Original or Source?

Original

The Source version has a bunch of bugs that fuck up the game at points and it doesn't look any better than the original version.

>>383700597
Original, Source isn't worth it

Original.
It's not a matter of preference, Source version is shit.

Original, also use original models, make sure HD models are disabled.

>>383700597
The original.
The source port was hasty hackjob, full of bugs and conflicting art stuff.

File: 20170712182558_1.jpg (53KB, 528x422px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 528x422px

>>383701160
This shit here. Disable it.

>>383701160
Why no hd models?

>>383701363
he's nostalgic for his pre-Voodoo era gaming years.

>>383701363
They don't fit aesthetics of level design. They were made for console ports, which also had graphically more complex environments. Also they're not really liked by the fans.

Also it breaks lore. There's no reason for Beretta and M4 to share 9mm ammo, nor there's a reason for M9 to have full auto mode.

>>383701363
not that anon but it really messes with me how they made the smg into an m16 in the HD models

An assault rifle that can't hit a target more than 2 feet away? fuck off desu

HD grenade is the only weapon that actually looks better anyway

>>383701743
>They were made for console ports, which also had graphically more complex environments
Wrong.
Plus I am a fan, and I love the HD models. And there's no "full auto mode" on pistols, period.

>>383702072
>there's no "full auto mode" on pistols, period
wrong

>>383701869
This is the only good response, thank you

>>383702280
if you count a only slightly faster with slightly less accuracy button full auto then maybe

>>383702072
>Wrong.
I'm not. These models were made for cancelled Dreamcast port. And PS2 version is indeed graphically more detailed. More detailed environments, even the models themselves.

>>383702495
>These models were made for cancelled Dreamcast port.
And I have no idea why, because the framerate in the Dreamcast version is shit.

>>383701363
They look like shit and look even worse with the low detail maps.

>>383700597
Original, plenty of bugs on Source.

I stopped playing the Source version on the part where you are on several conveyor belts because the liquids were so bugged they stretched out all over the map in a bright yellow/red color and it was impossible to see anything.

>>383702280
Fast tapping trigger =/= full auto, you noguns moron.

>>383702495
I own the PS2 version, and I can say that the ENVIRONMENTS were not upped whatsoever. The only exception are the F-Aid & Charging station devices.

>>383702280
It's only in Sven Co-op, in the original game the pistol don't have an auto mode.

Best pistol
Worst smg

Steam or WON?

>>383700597
How do Original and Source differ?

I don't even know which one I played (but probably Original, I think), I just played Half Life.

>>383702641
You're aware that's Glock 17, which can be converted into full auto? That's the reason why this one is in the game.

The original with HD models off. Source is a buggy piece of shit that doesn't benefit at all from the engine.

Original. Also Black Mesa is not HL, it works completely different regarding the AI and shit (inferior, does not use HL neural net AI)

>>383702942
One has ragdolls.

>>383702495
>These models were made for cancelled Dreamcast port.

No, they are from Blue Shift.

>>383702942
Source has increased movement speed, new "nicer" effects such as water reflections, which really don't fit the game, new bugs.
Also >>383703265 which doesn't fit the game.

>>383702641
(you)

>>383703357
Blue Shift was originally a bonus in the Dreamcast port, moron.

>>383703357
They were made for Dreamcast port in the first place. Educate yourself.

>>383702942
Not so much, Source having stuff like ragdoll on death for instance instead of the death animation of the Original, and small tweaks on weapons and enemies.

But compared to the Original, HL Source is full of bug, if you had stuff stretching out over your entire screen it was probably the Source version.

>>383702734
They changed the beginning of Office Complex and the end of Blast Pit

>>383700597
Black Mesa Xen coming out this year

>>383702942
>How do Original and Source differ?
Source is just a quick "remake" of HL1, running on Source engine. Same character models, maps, textures, etc, with a simple bloom & watershader paint on top, with ragdoll physics as bonus.

>>383701363
People liked misaligned textures and creepy Barneys

>>383703823
>remake
It's just a port. Literally.

>>383703408
Ran out of arguments, huh?

>>383703823
It's one of the laziest ports in vidya history, not a remake.

>>383703903
it's not. If you recreate a game on a new engine, it's a remake. Not a RE:Remake -level amazing upgrade, but still.

>>383703980
Maybe if you actually, you know, REMAKE everything

>>383703980
Source is literally massively upgraded goldsource.

If anyone is interested, here's a PS2 version playable on PC. At least single player part.
http://www.moddb.com/mods/half-life-playstation-2-port-xash/downloads

Decay the coop part is available as other mod.

>>383702605

I'm so glad you mentioned this as I thought my graphics card was dying on me

I'm gonna replay the original then next week.

>>383704197
I was wondering when this would happen

>>383702551
>the version we got would not be the final version

>>383703823
Pretty much Half Life assets quickly converted to source.
Maybe if you really like sources water effect

>>383705680
>Maybe if you really like sources water effect
Don't forget the bullet impacts