Am I missing any popular YT video game critics? (E-celebs and

>>387532231
check this 5!

Egoraptor is good at making it seem like he knows what he's talking about, but is shit at games
I like critics who are at least alright at the game they are reviewing, what games is arin good at?

>>387532231
Jamtram?

>no Crowbcat

>>387532430
seems like you dropped it. don't worry my man I have your 5 right here.

>>387532231
I don't even know who most of these chucklefucks are. I only recognize Jim Sterling and Angry Joe cause you faggots won't stop talking about them.

> Raycevick that low

Shit list. Dude makes good content and he actually reads and responds to his comments.

I left like 9+ paragraph comments on all of his Halo X years later videos responding point by point to the stuff he said in each back when his channel was still small and he responded to every one with like 6 paragraph responses of his own

>>387532231
Who's guy at the top?

Ah yes only have their current avatar instead of putting their names over each one. This image will age perfectly.

>>387532884
Turbo Button
Never heard of him before either

File: accursed farms.jpg (6KB, 176x176px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 176x176px

>The objectively best one isn't even on the list

Come on now

>>387532231
Why is digibro even on this? He does anime videos.

>>387532430
You mean this 5

>>387532672
He's borderline. I didn't include him because he's not really a critic. He just splices clips together to imply a broad point, usually about the games industry. AFAIK he's never done an analysis of a game mechanic, or a critical response to a game.

>>387533091
He has done video game videos.

>>387532231
where's somecallmejohnny?

you forgot the egg.

I only recognize TBs hat.

>>387533275
>(E-celebs and comedians need not apply, critics and analysts only)

>>387532430
>>387532712
>>387533152
You people are posting without your fives?
I'll have to haul your asses into the station. While on the topic, check this 8

File: 1384688647435.jpg (70KB, 330x319px) Image search: [Google]

70KB, 330x319px

>video games are so shit they don't even have academic critics, but rely on literally who youtube shits

>>387533505
It seems you misplaced that 8 officer, you can borrow mine.

Why do they majority of these e-celebs have such effeminate male voices?

Haven't their testicles dropped by now?

>>387532231
There's nothing more pathetic than rating e celebs who happen to review games. What a bunch of losers kek.

>>387532430
no, check this 5

>>387533727
Do I really have to be THAT guy who ends the chain by getting an 7 ?

Worth a Buy is good, he's constantly raging about the state of the industry - like you guys.

What about caddicarus? (Low tier for me)

>>387535883
I dunno. He shat on 2b cause he said she looked 12 and had unrealistically big tits. You can hate it for waifu pandering and I don't really care but worthabuy is retarded

Arlo needs to be shit tier. If "Nintendo Internet Defense Force" were an actual person, it would be him.

>Defends Nu-tendo doubling down on making shit Paper Mario games
>Makes an entire video about how the weapon durability in BoTW wasn't poorly executed

File: 1492644310872.jpg (17KB, 617x627px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 617x627px

EmptyHero should be at the top.

>>387532231
I like the reviews of Joseph Anderson but i really hate when he is forcing his headcannon or bringing "solutions" for narrative problems.

His video on Last of Us really made me angry, how he wanted to read between the lines and prove that Joel did the right thing was ridiculous. The scene was badly written and nonsensical, created a conflict where there were none and exists just so you can justify a "dramatic" killing spree.

File: liam.png (682KB, 596x663px) Image search: [Google]

682KB, 596x663px

>Dunkey in mediocre to bad

File: 5.png (597KB, 555x555px) Image search: [Google]

597KB, 555x555px

>>387532430
Lookin for this?

>>387535745
Ummm, no sweetie, check my 5

>>387537370
>league youtuber
>makes "lol so randum" videos
>completely fabricated personality

>>387537479
Are you faggots going to stop at fail and check this 2

File: duvwhoo.png (249KB, 410x443px) Image search: [Google]

249KB, 410x443px

>>387537563
He hasn't done League for a couple years now and I don't care who he is outside of the videos honestly

anyone who watches BigFry here?

Also who is the top 4 of this list? I have never seen these logos before.

>>387537665
I don't think so, check my 6 niggas

>No SCMJ

This mentally ill trans freak should be on the list

https://youtu.be/-6ZChfTF0-k
https://youtu.be/2Ptj6JGKSko
https://youtu.be/nqsspa30xOE
https://youtu.be/jMxv7IWll0A


and this trans freak weirdo
https://youtu.be/h2NZCTcLCR0
https://youtu.be/5vVsVs3hMYo

why are there so many mentally ill trans people with such good taste in video games?

>>387537849

I see your reverse 6 and play a 4.

Whos the top one?

>>387538039
They know how to live a fantasy life very well

>>387538184
Impressive, sir. But not as impressive as this 8.

File: 1502689101752.png (361KB, 473x675px) Image search: [Google]

361KB, 473x675px

>>387538184
N-nani!?

>>387532231
I can name like 5 dudes on this list at most

Who are those on the top three tiers

>>387538184
Ugh, does anybody even play 4 in their deck anymore? Anyways you just activated my 7 card.

>>387537809
i only recognize Joseph Anderson, the dragon one

>>387532231
I'm looking for Giant Bomb in the bottom tier but I can't see them

>>387537809
>>387538406
>>387538219

https://www.youtube.com/user/KuribosMask
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCyhnYIvIKK_--PiJXCMKxQQ
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCT7njg__VOy3n-SvXemDHvg

Not sure about the "O"

>>387532231

TB definitely belongs in "Are you even trying?"

Non-reviews consisting of unedited footage from his streams that he calls "first impressions." Podcasts where it's blatantly obvious there is no planning done and they just wing it resulting in unnecessarily long clusterfucks. "Port reports" that are little more than "It works/doesn't work on my machine." Excluding the podcast uploads he barely averages 1 video every 2 or 3 weeks which is shockingly lazy considering how little effort goes into each videos.

Honestly, how this man's career as an e-celeb is still going is baffling to me and the fact that he has balls to endlessly shit on whathisname and whatshername from the podcast about their content is an amazing display of self-delusion. Even if they are shit they are still way better than he his and put in a fuckload more effort.

>>387538812
Alright, thanks mate

>>387532231
Somecallmejohnny is a good guy

>>387538878
yeah but TB's nailed the excuse of "it's just first impressions!" so he can be as lazy and sloppy as he wants

at least he's done a good job convincing his fuccboi viewers that it's acceptable content.

File: 1500608658692.jpg (31KB, 316x340px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 316x340px

>>387532231
> Egoraptor that high

>>387539064

Sure, he calls them "first impressions" to dodge the quality complaints but when the copyright strike happens all the sudden they are "reviews" and covered by fair use.

>>387532231
>implying i can recognize these fucking icons

Stop posting this cancer list and give me text names you tards

Game analysis YouTuber starter pack:

> *Souls games
> Metroid Prime
> Platinum/Clover games
> Metal Gear Solid in general, Snake Eater in particular

There is exactly ZERO to be said about these games that has not been said before, I don't know why anyone bothers.

If your channel is nothing but the above titles, it is really, really boring to watch.

>>387539294
My understanding was that his first impressions were still critical.

File: 1489217960614.jpg (28KB, 645x440px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 645x440px

>>387532884
Turbo button
He's an idiot and was put on top as a joke

>>387532231
I think Ross's Game Dungeon is by far the best video game show on Youtube

>>387532231
>Not putting Based B-Mask at the top
That was your first mistake. What's /v/'s hard on for turbo button all about?

>>387539535
You forgot how they overanalyze incredibly popular games like Zelda or Uncharted

>>387537563
>league youtuber
Shows how much you know about him nowadays.
>completely fabricated personality
You mean 95% of Youtube?

File: Fjz8UUE.png (379KB, 610x413px) Image search: [Google]

379KB, 610x413px

>>387532231
Needs a special below bottom tier for "Angry Joe" Vargas.

I'm gonna get shit but i really like dunkey, not every video is great, but i like the guy and overall is very entertaining, i wouldn't consider him a reviewer though. Also GMT and Core-A are great though Core-A tries too hard including weird theories.

>>387539591

That's not the way fair use works.

Shitty, lazy, inaccurate, incomprehensive, etc. reviews that damage the marketability of a product are NOT covered by fair use. This is why companies can't just pay to have their competitors' products reviewed poorly.

>>387532231
>brihard somewhat low
>shammy low
>egoraptor WAY too high
I agree with a lot of placements (idea channel, core-a, hbomberguy) but that "mediocre to bad" category is too bloated. Separate it.

i really like downward thrusts work and i dont see his avatar on the lsit.

also Sterling is top tier.

>>387532231
Who is that with blue hair and glasses?
There's someone at my university who looks exactly like that, and I know he's written a few papers about video game design. I wonder if it's his channel, or if he's copying that guy's style

>>387540081
What was his name again?

>>387533084

Easily the best of them all.

i like uberhaxornova

>>387533084
new phone who dis?

>>387540219
Criticism does not exist for the benefit of the publisher. Slander is not covered by fair use.
>This is why companies can't just pay to have their competitors' products reviewed poorly.
That's a bribe, not criticism.

>>387533159
Do we even know if CrowbCat is a man?

File: 1500505555162.png (579KB, 857x783px) Image search: [Google]

579KB, 857x783px

Who is the lindybiege of vidya?

>>387532231
who are the three in the in the great category

File: 1503085334907.png (1MB, 897x1488px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 897x1488px

Try and prove me wrong.
https://youtu.be/baV3dFX9uv4

Is there anyone else like Mattmatosis who I can throw on for backround noise for hours

>>387532231
>Errant Signal
>Any lower than "Sure Why Not"

Fucking hell mate, you could at least TRY to look like you're not baiting the fuck out of people.

>>387532231
>dunkey not in brilliant tier
stopped reading there

>>387541248
This man is >>387533084

>>387541415
Who even is this

>>387532231
Why is Mathew always so low? Is it cause he gets shilled a lot here? I disagree with like half the stuff he says but he's still my favorite reviewer.

>>387541619
A true video-game philosopher.

>>387540926

Saying "But it's a review" does not mean you automatically get covered by fair use.

Fair use is not a way to get away with copyright infringement, it's a compromise. Basically, you have to either show either a) you don't do anything to harm the marketability of what you have infringed on or b) if you do it is reasonable that you have done so, e.g. a thorough criticism. You are also supposed to do the absolute minimum of copyright infringement that is necessary. That's why you can't just upload entire movies with your commentary track over the top and call it fair use. You are going to have a very hard time convincing a judge that a "first impression" that consists of unedited footage because you were too lazy to put in effort is both thorough and a reasonable amount of infringement.

>>387541669
because hes a fucking mick

>>387541559
Almost everything he says is really dumb while he's acting like it's really smart

>>387541669
People got mad at him for shitting on over half of the souls series.

>>387540542
Sunder

>>387532231
Can someone list out everyone to SURE WHY NOT? I don't have enough autism to recognize all of these people.

File: really.jpg (53KB, 428x428px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 428x428px

>>387541248

Angry Joe.

Starts out upload regular videogame related videos ends up doing fuck all and if he uploads something it's not what the original viewers subscribed him for.

Seriously when was the last time this limey twat uploaded a video about a weapon, mediaeval armour or something ? I don't care about his Q&As, his political ideology or his views on gender politics. I'm trying to avoid that shit and learn something about the past yet you can't fucking escape politics and social bullshit drama no matter what channel you watch.

>>387532231
Jim Sterling belongs in the lowest tier for his superfluous faux-arrogant demeanor and how much it blew up in has face over the blowback he got for his review of that new Team Ninja game.

>>387540081
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ICFokPABGxw

>>387541528
Joseph Anderson

>>387540675
I just told you,
>"Angry Joe" Vargas

>>387541415
>it's a 40 minute video on Oblivion's plot, of all things
>he's greenscreened himself over the game footage for pretty much the whole video

this is a joke right?

File: YC-7plA9.jpg (42KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 512x512px

>>387532231
>Super Bunnyhop
You can do better.

gggmanlives is good

>>387532231
>theautismbrit and hyperpretentioushero in the same tier as matthewmatosis and hbomb
>dunkey in the same tier as pissed off pedro, puppet autism man, literally jim sterling, owl avatarfag, and prosellout
shit list op, the 5th tier ranges from good to worst of the worst, 4th tier has a bunch of people who should be moved down

>>387542412
You wouldn't understand mortal.

I loved watching Arin discuss game design in sequelitis, but he just doesnt make content because game grumps makes more money and its easier. Does he even draw anymore?

File: Untitled.png (39KB, 210x194px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 210x194px

>>387536868
can't be on top when you're banned
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zMz9Ia3Qcw8

File: jesus christ how horifying.png (570KB, 647x457px) Image search: [Google]

570KB, 647x457px

>>387532231
>Custom Gamer in the same tier as Egoraptor and Hbomb

File: 1486764811262.jpg (88KB, 1190x906px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 1190x906px

>>387537563
dont know how to use google, huh?

Why are FemFreq so low? Theyve arguably made the biggest impact on the industry with their content

>>387543997
It's a judge of how good they are, not how controversial or influential they are.

>>387536868
>t. 14 year old

File: 1501119375543.png (19KB, 512x323px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 512x323px

I like Clemps, but know exactly why I shouldn't.

File: 6427586970.jpg (68KB, 900x700px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 900x700px

>>387532231
>Errant Signal
>Hbomber
>Jim Sterling

Why is rags so low ?

File: Video-games--Sequels,-rape-jokes,-reboots,-no-female-protagonists,-unyielding-gritty-militarism,-60-FPS-cars,-inappropriate-cat-calls..png (48KB, 640x343px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 640x343px

>>387541559

>>387541968
This, who the fuck are they?

>>387543051
Dunkey isn't good

>>387544956
Rags is a pretentious piece of shit.

I don't recognise half of these. What's the point in this if there are no names to go with them?

>tfw starting my own matthewmatosis/joseph anderson knock off channel
>tfw my only gimmicks are trying to be funny and being absurdly autisticly in depth
>will only be remembered by 5 people for being the guy almost as autistic as the dude who made thousands of thomas the tank engine vids

fuck my life. I can't stop now though, it's the first thing I'll have ever finished. I just wanna see my name up on that chart. I just want fat retards on /v/ to know my name.

>>387543051
dunkey hasn't been funny in literally years at this point
go back to www.reddit.com

>>387532231
Whos the guy next to $5 Joe?

I object to myself as I'm not popular. I'm just a bloke that hates new Tomb Raider. If anything i should be under "Are You Even Trying?"

>>387532231
Retropolis Zone
August Keller
The Davoo

Wheres Chad Warden, The undisputed king?

>>387532231
Don't know any of those i think, and even if i did, i can't recognise them from their logo.

You tryhard.

>>387532231
>SuperBunnyHop
>Not Great tier
I mean give me a good reason, he actually brings real journalism to the table too unlike everybody else, that alone disserves a tier of its own.

>>387532231
>LambHoot in mediocre to bad tier

Fucker cares a bit too much about little flaws in games but his analysis is on the next level compared to other shitty critics in his rank

/v/ is fucking dead

>>387532231
Dunkey is pretty good.

>>387532231
>clemps that low
why though, his videos are quality

>>387532231
>hbomberguy
>anything but bottom tier
He has like 3 really good videos and the rest is Sarkesian bullshit and festering anti-gg crap

His main gimmick is holding controversial gaming opinions

>>387547628
give me the name of one of your videos

>>387547628
It could be worse, you could be known by far retards all over /co/ like I'm trying to do.

File: __hakurei_reimu_touhou_drawn_by_chamaji__fd21d7ad13739d073e9ea7b5dfbbee69.jpg (66KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 1000x1000px

You know nu-/v/ is for real when we have unironic threads like these nowadays.

>>387550121
haven't created one yet. Been working on it for a while though and I'm almost done

File: 1375639334600.jpg (142KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]

142KB, 512x512px

>>387532231
>manlytears is still making these threads

>>387532231
Missing the part where you put a gun in your mouth and pull the trigger for being a faggot stream watching retard

>>387549575
Are you a weeb by chance

>>387551445
not really. all of the content he posts outside of youtube is garbage but i really don't see how people can deny his video quality

>>387551362
>stream

>>387551846
Most of his "analysis" videos are just plot summaries and though some of his humor is funny, a lot of it is pretty pandering, obvious or just annoying.

>>387532430
Apply yourself
Here's the 5

>Mandalore in Come on you can do better tier
Come on Anon, he's gotten 100 times better

dubs?

File: 1464897430412.png (74KB, 1008x552px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 1008x552px

>>387550625
you're thinking "nova-/v/".

>>387555251
>People who grew up in 200X don't know what DLC-free alternatives are
>Found /v/ through /b/ and /b/ through epic legion shit despite that taking place in 2007
>Prefers games that aren't PS2/GC/Xbox ones
Always funny when faggots try to act smart in 2016, yet know so little about history and project their own flaws onto everyone else.
There are only two groups here. Oldfags who were here before 2007 and newfags who came here during Chanology in 2007 or afterwards. That's it.

>>387543997
That does not change the fact the quality of the content is poor and filled with lies and strawman.

File: king of small people.png (408KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]

408KB, 512x512px

manlet tears >>>> manly tears

>>387533159
Digi the "I only played Dark Souls for 10 mins and it's my favorite game!" faggot brony

>>387557342
Calm down.

>>387532781
This, i still cant understand how watching some one play can be fun.
Also most reviewrs dont know what they are talking about, the only YT i respect is the completionist. even if i disagree with his opinions most of the time, he does complete the games. that is more than every other "reviewr" does

File: kizuna_ai_by_keenh-db1b8lr.jpg (62KB, 400x703px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 400x703px

>>387532231
What about Gacha shills?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L-Zgw1FSLcQ

It's a rabbit hole.

>>387536520
Caddy is ok their but the padding in his videos is really bad
Idk why Projared is so low though he's based

File: IMG_0299.jpg (78KB, 434x325px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 434x325px

>no Jerma tier above all others

>>387559624
>Video game analysis/critics
Wouldn't expect anything but an illiterate from the Jerma fanbase, but come on.