Which one is better?

They're both great, but blood borne is slightly better.

>>380690493
Bloodborne. DS3 is the most under contract game I think I have ever played in my life.

>>380690846
>>380690998
Da3 has more enemy and envrionment variety so it automatically wins.

File: 1493564108261.jpg (82KB, 706x674px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 706x674px

>>380691219
Bloodborne had more insight mechanics so it automatically wins. Dumbass.

File: bloodborne-old-hunters-750x422.png (657KB, 750x422px) Image search: [Google]

657KB, 750x422px

If you played them in order it's very clear Bloodborne is better, as DaS3 is just reused ideas and enemies from that game except clearly more rushed.

Bloodborne also has better art and is much more replayable.

>>380690846
Honestly this. Dark Souls 3 suffered from being even more unfair than Bloodborne and having a couple of terrible areas. But otherwise they're about even in being the most streamlined and overrated pieces of shit the souls franchise.

>>380691673
>and is much more replayable.
Strongly disagree. But then again, I played Dark Souls 3 first.

File: 1480563965603.png (48KB, 752x685px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 752x685px

>>380691889
Not him but I think your first souls game is the most replayable.

>>380691889
>more unfair

M8 what
In what way?
You can dodgeroll through anything with a trillion i-frames.

File: (laughter stops).png (23KB, 152x167px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 152x167px

>>380690493
Dark Souls 3 on the sole basis that it's fanbase didn't start saying "kino" in a video game board.

>>380691423
>Bloodborne had more insight mechanics so it automatically wins
Is that you DSP?

>>380690493
BB has a better campaign
DaS3 has better replay value

Bloodborne's online systems left a lot to be desired.

BB by a lot. DS3 couldn't even beat in it item descriptions despite being the third game in a series.

>>380692096
Ninja thralls and teleporting dogs. Pontiff guards with no startup frames. Fucking blue lothric knights(though they're not that bad if manage to get a hit in with a fast weapon, but of course I only play with fucking sords)

DaS3 is the New Super Mario Bros. 2 of the franchise, so probably Bloodborne

File: 1464988127920.jpg (57KB, 654x585px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 654x585px

>>380692232
i wish

>>380691889
>>380692287

How the fuck is DaS3 more replayable

>>380692473
Because you can play the worst early and mid game in Fromsoft history with 4 different playstyles instead of one of the best early and mid games in Fromsoft history with just 1.

>>380692473
Rolling out a build is a lot faster and every level not being an amalgam of brown bricks and graves woven together in hues of dark blue really helps

>>380692692
Early game dark Souls 3 is very inconsistent. Lothric is a great level, Undead Settlement is alright, Cathedral of the Deep is AMAZING but the Farron Swamp and Catacombs of Carthus suck dick.

>>380692708
I personally found Bloodborne more colorful, DaS3 was just very grey most of the time.

>>380692473
3 has way more build variety.

>>380693048
That's actually a filter they put on the game to make everything look like it's withered in ash for some reason

File: 1497164062708.jpg (58KB, 840x544px) Image search: [Google]

58KB, 840x544px

Dark Souls 2

I liked 3 more, but I'm a sucker for traditional fantasy settings. Also I don't understand the love for trick weapons. I carry 3 weapons in ds3 so I feel like I actually have more variety.

>only 1 blood rock in the entire main game
WHAT THE FUCK WHERE THEY THINKING

>>380693748
but you can get blood rocks from the insight shop

DS3 has more variety in weapons, builds, environments, and enemies. BB may be the better game, but I found DS3 to be more fun to play. Plus I love medieval fantasy settings. If only the weapons in that game had more fleshed out movesets and the amount of detail that BB had.

>>380692708
>>380693137

Except in Bloodborne you can have a functioning mono build right out the gate that isn't 90% quality

>>380693748
>Eat all my insight items
>Dump them in to random items because nothing cool ever pops up in this pool anyways
>Scroll to upgrade page
>See insight pool is selling them for 60
>3 insight left

It was a very bad feel indeed.

>>380691673
I played bb before ds3 and i can say i like ds3 more

>>380694061
Then you're a pleb

File: 1491505749996.png (131KB, 396x385px) Image search: [Google]

131KB, 396x385px

>>380693426
Here we go again.

>>380693932
>DS3 had more build variety
False, faith and sorcery are terrible options in DS3, maybe they improved them since the last time I played, which was when AoA dropped, but on release those builds were the equivalent of intentionally gimping yourself

>>380693878
Yeah, with 60 motherfucking insight

>>380693959
What. Pure STR and DEX are extremely viable in Dark Souls 3, so much so that 80 DEX and 66 STR builds are a thing.

>>380694192
>Pure STR and DEX are extremely viable in Dark Souls 3, so much so that 80 DEX and 66 STR builds are a thing.


Yeah, at the end of the game

Dark Souls 3 because it's on PC and I can play it

>>380694117
Sorcery is ok now. Pyromancy has been overpowered since day one. Faith is ass.

>>380693959
Quality isn't good anymore.

Heavy and Sharp infusions are often the best possible setup even at base stats.

Bloodborne because it's the only worthwhile game for my $300 paperweight

>>380693426
Is DaS2 the only damn game in the series you can actually play through the game with your build?

Every other souls game you have to basically beat the game to get equipment with good scaling, meanwhile I can get an S faith scaling chime in DaS2 20 minutes into the game.

>>380694307
Yes it is, that's a blatant lie

>>380691219
>100 churches and swamps
>more variety

is this pc fart serious?

>>380694462
Dark Souls 1, Demon's Souls

You can't be a caster in BB, so DS3. Magic might be shit in it, but it gives it more replay value.

Everything with DLC included

BB>DaS3>DaS2>DaS>DeS

Dark Souls 3 would be below DaS2 without ringed city

>>380694797
DaS3 has the most disappointing set of DLC in the series.

>>380694875
t. lore eater gael victim

>>380694656
Even if I hate the game now outside of nostalgia, this is correct.

Some of the best weapons in the game are gained in the first castle area.

>>380690493
Bloodborne has better lore and singleplayer if you're only gonna play through it once.
DaS3 has way better online interactions, as well as a vastly higher potential for different playthoughs and novelty builds.
Also, chalice dungeons can go fuck themselves.

>>380691219
Bloodborne is an exclusive so pcbro cancer cant play it so it automatically wins

>>380691673
>Bloodborne
>much more replayable
Hell no. There are two and a half viable builds.

File: Ludwigs Holy Blade.webm (3MB, 768x384px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 768x384px

>>380690493
The one that is it's own idea and first since Demon's Souls to actually mix it up in both gameplay and setting

Best fucking movesets and funnest melee weapons in a videogame

>>380695197
Bloodborne has 20 unique weapons that all change your playstyle

Dark Souls 3 has 100 weapon with 6 movesets and only 10% of those weapons are viable

>>380695197
Every build does insane damage in PvE so I don't see what you mean.

>>380695360
I don't rmemeber that outfit from the game

>>380695360
It doesn't even have the best movesets in a RPG, let alone vidya as a whole

>>380695526
Student set

File: 5261858+_78f4dbfe3d2ee22f4045ac5a721dd68c.png (76KB, 325x358px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 325x358px

B-but the waifus from DS1-2-3...

DS3 has better bosses.

Bloodborne only has two good bosses in the entire game and both of them are in the DLC.

>>380695697
Ludwig
Orphan of Kosm
Matyr
Gherman
Gascoigne

shit on every single boss in das3

>>380690493
BB

>>380695439
Yeah as a pc fat ds3 is a fucking chore to play. I definitely got memed. Shit repetitive levels, shit Das 1 rehashes, and just an absolute mind blowing amount of imbalance in the loot

>>380690493
Bloodborne. Dark Souls 3 was wayy to easy for a souls game it bored me half way through. The only boss that actually felt challenging was the guy with the big-ass shield

File: 1462055601390.png (107KB, 320x287px) Image search: [Google]

107KB, 320x287px

>>380695697
>Gehrman, Amelia, Logarius, Keeper of Old Lords, Gascoigne, Pthumerian
>bad

Damn that's hot bait

>>380694875
Not when ds2 exists TOH > TRC >>>> AOTA >> AOA >>>> DS2 Trash

>>380690493
I haven't played DS3 DLC yet.

I prefer Bloodborne. I feel that its lore and world are a lot more cohesive and interesting. I also think that trick weapons and off-hand guns were a really smart way to keep the combat fresh, considering that 3 souls games preceded it. It's also less linear than DS3, although more linear than the earlier souls games. Bloodborne is a game with very few real faults. The only serious one is the Chalice Dungeons, which were unbelievably repetitive. If you want to get to the final dungeon boss, you have to not only play through countless cut-and-paste rooms, but fight the same bosses multiple times.

Dark Souls 3 should have done more with weapon arts to make combat feel new again, and shouldn't have (all but) completely removed poise. It also walked back a few of DS2's were obvious improvements, like being able to do multiplayer anywhere even if the boss is dead. And scaling on INT and FAI is terrible until very high investment, meaning hybrid phys/magic builds are not possible. There's not reason for that.