who is the better protag?

The former

>>386811416
>Yu
>A good protag

File: IMG_4781.jpg (410KB, 1565x3780px) Image search: [Google]

410KB, 1565x3780px

>>386811416

I prefer rebels to Chads.

>>386811825
MY MAN!

File: d77d1dfdc7971106f6b205ec7ae6eb86.png (331KB, 600x570px) Image search: [Google]

331KB, 600x570px

>>386811416
Ziodynecock is fine and all for memes, but pales into comparison to Tatsuya in every way, especially voice acting. Fuck Johnny Yong Bosch..

File: 1443916615266.png (150KB, 412x245px) Image search: [Google]

150KB, 412x245px

>>386811416
Yu would be fine if he was just in P4.
Unfortunately they kept putting Mister Ziodynecock into everything until we were sick of him

File: eternal punishment.jpg (19KB, 156x190px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 156x190px

Brotag is just a perfect self-insert with a terribly bland default personality when he isn't being controlled by the player. Tatsuya is way fucking better. He has(gains) his own personality and his imperfections actually make him feel identifiable than any other MC. I would have done the same thing as him and so would most people.

Can't wait for Tatsuya to put Cuckira into his place when he gets smarmy in Q2.

File: 28747429.jpg (130KB, 800x1132px) Image search: [Google]

130KB, 800x1132px

>>386814019
>P2 being acknowledged ever again besides a small shoutout
I wish though. Cross over shit gives me gigantic hardons and I am constantly blue balled by the P2(and some of 1's) cast getting shafted in these side games. I think Tatsuya would be more chill with Joker than any other Persona MC. The title of Joker might put him through a PTSD moment though.

Eternal fuck up vs Gary Stu

File: i calmly ride to my death.gif (993KB, 290x198px) Image search: [Google]

993KB, 290x198px

>>386814942
Gotta go with eternal fuck up here.

>>386815448
>>386814942
That eternal fuck up has managed to get the personification of humanity's dark half, humanity's shadow to make really gay comments towards Tatsuya

Yu just has fucking Yosuke

check mate

>>386816047
Kill yourself.

File: Hero1.png (203KB, 460x640px) Image search: [Google]

203KB, 460x640px

Autism bunny is best

>>386811416
Eternally my boy Joker
>absurdly /fa/ sense of style
>average height so he doesn't get any immediate advantage
>becomes powerful enough to have "Chad" sucking his toes in a potential fight
>has the best theme
>has the best girls
>has the second best game
>anime adaptation a year before Yu got his
Someone stop this madman

File: rabbit.png (68KB, 814x487px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 814x487px

Hello I am here to save the world.

>>386818982
isn't he tall for japanese standards?
he's taller than pretty much everybody except yusuke

File: tumblr_oq5oq7PmQO1vzfjeio1_r1_1280.png (418KB, 900x1110px) Image search: [Google]

418KB, 900x1110px

>>386811416
Katsuya > Tatsuya

>>386820596
What's that, severe gyno?

>>386811416
I want to give Tatsuya a hug

>>386821262
where's the gyno

File: 1500353085404.jpg (123KB, 960x718px) Image search: [Google]

123KB, 960x718px

Demi is best.

P1 MC is my favorite

File: ishyjddt.jpg (10KB, 231x254px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 231x254px

>motorcycle noises

>>386811416
Piercey

File: 1451258562198.jpg (128KB, 739x625px) Image search: [Google]

128KB, 739x625px

>>386821742
Femi is best

is P2 worth playing

Definitely not Mr. "I'm a whinny bitch that can't make the same sacrifice that all my friends made So I'll have a temper tantrum and punch Philimon in the face and put the world in danger again"

>>386815351
Ayy that looks like P3 and P5 protag with opposite color theme.

File: chad got picaro'd.jpg (51KB, 361x250px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 361x250px

>>386818982
Don't forget about stealing Yu's persona and Nanako's heart.
https://my.mixtape.moe/rmndzb.webm

>>386823905
The story is fantastic, the gameplay can range from eh to GOD YWHY

Recently played the PSP port of Innocent Sin. It's nice. Now playing the PSOne version of EP. Not that nice. I so wish the translation patch for PSP EP was done.

>>386821742

I cant defeat this fuck in DDS help

>>386824296
Fuck that sleep rng and just go on to dds 2. Or just be a man and keep going

File: Cxsrl80VIAAfcyf.png (359KB, 750x840px) Image search: [Google]

359KB, 750x840px

Persona 4 will always be my favourite, considering it was my first rpg that I cared to beat. Even after playing P2, both parts, theres something about 4 I love the most. So I'd go with Yu, even though Tatsuya is fine on his own. I don't understand why people have to argue

>>386811416
Yu because he didn't fuck up the world

>>386825715
I don't think any protagonists have actively ruined the world. Shit just happens to get fucked up around them.
Unless you're >implying that chaos endings are canon

>>386825528

it's /v/, people love to argue dumb shit all the time

File: 1500019623968.jpg (490KB, 1900x1200px) Image search: [Google]

490KB, 1900x1200px

>>386825528
persona 4 is easily one the most comfy games of all time IMO

>>386827653
Dead silent hill town, and overly happy teammate that felt artificial actually removed any sense of comfyness for me.

>>386827742
i can respect that
to each their own

>>386827960
No fuck off, P2 is better compared to P4 in everyway.

>>386828000
Except a big ass aspect of the game called the gameplay

>>386811416
Yu is just "muh wildcard" and quite the Mary Sue.
Tatsuya is an actual character, at least if you include EP.

>>386828000
i'd disagree in terms of gameplay but again, to each his own
i also haven't beaten persona 2 yet, but i'm trying

>>386828070
>>386828990
>caring about gameplay in literal VN game

>>386830338
P2 isn't a VN though. And you've gotta compare what they have in common.

>>386830426
>P2 isn't a VN
>80% of the game is a literal text dialogue
That's rich.

theyre both self inserts who gives a fuck

>>386830717
Fuck off P3fag.
GODDAMN FUCK WHY IS P3FAG THE MOST CANCER OFF ALL THE FUCKING FAGGOT?