He did nothing wrong

>>383988398
Oh boy here we go again.

>>383988398
He didn't even get with the girl that's the sad part
>TFW Ellie will never pass on the immunity to the spores because of muh lesbianism

I unironically think TLoU is one of the best games of all time.

He made a very human and unsurprising decision.

>>383988540

Same here, senapi

>>383988398
Whether or not it was "right" or "wrong" is really irrelevant. It was relatable, and that's what's important.

He did not pass the marshmallow test.

>>383988690
Sounds stupid.
How does that even apply to his situation?

>>383988630
I have nothing else to add.

/Thread I guess.

Just a reminder that the entire point of bringing Ellie to the fireflies was to get a bunch of guns and they didn't even give them to him

He did wrong things, but for the right reasons.

Yes he did

>>383988398
only a literal autist would disagree.

>>383989041
Don't know about you but I got my fill of guns and ammo from the Fireflies in the hospital.

>>383988398
He doomed everyone because muh feefees

>>383989413

The Fireflies had no clue what they were doing

saving his "daughter" was more human

>>383988398
He didnt even have to do ot in the first place. Taking Ellie there was already a suicide mission, excuse him of he decides to not let his new bond go to waste to some dissection that might not even work

>>383989413
Everyone was already doomed.
Even in best case scenarios the vaccine would have pretty marginal effect because the main thread is billions of fungus zombies tearing people apart.

File: 1494640926492.jpg (243KB, 746x1080px) Image search: [Google]

243KB, 746x1080px

the recordings kept saying how incompetent firefly doctors were and their head doctor was disgusted by the incompetence

>>383989413
Anon if you commit suicide the world might become a better place.

>>383989453
>muh daughter died
>better kill everyone inadvertently because of it

>>383989614
>>383989565

>>383988398
the only thing he did wrong was not asking Ellie's opinion about the thing

and even that is debatable, since she would've gone into it out of survival guilt

>>383989614

What were the Fireflies going to do about it?

>>383988398
>killed a defenseless black woman

Is Neil Druckmann racist?

>>383989752
Synthesize a cure from Immuno Juno

>>383989775
>defenseless

She had a fucking gun on him. Come to think of it it was pretty skillful of Joel to reach in and grab his gun and shoot her all while holding Ellie

>>383989901
Yea he shot her once in the stomach and she was on the ground and defenseless.

Then he shot her again in the face. RACIST

>>383988398
>Wipe out a good chunk of the remaining post-apocalyptic humans
>All to save a dyke who won't even breed her genetic immunity to the next generation

kek

>>383989839

But they had no clue what they were doing

>>383989964
Are you saying it would be more noble to leave her to die slowly of a painful gut shot?

>>383989967
>genetic immunity
Immunity is overrated and anyone who thinks that Elie fucking bunch of people and popping out children like some welfare queen would have any effect at all is deluded as fuck.

>>383990020
She was in a hospital :^)

>>383990016
>had fully armed military men during the apocalypse
>scientists and doctors too
Hmm an emotional hick with a flannel shirt knew better

>>383990103
I'm pretty sure Joel killed every single human there so it doesn't really matter.

>>383990164

Listen to the journals, you mong

File: Brad.png (2KB, 100x155px) Image search: [Google]

2KB, 100x155px

>>383989565
There were more than enough people around to restart humanity.

Pic here, he was completely justified in wiping out everyone in his path because humanity was 100% doomed to go extinct. May as well spend the last years with your adopted daughter rather than making her be forced to give birth every year only to bring into the world more female sex slaves.

He should have fucked Ellie.

There's always the sequel.

>>383990171
Wrong. And you don't die from just one bullet anyway

>>383990301
Right. Yes you do.

>>383988398
>mow down scarce survivors who are te only ones working towards a cure
>to save a dyke babby
Off yourself my man

>>383990204
>There were more than enough people around to restart humanity.
But you only focus on sheer numbers of survivors which doesn't matter.
They don't have enough food and it's getting worse day by day.
Even if they all magically got their hands on a vaccine the world outside is still filled with billions of zombies they can't deal with.
Humanity while still having working military with all the tech available couldn't.

>The world was doomed anyways
The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

Fucking liberals.

>>383990724
Liberals are the ones who are utilitarians dumbass. That quote would fit quite well under wealth redistribution. Meanwhile conservatives are all about hording wealth and believing they deserve to do so even if it causes others to suffer.

>>383990915
>others
>2 people

>>383990724
> sacrificing your "daughter" for some fake sense of altruism
> "liberals xDDD"

nice one

>/pol/ fags have arrived
well that was it i guess

>>383990301
You need to stop playing vidya and watching movies for a while.

>>383991134
Point them out for me, Reddit-kun.

>>383991219
>uppity /pol/ fag pulls out $boogieman_site to fit in
lel

>>383991274
>cries /pol/fag
>gets upset when they get called a redditfag
You have to go back.

>so we have this girl who as far as we know is the only immune person on the planet, how should we start?
>Blood tests, tissue samples, anything non-invasive?
>Nah, let's just cut her fucking brain out and hope we can work it out from there.
Can't really say I blame Joel.

>>383991463
The fireflies were terrorists.
Can't expect them to know what they're doing.

>>383991463
Yeah, basically. Fireflies were fucking idiots. The fact that they had to rely on someone like Joel to get their last hope for humanity anywhere says it all really.

File: 1493356276572.jpg (65KB, 642x534px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 642x534px

>>383988398
>mfw i realise the ending to this game is a white guy shooting a black chick to save a little white girl

literally kino

>>383989614
Are you implying you wouldn't do the same if your daughter died?

>>383989967
>can only birth one child every year
>a max of 8 children before she dies
Oh yeah, that's gonna save us.

>>383989041
How many guns was he supposed to get anyway? Was he supposed to get a truckload of military weapons and gear or just a box of the shit he's using for most of the game?

>>383989740
Her mind was already made up before you meet her. Besides that, he suggests to her right after the giraffe scene that they don't need to do this.

>>383992283
Wouldn't any person that fucks her become infected though

>>383993041
Depends on what the writers put into the script I guess.

>>383992637
According to Tess, “a lot”

>>383988540
Me too.

>>383994223
>have lots of guns
>lend them to someone
>only have a shitty 9mm pistol with 4 rounds left for yourself

>>383991419
Shut the fuck up fag

How many of you actually care about other people beyond your family and friends? I would trade the lives of all of you for the sake of my loved ones any day of the week. I would probably miss shitposting with you all, though.

>>383988398
>he didn't fuck her
He did everything wrong.

>>383996724
This was especially true in Joel's case. 95% of the people he interacts with during the course of the game are straight up evil pieces of shit. The gang in Shitsburgh, the cannibals, Fireflies, government fuckers. Everyone left is a scumbag, and i think that was a major point of the game. Humanity was lost.

>>383988513
>>383990285
>>383996860
Stop trying to fit in it's embarrassing

>>383988398
Was it really necessary for a sequel? I thought it ended great and now if the sequel sucked it would ruin the impact of the previous game

>>383997115
Yeah, no point in fixing what's hopelessly irreparable.

>>383997356
*trying to fix

>>383997115
What about Joel's brother and his group? They weren't so bad. Plus shitty groups running amok is because of all the shit that happened. I think it's unfair to say "humanity is lost" without at least trying to make things right

>>383997248
>Over 12m copies sold
Yeah I'd say it's pretty necessary

Also I don't get this logic of sequels somehow “ruining” the first games. Even if TLOU2 turns out to be a big disappointment that doesn't change how good the first one us

>>383997232
>implying you wouldn't give her one

>>383997568
>Every multimillion seller must have a sequel
It just feels unnecessary when the first game ended nicely with no loose ends whatsoever. I'd rather have a new IP

>>383997518
You wouldn't do that. No one in their right mind would willingly KILL a loved one for the chance of getting mankind back on its feet. Unless you're God himself and love your creation that much.
The sacrifice and suffering that would come with it is just too much for the average Joel to endure.

>>383997518
That grou p was just like the other bandits, only Joel's brother led them, so they weren't hostile to you. Humanity was beyond saving. There were also a ton of clickers and bloaters still about that could kill without infecting. No government or infrastructure either.

File: Bill.png (249KB, 413x545px) Image search: [Google]

249KB, 413x545px

Would the game have been better or worse if he stayed longer?

>>383991463
They already tried the non-invasive methods in the previous immune persons. There's an audio log in the hospital that says so.

>>383999907
Nah, Bill belongs in Bills Town

>>383988398
Neil Druckmann also did nothing wrong.

Seriously he's cool

>>384000557
t. Neil Druckmann

>>383990724
okay we'll kill you first then.

>>384000627
Not him but what's wrong with that guy? Do you guys hate him?

File: C9PQ6lTXsAEPGW0.jpg (19KB, 235x326px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 235x326px

>>384000557
I would like to have a chat with him, just to see what he's really like irl

Also he needs to shave or trim his beard, he looks dirty now

>>384000668
>n-no i wasn't talking about me i'm an exception
t. Every faggot that says to cull humans

>>384000479
Do you think he'll be in part 2?

>>384001048
No, I think TLOU2 will take place in new locations