Game Physics

>Game A
Horizon Zero Dawn
>Game B
Breath of the Wild

game B
who would want graphics over gameplay

A if I want a movie, B if I want a game.

is this a cleverly disguised horizon vs botw thread?

>>383540489
If it wasn't before, it is now.

>>383540326
>You can interact with nothing

Then it literally isn't a game.

File: BOTW-Share_icon.jpg (237KB, 1200x630px) Image search: [Google]

237KB, 1200x630px

i like game b alot

>everything is static
So it isn't even a movie, just a giant picture? Who would even pick A?

>Game A:
All ps4 games

>>383540326
>game A
doom3
>game B
half life 2

>>383541094
I think OP meant everything being static in regards to interactivity with the environment.
You can't pick up a tree branch or light on fire, for example. It's just a part of the environment. Walking on it or attempting to move it doesn't affect it either.

Game B doesn't exist yet

Game B. Everything described in Game B helps gameplay. Nothing described in Game A helps gameplay. Game B is superior.

File: meat.jpg (40KB, 468x420px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 468x420px

>>383540326
>game A is a movie
>game B is a game
Real tough choice.

>>383540326
>A: uncharted x

>B: nothing yet.

>>383543021
>game A is a movie
>game B is an incredibly laggy phsycis sandbox

File: 1499715078849.jpg (201KB, 841x951px) Image search: [Google]

201KB, 841x951px

>>383540326
Alright, what if game C
>as static as A
>as simple graphics as B
>but AI is practically sentient and dialogue options are replaced with just typing the text directly

>>383540326
I feel like we've had Game A as the standard since the original Xbox, but now it is starting to show its age.

Game B is the future, and it could maybe become more of a hybrid with Game A.

>>383543741
Then I'd have no friends in game either.

I'll take game B please.

>>383540374
/bread

Depends entirely on how the graphics or physics are used.

>you can interact with nothing
Then what's the fucking point?

>>383540326
I want Game C
>world is creative and unique
>has its own phenomena, ecosystems, metaphysics
Xenoblade

>>383545595
Thats not broad enough were talking about mechanics not lore details

Going against the popular vote with A here.

Game B is just open sandbox action game, like Red Faction Guerrilla. The idea has been done to death, usually fun for a few hours then repetitive and boring.

Game A has never been done before. Sure you can say it would be as much of a game as gone home, but it would be of a quality we haven't even been close to seeing. bonus points if its just POV porn.

>>383540326
Game A is a movie.
Game B as described is just a physics toy. Fun to play around with, but not really a game.

Get Game A the fuck away from me, holy shit that's disgusting

>>383540326
CryzenX is shit tier. Fuck off.

>>383542665

Dwarf Fortress

>>383540326
Game B by a fucking mile.
But in an ideal world there would be multiple games that are both.

>>383547381
>can't grasp and use air as a tool/weapon
reeeee 0/10

Game B

Game A is really only good for screenshots and whatever the inherent gameplay is. Game B allows for the inherent gameplay the be enhanced through physics shenanigans. Instead of just fighting a monster, you could knock it off cliffs, throw it through doors, break open a wall to attack it, and more. It adds to how you play and enjoy the game, rather than just being appearance based.

>>383543278
Holy fuck I've never heard of uncharted X. Sounds rad though.

>>383546401
>Game A has never been done before
What? There's tons of recent examples that prove you wrong...

so basically game A is a UE4 photogrammetry demo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DqraO04zbxI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_dDpdibtJ0

>>383540374

yeah right, BotW doesn't have advanced physics like that.

>>383548242
is that youtubes shitty framerate or ue4s?

>>383549050
I think it's partly youtube, partly UE's shitty stock movement controller which does some weird quantized mouse-look thing. It's been a long time since I used UE though, so I'm not entirely sure. I doubt it's a framerate-pumping problem though, these photogrammetry scenes usually aren't that intensive.