None of these games are bad games

I agree.

I disagree.

I also agree. Some of them might be weaker than others but none of them are outright horrible

The ones that have been released most certainly are bad, 64 chief among them. The ones that haven't been released will almost certainly be bad.

Mario doesn't work in 3D. Same as Zelda, same as Metroid.

>>380881824
Agreed, but 3D World is the worst of the lot.

File: hmm.jpg (178KB, 1024x1024px) Image search: [Google]

178KB, 1024x1024px

>>380881824
You are right.

>>380881978
No 3D land is worse.

>>380881824
You can't say that about Odyssey yet.

>>380881824
Corrext

File: wizard.png (400KB, 661x462px) Image search: [Google]

400KB, 661x462px

>>380881824
They're not bad, but they're not great.

>>380881978
I havent played 3D Land, but I have played quite a bit of World and really enjoyed it. Is Land really better?

>>380881960
Is this that one post near the top of a thread that will get a lot of (you)s

I agree. But some are better than others.

>>380882057
not OP, but yes we can.

>>380882056
I enjoyed 3d land to completion
3d world has a shit cat gimmick that all the levels are based around

File: murder.gif (3MB, 300x236px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 300x236px

>>380881824
3D World is

>>380881824
You're right, yet people still complain about how newer games aren't exactly the same as the last titles

File: 2d63be910f13be9893e6a83a36a7e702.jpg (20KB, 350x480px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 350x480px

>>380881824
I left nintendo consoles after the N64.
Got Super Mario 3d World because it looked interesting..
It is fine....
But it isnt anything special as I wanted it to be.
Kind of dissapointed on it.

>>380882057
I'm fairly confident I can to be perfectly honest.

>>380882204
Most complaints either go to 3D World, Sunshine or Galaxy 2 it seems

>>380882185
I wouldnt say that. Unless you are going for 100% in which case a lot of the stamps and stars really are based around it

File: 1457885062908.jpg (18KB, 285x298px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 285x298px

>>380882057

3DW has multiplayer so it beats out 3DL.

I had a blast playing 3D World, even more with friends. Much better than 3D Land, but it's still good

64 will always be my favorite, and I always preferred the 64/Sunshine style of levels, Galaxy 1 and 2 were close enough to satisfy my craving, 3D Land and World were not what I was looking for but still a ton of fun, Odyssey is returning to what I always wanted and I'm very happy about that.

File: 44293988_p0_master1200.jpg (284KB, 827x1168px) Image search: [Google]

284KB, 827x1168px

None of them are bad, but some aren't that great. And by some I mean Super Mario 3D World and 3D Land

>>380881824
I agree though 3d land and 3d world are kind of their own thing
I'm actually playing through SM64DS right now, 60 stars in and I'm really enjoying it. the circle pad actually does make the game better. I was a bit surprised honestly

>>380881960
>Mario doesn't work in 3D.

Why not?

File: 1480198936796.jpg (42KB, 640x301px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 640x301px

>can't invert the shooting controls or camera in sunshine

>>380881824
3D land and 64 and definitely subpar

3D world is better than 3D land

The 3D sub-series is not fun.

>>380881824
Your story checks out, probably. Odyssey isn't out yet.

>>380881824
Sunshine was bad but had some neat ideas. 3D Land and 3D World were so mediocre that they were completely forgettable.

File: 1496388224753.png (51KB, 599x338px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 599x338px

>>380881824
But are any of them good?

Sunshine is garbage.

Galaxy 2 is one of the best games ever made.

>>380883658
All of them at varying degrees.

File: .jpg (42KB, 600x653px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 600x653px

>>380883658

Ever notice that whenever anyone tries to complain about Sunshine, all their complaints amount to them just being bad at Mario games?

>>380883163
It really does honestly. I was gonna replay 64 but decided to play DS instead once I got it working on my 3DS

>>380883397
You just have bad taste. They may be different but they are still very well crafted games

>>380883636
and you are mixing things up. The high quality of the rest of the series may make 3D Land mediocre in comparison, but in the end the game is still really good. World is great and you're just a fucking pleb about that

>>380883732
only v

They really aren't, but when people are so fervent about discussing which one's the best, they forget that all of them are good. The same is true for every 3D Zelda game.

>>380883732
fuck you i replayed sunshine for the first time since i was 9 and i loved it

64 should be put on a class of his own to be honest, levels are open but the mechanics are completely different from Sunshine or Odyssey.

>>380884001
Blue coin collecting sucked

>>380881824
I agree but Sunshine is by far the worst of the bunch, easily worse than 3D Land and World.

>>380884295
Your "win" button is in the mail.

>>380884127
While I agree with you, I cant deny I really dont like TP all that much. I'd say its easier to call all 3D mario good than all 3D Zelda, though in the end no game in either franchise is really bad. Even the worst 2D mario (NSMB2) is a 7/10 at worst

>>380884308
Why does it matter?

>>380881824
U R MR GAY

huh???

>>380884054
The 3D sub-series is essentially 2D Mario without the quality.

>>380881824

3D Land and 3D World are nothing compared to the old school 2D Mario games, not worth the hype.

Galaxy 2 > Odyssey (probably) > Galaxy > Sunshine > 3D world > 64 > 3D Land

>>380881824
None of these games are good games

>>380884497
>64 that low

Really nigga? Otherwise I agree.

>>380881960

>Mario doesn't work in 3D. Same as Zelda, same as Metroid.

Millions of people disagree with your faggot-ass opinion

>>380881824
mario 3d has really shitt controls, run button is terrible for 3d

>>380884578
He's right about Metroid though, Other M sucked balls.

>>380881824
Doesn't change the fact that it's getting stale and mario is boring as fuck.

>>380884441

Yo, >>380884448 here, just thought I'd let you know you have impeccable tastes and opinions.

>>380884679
>ignoring Metroid Prime just for fun
kys

>>380881824

What about Super Mario 64

YOU MOVED WITH THE FUCKING DPAD

and no you can't use the 3DS circle pad argument because that came out YEARS after the actual game

>>380884704
Literally the only one remotely stale in the image is 3D Land. But this is bait anyways

>>380884646
it's a 2D game

>>380884497
Galaxy 2 > Galaxy > Odyssey (likely) > 3D World > Sunshine > 3D Land > 64

>>380884782
Don't be retarded, Prime isn't just Metroid in 3D, it's a completely different kind of game, it's the same as saying Paper Mario is a 3D Mario.

>>380881824
Maybe not but the left ones are vastly superior and the rest are watered down versions.

>>380884441
Exactly this

>>380881824
3D World and 64 are meh, but yah theyre not bad

>>380881960
I hate how sequilitis is brainwashing you toddlers.

File: armstrong-louis-5484a52fc2b51.jpg (560KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

560KB, 1000x1000px

>>380884804
>Underage doesn't know that he played a port
Jesus, I'm getting old

>>380884448
>>380884497
But that's not true. In fact, I'd say old 2D mario is very good, but also overrated. No 2D Mario before World can compare to anything World and onwards

File: 3371.jpg (23KB, 360x270px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 360x270px

>>380884804
>not using the included thumbpad for precise analog movement
LOL

>>380884892
Happy 18th birthday

>>380884992
>64
>meh
you're too young for this board

>>380881824
>Judging a game that isn't even out yet

I think it will be good too, but come on.

>>380884921

>Don't be retarded, Prime isn't just Metroid in 3D

The only retard here is you.

>it's the same as saying Paper Mario is a 3D Mario.

People say Paper Mario is/was a turn-based RPG you fucking mongoloid.

>>380885236
Not OP but it's fair to say it'll be good when every 3D Mario that came before it are good, this is called common sense.

>>380885218
24 is too young for 4chan now?

>>380884860
no

>>380881824
maybe, but I dont like most of them

They are all well designed games. Personal taste and bias need bot apply.

I liked 3D Land more then World, but it could be because I felt more comfortable playing it.

>>380883732
played sunshine for the first time last year (I did play the demo as a kid but that's a far cry from 100% completion)
while I don't care for the way the game handles blue coins and I did miss the more varied courses from SM64 it's still a really good game, and FLUDD was a great new mechanic

>>380885359
idiot!

File: giphy.gif (480KB, 493x342px) Image search: [Google]

480KB, 493x342px

>>380884860
>it has a linear path so its 2d

>>380885436
correct

>>380881824
Can we at least all agree galaxy 2 is the best one?

>>380885532
no u

>>380885606
no, 64 is the best one

File: 1495832116892.jpg (15KB, 500x333px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 500x333px

>they switched the M and I colors
This annoys me more than it should

>>380885717
>64 better than Galaxy 2
Fucking notalgia fags get off this board.

>>380884892
Galaxy > Galaxy 2 > Odyssey (likely) > Sunshine > 64 > 3D World

I liked all the games.

3D Land = (never played)

>>380885840
Dude, this is 3D mario and all the games are really high quality. It is perfectly conceivable that one may like 64 the best, the same way one may like Majora's Mask the best. Especially when the games are specifically executed in different ways. Galaxy 2 is pretty much 3D World with a gravity mechanic

>>380885746
i will never unsee it

>>380885746
The M really should be red. They goofed by making it blue in the first place.

>>380884497
64 > Galaxy > Galaxy 2 > Sunshine > 3D World > 3D Land

Odyssey will likely be between the two Galaxies.

File: 1410073216068.jpg (75KB, 827x755px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 827x755px

>Mfw love my WiiU and 3D World is one of the favorites on the console
>Playing 3D Mario with friends, jumping off of each other and shit
>Motherfucking cat suit, tanooki, boomerang, box helmets, fire flower, top tier powerups
>Actual platforming instead of running around a playground, which was done better by Rare during the 5th gen anyway and never Sunhshine never surpassed the bear and bird
>/v/ is mad as fuck about it and it can't stop me from enjoying myself

File: Rosalina_(Mario_Kart_8)_reduced.png (3MB, 2150x2164px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2150x2164px

I hope Odyssey has some Galaxy style levels with gravity effects. That's kinda what it takes to compete with Galaxy now.

64 is still one of the best games I've ever played. I fucking love it.

>>380886889
i know right, any ome who doesn't love 64 i don't believe is human

>>380881824
yes

Dear Diary: Today, OP was not a faggot.

>>380886227
this. 3D World is amazing and /v/ only hates it because it isnt Galaxy or 64

>>380884804
Are you talking about Super Mario 64 DS and not the original?

>>380881824
Why are the A and R in the Mario titles the same colors in the titles but not everything else?

>>380886227
Funny how actual platforming means simply running and jumping to this board. You kids would have had a blast during the early 90s when 3D platformers were just that.

>>380886712
Not really, it just has to have good levels

>>380888037
using a relatively simple set of controls and applying it to a wide variety of levels is indeed exactly what platforming is about

File: 1441236507413.gif (84KB, 253x230px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 253x230px

I'm extremely glad we're getting a 3D exploration game in the style of 64 again, but let's be honest.

Galaxy 2 = Galaxy => 64 >>>>>> (power gap) > 3D World > 3D Land > Sunshine

Not even kidding. I don't understand the boner people have for Sunshine. A large chunk of the Shines are blue coin pixel hunts, another large chunk is the vast amount of unfun "THAT FUCKING LEVEL" compared to other Mario games (Pachinko, Lily Pads, Watermelons, I'm a Chuckster, Red Coins Fish etc.), and a lot of the remaining ones are pointless non-platforming fetch quests like help all the Sunflowers on the beach.

It's ironic that people who like Sunshine call the Secret Levels the best part of the game, while Galaxy 1/2 and to a greater extent 3D Land/World are basically entirely composed of those levels.

File: 1362240881027.jpg (132KB, 965x1305px) Image search: [Google]

132KB, 965x1305px

>>380888423
>ANY powergap in 3d Mario.
You're retarded. They're all fun for different reasons. And all great games.

>>380888227
>using a relatively simple set of controls
>is indeed exactly what platforming is about
For you loud depth impaired cunts.

>>380888423
there is no powergap. You are right otherwise

>>380883732
While I wouldn't call Sunshine 'garbage', I definitely consider it the weakest of the games OP posted. I feel like it's a difficult game for all the wrong reasons, like I'm constantly fighting controls or the entire situation itself is fucking stupid like the pachinko machine or the leaf on the toxic river. In a series that's all about controls, I feel like Sunshine has the poorest.

And yes, Galaxy 2 is near perfection. The only real downsides were the motion controlled sections, and even those actually ended up fun, if not quite on part with the rest of the amazing levels.

>>380888620
They're all fantastic games and are powergaps ahead of your average AAA game already. It's just that 64, Galaxy and Galaxy 2 are so utterly godlike and masterful in their design that they're in a league of their own.

>>380886074
Who the fuck puts Galaxy 1 over Galaxy 2? Galaxy 2 took everything Galaxy did and made it better. No more horribly long intro, no more boring hub, way better level design, way better challenge.

>>380889017
Some people have a real hard on for hub worlds I guess?

>Odyssey
>a game that isn't even out yet

I didn't like the galaxy's

>>380888423
I mostly agree with you.
I admit I have a boner for sunshine aesthetics.
It's probably the only thing it got over the others.

Galaxy 1 and 2 were always my top favourite. I skipped 3D Land and World, I never really got the same feeling as I did with the other 3D entries. That said, Odyssey is looking like the 3D Mario I've wanted for so many years now. Best timeline

File: goodsonicgames.png (4MB, 2000x1800px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 2000x1800px

None of THESE games are bad games

>>380881824
Odyssey looks like a mash between Sunshine and 3D World.
It will be shit or 5/10 at best.

For me, 3D Land/World is like the Banjo: Nuts & Bolts of the Mario series.
They're not bad games, but they're not good Mario games either.

>>380890703
it will be a 10/10 screencap this

>>380890703

You never had a chance.

File: 7c9b03d033a74176fd88bd99864ab7d728a3e3502ed83f1f848348ef6d1afd8f.jpg (31KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 300x300px

>>380890556
I am so anxious about this.
Everything about it seems great until now, but so much shit happened in 20 years.

File: 1485750821045.png (527KB, 678x417px) Image search: [Google]

527KB, 678x417px

>>380884804
>YOU MOVED WITH THE FUCKING DPAD

>>380890556
no CD?

>>380881824
Now we need Galaxy 3 and a 3rd 3D-X game so we can have a literal 3x3 of these games.

>>380890370
I find the aesthetics inconsistent. First, you have the main areas, Delfino Plaza, Ricco Harbor, Noki Bay, etc. They do they're best to make these parts of the game very detailed, as well as interconnected. For example, if you're on the beach in Pinna Park you can see Ricco Harbor off in the distance. They want Delfino Island to feel real and like you're actually on vacation.

Then you have the secret parts of the game. Where you're jumping on floating wooden blocks in an empty skybox with NES Sprites in the background. They don't make sense and you couldn't locate them on a map. Both of these ideas are totally fine, but thematically they might as well be seperate games. I'm positive that if the dev team didn't run out of time the secret parts wouldn't have been in the game because they contradict what they were trying to go for in the first place.

>>380890720
The way I see 3D world is like this

Super Mario World: Reinterpreted in 3D

Not really as much of a new installment in the 3D lineup

>>380881824
3D world was butt

File: goodsonicgames.jpg (1MB, 2000x1600px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2000x1600px

>>380891384
fuck, can't believe i forgot about CD

>>380881960
Imagine being this asshurt.

>>380889017
Galaxy 2 didn't have as many large levels as 1 and while 2 did improve on some aspects of 1 it felt a lot less grand from music to layouts to atmosphere

>>380884578
U mad bro?

>>380885164
>this is 13 years old

H-hold me bros

>>380892486
Ah.. the brick

>>380881824
i really wanted to like galexy but i just cant get into the wii remote control.

sunshine is my favoritte.

>>380892585
Man I was so hyped opening that thing up on Christmas morning. Playing that hella comfy metroid prime hunters demo, calling my body to verbally shitpost about Mario 64 ds. Those were good days

;_;

>>380892309
>No Advanced 1 or Rush
At least Advanced 1

>>380892779
*buddy

>>380891868
I'd say an 8/10 is the lowest it culd be

>>380881824
Okay, but Sunshine is the worst.

Galaxy > Sunshine > 3D World > 64 > Galaxy 2 > 3D Land

Galaxy 2 was underwhelming as fuck, gameplay was great but thematically it pales compared to the first one. Especially the final boss and ending.

>>380894552
>3D World > 64
rethink your life

>>380894907
>the bad control and map design is okay because nostalgia

t. anyone who thinks 64 is acceptable by modern standards.

>>380895426
>he thinks the controls and map design are bad
Ok kiddo

File: hqdefault.jpg (16KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 480x360px

Ur Mr gay lmao xD

Mario 64 is probably the best game here. I have not played Odyssey yet so im not sure how good that is. It look fucking great at E3 though.

>>380895426
>the bad control and map design
Just further proof 3D World is favored by those who can't grasp 3D platformers.

>>380881824
3d land and 3d world were mediocre. Everything else on that list is fantastic, probably including Odyssey though it does look a bit like a sequel to 3d world

>>380881824

3, arguably 4 of those are.

>>380895553
It's not a bad game. It's still fun despite that, it's just those parts haven't aged well.

Despite it's flaws it's still better than sunshine and galaxy 2.

It's just like OoT for Zelda, it hasn't aged well but that doesn't make it suddenly bad. It's still better than most other Zelda games.

>>380894907
desu people who rage whever 3D World is high on someone's list are the people who think the first games should always be near the top on principle. Like Pokemon fans.

This is why nobody should take the opinion of a NintenDrone seriously. The new Mario game isn't out yet and yet they say is at least an 8/10.

I hate Super Mario Sunshine!

>>380891384
cd is pretty bad

>>380896495

3D world is flawed at it's core lmao

>>380897312

>CD
>Bad

>>380897590
yes, that's what i said

cd is a bad game

>>380890085
This. So overrated and a watered down 3D Mario.

There are many people who unironically call them the best games ever made.

File: Not Liking SM3DW.png (65KB, 253x238px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 253x238px

>>380881824
I agree. And 3D World gets shit on more than it deserves. Fuck the haters, it's a ton of fucking fun with a friend.

>>380881824
No mainline Mario game is bad.

Sunshine is just weak, but far from being bad.

File: 1482203000608.jpg (14KB, 221x246px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 221x246px

>>380892486
The time between SM64DS and now is longer than the time between SM64 and SM64DS

>>380881960
is this the new contrarian opinion or something?

what kind of an idiot honestly believes that

>>380897679

And why might you think this my fellow anon?

>>380884441
This

>play Odyssey
>any enemy that even remotely approaches me, I just throw my hat at it and resume play as the enemy
>no way to take damage whatsoever
>get to Bowser, throw my hat at him
>jump his body into a spike pit and then unpossess him as he falls in
ZERO FUCKING CHALLENGE
this game was shit, I want my money back
I can't believe we waited all this time for this

File: 1486225713769.jpg (20KB, 570x479px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 570x479px

Why cant they just make a Super Mariog 3D game with out a stupid gimmick and just make it hard platformer like Mario 64.

I know 64 had the flying cap ect. but it dint take away from the game and revolve around it

>>380884921
Prime is literally super metroid in 3D

and it's fucking amazing

>>380897813
levels are way too big, too long, designed in such a way that it makes it difficult to use the time travel gimmick

every level feels like a slog like marble zone

>>380881886
>>380881940
I may agree

>>380898081
(you)

>>380881978
Don't parrot Dunkey.

3D World takes every concept 3D Land introduces and makes it bigger with better level design. The only thing missing are le epic 3D puzzle rooms.

3D Land is fine for what it is, a handheld Mario, but it's certainly not better than World.

>>380882121
this movie was great

>a new game!

>>380881824
I didn't like how in Galaxy it felt as if you stopped for a split second when you jumped

File: boss_draygon.gif (24KB, 512x446px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 512x446px

>>380898154
Don't you ever insult Prime like that again.
Super is fucking garbage for one reason, pic related.
Prime never resorts to such trash.

>>380898508
>get grabbed
>grapple beam the electric spot

what's it like never experimenting with anything?

Here's your >>380881960

>>380898685
wait
WHAT

>>380884892
Galaxy > Odyssey (probably) > 64 > Galaxy 2 > 3D Land > 3D World > Sunshine

>>380898101
World didn't have a gimmick and everyone shits on it.

>>380881960

I tip my fedora to our intelectual superiority good sir.

>>380899112
You're a gimmick

>>380898101
>3D game
>hard platformer like Mario 64

That's what it's shaping up to be.

>with out a stupid gimmick
But Super Mario 64 has a gimmick you idiot. In fact it also has a cap gimmick.

>>380899829
You didn't even read my post you fucking moron

>>380881824
>3D land
I can admit that its a marvel for the 3ds but it got old so fast especially with you playing the entire game over again in the special worlds

>>380898870
>shoot things on wall
>get hit by sticky stuff
>get grabbed
>get hit a few times as Draygon moves further and further to the left and right
>grapple the electrical spot you broke open
>electricity passes through Samus and fucks up Draygon
>dead

>>380881886
>>380881940
>>380898169
Can you repeat the statement?

>>380899112
World isn't an exploration game, it's not in the same vein as 64. In 64 you enter a course and complete objectives in every direction. In World you enter a course and move largely in one direction.

That said, I still like 3D World.

>>380900008
>have to play the entire game with mario and luigi/get all medals/all gold flags just to get the final level

File: no.jpg (34KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 600x600px

>>380888423
>muh jumping from planet to planet with waggleshit

>>380899917
Literally all you said was "b-b-but 64's gimmick wasn't that bad!"

Both games are 3D platformers with a gimmick, you're just choosing to forgive one gimmick for no reason. You're fucking retarded.

>>380882121

>SUPER MARIO BROTHERS, THREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>>380899112
it's a bland game. not outright bad, just forgettable

>>380881824
sometimes the gameplay, level design of a game can be good, fantastic even, but the tone/atmosphere set by the game can be so terrible to make it unplayable for me. All mario games since super mario 64 make me feel like I'm watching teletubbies, and are unplayable for that reason. I can't fucking listen to my character go wahoo. I'm a grown man

>>380881824
3d world was too gimmicky and overall lacking but you're not wrong

>>380895426
Okay while those things are bad it was a legitimately good game back then

>>380898159
I personally enjoy that because I like longer and difficult games, and u get what you're saying but you come off as a shitty player.

>>380881978
Anyone who thinks Sunshine is better than 3D World is a delusional nostalgiafag.

>>380884921
>Metroid 2D and Metroid Prime aren't the same kind of game

Oh but the balls-to-the-wall action game that is Other M surely is, right ?

Are you mentaly challenged?

>>380881960
have my fucking reply you piece of shit

>>380898081
I agree, Odyssey looks like it's gonna be too easy in the pursuit of encouraging exploration. I wish it didn't have the hate mechanic, I wish it could punch and walk around the levels like in 64, I wish I didn't have to use motion controls.

There's never been a bad mainline Mario game. When I mean bad, I mean bug riddened with horrible controls and glitchly gameplay. All Mario games are decent. Most people argue about the gameplay style.

>>380899829

>Optional Power ups that weren't even needed for over half the game is the same as a gimmick that you will be needing to use all game

>>380901164
I'd rather have a different game than the same game, thanks

>>380901196
>I know exactly how odyssey is going to play

>>380897590
>lmao
you are even boastful with your delusion

>>380898081
Isnt your health only 3 hits now?

Then again it's just two/one in 3D World

>>380901497

From what we've seen, it's fairly obvious.

>Use cap to possess X to solve X that it would be impossible to solve without

Every single level they showed, they also showed a required puzzle using the cap possession.

>>380901586

Because it's true.

>>380881824
>None of these games are bad games
>Posts an unreleased game
Quality

>>380901805
>Have new idea
>Don't show it off

yeah that sounds likely

>>380902119

>show how forced your gimmick is all through out the game

Very likely.

>>380881824
True.
Sunshine is still the worst one

>>380900184
>Literally all you said was "b-b-but 64's gimmick wasn't that bad!"
You're a moron

>>380902247
t. no rebuttal

sorry m8 better luck next time

>>380901386
So new levels and powers(meaning mushrooms, suits etc) don't make it a new game? I just wanted a new Mario with 64(size exploration) like levels with traditional controls not a waggle gimmick that makes the game harder if I don't use it, which I can't if I play in handheld mode.

Galaxy > Galaxy 2 = Sunshine > 3D World > 64 > 3D Land

>>380881824
64 > Sunshine > Galaxy > 3DWorld

I never played galaxy 2 or land

>>380901805
In the treehouse demo they possess an enemy with the cap only a few times, it's no worse than if the possession cap was found in an exclamation mark box like the wing/metal/vanish caps.

The amount that you use it seems a lot closer to SM64's cap gimmick than to SMS's FLUDD gimmick.

>>380900184
Here's the reason, you didn't have to use the cap gimmick that often in fact it was a central game mechanic, the cap in Odessey is used for simple combat and is a central gameplay mechanic. One(64 cap gimmick) is non-consequential and the other is a hindrance (Odyssey cap gimmick)

>>380903239
*wasn't

Sunshine >= 64 > Galaxy 2 >=Galaxy > 3D World > 3D Land

Prove me wrong.
Pro tip: You Can't

>>380900418
This triggers the nintoddIer

>>380882138
>Is Land really better?
No. World is Land's formula but better.

Land is the least great game in OPs pic. It's uninteresting visually, has much simpler and easier levels and probably the least content of any game in OPs pic.

It's by no means bad, but it doesn't stand up to the other games in OP pic and its formula was done in a much more interesting way in 3D World.

>>380903519
Huh, you know, i agree with you. I still love every game tho.

>>380903519
>greater than or equal to
what? pick one or the other nigger

>>380903729
Land was easy as hell, too

>>380881824
>3D World
FUCK YOU YOU PIECE OF SHIT SUBHUMAN YOU ARE THE REASON I CANT TRUST PEOPLES OPINIONS ON NINTENDO GAMES

I remember starting 3D World and just having a good time. There was nothing obstructive or pointless, just a game that was clearly made with having fun in mind.

>>380903729
Nah, Land was better simply because it was simple and it was essientally the best model for the modern Mario aesthetic that lasted from the Wii era to now. It was simple, short and fun nothing more and nothing less and that's what I like in a DS Mario game

File: Mario_NSMB2.png (3MB, 2216x2842px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2216x2842px

What is there left for Mario to jump into? It seem they're running out of setting/gimmick for the italian plumber to jump onto.

>>380881978
It's objectively better than 3D Land, it's got more power ups, more playable characters, a ton more levels, and those levels are a lot more varied, too. The issue is that 3D Land did it's best for the hardware it was developed for, and 3D World unneccessarily took on all its limitations. It's a better game but it could have been so much more.

>>380904985
One thing I really liked about 3D World is the overworld

File: .png (657KB, 1024x1163px) Image search: [Google]

657KB, 1024x1163px

>>380904793
Mario action rpg. Mushroom's Souls.

>>380905487
I like how whoever made this clearly gave up after the shield.

File: 1478561765256.png (53KB, 256x256px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 256x256px

>>380904793
Mario game set in Italy.

File: fat jew fuck that cant count to 3.jpg (20KB, 480x480px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 480x480px

>>380905990
These things... they take time.

>>380881960
>le 8-bit /16-bit faggot

Probably some usual 80s born faggot with their usual spoiled superioty complex. Don't you have a will to write old fuck?

File: 3DWorld.webm (3MB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 640x360px

>>380881978
>>380883397
>>380884441
>>380884961
>>380885885
>>380888423
>>380890720
>3D World
>Bad
(You)

>>380907814
Never said it was bad, only that the others are better. Something had to be at the end of the list, and it is the one that is the least interesting. It's very tidy and well polished, but also somewhat safe and unadventurous.

>>380900041
You skipped "I don't know". It goes "yes, no maybe, I don't know, can you repeat the question" and you skipped "I don't know."

>>380908376
Personally I liked 3D world for being simple and fun in all the right ways.

It could have taken more chances but it really didn't need to. Mario has a way of making even stale formulas feel fresh.

>>380908637
You're not the boss of me now.

>>380881824
Super Mario 64 is a bad game.

>>380885016

Why? Arin did some prety brud videos back in the day

File: baitisobvious2.gif (29KB, 131x131px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 131x131px

>>380908932

>>380907814
Was that webm supposed to be impressive?

>>380909089
It aged like spoiled milk.

File: Inkling.jpg (78KB, 775x525px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 775x525px

>>380907814
>That spinning jump
You can do that?!

File: IMG_0072.jpg (29KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 480x360px

>>380900041
>That's me. Mario.

>>380909330
it may be pretty much an inferior version of Galaxy, but it's undeniably one of the most groundbreaking games ever made and I still find it fun

speedruns of it are unironically entertaining

File: Watermelon-gelato-8.webm (3MB, 520x360px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 520x360px

>>380909272
Do you find this impressive?

>>380881824
personally I don't like galaxy

>>380909761
I hate whoever did this.

File: daily reminder.jpg (20KB, 330x197px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 330x197px

you have been reminded

>>380909761
fuck that level man

>>380909761
sure

>>380909761
This is actually kind of impressive, yes

>>380881824
Maybe not, but Sunshine is the least good of the lot. It's certainly the only Mario game I've ever sold.

>>380881886
/thread

>>380884804
Underage?

Left lane underrated and objectively the best of the three.
Mid lane overrated with perfect scores and while good, don't live up to the hype.
Right lane one drastically underwhelming game and one pleasant HD surprise though both lack proper movement and camera controls that make the left lane so great.

>>380884804
>d-pad

I was sitting here trying to understand what he meant by this but damn if you didn't just out yourself.

>>380911559
I'm not sure this is a popular opinion. I love Sunshine, and I think it ranks in the tops as far as Mario games.

>People get mad here when you hate on a game before it comes out.

>No one gets mad that Odyssey is on there and people are saying they like it before they even play it.

>>380911559
What the actual fuck.

>best atmosphere
>tightest controls
>best music

>>380881824
On the contrary, that is literally the holy trinity of bad games.

>>380912838
i found the contrarian guys!

>>380912716
>Sunshine
>Best music
This song alone proves you wrong.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VEIWhy-urqM

>>380912647
Do you honestly, legitimately, think that there is any way it will be bad?

>>380913061
>>380912716
This song blows the both of you out of the fucking water
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ELbrDrnTsrM

File: Super_Mario_Odyssey_Dance.gif (2MB, 446x324px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 446x324px

>>380913294
Not even the best song from Odyssey.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAfzpGpERUw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VU74P0wX-iE

>>380912716
yeah, those don't necesarily make games good, speciallyplatformers.

>>380881824
3D World has a goat ost

>>380912716
Beat Block Highway

Galaxy has a LOT of waggle shit in it.

File: rftUSdP.gif (1MB, 258x191px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 258x191px

>>380913494
OH THAT WOODED KINGDOM MUSIC

File: 1482061100939.png (133KB, 330x248px) Image search: [Google]

133KB, 330x248px

>>380881824
>3D Land
>3D World
>good

Ok I'll be fair, they aren't Sunshine.

>>380913543
Tight controls and level design aka atmosphere are basically the 2 single things that make up a platforming game.

File: super-mario-sunshine-lily-pad.jpg (15KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 480x360px

>>380914813
>Sunshine
>Good level design

>>380913294
Obviously, that song is the best thing Nintendo has ever done but in terms of released games, errybody knows Sunshine got the best themes, aight?

File: 1494362504598.jpg (13KB, 398x381px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 398x381px

>>380914813
>level design aka atmosphere

File: 1495763607394.jpg (23KB, 500x381px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 500x381px

>>380914813
>level design is equivalent to atmosphere

>>380914939
There is a bad level in every single Mario game. Get over it. Did you have a copy that only had that one warp pipe available to you?

>>380915032
The thing is, it takes forever to even get to that level, and if you fuck up you have to do it all over again.

File: 14059869921612.gif (2MB, 600x328px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 600x328px

>>380915032
>Sunshine only has one bad leve-

>>380914969
>>380915027
They're not mutually exclusive but the level design informs how good the atmosphere can be. You can't have one without the other or else it becomes a rhythm game.

File: 1397205504320.png (393KB, 477x627px) Image search: [Google]

393KB, 477x627px

>>380914939
>it's bad because it's hard

>>380915186
Professional video game tip from the pros:
You stand in front of them, idiot.

>>380915186
d-did he just murder Mario?

>>380881824
I remember Sunshine was somewhat Maligned at first, but people came to appreciate it more as the time went on

>>380915194
You're still wrong, but at this point you are saying a completely different thing than you said before

>>380915364
We were all busy having the perfect summer indoors playing the ultimate summerfeel game. Too busy to complain.

File: Pinna-8.jpg (54KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 1280x720px

>>380915320
>Sunshine only has one bad leve-

>Blue, green, yellow, red, green
What does it mean?

>>380915561
>>380915561
>pinna park is bad for one shine
nerd

>>380915675
number of letters

>>380915561
don't lie though, that cut scene leading into the boss fight was fucking awesome

>>380881824
i recall 3d land being medicore, but i played it after 3dworld so it might just be i played the superior version first

>>380912957
>not liking 3D mario games because I think they're too popular somehow makes me a contrarian
I swear to god /v/ doesn't even know how to use half the buzzwords they regurgitate.

>>380898081
>>get to Bowser, throw my hat at him
jokes on you, he wears a top hat, you cant control him

>>380881886
>>380881940
Why can't every /v/ thread be this civil?

>>380916074
>not liking 3D mario games because I think they're too popular
oh so you're a hipster?

>>380881824

3D Land was the first game I regret purchasing digitally. I paid $40 for it. I got roughly $10 worth of enjoyment playing through the entire game.

File: CyXevZ8WgAEZhub.jpg (93KB, 443x750px) Image search: [Google]

93KB, 443x750px

>>380909761
>Reminder that you can actually clip through the ceiling without doing any of that shit

>>380916718
>digital
>nintendo

I understand the appeal of digital but 1st party Nintendo games? A physical copy will either hold value for eternity or increase over time. Player's Choice is the only time those games get discounted.