What is the best western Silent Hill game?

>>380846685
Origins or Shattered Memories probably.

>>380846685
As much as twin perfect wrecked downpour, I still think it's the best of the bunch. It's the most engaging game of the western lot and it's also got a SOMEWHAT interesting story. Origins was a dumb game that was clearly not meant to be an SH game, homecoming is inspired by hostel, and shattered memories just doesn't have interesting gameplay, but it's a runner up for me.

They're all schlock better left unplayed in favor of more enlightening experiences.

>>380846809
>homecoming is inspired by hostel
What? Homecoming is LITERALLY Jacobs Ladder the video game. How the fuck is it anything like Hostel?

>>380847638
homecoming is torture porn

Shattered Memories>Homecoming>Origins>Downpour

>>380846809
Spot on my son. Murphy is quite interesting and the endings where very good. It's got it's problems don't get me wrong but it certainly deserves far less flack than it gets.

I played Downpour because I figured /v/ was just being dramatic

Its shit. Pure shit. Theres nothing good about it, there isnt a single interesting game mechanic, design or sound. Its shit, irredemeable shit.

Shattered Memories > Origins > Homecoming > Downpour