Nier Automata or Persona 5?

>>380257174
Nier Automata

Played and 100% both. You're getting much more bang for your buck with Persona 5 and I would have to recommend that one. However Nier is a great game and you should get that afterwards pretty much as soon as you're done with P5.

>>380257442
how long is p5? nier:a lasted me 80 hours.

>>380257778
I mean I 100% without buying the achievements in 45 hours so I'm not sure in that case. With that amount of playtime I'm guessing P5 is stepping into 130+ hour territory for you.

>>380257968
100% Nier I meant.

>>380257968
did you just not bother with lv8 chips and ex rank dlc?

>>380257174
Persona 5 and then get Nier cheap on PC.

File: 62599873_p0.jpg (1MB, 1200x1600px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1200x1600px

>>380257174
Just buy whatever you want I guess

>>380258065
probably 40-50 hours

>>380258141
Why would I bother with lvl8 chips when I never even needed them? Even the secret boss was fairly easy. And no I didn't play the DLC. I wanted story DLC and that is not what we got.

>>380257174
Both.

File: urok.jpg (8KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 250x250px

>>380257174

If your controller is spazzing out, go for a turn-based game over an action one. They're both great games.

File: DBugj5OVYAAm0Ln.jpg_orig.jpg (874KB, 3000x1686px) Image search: [Google]

874KB, 3000x1686px

I liked NieR a lot more and it is my GOTY but Persona 5 is easier to recommend.
They're both great games regardless.

File: 1497065740593.jpg (289KB, 600x862px) Image search: [Google]

289KB, 600x862px

Persona 5 is great value for money (my first playthrough was 94 hours, though it dragged pretty hard by the end).
Nier meanwhile took 42 hours.

Sidenote: I was spoiled on literally everything about Nier prior to release which attentuated its novelty- and despite that I think I enjoyed it more. Your mileage may vary.

>>380257174
I like nier way more but you'll get more hours in persona 5. So more fun but shorter experience or less fun still fun and more length. It's up to you

>>380258661
the dlc deals with plato 1728, who was referenced in some intel in the main game. you also learn about the machine equivalent of yorha operators, the training and maintenance regimens of the machines and them slowly developing emotions and having dreams about the lives of human gestalts. you have to beat the colosseums to gain access to the story content. lv99 emil ain't shit compared to ex rank flooded city arena - every hit is an instant kill without maxed def and hp or cheesing it with berserk letting you tank one hit no matter what.

File: 1482460689596.jpg (1MB, 847x1059px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 847x1059px

Thanks for the opinions and recommendations, Anons.

>>380257174
Literally flip a coin.

Both are 10/10 and recommending just one hurts me too much.

>>380257174
Do you wanna play an action game? Or do you wanna play a JRPG?

That's the main question you gotta ask yourself. You can tell me the latest Forza is the best shit ever but like, I don't play caaahhrs games.

>>380257174
>I'm not a traditional JRPG player

Err... yeah just go with Nier:automata. I have both and love both. You would get more hours out of persona for sure but with the risk of not liking jrpgs or turn based, I'd say nier is a safer bet.

File: 1495061910669.png (634KB, 1280x1760px) Image search: [Google]

634KB, 1280x1760px

Both are great but i would say that you will lose any will to play games for a while after beating Automata as it's an amazing feels ride.

>>380260312
why you calling it an action game when it's created by japs? While it has rpg elements with cuhrayzee combat mechanics? I don't see the logic in these posts..

>>380257778
100 hours for a first run