http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1393699
>Do you agree?
1. Super Mario Galaxy - 260, 9 Honorable Mentions
2. The Last of Us - 220, 15 Honorable Mentions
3. Dark Souls - 216, 7 Honorable Mentions
4. Super Mario Galaxy 2 - 167, 9 Honorable Mentions
5. Demon's Souls - 139, 9 Honorable Mentions
6. Mass Effect 2 - 138, 16 Honorable Mentions
7. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves - 132, 28 Honorable Mentions
8. Red Dead Redemption - 108, 17 Honorable Mentions
9. Mass Effect - 98, 7 Honorable Mentions
10. Bayonetta - 94, 12 Honorable Mentions
11. Portal 2 - 92, 17 Honorable Mentions
12. Bioshock - 86, 17 Honorable Mentions
13. Xenoblade Chronicles - 83, 8 Honorable Mentions
14. Halo 3 - 63, 11 Honorable Mentions
15. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots - 62, 11 Honorable Mentions
16. Fallout: New Vegas - 61, 12 Honorable Mentions
17. Portal - 60, 17 Honorable Mentions
18. Batman: Arkham Asylum - 55, 18 Honorable Mentions
19. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - 55, 11 Honorable Mentions
20. Journey - 53, 18 Honorable Mentions
21. Grand Theft Auto V - 51, 15 Honorable Mentions
22. Valkyria Chronicles - 48, 12 Honorable Mentions
23. Fallout 3 - 44, 5 Honorable Mentions
24. 999: Nine Persons, Nine Hours, Nine Doors - 43, 8 Honorable Mentions
25. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess - 40, 10 Honorable Mentions
26. Mirror's Edge - 39, 10 Honorable Mentions
27. NieR - 36, 8 Honorable Mentions
28. Dragon's Dogma (OG 20, 2HM | DA 16 1HM) - 36, 3 Honorable Mentions
29. Wipeout HD (HD – 29, 8 HM, Fury – 6 , 2 HM) - 35, 10 Honorable Mentions
30. The World Ends with You - 35, 6 Honorable Mentions
31. Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney - 34, 7 Honorable Mentions
32. Dead Space - 33, 11 Honorable Mentions
33. The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword - 33, 9 Honorable Mentions
34. Team Fortress 2 - 33, 4 Honorable Mentions
35. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare - 32, 16 Honorable Mentions
>>380991109
>movie game
>two souls games in a row
stopped reading. How does THIS make you feel OP?
>>380991109
>The Last of Us
>game
>>380991256
Dark Souls is a good game you contrarian fag
>>380991109
Dark Souls is way too high, latter part of the game is bad. Halo 3, even if people shitpost about it a lot, is one of the best games on the list. RDR is way too high. As is Bioshock and Journey and Skyrim. And who the fuck voted for Mass Effect 2?
>Galaxies at 1 and 4
Surprising. Seems like it's too gamey/ story lite for their sensibilities.
>>380991361
I don't like dark souls, and souls is the biggest meme genre of the past decade. Does it sting?
>>380991536
Galaxy is perfect for casuals.
>>380991615
it would sting if the former wasn't so obviously a direct result of the latter
>>380991109
I think it's reasonable, although I don't like modern Naughty Dog games at all.
Also I would've put Gears of War on there somewhere, because that was the most defining game of the generation.
>NeoGAF
>>380991536
The fuck are you talking about? GAF are total weebs.
>>380991109
I've never played Super Mario Galaxy 2. I have a Wii U and apparently it's out on Wii U. I don't really want to have to try to find my Wiimote though. Worth it, /v/?
>>380992786
I dunno.
Is one of the best games ever made worth it?
hmmm such a very hard decision.
>>380991109
WHO CARES
>>380991109
TLOU is far too high. Halo 3 is too low. Pretty meh list honestly aside from a few selections like Valkyria Chronicles, TWEWY, Mirror's Edge, and 999 which are admittedly very nice picks.
>>380992786
It's pretty good. Might as well look into it.
>>380991109
An alright list I guess all things considered.
Surprised Skyrim isn't higher, I figured is was just /v/ that enjoyed hating on it.
Bayonetta is higher than I expected it to be.
Valkyria Chronicles and The World Ends with You are 2 games I really didn't expect to see.
I've never used Neogaf so I'm not sure what I should have expected, but the list could have been worse.
>>380992226
>trump is fascism
Ironic desu, especially in the light of The Last Night debacle.