tiers because typing makes it get fucked.
>>27852641
>It's evo is just sinfully ugly
How is Samurott ugly? Its a freaking BEAST.
It's kinda 2edgy but I don't care
>>27853830
Samurott just needed to be bipedal then it would be 10/10 but gamefreak fucked up.
>>27853914
I've always found the contrast between fire starters fans and water starters fans to be so funny in this regard. The first hates so much how many bipedal starters they have, the second is angry that just one of the 6 they have isn't bipedal.
>>27849061
always adored gliscor. its so cute and a bit of furbait. tried hard to use it in 4th gen competitively. but then 5th gen came along and made it annoying
>>27848987
Dusclops was didn't need an evolution
>>27848938
Always wish they had gone kind of Mewtwo-esque with Magmortar; big legs, medium torso, slender upper body. Turning the point of flame from the mouth to the hands is an interesting idea, but I've never really liked the execution. Shame, too; I always liked Magmar in Red/Blue.
>>27851146
Shameless Genwunner; I never liked any of these except Lugia.
>>27854291
Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication.
>>27854777
I like it more now because toxic heal makes it the best sweeper ever, no fear of will-o-wisp or need for leftovers
>>27854777
>a bit of furbait
What? why?
>>27849075
Why did they make a Sai Saici pokemon?
>>27848541
Best Kappa/duck/platypus
Rowlet's got nothing on this