Is this the most overrated game of all-time? >combat is super

File: 846734aa0bcdb0b24eae2ca52578fb26-d564g6c.png (332KB, 537x900px) Image search: [Google]

332KB, 537x900px

>botwfags trying to attack the greatest zelda cause people are shitting on theirs for having nothing great from the golden era of zelda games

Fuck off. Not even your waifus were good

>>382410902
no its the greatest game of all time
>combat is fun
>puzzles are fun
>dungeons are fun
you just got completely BTFO bitch

>>382410902
You dropped your Dark Souls picture, anon.

>>382411000
I've never played BotW.
>>382411012
You're the reason people say fun is a buzzword.

>>382411032
Zelda and Souls are great for similar reasons so I don't see why there would be any antagonism.

>>382411314
Souls is a superior zelda game.

>>382411000
>Posting worst fanart of best girl while sporting trips
>Implying BOTW doesn't have amazing waifus
Fuck off.

File: 1497775853238.png (171KB, 364x399px) Image search: [Google]

171KB, 364x399px

OoT literally split gaming history into BEFORE OoT and AFTER OoT. It's impact cannot be overstated enough. The only people who think it's overrated are either salty Nintendo haters or clueless kiddies who understand fuck all about video games.

>>382411409
>>382411409
Being influential doesn't make it good.

File: 1386049567359.png (290KB, 745x742px) Image search: [Google]

290KB, 745x742px

>>382411397
Botw's waifus are shit tier, faggot.

>being not only envious of oot being the better game, but also of my trips

insecure small dick faggot

File: Demo.png (64KB, 168x184px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 168x184px

>>382410902
Wow, you really shook the world with this one, OP. Next time you're gonna be telling me you think FFVII is overrated.

>>382411559
The question is whether or not it's overrated. Stay on topic.

But yes, it IS good. Fuck sake.

>>382411649
Woah there, champ. As a person who likes that universally acclaimed game, I am compelled to reply to you after you criticize it and inform you how incorrect your opinion is.

>>382411351
I disagree. DS1 is better than most Zelda games at a decent number things, but even its strengths still aren't enough to reach the glorious heights that Zelda is capable of at its best.

Anju and Kafei are so fucking hot

>>382410902
Its overrated, but that doesnt mean it isnt fun. I think there are even more overrated games out there.

>>382411114
>>I've never played BotW.
lol faggot, how can you say this one is overrated if you havent even played botw? are you retarded?

>>382410902
>zelda fans hate other zelda fans the most
kek

Shitting on OoT at this point is just as overdone and boring as praising it. There is not one interesting thing you can possibly say about this game at this point, let it fucking rest.

>>382410902
Half life is more overrated this game is quite for its time, i emulated it and played jt for the first time on emulator i really liked it but half life 2 was really blend

File: giphy.gif (480KB, 493x342px) Image search: [Google]

480KB, 493x342px

>>382416420
Not even the guy,

That doesn't make sense. Why would he need to play BotW to rate a different game.
Sure it's a game in the same universe, but a game should be regarded on its merit not compared to other games unless they're basically identical in game play and BotW is very different from Ocarina of time.
He was just asking if(/stating that) ocarina of time was overrated.
Which is a stupid as fuck thread anyways when the game came out almost 20 years ago and expectations of what a game could be, or should be were wildly different because it was fucking almost 20 years ago

>>382417291
because saying its the most overrated game implies he is comparing it to other zeldas, you cant say vanilla ice creams are the best if you never eaten chocolate ice creams you stupid nigger

>>382417427
No one has to play botw to say whether a past zelda game is good or not.

btw botw is shit

>>382417528
OP said oot is THE MOST overrated zelda, not that its good or bad, learn to read you illiterate subhuman

>>382417738
overrated is a negative connotation. you're the one who needs to check his comprohension

>>382417787
oot cant be the most overrated zelda because i didnt play it so it doesnt count, see how that works?

File: NES_Tetris_Box_Front.jpg (35KB, 223x320px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 223x320px

>combat is super simple
>puzzles practically solve themselves
>only one dungeon that isn't linear as fuck
>progression can sometimes be unreasonably obscure

>>382411559
Not an argument, kid. OoT is widely considered to be the greatest game of all time. Every developer out there has stolen shit from SM64 and Ocarina.

>>382410902
nah that unironically goes to Skyrim

OoT also isn't the best game ever but it's really high up there.

File: 1473635014376.jpg (108KB, 547x400px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 547x400px

>combat is super simple
>puzzles practically solve themselves
>only one dungeon that isn't linear as fuck
>progression can sometimes be unreasonably obscure

it was legendary for how it innovated 3d games and is STILL fun to play today. the atmosphere and themes of the game still gets to me. if there is one game that definitely deserves its praise, it's oot.

>>382418013
Also, not an argument chump.

>>382418081
nice try

>>382417949
>implying "form a line to clear blocks" is somehow obscure
>puzzles are challenging
nice try, zelda fans

File: 1498811422624.jpg (12KB, 258x245px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 258x245px

>>382418115
>Dungeon
>In Metroid
I know you mean something else. But what does it mean??? Are you pulling this out of your ass??

File: j6sDeC2.jpg (546KB, 1920x1200px) Image search: [Google]

546KB, 1920x1200px

>>382417738
>>382417427
I hope you're ESL or something cause your reading comprehension is DAMN
Most overrated game means all genre's, all consoles, pong to now. There was never a direct comparison made in the original post to BotW; that didn't come until you.

You just made the assumption, out of fucking no where, that "botwfags" were attacking OoT (only an autist like you could come up with a reason for that)
And jesus christ yes you can say vanilla ice cream is the best without eating chocolate people do that shit all the time even if it's only hyperbole.

He never said THE MOST overrated zelda, he said all time look again you double nigger

>>382418474
how can you know botw is not the most overrated game if you never played it?

>>382418594
Again I'm not the dude (OP) that you started talking to I'm:
>>382418474
>>382417291

I have played BotW and it IS NOT the most overrated game anyways, BotW deserves a good deal of its praise, even though it's not perfect it does enough stuff right.
OP said "Is this the most overrated game of all-time?" direct quote, and who knows maybe it fucking is, but again stupid thread anyways.

>>382418454
the game is 1 dungeon

>>382418768
its literally wind waker with open world land and fetch quests from wow, it didnt deserve 98 and saying its the best game of the decade means botw fags and you are retarded. botw is overrated

>>382418937
BotW may be overrated, but is it the most overrated game of all time? Jesus christ no there hasn't been enough time for it to be "the most overrated game of all time"!
People have been sucking that OoT dick for almost 20 years. I'm sorry that you can't have fun anymore in video games, but I found some cool shit in BotW so that's enough for me. It wasn't superb, or anything, but it was good.

>>382419140
>BotW may be overrated, but is it the most overrated game of all time?
yes it is, just look around the internet how people say it reinvented video games

>>382410902
>only one dungeon that isn't linear as fuck
>progression can sometimes be unreasonably obscure
Be consistent faggot, which is it?

>>382419140
Botw has gotten instant 10/10s from most top review sites. It is definitely overrated, especially after the ass beating SS got for being a worse zelda. Then suddenly botw comes along, throws away all the elements reviewers were asking for, and suddenly 10s suddenly. As if they were being paid off or something.

>>382410902
people calling OoT (or Mario 64 for that matter) "overrated" always seem like teenagers that don't realize how much it changed the game. Today it doesn't seem that unique anymore, because literally every 3D game copied from it. And even to this day it still holds up.

It's like calling Citizen Kane overrated.

>>382411559
Being influential literally makes it objectively not overrated, you dumb stupid fuck. If it was influential then it deserves the praise. The term overrated doesn't mean "i dun liek it as much as othurs so i git 2 decid how much praize it gets!!" you fucking inbred.

>>382410902
It got popular because of the artistic direction.

>>382419404
>it was the first so it must be the best
Stop being retarded.

>>382419404
>Today it doesn't seem that unique anymore
You're basically admitting that this game is nothing but nostalgia.

>>382410902
Name a better game.

>>382420106
100% Orange Juice

>>382419625
He didn't say it was the best. The term overrated shouldn't be used towards something influential. It makes absolutely no sense. How can something that revolutionized whatever medium/art form it's in be over praised?
Something that was revolutionary should inherently be praised because of its achievements, regardless of what came after it. It may not be "the best" but it will forever still be "good," because nothing came before it. There was no standard you can hold against it before it came about. You can say it's shit because that implies you dislike the game, but specifically using the term overrated implies objectivity defined by subjectivity, it's a literal meme buzzword.

>>382419989
No, it's not nostalgia, it's putting things into context. I'm trying to explain, that if videogames want to be seen as art, it's only logical to take into account how influential a game is today and how it was received during the time of it's release. Of course an older videogame seems "inferior" nowadays, because other game designers learned from and improved it.

>>382420264
>if videogames want to be seen as art
>seen as art
You're a dumbass.

>>382418170
Why so butthurt?

>>382420423
ok,so because you don't have any real arguments,you use insults. Nice discussion. But I guess having an argument about something being "overrated" is futile anyway. Words like overrated and pretentious are being thrown around so much on this site, that they lost all meaning anyway.

File: cec07fa3d1c2f968afb6d7853a91b01b--zelda-twilight-princess-the-heroes.jpg (18KB, 236x239px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 236x239px

>>382410902
nah
still waiting for the third chapter

>>382420524
>muh art
>muh shrine of masturbatory value
>don't use words I don't like
You're everything that is wrong with this industry and OoT is still extremely overrated, also you're mighty dumbass.

>>382420753
Overrated basically just means

>hurrr other people like this game and I don't, but my opinion is more valuable than that of countless professional critics and gamers, which is why this game is OVAHRATEEEED

you sound like you're 12

>>382410902
The most overrated game of all time is going to be some sort of RPG where people like the characters more then they do the game.

>>382421038
>hurrr my opinion is better because it's backed by "professional" "video" game ""critics""

>>382411000
>waifufag
Fuck off retard

File: fascinating.jpg (43KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 250x250px

>>382410902

>the same old "OCARINA ISN'T THAT GREAT" argument again

wow anon your opinion is so subversive and unique

By the way, your first and last points are retarded because they're features of every fucking Zelda game (simple combat and "obscure" progression? so basically: the game isn't primarily about fighting but it does require immense exploration of its world)

can people stop dickriding the ocarina of time hate boner and just actually compliment what it did for video games? yes it's become worse with age but it's time to shut the fuck up.

>>382410902
It's Chrono Trigger. If you talk about the best rpgs or best games, some fuck will come along and put Chrono Trigger at the top and crown it winner.

Definitely not. It's the single greatest achievement in video games.

It's like everyone was making horse drawn carts and Nintendo decided they were going to make a car and they made a Ferrari as their first car.

It's a triumph of game design.

>>382411409
wow that's a really accurate analogy.
The only game I can think of that would come close to OoT levels of influence is Super Mario 64

>>382418454
>are you pulling this out of your ass?
see
>>382410902

>>382423478
>It's a triumph of game design
No, it's not, it managed to make 3D gameplay functional without feeling clunky but it also did so by putting restrictions to hide all the shortcomings of a 3D environment.

>>382410902
You're just mad because you couldn't enjoy it like everyone else

File: TLOU-GOTY-cover.jpg (228KB, 650x768px) Image search: [Google]

228KB, 650x768px

>>382410902
No.