Which game deserved its score more?

File: witcher-combat-1.webm (3MB, 960x540px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 960x540px

>>377457993
Witcher deserves a 72 max.

>>377457993
I've never really cared for any zelda game. Witcher was a good rpg, so yeah... I think witcher deserves more.

who the fuck cares

>>377458213
fuck you

>The best game of this decade
or
>Manchild nostalgia weeb pandering trash
Gee, I wonder.

>>377457993
I could only stomach the crapper 3 for 40 hours and decided that's it's a pretty shitty game. When I say pretty, I mean aesthetically. But when I say shitty, I mean a giant clump of op crap.
Botw is fun, mindless and doesn't take itself serious. It doesn't feel like a chore to explore.

File: tmp_20634-Screenshot_20170426-120929~2-662687069.png (973KB, 1868x1212px) Image search: [Google]

973KB, 1868x1212px

>FFXV is at 81

>>377458348
>Manchild nostalgia weeb pandering trash
What does that have to do with The Witcher at all?

>>377457993
Non.
There is no such thing as a 10/10 game
everygame has its flaws.
People who rate shit 10/10 shouldn't be counted.since they are clearly fanboying.

>>377458606
>crapper 3


How old are you, child?

>>377458738
>There is no such thing as a 10/10 game
You are dumb.

>>377457993
both of them are a good 2-3 points higher than they should be so neither

>>377457993
>The most immersive, well written and mature game ever made

Vs

>Some weeb shit

Lol

>>377458790
Old enough to not insult strangers when someone hurts my precious feelings over a stupid game.
It's crap, so go dry your tears.

>>377457993

Both amazing games, do you prefer a more serious or light hearted adventure?

Zelda captures a wider audience, probably why the higher scores.

>>377458834
>>The most immersive, well written and mature game ever made
>
>Vs
>
>>Some weeb shit


Literally no way to know what game you are talking about.
Witcher 3 by default can not be immersive if half the fucking quests you go into batman detective mode to be led to the goal.

File: 21a.jpg (108KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 1280x720px

>Witcher 3 Angry Joe score: 10/10
>BoTW Angry Joe score: 9/10

Weebs eternally and ultimately BTFO

This is pretty much my feelings on the new Zelda.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T15-xfUr8z4

>>377457993
Reminder to remove the 10 points given by the Nintendo children working at review sites

>>377458816
not an argument.

>>377457993
Damn, Witchercucks are in full damage control trying to keep "their" game relevant.

>>377457993
BotW

It's not a 98 but it deserves 90+ a hell of a lot more than Witcher 3 does.

>>377458348
Witcher wasn't even made by nihon. How is it weeb trash? Explain yourself.

File: 1481885713543.jpg (256KB, 1000x1502px) Image search: [Google]

256KB, 1000x1502px

>>377458953
>witcher 3 was too complicated for this anon
go back to cawadoody faggot

>>377459069
>BotW
>flaws
This guy is a retard and you're also a retard for believing him

>>377457993
the witcher has a lower score because the low test man-children of today can't relate to Geralt's pussy slaying manliness, but they can relate to puckered boipussy trap Link

>>377457993
Of both series I've only played The Witcher 1, Ocarina of Time and A Link to the Past.
Based on those experiences I can say, without a shred of doubt and without playing TW3 or BOTW, that BOTW is the better game (or more exactly, an actual game) and TW3 is fucking garbage.

File: 1475565739718.jpg (65KB, 539x480px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 539x480px

>>377459483
>Shitter 3
>complicated

Almost as funny as the drones who insist that Death March fixes the gameplay.

>>377459053
wait, I forgot what his real name was. cans someone please inform me?

>>377459764
Joe "Spic on a Stick" Vargas?

>>377459506
>Thinking Zelda:BotW is not flawed
I watching the video and the dude is right. Go back to buying Ameebois or w.e they are called and jerking off to Yoshi.

File: 1453681286097.jpg (26KB, 318x318px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 318x318px

>>377459573
I can't read or really see at all but I know with out a doubt that you are the biggest faggot and I don't even understand what that word is.

File: tutut.png (1MB, 1024x683px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1024x683px

>Graphics
the witcher 3. Not saying the witcher 3 has the best graphics ever for an open world game. FFxv alone is better but it looks much better than zelda.

>gameplay
Zelda easily


>story
Equal points?

>>377457993
>open world meme full of missions that are all solved by using your Batman vision
>open world meme full of nothing
Neither.

>>377459970
Then again, Witcher also beats Zelda at

>Characters
>Story
>Source material
>Music
>Climate

Easy win for Gerardo.

>>377458075
I knew the faggot posting this was a retarded Nintendo fan.

File: 1487622621656.jpg (45KB, 481x676px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 481x676px

>>377460117
Probably yes

>>377460185
>responding to b8
>inb4 you assume that post was mine

>>377458678
>tfw Conan knew all along
I swear the segment is fucking gold.

>>377459927
>hating Amiibos
Go back to /vr/, nostalgiafag

>>377457993
Witcher is less generic than Horizon at least the score for both games is fair. BotW is the greatest game ever made

File: GreatSwordWitcher.webm (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

well gameplay on witcher sucked major elf balls

so i dont think it deserved a 92. no good story can save a terrible gameplay

>>377457993
neither, they both should get like 7/10, if breast of the wild cunt is practically a 10/10 game what about games that are actually like masterpieces, they're only 2% better than a pretty good game? bullshit.

File: 1491588978933.gif (405KB, 359x371px) Image search: [Google]

405KB, 359x371px

Link can't even get pussy. 99% sure Link is a incel insert character to make the fat nerd who plays Nintendo to recreate their dead childhoods.

>>377457993
Never played The Witcher III.

BoTW was good, but certainly not a 98. Maybe anywhere between 90-93.

>>377460404
with that said, its FUCKING MILES BETTER THAN WITCHER 2

witcher 1 is the best one

>>377459927
This is a witcher fan notice the sad attempt to mispronounce a word to seem cool and the need to reference masturbation so mature.

>>377458953

I don't even care about TW3. Saying Crapper 3 is just the lamest most childish thing you could do.

I think Witcher.
It nailed what every open/trilogy AAA game was going for the last generation while not even having the normie audience until the final entry into the trilogy.

Every Zelda gets 10/10 reviews

File: IMG_4563.jpg (125KB, 768x1024px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 768x1024px

>>377459483
>complicated
>he's serious

you're adorable

Both

They are designed different and are praised for their own reasons
Don't shit fling stupid comparisons

File: images (1).jpg (5KB, 256x197px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 256x197px

>>377460484
>witcher 1 is the best one

Oh. a nostalgia fag. The grass was greener the light was brighter blah blah blah. Read this >>377460434

>>377460578
>plays video games as a hobby
>can't handle criticism
>calls others children


Intresading

File: Witcher 3.webm (631KB, 960x540px) Image search: [Google]

631KB, 960x540px

Zelda wasnt downgraded

Witcher 3.

Sure the main quest sucks but Heart of Stone is amazing and Blood and Wine is okay.

BoTW story sucks ding dong.

Combat-wise, W3 also manages to be deeper.

File: witcher nice job.jpg (61KB, 600x338px) Image search: [Google]

61KB, 600x338px

>>377460434
>i cant get pussy so i going to play as a white mutant with a 20 inch dick that can fuck anyone and never get anyone knocked up. so its aways casual sex
>he can also kill any monster and human because his fight style is the best fight style ever

>>377460117
The gameplay part could not be anymore important for the difference.
Witcher's open world is complete and total garbage. Half of it is complete filler with very little interesting side quests in themselves that aren't way better in the main areas like Novigrad.
Especially fucking Skeliege's dry as fuck area.

Meanwhile, I'd take low durability over the completely insignificant crafting in WItcher 3.
Just apply quen, a witcher armor set and get a superior bomb that affects most enemies.
Skill trees are garbage. At least Link's simple combat knows exact what ti's doing than pretending anything short of never equipping any rare gear on Death March is a complete non challenge.

>>377460790
>implying
yeah, same drawdistance as the bullshots and promotional videos, same silky smooth fps as well

I always knew the people who shitposted about the witcher were nintenbros

>>377459970
>>story
>Equal points?
lol

>>377458075
really helps having god mode on..

File: 1494097484831.png (2MB, 1221x1030px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1221x1030px

>>377457993
Haven't played Zelda, probably never will because
>lolswitch
Witcher is kinda mediocre. There's not much in terms of exploration or figuring shit out, most of everything is solved by pressing left trigger or following a waypoint. The only reason it won so many awards is because its only big competitor was Fallout 4 and that game was barely playable.

File: Witcher Execution.webm (2MB, 720x576px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 720x576px

>>377460734
Witcher one is not even that old. what a fuck are you talking about?

Witcher 1 had better gameplay, better choises , better story, better lore, better crafting, better dificulty

graphics are shit but there are mods for that


also raising the fucking last boss so he uses whatever you teach him as a reason to fight you was genius

>>377461025
>left trigger
Y-you play it on consoles?

File: 1489145697817.jpg (81KB, 659x667px) Image search: [Google]

81KB, 659x667px

>>377457993
>The best RPG in the last decade and probably the best game as well with one of the best stories ever.

vs

>weaboo anime nostalgia jerk for kids and manchildren.

...

>>377461068
I'm not sure I would say Witcher 1 has better gameplay.

Better story, atmosphere and music sure, but gameplay?

>>377461215
do not try to reason with cRPG fags, they think excel sheets are gameplay

>>377461068
Oh yeah better sidequests

>witcher 1
A sister killed the other, so you must find a way to free her soul

>witcher 3
there is a monster in that cave, kill him

>witcher 1
You got find the identity of the werewolf killing bandits on the city
you can kill him, cure him and depending of your actions the werewolf can come and save your ass in the main quest

>witcher 3

there is a monster in that cave, kill him. and i'll give you a card

>>377461025
Shit, I probably wouldn't like Witcher 3 either if I had to play it with a controller. I tried that for about ten minutes and it was fucking awful.

>>377461068
Witcher 1 was fucking terrible, i've never even been able to get past chapter 2 on it.

Listen here you fucking kike piece of shit, spread your jew shill magic bullshit again and i'll get a mod to ban you.

>>377460908
>skill trees are garbages
But they offer 3 unique classes and you can mix-match and create hybrid builds.

>>377461169
>best stories ever.
go read the books if you want stories faggot

we talking GAMES in here

>>377461304
That's a gross generalization of Witcher 3 quest since it also involves you know putting soul to rest and curing curse.

>>377461169
>Best stories
I still like Witcher 3 despite the problems but HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH no. No. Just no.
If you're remotely impressed by the romance and Ciri, you're closer to a weeaboo than you think.

>>377461304
Why even bother when you're fully aware that you can cherrypick just as hard in the other direction?

File: 1488272548921.jpg (279KB, 550x791px) Image search: [Google]

279KB, 550x791px

>>377461134
>>377461310
I play it on PC, the controller worked fine.
Does the game remove waypoints, the witcher sense and change the entire combat system when playing on keyboard?

>>377461315
>i've never even been able to get past chapter 2 on it.
casual filter working like magic.

>>377461304
>You got find the identity of the werewolf killing bandits on the city
>you can kill him, cure him and depending of your actions the werewolf can come and save your ass in the main quest

Witcher 3 had a similar side quest. I guess you chose commando :^)

>>377461318
>3 unique classes
That all break the fucking game by the fourth tier and don't play significantly different like say, DMC3 Swordmaster with twin swords to Royal Guard with Rebellion.
>Mix and Match
If you want to complete neither.
>Hybrid Build
See above.

>>377461446
Uh, yeah considering KB+M has different control scheme.

>waypoint
You can turn that off m8.

>>377459764
Stressed-out Sam

I'm about to start Witcher 3 but I'm afraid I'll be overwhelmed by things to do/see

I haven't played an open world game in 10 years

>>377457993
Neither
Both had glaring flaws

>>377461565
Better play the first two, if you haven't.

>>377461551
How? I looked for a while and couldn't find anything like that. Is there also a way to remove all of the undiscovered secrets from the map? It's not only insulting but it clutters the fuck out of it.

Zelda

File: 1489553514131.png (123KB, 785x757px) Image search: [Google]

123KB, 785x757px

>>377460881
Link has being chasing the same old pussy for 30years bro. It's time to grow up and stop living for her.

>>377461520
>That all break the fucking game by the fourth tier
Sure it does, but that's an argument to be made for every RPG.
>and don't play significantly different like say, DMC3 Swordmaster with twin swords to Royal Guard with Rebellion.
Why the heck do you bring DMC to this? But a sign build or alchemy build do not play like a sword build.
>If you want to complete neither.
>See above.
That's the point? Do you want to master two paths or what?

>>377461315
I managed to go as far as that part when you're forced to help with a wedding (chapter 5, I guess). When I had to walk through a long, boring, lineal prairie and the main quest was something like "help with the logistics and do some errands" I realized I had enough of that game.
50 hours. I don't exactly regret them but I only had fun with less than half of those.

>>377461727
*been

>>377461689
Option and the mod friendly hut.

>>377460596

>It nailed what every open/trilogy AAA game was going for the last generation

Except for borderline good gameplay

>>377461384
>Game can't have good stories.
GOOO HOME GAMER GIRL

>>377461859
It manages to have a deeper battle system than boTW, that's for sure.

>>377461859
What do you consider "good gameplay"? Some examples?

>inb4 (((Dark Souls)))

>>377457993
TW3 is a real score
BotW is a paid score

File: file.png (2MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1920x1080px

>>377461727
>his witch waifu literaly fucks guys all the time
Geralt is a cuck

>>377461734
>Sign build and alchemy build
Are you serious, you apply buffs and use signs anyway.
>Why the heck do you bring DMC to this?
A comparison? You know? In an argument?
>Do you want to master two paths or what?
So Geralt can't learn how to use signs and swing his sword fast at the same time but having 5 legendary swords he doesn't even use over the one that came with Cat is fine?

The witcher had no real fanbase before Witcher 3 trailers. People who like it voted it highly because it was good.
Nintendo has a large fanbase from decades ago that are more likely to rate nintendo titles favourably due to loyalism/nostalogia. Also Botw runs on average 20fps so what kind of score would it get if it was 60? 120/100?

File: 1490874617462-1.png (389KB, 978x1736px) Image search: [Google]

389KB, 978x1736px

>Witcher 3 has good charac-

>>377461915
>i only play games for the story and gameplay is irrelevant
Go away kotaku.

>>377462131
>implying witcher was some super niche series before 3

Witcher 2 was very popular and sold a lot

>>377462083
>A comparison? You know? In an argument?

Not the other Anon, but to compare hack and slash combat to RPG combat is just stupid.

>>377462190
>t. the Lightrail Avenger

I'm expecting a *tip* from you.

>>377462131
>The witcher had no real fanbase before Witcher 3 trailers

??????????????

>>377462237
It sold ok at 90% discounts, but relative to post- witcher 3 cdpr/nintedo it was rather tiny.

>>377462190
I'd argue that gameplay can take a back seat depending on the overall goal of a game. Silent Hill 2 didn't have good combat or amazing controls but the atmosphere was so good it's still talked about today.
In a role playing game where the idea is you play a role and immerse yourself, I think story does take a high priority.

File: 1455500471472.png (199KB, 567x378px) Image search: [Google]

199KB, 567x378px

>2 years ago.
>Dark Souls? More like SHIT SOULS has no verticality. Check this Witcher video of Geralt jumping around roofs.

>Now.
>BotW comes out in which you can climb literally everything.
>Witcher fags getting BTFO about their comparatively barren and non-vertical open world.

Feels good to be a Dark Souls and Zelda fan today.

GERALT ETERNALLY REMEMBERED AS SECOND BEST FOREVER AND EVER.

>>377459535
Geralt is the typical Gary Stu. A power fantasy, every hot female wants his dick. Pretentious as fuck. At least Link is a well rounded, believable character.

>>377462470
Most consumers dont buy every console, most people use 1 pc and thats it.
If you have unlimited money why not just fuck prostitutes all day and eat 3 michelin star restaurants every day instead of playing games?

>>377459483
>complicated

Witcher 3 is the easiest "RPG" and least RPG I've ever played, devoid of anything of interest, zero innovation. If Witcher 3 is too complicated for you, you may as well resort to bashing flint together.

File: ds fans.png (671KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

671KB, 1920x1080px

>>377462470
>nobody talks about dark souls

>it HAS to fucking bring the fucking thing to the conversation

You are the reason people hate that fucking shity game

>>377462383
You are deluded. The game sold 1m in 3 months back in time.

>>377462538
Are there mods to change the character model for Geralt? If I'm gonna play as a character I don't care much for, I'd at least like one that's a pretty lady.

Gee Whiz, let's have a think

One game is actually fun to play and the other is literally a polish VN with waifus but awful gameplay.

>>377462730
>Legend of Zelda
>fun to play

For autistic virgins, maybe.

File: ZELDA - TAO LINK LINK.webm (3MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1280x720px

>>377462905
>waifu simulator
>calling other people virgins

get fucked by your terrible gameplay and atrocious hitboxes

>>377457993
I AM NOTHIN' BUT A GOODBOY ALL MY LIFE! I ASKED MOMMY TO BUY ME ZELDA . BUT SHE CAME BACK WITH MARIO!!111! SO I POOPED ALL OVER MY BED AND MADE HER CLEAN IT WHILE I ATE MY TENDIES.

i think a lot of witcher 3's combat complaints come from the shitty leveling system and people gimping themselves really hard.

the leveling system and loot scaling is pretty bad in the game.

Why are people buying the switch? It only has Zelda and indieshit

>>377462905
You've clearly never played nintendo games you autistic slavshit. Nintendo understand the meaning of fun, and it's not swinging a sword 50 times at an NPC until he drops dead over and over again.

>>377462269
I'm comparing the moveset variety in builds, not the combat.
Regardless, Aqua, Terra, and Ventus play significantly from each other, and TWEWY lets you do virtually any playstyle you want, if you want an in genre comparison.

File: 1494295220647.gif (683KB, 500x482px) Image search: [Google]

683KB, 500x482px

>>377462591
>>377462601
FUCK YOU FUCK YOU

YOU MAD YOU MAD

HAHAHAHAAHAHAHA

I laugh at your misery.

Don't even bother responding to this post, for I am OFF playing the greatest game of this generation: BREATH OF THE WILD (not the SHITcher.)

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

File: 2ewyterhcobx.jpg (89KB, 960x782px) Image search: [Google]

89KB, 960x782px

>>377463102
because it's cheap and very reliable!

>>377463082
The entire gameplay department is a disaster. I really do like the characters and stories and waifus but they need to make the game actually fun.

>>377458738
Tetris is a 5/5 game (10 point scale is for retards lmao).

Also, having a score system but banning the top score is fucking retarded. This isn't a test, assuming a game should have literally no flaws is completely unreasonable. If a game has no significant flaws in its design or technical execution, especially none that compromise its potential, there's no reason it couldn't be rated 5/5.

File: freeposting.jpg (21KB, 416x315px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 416x315px

>Witchturd 3

Haha I can't believe you suckers still play this shitty fart-smelling game. I'm so glad I relieved myself of this garbage dump heap and just had to come by here again to laugh at you idiots who can't let go. This game is a poop-stained asshole ready to dump fecal butt sauce all over your faces and you all LOVE it. You can't get enough. Hahahahahahahaha. I bet you all ask mamma for a nice helping of steaming ass barf as soon as you wake up and hop in your sweaty semen-encrusted chairs and start up this ass explosion of a game.

Witcher 3? What a fucking joke. More like Shitter Pee. Hahahahahahahahahahaha! Enjoy swimming in your pool of diarrhea anal droppings you shitheads!

I am free! FREE!

>>377463207
After you finished Botw what are you going to play btw? Can you browse porn on switch?

File: BB Combo.webm (3MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1280x720px

>>377463207
why
too tired of playing all the souls rehashes?

>>377462538
This is something that plagues Western RPGs. There too much Gary Stus and Mary Sues and Chosen ones. Every protagonist, and most important characters simply HAVE to be special snowflakes. Say what you want about JRPGs, but at least they aren't so power fantasy centered, you don't have to be the edgy savior of the multiverse monster slayer that can fuck every single NPC in the game.

File: Horizon.jpg (261KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

261KB, 1920x1080px

Why is nobody talking about Horizon Zero Dawn anymore?

>>377463436
because it's trash

>>377463419
For the love of god do not even try to praise nips ability to write believable characters. Just dont

File: Cloud-FFVIIArt.png (181KB, 456x544px) Image search: [Google]

181KB, 456x544px

>>377463419
this is hilarious considering the design of typical jrpg trash

Witcherdrones constantly getting BTFO yet they still make these threads every day. When will the learn?

>>377458827
this

File: Angry Joe.jpg (76KB, 720x538px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 720x538px

>>377459053
>skyrim 10/10
>guild wars 2 10/10
>more movie reviews than games reviews
>getting cuked by a gold digger whore
>getting more and more fat

>one game is restricted to a single console known for its rabid fanboys, has the advantage of Half Life tier nostalgia and easy mainstream recognition because everyone and their gamer girl reviewer love 'the zeldas'

>other game is playable on multiple platforms, guaranteed to garner more critical reviews and feedback, comes with views considered women-unfriendly in this day and age

golly i wonder

>>377463697
Skyrim was 10/10 for its target audience.
Guild wars 2 was 10 the first 20-30h. Then you say okay time to quit.

>>377458075
>>377460908
>>377462182
>>377462470
>>377463207
>>377463347
THIS

>>377462182
>The Witcher 3 has the best story ever written
Yeah, it sure does.

File: 5c0.jpg (101KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 1280x720px

>>377458678

>fell from 86

>>377458719
>>377459292
zeldafags pls

>>377463546
>>377463618
Is this double shitposting?
Cloud's like the exact opposite example you'd want to use. the entire twist is that he's just a lucky little bitch who happened to know a cool guy who could project into.

>>377462083
>Are you serious, you apply buffs and use signs anyway.
Just like you do slash shit in DMC3 regardless of style
>A comparison? You know? In an argument?
A nonsensical comparison, why do you compare action RPG with a hack and slash? Do I get to complain about DMC3 lack of choices and consequences and romance options as well?
>So Geralt can't learn how to use signs and swing his sword fast at the same time
But he can, in the game? He can cast signs even when he master swordmaster, he doesn't just master both paths because that's overpowered and unnecessary.

File: screen shot 2015-07-30 at 2.31.57 pm.png (660KB, 1106x1012px) Image search: [Google]

660KB, 1106x1012px

>>377463207
>>377463347
>Zeldrones are literal autists
Why am I not surprised

>>377464138
The fact he's accidentally a SOLDIER aside right?

>>377459069
>Starts out the video posting pictures of his tweets when the game launched
>All of the tweets are him bitching about people giving it a 10 and how upset he is about it

Every time.