>open world >10 main dungeons that are sprawling and sandboxy

>no quest log
>no quests

Why?

File: 1486657592158.jpg (61KB, 670x503px) Image search: [Google]

61KB, 670x503px

>>385319734
Your cringy post aside,
>tfw no decent Middle Earth RPG

>>385319734
Highly fucking doubt it with such arbitrarily specific requirements.

>>385319941
because i hate checklists.

You already have dozens of games

where's muh Wheel of Time games?

I just want an RPG like this:
>you aren't part of some prophecy
>you're just some regular dude
>start out super weak
>have to work hard and do many quests just to become as good as any adventurer
>thus your skill feels more like something you worked for and achieved rather than "congrats, you're a superhuman capable of insane feats with world shattering powers"
>that way when you kill the BBEG it's not "The prophesied hero did what everyone expected"
>but rather just some random veteran/farmer's son/orphan/hermit/whatever the fuck trained to become an adventurer and burned his name into the history books

Would be so much more satisfying tbqh.

>>385320275
>You already have dozens of games
honestly, they're all trash.

>>385320336
>>385319734
Kingdom Come: Deliverance is all of these. It's not out yet, but they've been on it for years and years.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=37EVHIw7o8A

>>385319734
the X series is fairly close to what you're looking for

except it's set in space

>>385320520
TL: It's stuck in development hell, and will likely not live up to expectations when released.

Please, no more raping Tolkien's work.

Thank God based Christopher does everything he can to stop you faggots.

File: middle-earth-shadow-of-war-listing-thumb-01-ps4-us-17feb17.jpg (322KB, 1600x900px) Image search: [Google]

322KB, 1600x900px

Leave Middle-Earth to me.

>>385320642
>Development hell
They released the PS4 cinematic trailer yesterday.

>>385320520
run like crap with huge drops
currently unplayable

unironically Minecraft

>>385320723
pls no it's shit

>>385320336
>start out super weak
That's what I want, your some weak skinny guy when yours skills are at level one you shouldn't be able to beat an Imperial guard with your bare hands and steal his equipment.
You should do things to raise your strength, climbing walls, chopping trees or wood, mining stuff like that would get you bigger and stronger, the more you use a weapon the better you get with it, but your sword type shouldn't determine the strength (iron does almost no damage dremora does a lot) a sword is a sword, it will slash and hurt someone, but maybe a higher grade would have more durability and be lighter and easier to use?
The progress you make should be personal, you get stronger, faster, smarter whatever it is not just wow I'm level one and found the best weapon and can kill everyone

>>385320681
that was just an example of how maps in medieval games should portrayed not that gps satellite imagery from The Witcher and Skyrim. i myself hate Tolkien knockoff which's the majority of rpg games ever released.

>>385320681
explain this and it's prequel then >>385320723

File: Mordor.webm (3MB, 960x540px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 960x540px

>>385321017
Lol get fucked.

>>385319734
>>open world

Better than linearity.

>>385320809
>open world +
>10 main dungeons that are sprawling and sandboxy with multiple paths and approaches (kinda like Thief levels) with bosses -
>2 or 3 optional dungeon that just as big as the main ones -
>few mini dungeons +
>one big city -
>3 towns -
>~10 villages +
>no quest markers +
>no quest log +
>no quests +
>no minimap (a simple compass that shows you cardinal directions is fine) +
>varied lands and terrain (forests, deserts, snowy, volcanos, oceans...etc) +
>varied enemies and just enough of them to cover the size of the world without feeling samey (like Dragon Quest) -
>hand-drawn paper world map that only shows the location of said city and towns similar to pic related -
>systematic rule-driven crafting and alchemy system like Morrowind's, none of the scripted shit from TW3 and it's ilk of ubisoft games -
>the capability to climb and scale walls using ropes (like Thief's rope arrows) -
>party-system that isn't mandatory (i can play solo or with party) -
>economy system with currency that matters for the duration of the game -
>cool mysteries and environmental storytelling discovered through natural exploration that doesn't spoonfeed itself forcefully down the player's throat -
>challenging, i wanna feel the epicness of the journey, not some easy shit that any casul and his sister can finish -
>1st-person view cuz i ain't no peasant +
-16 +9
INB4 mods
Literally any game can be anything with mods, that's a shit argument

>>385321148
only plotfags like linearity.

>>385321131
it's shit and your webm prove it

>>385321196
>Lol get fucked.

>>385320336
Gothic

File: Trebek.jpg (85KB, 395x395px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 395x395px

>>385319734
>>open world

this meme needs to fucking die already

>>385321172
No games is as customizable, moddable than Minecraft itself. Garry's mod is a close one, but Minecraft is something completely different in terms of modding- you can change everything and add everything. That's what makes it a great games.

File: 1483134970208.jpg (593KB, 2500x1500px) Image search: [Google]

593KB, 2500x1500px

A LONG TIME AGO, IN THE FAR AWAY LAND OF...

>>385321390
>implying linearity is superior

File: 1490143055734.png (319KB, 626x423px) Image search: [Google]

319KB, 626x423px

>>385321131
>lel XD KEK you can run around doing AWSUM stuff and being AWSUM

All you're proven is that the game is about an inch deep and a mile wide, and that it caters to the lowest common denominator, just like every other open world shovelware they keep churning out.

>>385320723
>>385319734
I could get into a LotR/Middle Earth game if they would just let you make a character

>>385320336
the problem is then that the game gets pilloried by "muh plot" fags and tvtropes types

>>385321531
b8, can't even quote cause the whole statement's just b8

>>385319734
>Modern RPG
>Mash button
>win
>have 100 shitty unorganized quest on your quest log after 10 minutes of gameplaye
>follow big arrow on screen
>literally cant remember any landmarks towns or anything because you're constantly staring at big arrow pointing you where to go
>get to quest location
>kindergarden level puzzle
>answer to the puzzle is basically spelled out to you on screen
>everything is incredibly easy
>character creation means nothing since the game will be easy as shit anyway
>no punishment for dying just quickload 5 seconds back or spawn at a checkpoint 5 seconds back
>no tension just boring shitty grinding

autism itt

>>385321986
> I can't argue against it so it's bait ;^)
Ok.

>>385320336
Gothic, son

>>385321131
Shadows of Mordor would probably be a 11/10 game if your character literally couldn't make a physical impact on the world.
If the entire game was about influencing interpersonal relationships between the AI, maybe add another faction or two and have some different endings it would be pretty damn GOAT.

Instead it's a cool idea that will never go anywhere because its wasted on BAMHAM MASH X TO AUSOME OPEN WURLD EPOC STURIES WHERE YOU KILL SAURON

>>385321712
Its extremely boring console button masher after a few hours

>>385321684
>>385322069
>Being this much of a faggot
wew

>>385319734
Mount and blade warband lotr mod.

>>385321531
>>385322216
Grammar:
>No games is as customizable
>games is
>is as customizable, moddable than Minecraft itself
>is (...) than
>Minecraft is something completely different in terms of modding-
>modding-
>That's what makes it a great games.
>a great games

One or two fuck ups is ok, but damn.

Your claim that minecraft is the most modifiable:
>www.minecraftmods.com has 392 mods total
>meanwhile skyrim on the nexus has 53, 501 mods

Lot's of games on nexus blow minecraft out of the water

Your claim that it is a good game:

Dwarf fortress is better.

Conclusion: u r fukign leaf arnt you

>>385323339
>you have to like boring easy games or ur gay :D

Sure thing fag

>>385323457
>lot's

>>385323790
It was more that you were saying retarded shit while losing grip of all grammar that gave you away. A truly good bait isn't that strong.

>>385323707
Who are you quoting?

>>385323950
>you
let's be honest you're an ESL bullying an ESL

File: 1500427398813.png (186KB, 370x430px) Image search: [Google]

186KB, 370x430px

>>385323457
> You have some grammar error so it means you're wrong
I'm a white flag, sorry about that.

You know there's more mods site than minecraftmods.com right? And that there is wayy more mods than 392 mods in minecraft, just lookin' at the forum already blows your theory out of the water. Not only that, but the mods of minecraft are much more game-changing than skyrim can ever hopes: that's what i was talking about. you can change the whole core of minecraft. Whereas in skyrim you can add, what.. Quest, Weapon, and change some element to be more of a survival game, whereas in minecraft, you can do anything, even in the base game with the help of the command block which gives you access to basically the source code of the game, you can do amazing and great thing. No other games allow you such depth of customization. Quality of mods in minecraft, their content are amazing. How many mods are Aether 2/1 tier of content in Skyrim? I don't know that much. Twilight forest tier of content? Industrialcraft game-changers? Turtlemod? Buildcraft? Spacecraft? Is there anything, that adds as much content and change the game as much as those mods in skyrim? I'll tell you, there's not much of them in skyrim, but they exist, with less depth.

I'm not a skyrim haters or anything, but minecraft modding is way more open and deep than skyrim. Also, it's easier for modders to mod in minecraft than using the GECK version of skyrim, the engine of which is very buggy and they have to employ so much workaround to simple thing.

>>385319734
The last days mod for mount and blade is a lot of fun

>>385324023
You

>>385324240
Not that anon but skyrim has sex mods and minercraft doesn't. Checkmate.

File: B44_1_0.BIN_1.png (30KB, 227x249px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 227x249px

>>385324429
This is a questionable claims.. wink wink.

>>385324935
>This is a questionable claims.. wink wink.
what did he mean by this

>>385321172
if someone makes a map then most of those -'s could be +'s with little argument or mods: town/dungeon stuff, world map, party system (aka not having a party system)
cool mysteries could be doable

truly out of the question without mods: varied enemies, rope arrows

>>385324265
But i didn't say any of that though. are you ok?

>>385325071
Are you gay?

>>385319734
Its so cool how the mountains on the western edge, ered luin, are the only remnant of the land that the entire first age took place in.
Theres so much material there involving the elves and morgoth that it makes me mad how developers make a medicore and non canon story. Fuck me we'll never get a game that takes place in Beleriand

>>385325570
Ok friend. Maybe dont get so upset on this image board.
Have a nice day!

>>385325770
what a fag

>>385320336

Gothic

>>385325770

kill yourself and go back to >>>/r/eddit with your shitty surface games

>>385326759
How about you two make out already? I mean thanks for bumping the thread but it can be done without you two flirting

>>385320336
gothic 1 is literally what you describe
>play as a no-name random criminal
>get thrown in prison colony where inmates dig up ore in the mines
>prison colony is under control of criminal ringleaders who trade ore for resources with the outside world
>start out as a weak scrub, get bullied and fucked up whenever you look at someone funny
>have to slowly earn respect, experience, skills and equipment to make your way up the foodchain

File: 1498076662-1485549015-trgssgsf.png (17KB, 136x102px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 136x102px

Skywind when

>>385320336
Gothic, mister

>>385321383
>>385322280
>>385326663
>>385327435
While Gothic is a pretty good example it violates one major point: you are part of some prophecy.

>>385320336
gothic just in case u didnt see all the other replies

>>385320336
The Age of Decadence