Ok we need to finally fucking settle it, /v/. Which one was better?

>>378099851
>Ok we need to finally fucking settle it, /v/
Why? Just play one, both or neither.

There is nothing to settle.

>>378099851
better at what?

>>378100003
sucking dick

SMT4A. Better gameplay, better story, less annoying characters.

>>378099851
One, fucking why? Both are fantastic.

Two, P5 is better because it's better designed and has much more in the way of QoL improvements.

But /v/'s standards for what "good" is is so fucking bas-ackwards that P5's well designed menus and fast-paced but meaty story make it more "Casual" and thus worse somehow

>>378100695
Menus do not a good game make, anon. And P5's story sucks.

>>378100784
Menus is literally all SMT4 is, and at least P5 actually *has* a story

I'm sure this thread will be filled with legitimate discussion and not autistic shit flinging.

>>378100883
We're talking about SMT4A, which definitely has a story. 4 does too for that matter.

>>378101037
Do we ever have legitimate discussion though? The closest I've seen in a while is Nyx fight bitching.

>>378099851
we don't need to settle shit.

>>378099851

One game is weeabooedgelord trash, the other is weeaboo trash

What is there to settle?

>>378100695
>QoL improvements

Where is my fusion search and why is MC death still game over?

I like playing SMT4A more than once but I liked P5 more than my first run of SMT4A.

Both gay anime garbage

>>378101318
>WeeabooTrash
Why isn't this called out as the most autistic meme and anti-4chan meme of all?
>Oh my god, people LIKE something originally oriented for someone else. What WEIRDOS!

>>378101435
i wanna be the first reply

>>378101318
Found the Biowaredrome

Both SMT4 and 4A are worse than Strange Journey

>>378102061
Who doesn't think that? SJ is the best SMT overall.