Agree of you don't know shit

>R/S/E as shit

Well somebody is fucking retarded.

File: retard.jpg (77KB, 400x551px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 400x551px

>>27418877
>not liking emerald

>Emerald is shit
>XY are good

Nice bait bro

>>27418877
>DP Top Tier
>BW Bad Tier
I can agree that OP doesn't know shit

>>27418889
he's not wrong, anon

>>27418877
Switch frlg with dp and move emerald up to god tier. Bump gsc down one tier and rby down one tier and RS up one tier. Perfect

>>27418877
>sinnoh babby
k

>>27418877
I already discarded your opinion the moment I saw BW2 in God tier

>>27418877
>Emerald shit tier
>BW and Y bad tier
>XY good tier
>HGSS the same tier as DP and god-tier with bw2
>ORAS anywhere but shit tier

You took my (you).

>>27418965
*and not
fuck

>>27418877
>Diamond/Pearl
>Top Tier

File: 1463426319640.png (139KB, 500x449px) Image search: [Google]

139KB, 500x449px

>>27418877
>DP
>top tier
>xy
>good tier
>bw
>bad tier
>emerald
>shit tier
>red and blue on mediocre
>yellow on bad

I started on gen 4 the post

Great games on top spots and great games on low spots.

File: wewladtoast.png (9KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 512x512px

>>27418877
>Emerald
>Shit tier
>Diamond and Pearl
>that high
wew lad

>>27418877

I agree 100%

>>27418877
>Gen 4
>the generation that's hated by the majority of the fanbase
>that high
>gen 3
>The game that revived the series after gen 2 killed the hype
>That low
>Black and White
>the games that dared to be different and succeeded and gave us features the game should have had in the beginning
>that low

Shit list confirmed.

>>27419007
Because they were shitty games? Literally their only appeal is nostalgia

>>27418877
swap GSC and RSE
swap XY and BW
swap Yellow and RB
move DP down a tier
move ORAS up a tier

There you go.

>>27418935
Seconded.

>>27419040
Just because other games improved on them, like they were supposed to as SEQUELS don't make them bad.
That's just stupid

>>27419007
Talking as a person who was in the high school years during Pokemon's release it was a shitty game for multiple reasons even back then.
The only thing that made it take off in the west was the anime and in japan it was their fascination with cute monsters and having something other than Tetris to play on their commute.

>>27418877
Red and Blue are shit tier, those games are an inconvenience to play and don't hold up at all.

File: 13669442_1209697895731434_434573113965570792_o.jpg (98KB, 672x1000px) Image search: [Google]

98KB, 672x1000px

>>27418877
>objectivity
God tier - HGSS, EMERALD
Good tier - PLATINUM, BW2, GSC
Meh tier - FRLG, BW1, D/P
Below shit tier - XY, ORAS, R/S, RBY,

File: are you fucking kidding me.jpg (84KB, 828x342px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 828x342px

>>27418877
>XY over ORAS

um

My rating:

GOD TIER:
Platinum

TOP TIER:
Heart Gold and Soul Silver,Emerald.

GOOD TIER:
Gold,Silver,Crystal,FireRed,LeafGreen,Diamond and Pearl,Ruby,Saphire,Black and White,Black and White 2, Red and Blue,Yellow,Omega Ruby
and Alpha Saphire:

BAD TIER:
X and Y

>>27418877
Put Black, White, Gold, and Silver on Shit Tier, Emerald and Crystal on Bad.
Then, I'm with you.

>>27419103
they were both horrible

>>27419007
Have you ever tried comparing it to other games?
Barely any story (it's subjective if it's a bad thing), designs are the least imaginative, much less things to do than in later entries.

>>27419078
>God tier - BW2, EMERALD
>Good tier - BW1, ORAS
>Meh tier - FRLG, D/P, HG/SS, PLATINUM
>Below shit tier - XY, R/S, RBY, GSC

Fixed.

>>27418877
>Agree of you don't know shit
OP don't know grammar

>>27419116
no shit, they're later entries for a reason
you built on a game, not take things away on next iterations, something that gamefreak forgot to do

File: 1381323491753.jpg (148KB, 750x1000px) Image search: [Google]

148KB, 750x1000px

Reminder that Platinum will always be the best and that the other games are just competing for second.

>>27419134
Are you retarded or something?

>>27419039
Fucking hoennbaby you have no idea what are you talking about.
>Gen 4
>the generation that's hated by the majority of the fanbase
That's gen 3. Gen 4 is hated by the majority of the player whom started in the GBA era, this is for sure.
>gen 3
>The game that revived the series after gen 2 killed the hype
Gen 2 never killed a shit. They sold much more than gen 3 anyway.

File: 1469466846042.png (177KB, 664x520px) Image search: [Google]

177KB, 664x520px

>>27418877
This fucking list

>>27419146
>Saving A LOT of data...

>>27419155
>the generation that's hated by the majority of the fanbase
>That's gen 3.
It's actually gen 5.
Only /vp/ thinks it was the best gen.

>>27418877
Soul Silver and Platnium are god tier
Great Tier arr Heart Gold and Emerad
Good tier are S/G/C, Fire Red, Leaf Green, Black 2, X, and Y
Mediocre Teir is ORAS
WTF you doing tier is RBY, Black, White, White 2, Diamond, Pearl, Ruby and Sapphire

>>27419053
Makes them bad compared to the others, yes.

>>27418877
>DP and HGSS in the same tier
>Platinum and B2W2 in god tier
>Emerald in shit tier
>XY in good tier
>Yellow in bad tier
Shit list and full of underage faggotry.

>>27419078
>emerald in god tier
>RS in shit tier

>Platinum in good tier
>DP in meh

Did you not think while you were making this? Because the gap between R/S-Emerald shoulder be smaller than the gap between Platinum and DP

>>27419118
>Platinum
>Meh tier
Opinion discarded

>>27418877
Switch XY with BW, and move emerald up to good, and you'd be 100% correct.

>>27419168
False. Only desperate genwunners think so.
BW was revalued for a long while, and usually are considered, if not the best, a good generation which is underrated by the most casual part of the playerbase (ie normie genwunners).
And not only /vp/ thinks is good, by now.

>>27419173
this isn't even subtle

How do you put Yellow below Red and Blue? Graphical improvements, story tweaks for the better, more bonus content- how is that worse? You're not memeing just because of Pikachu are you?

>>27419155
>That's gen 3.
Not really, if anything people really liked Gen 3 given the reaction to their features being casualised or removed in DP and Plat. You should have seen the initial reaction to Gen 4's battle frontier, it was hilarious to see how many people were mad because of it.
Then there's the Cross gen evos which were hated to the point where GF had to make Eviolite and Megas in response.

>Gen 2 never killed a shit. They sold much more than gen 3 anyway.
GS did, but it was still riding on the coattails of gen 1's popularity. The generation petered out very quickly which is why Crystal, despite gen 2 not killing anything according to you, is the lowest selling third game despite the system selling more than the GBA. The anime couldn't even keep it afloat because it was struggling at the time in the animation and storytelling areas, rewatching it the Johto series is the Adventure 02 of the Pokemon series in terms of consistency.

Sorry but the facts don't lie

>>27419180
Someone didn't play Ruby or Sapphire and then Emerald.
And/or Diamond or Pearl and then Platinum.

>>27418877
Why do people like Red/Blue over yellow? Yellow has colors and that seems to me to be the only real difference

File: 1469829032194.png (3MB, 1615x2836px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1615x2836px

>>27418877
That list was so horrendously bad I had to fix it.


Here, 100% non debatable, fixed list.

On terms of overall quality, this is it people.

>b-b-but!
no

it's fixed and non debatable

File: 4345271-1974193113-rayqu.jpg (185KB, 1068x748px) Image search: [Google]

185KB, 1068x748px

>>27419180
I like the limited dex of d/p, and the fact that gym leaders/e4 didn't just have boring mono teams. If it wasn't for the slow battle and surf speeds I would put d/p on the same tier as platinum. I think it's obvious that emerald made more improvements over r/S than Plat did over dp. Combining the team narratives and giving them more story, the rayquaza cut scene, water champion as well as the ability to challenge Steven at meteor falls at higher level, and battle frontier. Honestly if oras had gym rematches and used emeralds story and climax they would be God tier instead of emerald not even accounting for no battle frontier. The fact that oras didn't so this made them so low. (Maybe oras should go up to meh tier, maybe)

>>27418877
From all of my experiences, Nuzlockes included.

God Tier
>Platinum
>BW2
Top Tier
>BW
>XY
Good Tier
>Emerald
>FRLG
>HGSS
>ORAS
Mediocre Tier
>GSC
>RS
Bad Tier
>RBY
Shit Tier
>DP

>>27419007
The PC is fucking garbage for starters

File: Shitposting kitty.gif (33KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 250x250px

>DP abouve FRLG
>Emerald being THAT low

File: secretary.webm (3MB, 960x540px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 960x540px

>>27418877
>You will never be this underaged

>>27419191
>Platinum
>not meh

>Speed was the same outside of surfing which was faster and saving a lot of data which was considerably worse
>Gimmicks instead of substantial additions
>>Distortion world being the worst and most underutilized area for a time/space plot
>Underground not fixed
>BF is worse and has less content than the previous version
>New framedrops in cities where it didn't happen in DP
>still have to see everything to unlock the rest of the postgame which is only made more tedious because they expanded the dex

And for gen 4 as a whole
>removing the mass move option in the box

Platinum is the most underwhelming third game yet.

>>27418877
For some reason I just really don't like ruy/sapphire, nor the remakes. I don't like the map, I don't like the music, and I don't like about 90% of the pokes. I imagine the reason why people like gen3 so much is because it has the prettiest graphics, 'cause it does, but everything else about it is just so shit

>>27419273
Switch XY with DP and you got this.

>>27419269

Mostly it's just people who are phobic of the games having parallels to the Ashnime Boogeyman, even though it's the same game with a different starter and new rocket admin bosses.

I personally like the more off model sprites from Red/Blue

>>27419333
>>27419273
Fuck I meant DP with ORAS.

>>27419007
The broken glitchy mechanics and lack of balance seem fun but the cons out weigh the pros. And that tiny bag, having to discard items or put them in pc storage, not being able to catch mom's if your box is full, and having to go to the poke center and save to change boxes, but most of all the fact that you can give e your mons cool tm moves but the npcs have the abysmal gen 1 level up movesets. Honestly look up garys final team. I'll wait.

File: 1439837045252.jpg (7KB, 173x154px)

7KB, 173x154px

>>27419273
was dp really that bad.

>>27419387
It's the definition of "Pokemon sells everything, even shit".

>>27419326
Platinum to date is still the only game with a good Elite 4.
Gens 1-3 had half assed teams, Gens 5 and 6 had only 4 pokemon each.
That alone makes it top tier.

>>27419387
it was such a different game come platinum

File: mega mad.jpg (18KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 480x360px

>>27418877
>DP are top tier
>this high above BW, E
AHAHAHHAHA

>>27419269
Idk yellow is superior for better sprites, getting all 3 starters, and charizard can fly. The only argument against yellow is that they monkeyed with the gym leader teams and some of them are just wack. (I think they did it to make them closer to anime.)

GET THE FUCK OUT OF /V/

STAY THE FUCK OUT OF /V/

DONT COME BACK!!!!!!!!! BABY SHITS PLAY A REAL GAME!!!!!

God tier: emerald, b2w2
High tier: frlg, Hgss bw
Mid tier: Gsc, XY, Y
Low tier: ORAS, rb

>>27419438
Gen 5 just needed more pokemon and it wouldn't even be a contest.
It also has the best theme by far.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMK1evpnYGo

>>27418911
At least it's better than the /vp/ hivemind opinion.

File: b42.jpg (40KB, 533x388px)

40KB, 533x388px

>>27418877
>i actually agree

>>27419134
You backpedaled like four fucking times in that one post.

Like Elder Scrolls games or whatever fucking else, Pokemon games don't have the same features, story, whatever in every game. RBY is considered bad objectively, just like the original Elder Scrolls. Later entries have controversial rankings, just like Elder Scrolls.

This shit isn't complicated. There are franchises where the first game or one of the first is arguably the best. Pokemon is not one.

>>27419438
Gen 3's elite four was GOAT. Good distribution of hoenn pokes

>>27419462
>Gen 5 just needed more pokemon and it wouldn't even be a contest.
Well it didn't have more pokemon, so it's inferior.
Better theme is subjective.

>>27419326
Platinum fixed the dex and the E4, gave you a good level curve that wasn't piss-easy like XY or pants-on-head-retarded like HGSS, gave you a ton of options for mons in the mains story, had a Battle Frontier, and gave the Gym Leaders and E4 the best movesets and teams they've ever had in the franchise.

The only real bad part I noticed after playing through it recently was the Distortion World. It was horribly underused and yet overstayed its welcome at the same time.

>>27419512
>2 sealeos
>shelgon
>pokemon repetition
>all of sydney's pokemon being shitmons

>>27419546
Sidney is easily the best e4 member since he had all different types.
>shitmons
Well he made the most with what he had.

>>27419326
If you battle every trainer you automatically and up seeing every mon except for the lake legendaries, dialga and palkia (which are shown to you in celstic) unown, and rotom afaik.

File: Bertha.png (88KB, 792x660px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 792x660px

This is how they should be building all Elite 4 teams.

The only bad thing about this team was that they didn't give her Mamoswine.

>>27419550
Honestly this is the one I agree the most with.
Diamond and Pearl aren't bad games. They just have inherent flaws that make them a chore to get through now.
The fun tier games are still fun despite them not being as good as some other games in the franchise.
Everything from Good upwards are all worth playing through again and again.

>>27419623
>Held item: None
nah

>>27419573
>If you battle every trainer you automatically and up seeing every mon
Only true in DP, a lot of the trainers don't carry things like the evos and other shitmon. Even then if you miss a few you'll be scouring the region for those specific pokemon or their trainers without knowing which ones you battled and which you haven't.

I'll never understand why everybody puts Emerald in a good position while Ruby and Sapphire is always bad.
They don't have those details that made Emerald great alright, but they're still decent pokemon games to play, far from being shit. It's like people who never played RSE just hates Hoenn in general but don't want to be seen as fools if they shit on Emerald.

The same, on a different way, happens with DPPt. Everybody says Platinum fixed "literally all of the flaws DP had" but it didn't fix even half of them. Even the speed in combat has been proven to be the same in Pt several times.
And again DP weren't bad or horrible as some put them, just had some flaws.

>>27419285
Rant time for DP

It's not the non mono type that make Dp teams shit. It's just the Pokemon

Ie in a game with 9 new bug types Aaron chooses 2. And 2 of his pokemon are the HOENN BUTTERFLIES

Like what's the point of being a fire type expert with 2 fire types.

Or not using the new wordam grass type for the grass gym leader, no they choose a starter!

Also the gym puzzles were disgusting. Like why does Fantina have math problems. Who thought Gardena's perspective puzzle was a good idea

Like what's with the idea of locking out so many fucking Cross evos, a highlight of the fucking game? Also so many gimmick Pokemon with shit evolution methods.

Also the story was dogshit. You defeat Cyrus by using the pixies, that you freed, because he made you, after he used them to create the red chain which most of the game is spent on. He just makes you release them and then they are the thing he stops them after so much effort catching them. Then when you battle him and loses he literally walks away with no punishment vowing to comeback but never does. Also remeber that grunt who kept running away then stopping, then running away then fights you when he gets tired and leads you to the rest of his team, then runs away. What is that bullshit

Also the fucking level curve was atrocious, 10 level jump between 10 Aaron and Cynthia. When in the elite 4 you grind on low 50's trainers with 1-2 Pokemon.

Also the fight gyms in either order is retarded because you become completely overleveled for the second one. I cannot express how much I hate Diamond and Pearl

>>27418877
How can one person have such perfect taste?

>>27419662
Only challenge mode had held items, and it's likely we'll never get a challenge mode ever again.
I would settle for having good teams in the regular playthrough.
Something gens 5 and 6 failed to deliver.

>>27418877
There are lots of things wrong here nigga.

Put DP, GS, RB, ORAS in shit tier and everything else in good tier then its fixed.

>>27418877
got your list upsidedown there kiddo

>>27418877
>God tier
BW2 Plat HGSS
>Good
Emerald BW Crystal
>Mediocre
FRLG ORAS GS
>Shit
XY DP

Gen 1 is too different to judge

File: tiers.png (4MB, 1412x2752px)

4MB, 1412x2752px

>>27418877
Your bait is stale as fuck sir.

>>27419538
>Platinum fixed the dex and the E4
Fixing the dex is all well and good but it just made seeing them all the more tedious which blocked players from the post game until it was done.
The E4's teams were improved at the cost of about 3 to 5 levels making it easier to deal with because of the lower stats.

> gave you a good level curve
Eh, not really.
It was kind of weird.
They raised the level of previous gym leaders and such but drastically lowered the E4 so you were kind of over levelled by the end providing you battled everyone. Kind of the opposite problem Johto had.

>had a Battle Frontier
Dude, for the longest time that was a huge negative for gen 4 because it rewrote the previous frontier for some reason and GF made no attempt to even aknowledge it. Not to mention it was easier and had less content.

>and gave the Gym Leaders and E4 the best movesets and teams they've ever had in the franchise.
Eh, they're still better in Black and White 2 by quite a bit. Iris' Haxorus can easily get the better of unknowing players.

>>27419702
I'm playing through Platinum right now and I'm almost at the Battle Frontier. One flaw they didn't fix from D/P is that the region is sometimes frustrating to explore. Some people hate Hoenn for all it's water, but all you have to do is use a repel and that's it. Sinnoh has snow and swamp routes that make it impossible to bike and run through, and sometimes stop the player completely. There are also a lot of caves to explore that require several HM's. That said, I'm still enjoying the game. Barry is a cool rival, Team Galactic is a cool team, and I like Cyrus more than I used too.

>>27418877
>most abstract taste possible
Nice spicy meme

>>27419709
>GL and E4 using starters hurr durr
So? You wanted to feel special like XY make you feel? You needed to see all the pokémon for unlock all the battle aria, so of course you needed that some npc had some starte

>>27418877
Never played BW2, so I'm excluding it from my autism list
>God Tier
Platinum
>Top Tier
Crystal
HG/SS
Emerald
>Good Tier
GS
FR/LG
>Mediocre Tier
BW
RBY (Mechanics were mediocre as far as battling goes, but they were great at the time.)
RS
DP
>Shit Tier
ORAS
XY

>>27419905
I'm arguing against Gardena's starter because there is a multitude of other grass types in the region, like the Wormadam prevo in the forest before it. I couldn't care about Flint using a starter, I care that he has less than fire types than more

Also 1 point out of like 10

File: gen 5 lmao.jpg (267KB, 1454x1006px)

267KB, 1454x1006px

>mfw /vp/ licks gen 5's ass because they're sad autists that want to feel unique
>mfw gen 5 is by far the worst gen both objectively and spiritually
>my literal face when

I just cannot stop kekking

>>27419824
Hell that one guys who streamed the /vp/ runs who did black2 mostly blind was overleveled as fuck with an ice type and wiped to her. He was cool, the last time we saw him was playing XD and he said he was sick. He hasn't streamed anything else to my knowledge. I hope he's ok

>>27419950
Fun fact the black copy is edited where it's tied with X and Y and platinum is rated lower than Diamond and pearl

>>27419950
>diamond
>rated higher than platinum

This is the place that likes X and Y the best. Congrats on your shit taste

>>27419950
>yfw people have opinions

>>27419251
I don't really blame them for being mad. Emerald's Battle Frontier was better in pretty much every way.

>More facilities
>Felt like an amusement park whereas Sinnoh's was in a cramped oval
>You meet the owner of Emerald's Battle Frontier throughout the game, making it feel more important when he personally invites you

>>27418877
>gen 5
>even listed
thread discarded

>>27419872
I actually love both the water routes in Hoenn and the snow/swamp zones in Sinnoh; it makes you feel like you're in a real adventure.
But both regions could have been much better if they had better pokemon variety and less dependency on HM's respectively.

File: 124543646546546.jpg (5KB, 160x160px)

5KB, 160x160px

>>27419950
>both objectively and spiritually
My sides

In all seriousness though, I agree with you that gen 5 is the weakest gen overall. The only place you'll hear praise for it is on /vp/ for the exact reason you listed.

>>27419930
I'm not even arguing with you about the fact that DP is or not a bad game. I consider it a valid game, and don't care about make other's opinion change. I just pointed out that the point about Gardenia made no sense.

>>27419146
But Emerald did what Platinum did first AND better.

>>27420032
You should try leaving /vp/ once in a while.

>Agree of you don't know shit
>Agree of you

I'm trying to ignore that, I know he meant "or" but that makes the sentence so prefect for this thread.

You guys are able to seriously rank updated clones of the same game. I mean I get preferring one or the other, but these are all the same game with slightly different bells and whistles based on the tech of the time. Being able to enjoy one version while hating any other just doesn't make sense to me. Maybe its because I had to play them in order with time between each.

File: worthwhile designs.png (3MB, 3392x1904px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 3392x1904px

>>27419950
>Gen5posting again

Gen 1 had way more terrible designs then Gen 5. 5 literally had 2 lines and victini where as 1 was more then half the dex.

>B-BLUB-BU-B-BUT THEY'RE ICONIC!!!

And? classic mario is iconic and he's a mistake.

>>27420032
But why do you dislike it?

>>27420147
>inb4 the story

>>27419950
>look I posted it again!

Fuck off it's edited to be false

http://www.metacritic.com/game/ds/pokemon-black-version

>>27420253
On top of that it's the only Pokemon game to get a perfect 40 in Famitsu.

>>27420273
Really? I like it, but it's not perfect.....

>>27420281
Yep.
http://www.giantbomb.com/profile/patronics/lists/perfect-scores-from-famitsu/56805/

I'm guessing because it didn't feel as rehashed as the last game?

File: Gen 5 dex.jpg (384KB, 900x964px) Image search: [Google]

384KB, 900x964px

>>27420121
Your entire list is laughable desu, just like your taste.
Pic related are quite literally the only good gen 5 designs.
Cannot even make a team of 6, the entire dex is a joke.

I want underage gen 5 kids to leave.

>>27420253
Pokemon Y is still rated higher, and has 8 extra points in user score.

Nowhere else on the internet likes gen 5, only this shithole because underage kids like yourself can post anon. You'd get laughed off of any other place for having such shit taste tbqhwy.

>>27418877
Sinnohfetus detected

>>27419060

The fuck it was.

Those games were pretty ahead of their times. There had been handheld RPGs before but they weren't as non-linear in how you played or as jammed with content. Nor had any really been as widespread in popularity. The fact that no two playthroughs of RB really had to be the same was pretty revolutionary at the time for a handheld game. It was a game of near endless possibilities. You didn't really see games like that then. Sure a game like Link's Awakening was pretty open but it was no where near as customizable. It gave you no where near as much control over the game, nor did the limited FF Legends.

I recognize that later games are better, and that RBY didn't objectively age well in a few respects, but for their time they were great games even with the glitches. Hell for most people the glitches and exploits were half the fun of those games but that's neither here nor there. Red and Blue are two really important handheld games. They sparked innovation and changed the way developers thought about the system.

I guess I try to judge games based on their time of release, personally, and RBY are great handheld games for their era. Gameboy games were very rarely good and Red and Blue really, really stand out. They're far from my favorite, BW2 is pretty much near perfect and they can't compete with Emerald, but they're still good for their time, and important in the overall scheme of the gaming industry.

>>27418877
>DP Top Tier
> Red and Blue that high
> RSE shit

Holy shit kys

>>27420273

Didn't Final Fantasy XIII get a perfect score from Famitsu too?

>>27418877
Why do sinnohfoeti hate gen 3 so much?

>>27420401
>Those games were pretty ahead of their times.
Stopped reading here.
Pokemon were well below the bar games like SMT set mechanically.

>>27420436
Because everything good in Sinnoh was better in Hoenn.

>>27420442

If you read on you'd see I was talking mostly about handhelds.

Glad you lacked an attention span though.

File: 1468085844951.png (51KB, 349x314px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 349x314px

>>27420371
>Golurk

Nobody hates giant robots anon. NOBODY. You're the one who needs to leave.

>>27420465
>If you read on you'd see I was talking mostly about handhelds.
Which is completely irrelevant to the mechanical quality of the game.
If you were talking visuals you would have had a point.

>>27420371
Braviary and Galvantula...

>>27419950
Jeez I didn't know Emerald was the worst game

http://www.metacritic.com/game/game-boy-advance/pokemon-emerald-version

>>27420371
>listening to normies

Literally kill yourself

Why is Emerald so fucking low? Why is platinum rated lower than DP

Fucking kill yourself

>>27420371
>Nowhere else on the internet likes gen 5
Except every other Pokemon related site. What you're thinking of is gen 4, that game is almost universally hated and only a handful of people legitimately like it.

>>27419387
>2 fire types

>>27420371
Anon, I don't even like gen 5 that much but that is some truely shit taste

>>27418877
>Gen 3 in shit tier
>Platinum in god tier
>D/P in top tier
>ORAS below XY

Sorry anon, more people agree that this list sucks.

>>27420530
It is confusing especially since they rated Platinum 83 when it was a lesser Emerald.

>>27419815
I agree with this list although i might put FRLG one tier higher.

>>27420121

If you squint at gen 1 it kind of looks like omastar

Gen 5 looks like a pokemon too but I can't place which one.

File: 1469052674489.png (30KB, 911x339px)

30KB, 911x339px

>>27420476
>>27420517
All dog shit. I'd be willing to bet you underage kids like hydreigon and krookodile too

>>27420530
Emerald has some of the highest rated user scores on metacritic, meanwhile both gen 5 games have some of the worst.

Those normies are legit more well versed on the games than you contrarian cunts.
Gen 5 games are the only ones in the entire series that I have never finished because they are just that bad. Both of them.

Do yourself a favor and take your own advice by killing yourself you underage piece of shit.

>>27420533
Completely false. From gamefaqs too Serebii, gen 5 is unanimously agreed upon to be a blight to the series.

Show me your backpeddling you pitiful cunt.

>>27420558
Both of them being inferior is mind boggling

Hoenn's never personally clicked for me, but I still respect it

>>27420505

Given what most handheld games were an RPG with 151 playable characters, about 20 bossfights, a fully fleshed out world, tons of possibility, non-linear choices, and multiple dungeons and areas to explore. Even graphically they were topnotched for a gameboy game.

The MT gameboy games were no where near the quality of RBGY.

I mean I agree the games didn't age well but if you look back to 96 and other gameboy games being released they were pretty revolutionary.

We look back now and say "Well the newer games were better so they're shit" and the newer games ARE better. A lot better. I don't hold much nostalgia for Gen I at this point in deluding myself to viewing them as good in todays frame of mind. However in the frame of 1996/1998 the Gen I games were easily some of the best handheld games ever made at the time. Especially Yellow. That game really pushed the original Gameboy from a graphical standpoint. Those are some clean ass sprites.

>>27420588
>GameFaq's
Seriously, you're fucking joking right?

This is the same place that voted Undertale the best game of all time

You should really reevaluate your life

>>27420607
>Show me your backpeddling
>Immediately backpeddles
He just blew you the fuck out in all honesty.

>>27420588
>talks about X and Y being great
>2nd lowest

Fucking make up your mind

>>27420588

>RBGY at the top

I'm shilling them as revolutionary here and even I'm disgusted by this.

BW2 were too pure for this world.

>>27420607
lol yeah how cud undertale win, its tumblr lol i evn plaid it...

File: 1242543545345345.png (300KB, 599x388px)

300KB, 599x388px

>>27420607
Like clockwork.
Feel free to show me the polls of anywhere more relevant putting black and white anywhere near the top of a poll.

>>27420633
Gen 1 and gen 6 are the two best, so I'm fine with either being at the top. Either way, the point is that gen 5 is always bottom, and at the end of the day that's all that matters since it's factually the worst gen no matter which way you look at it.

>>27420636
>BW2 were too pure for this world
Oh they were pure alright. Pure shit.

File: pokemon rankings.png (1MB, 1087x1870px)

1MB, 1087x1870px

>>27418877
It's rare to find taste as bad as yours.

>>27418877
hey OP
I agree with you

>>27420627
See >>27420633

>>27420636
It's almost frustrating. Like we're hit from every side it feels like

>>27420600
>most handheld games
Again, that only relates to the graphics and not the mechanics which is a key element in RPGs.
And I admit that the graphics were Average at best.

>We look back now and say "Well the newer games were better so they're shit"
You may think that but that's not the case. All through this reply chain I've been saying that they were less than stellar RPGs compared to series BEFORE it in the place that counts the most. Especially considering the majority of the content comes from multiplayer and PvP which the game wasn't geared around at all.

Anything after RBY doesn't matter in this argument, you should be looking backwards instead of looking forwards for points that won't help you.

>Diamond Pearl in top.
>Black and White 2 above black and white.
>Pretty good Gen in shit tier.

At least 26 people fell for this shitty bait thread. God bless.

>>27420663
That's some good taste anon

>>27420663
It is rare, and yet you still managed to pull it off by having worse taste.

>le x and y are bad meme, guys do i fit in yet xD

>>27420663
>Black and White
>High
Would be a perfect list if it was lower.

Why does everyone keep saying Yellow is bad? I'm genuinely curious.

>>27420719
They probably just hate anything related to the anime.

I actually personally prefer Blue, but I think it might be nostalgia since Blue was my first game and Yellow my second.

File: fbae149bd5e83ad2e9bb1bcabd7964e8.jpg (11KB, 236x181px)

11KB, 236x181px

>>27419697
Git fucking gud m8.
I always easily completed the sinnoh dex every time I played platinum it isn't that hard.

>>27420688
>X and Y
>not shit

Like look at route 14, you cannot tell me that they actually tried to make a good game

>>27420747
I rather like Yellow. The sprites are better and the idea of the rival having an eevee that evolves based on what battles you lost/won is an interesting idea.

>>27420663
That god tier is perfect.
These are the only games that actually matter.
You could skip the rest and you wouldn't be missing out.

File: 13423448_270207930006462_1255676474_n.jpg (35KB, 640x360px)

35KB, 640x360px

Gen 4/5 are the best games, this is non negotiable.

Gen 4 has
>An interesting new region with a great plot, good villains after Team rocket who aren't eco-hogs and amazing music
>Physical special split actually fixing the metagame and making competitive pokemon fun
>Online
>A full remake of Gen 2 that improved in every way by modernizing it, adding more pokemon and giving it the physical special split

Gen 5 has
>The best Dex to date by far
>The best region to date by far
>Animated sprites and the best battle sequences
>Evolite making every pokemon viable so people could play with their favorites
>B2W2 improved everything
>Better gym leaders
>The pokemon world tournament

Gen 1/2/3 are all outdated and have superior remakes. the only outlier is emerald, which is still good on its own.

Gen 6 went too far. Nobody asked for ugly washed out 3D visuals, France, and Mega's to get shoehorned in and ruin every possibly good thing 6 could have had.

Gen 7 looks the worst pokemon has ever been and is continuing on exactly what makes gen 6 so unlikeable and disgusting

>>27420756
>easy means quickly!
Stop being retarded anon.
Difficulty and tedium are two completely different things and it's even worse in Plat given that there's nowhere to even grind up Pokemon if you need to evolve them until you've reached that postgame which you're grinding for.

To describe the entire game it's like slogging through mud, wandering into a cave and sidling the wall for some way to find an exit but there's absolutely no danger.

>>27419697
Apart from Manaphy, Rotom, Dialga, Palkia, and Unown you can find a trainer with every pokemon

>>27420817
That's only true in DP anon.
At least go and play Plat.

>>27420659
I'm done fucking giving you (you)'s

>Gen 1 and gen 6 are the two best, so I'm fine with either being at the top
>gets second to last
>is ok with it

>>27420826
I have. You must be missing some trainers.

>>27420802
It's agony being a gen5 fag. You're despised especially by hoennbabies/Kalosperm/gunwunners and some sinnohshits. They people that are fine are HGSS people

File: 1465671025862.jpg (345KB, 1273x700px) Image search: [Google]

345KB, 1273x700px

>>27419709
I like it because it's a unique version of the sinnoh experience and is still novel because I always played platinum. The weird gym teams, off type e4 members and big level jumps are what gives them charm for me. They are like an alternate universe sinnoh, a directors cut. And that's why I would put dp in the same tier as platinum if only for the surf speed. That is just unforgivable, could you imagine going that slow throw trumpet wingle hoenn? Why was it that slow for dp. And the cross gen evo locking is legit I forgot about that. But yea dp will always have some cool unknown charm to me because I bought Plat at release having never played either d or p. It's the game that got me back into pkmn as an adult.

Tl;Dr
Sinnoh is a nice region m8

>>27420817
this is true

>>27420826
What pokemon do you think cannot be seen by battling everyone?

>>27420826
http://www.serebii.net/platinum/nationaldex.shtml
Here's proof. Oh yeah you need to battle the Lake Trio and Giratina too. I forget about the Lake Trio sometimes.

File: 1368711474343.gif (2MB, 320x240px)

2MB, 320x240px

>tfw I liked X/Y

wh-what was so wrong with it?

>>27420872
And you're no better using those terms. A true pokemon fan is supportive of any and all fans, even if they don't necesarily like the gen.

I don't think XY was that bad at all...
The only thing i think they did wrong was focusing in the old to much...the new pokemon where overshadowed witch it have a bad taste in my mouth,when they did good pokedexes in the past (Emerald,BW2 and Platinum had a perfect balance,and XY distrubution was as bad as Jotho).

But asides the regional pokedex,i think its a solid game,i don't know why people hate it to much.

>>27420677

And in terms of mechanics they're fine for their time though. No more broken then any other handheld game at the time. Psychic is OP because the Ghost/Psychic weakness wasn't mapped out properly, and a bit glitchy but given what they are they work. Most of the core mechanics are STILL in modern games. They're more refined now, but the core mechanics are still there. Gen I essentially plays just like a much, much, less refined later game. You catch and choose a team, you train it, you fight your way through the game.

You can say "MegaTen was better!" all you want but MegaTen being better really doesn't negate that they were fine games for their time, and revolutionary in terms of their make on the world and gaming as a whole. You'd have to be retarded to argue that they weren't. They birthed an entire renaissance of kids RPGs from Telefang, to Devil Children, to Megaman Battle Network and so much more. MegaTen are great games, better games, but they changed literally nothing, they're not mainstream past Persona (Which wasn't even really an SMT game), and still to this day have never really left a mark on the world or industry past "being really good games"

>>27420911
A lot of things. It's ok to like bad games anon. The entire Pokemon series sucks and yet here we are

>>27418877
> DP HGSS being good
Such shit taste

>>27420802
>Gen 4/5 are the best games, this is non negotiable.

That is ABSOLUTELY negotionable. Gens 4 and 5 are arguably the two worst gens. Also lol at Unova being the best region.

>>27420802
>>An interesting new region with a great plot
Region was convoluted and filled with dead ends that promoted backtracking also you traversed Coronet way too much and HMs were overused.
The plot was essentially RSE on a much, much more grander scale.

>good villains
Yeah no, the only part of Galactic that was good was Cyrus and I use that in relative terms because he wasn't a bumbling idiot. That said it was because he lacked any kind of personality and until the very end he was as flat as a board.

>>A full remake of Gen 2 that improved in every way by modernizing it
Except it didn't fix
>the level scaling
>Pokemon distribution
and made things like the daily events considerably more tedious because they worked in real time.
Not to mention the following Pokemon mechanic which they foolishly linked to the trainer card so you had to wrangle with the RNG to get that last upgrade.
Oh and for some odd reason blocking location based evos despite having areas for them like the power plant, Ice Path, Ilex and Viridian.

Oh and event locked formes. It still confuses me as to why they made Origin Giratina event locked in HGSS.

As for this
>>The best Dex to date by far
>The best region to date by far
That's an opinion and you shouldn't take subjectivity into account because it's just baiting people for responses.
That said the Habitat dex was an amazing feature and it's a shame it only made pseudo return in ORAS
And out of their original resolution they pixelation is extremely noticeable.

I honestly can't say anything else about gen 5.

In any case speaking objectively gen 4 was extremely far from the top Gen 5 is certainly one of the better gens however.

File: 1467875124139.jpg (55KB, 717x720px)

55KB, 717x720px

>>27420840
All I'm hearing is
>"Wahh I'm done getting well and truly ruined in this debate despite moving goal posts with every single damage control reply I give to you, please stop bullying me on an anonymous imageboard"

gg ez honestly.

>>27420935
>>27420911

XY's greatest crime is that they didn't get a third version.

Almost no one likes the OG games. It's always the third version that swoops in and saves a region.

Even Gen I had Blue version, which was leagues better than Red and Green. To a point where the US release was just rebuilt from it instead of releasing the original games.

>>27420990
Very true. They stripped down content in preparation for Z and then forgot to make it.
>no decent move tutors in the first two games ever
God this pisses me off so much so much more than no Battle Frontier or no walking Pokemon or anything. I have no idea why they keep doing this.

File: 1385433000559.png (179KB, 600x500px)

179KB, 600x500px

>>27420811
Anon, I've seen you in like three different threads today, give it a rest.

File: charizard.jpg (449KB, 2845x1377px)

449KB, 2845x1377px

>gen 5 children think gen 6 has washed out visuals
Do we need any more evidence that these babies are quite literally underage?
Your oversatured garbage is the problem. Gen 6 pokemon colors are extremely accurate with official art.

>>27420663
Something about HG/SS bores me, but since you gave Emerald the respect it deserves, I say it's a good list.

>>27421047
This.
Later gens started going overboard with the colour, sometimes giving pokemon a completely different hue than they should have.

>>27421047
that's the method i've used for spotting underage neo-gen posters for a while now. they grew up with gen 5 and think that shit is normal.

>>27420811
No retard, by easy I meant fucking easy.
Literally all you have to do is battle all trainers, see an unknown, look at mana manaphy at the mansion, see rotom, see the lake trio, and see dialga and palkia, which you can do at Celestic from cynthias gma or whatever. This is in platinum. It takes maybe 5 minutes after the elite four to have all pokemon in sinnoh seen and get the natl. Dex if you're not a retard and actually explored and battled everyone. EASY

File: Charizard Ken Sugimori.png (116KB, 300x262px) Image search: [Google]

116KB, 300x262px

>>27421047
No its not. The skin in the new games is too light. This is the official art.

File: 1469675412725.png (828KB, 613x497px) Image search: [Google]

828KB, 613x497px

>God Tier
HG/SS B2/W2
>Top Tier
Platinum
>Good Tier
Emerald, ORAS, BW
>Mediocre Tier
XY, FR/LG, Crystal
>Bad Tier
R/B/Y GS RS
>Shit Tier
DP

>>27421026

The anime is proof they were planning on it. It's heavily pushing Zygarde at the moment, it was renamed to XY&Z in Japan, the name change debuted at a point were we usually get new Pokemon games, CoroCoro was teasing Z for a bit when Zygarde was being talked about, Ash's Greninja was likely supposed to be a Notch-Eared Pikachu like event hence why they're promoting an OC concept over giving him Mega Charizard Y or Mega Sceptile.

It just all feels like it's promoting something that does not exist. That was likely planned in advanced. These kinds of synergy pushes are always planned a good while in advanced.

They most likely decided to put focus on Sun and Moon because the 3DS is winding down and the two games were in too deep in production and they probably didn't want to have to scrap them. I'd place good money that the team working on Z was pulled to help finish Sun/Moon. I really would. It just seems obvious you know?

>>27420931
>And in terms of mechanics they're fine for their time though
Very far from it. In fact they were horribly mediocre.

> No more broken then any other handheld game at the time.
I don't think you're aware as to how broken gen 1 was anon the mere mention of the special stat sets it lower than even the few handheld RPGs let alone RPGs as a whole. Then there were some subtle glitches and mechanics that were just incredibly retarded additions or mistakes.

> Psychic is OP because the Ghost/Psychic weakness wasn't mapped out properly, and a bit glitchy but given what they are they work.
That and the fact that GF neglected to add more than three ghost type moves into the game.
One of which was a status move.
Another did fixed damage meaning you had to rely solely on Lick for SE and STAB Ghost damage.

>but MegaTen being better really doesn't negate that they were fine games for their time
Of course not, but the fact that the game was poorly thought out and made does. While it was one of the less bland RPGs on handhelds it was certainly the least mechanically stable of them.
Which is made even more shameful when you realise the game took 6 years to finish with help from Creatures Inc. which was made of former Ape inc. members who had previous experience with the mother series so it's not like they weren't unfamiliar with the mechanics of RPGs.

>and revolutionary in terms of their make on the world and gaming as a whole.
I'm not going to argue that the franchise wasn't revolutionary but the games certainly weren't.

>MegaTen are great games, better games, but they changed literally nothing
This has nothing to do with this argument at all, you're basically saying that a new game can't be as good as an old game because the old game wasn't as well known.

File: 1469557328603.png (84KB, 300x325px)

84KB, 300x325px

>>27421111
No it isn't. That's the original art. The official art is literally what I posted you dumb cunt.
Learn the difference before embarrassing yourself again.

>>27421127
>the original art from the game where the Pokemon originated is not official
You're literally retarded.

>>27421112
Maybe move Emerald down a bit because of all the Battle Frontier whining ORAS got. It permanently stained my opinion of it. :^)

>>27421111
Too bad they didn't choose this color palette in either the anime or in the games. Ever.

File: tumblr_nl3pkpRYKx1unlgoso6_400[1].jpg (27KB, 260x240px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 260x240px

>>27421111
That's not even the original artwork.
This is the original, the one you posted was artwork for Blue.

File: 1466853621736.jpg (78KB, 735x986px)

78KB, 735x986px

>>27421140
>Get blown the fuck out
>Post damage control reply back that doesn't refute anything in a desperate attempt to save face
Pottery.

>>27421111
are you retarded?
can you be any more underage?

>>27421157
You're not refuting my point either, nigger. hat's the official artwork that was released for the game in which Charizard officially appeared. And you're saying its not official artwork.

>>27421144
I know you're funposting but I don't understand this funpost

>>27421174
>You're not refuting my point either, nigger.
That's because someone else did, nigger.

File: 12453456436465654654.png (101KB, 465x421px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 465x421px

>>27421174
If you're too dumb to be able to differentiate the difference between original and official, then I don't know what to say to you.

These two guys blew you the fuck out as well, and I see you conveniently tried ignored them.
>>27421154
>>27421148

>>27421207
>I can't prove my point so I'll just say you're too stupid to understand

File: kensugimori.jpg (43KB, 500x550px)

43KB, 500x550px

Ken Sugimori's artwork is literally the best. Anyone who disagrees is underage.

>>27419078
this is good list except for RBY

File: original official.jpg (33KB, 500x213px)

33KB, 500x213px

>>27421212
Except you are.

Original pikachu and official since you're quite literally retarded.

>>27419107
this is a good list also, except i would move up HGSS and BW2 by one slot each
i'd probably also move down ORAS

>>27421231
no thanks, too washed out, i prefer b&w style

>>27421212
Not him but dude, come on.

Your only point was blown to pieces. I mean, you're using international art instead of the Jap art when the Jap game came out 2 years before the international version

File: Amano_Faris_III.jpg (19KB, 270x371px)

19KB, 270x371px

>>27421212
http://archives.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Category:Ken_Sugimori_Pok%C3%A9mon_artwork
Have a perusal man. It seems that there's always one art per Pokemon with retarded color schemes and everything else looks fine. Please don't tell me you think Venusaur is actually supposed to be that fugly neon blue color because one art out of four has it.

Protip: artists sometimes change palette colors in "official art" for effect!

>>27421212
>This is your average gen 5 poster
No wonder the fanbase has such a bad reputation.
Kys.

>>27421248
>>27421262
>>27421268
>b8ing this hard
I should have known better than to argue with underage children

>>27421281
>gen 5 poster
If anything he's a genwunner woefully stuck in that bubble.

>>27421282
>gets BTFO several times
>e-e-everyone else is underage!!!
Unless you can actually argue your point, just stop responding and save face.

>>27421295
>he thinks he won he argument simply because he said so
Must be nice being 13 years old

>>27418877
nice bait

File: duh.png (1MB, 1166x1362px)

1MB, 1166x1362px

You guys are so full of yourselves that it's fucking hilarious.

>>27421307
you are literally doing that exact thing

explain why you are preferring >>27421111 over >>27421154 and >>27421047

>>27421324
>autism
That's not how you say excessive marketing.
Seriously the game didn't even sell in the west because it was a game but because of the anime.

>>27421231
Well, technically, anyone who disagrees shouldn't be here as they probably don't like Pokemon very much.

>>27421268
>[pokemon]_RB.jpg have really weird palettes
>[pokemon]_RG.jpg have palettes more in line with the updated official art
>RG are the actual original games in Japan
what did they mean by this

>>27421231
>Washed out incorrect colors all because of "a stylistic choice" over acurate depictions that don't all look like the same black haired japanese man/woman

Yeah no. Literally worse then toriyama with this shit.

>>27421101
No anon, you don't get it, actually playing the games is tedious, stop triggering me.

>>27421401
desu it has a nice nostalgic vintage feel to it. I'm glad they didn't keep the colors in later game but I'm glad the had it in the first place. I wouldn't mind if they made watercolors of newer Pokemons

File: Cogsgrove.jpg (14KB, 450x338px)

14KB, 450x338px

>>27421424
>Desu

Holy fuck shut up you derranged weaboo. Opinion fucking discarded. stop talking to me.

>>27421437
>he doesnt even know about the word filter
Newfags pls leave

>>27421437
desu baka senpai

>>27421444
sometimes when I want to say t b h I just cut the middle man and type desu
I did it that time

>>27421101
>Sinnohfetus defending Gen 4's shitty decisions
Color me surprised.
Seriously though why would anyone try defending a completely arbitrary and nonsensical choice like that? I mean you're not even fucking capturing them either you're just looking at them.

If you battle them all you still have a handful of evolutions you need to find.
If you don't battle them all you're scouring the region for that one so you don't have to put yourself through the trouble of trying to catch some honey mon with a bullshit encounter rate.

And like he said easy isn't the same as quickly, you retard.
Especially in a game that moves slower than fucking OAP. Hell it takes fucking five minutes to traverse one route because it's so fucking slow and god forbid you missed a trainer on the snow route.

Jesus Christ, how long until the Sinnohfetuses have been purged?

>yellow
>bad

pleb

>>27421481
>If you battle them all you still have a handful of evolutions you need to find.
nope already disproved. you just need to find legendaries, rotom and unown
http://www.serebii.net/platinum/nationaldex.shtml

didnt read the rest btw

>>27420802
>Gen 5
>best region

I agree with everything else but Unova's linearity holds it back, even if the routes and towns have great music. I also hold a grudge against Eviolite for seemingly killing cross-gen evolution forever.

>>27419007
RBY was fucking broken.

>>27421501
Are you fucking retarded?

>>27421535
>I also hold a grudge against Eviolite for seemingly killing cross-gen evolution forever.
Eviolite didn't kill it, the Gen 4 evos did.

>>27421550
>game developers first attempt isn't very balanced and has flaws
Shocking

>>27421551
Are you? Did you even look at the link? Trainers have nearly every Pokemon and "if you battle them all" there is no "handful of evolutions you need to find"

>>27421572
>first attempt
>Creatures Inc was made up of ex-Ape Inc. members who had experience in RPGs. Specifically the Mother series
>GF themselves have 10 or so games under their belt at that point.
First attempt my ass.

>>27421593
Allow me to correct myself: first attempt at this type of game

>>27421606
>creatures inc

>>27421606
>>27421572
Anon. RG is potentially the most broken game I've seen with that much Dev time. Also 3 separate new versions are all buggy exploitable messes (Blue American and Yellow)

>>27419107
Best taste

>>27421621
And what game did they make that is the same style as Pokemon? Not trying to patronize you, just trying to get a better understanding.

>>27421647
I mean these aren't intensional. Even the fucking intro is messed up. You can glitch Professor Oak leading you to the lab. You can glitch the game if you try to leave the lab too much

>God Tier
Black 2 White 2 Emerald
>Great Tier
Platinum Omega Ruby Alpha Sapphire Crystal Fire Red Leaf Green
>Overrated Tier
Heart Gold Soul Silver
>Decent Tier
Ruby Sapphire Gold Silver
>Meh Tier
X Y Diamond Pearl
>Flawed but not complete garbage tier
Red Blue Green Yellow

>>27421647
What are you even trying to say

>>27418877
>Red/Blue in Mediocre tier
>But Yellow in bad even though it's objectively better than those games

Alright, anon. Whatever you say.

>>27421669
As, I see what you mean. I thought you were saying the game was unbalanced. As in competitively.

>>27421669
It would be easier for you to guess a part of the game that isn't broken

Literally try

>>27421699

Not him but seeing as I was able to get through the game just fine without glitching like a hundred times as a kid they're really not that bad.

They're not the best games but how bad the glitches are is such an overblown meme.

>>27419387
I remember the wild encounters having so many annoying pauses

>>27421719
Name a part of the game that can't be messed up or abused?

>>27421719
>Not him but seeing as I was able to get through the game just fine without glitching like a hundred times as a kid they're really not that bad.
Chances are you came across some stat/move glitch without noticing.
You have no idea how hard it is to not encounter these glitches once you know what they are.

>>27421743

Most of the game can. That doesn't mean the glitches are intrusive. You can trigger them or exploit them but it's also pretty easy to avoid them. The games are loaded with them but they're really, really overblown with how game breaking and intrusive they are.

You can easily do a playthrough without glitching. The hardest one to avoid is probably Missingno.

I probably beat Blue on repeat non-stop as a kid and while I certainly hit them certainly had more glitch free runs.

>>27421793
What about the 1/256 chance of missing?

>>27421793
The probem isn't that you can't play the game, it just literally every single thing in the game can be broken with little effort

File: 1469514168653.png (34KB, 444x424px)

34KB, 444x424px

>>27421864
dude wtf. nobody who was playing those games played them to break them. The game can be played start to finish no problem. They crammed so much into that little cartridge. They even added code once they removed the debug kit. Yes you'll get glitches easily if you try to get them, but who cares? Hell the glitches make the game a fun speedrun.

>>27421793
>The hardest one to avoid is probably Missingno.
That's the easiest one to avoid anon.
The hardest would probably be the text overlapping with Oak, Rage, the catch rate glitch(which is just guaranteed), Focus Energy/Dire hit, Mirror Move desync in multiplayer, Psywave desync in multiplayer(which is inevitable) and the substitute glitch.
And this is just scratching the surface.

Oh and Toxic's multiplier still working after it's been cured using something like rest.
In other words if you burn or seed them they still get the multiplier each turn in addition to the effects of the new status effect.

>>27421940
>it's another "but glitchest are fun" epsiode

File: Pokémon Games.png (3MB, 1380x2485px)

3MB, 1380x2485px

>>27418877
>>27419273
>>27420663
Pokémon games best ever and tiers.

File: 1469461499377.jpg (97KB, 624x491px)

97KB, 624x491px

>>27418877
>BW2 are the highest
>DiaPer are Top Tier
>G/S/C and X/Y are Good Tier
>R/B and OR/AS are mediocre
>BW and Y are bad
>R/S/E are shit

>>27419155
That's wrong, sinnohfetus.
R/S still remain to this day as the highest selling GBA games.
If the chart is flipped, then it would be correct.

>>27419146
Emerald and Crystal are superior.

>>27422560
Black and White 2 as well.

Why does everyone forgets that final fantasy legend/makai toushi SaGa was acually the first rpg on a portable device. Not pokemon

>>27422407
>Emerald
>ok tier

>diamond Pearl
>top tier
>sharing a tier with HGSS/plat

>BW above BW2

Is this suposed to be a joke?

>>27419155most
you dumbass, R/S, E and FR/LG where the top 3 games sold in the game boy advance

>>27419107
I've never played past HGSS, but this looks accurate

>>27422973
Did anyone here claim they weren't?

FFL2 is so fucking hard, grinding is the most tedious thing with the mechanics in this game and Apollo won't stop killing my party members in one hit.

>>27418877
>emerald under shit
>red/blue not in shit
>x/y not in mediocre
>black/white not in at least good tier

File: 1469512028115.gif (1MB, 167x170px)

1MB, 167x170px

>>27420317
>taking a magazine that gave a perfect score to nintendogs seriously

>>27421111
>The skin in the new games is too light.
WE

I don't like gen wars myself, but I'll never forget how disappointed I was with R/S. It was so fucking boring and you needed Pokemon Colosseum to get a lot of shit not in the game. It truly made catching them all a pain in the ass. Emerald was better, but fuck R/S.

Diamond and Pearl were slow as shit. Platinum was pretty good though.

>>27418877
shit list. DP are easily some of the worst

>>27425683
I think GS and BW1 are the only first versions of a generation that weren't completely terrible. GS might be nostalgia goggles but BW1 was definitely at least passable.

File: 1469158881974.jpg (27KB, 486x416px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 486x416px

>>27418908
I never really like that gen it turned me off pokemon until y and x came out didnt care for them much either just picked white version and its surprisingly not as shit as i thought it would be

>>27419039
You must have autism if you think gen 1 and 2 were worse than gen3 2 is still probably my favorite

>>27426121
2 literally almost killed Pokémon anon.

>>27426128
I dont see how it had a decent story and let you go to kanto then of course the battle with red made me freak when i first found him but its just preference

>>27419115
ORAS was still better than XY

>>27420371
>He doesn't like donut muncher

>>27419550
perfect, I can fully agree with this

>>27419164
i could literally fap before it finished saving

>>27420663
I would put Crystal in Good Tier even if HGSS exist.
Your ranking is perfect anyway.

>>27418877
What makes B&W2 THAT much better than B&W?

>>27427908
Postgame.

>>27419331
Same. I originally thought I hated 3rd Gen because I played it when I was in High School and just wanted to be a cynical douche who hated everything, but even going back to it years later, then again in the remakes, it's just weak, all around.

>>27418877
I agree with most of this, except I don't understand how B/W2 can be god tier while the originals are in bad tier. There wasn't enough of a difference between those games to account for such a disparity.

>>27427908
This
I think they're good great games,but i feel like BW1 was more unique to my eyes so i liked it more than BW2,both are awesome games,trough.

>>27418935
>>27419050
Thirded

>>27428178
Hoenn has never clicked for me, but I still respect it. Also I put BW2 1# tier then BW in #2 tier

>>27418877
I never played bw2 so I can't really disagree with those, but i'd put black/white above red/blue/yellow and move emerald into good tier. I thought leaf green and fire red were pretty mediocre also, with omega ruby alpha sapphire being slightly better.

>>27419053
They're not bad. This list is simply comparing each pokemon game. Within gaming as a whole, they are way above average.

>>27428272
BW is still really good, but the sense of openness of BW 2 is pretty great. I know it's a bit of a meme, but BW is a bit linear. That climax though

>>27426585
I think you mean XY was better than ORAS.

>>27428386
If it wasn't for Emerald ORAS would be liked more

But considering that a 10 year older game has more content than the current one Its seen as much worse

>>27419438
Platinum was shit. Shinohfetuses are literally delusional Cynthia is easy as fuck only garchomp is a threat and even then any ice attack rapes it.

>>27428472
>fire blast
>stone edge

It's pretty good. Fuck off Platinum is the hardest outside of BW2 challenge mode

Is ORAS really that bad? Was thinking of picking it up.

>>27428734
No it isn't. It's just autists that are asspained over no frontier and kids that never liked hoenn at all

i can't believe so many people like gen V

its garbage in almost every single aspect except quality of life improvements

they must be underage

>>27428734
Well for nostalgia run it is bad

>>27428770
>must be underaged
>can't type correctly

Pottery