You DID kill his wife and brother, right? I sincerely hope you

I just killed the dude, his family didn;t do me no harm

>>378910007
>killing unrelated family members for 'revenge'

niggermind.jpg

>>378910142
This. An eye for an eye. He didn't kill Marston's wife or brother or anything

>>378910007
Making ten assholes out of him is enough. Good that Rockstar added those options, though.

File: dog.jpg (26KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 600x600px

>>378910142
>>378910252
>Morals in the wild west

Presentfags begone

>>378910287
>>378910252
>>378910142
He was going to fucking kill them, though. Marston just didn't let them

>>378910381
>>378910471

>wild west
>not living with honor

Back to the inner city with you, nigger

>>378910471
HE was? Oh so his family wasn't doing anything? Why the fuck would I kill them then? You want to be the same nigger scum as the guy you're getting revenge against? Great plan, idiot.

File: 318271da980706f7a18a811c3456a77d.png (29KB, 633x758px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 633x758px

>>378910639
>Assuming I'm a nigger
>Being correct

S-shut up!

File: sorry.jpg (77KB, 1366x768px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 1366x768px

>>378910812
Oh shit, I'm sorry

>>378910142
>>378910252
>>378910287
He killed the uncle though, so i just killed his brother

>>378910007
Hell yeah, shot her in the chest then lassoed her and dragged her wounded ass almost all the way to the brother in law. Put one in the back of his head.

File: itsok.jpg (19KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 480x360px

>>378910979
I forgive you

>>378910471
If Ross really wanted the whole family dead he would have sent men out to search for Jack and Abigail, or he would have left a garrison of troops at their homestead. The fact that Abigail was buried next to John proves otherwise.

>>378910007
>>378910381
>>378910471
>>378911078
>>378911132
Way to be a fucking disappointment to your father.

File: 7684296.jpg (13KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 300x300px

>>378911729
>father

Gotta kill everybody involved, or else they might come back for revenge against you.

>>378911729
If he wanted his input noted he shouldn't have gotten himself killed.

I just killed the dude, I'm not going to stoop to his level and kill unrelated innocents for petty revenge

>>378910007
I just killed the wife. Let him live with the grief like Jack did.

WORK YOU DAMN NAG!

File: troubles are over.jpg (31KB, 670x503px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 670x503px

>>378910007
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yag41F7eCLU

You kill the rest of his family you become exactly what your pa didn't want for his only son.

>>378910007
I roped his wife and made her watch me kill him

>>378910007
But why bother killing the wife and uncle when if I leave them alive they will live with the knowledge that they gave away the location of their dearly departed to some mumbling sketchy autist

>don't kill siblings
>they end up looking for you and killing your family

nah fuck it I erased em all.

>>378911729
Jack is a disappointment regardless since he still kills Ross and lives the outlaw life John didn't want for him

>>378910007
Yes I did.
Drowned his wife on the lake near her house and hog tied his brother and made him wait for the train.

>>378910007
Why? Ross' wife was a sweet old lady. Ross' brother didn't strike me as an asshole like Ross did. Either way, it would be entirely out of Jack's character to just murder them.

>>378914408
>Jack
>family

>>378910007
I just killed everyone, fuck having to deal with his brother a few years later down the line.

>>378911729
You had the option to play like a fucking murdering asshole as Marston as well. Hell, Marston WAS a murdering asshole. I was just making Jack like his father.

>>378910007
I wanted to spare them... but I knew that any survivors may one day come after me or (if I have any) my kids. I killed his wife and set the cabin on fire. I killed his brother and placed his body in the water. Then I killed him... and then placed tnt on his corpse.
This one's for you pah.

>>378915475
Marston didn't want his son to turn out like he did. He wanted a better life for his kid.

File: 1400025666639.jpg (639KB, 2560x1600px) Image search: [Google]

639KB, 2560x1600px

https://youtu.be/_Mk_f75TS1A?t=1m5s

>>378916304
It was too late for that as soon as he set out to kill his father's murderer. He put himself on the path

>>378916504
Hence why jack is a disappointment

>>378910007
He is going to be the main char of RDR 2.
It will be the story of how he became such a hardass.

>>378910287
>>378910471
True, still though, Red Dead didn't give me the MURDER RANDOM CIVILLIANS urge like GTA does so it didn't even occur to me to kill his wife and bro. My roommate at the time this game came out did though.

>>378917356
god I can't fucking wait for RDR 2. I'm even buying a PS4 for it.

I made the choice that John would've liked and stopped playing the moment he became the main character.

So in my game he never went to become a faggy outlaw and maybe grew up to be a productive member of society

File: 1494991428190.jpg (26KB, 192x297px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 192x297px

>That side mission where you pay off the pimp
>Never give him the money as John
>Give it too him as Jack
>That guy has been standing there for 2 years

>>378912876
This is why I murdered in cold blood.

What if he has a son who'd like to avenge his death? gotta kill em all.

>>378918063
All the side stories are like that. Imagine being that crazy religious chick and wandering in the desert for three years

>>378910639
It's what young John Marston would've done, like father like son. Prove me wrong faggots.

>>378910007
One of the most poignant things about RDR is how the father sacrificed for the freedom of the son, but the son just didn't understand. The cycle of violence continued, no matter how hard John tried to break it.

>>378919668
Fucking LUDO ahhhhhhhhh.

Who the hell directored RDR those Rockstar credits are always a fucking mess.

>>378918063
>>378918998

I don't see why anyone would keep playing after killing Ross. I just made sure I played until I was sick of it with John, then finished the game.

WORK YA DAMN NAG.

>>378918063
I always wondered how the side shit works. I didn't have any side quests left after I finished the story so does it just play the same exact thing but with jack instead of john?

>>378920516
From what I can gather, yeah. They have dialog for Jack for anything John missed, no matter how comically impractical. Its so players won't have things lost forever if they missed it after the story.

>>378920841
Besides death, I thought that was the only one that would be impossible if John died before completing it.

>>378920841
I remember I couldn't get 100% completion because of one side quest that I could only finish as John or some shit. Was fucking infuriating.
Think it was one of the Irish ones.

>>378922230
Most likely the one where you meet the devil. Only john can meet him.

>>378924161
He's death, not devil.

>I'm an accountant of sorts

>>378910007
nah i let him go, he was just doing his job.

>>378924324
He did some highly illegal, morally questionable shit to do his job. The nuremberg defense doesn't actually work.

>>378920402
>NAG
>Not NIG
are you deaf

>>378924467
john was a cumskin, why should i care about cumskins

>>378911729
>Implying John would have wanted Jack to waste his life on revenge in the first place.
The whole point was he wanted his son not to be the kind of person he was for most of his life. It's what makes the ending rather sad.

>>378924567
A what

File: sad raiden.jpg (90KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 1280x720px

>>378914073
>Jack will probably still be empty and bitter for the rest of his life. Exactly what John didn't want for him.
I didn't cry, but I felt so damn empty finishing this game.

>>378924635
Cumskin aka white boy

>>378924954
God damn, you niggers come up with the gayest fucking pet names.

File: nag.jpg (20KB, 366x191px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 366x191px

>>378924495

File: be37f1d2c8d02e2f286bad8af2c1e5f9.jpg (110KB, 1024x768px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 1024x768px

>>378924495
>NIG
>not MIG

>>378914128
Underrated post