Old thread died, let's go again
OP's favourites
>>27321837
How do these work with dual types?
If Roserade is my favorite pokemon, wouldn't I have to place it on both Grass and Poison?
>>27321898
If it's your favourite Grass type AND your favourite Poison type then yes!
>>27321844
14/18
>>27321837
>>27321898
I just put it for whatever fit. I like Heracross and Paras, both are bug. Don't like anything better for bug or grass, so Heracross gets bug, and Paras gets grass.
>>27322033
Damn good taste. 18/18
>>27321844
12/18
Litwick and Snorunt a qt +2
>>27322017
4/7
>>27322033
11/18 Volcarona <3
>>27322384
13/18 Glad to see (M)Pidgeot on someone's list.
Forgive my shit MS Paint skills.
>>27322384
Nice choice of picture for Gengar.
>>27322473
Pretty solid taste, 12/18.
>>27322865
12/18, nice seeing someone else who likes Wigglytuff.
not too late am I?
>>27322927
>Didn't judge anyone else.
Yes, yes you are.
>>27322955
>not judging in a seperate post
lol
>>27321844
9/18
+++Sandslash, Sudowoodo, Quagsire
++Furret, Cynadquil
+Axew, Joltik, Swellow, Snorunt
>>27322017
6/7
++Jolteon, Haxorus, Hawlucha, Salandit
+Crobat, Crawdaunt
>>27322033
11/18
+++Togetic, Krookodile, Rotom, Politoed
++Volcarona, Duskull
+Gyarados, Torterra, Crobat, Starmie, Kabutops
>>27322384
8/18
+++Dragonair,
++Jolteon
+Scyther, Ninetails, Gengar, Froslass, Crobat, Blastoise
>STILL liking Golem
>>27322473
12/18
+++Breloom, Dragalge
++Volcarona, Emolga
+Kingdra, Pidgeot, Froslass, Gliscor, Starmie, Scizor, Mawile, Feraligatr
>>27322856
7/18
+++Togekiss, Ho-oh,
++Shedinja, Yveltal,
+Typhlosion, Grovyle, Bellsprout
---Reshiram :(
>>27322865
+++Heliolisk, Druddigon, Quagsire, Lapras, Wigglytuff
++Tropius, Roserade
+Crawdaunt, Gengar, Blastoise
>>27322927
+++Lickitung, Sudowoodo
++Escavalier
+Goomy, Raichu, Dusknoir, Starmie
>>27322981
He's yet to make a separate judging post, and the only people to judge without an image were me and OP.
>>27322865
Ooh, I like the favourite pokemon up at the top. 14/18 my Quagsire brother
>>27322856
Would be 9/18, but Arceus makes it 5/18
>>27322473
15.5/18
>>27322999
gimme a minute christ
>>27322983
hell yeah escavalier, jellicent and lickilicky, also Ho-Oh is pretty based, really lovely man
>>27322865
slurpuff, torkoal and crustle are great, also wigglytuff's a really good choice for normal type
>>27322384
oh my god I forgot about mimikyu as far as fairy types go, I fucked up, also 10/10 because miltank and claydol alone
>>27322983
>---Reshiram :(
W-what's so bad about Reshiram?
>>27323027
>gimme a minute christ
All is well now. It's just that selfish people trigger my autism.
>>27322927
13/18 No you aren't too late, I'm just playing Fire Red Omega so I'm slow to respond
>>27322983
15/18
>>27323032
It's my least favorite Pokemon. I think it's extremely disproportionate and awkward looking, but oh well.
>mfw feather boner
>>27322983
S-stop it, sempai, your good taste is blinding me!
>>27322983
Love the judging style btw
>>27323065
Ah well, to each his own. Reshi's my absolute favorite though, especially after growing on me a bit with PokéPark 2.
>>27323026
>15.5/18
Should I assume the .5 is for one of the steel/psychic mons?
>>27323071
rate
>>27323126
Aye, not a fan of Mawile
>>27321837
Good thing I save these.
>>27322033
You'd be perfect if not for Blaziken.
>>27322927
>Nidos
100/10
>>27322983
Points for being one of the few people on plant Earth that likes Dragonair AND Dragonite.pancham a shit though
>>27323146
14/18, Togekiss redeemed you.
>>27323155
10/18, people actually like Kabutops?
Shit all over me. I loved Gen 3 too much.
I just realized most of my favorites are bugs, what does that say about me?
first stages are just too cute
>>27322384
Fuck I forgot zoroark existed!!! Oh well, I still like drapion as my dark pick for his typing
>>27323305
8/18
>>27323333
7/18
>>27323338
6/18. I like the pictures you chose.
Rate other people with your picture, guys, it's selfish not to. And we can't tell it's you rating when you do it in a separate post.
>>27323338
>tauros
>bergmite
>tyrantrum
you are a pure and beautiful friend. i love you.
Flygon gets no love on this board
rate or hate gamers
>>27323616
Hitmonchan is confusing the hell out of me, but otherwise top tier taste!
>>27323535
Acceptable taste, glad to see another Lanturn lover!
>>27322033
>>27323338
You guys have great taste
>>27323762
11/18, bonus points for the quality chart!
>>27323762
The effort in this is killing me because there are so many irredeemable choices. Like, not just any Lucario, but Mega Lucario. Why?
>>27323688
ok. to explain hitmonchan I've loved him since I was a kid and in general if a game has a boxing character (i.e little mac, balrog, roger etc.) they're probably my favorite. however I am alone in this thought because he had bumfuck nothing in the way of fan art so i had to use a shot from the anime.
>>27323838
I can get your reasoning for liking Hitmonchan. It's just that the Hitmons and Kabutops have always looked like roaches to me.
>>27324237
if you have heracross on your favorites it's an instant 18/18 and i can't even fault the rest of your choices.
>fungus
>>27324059
aside for dark, fairy and fighting i generally agree with you, but FUCK OFF grass is great. 14/18
>>27323762
This really well put together and some of your choices are top notch but steel triggers the fuck out of me. 15/18
>>27324059
>would fuck/10
>>27324237
>alakazam, marowak, escavalier, articuno, typhlosion.
are you me?
10/10
Shit taste coming through.
Also, I couldn't find any good regular Gallade fanart so I went with the Mega one instead.
>>27323305
I love Hoenn too. 13/18
>>27323155
Solid taste anon. 15/18
>>27322983
Awesome putting Escavalier there m8. 14/18
>>27322927
Hello, fellow Dusknoirbro. 14/18
>>27322865
Pretty good 10/18
>>27322856
....
9/18
>>27322384
>Malamar
Aww yiss. 14/18
>>27321844
I like your taste OP. 15/18
>>27324521
is ghost your favorite type?mine too
>>27324630yes
>>27324516
18/18
I don't like Gallade but the rest are fine and Malamar is worth 2 points
>>27323802
>not just any Lucario, but Mega Lucario. Why?
>>27324319
>steel triggers the fuck out of me
It's honestly only because I use him in Smash bros.
Finally got around to doing this
>>27324738
Flawless
>>27324748
15/18
Why do Gen 3 and 5 designs suck so much?
>>27325208
How could you have such flawless taste but such shit opinions on gens?
r8 and h8
>>27325242
I'm an enigma.
I wasn't talking about the generations as a whole. I just think the designs from those games are generally pretty bad. I genuinely only like ~15 or so Pokemon from B/W, and even then none of them are particularly great. And no, I'm not just hung up on Vanilluxe and Garbodor - they aren't even the worst offenders. That honour goes to shit like Klinklang, Cobalion, Keldeo, Amoongus, Beartic, Gothitelle, Sigilyph, Cofagrigus, Basculin, Sawk/Throh, Conkeldurr, Seismitoad...the list goes on.
>>27326401
my guy
>>27321898
Try to make it so you can fit as many pokemon as you like, for example, maybe you like mandibuzz, but also zoroark, then you place mandibuzz in flying so you can put zoroark in dark!
I'm back from last thread, I think alreaady rated most of these but whatever
>>27321844
15/18
>>27322017
6/7
>>27322033
14/18
>>27322384
13/18
>>27322865
15/19
>>27322927
12/18
>>27322983
HNG sable- uh, I mean 15/18
>>27323155
14/18
>>27323333
14/18
>>27323338
16/18, gliscor twice? he's awesome but come on
>>27323535
14/18
>>27323616
(thats cute sableye, I needs the source please) 18/18
>>27325334
14/18
Any that I didn't put its because I think I already rated you past thread. Anyways, r8 or h8 or congratul8
>>27326985
14/18
>>27326947
11/18
>>27326689
10/18
Its begining to dawn on me that maybe sableye is more loved than I thought
>>27326689
12/18
>>27326947
15/18
>>27327205
16/18
>>27326689
12/18
>>27326947
15/18
>>27326985
11.5/18
>>27327502
10/18
>that togedemaru
>>27327553
>11.5
Excuse, what?
I strated with Gen V and have gone back to play the old games, but none of the designs from those hold a candle to the Unova mons.
as you can seefuck gen 4
>>27327626
>unova/10
9/18, I guess you have your own taste...
>>27327997
15/18, what did gen IV do to you? if anything it gave sneasel weavile that is better in every way, even design-wise.
I always struggle to understand how people can just like one gen completely and not the others or hate one absolutely. It seems so drastic not to appreciate the good and bad of every gen and how some excell in areas others dont.
nothing really, just after making the list realized I hit every gen but 4. Personally, I don't like Weavile's design as much.
>>27321837
>>27328092
That hasn't happened to me. I think I have at least one favourite in each gen, and I'm pretty sure it is because of pic related. Filling it made me realize there were so many mons I liked, you should try it. Weavile is my second favourite gen 4 mon after gliscor.
>>27328128
15/18
>>27328214
13/18, I love the sawsbuck, he's a top-tier bromon
>>27328312
16/18, so many great choices
>>27321844 11/18
>>27322017 5/7
>>27322033 13/18
>>27322384 16/18
>>27322473 11/18
>>27322856 9/15 ++ Delibird, not counting Arceus
>>27322865 11/19 ++ Cobalion, underrated legendary
>>27322927 11/18 Nidorans a cute
>>27322983 15/18
>>27323146 12/18
>>27323155 12/18
>>27323305 12/18
>>27323333 10/18
>>27323338 13/18 nice to see Klefki
>>27323535 13/18
>>27323616 14/18
>>27323762 13/18 +++ effort
>>27324059 12/18 - why the hate on grass?
>>27324237 16/18
>>27324344 11/18
>>27324442 12/18
>>27324516 12/18
>>27324521 9/18
>>27324667 12/18 seeing Bellossom in a list always warms my heart
>>27324738 14/18
>>27324748 12/18
>>27325208 15/18
>>27325334 13/18
>>27326646 12/18 funny images, but your Garchomp somehow makes me feel uncomfortable
>>27326689 10/18
>>27326947 13/18
>>27326985 15/18
>>27327205 14/18
>>27327502 12/18
>>27327626 11/18
>>27327997 15/18
>>27328128 10/18
>>27328214 11/18
>>27328312 13/18
welp, everybody got pretty average ratings from me, maybe I should try giving different points for really great and just ok choices.
Overall I can say, good taste /vp/, I always liked at least half the mons.
I'm impressed about how much effort some of you put into those, that made going through the pics quite fun.
Thanks for that and sorry for my standard art image.
>>27328092
I know that feel. One reason why Altaria made it into my list was because I felt bad for the lack of gen 3
>>27326646
Here's the full sableye
>>27321837
>>27328622
Thanks for the 12, that garchomp is the only one I had and I was too lazy to look for more
I give you a
13/18
>>27328692
Thanks!
>>27321837
feel free to rate
>>27329299
>heracross
>sableye
>whatever that RAD electric gen 7 beetle is called
>marowak
>escavalier
(You)'re pretty good
>>27323146
>snorlax
>togekiss
nice
>>27322033
What a tasteful anon
>>27328693
>Genwun/10
15/18, but seriously, I'd call you genwunner but you chose a gen 5 pokemon, the gen most hated by genwunners
>>27329299
16/18
I think you've convinced me that people in average actualy like sableye, I can die peacefully now
>>27326646
good taste in rock types
>>27331911
probably the best taste ITT
>>27332299
Weavile and Froslass could fit in Ice too
>>27332328
Can someone post the template for this one?
It's infinitely better than the one being used by most of the thread.
>>27331911
I'm saving this.
>>27321837
>>27331911
this is really fucking good. and i dont even like shuckle. nice job anon.
>>27332328
>>27332472
yeah its really good. it almost looks like he drew those himself. im wondering how he got such good images.
>>27333833
I'm talking about the template, not the illustrations, you absolute ocean of cum.
>>27333924
but does it really matter if you cant get those images?
>>27333833
those are the pokemon global-link art work, they weren't drawn by the anon.
I guess I'll not be a leech and rate some too.
>>27328603
Very good taste not a single bad one.
>>27328622
Also pretty good taste, but a little bit lacking in the electric department.
>>27328693
You got some goodies like fighting/ghost, but also some pokemon that suck man ass such as Mr. Mime. Your taste is mediocre+.
>>27329299
Your taste might even rival my own.
>>27331911
10/10, I would've dressed better if I knew Jesus himself would've entered the thread.
>>27332299
I'm getting mixed messages out of this. Some of these(fire, flying, poison) are really good picks, while other(normal, ground, fighting) are not so good.
>>27332328
Take away fighting and you got yourself some premium taste.
>>27332450
You get some extra point for effort, but fighting, poison and water pushes you down a bit despite the good ones like grass, water and steel.
Also, for everyone having trouble with with pictures from google being too large to fit in the box, rezise the whole picture(110%) first and then rezise it back again(1030x1240) when you're done. Makes the whole prosses a lot easier.
>>27332450
13/18
>>27332299
15/18, love the rampy
>>27332328
13/18, you got a lot of inanimate object mons, odd taste
>>27334024
Which is your original post anon?
>>27334105
Oops, forgot to quote it.
>>27333806
>>27334182
Wait, I think I rated you last thread. Well whatever, I'll go in-depth this time because I feel like it:
16/18
I only dislike the psychic and fire choices, mainly because I never liked claydol since its name is so uncreative and the thing is just too weird for me, and torkoal always was too bland and boring for my taste. Your best choices are definetly Drapion and armaldo because of rare good taste, and gliscor because he's just awesome.
However no sableye means 0/10 for you
>>27334401
(my post, forgot r8s)
>>27332299
12/18, good stuff
>>27332328
16/18 EXCELLENT taste
>>27332450
10/18 decent, nice cofag drawing
>>27333806
8/18, bonus for claydol and torkoal
your taste will never be as shit as mine, kiddo
>>27334401
Magcargo, Cradily, Haunter, and Heracross are your best picks.
Not having Tyranitar is wrong.
7/18
>>27333806
6/18
Aggron is a decent choice, as is Torkoal.
>>27332299
5/18 but much better than this rating suggests
>>27331911
18/18
>>27329299
8/18
Shiftry, Sneavil, and Sableye are nice choices.
Sudowodo is the only acceptable alternative to Tyranitar.
>>27328622
11/18 I admire your taste
Finally did it woooo
hmmm