What games have the best hitboxes?

Post examples of real, bullshit hitboxes.

>>385038192
fpbp

File: 1487723776969.png (382KB, 1280x1248px) Image search: [Google]

382KB, 1280x1248px

>>385038060
Smash doesn't use hitboxes.

>>385038192
this

Why is smash in this comparison?

File: Monster_fb05a4_5505462.jpg (39KB, 600x337px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 600x337px

>>385038286

File: game decides these headshots don't count.webm (3MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1280x720px

Overwatch

>Skullgirls
>Not shit
Pick one and only one

>>385038060

War of the Roses has the best hitboxes in any fighting game period
it will never be surpassed

>tfw stabbing somebodies eye out


>>385038286

Dark Souls, all games.

>>385038365
It does, they're just not box shaped. They're spheres or cylinders with half-spheres on the end.

>>385038483
>>385038518
Post the images with the hitboxes, geniuses.

>>385038451
As the guy who made the original images that aren't Smash (shoutouts to Twitter and Facebook frauds for jacking my shit), it was made after the fact since the originals blew up and Smash wanted to be in on the joke since I didn't make pictures for their party game.

File: 1494713288638.png (193KB, 458x429px) Image search: [Google]

193KB, 458x429px

>>385038060
>Counterstrike Global Offensive

File: 1494221142981.png (44KB, 864x576px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 864x576px

>>385038651
>Smash doesn't use hitboxes.
>No it has hitboxes, they just aren't boxes.
This is autism.

>>385038485
You didn't hit him

>>385038192
I'm not sure how someone can say that when RPG exists

>>385038687
The hitbox on the plesioth picture is out of frame

>>385038485
I love how you can practically hear him going "what the fuck, game" as he backs up

>>385038286
Tons of MUGEN characters, especially old DBZ ones.

Yoshi's Grab in Melee because it's a 3d space and goes slightly to the left.


>>385038719
>tfw Valve is still ajusting hitboxes.

>>385038286
Dark Souls 2

File: 20246133_835020623320256_2739235484105459469_n.jpg (46KB, 440x960px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 440x960px

>>385038060

>>385038192
Injustice made me appreciate them. If only because I finally learned a characters bread and butter and started cleaning up people like you.

File: 1439800345186.png (19KB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 200x200px

>>385038758
>black hole
>isn't actually a hole
>uncanny valley
>isn't actually a valley
(You)

>>385038758
rectangle hitboxes aren't boxes. They don't contain anything.

File: Untitled-2.jpg (446KB, 890x960px) Image search: [Google]

446KB, 890x960px

>>385038765

hmmm

>>385038758
They behave like hit boxes (checking if they clip with another box). That sounds like a hit box to me.

>>385038719
i remember seeing a vid about them. they have those cylinder hitboxes that match up exactly with the model.

>>385038192
>>385038330
>>385038371
People only think this when they're too stupid to understand them.

File: #raugh3.jpg (50KB, 293x331px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 293x331px

>>385039085
>tehy got winston

>>385038365
are you fucking brain damaged?

File: DFTDyrDUIAEkMhn.jpg (23KB, 540x370px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 540x370px

>>385038060
life

http://wiki.shoryuken.com/Dee_Jay_%28ST%29

>ok so the shotos had some really dumb hitboxes in the first couple iterations of this game let's make the hurtboxes bigger so you can at least trade with their shit especially the jumping ones
>LOL DJ THO

File: 1500599964326.png (123KB, 500x663px) Image search: [Google]

123KB, 500x663px

Siege

File: 1445805386532.png (5KB, 453x439px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 453x439px

>>385038687

>>385039142
The correct term is 'hit polyhedra'.

>>385038758
>a bunch of pixels on a screen
>it's a box
t. room-temperature IQ

>>385039449
Jokes on you, he's measuring the room temperature in Kelvin.

File: 1451698580784-3.png (273KB, 600x583px) Image search: [Google]

273KB, 600x583px

>>385039057
I was gunna make that post using that very same image.
Mine's 700x700 fucker and I haven't had the chance to post it in years

>>385039562
just post it anyway you nigfuck

>>385038516
this the hit boxes are actually next level crazy.

>>385039518
so then he's the one with autism
checkmate

File: 1492048517796.jpg (7KB, 167x144px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 167x144px

>>385039057
>>385039069
>>385039142
>>385039350
>>385039449
This is why you're on /v/.

You can't communicate with someone in an efficient way without being a troll.

File: s-lk-1.png (11KB, 579x468px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 579x468px

>>385038286

>>385039562
Doubling down on a reaction images always leads to some good meme's, nigfuck

>>385039085
>what is network lag

>>385039627
>hurr durr ur'e a troll
incredible, are you a communications major by any chance?

>>385039650
wtf, that has to be a mistake right?

>>385039650
waht

>>385039627
Thank you for reddit spacing and posting a reaction image, we couldn't have understood you otherwise.

>>385038963
>>385039390
You have the 'watch the hip check' jump out the window one?

>>385039650
explain this garbage

File: mbh.jpg (141KB, 1184x1200px) Image search: [Google]

141KB, 1184x1200px

>>385038060

>>385038060

Funny thing is, I read this as "shitboxes".

>>385039868
People were double spacing on 4chan before you were born you underage cunt.

>>385039627
Woah he must have a lot of (You)s

>>385039085
That has more to do with Blizzard's shitty low tick servers more than it has to do with hitboxes in that video. If youre going to shitpost about a game, at least shitpost about the right things.

>>385039953
i'd like to see some skullgirls shitboxes if ya know what im sayinnnn

File: Daimon98_stB.png (6KB, 122x129px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 122x129px

Out of the way, shitlords.

>>385039650
Sagat has a sharp penis confirmed.

>>385038060
Tekken

File: Snake_Up_Tilt_Disjointed_Hitbox_Brawl.png (111KB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

111KB, 640x360px

>>385038286

File: 1450392335584.gif (371KB, 320x230px) Image search: [Google]

371KB, 320x230px

big butt coming through

>>385039986
sure thing reddit

>>385040315
BRRRAAAAAAAPPPPPP

File: 0b6RVr1.jpg (126KB, 800x470px) Image search: [Google]

126KB, 800x470px

KoF hitboxes more like

>>385040105
>>385040223
I don't into fighting games. I just came for the inevitable Plesioth jokes. What's the light blue box?

>>385039650
this one legitimately makes me mad, what the fuck

>>385039196
Yeah dude everyone in the fgc is just so intelligent

Design characters around hitboxes, not hitboxes around characters.

Having hitboxes perfectly adhere to characters that were designed first results in bad balancing and shitty attacks.
However, having a character's hitboxes barely adhere to their design is also a shitty system because attacks become hard to follow for anyone not intimate with the hitbox of certain attacks.

File: super turbo is a very good game.jpg (124KB, 854x481px) Image search: [Google]

124KB, 854x481px

*x-files theme*

>>385040393
it's a mystery box

>>385038192
this

File: t hawk.png (27KB, 384x224px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 384x224px

nevar 4get

>>385039650
what the fuck is green

>>385040374
Go look up some screencaps if you want. Ones from 2005 should work, only a couple years before you were born.

>>385038192
>visual novels, telltale "games", literal walking simulators, bullshit like gone home, heavy rain and until dawn all exist

i understand you dont like fighting games but try to be less retarded in the future

>>385038192
>what are ASSFAGGOTS
>what are turn based RPGs

>>385040393
Likely a static ever-present hurtbox that exists throughout the entire animation.

>>385039793
Wrong, it's been confirmed that Overwatch headshot hitboxes are far bigger than the actual heads, it's even worse on consoles.

>>385040576
Collision box probably.

>>385040587
>4chan
>2005
wew

>>385040393
Where the character is actually idle outside of the animation playing

File: 30_drdoomhitbox.jpg (88KB, 480x640px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 480x640px

lmao

can people post example of skullgirls hitboxes?

>>385040393
"light blue is the character position box. It determines where the character is located, whether the moves can cross up or pass through (for teleport moves) etc."

File: Iori98_fA.png (6KB, 114x98px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 114x98px

>>385040393
The light blue is the push box. It's the actual physical block that stops two characters from walking through each other. In this case
>>385040223

the push box is fucked and Ralf can actually teleport through you to do far C and will switch sides after the recovery of the move.

File: tumblr_inline_oomzcypY4s1speybs_540.png (129KB, 405x312px) Image search: [Google]

129KB, 405x312px

>>385040706

>>385040737
arfenhouse

File: 1427617145017.jpg (13KB, 395x395px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 395x395px

>yfw everyone in the "fighting games are too hard" thread just migrated over here

>>385039650
FGCucks be like:

>DUUUUH OF COOOURSE SAGAT'S HITBOX IS LIKE THIS, IT'S COMMON KNOWLEDGE AND AN INTENTIONAL BALANCE THING, GIT GUD KID

>>385040393
it's where the character actually is, if that makes sense
the sprite for both of those attacks moves forward a bit but in game terms they're standing still

>>385040354
Hnnng that circle jiggle.

File: 18hgijykap8gmjpg.jpg (40KB, 340x268px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 340x268px

>>385040383

File: 1439951262252.jpg (98KB, 491x508px) Image search: [Google]

98KB, 491x508px

>>385040701
Why did you have to remind me of this bullshit.

File: file.png (52KB, 497x518px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 497x518px

at least it's not Zero's j.h

>>385038963
Nice facebook filename.

File: GWxV08u.png (71KB, 710x510px) Image search: [Google]

71KB, 710x510px

>>385040813

>>385038758
>it's not literally a box so it's not a hitbox
No anon, that's autism

File: VeryHard.jpg (36KB, 470x492px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 470x492px

>>385038926
>Yoshi's grab
>Not Marth's

>>385040845
The colors are probably reversed for the Alpha 2 hitbox viewer. The Guilty Gear classic hitbox viewer does the same shit, red is hurtbox blue is hitbox.

>>385040978
It's just a different way of answering the question. Yoshi's grab is bullshit if you're Yoshi.

>>385040964
That's actually impressive.

>>385040964
Is this a bit wasteful or good? Like it seems like her middle is gonna be rarely if ever hit.

>>385039845
>>385039862
Back of the knee maybe

File: 1487264662990.png (10KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 800x600px

>>385040105
This shit was so fucking stupid it's not even funny WHAT WERE THEY THINKING

File: serveimage.jpg (486KB, 1500x800px) Image search: [Google]

486KB, 1500x800px

Quake 3.

>>385040701
YOU HAVE NO HOPE!

File: 07-j236b.jpg (23KB, 315x318px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 315x318px

Melty Blood hitboxes without context are fun

>>385041158
Very wasteful. You could get almost identical results with far less hitboxes. If you look at the hitboxes for newer characters, they toned that shit way back because they were wasting a lot of time trying to be sprite accurate to thousands of frames of animation per character.

File: question mark.png (163KB, 356x356px) Image search: [Google]

163KB, 356x356px

>>385040683
what are you implying

File: UFI4nDW.png (889KB, 1458x545px) Image search: [Google]

889KB, 1458x545px

Reflex

>>385041353
>hitbox everywhere but the knife

>>385041353
>everything but the knife
maybe they should stop squinting their eyes while programing

>>385039650
Well, irl you have to be a little close to make an effective thai low-kick. You try to hit with the leg more than the ankle.
Leg extension isn't really what the kick is about.
This weird hitbox could be a developer's stratagem to make Sagat's kick feel more real..

>>385041158
It's both good and wasteful. The final product is excellent but it also takes far too much effort to actually be worth it in the end.

>>385041484
>>385041493

Haven't played MB but I bet that's the frame after the knife was being swung.

>>385041353
Is there some kind of slashing effect that is a separate sprite and not included in that render?

>>385038192
Tekken 5 was one of the best PS2 games.

>>385041428
You're never going to get a response to this, you know

File: IMG_puxdz2.jpg (9KB, 121x159px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 121x159px

>>385041304
>they nerfed far B in XIV
>but let him chain into df.C
>also all of his other buttons are still godlike
XIV is so amazing. It's the best Daimon has been since 98.

>>385041482
> Capsule

reee. reeeeeee activision

>>385038060
I mean I don't play fighting games but Skullgirls seems the most realistic according to this

File: 1468117112506.jpg (31KB, 355x279px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 355x279px

>>385041676

>>385038192
first post best fucking post

>>385040614
>visual novel
>bad genre
So how many have you played/"read", anon?
Also, I don't know about telltale nowadays but Sam & Max and SBCG4AP were pretty good.

File: fighting game.png (428KB, 523x386px) Image search: [Google]

428KB, 523x386px

>>385038286


>>385038365
What is this then? get btfo scrublerd

>>385039986
>>385039868

I don't get this meme, I stop paying attention for a week and everyone is losing their minds about spacing and trees with faces

File: shb.png (8KB, 424x382px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 424x382px

>>385041353

>>385039650
Thai fighters kick with the shin, not the instep tards...

File: tiger tiger tiger tiger tiger tiger tiger.png (10KB, 588x452px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 588x452px

>>385039650
i'm not going to fire up the ol emulator for this but i'm just going to assume that's a cancelable frame of s.lk, because i guess they didn't want sagat terrorizing people with s.lk tiger shot again

File: CsgH5kCWAAA7K00.jpg (31KB, 1010x720px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 1010x720px

>>385041353

>>385042070
______________________________________________________________________________________NO ROUTE

>>385041612
Yes

>>385038060
i'm probably retarded but the red box means you'll get hit if you're in it right

>>385042051
The tree meme is a new forced unfunny meme. The reddit spacing thing is a way to discredit your opponent for having readable posts.

>>385042162
post the wolf of many clashes and jump stuffing

>>385042235
If the blue box of your character touches the red box of their character, you get hit.

>>385042162
Is he the least fun character to play against in the whole game that isn't an SNK boss?

File: serveimage.jpg (17KB, 390x242px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 390x242px

>>385041312
More interesting example from the same engine. Enemy Territory's prone hitbox.

>>385042235
If red box touch blue box, owner of blue box get hurt.

The more complex shapes you have for hitboxes the more data there is to lose when the client and server are communicating.

More complex shapes will provide better hitbox accuracy but at the expense of performance and data transfer.

>>385042070
>>385042162
I think I understand Uniel and it's full screen normals little better now. It's just following Melty's footsteps, but they decided to make the normals as fuckhuge as the hitboxes.

>>385038758
(You)

>>385042309
>>385042320
thank you friends

>>385042323
Fighting games shouldn't be transferring hitbox data online in the first place, the only thing you need to send is input data.

>>385042051
>thinks reddit spacing is new
hellooooooooooooo, reddit!

File: 53913260851a77446cf833e6e80ec061.png (241KB, 1000x725px) Image search: [Google]

241KB, 1000x725px

>>385038365
Dont use Kotobuki to say dumb shit.

>>385042235
Yes
>blue : the character's hitbox
>Red : The attack's hitbox
>green/light bue/whatever else : the physical barrier representing the character that you can't traverse

>>385038060
Street fighter is the only one in that image with whiff punishing to street fighter.

>>385041353
>>385042070
post sions whip

that shit makes me 10/10 mad every fucking time

File: jigglypuff bair.gif (80KB, 320x230px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 320x230px

>>385038286

>>385042423
man, if only there were shapes other than rectangles

>>385040119
jesus christ that is so garbage
i wish nintendo would get its head out of its ass and just release a balance patch for melee

File: serveimage.jpg (14KB, 285x203px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 285x203px

>>385042316
The "primary" hitbox in Quake 3 doesn't support rotating. Many realism mods got around this by shrinking it down, then putting supplemental boxes else where. The ET devs didn't do this.

File: 214a2.png (3KB, 417x239px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 417x239px

>>385042596

>>385039370
>Play as Blitz
>Get shot in the headphones
>Die
They actually fixed some of the really bad ones, but the game is fucking weird still.

>>385042438
The Smash Bros games all work like that. Depends on whether or not you consider them fighting games though

File: bananaya.png (6KB, 392x309px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 392x309px

>>385041353

>>385042732
SHIKI NO

>>385042703
Smash Bros online is also particularly trash. Some of the worst online in a competitive game of that nature. They could drastically cut overhead but not doing that, and if they could implement rollback netcode it would get even better, although I don't think they'd be capable of implementing savestates into Smash.

>>385038060
Skullgirls is the only correct answer and even it is lacking. Hotboxes should be pixel perfect. Anything else is worthless.

File: sniper what.gif (564KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

564KB, 250x250px

>>385042672
jesus christ
who approved this

>>385042463

I don't keep up with /pol/ memes, sorry

Only noticed "Reddit spacing" being a thing in the past week or so despite breaking my quote and post since 2006

File: image.jpg (138KB, 975x904px) Image search: [Google]

138KB, 975x904px

>>385039370
>mfw Siege will never be the game it could be from numerous technical issues

>>385041729
there's nothing wrong with capsules

File: hitbox.jpg (5KB, 301x168px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 301x168px

Let's see... Tekken's hitboxes.

>>385038060
>smashbros logo that is on the top of the image rather than bottom
Unacceptable. Fucking ruined the image.

>>385042852
You're a fucking idiot and you have no idea what you're talking about.

What are hitboxes? and what do the colors represent?

>>385042863
its not that bad if you actually play melty because you can block in the air

File: 1446328224874.gif (1001KB, 440x300px) Image search: [Google]

1001KB, 440x300px

>>385038485
>>tehy got winston

File: Hipcheck range.png (1MB, 1366x2196px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1366x2196px

>>385039870
Probably somewhere, but my MH folder is poorly sorted

File: bananaya.png (85KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 512x512px

>>385042732

>>385039196
>You need to be intelligent to enjoy fighting games

kek

>>385042863
Everyone in UNIEL has huge moves so it's ok.

Someone post new whip girl's sweep

>>385042863
She also got gun

>>385040437
>>385043028
You belong in a different thread. Maybe even a different website.

File: khb.png (6KB, 294x250px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 294x250px

>>385042164
isn't it sad ;-;

>>385042463
Having fits about reddit spacing is definitely the hottest new meme of this summer.

File: banshee.jpg (123KB, 353x468px) Image search: [Google]

123KB, 353x468px

>hitbox flies like 10 feet outside of model

File: hurtboxes.webm (2MB, 608x448px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 608x448px

>>385040389

>>385043110
tfw i play both kouma and satsuki

>>385038483
>10 years of MH
>still haven't fixed this
it is so funny when diehard fags tried to argue that Plesioth was "fixed" it is still fucking awful
https://youtu.be/ALggznS9kRk?t=6m49s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bz7E6b_2UwA

it is time to downgrade Plesioth to minigame status like in 4U and just do more work on Lava and Cepha instead

>>385043134
Man 02 is a shit game.

File: 1493624027640.jpg (73KB, 800x318px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 800x318px

>>385038060
Smash has better hitboxes than fighting games.

File: MonChanWillNeverBeReal.jpg (163KB, 631x1930px) Image search: [Google]

163KB, 631x1930px

>>385042989
I fucking love monster hunter threads

Why do people play these pieces of shit competitively

>>385042678
>ash uses kabbalistic magic to transport her hitbox to a realm beyond space and time

>>385042920
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=trVFQGZ95eE

>>385038060
csgo's are unironically pretty good now

>>385043113
"reddit spacing" is not a new meme whatsoever. That being said, it's fucking stupid and only people trying very hard to fit in use it

>>385043291
>those hitboxes going into the third dimension

my diiiiick

>>385043204
>letting the animator decide game balance rather than well crafted designed hitboxes is better
Smashbabs please.

File: thats a nice df 1 you have there faggot.png (378KB, 522x422px) Image search: [Google]

378KB, 522x422px

>>385042920
:)))))))))))))))

File: pushu.png (5KB, 472x200px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 472x200px

>>385043178
keep the grabs away! donkey desu

>>385042463
this spacing shit began after they filtered all console war terms to "-bro"

>>385038286
Dark Souls II in general

File: Hipcheck Haiku.jpg (198KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

198KB, 1280x720px

>>385043221
One day we'll be back to comfy monhun threads.
One day.

>>385042963
I'm sorry for your mental retardation.

>>385043530
*Soul games in general

Skullgirls, easily.

Anyone who says otherwise is delusional.

File: 1498329000322.jpg (85KB, 640x640px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 640x640px

>>385043179
>Frontier Plesioth's lie about the hipcheck being fine
This was such a piss-off when I was blatantly lied to when trying Frontier TW out. The hitbox was still really fucking bad on the tail spin and hip check and never changed. The only difference with the higher variations is that it would do them much less

>>385038286
Counter Strike

>>385038516
Hi, retard.

File: Plessy Hipcheck 1.png (3MB, 925x3000px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 925x3000px

>>385043691
Oh god fuck the tail spin so hard.
Arguably worse than the hipcheck.

File: Victor_cmd_throw.png (13KB, 180x130px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 180x130px

Why is this allowed?

>>385042108
>>385041526
the red is over the wrong leg, dummies.

File: 1453158412136.png (547KB, 374x667px) Image search: [Google]

547KB, 374x667px

>>385042920
>>385043291
>It's "low crush whiffing on snake edge" episode

>>385040658
That has been fixed for awhile.

>>385043221
Oh god, these are great!

>>385038518
Dark Souls actually has great hitboxes, the problem lies in the shitty netcode.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6qa7aptE1Q

>>385043910
#grapplerlivesdon'tmatter

>>385043596
Wow bro you sure got me with that "no u". Really witty retort.

>>385043978
and then they changed it back

because casuals

>>385043113
the meme is almost years (plural) old, faggot

>>385044075
They only changed the projectile sizes back because Mei's icicles were going straight through people's heads half the time. Same thing with Hanzo but far less often

>>385044034
what gam

File: 1383429905482.jpg (955KB, 5000x5000px) Image search: [Google]

955KB, 5000x5000px

>>385041874

File: 1500809637005.jpg (69KB, 768x768px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 768x768px

>>385042678
>play as fuze
>set charge
>grenades home in on me and team
>kicked for team killing
Ive also seen this effect on other explosives like the c4 although it was less of an attraction and more like it hadnt been planted yet and instead of blowing midair it transported back to last place it was and killed me.

>>385041874
I'm at a loss for words, Smash is so shit.

>>385041781
It is, but each character cost them like 150k to make.

>>385043179
This looks minnumblingly boring. I don't see the appeal, att all. I don't know if it's the slow attacks or the fact that the dragon thing don't seem to be able to hit for SHIT whil the guy is standing still but I don't understand how anyone would want to play this more than 5 minutes.

Doesn't MK (and I guess other NRS games) have hit"boxes" that are literally the model itself?

Why isn't that the norm?

>>385041526
This guy is on the money.

>>385039370
Been wanting to try it out, but I kind of hate FPS even though I'm mechanically good at them and I don't want to deal with that horrible low tick rate. I've seen enough bullshit in videos and clips where what the enemy sees is almost 2s behind what you're actually doing.

File: unreal black things.png (6KB, 318x320px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 318x320px

>>385042162

File: nerbuous.gif (2MB, 300x332px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 300x332px

>>385042316
>>385042664
and they got away with this?

>>385044203

>earliest results for "Reddit spacing" are from less than a year ago on /pol/

hmmm

>>385038060
KOF seems like the best one desu

Too bad only mexicans and koreans play it

>>385044310
>the suffering of a grappler.webm

>>385042162
>>385042310
easily

anyone the "mains" him is 100% a no fun allowed faggot

>>385044504
Go back to /pol/

>>385044492
How are warakia hitboxes?.

>>385044353
that is just a generic smash image with red boxes on it, smash is shit for a lot of reasons but misleading hitboxes generally isnt one.

>>385044310
>no homo

>>385044384
Which is cheap in terms of game development. Developers don't do what Skullgirls does not because it's expensive, they don't do it because it's stupid and there's no point and often trying to match the animations exactly to the pixel will make your game feel shitty and inconsistent, which is a big no no in fighting games. Not even Skullgirls does that shit anymore, none of the new characters are that ridiculous and there are tons of instances like when your character is in hitstun that they drop the bullshit entirely and go with very simple standardized hurtboxes so that shit works reliably.

>>385039993
Actually, the game suffers from both low tickrates and permissive hitboxes. Just look up for OW hitboxes on google and you'll have plenty of examples.

So can we all agree that Skull Gilrs have the best Hitboxes from eny Fighting Game?

and the best girls too, post them

Does anyone have any links of the MvCI reused animations/attacks video with gamora?

>>385044467
Because things like opponents idle animation should not factor in do you hit them or not.

>>385044783
t. retard

>>385039152
Yes but they don't register the hits.

File: Hold on I got a text message.webm (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

>>385044289
>Fuze drops a charge from the second story
>It bounces back up and kills him
Probably the most funny thing that can happen in the game.

>>385044646
superior

limb

based

combat

>>385041158
The real question is why they still keep using boxes when in 2017 you can intersect way more complex polygons. You can even do per pixel collisions if you want with no performance drop.
The snes cpu was 21 Mhz, you don't need to keep following those rules.

>>385043623
Not really

>>385040701
FOOT DIVE

>>385038060
>bottom two
>The Virgin kick
>The Chad Boot

>>385044589
>mad because he got fucked up by a deer
a fucking deer lmao

File: 1474305618177.webm (1MB, 900x506px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 900x506px

>>385038060
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - Game Of The Year by CD Projekt RED

File: hitboxes.png (419KB, 512x440px) Image search: [Google]

419KB, 512x440px

>>385038060

File: christmas came in july.jpg (3MB, 2990x2073px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2990x2073px

Dark Souls has the best hitboxes of any fighting game, and it's not limited to 2D fossil art.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6qa7aptE1Q

>>385040223
>Hit someone so hard you leave your physical body two feet behind you

damn son

File: x.jpg (762KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

762KB, 1920x1080px

is skullgirls fun or is it just cartoon waifubait. i'm shit at fighting games but the character art style looks cool to me. can i enjoy it or is everyone still playing at this point a pro who will crush me every match.

File: A Wild Stag Appears.jpg (10KB, 160x160px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 160x160px

>>385044589

>>385044870
Says the actual retard who doesn't play fighting games above a mashing level and hasn't seen exactly that type of shit happen in plenty of games, even SF4 where hitreel animations will fuck your combos up because hitboxes are tied to animations.

>>385044951
They actually tested that with street fighter. The thing is the mechanics of the games are too different with form fitting boxes and no one liked it.

>>385038485
Wasnt this fixed like half a year ago? I remember headshotting but not killing anything, tried playing again but didnt have the same issues, perhaps better client:server hit detection or something?

>>385045014
>mad
not really
I wont refuse matches because someone is playing him or anything
its just exhausting and not fun

>>385044783
How often does something like that realistically happen though? I don't think I have ever seen that happen in MK nor Injustice (1 or 2).

Then again, NRS games tend to have very static idles, so maybe it wouldn't work for games with very animated characters, like Eddy from Tekken.

>>385045030
> PS4 controls

Wah, it's shitty and bugged on consoles, what a surprise, thanks Brian.

>>385045187
You're supposed to jump over the shockwave, retard.

File: hipcheck.jpg (146KB, 680x720px) Image search: [Google]

146KB, 680x720px

>>385039870
I know I'm late but here

File: IMG_4603.gif (285KB, 453x436px) Image search: [Google]

285KB, 453x436px

Trigger warning

>>385040461
>>385040574
>hurtbox two feet above his head
>hurtbox on the floor behind him

What the actual fuck is wrong with T.Hawk?

>>385044467
The did it for MK9, but went back to hitboxes for MKX and Injustice.

It's one of those ideas that sounds good on paper. But when implemented, it just doesn't work for a 2D fighter. It makes things inconsistent, especially trades.

File: Hipcheck.jpg (244KB, 960x1016px) Image search: [Google]

244KB, 960x1016px

>>385039870
Gotchu fampai

File: RL hitbox.webm (2MB, 1152x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1152x720px

>ctrl+f
>no Rocket League
pathetic

File: 180px-MarthAndYoshiGrabRange.gif (515KB, 180x106px) Image search: [Google]

515KB, 180x106px

Posting the classic

>>385040701
and people say this was a good and balanced game. If you didn't have Doom on your team you were literally handicapping yourself for no reason. Hopefully MvCI fixes this shit and makes everyone viable.

File: whb.png (12KB, 449x350px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 449x350px

>>385044629
they're alright

>>385044913
My fucking sides, this can't be real

>>385038192
>all these le "fpbp" upboats

Reddit migrators confirmed for shitters at fighting games, no surprises here.

>>385045151
Huh. The more you know.

>>385038060
OG monster hunter... :^)

>>385045223
Weird drops due to inconsistent hit frames happen kinda frequently in MKX and IJ2, it was worse in older games like MK9 but they've improved the system a bit. It's not just the idle animation that can fuck you over, it's every animation, like the animation of being juggled in the air or the reaction the enemy makes to being hit. 2D hitboxes have stuck around for a reason, developers have absolutely experimented with more realistic and model tied hitboxes and basically every time it's a way worse game than 2D hitboxes. Even Tekken, which does model based hitboxes, fudges the fuck out of the size of things so that things work how they're supposed to, but even then you still get goofy shit like side wall combo stuff.

>>385045304
I just love how the smaller hitbox is still bigger than the hurtbox.

>>385045045
>i'm shit at fighting games
No it's not fun.
Sure you can get some enjoyment out of playing it single player, or with local friends, and it has pretty good tutorial to help you be little less shit at fighting games, but it's not my preferred fighting game.

>>385044913
Thats siege baby!

>>385041353
>nothing personnel kid

>>385045487
That is not too bad.

Are there drawbacks for using so many squares for hitboxes?

>>385038798
Easy, RPG have immersion, fighting is mindlessly pushing buttons

>>385044501
It was a free game, so people put up with it. It definitely was a huge newbie trap. You'd rage for hours wondering why that prone fuck didn't die even though you sprayed at his head from point blank.

I always wanted to get decent at fighting games but no idea what I want to play, which anime fighting game should i play?

File: dunk.png (332KB, 634x443px) Image search: [Google]

332KB, 634x443px

>>385043110
i fucking love melty

kinda wanna get UNIB next time its on sale

>>385045661
more data to process. It's allright if you aren't playing on a toaster but for online play it can be a real issue.

>>385038518
>War of the Roses
Game is so unappreciated. At the time had great graphics and the gameplay was solid af. I fucking miss it.

>>385042672
Just jump at her bro

>>385045661
From a hardware/performance perspective? No.
From a design perspective, maybe, there's only personal preference.

>>385045661
Basically waste of time and thus money.
Just initially making them is wasteful and just imagine if developer decides to adjust the hitboxes as a balance thing. Have fun fiddling with hundred tiny boxes for tens of frames instead of just few.

File: Eltnum Grab.webm (3MB, 1144x712px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1144x712px

>>385045748
melty's the fucking best

>>385038192
>>385045556
fpbp

>>385042854
>Hitbox extends twelve miles into the air
>Protects him/clashes with lows as well

I don't play BB but literally how the fuck do you beat this if you don't have some kind of fireball? Just block and punish?

File: BbQkkwo.png (917KB, 1030x1500px) Image search: [Google]

917KB, 1030x1500px

csgo's arent bad now they were replaced a long time ago

File: Counterstrike hitbox and camera position.jpg (53KB, 282x311px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 282x311px

>>385038719
>Counterstrike hitboxes
Besides Valve still having garbage netcode (no the 120 tick bullshit meme doesn't do anything), an equally shitty issue is with the fucking camera. The thing drops to your balls when you crouch so you can't see or shoot shit even if your whole upper body is visible over the cover you think you're behind.

>>385043995
It's funny how soulsborne hitboxes get shit on only for the the multiplayer and other rare occurrences when a majority of the time the hitboxes are actually amazing.

>>385045993
>Melty is the worst, it's training wheels for small dick weeb losers that can't play a fighting game

Fixed.

>>385043134
So good to see this fag get wrecked by Daimon at Evo.

>>385045430
was just about to post this thanks anon.

>>385045748
>kinda wanna get UNIB next time its on sale
Why wouldn't you wait for [st] to come out of pc? You have waited this long, so might as well go all the way.

>>385038192
FPBP

File: vergil standing H.jpg (125KB, 480x680px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 480x680px

Now I'm motivated

>>385038286
Hanzo when the game first launched

>>385045167
no
tickrate was "addressed" but they did some backend fuckery in the recent anniversary update and ruined everything again, to the point that entire characters are unplayable and require broad sweeping bandaid buffs just to compensate for it

>>385045724
dont
or puyo puyo tetris

>>385043910
>you have to be touching dicks to get your command throw to work

Grapplers: Not even once.

>>385046401
That explains why I can't play as rein anymore, fuck

>>385045042
What's going on in this cap?

>>385038060
Bloodborne. DS3 impressed me a few times with hitboxes too.

File: IMG_20170724_145823.jpg (295KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

295KB, 1920x1080px

>>385046409
Or you could play a grappler in a game that doesn't treat grapplers like second class citizens.

>>385042678
They fixed getting shot in the clothes counting as damage but the game STILL needs net code improvements almost 2 years later

>>385046581
this game still blows my mind every time at how ugly it is.

File: 1425319939624.png (41KB, 768x850px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 768x850px

>>385038483

>>385046581
>Daimon idle animation.jpg

>>385045045
I don't think everyone still playing is a pro, but if you do random ranked, you will run into a pro every now and then.

You can tell who they are because they'll be able to sweep you in seemingly infinite inescapable combos. It's that kind of game.

>>385046581
>A Daimon main won Evo
I love KoF's grapplers so goddamn much.

>>385046220
It's ok smasher. Someday, someone will pretend you don't smell for a couple minutes. You don't need to be so angry.

File: IMG_20170724_150149.jpg (211KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

211KB, 1920x1080px

>>385046792
HCB,F is 1 frame so you get tossed before you ever see him move.

File: just block the overhead my dude.png (13KB, 577x575px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 577x575px

>>385046110
It's -122 on block, and it costs 100 meter to do so he can't cancel out of it. All you have to do is block, but he can confirm into it from pretty much any attack, so it's pretty dangerous to get hit when you're in Astral range.