SMG1>SMG2

Sunshine>>>>>>>>>

>>381067456
Sunshine is better than nothing? Glad we can agree on that

I didn't even know there was a second Galaxy

>>381067456
Sunshine is dogshit

>>381066572
Why?

>>381066572
>>>/kys/

>>381066572

Smg1 is only liked by people who wish they were still playing SM64

>>381066572

SM64>SMG1>Sunshine>SMG2>SM3DW/L

>>381066572
it's literally only because you played it first, anon.

I'm sure if you played 2 first you'd feel it far outshines the first

>>381067456
If sunshine didn't have Blue coins, it would be GOAT

Galaxy > 64 > Galaxy 2 >>>>>> 3D World >>> 3D Land >>> my dad's hairy taint >>>>>>> Sunshine

Is it weird to like 3D Land over 3D World

3D World definitely has more variety but 3D Land's single player focus appeals to me more and i love how you get to do another 8 worlds with either new levels entirely or altered levels

Better question

Try to predict where Super Mario Odyssey will stand within the 3D Mario's

I predict a similar BOTW issue where it sets itself on it's own level but others will be buttmad it isnt exactly like 64

>>381068884
Eh, to each their own. Personally, I vastly preferred the level design in 3D World. Also wasn't a fan of 3D Land's extra worlds.

>>381068094
>SMG2 literally has a SM64 level in it

>>381068265
>muh blue coins!!!!!
really shows how many /v/irgins today never played NES games to see what actual cryptic bullshit is like

name ONE blue coin that actually required a guide to get it and wasn't just you not checking the area properly

>>381071282

Define 'properly'. You mean shooting literally EVERYTHING with water?

There's a few in Noki Bay that have you shooting water at random walls to get them to appear.

I know bosses in Mario are usually shit but the final boss in Galaxy 1 was pretty epic. 2's bosses were so shit that it just sort of soured the game for me.

>>381072241
>random walls
you mean the brown bricks who clearly stand out?
ok

>>381072451

Not those, I mean those massive cliffside walls.

File: 1490003108045.jpg (49KB, 240x291px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 240x291px

Galaxy 1 gave us all the assets, all the music, all the creativity, all the story, the characters, the charm, the space ambience

Galaxy 2 gave us the same fucking shit, but amped the creativity in the levels. And swapped the space tone for wacky 3D World levels.

How can people give more credit to galaxy 2 is beyond me. It has great levels but it's not like it completely overshadows 1. 1 has way more going for it overall and leaves you with a satisfying mainline mario experience with a gigantic beginning and ending, while galaxy 2 feels like literal dlc

>>381072647
>while galaxy 2 feels like literal dlc
It IS literal DLC. It was supposed to be "More Galaxy" as an expansion pack for Galaxy 1. Too bad the Wii didn't have native DLC support and Miyamoto just had to be a fucking jew and be all "muh story in muh Mario" with Rosalina.

>>381066572
I agree
though 2 was far more challenging, 2 kinda took the soul out of galaxy and just added more power ups.

File: 1471018553313.jpg (95KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 640x480px

I liked both and neither left that strong of an impression on me to be honest.

>>381073096
it was still a full game at least.

>>381066572
I agree.

>>381068221
I played 2 first and I still think 1 is better.

File: 1494068762151.jpg (51KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 640x480px

Super Mario Galaxy > Super Mario 64 = Mario's Time Machine > Super Mario Galaxy 2 = 3D World > 3D Land > Sunshine

>>381072527
those have grooves in them that seemingly lead to nowhere
you should be able to tell that something isn't right with those walls

Beat Sunshine about a week ago, levels feel real shit in comparrisson to 64, G1 and G2

>>381072407
>2's bosses were so shit that it just sort of soured the game for me.
They kept recycling the same bowser fight, over and over again, I'm sure it was a homage to the original mario games, but that doesn't mean I have to like it.

File: 1471531819887.jpg (94KB, 600x510px) Image search: [Google]

94KB, 600x510px

>>381073702
I'm replaying it now and I'm finding the inverted camera obnoxious as shit. I didn't find it that annoying in 64 probably because you used it much more in Sunshine, with shooting and moving the camera so much more.

>>381072407
>first time fighting bowser in smg

Ill never forget how shocked I was that they made a plumber and a nemesis turtle fight seem so fucking grand. Even prior to the fight and cutscene i was fucking amped

>>381073096
New assets though, aside from Mario and Bowser and some enemies/toads all the levels were new.

>>381066572

SMG2 generally had better level design, but it lacked the atmosphere of the first game and the settings were cooler in SMG 1. I also dislike how much mini-game shit SMG2 had.
SMG2 is basically like a traditional Mario game but with space an excuse to use wacky and creative ideas.

File: 28256757.png (115KB, 636x440px) Image search: [Google]

115KB, 636x440px

>>381068221

>>381074126
>all the levels were new
>literal copy+paste of 64 level
>literal copy+paste of the Beach Bowl cyclone planet
>copy+paste of Sunshine level
>galaxy 1 boss rush
Yeah fuck off anon

>>381074343
>copy+paste of 64 level
If you're actually interested in how making games works I can explain to you why that's not true.

If you don't care and just want to shitpost I can understand that too.

Smg2 is the best platformer of all time. Smg is a no skill collectathon. I thought this was common knowledge?

>>381074498
Both games are about the same difficulty.

>that level in SMG2 set in an underwater cave and when you got out music stopped playing and you only heard the breeze on white flowers

File: 1478411866530.gif (3MB, 200x180px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 200x180px

lets be honest all mainline mario games are fucking ace

if you haven't 100% them all you're just a fucking fruit

>>381066572
I feel you pham. there is literally no fucking story or emotion in 2, it's a fucking joke.

>You will never experience these for the first time again
>First time hearing Gusty Garden music
>The final Bowser battle
>tfw Galaxy 2 trailer
>Cried when Yoshi appeared

File: toadstool.jpg (54KB, 727x681px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 727x681px

>>381068094
Shit son you got me there

>>381076836
>gusty garden
>the entire galaxy soundtrack
>nintendo music in general
why are they the only company that gets this right consistently?