What is the most relevant thing to make a comfy region in a fan game?
The graphics? Mapping style?
>>27580181
The flow of the map, certainly, but I also think choices for early mons is very important. A lot of 'primary', I think, solid single-types that are decent if you keep them around later on.
>>27580181
Probably mapping style. What looks good from far out can be confusing and hard to navigate when you're playing the game. Map design is pretty important
>>27580181
>big places
>no missions
>comfy soundtrack
>>27580181
What game is this?
>>27580226
Would this dex work? I mean, it's not a long game and not based on legendaries or evil teams.
>>27580273
It's not bad, but if it's a small dex, I'd maybe cut a few starters for different mons.
>>27580273
Why so many starters? I notice a lot of romhaks try and do that.
Also, I'd say the biggest things of importance are idyllic terrain, soundtrack to go with it, and a nice path to follow. Things can meander around, but you shouldn't be constricted, and you shouldn't be getting lost.
Pokemon are a bit secondary to that, though I tend to find that what helps are cool pokemon that aren't major powerhouses, but are still helpful. This is more subjective, but I'd say you want to avoid filling everything with the best pokemon ever, and ensure good route variety. You don't want the same two pokemon showing up on all the routes.
>>27580495
This, yeah. When I think of mons that have the right degree of 'cool', 'strong', etc. for early game, I tend to think Growlithe is a good mindset to base around. Strong, a solid rep of it's type and fairly popular, but not OP and unlikely to turn early game into cruise control.
>>27580736
That's the sort of thing I was getting at. Growlithe is a good example of a balancing point. Loading up the early routes with the standard rats and birds just gets people impatient. You want to have interesting things there to encourage people to linger more.
>>27580181
I don't know if this belongs in the general or not (didn't see one), but what are some tips for lanscape "flow"? I can't figure out how my routes will transition from a Kansas farming type landscape (starter town) to an desert city like Phoenix (first gym). Basically, I suck at route design and planning. Any tips?
>>27583751
Well there's a huge mountain range in between those two places.
But if you were to go through OK and TX you'd see the dry plains just become drier and drier until there's no more grass and just dirt.
Somewhere in between the dirt and sand there would be a rocky region with canyons and plateaus.
Grassy>Dirty>Rocky>Sandy
Just get drier and drier.
>>27583751
>>27583832
Maybe try to google image search for inspiration.
I typed in 'Texas landscape' and got really nice results.