Ok /v/, which one was the superior western game?

>>377088773
Gun was basially what I assumed Red Dead Revolver was going to be. It was a pretty hokey and cartoonish game but i was in 7th grade and it satiated my desire for a western themed GTA style game. I never actually played Revolver though.

>>377088773
Loved both, Red Dead Revolver is more memorable for me though.

Also that god tier opening theme. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZQk0EWvH4R0

>>377088773
Gun was surprisingly good for what it was at it's time. But Red Dead is the more stylish game of it.

>>377088773
Too bad they're both shitty Bloodborne ripoffs

>>377089079
>Gun
>cartoonish

Nigga, go and play Revolver. Then you'll know what's cartoonish.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9uMtRwdUNCg

File: 1455034506018.png (87KB, 300x256px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 300x256px

>>377089298

>>377088773
Gun hands down, doesn't hold that well now but back then it was pretty good game.

File: 1492978253015.jpg (50KB, 599x563px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 599x563px

>>377089298
is this a new meme

>>377088773
Gun because Kris Kristofferson is in it

I only played Gun back when they came out.

Can't remember very much of it but I liked it. I played Revolver a few months ago. That was good too.

>>377088773
Definitely Gun.

File: latest[1].png (2MB, 1599x563px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1599x563px

Are Call of Juarez games any good?

>>377089668
Gunslinger is a nice little game.

>>377089482
Someone's trying to force it real hard anyway

>>377089668
Cartel is trash
1st is meh
The other two are good

>>377088773
None, western games are all cinematic trash for cucked nu-ma-... wait a minute.

>>377088773
gun, duh

>>377089668
I like the first one, it is its own game

The others seem like CoD knockoffs, played bound in blood when it came out and it ruined the franchise for me.

>>377088773
Gun if you want a world to play in and Red Dead if you're into the gunplay.
I played RDR campaigne and multiplayer all the time with NPCs unlocking new characters and bonuses.
Gun, as soon as its over, it's over, nothing to unlock

>>377089668
why do they all look so damn generic

File: Oddworld-Strangers-Wrath-Copertina.jpg (767KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

767KB, 1920x1080px

Does this count as a western?

>>377091017
yeah, a very unique one.

>>377091017
That game is so fucking good.

>hunting shit with bow and arrow in Gun
aw yeah

>>377089668
Bound in blood and gunslingers is 8/10 at least if you fancy spaghetti western games. The thing between both is that one is a serious tone another being a comical tone. But its a fresh change.

>>377088773
Revolver is miles better

Red Dead Redemption 2 maybe coming this year
Sucker Punch rumored to be making a western
Far Cry 5 rumored to be western

wew lad

>>377097217
I heard the FC5 western setting wasn't true and it was going to by a modern day setting. Although i heard that here so it could very well be false.

>>377097217
>calling it Red Dead Redemption 2 when it's the third game in the franchise

>>377097785
Most people have never heard of Revolver, i can see why they did it but i can see why it's also retarded. They're probably treating it like Redemption is to Revolver what Dark Souls was to Demon's Souls.

>>377091017
the first half does

>>377089668
Gunslinger is great, love that game. It has lots of humor, lots of color and doesn't have any stupid stealth sections or escort missions or vehicle sections. It's all about shooting things from start to finish and thankfully the gunplay is pretty good. The guns sound powerful, lots of blood is flying out of dudes and you get a choice between shotguns and rifle/pistols.

The only weak element of the game are bullet spongey bosses and awkward duels.

>>377089668
Enjoyed Gunslinger haven't checked out the others yet.

Is the X360 version of Gun any good?

>>377100285
I have it but i honestly don't remember.

>>377100285
Feels and looks the same as PS2 but with achievements

Curious about the gamecube one though

>>377088773
GUN was a rather generic, small open world game with really awful setpiece battles starring the most bland motherfucker ever. I remember there being multiple memory leaks that make playing for more than an hour at a time result in the game getting really buggy.

Red Dead Revolver was a pretty damn good, campy third person action shooter divided into a variety of missions and starring a handful of dudes you switched between as the story went on. It was a really fun spaghetti western.

I was really bummed that Red Dead Redemption ended up more like GUN (except instead of a small open world it was a big empty open world) rather than a proper sequel to Revolver.