witcher 2>>>>witcher 3 Prove me wrong

>>382526287

W3 had abetter story

W3 had a bigger world

W3 had more armor, more swords more options for customization

W3 had more bitches i could fuck

W3 had better gameplay

>>382526420
>W3 had more bitches i could fuck
0 isn't more than 0 you mong

>>382526420
>better story
That's wrong, the main plot in witcher 2 is far better than the one in the witcher 3
>bigger world
Bigger world does not mean better world
>more x
Literally does not matter when all of them feel the same
>more bitches
Just watch porn you deprived virgin
>better gameplay
Shallow as fuck compared to W2

But then again you are a retarded tripfag so I guess you don't know quality when it slaps you in the face

File: 1466512764530.jpg (17KB, 468x359px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 468x359px

>>382526517
>opinion
>opinion
>hurrrr
>huurrrr durrr
>DERRR HRRRP DARRH
Anon goes full retard in 5 sentences.

>>382526656
>the average witcher 3 fanboy
I hate that my favourite series is now catered to you obnoxious faggots

File: 19146177_1660200817347470_1213591861832756125_n.jpg (25KB, 960x960px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 960x960px

> tfw bought witcher 3 collector's edition for pc
> came with no steam key
> considering buying witcher 3again on Steam and replaying to get achievements and track played time

>>382526287
Nothing to prove wrong here
Witcher 2 was a polished singleplayer experience, the Witcher 3 was just bloat smeared all over a half empty map
And having a lekker encounter every few meters doesn't make the game dynamic

>>382526939
>derpily duurrrrp
Stop it anon, it's embarrassing.

>>382526287
Witcher 1 > Witcher 2 > Witcher 3

1's a buggy mess too.

>>382526517

>That's wrong, the main plot in witcher 2 is far better than the one in the witcher 3

Thats just your opinion. Also there were much better and more sidequests in W3

>Bigger world does not mean better world

In this case yes it mens excatly that. W2 had 3real places you could explore that were pretty good. W3 Novigrad was abetter city than all off W2 combined

>Literally does not matter when all of them feel the same

It actually does because the armor was diverse ( heavy, middle light ) more weapons mean more variaty challanging opoonents and its always better to have more options

>Just watch porn you deprived virgin

Bitches to fuck also increased side quests

>Shallow as fuck compared to W2

Actually deeper but okay

File: 20170227193413_1.jpg (218KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

218KB, 1920x1080px

>>382526287
>no yen

Shit game confirmed

File: rZOaHhx.png (56KB, 192x154px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 192x154px

>>382527373
>Actually deeper but okay

>>382527442
I bet you didnt even play the first two games

>>382527373
>actually deeper
Lol?

>>382526287
Shit > Filthy Shit

Wooooooow

File: latest.png (522KB, 312x1097px) Image search: [Google]

522KB, 312x1097px

I think they excel in different areas, but overall I preferred W2 over W3. I was just more interested in the political oriented story and Letho was a much stronger antagonist than the Wild Hunt and had a better payoff. Despite being shorter and more contained it also allowed you to look at the conflict from two different sides with Iorveth and Roche and the cast of characters they interacted with.

If I had to pick a reason why W2 stinks, it's the lack of a certain someone...

File: witchersteam.png (2KB, 258x57px) Image search: [Google]

2KB, 258x57px

>>382527514
Guess again poohead

All books read too

I really liked 2, but c'mon, son. The only thing 2 really has over 3 is that the story is arguably better if you find all the politics and mystery appealing.

>>382526287
make an argument worth disproving first.

File: 180804.png (4KB, 255x73px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 255x73px

>>382527694
>posting library which allows you to add non-steam games
Ok my dude

>>382526420
Witcher 2 had a better main story but inferior side quests.
Witcher 3 main story sort of gets lost in the immensity of its world. You start with the Wild Hunt, they are even coming after you in White Orchard, after that you visit a village destroyed by the Wild Hunt in Velen and then...welp it sorts of disappears. The last part of the game is rushed "look I can magically prove that the King of the Wild Hunt poisoned the previous King, WHO WOULD HAVE THOUGHT?".
Also, they lacked the time the fully develop the personnality of the King of the Hunt, turning him into an over the top villain. They definitely should have spent more time developping your "relationship" with him. They did a far better job with Gunther O'Dimm in HoS.

>>382527978
True. I'm glad the characters themselves are appealing because the plot does indeed get a bit confused at times, especially near the end. Glad they ended things on a better note with HoS and BaW.

File: Hey Gerald of Bolivia I know you just murdered the king but now I need you to not get involved in politics and let me murder all your friends I am so smart btw.png (109KB, 360x400px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 360x400px

Witcher 3: Assassin of character

File: TheMostInterestingWitcherInTheWorld.png (326KB, 363x392px) Image search: [Google]

326KB, 363x392px

>>382527971
yeah I'm really going to go through the effort of adding two fake games to my steam to convince some random autist that I've played two real games

>>382528220
Just show him the time played.

witcher 2 was shit

>one curse and a handful of contracts
>the most witchery thing (batlimore's nightmare) was a side quest

you do more witcher shit the prologue of w1 or the tutorial town in w3 than the entirety of 2. witcher 2 was a gas leak game.

>>382528137
This is the only real part of the game's writing that seriously bothered me. Supposedly they had to alter the quest's ending due to time constraints, but it's still unforgivable.
I'd almost prefer breaking his other leg if it didn't mean that the Rad man wins.

>>382527045
That stuff is on GOG if you use Galaxy.

>>382528126
My only concern with BaW is how you see coming, miles away, that Detlaff is being blackmailed by Syana. That being said, I guess we could give them a pass because of the setting : Toussaint is a cliche "world", so this kind of plot makes sense.
It's kinda sad that the White Frost isn't more exploited in W3, though. W1 was about Alvin trying to find a way for Humanity to survive the incoming White Frost. the King of the Hunt himself is just looking to impregnate Ciri so she could give birth to a child of old blood strong enough to allow his people to migrate in an another world, like the Humans did by "accident" during the Conjunction. By destroying the Wild Hunt, we condemn his people.

I liked the atmosphere of 2
I can't really put it into words without using PR speak but I felt way more involved in 2 as opposed to 1 or 3.

W2 was absolutely incredible experience back in 2011, much more grounded and mature than DX:HR or Mass Effect.
Its just different scale of experience to w3 which does pretty much everything better.

File: shove aside.png (661KB, 848x844px) Image search: [Google]

661KB, 848x844px

>>382528137
>>382528419
Beheading Djikstra like he isn't more than a thug in an alley really disappointed me. I just wanted to break his leg again.

>>382528763
i tried witcher 1 the other day and found the combat kinda bad
should i skip it and just go to 2?

I never got the hate for w2
it wasnt as open as the first game but your choices made a much bigger impact and isnt that the best thing an RPG can do?

>>382528909
too bad that breaking his leg a second time excludes you from rads quest

>>382528909
>FORCEFULLY

File: Witcher Broche.png (215KB, 350x265px) Image search: [Google]

215KB, 350x265px

>>382529262
I know, but I wanted a second opportunity to break his leg again (the first time being before W3).

It's a shame that in witcher 3 I couldn't continue going on adventures with my bro Roche

I'd love witcher if they made me play as a random fucking witcher doing witcher things instead of playing as Geralt where everyone treats me like a piece of shit and I have to be a dick just so my "friends" tell me what the fuck they're planning when they tell me to do shit. Fucking sorcerers. I just really love monster hunting.

File: Witcher who did you side with.jpg (96KB, 900x559px) Image search: [Google]

96KB, 900x559px

>>382529020
Yes. Combats in Witcher 1 are just a question of rythm. W2 combats are much more like the ones in W3. If you hate the combats in the 1, you might as well directly play W2.
>>382528763
It's simply that W2 had a better rythm, which is helped by the fact that it's smaller and quite linear.
Also, you start with a question "why are some witchers killing the Kings?" and a few others are adding "Can I trust Triss and the Lodge? Who is Saskia?". It makes the story more intriguing than looking fore someone whithout a lot of mystery. I loved both games and I really hope CD Projekt will learn from it for next big game. HoS was really a good omen in this regard.

>>382530001
Then go play monster hunter and stop complaining a game is loyal to what its source materual is about.

>>382529080
The impact of the next 2 games aren't as great if you aren't familiar with W1's storyline. Also the only Witcher title that gives you save imports that matter

File: 41ee3d3c8ecef387acf0fc6f585847e2_tumblr-not-even-once-dankmemes-not-an-argument-meme_598-792[1].jpg (237KB, 598x792px) Image search: [Google]

237KB, 598x792px

>>382530153
What? Witchers killing shit is also the source material you cunt. If the game revolved around assassinating people as a cat school witcher it'd be based on the source material.

>>382530091
I never considered the main story of TW3 to be all about about finding Ciri, it's something you quickly forget about since each area you visit is made of more focused subplots which end up being much more interesting, nor do I consider the Wild Hunt to be the main villain until the last quarter of the game.
The pacing is pretty much like the books, there's a clear goal with a lot happening in between, and those end up being the focus for the most part until the goal catches up at the end.

witcher 2 hurts my eyes with that purple shit

File: 1477176825758.jpg (470KB, 1440x810px) Image search: [Google]

470KB, 1440x810px

>>382531269
I agree with you that the subplots are more interesting. I really enjoyed discovering the rivalries in Novigrad, I'm almost sad that we don't have more of it with the King of beggars for example. That being said, it is, like you rightfully said, "subplot".
I prefer W3, though. I was just proposing an answer to that guy who said he couldn't explain why he felt more involved in W2 than in W3. They are both great games.

File: 1306782704414.jpg (109KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 1920x1080px

>>382526287

>Prove me wrong

I can't. Best characters in the series hands down.

>>382528137

Same for RADovid. It's like Redania in general triggers cdpr.

>>382528752
>By destroying the Wild Hunt, we condemn his people.
Ciri stops the White Frost.

>>382528763

W2 world really does feel overwhelming. W3 feels so shallow in comparison.

>>382532694
He was right to kill the non humans and hunt the Lodge, though.

>>382526287
your're absolutely right anon, tw2 is the best plebfilter I've ever played.

>>382532975
Only if you have the happy ending.
> it still hurts

File: witcher3 2017-06-18 21-12-47-93.jpg (2MB, 2560x1440px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2560x1440px

>>382526287
1>3>2

Proved you wrong bitch boi

>>382526287
>witcher 2>>>>witcher 3
the witcher 2 is actually a narrative driven rpg, while the witcher 3 is a glorified barbie game for fags.

>>382533014

That's besides the point, he's portrayed as a madman and a despot, instead of a cold calculating son of a bitch.

>>382533150
even if she dies because you're a bad person the White Frost is stopped.

>>382526287
the story in TW2 was miles better than TW3, almost enough to consider it the better game. But TW3 did everything else better, and the DLCs just push it over the edge to make it better than W2.

Then again Witcher 3 didn't let you fuck a succubus, so idk.

>>382533257
We don't know for sure.
Also, sorry for not realizing that playing snow fucking balls was necessary to save the World.

>>382533470
I agree with you anon, but the open world aspect of TW3 was some of the most horrible game design you can experience. If TW3 were a linear experience as is TW2, I would agree that the third one is the better game.

File: 1334242359495.gif (241KB, 553x393px) Image search: [Google]

241KB, 553x393px

I miss my bros

>>382526287
dumb contrarianposter

>>382526287
Witcher 2 had a better main quest, all the rest is better in witcher 3.
The main quest of W3 is painfully bad though, like Oblivion tier.

>>382533664
I appreciate that they tried to adapt the whole world in an open world game but I might have to agree as well that because these games are narrative-focused, they would benefit more from a structured progression of "hubs" like in W2. This would allow them to concentrate their great side quests to be easily available as well as focus on producing more of the interesting ones, since they wouldn't waste resources building the open world and the useless question mark loot locations.

On the other hand, some monster hunting quests were enjoyable and had an interesting twist to them, and these quests are only possible thanks to the open world. They took W3 in a different direction, and both are very enjoyable, so I can't say anything in the end. Some sacrifice of open world elements towards more political side quests akin to W2 would definitely be preferable however.

Witcher 3 had better: Visuals, music, combat and gameplay in general, atmosphere. The only thing that you could argue is better in 2 is Story and characters, but even then Hearts of Stone is the best story in the entire series so yeah. Witcher 2 is a sack of shit compared to 3

>>382527978
>Witcher 3 main story sort of gets lost in the immensity of its world

I definitely know what you mean here. You get given like 5 main quests to pursue when you arrive in Velen so there's no real sense of a linear plotline like in other games and then it all gets muddled with the huge amount of side-content that appears whichever way you go

File: Witcher 2 Spinning Iorveth.webm (3MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1280x720px

>>382534486
Yeah but did it have THIS?

>>382534190

The only good quest in witcher 3 is the one where you kill the giant with Hjalmar.

>>382534389
based broche 10/10 vidya companion

>>382526287
I liked Witcher 2's self contained areas more, and I miss when each chapter focused on a big bad monster boss. That said, DLC pretty much cover that entirely and then some so now

Witcher 3 w/DLC >>>>>>>Witcher 2>Witcher 3

Yen a best girl and waifu game in 2 sucks

>>382534486
>Visuals
sure, it's a newer game
>music
not even close to true
>combat and gameplay
no, tw2 is more difficult than tw3, thus more satisfying to play. also, the second doesn't suffer from the stupid ubisoft tier marker open world design that you have in the third.

>>382534759
The other skelig one where the guy is cursed by the shadow monster, and the abortion monster quest are also goat. And the plague ghost. Actually a lot of the major secondary quests were rock solid

File: 1498560600252.jpg (61KB, 520x719px) Image search: [Google]

61KB, 520x719px

>>382526656

>>382526420
>better gameplay
nahhh

>>382526287
how's the loot game in 2? W3 has a very weird loot level scaling.

>>382534951
Sorry, but Witcher 2 had an incredibly forgettable soundtrack. Also, it's more difficult than 3 because the combat is clunky and shit, but hey you're a contrarian so it's super satisfying for you lmao

>>382535168
how salty do you even have to be to make a comic like that?

>>382535218
Because TW2 consists of self contained areas instead of an open world, there's no level restrictions on gear. You're restricted by what weapons and recipes you can buy or find.