which is the most overrated?

>>377198534
>trinity
>4 games
anon...

Also nobody cares about Nier, there's only about 5 Tarofags who constantly make threads.

ZELDA botw. Final answer.

>>377198534
Your favorite game

>>377198534
BOTW. It didn't bring anything new and it is obvious it got 10s on mostly name alone.

Persona is underrated if anything.

>>377198804
what's my favorite game?

>>377198832
Shit

>>377198534
>weeb games and 1 wrpg that isn't even as good as skyrim
All of them desu

>>377198857
never head of it

zelda by a pretty long shot
if you said "on /v/" it'd be much closer

>>377198534
BOTW.

Good game but no t the godsend people make it out to be. Game doesn't provide much entertainment you mostly have to make your own.

File: 442817_channelcomiket_nickpeorth.jpg (194KB, 756x1100px) Image search: [Google]

194KB, 756x1100px

>>377198534

>>377198534
>trinity

>>377198534
damn pretty hard to decide i am inclined to say zelda botw but its the better game out of all those 3 games and nier as well as p5 and witcher3 are overrated to an eyerolling extend.
Yeah my list is zelda botw>witcher3>persona5 on the overrated scale didnt play nier yet.

>>377198534
If overratedness is measured in the relation between good scores and praise to actual game quality, Witcher 3 probably wins.
If you talk only measure on /v/, BotW wins big time, though.

>>377198818
are you kidding. that game gets 10/10s based solely on waifu appeal

>>377198534
I have finished and enjoyed all 4 of these games.

I liked them all 4 and I am a depressed salty negative faggot that hates everyone and his self.

So that says something about the quality of these specific games. /v/ is just contrarian like always so have to hate these games.

Prey is probably also going to be called "overrated" on /v/ in a while despite it being a really cool game and underselling right now but it will get a cult following making /v/ slowly hate it over time.

>>377198921
Outside of /v/ it's Skyrim.

>>377199039
Breath of the wild is easily the most overrated, this is coming from a lifetime zelda fan, no idea about witcher or nier though

File: cdpr_go home kurwo you're drunk.jpg (65KB, 463x622px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 463x622px

>>377198534
Why is CDPR the only developer that has actually grown creatively between their games? BotW is basically "we can't keep making the same game we always do so let's let the new kids give it a go".

>>377198534
Witcher 3 deserved every single of those 254 GOTY awards it got.
Because even with proper criticism applied(overusage of witcher senses, floaty combat, etc.) its still one of the best games ever made.
Zelda, Persona and Nier? Now those are standard games that get hyped above reason.

>>377198818
hardly, its a reskinned p4 with a new UI.

Witcher is loved by people who barely play games
Automata is loved by pseuds who dont actually like games
Zelda is alright
Persona is just doing the same thing its always been doing, being a glorified visual novle

>>377198534
Nier isn't overrated, it is well received for ass and nobody claims otherwise.

they're all good games though.

>>377198534
>Nier

It barely sold and no one outside of /v/ talks about it. Admit you're a contrarian fuck that doesn't enjoy video games.

>>377198534
BOTW

>>377199293
because they can afford it when they essentially release one game per generation. or close to, considering first witcher came out in 2007. also, new engines and overhauls between games.

>>377199336
>unambiguously wrong
best dungeons of the series

>>377198534
Nier, easily

>>377198862
Todd please go

Minecraft

>>377198534
Never played them, so wouldn't know

>>377198534
>Nier
I can understand it's somewhat a Niche game, but i don't believe it's overrated.
>BotW
Played it, and whilst an incredibly fun game, it's nowhere near the amount of 10/10's it got.
>Witcher
Best game out of the list
>P5
Weaboo shit.

>>377198534
Zelda.

It's like MGSV, but without guns.

I'll give it this though; BotW is an actual game and not a 5 hour experience until it hits forever repeating missions and a botched ending;

Witcher 3 is a close second, Persona behind that;

botw by a lot. there are 3 things to do in that game, and like 3 side quests.

>>377198534
Why is witcher shit on so much? It's the most enjoyable game i've played in years.

>>377198534
>>377198739
>>377198818
>>377198921
>>377198937
>>377199039
>>377199053
>>377199195
>>377199293
>>377199307
>>377199367
>>377199437
>>377199505

Zelda is rightfully rated as one of the best games ever made.

>>377199708
zelda is a 2 hour experience before you start repeating missions. it's skyrim tier but skyrim has hours of story and side quests. zelda has 12 30-second story segments.

>>377199505
>It barely sold
It sold over a million copies. You can stop pretending you're into some obscure niche game.

>>377198534
can't speak for Breath of the Wild, but I've played the other three and I'd say TW3
I bet BotW is, zelda shit is always overrated

On /v/: Automata

In general: Witcher 3

>>377199791
it's not even the best zelda game

it's not even the best wii u game

it's not even the best fucking switch game

>>377199756
>It's the most enjoyable game i've played in years.
Because of retards like you who have never played a game other than skyrim before.

File: 432987420974290387.jpg (17KB, 240x351px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 240x351px

Toss up between W3 and BotW but I think BotW deserves the title more because W3 definitely is better has much better characters and voice acting

>>377199878
skyrims shit. tw3 is great. you're a permavirgin.

File: 1494164163153.png (922KB, 1400x1050px) Image search: [Google]

922KB, 1400x1050px

>>377199856
>baseless hyperbole
Every time

>>377198534
Zelda and Witcher 3 are extremely overrated. Persona 5 is fantastic and deserves the small amount of hype it got. Haven't played Nier yet.

Dark Souls

Fyi, /v/ is not a good gage for the gaming community as a whole. These games sure generate a lot of discussion here, but your generic games consumer would get lost the second you mention these games beyond a "have you heard of this game called (title)"

GOTY and flavor of the month vidya.
You'll be fine.

>>377199961
>console zelda game gets overrated while being empty and having no replay value
every time

>>377199958
>skyrims shit. tw3 is great.
It's funny you say this considering they both suffer from the same problems.

>>377199961
Gee, it's almost like it's overrated.

>>377200034
>sour grapes: the post: the human being
Every time

>>377198534
>all these games are good
>none were made by western

Really activate my almonds

>>377200126
But it's not, you're just desperately trying to convince others it is.

>>377198534
persona

>>377199756

People love to shit on everything. Instead of saying this game isn't for them or they weren't in the right mood, they decide the game is objectively shit.

>>377198534
>trinity
>I don't like good games

>>377200385
>unironically thinking any of those games are good

>>377200229
>But it's not
It is. It's a good game, but absolutely not deserving of all those scores. Very far from perfect.

>>377198534

Reomve Zelda and add Uncharted 4 instead of Witcher and we have a deal

File: spinzaku.gif (2MB, 448x252px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 448x252px

>>377198534
BotW by far. People are already calling it "the greatest game of all time". I mean really? Fucking really? It's not even the best Zelda. There are a gigantic amount of flaws. I honestly believe that people just want to be part of an "event", "the next big thing". They're not evaluating it as a game, they're treating it like a phenomena. OoT syndrome.

>>377198738
there are 6, don't forget me

Can we all get along? 2017 is a way better year than 2016 at least.

>>377200198
>unfunny weeb redditor whose personality is just an amalgamation of the media he takes in reuses a tired, unfunny meme


Damn... now that one realLEy activates 'em

Bloodbourne

>>377199692
a fellow masterracer i see.

>>377200468
It's babby's first open world + Zelda. You can't tick any more hype boxes.

>>377198534
P5
All of you bitch about a lack of gameplay while you praise P5

>>377199961
>thread about BotW being overrated
>post its inflated review scores, thereby proving it's overrated

Nice going, champ.

http://www.strawpoll.me/12983223

>>377200468
It's some next level shitposting it has to be.
>botw being praised as innovating open world games
>every response is because of gliders

You learn to just stop feeling. One day at a time.

>>377200434
There is no such thing as a perfect score. 10 does not mean perfect. It means it's a masterpiece. No we're not going to rate games only 9.9/10 and never use the 10.

>>377198534
I legit cannot stand the combat in Witcher games.

>>377200664
Not him but it's not a 10 either, the game has enough flaws to dock some points.

>>377198534
Zelda

File: 1494881271084.jpg (45KB, 600x585px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 600x585px

BOTW is the most overrated out of them. And also the best out of them.
people seriously think it's that impossible objectively perfect game, even on here. and go bring out their sonybro pictures the moment an actual fellow switch owner dislikes a mechanic or whatever. emberassing

>>377200664
>It means it's a masterpiece.
Which BotW isn't.

there's nothing to fucking do in zelda

i bought a switch for this but it's just fucking empty. who likes this shit? at least TW3 had a crazy amount of quests and nests and dungeons and side quests and treasure hunts. Zelda had fucking nothing. Its seriously just a ubisoft tower climbing simulator with less content and variety.

There's also seriously only like 4 enemies. Shits fucking ridiculous.

>>377200651
What the fuck is a poll going to prove
You realize that the least voted for option will be the most overrated game on /v/ right?

>>377198534

Is OP some kind of shitposter shitposting for the sake to get attention from poorly baited people?

Is he a nostalgiafag shitting on these new games because when he was young he was playing "superior" games but now every young person enjoying the new trash is a bad person for playing these games?

>>377198534
apparently triangles
because you seem to have ignored how they work in that image

Is everyone on /v/ thats too poor to play games this fucking dumb?

>>377198534
BotW I might say but the praise Nier: Automata gets is way WAY more overblown than literally any game I've ever played and that is saying a lot.

>>377199293
Im not sure why you would say that they grew creatively considering that witcher 3 was a complete downgrade in terms of the choices, the other games had a lot more variety when playing while the choices in witcher 3 hardly affect anything. The story in general is just shittier because of the open world.

>>377200883
maybe you just have bad taste in games

>>377200872
Why does every post complaining about Zelda being empty sound like the poster never played the game

ur mom

>>377200890
enjoying your first day here?

>>377200661
Normies who barely played previous Zelda games are amazed by an open world game with a FUCKING PHYSICS ENGINE HOLY SHIT HAHA WOOOOOOW PHYSICS DUDE AMAZING
>>377200883
Someone post the compilation of this nigger's shitposts

>>377200712
Not objectively, no. The complaints also wouldn't dock full points. You don't drop a grade for 1 perceived issue.

>>377198534
>No Bloodborne
OP is a disingenuous faggot

>>377200823
Yes it is cuck, nobody has proven otherwise

>>377201056
if there were 5 games it wouldnt be a trinity

>nobody even mentions Horizon
wtf

BotW is great in that it's how new open world games should strive to be like. Literally something to do or explore everywhere. SR2 was fun to just dick around in because it was packed with shit to do everywhere.

Sadly there wasn't enough tangible rewards for exploring in botw. Once you unlock the Master Sword and max stamina, there's no real reason to keep going. You know there won't be any hookshot, or new item, or new tablet ability. Maybe if there were low powered infinite durability weapons in the shrines it'd be worth it. Like a real weak hammer to break ores, a boomerang which is rather unconventional as is so an infinite durability one wouldn't hurt. Plus if you don't retrieve it it'd be gone for good or sent back to the shrine making you go fetch it.

Solid 8 to me. Needed more tools, tangible rewards, etc. Also gloves for climbing in the fucking rain.

>>377198738
It sold absurdly well compared to how niche the first one was

More than MGS2 at the same time after release

>>377201083
No it isn't cuck, nobody has proven otherwise

>>377201056
Dark Souls 1 is more overrated due to wider exposure

File: 20170517_085448~01.jpg (2MB, 4160x2271px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 4160x2271px

Zelda. Because I havent played it.
Witcher 3 with dlc was my last years goty from what I played with Uncharted 4 and Fallout 4 complete.

Nier was just fantastic game.

Persona 5 still havent finished it, 95h in, just got back from beach trip.

Zelda is a dumb overrated series as a whole

>>377198534
Nier

>>377201212
If you're going by pure normie appeal, none of these games are overrated except for BoTW (don't hear much people talking about W3 compared to Zelda)

>>377199195
Mein neger

botw clearly

Reminder that Skyrim is the #1 RPG of all time.

Nier. Witcher. Zelda. Persona. In that order

>>377201547
i own a switch. zelda is shit. stop creating boogeymen that don't exist.

>>377201545
This.

>>377200946

>I have bad taste in games
>Every critic has a bad taste in games
>The majority of people have a bad taste except for me

So OP is shitposting okay

>>377201658
>that one faggot with shit taste and a switch trying to speak for all people in the board

>>377201739
>that one faggot who hates sony and tries to speak for everyone in the world who's ever owned a sony product

File: 1488818301700.png (1MB, 1953x1209px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1953x1209px

>>377201658
>boogeymen that don't exist.
Oh, please. People shitposted about BotW for a whole fucking year. I've never seen sony drones so btfo before. It was hilarious.

File: 1483750478389.jpg (411KB, 1069x643px) Image search: [Google]

411KB, 1069x643px

>>377198534
>no Bloodborne/Dark Souls

Weak list.

>>377201713
Kill yourself you dumb tripfag.

>>377201792
again, i own a switch and a wii u. i hated BOTW. it's empty, boring and repetitive. "sonybros" don't exist. not everyone who dislikes a nintendo game comes from a cabal of sony drones that are hinging on nintendo failing. people are allowed to just not like a fucking game.

>>377201957
>more baseless hyperbole
Every fucking time
You'll get to play it someday, stop crying.

File: 1494593079770.png (1MB, 2000x2000px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2000x2000px

>>377201957
>"sonybros" don't exist
Stop embarrassing yourself.

>When you make a game so good that 2 months and a half later the sony ponies are STILL upset about it

Fuck, they don,t even care about their own ''games'' that long. Poor roaches

>>377198534
the one you like

Nier was Legend of Korra trash with people praising it like the second coming of Kamiya

Kill yourselves and tell your parents to bury you with that copy of feces.

>>377202054
>you will never be stuck in an imaginary war with a community from another website entirely

File: IMG_6612.jpg (1000KB, 3264x2448px) Image search: [Google]

1000KB, 3264x2448px

>>377202007

>>377202213
I don't care about the console war but it's obvious sony drones shitpost constantly, there's a reason why they're known as the worst fanbase. The release of BotW is a great example of this. Zero bombing a game you can't play because it's on a console you don't own? Pathetic.

Nier is bringing terrible posters to this board.

Third to the right, or second to the left.
The amount of universal praise it got showed me how the western games industry operated.

BOTW has no chance of getting as many GOTYs as Witcher 3.

>>377202270
>look mom I posted it again
>that one faggot with a switch and shit taste trying to rewrite history by crying and shitposting
Every single fucking time.

Only p5 and automata are overrated

Especially p5 which is a boring dating sim with shit story and 20yo gameplay

>>377202384
you're fat and friendless. have a bad day.

>>377202431
>fat
Wrong
>friendless
Wrong again
Enjoy having shit taste for games.

/co/ here, P5 is actually that good, I wouldn't say that about the others

>>377202098
Which one do I like?

>>377202324
It's basically the open world genre that's overrated as a whole. TW3, GTA 5, those games just suck ass but every time it's an open world game that wins game of the year. The only open world game I've played and liked is BotW, it's just a shit genre otherwise.

>>377202454
Drones actually exist. Damn.

>>377201547
This is kinda amusing because in just about every botw thread I see people giving good criticisms (shitty enemy variety, repetitive fetch quests etc etc) and then botw fans just ignore those posts and act like they don't exist

>>377202534
thanks

>>377202689
>good criticisms
>not nitpicks
Every time
Must be hard hating on a game that does everything right.

>>377202689
>they ignore shitposting
Really tinkers my spinner wheel

File: 1485586651388.png (178KB, 438x503px) Image search: [Google]

178KB, 438x503px

I can't imagine how much of contrarian video game hating monkey you have to be to say that Witcher is overrated.

>>377202773
>>377202791

Hit the weights. Take a shower. Get a clue. Seek sunlight. Have sex. Youre a bunch of fucking pinheads. Copy and pasted enemy design and fetch quests are valid complaints.

>>377202948
No they're not, they might be for your average neckbeard handholdless /v/irgin but not for actual human beings.

>>377198534
>overrated
>caring what other people think about things you enjoy or dislike

>>377203036
it's just memes, bro xD

>>377202534
/co/ here too
we are such weeaboos but p5 is totally fine

>>377203036
why would you come to a video game discussion board if you don't care about people's opinions you fucking dumb faggot? you can care about reception of something while forming your own opinion.

>>377203192
git mad, fag LOOOOL

>>377203036
if your opinions get easily swayed by randos on the net, it's a pretty bad sign anyway

>>377198534
Zelga: Winny Racker is the most overrated shit of all time.

Literally "Le Wrong Generation": The Video Game

>>377199195
Yup to all of this

File: 1494762546786.jpg (111KB, 700x913px) Image search: [Google]

111KB, 700x913px

>>377203259
kys salty fag

File: 1489786264955.jpg (67KB, 715x722px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 715x722px

>>377202948
Enemy variety is better than most games out there since you only fight human enemies and their AI is awful but in BotW they're pretty smart. Side quests are also better than the trash you find in other open world games by far, but again, they have the real fetch quests and nothing else.

>>377203192
Get a load of this guy

>>377203385
AI has nothing to do with enemy variety. Other than mini bosses like the fat pig things and the minotaur things (of which there aren't many) all you get are bokoblins, moblins, lizials, bats, slimes and then infinite recolors of them. you can literally count the enemies on one hand

2B's ass>>>>>>>>>>>Zelda's ass

>>377199293
>grown creatively
>tw3

How? The game is a complete let down in terms of choices/consequences compared to tw2 and even tw1.

>>377198534
>which is the most overrated?

the one that's on the platform you don't have.
welcome to /v/

>>377198534
Zelda.

I've yet to see someone claim that one of the other 3 is the best game of all time.

File: 1493970945254.png (210KB, 872x632px) Image search: [Google]

210KB, 872x632px

>>377203614
So having 64 enemies in one game is supposed to be "bad" enemy variety? Delusional.

>>377198738
I genuinely enjoyed NieR: Automata. I'm glad everyone here just shitposted about it, kept me from getting spoiled. Same thing happened with Persona, people shitpost about waifus and I don't miss out on any of the story. Genius!

>>377198534
Good, good, shit, haven't played.

>>377198534
The Witcher 3.
Absolutely dog shit gameplay.
It should have been a telltale game.

File: iwata2.jpg (78KB, 850x657px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 850x657px

>>377198534
The one you like the most

>>377199336
>best combat
>best dungeons
>enemies are actual demons and not shitty looking shadows
>better slinks and characters
>reskinned

Just admit you've never even played it, your post is beyond retarded.

>>377198534
BotW probably wins, if not for being the most oversold, for probably being the worst game.

>>377204009
End your life kid.
kys yourself tbqh famalam your parents won't miss you
what a failure
kys yourself tbqh

>>377198534
The insufferable, insecure BoTW fanbase makes it look like the worst game on that list. Bringing up metacritic scores every time someone dares to critisize this "perfect 10/10" game, is beyond pathetic.

>>377204269
>>377204009
>samefagging this hard

File: 1493997881572.jpg (125KB, 1375x749px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 1375x749px

>>377200651
>BotW wins
And It claims another win, this time for most overrated game, how Sonnigers will ever recover?

>>377198534
Gonna have to say W3 because --I don't play weebshit so I can't judge the others-- it was a 6/10 at best but GOTYAY says /v/

File: 42369.jpg (13KB, 210x230px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 210x230px

>>377204308
>sAmeFaGgiNg ThiS hARd

>>377201023
>Not objectively, no.
It had a 98 on metacritic when it dropped to 20 fps and stuttered when calculating big ragdolls, but I guess those are just subjectively bad aspects.

>>377200014
This.

If anything P5 is underrated considering P4G has the same metascore.

>>377204456
Patched.

On /v/? Just through the sheer amount of threads I'd say it's

Persona 5 > Nier autism > zelda > witcher 3

>>377204586
Still got the scores before it was patched because it's okay when it's a 3D Zelda.

>>377204640
Bloodborne ran like shit, too. So did lots of other great games.

>>377204308
>Being a poor Brazilian monkey
Wow

>>377204728
Bloodborne dropped to 25 FPS and never froze completely like BotW as far as I know. It also didn't get 98 metascore. Maybe because of those issues? Or maybe because it's not Zelda.

>>377204610
Nier had more threads about game. Zelda had most threads overall but half of them where shitting on it

Only game I haven't played is P5.

Automata is by far the most overrated. It has good aspects but it's spread extremely thinly over boring level designs and bland scenarios. And the combat is arguably shallower than any other of the games, even Zelda. It's just as shallow as the original Nier. I was shocked considering how much people were praising that particular aspect.

Story is great but fuck those side quests designs, Jesus it is nothing but mindless fetch quests in rehashed environments. And fuck 9S in particular, what a awful playstyle.

>>377204856
>It also didn't get 98 metascore
Because it's nowhere near that good. Critics shouldn't completely ignore FPS drops but if a game is godlike and the biggest problem is FPS drops? Who cares. It can be patched.

File: hmm.png (36KB, 500x566px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 500x566px

Neir automata

the other 3 are legit at least 9/10

Neir has one of the most shallow platinum combat systems not counting C team shit like korra or transformers while the story isn't as ambitious as previous Taro games

>>377198534
Trick question..
all of them

>>377201545
perfect

>>377204983
>nowhere near that good
>Who cares. It can be patched.
Good shitpost.

Nier.

File: ----.png (235KB, 304x302px) Image search: [Google]

235KB, 304x302px

>>377205204
Are you implying FPS drops can't be patched?

>>377205130
I think it's fair to put Automata on the same level as Transformers and Korra.

>>377198534
>Nier Automata
hurr durr play it 26 times to get the real ending. Besides that, threads on /v/ here is just 2Booty postings. Not overrated.

>BoTW
Yes. For a "10/10" game, the game definitely didn't bring much to the table to actually warrant that 10/10. The story is easily the weakest point of the game, this is why open world needs to die, I do see it as an advancement from a technological standpoint, but devs really is struggling with the story in almost every open world game.

>TW3
The sidequest story is really good. But the gameplay is pretty meh. Geralt is boring in TW3. Overrated? Yes.

>Persona 5
For a $60 game, I expected more. It literally is a PS2 game (in terms of technology). The style that people gets wet over, meh, not my cup of tea. But my word, I really like the social link events in this one. For a turn based JRPG it really is fun. Not overrated, but I do see why people might see it as such. But them waifu threads here needs to be kept in one thread. Fuck sakes.

>>377198534
Haven't played Persona 5 yet, but Witcher 3 is some of the most over rated trash I've ever had the displeasure of playing.

Persona >>> Nier > Zelda > Witcher

>>377205247
You can patch gameplay as well, but you rate a game for what it has, not what it can have.
Also, SS and WW are pretty much proof that Zelda scores are not to be taken seriously, so I don't know why you're thinking people should agree with BotW's score.

>>377205342
Proof of what? WW is definitely up there with other games of 2002. You'll have to use more than 2 words if you want to make any sense.

>>377198534

BotW and Persona 5

The witcher was alright and Nier was great

Persona 5 is easily the best game in that pic.

>>377198862
> wrpg
Witcher 3 is just slightly better done asscreed, it's not an rpg

>playing Witcher after playing Nioh
>the massive step down in combat quality

The story is pure fucking ass too.

>>377205307
now that's just memeing

>>377205517
Nier is the weakest game there, what are you on about? Commentary about the worth of videogames as a pass time aside, the gameplay is boring as fuck and by no means has the ability to carry a 25+ hour game. Fucking Kingdom Hearts did it better.

>>377205313
I agree with Zelda story, just gut it. None of them are good anyway. Lore in MM is alright though

>>377205745
>hurdur I didn't like therefore it's bad
>I probably played it on easiest difficulty and get all self healing
>why it's so boring and easy

>>377205474
That Zelda scores don't mean shit.
Are games ratings only based on what other games released that year? Then I can understand BotW's 10. Morrowind and GTA Vice City released in 2002 and Wind Waker isn't even finished (triforce hunt, cut content, few dungeons, bad overworld). If OOT deserves the score it has, WW is a 75. 80 at most.
Also, explain Skyward Sword's 10/10s (92 on metacritic). 2011 was a pretty good year.

I'm torn on how I feel about Nier Automata

I really think it was too long, and I got quite tired of the gameplay by the end. But the story was good, and I don't know how you'd make it significantly shorter without the story suffering. I think the combat just needed more depth, more skill required or something. The shmup sections were boring, the character action parts were boring when you could just spam dodge against enemies that just got more and more tanky despite not getting any more interesting. Every enemy that flew in the air like that one desert boss in the A2 route was extremely tedious and involved just spamming your pod beam until it finally died. And the Route B gameplay is even worse, it's the same dozen shmup layouts over and over again. At least the transition between hacking is very fast. If it took a long time it would be game ruining.

>>377198534
Only one of these games led to a DDoS attack on a website that gave it a 7/10. I think it's pretty clear that BotW is the answer here

Witcher and Zelda are the most overrated, easily.

But overrated doesn't mean bad. It's actually pretty retarded and pointless to argue about what's overrated and what isn't.

>>377205726
In what way? Automata's combat isn't challenging or complex. The enemies aren't all that creative. The quality takes a huge nosedive during the second playthrough as well.

It looks nice, but there's little to it overall. It's not bad, Korra and Transformers aren't bad either. It's just sort of mediocre.

>>377198534
These are all terribly overrated, except P5. I haven't even played P5, but there isn't a nonstop stream of shills (although the Witcher 3 is basically forgotten at this point) saying it's unironically the greatest game ever made, like there is for botw/Nier/tw3.

>>377206046
>unironically defending a cum in teh face cuck.

Wow, your parents must be quite disapointed

>>377206149
>korra and transformers arn't bad

they're pretty bad anon

>>377205950
BotW shits on the entire open world genre and makes the other games look like trash, it's objectively a 10/10.
>WW is a 75. 80 at most.
Why? Wind Waker definitely isn't GOAT or anything but as a game I'll definitely play WW over pretty much every game from 2002.
>Also, explain Skyward Sword's 10/10s
Same reason why GTA 4 and GTA 5 received so many 10s. Game length. I've noticed critics think a lot about content when they review games, if a game is really long they think it's worth 60$ which makes sense.

>>377206221
>Game length.
So that explains BotW's score. Glad we finally came to an agreement.

>>377198534
Those are retarted picks for overrated games, since they're actually all really good.
An absurdly overrated game would have to be something with a huge gap between its quality and the general reception, like Fallout 3 or 4

>when every single game you release pale in comparison from those DAMNED nintendildos so you shitpost your ass off for no compensation to dull the rectal pain

>>377206265
It's funny how butthurt people still are over BotW. Get over it already.

>>377206149
Transformers I agree, but the moment you included Korra I knew when to discard your opinion.

>>377206306
more proof that zelda is overrated

>>377206302
HZD

a slightly above average ubisoft style open world isn't worth a 88 or whatever that shitpile got

>>377206190
>tfw when Nintendy users your throat as a dick holster.
Glad I will never be this pathetic desu

>>377206339

You not liking it due to autism =/= game isn't good anon.

>>377205929
>hurrdurr if you play the game in one hit kill mode the game becomes more than just spamming light attacks in between mashing dash for easy perfect evades that give you absurd invincibility

No seriously, Kingdom Hearts did it better.

>>377206364
>admits it's slightly above average
>still calls it a shitpile
?

Botw

Only worse 3D Zelda game is Skyward Sword

>>377206420
You liking it due to autism =/= game is good anon.

>>377206190
>Proving my point
Thanks, bruther

>>377206330
I know, right? People get so upset when you criticize it and question its score.

>>377206364
No one thinks Horizon is more than an 8, though.
Okay, one guy on this board does.

>>377206414
But you suck our dick willingly, sony pony. I've never seen people so obsessed with zelda than the /v/ sony ponies

It's like a good game from nintendo unleashed a sort of primal autistic reflex in the sony fanbase. 2 months and a half, and just posting a botw imagine can trigger tens of sony ponies instantly.

That's power

>>377206265
you can beat BotW in a few hours

>>377206508
>I've never seen people so obsessed
Ironic.

>>377206434
Slightly above average ubisoft open world, ie shit

Just becuase it's slightly less liquid doesn't make it less shit

>>377206302
>since they're actually all really good.
Automata isn't good and I say that as a Taro fan.

>>377206553
>shit analogy
nice

>>377206534
you keep using that word. do you need help to find it's meaning ?

>>377206608
>meaning ?
Zelda fans confirmed for ESL. Pack it up, folks. We knew it all along but this gets it down on wax.

File: sonyniggers.png (755KB, 941x664px) Image search: [Google]

755KB, 941x664px

>>377206508
>2 months and a half
You must be new. Sony ponies are still mad about Ocarina's score and constantly say it's overrated when it did more shit than most games will ever do. They'll stay butthurt 2 decades from now and still insist it's overrated even if other developers think it's a masterpiece.

>>377206508
I'm currently playing botw on cemu and don't even own a Sony system atm, but good projection
Remain a Nintendy dick holster forever lol..

>>377206670
>Which fanbase is most adept at raiding a strawpoll?

>all these anons saying BOTW
finally the dick riding is over. Honestly, the game could've been so much more. I kept saying the game was average as fuck but my opinions were discarded since I wasn't praising it. I still enjoyed playing but it was underwhelming in the end.

Now I know why some people make "now that the dust has settled" threads.

File: lol.jpg (74KB, 800x372px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 800x372px

>>377206707
You were saying?

>>377206703
Sure thing, little buddy

>hurrr this game is shit
>but i'll emulate it

Feels good not to be mentally deficient like you :^)

>>377206795
Wow, that image has convinced me. Y'know, the strawpoll didn't really do it, but this image made in MS paint with arbitrary numbers really has.

>>377206795
>No Kingdom Hearts, Pokemon or MineCraft

>>377206807
>LOOOL YOU CAN'T SAY THIS GAME IS BAD IF YOU HAVEN'T PLAYED IT

>play it

>LOOOL WHY ARE YOU PLAYING IT IF IT'S SO BAD????

>>377206752
>all these sonybros upset at the nintendomination
Sadly, your asshurt will continue forevermore, retard-kun

Your opinion were discarded because you are an idiot, simple as that

Don't worry, there are hundreds of other mongoloids like you on this site, they'll continue making shit threads while the rest of us continue laughing at you

>>377206670
>>377206795
All this tells me is that Nintenfriends are the most vocal and aggressive fanbase on /v/.

File: 1477449016100.jpg (39KB, 467x433px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 467x433px

>>377206895
Nice Reddit spacing, bud.

>>377206893
>be you
>be retarded
sasuga, tard-kun

why are you wasting your time emulating a game you don't like. you got brain problems?

Is Witcher 3 good?

Funny how this is literally the 7th gen all over again but instead the sides are reversed.

The Xbox fanbase had always been the worse. They constantly shat on anything ps3 for a good 2-4 years before they realized they had no more games.
Now the tables have turned and the cycle continues.

Whichever console fanbase has the most will always be considered the most cancerous.

>>377206951
How are you supposed to find out if a game is good if you don't play it, you fucking idiot?

Don't reply.

>>377206807
Please link the lost where I said it's shit, go ahead lol.
Also, I'm not a retarded dick holster (like you lol) that pays for shit that can be gotten for free. Botw is decent, but at 20hr I'm feeling bored already and it's not worth paying good money for one 7/10.

;:^)

>>377206947
Nice asshurt

Wonder how hard it's gonna hit you when the new numbers get released. To be a fly on the wall and see your autistic sperg out...

>>377206670
That shit's outdated. Here, a new one:
http://www.strawpoll.me/12983500

>>377206569
It's good, it's just not up to the standards of a Platinum action game or Yoko Taro experimental narrative adventure game. It's in a tough spot of being only sort of competent at both, but had it excelled at one aspect, it would have made the other aspect pretty much unnecessary.

File: file.png (26KB, 610x182px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 610x182px

>>377207027
>Wonder how hard it's gonna hit you when the new numbers get released.
???

>>377206997
You can use the sonybro way and simply spout random bullshit to assuage the rectal ragnarok

>>377207046
but liking undertale only gets you retard cred, even if you're just pretending

>>377207072
You're not making any sense right now. You're upset that I played the game and don't like it, you literally don't know how to handle it. This is cognitive dissonance at its worst.

>>377207062

Wow the ps4 got almost 50 million retards? well done sony, you know how to market to niggers and other mentally defective trash very well

>>377206895
My opinions were discarded yet now the majority of players have my same opinions. Ironic really.
Nice assumptions btw. I don't even have a ps4. If anything, I'd be a nintentodler since I own a wiiU and switch.
BOTW isn't a fucking 10/10. The game isn't even a 9. It was an 8 AKA average ass game.

File: 1488367307727.png (178KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

178KB, 500x500px

>>377207135
>HAHA WAIT FOR THE NUMBERS HAHAHAHAHAA
>post better numbers
>w-what the fuck? numbers don't mean anything. they're just marketing to idiots h-hahahaha

>>377207127
No little nigger, i find funny that you pretend to play the game even if you say you don,t like it.

Ie, mentally deficient human trash.

But, don't worry, i'll continue laughing at you for the foreseeable future

>>377207181
>i find funny that you pretend to play the game
But I am playing it. I'm emulating it.

>>377207173
It's almost like its 4 years old.

jesus niggah, are you actually as retarded as you appear?

>>377207163
>8 AKA average ass game

Jesus Christ it's becoming real

File: Say my name.png (812KB, 794x661px) Image search: [Google]

812KB, 794x661px

>>377207163
>BOTW isn't a fucking 10/10.

>>377207265
And you give it what exactly?

>>377207250
Okay? It's outpacing the PS2's lifetime sales.

ITT: Extremely butthurt BoTW hating manchildren

>>377207298
By that logic, it should win GOTY this year hands down right?
When it doesn't, I'll have to make some threads shitposting the game hard. See you then.

>>377207371
ITT: cognitively dissonant Nintenbros who WILL NOT tolerate other opinions

The Witcher 3.

>>377207383
But it will, mongoloid-kun

Will you make a thread where you disembowel yourself if it does? I want to see it

>>377207383
>it should win GOTY this year hands down right?
GOTY doesn't mean anything but yeah, it'll win easily. The way critics, people, and other developers talk about this game stands out from other games. They constantly say it's a masterpiece, a classic, redefines the genre, and so on.

>>377198534

persona sucks dude

>>377207409
I don't like it, and that means that the millions who do are wrong . THERE

Also called ''the Autist''

File: 1483953158309.jpg (48KB, 358x513px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 358x513px

>>377207507
>it's popular so it's good

>>377207465
>>377207491
Don't worry we will see. There's nothing to even argue about here. Only time will tell.

>>377207305
It's not about what I give it, it's about what you think numbers mean.

By what possible metric is an 8/10 "average"? Even by modern game review logic that's still considered pretty good.

>>377207524
Its good so it's popular.

Do you need mroe help, kiddy ?

File: this thread.jpg (34KB, 450x415px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 450x415px

>>377198534
The autism here is at maximum levels. What have you done OP

>>377207590
>kiddy ?
keep going ESL-kun

>>377207542
Nope, most average games get an 8. Games that fall short get a 7 or a 6.

The scoring system is the same shit used in school. 5 does not mean average for games. It means the game failed.

>>377207173
Shut up you're supposed to compare to Wii U!

>>377207540
I'm curious what you think the general gaming press will inaugurate as GOTY over Zelda. What else is coming out this year?

>>377207646
Red Dead Redemption 2

>>377207621
I'm sorry, do you prefer kiddo? child? infant?

I'm all for using your pronouns, tard

>>377207590
So Clash of Clans on mobile must be the greatest game of all time then, right? I mean after all it's nearly the most popular game of all time so it must have earned that with it's quality, right?

def Zelda, juat beat it after 45hr:
>Seed collecta-thon.
>Shit weapons and movesets.
>Shit enemies and bosses.
>Shit performance.
>Complete joke of a last boss.
>Fucked-up hitboxes on dodge triggering flurry rush.
>Shitty shrines.
>Divine beasts are all the same.
>Lacking variety in almost every meaningful facet of the game.
>Too much hitstop.
There are your major flaws, but it still got all these 10s... Dunno why.. i like the exploration and all the neat stuff you can do, but there are tons of flaws.

>>377207660
It wouldn't win against Zelda.

>>377198534
>no bloodborne
>no the last of us

>>377207686
That's true, Nintendo fans are pretty cult-like and narrow minded

>>377207660
If this comes out this year then yea.
Even if it doesn't, I doubt BOTW is getting GOTY. It would be great if GOTY was determined by populous vote.

>>377207672
Good so it's popular, mongoloid kun. I already explained it to you.

Just because you post the same old shitposting checklist doesn,t make it true

Again i truly am sorry that a good game cause you so much asshurt, but you need to learn to let go. Nothing you say or do matter, and 10 or 20 years from here people will remember BOTW fondly will you try to threat your prolapsed anus

>>377207660
The first one was fucking garbage(in my opinion). Fuck open world and brown-gray american shooters.

>>377207697
Ape Escape fanboy detected

>>377207757
>Fuck open world
but zelda's cool right?

>>377207757
At least it will have a story unlike BOTW.

>>377207618
pitted 4 fan bases that are notoriously intolerant of criticism against eachother

>>377198534
>trinity
>4 games

>>377207790
Why are you so upset that BOTW is a good game? Please, answer frankly

>>377207775
No.

>>377205704
They have nothing in common.

>>377207618
stirred the sony ponies so they'd release their autismal, impotent rage about botw being GOTY. Nothing special

>>377207872
they have being a shit game in common

Persona and its not even close

Serious question. Why can Nintenbros not handle that some people don't like Zelda?

Why do they view it as a personal attack?

>>377199756
The more popular and praised it got the more the edgy contrarians had to hate it.

>>377207926
It's the Doctor Who of video games

>>377198534
Witcher 3

File: witcher3.jpg (251KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

251KB, 1920x1080px

>>377199756
official witcher 3 review.

all non-quest related things you can find on the world are copy paste boring shit
no one will talk to you unless they are quest related and you have the quest that requires them
awful ui made for consoles and only 2 consumable slots, making alch spec a chore
no resource management, you just instantly get all your potions back for whats essentiallly free
enemys have 1, maybe 2, attack that they repeat over and over, making fights absolutely boring after an hour
level system only works to the games detriment, as youll quickly outlevel everything you have to do and it will all be easier than the game already is
coming across a SKULL WARNING SIGN monster should be exciting but it's not, because you know it fights exactly the same as all the others of its kind, only with more hp.
"cinematic" controls that ignore accuracy in favor of looking more natural
even death march is easy as fuck due to a lack of enemy attack variety and every ability you can spec into being way too strong
ciri sections are boring and unneeded and only serve to rob you of what could have been the one interesting boss fight in the game.
the final moments of the story seem rushed as fuck, from oh hi crones now we fight, to im eredin i have a secret, im dying my secret is this guy tricked us and i had no plan to deal with it, to oh actually geralt i didnt trick you
majority of loot is randomized and scales to your level. Nothing you find really excites you.
all enemies have an extremely short tether that you will cross unintentionally more often than not. At this point they ignore you and start walking back to the center of the area or hang around to get hit easily
witcher senses are only ever used when the quest requires it and is just hold right click to follow quest arrow. you cant actually track monsters or anything out in the world(and why would you need to? theyre all tethered to a small location and never move away)

6/10 game. Had potential, wasted it.

File: 1494905963797.jpg (21KB, 350x464px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 350x464px

>>377207926
Serious question, why do sony drones feel the need to attack masterpiece because they're not on their platform?

File: 1431946172490.gif (478KB, 400x319px) Image search: [Google]

478KB, 400x319px

>>377208065
Serious question, why do you pledge allegiances to companies and brands? Why do you think people can only own one system and that's "their platform"?

Is it because you're from some third-world shithole that can only afford one system?

Serious question.

>>377207846
I'm upset at you fags that think the game is a 10. Idk if you all have just been playing mediocre shit the past few years and dulled down your judgment or what.

I played the game ever since it was leaked before release. I put in 50 hours, 80 if you count me restarting because save was deleted. The game has a lot of flaws and they all add up. On top of that, the performance was pretty shitty. A point off for each and I'm at an 8/10.
I enjoyed my time with the game until it got repetitive and I decided to end it. The ending itself was shit and some of you will defend that too.
I never said the game was bad at all, just that you fags blindly dick ride the game like it changed the gaming genre period. Most of the people aren't shitting on BOTW alone. They're shitting on you blind fans. 10/10 my fucking ass.

>>377207926
I would imagine it's because the people who don't like the game insist that the people who liked the game are wrong to like it.

I mean, isn't that the premise of this thread? Telling people that these games are overrated and that you're wrong if you like them too much?

Zelda

>>377208065
OP asked which was more overrated, people answered, then drones got offended no reason and once again for no reason began their holy crusade to defend Zelda. Maybe if you had used those posts to say one of the other games was overrated, we would have a thread where one of those other games was getting the most criticized, but you didn't.

>>377208030
Nitpicks.
It's one of the longest, largest single player games of the decade, manages to raise the quality bar above other games of similar genre and keep it up from start to finish.
God tier DLC too.

>>377208215
>Why do you think people can only own one system and that's "their platform"?
Because they're poor. /v/int showed this. It was all third worlders. It's sad, really.

>>377208220
8/10 by any reasonable measure is still pretty good though

>>377198534
Witcher 3 by far as its actual gameplay is horrendous

W3 easilly worst game play out of the group. And it's sad how the praise it gets is for the story.

>>377208319
>I never said the game was bad at all
Congrats, you got the point of his post. He likes the game but is still willing to criticize it.

File: 1494679206489.gif (3MB, 300x225px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 300x225px

>>377198534
Horizon Zero Dawn and Nier Automata.

File: sure.png (55KB, 217x190px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 217x190px

>>377208383
Thanks for defending me anon

>>377208292
>Major issues with every aspect of the game
>i-its just nitpicks bro! because its BIG

>>377208030
I stopped at 2 slots, it's 4 retard.

>>377198534
I like all four but out of those I think BOTW and Witcher 3 are the only ones you could actually call overrated.

Witcher 3 gets it's fair share of criticism online some of it deserved, especially any that's focused on boring and trivial combat, on /v/ though it seems people are overly harsh so it seems it might have flipped around to underrated if we're just talking about on here.

BOTW is a great game and easily the best 3D Zelda, but it does lack some of the meaty depth you'd expect. What it does well it does really well, this is one of the best over world maps in any game and it's a joy just to run around fight things, and it does a great job telling the player "there will be something cool over this next mountain just wait" if that thing ever shows up or not. But the game does feels light, none of the destinations are really places you'll spend much time save the very final dungeon, The Shrines, Laberynths, Challenges and even towns are small 5-10 minute distractions, you show up and conquer it before you really even know what it was. Hyrule Castle though is well sized and excellent. You can spend hours in hyrule castle or five minutes and it's really up to the player how much they want to explore it and if there were more places like that in the game of that size it'd be damn near perfect. Again on /v/ people will tell you it's the worst game ever made though so maybe all 4 are underrated.

>>377208494
It was 2 on release.

>>377208030
Now do one for all the other games!

File: 1484411340412.jpg (76KB, 470x531px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 470x531px

Patrician here. Here's the official TW3 review of DLC. Main story sucks ass in the main game. The side story with the Baron is overrated as fuck, the game is big but the combat sucks and that's the main thing you do in these games. Follow yellow or red footsteps isn't gameplay, it's braindead. It's a bad game with high production values, it's like a Hollywood movie. TW2 is superior in every way. The DLC are better but the core issues still remains, bad combat. The combat is so boring I can't take anyone who likes these games seriously.

>>377208570
havent played them

File: 1494989539087.jpg (33KB, 720x447px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 720x447px

>>377198534
None of them

They all are due the praise they get

>>377208613
Oh...
How about ones for re7 or outlast 2? Or I guess just whatever you played last?

File: 1471402933176.jpg (13KB, 245x245px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 245x245px

>>377208626
You're one crazy son of a bitch.

>>377208626
Delete this post please.

>>377208626
Ape Escape faggot detected

>>377208220
>I'm upset at people not having my shitty opinions

Yup, that's autism

File: disc-jam-characters.jpg (187KB, 1199x675px) Image search: [Google]

187KB, 1199x675px

>>377208670
last game i played disc jam
OFFICIAL DISC JAM REVIEW
improvement to windjammers formula by offering complete control of curves, no longer locked to quarter circles and allow backspin as well
-wallskips and stuff block are good mixup mechanics
-visuals leave something to be desired, but american gladiator aesthetic is nice
-doubles mode is great for teamplay but the only team youll find is the one with a faggot hugging the wall and passing to the shooter in the back
-only 1 level
-online only
-dead online

8/10 game, its dead

>>377208906
Does it have local coop?

File: 1468628382470.png (11KB, 420x420px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 420x420px

>>377198534
>Absurdly overrated games
>Bloodborne suspiciously mot posted
Soulsfag bait thread detected

Why does Persona 5 get a pass? It's a friend simulator for anime nerds who don't have any.

>>377208963
i dont know, i dont have any friends

>>377208985
>Muh Ape Escape

File: Autism.jpg (51KB, 514x536px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 514x536px

>>377209048
>>377208835
>Implying this hard

File: 1465259362415.png (942KB, 908x646px) Image search: [Google]

942KB, 908x646px

>>377198534
Ah yes, I truly loved The Redditor 3: Wife's Son

File: 2.png (1MB, 1285x1058px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1285x1058px

>>377208985
I'm a Ninty fan but Bloodborne is great. What's overrated about it? It's superior to TW3 and GTA 5 and on par with Nintendo games.

In the general gaming press, Zelda is most overrated by far. I shouldn't have to explain why.

On /v/, Automata is most overrated by far. People like to pretend it's a masterpiece when the gameplay just isn't very good for it's genre and the narrative has massive dull streaks, dropped plots, and unsatisfactory conclusions all over the place. Ending E aside, the game's story is a total mess.

And don't give me any of that crap that I need to watch the Japanese stage play to truly understand why the Red Dress girl exists or why Adam and Eve literally came out of nowhere. Nier didn't need any of that shit to have a comprehensible plot.

>>377209140
loli fucked detecter