/v/s shit taste

switch witcher with persona and you have the correct order, nier being the most overrated

Didn't we just have this thread like an hour ago?

All Japanese games are overrated on the internet.

>>378360778
>if it's popular, it's bad meme

>>378360778
>Trinity
>lists 4 games

File: smoked.jpg (13KB, 229x316px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 229x316px

>>378360778
Bloodborne

>Trinity
>There is 4 games

>>378360778
>trinity

>>378361005
its a trinity, not an order

>>378361229
>its popular, so its good
I guess we can agree that justin bieber makes the best music and that the fast and the furious kinography are the pinnacle of cinema

File: squinty.jpg (80KB, 1140x475px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 1140x475px

>>378361406

>>378361445
So maybe there's something to the idea that there's no connection between popularity and quality?

>>378360778
Just fucking play those

>>378361516
So why did you bring it up then?

>>378361382
>>378361410
>>378361431

Just giving you your (you)'s so we can get this out of the way.

>>378360778

>trinity
>4 games

>>378361382
>>378361410
>>378361431
hello newfriends

>>378361565
Because you're a fucking moron, and that wasn't even me.

It being popular doesn't make it bad, but /v/ keeps insisting that everything popular is automatically shit.

>>378360778
Memes aside it's definitely BotW, people were calling it "the best game of all time" for fuck's sake.

>>378361445
Nobody says JB makes the best music and no one says FF is kino, but they're far from bad. Claiming they're bad just because it's popular is childish and very demonstrative of your low IQ.

>>378360778
>All from the last 5 years
At least work on your b8 some more before handing it in to be graded.

F

All those games are good, not the best but BoTW and Nier are fantastic. Kill yourself hipsterfaggot

>>378361725
>far from bad

no, they're objectively both shit

>>378361689
>being this new

Zelda is definitely the most overrated, but that doesn't mean it's not good - it definitely deserves some of the praise it gets

>>378361725
They're the most popular, the sales alone speaks for their quality, just like these games.

File: 1495198514736.jpg (201KB, 449x998px) Image search: [Google]

201KB, 449x998px

>>378360778
>create a discount Ubishit open world
>throw in some gimmicks like cutting tree, burning grass and shit because muh technology
>slap Zelda name on it
>slap Ninty's Seal of Quality on it
>release it on a console with no gaem
>sit back and watch as all mainstream reviewers and Nintentards are all over your microdick

File: 1470502284690.jpg (17KB, 408x286px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 408x286px

>>378360778
>No Skyrim

Into the trash it goes.

>>378360778
Nier, easily. I really liked the game. I like Yoko Taro ways of telling a story. But I think it's overrated, gameplay's nothing special, few side quests are worthwhile, everything's quite predictable if you played any Taro game and the performance sucks both on consoles and PC. Still a great game tho'

>>378361692
So if somethings popular it cant be shit?

>>378360778
Witcher 3 and the polish/CDPR cocksucking is pathetic. Rest are good.

>>378362180
no one here likes skyrim

bloodborne

File: 1492258584091.jpg (50KB, 1024x867px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 1024x867px

NieR: Automata propably offers the least out of them. Pretty much everything about the game is mediocre and the only reason it's praised is because 'muh animu ass' and 'muh edgy writing'.

>>378362342
Where does it say /v/ in the OP image?

>>378362221
Yes. People always call out overrated garbage like No Man's Sky and ME:A and deservedly so. There's literally nothing wrong with the games in the OP. They're all worthy of praise in some regard, but you knew this too. You just couldn't help yourself from baiting (You)s

>>378362481
in the subject line

>>378362509
So I guess skyrim truly is the greatest RPG of our time by your logic.

>>378361406
>one of the most underrated games this gen
>overrated
Baito desu.

>>378362575
t. OP
No one reads the subject lines except redditards that use it.

All above are solid games.

File: 1398955273708.png (669KB, 507x545px) Image search: [Google]

669KB, 507x545px

im so contrarian enjoy ur trash lul

>"likes" deus ex and god hand despite having never played them

>>378362725
strong backpedaling, maybe try learning to read

>>378360778
Zelda by far. I played it and enjoyed it a lot but it really wasn't anything special from an objective point of view. It was special for the series but that's it. It fails in a lot of aspects, making it both an unsatisfying Zelda game and an unsatisfying open world game.

>>378360778
I've played and beaten all of them. Without a doubt, Nier: Automata is the worst one.

The game becomes easy mode when using 2B's default short sword, with Weapon Damage +6 and Shockwave +6 equipped as chips, so it's not difficult, but the game is intentionally tedious. By the time I beat Ending E, I was too enraged for the true ending.

>>378362675
No, but it's still worthy of praise in some regards. If people gravitate to it, then there's something done right with the game.

>>378360778
Where's Bloodborne on the list?

>>378362871
haha :P

>>378360778
>no chrono triggered xD
haha
>>378361725
They're objectively bad.The general public doesn't care about the truth.

>>378362897
Then something can be shit even if its popular.

>If people gravitate to it, then there's something done right with the game.

Yea, Advertising.

>>378362883
You have to go back.

Zelda > Witcher > Nier > Persona

In that order.

>>378363017
s t r o n g

>>378360778
Only Nier Automata. The other games have actually some positive sides.

File: 1496009534479.jpg (408KB, 1254x649px) Image search: [Google]

408KB, 1254x649px

>>378362927
I got you senpai

File: 00_Willis,_Terriermon_e_Wendigomon.jpg (44KB, 704x396px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 704x396px

>>378363017
To the beginning

Persona > Nier > Witcher > Zelda

Zelda actually is as good as everyone says it is. Persona's turn-based trash. Nier is alright but it's not better than The Witcher.

>>378360778
Witcher 3

File: witcher3.jpg (251KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

251KB, 1920x1080px

>>378362509
official witcher 3 review.

all non-quest related things you can find on the world are copy paste boring shit
no one will talk to you unless they are quest related and you have the quest that requires them
awful ui made for consoles and only 4 consumable slots, making alch spec a chore
no resource management, you just instantly get all your potions back for whats essentiallly free
enemys have 1, maybe 2, attack that they repeat over and over, making fights absolutely boring after an hour
level system only works to the games detriment, as youll quickly outlevel everything you have to do and it will all be easier than the game already is
coming across a SKULL WARNING SIGN monster should be exciting but it's not, because you know it fights exactly the same as all the others of its kind, only with more hp.
"cinematic" controls that ignore accuracy in favor of looking more natural
even death march is easy as fuck due to a lack of enemy attack variety and every ability you can spec into being way too strong
ciri sections are boring and unneeded and only serve to rob you of what could have been the one interesting boss fight in the game.
the final moments of the story seem rushed as fuck, from oh hi crones now we fight, to im eredin i have a secret, im dying my secret is this guy tricked us and i had no plan to deal with it, to oh actually geralt i didnt trick you
majority of loot is randomized and scales to your level. Nothing you find really excites you.
all enemies have an extremely short tether that you will cross unintentionally more often than not. At this point they ignore you and start walking back to the center of the area or hang around to get hit easily
witcher senses are only ever used when the quest requires it and is just hold right click to follow quest arrow. you cant actually track monsters or anything out in the world(and why would you need to? theyre all tethered to a small location and never move away)

6/10 game. Had potential, wasted it.

Breath of the Wild is the only overrated game on there. The rest are genuine masterpieces.

>>378363028
I'd switch Zelda with Witcher, because atleast Zelda is good game overall unlike Shitcher.

>>378360778
BoTW

>>378363445
Don't ever reply to me again with your childish mentality. How old are you that you call it "shitcher"? 12? Don't forgot. Don't reply to me you imbecile.

>>378363445
overrated =/= good/bad

>>378362978
>XD

>>378360778
not an argument

>>378363546
Don't tell me what to do.

>>378363591
Did you forget that SHITCHER yea fuck>>378363546
won the goty while being a literal movie game with clunky bamham combat?
It's the definition of overrated.

>>378363916
Youre right, its a question

>>378363015
>No Man's Sky get popular due to advertising
>Unanimously shat on after release

The difference is that the games in OP were advertised well and turned out to be good.

>>378364192
Just like Skyrim

Over 800 GOTY HOLYSHIT
CRY MORE /v/ Weebd

>>378360778
Is this a horizontal tier list?

>>378360778
>trinity
>there are 4 games

>>378361091
It's the same person posting the same shit evry other day.

I really dont understand what their problem is. The rating matters shit if you enjoy a game but OP seems like the kind of person that spends multiple hours per day watching multiple reviews of the same game and debating over nonsense.
Sad

>>378364969
>*Makes another say something nice about her thread*

File: 1471298433848.jpg (40KB, 981x773px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 981x773px

>>378361689
>newfriends
>meme that started like a month ago

>>378360778
Witcher 3 by far.

File: 1-1.jpg (23KB, 417x268px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 417x268px

Trick question: they're all equally overrated, and should instantly be considered bad games for all the marketers who shill them on /v/. Unless you want to argue that people like Jim Sterling are valid critics, or that kotaku is trustworthy.

>>378360778
New Vegas

>>378362892
I havent finished the game but I'm getting tired of it. Exploration, combat and quests feel more annoying than anything.

>>378365506
so if a game has any marketing,or anyone discussing it on a board dedicated to video games, its bad? Are you a retard, or just a contrarian faggot?

Objective order of overrated-ness:
1. BoTW
2. Witcher 3
3. Nier
4. P5

>>378363370
>DUDE PHANTOM THIEVES
>FUCK ADULTS, AMIRITE?
>GO HIGH SCHOOL KIDS!
>LET'S GO STEAL SOME HEARTS DUDE

>>378366541
also the first two aren't just overrated, they are complete shit in every aspect. Both drop off a rock after the first 10 hours of play.

>>378360778
I like them all a lot

>>378360778
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lcAsad-E9CQ

>>378362889
This. The first 10-15 hours of Zelda were fucking magical, but then the feeling of "just another empty open world game" creeped in slowly but surely.

>>378360778
>These things are too popular

>Let's talk a lot about them!

>>378366692
you're on the wrong board, /v/ isn't allowed to like anything, but especially not video games.

I would genuinely like to know what the people who call these games bad/shit consider good games.
Maybe I haven't seen the light yet, name some titles for me.

>>378362889
I liked it all the way through, and I usually hate open world games.
I think it's the first game in that category where I was looking at the environment and not the map most of the time

File: 1444234674456.jpg (30KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 500x281px

>>378366635
>ywn have taste this shit

>>378366626
persona 5 didn't get 97

>>378360778
remove witcher and replace botw with yakuza and you are 10000% correct

>>378366975
>replace botw
AH FOR FUCK SAKE! OVERRATED DOESN'T MEAN BAD!

>>378367115
What's your point?

Breath of the Wild is the most overrated there.

But it's also the best, to be fair.

>>378360778
This thread is cancer, OP IS A FAGGOT

>>378366626
>DUDE MEME ARROWS LMAO
I hope you didn't expect anyone to take you seriously.

What a shit thread

>>378364648

File: 1495570580952.webm (3MB, 800x450px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 800x450px

>>378361406

>>378360778

In order of most to least overrated: Nier > Persona > Witcher
In order of most to least insufferable fanbases: Persona > Nier > Witcher

BotW probably receives more praise than it should, but let's be honest here: Nintendo should be encouraged to continue going this direction with the series. Zelda has been far too linear for far too long. While the game may not be phenomenal compared to Elder Scrolls or other open-world series, it's still a massive improvement for a Nintendo IP.

>>378360778
OP is salty because he couldn't finish the Nier prologue in hard.

I didn't like the Witcher but I can understand why it was popular.

Persona 5 was a boring, poorly paced, badly written snooze fest.

I have yet to play Nier or BOTW.

>>378364247
Just name a better rpg which released in 21 century.

>>378370118
Witcher 3

>>378370276
Well, let's start from first moment - Witcher 3 isn't RPG since there are no roleplay, world is materialistically grey, so it's just arcade adventure. And second - it's a game where every aspect of game broken or undeveloped or useless in terms of gameplay, 50% of time you walking around and talking with plebs, the other 50% time you just fighting with one-button mechanics. Game of century, yeah, sure.

>>378370901
>Witcher 3 isn't RPG since there are no roleplay, world is materialistically grey, so it's just arcade adventure
is diablo not an rpg either?

>>378371253
No it actually isn't dumbass

>>378369324
Nierfags always on the defensive lol

as if hardmode makes enemies any less braindead

>>378370901
but youre also describing skyrim

>>378361406
>2017
>still the only game for ps4

dude never ever lmao

>>378362221
no. hes saying a game's quality isnt necessarily reflected in its popularity

File: IMG_0824.jpg (145KB, 1145x880px) Image search: [Google]

145KB, 1145x880px

>>378370901
Someone's upset.

>>378371972
So then a game can be both popular and shit.

>>378370118
Dragons Dogma is better by a mile and a half.

File: logo.jpg (24KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 400x400px

>Forgetting the absolute worst one

>trinity
>4 games

Zelda. Its damn good game but doesn't really do anything special.

You can say the same for Persona 5 but that game has too much style. Witcher 3 set the bar for open world games. Haven't played Nier.

BOTW by a mile. I found it to be a chore to play desu. Take out the Zelda branding and it would get 7/10's across the board.

File: 1494437065464.png (60KB, 215x250px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 215x250px

>>378374804
W3 and BOTW count as one game. They are exactly the same.

Replace P5 with >>378374693 for accuracy.

>>378360778
where the fuck is Fallout 4?

File: File_000 (5).png (651KB, 850x478px) Image search: [Google]

651KB, 850x478px

There really are stains who refuse to let any sizable amount of people think a game is good.

>>378362927
>>378363181
>The one souls game that tries to be different
>The one souls game that isn't dickridden to death by leddit

Wew

>>378374693
no one likes this garbage

>>378375572
There really are people who think popularity means you have to like it