Who suffered the most?

File: 1313671016753.jpg (49KB, 406x364px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 406x364px

>>382371463
Look in the mirror.

>>382371463
>>382371463
James
>travels through literal hell too save demon/hell/goddess spawn non-biological daughter
>saves her but she's a fucking baby and gotta change diapers and shit again
>gets stabbed to death in his own home while enjoying butter cake

Poor James.

>>382372339
Agreed.

Well, Murphy's kid got diddled and killed so...

File: Edward_Carnby_2008.png (1MB, 1100x809px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1100x809px

I would say Carnaby, but fuck you anyway.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5k8KYp0aaJY

>>382372339
Is this bait?

File: veryartywojak.png (865KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

865KB, 1920x1080px

>>382372156
end it pls

>>382372339
That's Harry.

>>382371463
Daniel

>>382371463
>lost wife, then lost child
>reluctantly killed wife, life fell apart
>lost father
>either loses nothing or his neighbor
>lost parents, became murderer
>lost brother, his fault
>lost child
>lost his entire fucking game

Reedus clearly.

>>382373629
Meme post, but I'll bite.

Alex Shepard also loses his parents, you'd know this if you actually played the game. Murphy's wife leaves him because of his obsession with revenge against his kid's diddler.

>Reedus' game didn't even get to see the light of day
clear winner here

File: image.jpg (47KB, 1190x880px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 1190x880px

>>382372156

>>382371463
Heather, because she is the only innocent person on the list. Literary. For all the others, SH was their purgatory.

>>382374383
>Literary

>>382374501
wasn't she? can't remember any fuckups of her

>>382371463
In terms of suffering, i think it was Alex Shepherd, the guy is mentally ill, his family hates him and he was born to be sacrificed.

File: image.png (2MB, 1002x1354px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1002x1354px

>>382371463
Heather. She is a good person deep down, and forced into situations because of who she was. And the person she was, also got forced into the situations the created all of silent hill. Heather has been fucked hard in three lifetimes. NOT ONE. THREE.

It all begins with Heather, it should have all ended with Heather. She will probably know no peace as long as Silent Hill exits.

>>382373629
>>382374356
He got a complete new game in exchange.

File: EA in charge of making an original prison inmate.jpg (125KB, 1100x647px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 1100x647px

>>382371463
Torque

>>382374631
Jesus Christ.

>>382374834
Probably not his first language dude. We know what he means.

And a nasty C-section scar

Not worth the tradeoff imho

>>382374826

Well damn that's an uncanny resemblance. Gotta replay The Suffering some day, that game was nightmare fuel for my young self.

File: 54780.jpg (6KB, 300x168px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 300x168px

>>382371463

>>382374902
Ah, the faggot was going ape shit over that word? Thought he had something to add.

>>382371463
James>Sheryll>Harry>Alex>Travis>Henry

not sure about this but I tried

can't comment on Murphy and nice meme putting Reedus's character

>>382371463
Us and James.

>>382375302
It's a very odd game, controls on consoles were tough to get into for me.
But i love how dedicated they were to create a VIDEOGAME over a cinematic horror. Like at one point you're kung fu jumping around shooting niggas with revolvers, than you impale them going on an autist fit, then you bomb ancient fat black slaves with dynamite on the beach and killing a bossfight with fowl.

Muddy, but good memories.
Edgy horror, but silly fun.

>>382372339
ITS HARRY YOU FUCKING RETARD. REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>>382374383
If I can remember correctly, Harry didn't do shit other than try to find his daughter.

>>382374383
harry didn't do anyhting at all besides wanna find his daughter.

>>382375586
this chart is trash and dumb to smoke

>>382375998
>>382376127
Didn't he do something to his wife as well? Not to be confused with James.

File: image.jpg (36KB, 480x480px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 480x480px

>>382375486
You are right though. Heather has been the unfortunate fall guy for the whole series since she was born as Alessa gillespie. She didn't ask to he born, and then people ruined her life, that wasn't enough, so the reincarnated her again, then she became the catalyst to ruin other multiple lives, then she was reincarnated AGAIN, and Harry paid the ultimate price for protecting her.

Basically, fuck that bitch Dahlia. Alessa/Cheryl/Heather never asked to be born.

>>382376262
They don't mention his wife if I remember right, the only reason they end up in silent Hill is because Alessa called Cheryl back to her. Besides, Harry isn't that kind of guy. I mean he raised a baby he just found as his own daughter.

>>382376262
no
his daughter just happened to be part of the issue is all

>>382376131
>one character, one space, can't have more than one in the same spot
>suffering/deserving are completely subjective and can't be measured accurately

of course it's gonna be shit but at least it's fun to build

>>382376262
naw, harry is straight up just a good guy that got caught in a bad situation with his daughter. Him and heather are just innocent victims

File: heather_silent_hill_3_by_kr0npr1nz-d75i75a.jpg (809KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

809KB, 900x900px

>>382371463
Heather definitely had it the worst, Alessa was bullied at school, burnt in a house fire, had to go through treatment with how badly she was burnt, causes all the crazy shit in Silent Hill, only friend was Lisa Trevor. I assume Cherly had it pretty good until Alessa called her back. Heather was reincarnated and goes through tons of shit because of the cult including having your adopted father murdered, made to incubate demon God throughout 3rd game.

>>382377007
Heather is an immortal demon.

File: image.png (379KB, 480x640px) Image search: [Google]

379KB, 480x640px

>>382377007
Harry was doomed the moment he got involved with that kid. Apathy was his sin.

File: image.jpg (85KB, 415x434px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 415x434px

>>382377297
We all just want to protect that smile anon.

>>382377317
isn't that alessa though? isn't heather still actually good, whether she's just another manifestation of alessa or not?

Harry

>dead wife
>loses daughter, only to be reincarnated as a different baby he doesn't know
>only to be killed in the end in efforts of protecting hell spawn from bringing about the end of the world

File: image.jpg (115KB, 1024x457px) Image search: [Google]

115KB, 1024x457px

>>382377317
What happens when Heather reaches old age and dies? Will someone rebirth her genes again?

>>382377297
>>382377478
That reminds me how fucking depressing her actual room looked too.

File: Harry_cheryl.png (2MB, 956x1600px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 956x1600px

>>382377319
>Apathy

What, as far as I can tell Harry was a great dad and person overall

>>382377607
Missing her Shattered Memories version.

>>382377662
I think he meant empathy

>>382375586

>kill family
>become a god

kratos didn't suffer. he was rewarded.

>>382377495
Alessa is good as Heather is bad. They are the same person, a perfect example of nature vs nurture. Alessa, Chery and Heather are literally the same person, and go to show what happens when you terribly abuse a person. They all had the same genes, but they didn't all get the same shot at life. Alessa was unfortunate to grow up with Dahlia, Heather was fortunate to get to grow up with Harry instead. Harry simply loved her right.

File: image.jpg (18KB, 240x305px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 240x305px

>>382377724
You're right. For some reason they put Alessa on there twice as both kid and ghost teen.

File: ClaudiaSmile.png (217KB, 350x466px) Image search: [Google]

217KB, 350x466px

>>382377297
Meant Lisa Garland, she was also friends with this crazy bitch

>>382377843
Thats the one i meant yeah.

>>382373629
>either loses nothing or his neighbor
Henry actually has nothing to lose he's a loner that potential is afraid of people in general. No one besides the superintendent cared about his disappearance. He "knew" all his neighbors but non of the ever even met him. He's probably the most pathetic SH hero ever.

File: hi_have_you_seen_my_truck.jpg (11KB, 350x193px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 350x193px

Travis, of course
>Tfw you need to walk out of your comfy truck
>No living mechanics around
>Can't drag it
>Forever trapped without truck

>>382371463

Of the number of games I played, a lot of these protags were actually pretty shitty themselves.

I'd argue that none of them suffered enough.

File: image.jpg (295KB, 996x1000px) Image search: [Google]

295KB, 996x1000px

>>382378083
Tilda Swinton innit?

File: image.jpg (35KB, 640x438px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 640x438px

>>382378313
>DON'T TALK ABOUT MY DAD LIKE THAT!!

>>382378313
Then you didn't play the original games by Team Silent. Barring James, none of the other protagonists did anything but get into cult fuckery.

File: Pg66-67SH3Character.jpg (542KB, 1648x1244px) Image search: [Google]

542KB, 1648x1244px

>>382378389
No, apparently Julianne Moore

>>382378027
They actually did a pretty decent look making her look similar to Heather given the difference in graphics and all in Shattered Memories.

>>382378653
skinhead covered in tattoos Claudia looks interesting to me but yeah, maybe overkill

>>382371463
Harry must have had a shitty life after Silent Hill
>All that shit he saw
>Probably had some PTSD about it
>Daughter is just the reincarnation of Alessa
>She grows up and weird cultist from Silent Hill start hounding both of you
>End up killing one in self defense
>Have to move
>One night you're just minding your own business while Heather is at the mall
>The world goes dark
>You've seen this before
>Get killed by the Missionary

Did he every truly leave Silent Hill?

>>382375328
"Raiden, 5 years ago... that's not what I meant.

File: image.jpg (32KB, 498x374px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 498x374px

>>382378653
Those absolute madmen... Thats not how to villian...

>>382378995
Wasn't there a bonus skin for Heather where she was covered in tats?

>>382379008
He should have tried to leave the entire country. The fuckers from Silent Hill would probably be too lazy to follow them to Europe.
Or Japan. The weird culture there might scare them off.

>>382379141
I think you haven't seen some of her more evil roles, anon.

File: God_of_Thunder.jpg (123KB, 708x654px) Image search: [Google]

123KB, 708x654px

>>382379145
Thunder God outfit which is also my favorite

>>382379351
>Hey girly, what's yer name?
>RAIDEN!

>>382379008
>Harry Mason
>lived in a small flat with a beautiful 17 year old girl that HE WASN'T EVEN RELATED TO
>he never re married
>he never dated
>the flat was small
>he just lay awake at night
>staring at the ceiling
>listining to Heather masturbate through the thin walls
>panting until orgasam
>this is everynight for the longest time
>quiet now, he stares at the ceiling

A BETTER MAN THAN US HARRY. F.

>>382375586

>Ridley too big

Kek

>>382377607
I think without the power of Silent Hill she dies. But if she stay in Silent Hill, i think she either gets a new body or just live forever with a rotting body. In SH2 we don't get to see what happens to Mary's body in the "Rebirth" ending, but according to Masahiro Ito, when they wrote that ending, it was going to be something like Pet Sematary, which means she would return as a rotting cadaver like a zombie.

>>382377495
Alessa is good as well. She just got crazy because her mind bound with the otherworld.

>>382379008
Don't forget harry had thoughts of just killing heather as a baby.

File: image.jpg (167KB, 736x1059px) Image search: [Google]

167KB, 736x1059px

>>382379796
>it was going to be something like Pet Sematary, which means she would return as a rotting cadaver like a zombie

n-no! Heather will be beautiful and freckled forever!

>>382379942
Yea forgot about that. To think all that shit happened simply because 24 years prior Harry and his wife found a baby at the side of the road and deciding to take it in as there own.

>>382378163
That's because Walter Sullivan is the main character of the game.

File: image.jpg (39KB, 336x400px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 336x400px

>>382379942
>Don't forget harry had thoughts of just killing heather as a baby.

Poor Heather...

File: 1469910605080.jpg (25KB, 327x315px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 327x315px

>>382380093

You mean all because Travis helped Alessa form the baby that would be adopted by Harry and his wife. :^)

File: image.jpg (57KB, 200x250px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 200x250px

>>382380365
>reminder when you look at Heather, she was borne from these genes

Theres a lot of evil bitch flowing in Heather's veins thats for sure.

File: 1470210534430.jpg (48KB, 365x529px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 365x529px

>>382379942

>I confess I had reservations at first about raising that baby. Could I love her? Her existence was thoroughly unexplainable. I thought, 'She could be that young woman who snatched away my beloved daughter.' That led to sadness, anger... there were times when I put my hands around her tiny little throat. Several times I even considered abandoning her. That's what a terrible person I am. But I decided to raise her after all. I just couldn't seem to let her go.
When she... when you look at me, you laugh, so...Even now, I can't forget about that girl.
But I love you. I have no doubts about that. That's all I ask you to believe.To my precious daughter...

>bottom 4
>ever
Are you retarded?

File: image.png (887KB, 1302x863px) Image search: [Google]

887KB, 1302x863px

>>382380863
f-fuck you a-anon!

File: 1470208547898.png (255KB, 494x586px) Image search: [Google]

255KB, 494x586px

>>382380776

>Some poor soul fucked Dahlia to allow Alessa to be born

Probably the scariest part about Silent Hill, desu senpai.

File: image.png (82KB, 220x263px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 220x263px

>>382381214
>some poor fuck

You misunderstand anon... Heather is not beautiful by accident, Dahlia was not always old and bitter.

File: image.gif (2MB, 500x282px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 500x282px

>>382380863
anon i....

>>382375586
Why are MGS characters so high?
They're fucking soldiers

Silent Hill is a bad horror game. How am I supposed to feel scared and horrified if I'm just filled with RAGE AND VENGEANCE?

>>382375586
>all the souls shit
>all the MGS shit
get out

File: image.jpg (81KB, 1024x578px) Image search: [Google]

81KB, 1024x578px

>>382381843
>Silent Hill is a bad horror game. How am I supposed to feel scared and horrified if my dick is ENGORGED WITH BLOOD AND MY TIP LEAKING OUT SEMEN?

File: 1469922607476.jpg (73KB, 1148x696px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 1148x696px

>>382381519

>Posting Dahlia's SM counterpart.

>>382376131
>>382377863
>>382381710
>>382381897
The chart was deveolped over like the course of a 2 week period, you had plenty of time to complain in the threads to move shit around

File: 1498835973464.jpg (35KB, 595x595px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 595x595px

>>382372156

>>382375586
>>382376131
I think the The Nameless One kind of redeems it.

File: image.png (99KB, 140x501px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 140x501px

>>382382178
Hey anon, i went for fucking YEARS without any more canon Heather fix. In my head i need to justify SM as a thing that happened and Cheryl as a mid 20's continuation of Heather. The hair dye gone, the teen need to look pretty fading as a priority... Still beautiful...

>>382379351
>R U L E S OF NATURE

File: big_boss.jpg (91KB, 436x459px) Image search: [Google]

91KB, 436x459px

>>382375328
wrong

>>382382742
>>382375328

For gods sake you two... let it go... My sons...

File: 1472865484644.gif (946KB, 399x225px) Image search: [Google]

946KB, 399x225px

>>382379351

I'm amazed the amount of skins TS gave to Heather. I wish the other games had something similar to it.

>>382378653
>Vincent
>24-26

Shit I thought he was def in late 30's.

File: Valtiel work with Valve.gif (618KB, 424x209px) Image search: [Google]

618KB, 424x209px

>>382383086

Most of the cultists we see look older than they really are.

>>382382357
WOW

>>382371463
Henry.

File: 1470211029095.jpg (54KB, 744x704px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 744x704px

>>382379485

>Heather sexually frustrated

That explains the nurses, I guess.

File: 1497714024629.gif (4MB, 720x574px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 720x574px

>>382371463

Harry obviously. Guy loses his wife, his adopted daughter, parts of his sanity and then his life trying to protect Heather.

Harry is the only one that dies.

>>382384082

None of the endings are canon faggot. Everyone could have died in the OP. They all have endings where they die.

File: Toal.jpg (50KB, 353x500px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 353x500px

>>382371463
>survived demon onslaught
>watched his commander die
>joined demons in hopes of betraying them later on
>went through hell to accomplish his goal
>killed his dad
>failed at accomplishing his goal
>his waifu turned into a rock
>got cucked post-mortem by some random redhead

Claw-man had a hard life.

>>382384337
Harry dies in SH3.
James is also missing in SH4, so he probably died as well.

>>382384337
He canonically dies in SH 3.

>>382384458
>>382384439


My point still stands.

>>382375586
>someone switch Solid Snake and Venom Snake.
I love whoever did that. Venom is still too high though.

>>382384389
Toal wanted the other goddess bud.

File: image.jpg (55KB, 372x504px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 372x504px

>>382383885
Hey, everbodies gotta cum now and again anon, otherwise we would all turn into terrible people. Heather seems like a "right before bedtime" kind of girl. A sharp panting moan a dripping squirt on the matteress and a gator roll in the sheets to sleep.

>>382384717
Who was also lusting after Adol by the time the main story began.

>>382382742
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Z195aCfuRSU

>>382384492
Harry canonically dies during the normal course of SH3, not in any of the endings. He's even canonically dead in Silent Hill Memories.

Out of all the protagonists, he's the only one that is most definitely dead.

>>382373260
Max Payne 4 looks fucking weird.

>>382384337
>>382384492
>None of the endings are canon

Harry adopted and raised Heather so we know either the good or good+ endings to Silent Hill 1 are canon. I don't think they mention Cybil so it's still a tossup between the two.

>>382375586
Why Melia? Is a dead dad and no Shulk D really that bad? I'm right after the Mechonis coming alive and don't know if there's worse in store for her.

Why won't more guys play sh I just want to enjoy the aesthetics while sucking dick jfc

>>382382357
made me laugh

>>382385002
No Cybil isn't mentioned. She's not even mentioned in the notebook Heather gets after his death which is truly odd since even though the ending of SH1 is ambiguous she was still there for everything before.

File: Capture.png (22KB, 310x95px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 310x95px

>>382384082
Is that really suffering though?

fitting captcha

>>382371463
Definitely James. Dude ended up killing himself.

>>382371463
The norman reedus character. He was the only one in an actually scary environment.

>>382386543
>corridor with a ghost
>scary

Spotted the 12 years old.

>>382373260
I fucking hate about what they did to the series

File: 1494378295411.jpg (89KB, 680x621px) Image search: [Google]

89KB, 680x621px

>>382382742
>>382375328
Nope

File: 1470202925442.gif (590KB, 424x208px) Image search: [Google]

590KB, 424x208px

>>382384762

I wouldn't be surprised if this were the case, considering all the moving prevents her from getting to make friends and shit. And probably what time she does spend in schools, she's probably an outcast for being "weird".