p4g>p5

File: image.jpg (22KB, 300x190px)

22KB, 300x190px

>>377710031
P4>P4g

Yukiko and Yukiko are worse than anyone in P5 or P3. They stop developing immediately after getting their personas and Yukiko especially is nothing but a SNRK machine for the majority of the game

>marie

>>377710842
I meant Yosuke and Yukiko, but fuck does yukiko suck

>>377710797
P5>P4

>>377710031
is it autistic for me to buy this game if I dont have a vita?
I emulated p4 and love it, but I would like to own it as retarded as that sounds, might pick up a pstv one day too if I have spare money

File: 1495400855490.png (165KB, 400x362px)

165KB, 400x362px

>>377710031
>Implying
P4=P5>P4G

File: image.jpg (67KB, 1000x562px)

67KB, 1000x562px

>>377711008

Why are people saying that Golden is worse than the original? Did I fuck up by buying this version?

>>377711825
Contrarians, while golden has some slightly improved graphics, extensive quality of life improvements, more events, an extra dungeon and 2 more social links, everyone thinks that the inclusion of Marie alone makes it worse.

>>377711013
I originally got a PSTV exclusively to play Persona 4 Golden. I encourage you to do the same. There are plenty of other great Vita games you can play on the PSTV too, if you want more reasons to get it.

>>377711825
P4G is better, people are just upset because Marie

File: image.jpg (241KB, 850x1204px)

241KB, 850x1204px

>>377711990
>and Chie's terrible new dub

File: 1451785250152.jpg (522KB, 960x1632px)

522KB, 960x1632px

>>377712237
Chie's new scenes are cute.

File: IMG_3202.jpg (129KB, 1475x1124px)

129KB, 1475x1124px

P5 is the peak of new Persona in every aspect except story

>>377712184
What's wrong with her? Never played golden since it's stuck on vita

File: 1407501704205.png (443KB, 552x700px)

443KB, 552x700px

>>377712915
atlus discovered the tsundere character archetype

>>377711825
People from both sides will always tell you "MARIE" but the real reason why P4G sucked for me is because the gameplay changes completely break the game wide open. You get Risette's fucking retardedly OP powers on top of the new skill inheritance system and weaker enemies in later dungeons. The quality of life improvements doesn't justify raping the actual gameplay aspect of the game.

>>377710031
Nah

>>377713270
Marie's dungeon was neat, slicing off your sp by half after each fight and throwing minibosses that forced you to use break spells/items.

>>377714108
It wasn't as neat to me because having a trumpeter with Megilodaeon + spell master pretty much helped rape everything on that dungeon.

File: 1494558447057.jpg (1MB, 2880x1632px)

1MB, 2880x1632px

>friendship and gang escapades
P4G>P5

>everything else
>P5>P4G

That's how I feel anyway.

File: 1442009555078.jpg (164KB, 700x525px)

164KB, 700x525px

>>377714384
Kanji wants the D.

File: 1494559019103.jpg (252KB, 960x1631px)

252KB, 960x1631px

>>377714513
You'd be gay not to give it to him.

P4 is the best weeb bullshit game
P5 is the best actual game

>>377714108
>Marie's dungeon was neat, slicing off your sp by half after each fight and throwing minibosses that forced you to use break spells/items.
it was the shittiest one by far, why even bother doing it if you're getting the same exp and money from the last dungeon and you're gonna lose all your treasure later? I literally skipped every fight possible and rushed to the end because of how shit it was. I liked the song though

>>377714384
drag costume a best, used it for Nanako rescue
agent suit is really neat too, especially when you try to capture Adachi

>>377715029
Dojima costume is best.

>>377710797

Sauce

>>377714628
Depends on what level of weeb bullshit we're talking here though. I thought P5 had better s.links overall although moreso with the NPC ones than the in-party ones (Tora's one alone was better than all the one's in P4). P4 in general has better "general hangout" type options though.

>>377712915
Marie wasn't even that bad in the game I thought. It was in the anime where she was obnoxiously shoehorned into every key scene.

>>377715326
Yeah, used it on Yu for Adachi's fight. Chocolate are for true men.

>>377716464
>to get the true end you have to max her s-link

If you could ignore her people wouldn't care but you have to spend so much time listening to her bullshit if you don't want to fuck up.

>>377716464
I didn't like how they forced the team to be included in most of her slink events but I guess they took that up to eleven in the anime

>>377712697
>except story
it's this too tbqh
P4's entire plot is dirt simple enough to be described in complete detail in 3 minutes and it still had massive problems, particularly with how the game deliberately withheld literally every single suspicious thing that Adachi had ever done just so it could have the team recall it all suddenly at the last minute after you've made your pick from a list. Pretty much 0 effort went into anything other than the wacky anime sequences and it shows in both the original game and in Golden.
P3 is the slowest burn imaginable and only the very end is actually really good. Further, Ikutsuki is barely on par with some of P5's shittier Mementos targets, and the entire first half of the game revolves around his bullshit. The payoff is not at all worth what you have to sit through to get there.
P5 has Kaneshiro's dungeon as its single low point. Even Okumura's arc gave us more insight into the villain, and of course had a major impact on the rest of the game. The story didn't kick in in the last 10 minutes, nor did it handle hiding shit from the player in a stupid way.

>>377714384
Is kanji just in to traps in both directions?

>>377717126
>Ikutsuki is barely on par with some of P5's shittier Mementos targets
This is actually completely true

File: 1494343277247.jpg (60KB, 1200x395px)

60KB, 1200x395px

>>377717126
>game purposely leaves out scenes showing their master plan for muh tweest
>hurr drugs lol
>clearly remembers everything from the past 8 months except those
>we also get to see SIU director scenes and other behind the scenes scenes even though the game is a giant flashback from Joker's perspective

fucking trash """story"""

>>377717126
Come on faggot give me the fucking (You)
I really need it today

File: 5f2e8404d5dc72a11698b23a013e2f0a.png (517KB, 1200x858px)

517KB, 1200x858px

anybody have a high quality picture of this?

>>377712237
>I like girls with adult uncute voices

>>377714108
>Hassou-Tobi

>>377712237
Chie's original dub is garbage, what crack are you smoking?

>>377710797
Source? Reverse image gets nothing

>>377710031
>>377710797
You're both wrong.

File: 1493239198668.jpg (313KB, 709x1002px)

313KB, 709x1002px

Genuine question. Which version of P4 should I get?
I just beat P3 FES recently for the first time and had fantastic time playing through it. And now am trying to do a 100% S.Link run for Telos, but am already half way through the game again and I want more of this.
From OP's picture, P4G is a Vita game and I don't have a Vita. Is there a PS3 or PS4 version of it?

>>377720776
No, but you can get a PSTV. P4G is the better version, though I suggest you avoid Marie for gour first playtrough.

>>377717824
Ah there were a very few hints that he was sad with the world and a little off. There was one scene where he defends the love hotel, saying "hey the beds there are a little more luxurious there dont diss it!"

But man, I wish he had more depth. Didnt like how in FES it spoils him early because it shows his "evil portrait" much earlier than its supposed to.

>>377712237
>high school teenager
>middle aged smoker's voice
would you have preferred the entire game to be remade managed by 4kids?

>>377721253
His "evil portrait" doesn't even look evil though, so I wouldn't say it was spoiled. Compare his to Adachi's or Goro's and they look much more evil, especially if you compare his to Cognitive Goro's.

P3FES>P4G

File: da5.png (138KB, 500x430px)

138KB, 500x430px

>>377718773
Lump