What's your GOTY so far /v/?

>>376950238
Persona 5

Vidya has been genuine shit since Witcher 3 and both expansions. I'm not even being hyperbolic, every single new release has either been disappointing or downright bad.

>>376950497
That's no coincidence. Witcher 3 ruined gaming now that everyone wants to emulate the brainless story driven open world formula.

I want to play original NieR but it's not on pc, what can i play instead that is cracked

>>376950238
Persona 5 bby girl, it might get btfo by rdr 2 or destiny 2 tho

File: prey-coverart-pc.jpg (780KB, 1527x2178px) Image search: [Google]

780KB, 1527x2178px

I'm not joking.

>>376950497
You're telling me that in the last 3 years there hasn't been a single game since Witcher 3 that you enjoyed?
>>376950712
Play God Eater 2
There's a new God Eater coming anyways so its a good game to play while you wait

>>376950238
Persona 5 or Prey, still debating

Yakuza 0

>>376950238
Tie between Yakuza 0, Nier Automata and Persona 5

>>376950497
gaming was dead years before witcher 3 and it's dead again after it

>>376950773
>>376950801
So Prey is actually good?

>>376950885
It just go cracked so find out by yourself.

Um... How has nobody said BOTW yet...?

Nothing so far. I'm still working my way through Persona 5. Haven't played Nier or Prey.

>>376950238
Prey

File: 1468379737810.jpg (28KB, 540x378px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 540x378px

>>376950238
Right now I've mostly been catching up on releases from previous years, but once I get through them, I'll start playing some of this years stuff.

>>376950959
I don't pirate games but I'll give it a buy if this is the case

>>376950980
Because it wasn't very memorable.

>>376950980
Because like... theres only been 10 posts before you...?

prey

>>376950238
Prey, just barely over BotW

>>376950885
Yes, people utterly shitting on it have no idea what they are talking about. Those who recognize the strengths but don't like it for other reasons I valid enough, even if I disagree with some of their issues with the game.

File: electionday.jpg (73KB, 1024x526px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 1024x526px

2015: monster hunter 4 ultimate
2016: pokemon sun/moon

>multiple furbait games
Shit thread.

>>376950885
It's pretty good, if you liked system shock or bioshock at all I recommend it. It's not the second coming of christ like all the journo's say but it's definitely worth a playthrough

File: krabs.jpg (55KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 600x600px

>>376950238
>MGS4
>Good

The things that worry me about Prey are the powers and weapons. The gameplay in general didn't feel smooth from the demo, and the Powers trailer was so bad.

Does the plot pan out?

>>376950238
jesus, your taste descended from good to fucking trash in 17 years

>>376951301
Games aren't suddenly invalidated from being GOTY just because they feature animal characters.
Those games are genuinely good, though some of them (Solatorobo and OneShot in particular) require you to be okay with the games not putting their gameplay on the forefront. OneShot is a walking sim and Solatorobo's gameplay is weak, instead making up for it through worldbuilding and story.

>>376951328
V was so bad I honestly have a pretty favorable view of 4 now.

>>376951350
OP's taste is pretty throwaway. Doesn't get better or worse. I mean shit, he's got 3 Zelda games on there.

File: bait.jpg (84KB, 1372x767px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 1372x767px

>>376951536

>>376951328
are you a 2 or 3 dude?

>>376951328
>>376951521
MGS2 > Red Band > MGS1 > MGS4 > GZ > MGSV > MGS3

>>376951660
5>3
niiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiice meme

>>376951207
The banks and the Jews still won, anon.

>>376950682
>story driven open world formula
isn't it what cRPG genre was supposed to be since its beginning?

>>376951328
>multiple paths to get through a particular area
>more gameplay mechanics than any other MGS game in the series
>can use any weapon you want whenever you want provided you have it
>had the best version of MGO
>visually the most good looking MGS game
>the fight between Liquid and Snake at the end
MGS4 was a good game

>>376951595
A S P E C
Also
2014: Dong Freeze
2015: Xenoblade X
2016: AM2R
2017 so far : NierR Automata

>>376951339
The ending twist is kinda annoying, but eveyrthing leading up to it was good. Honestly play it for the exploration/atmosphere and not the combat, it's passable once you get further in but never turns great

File: 1479438076907.gif (428KB, 748x550px) Image search: [Google]

428KB, 748x550px

>haven't played a single 2017 release game
What am I missing out on?

>>376951595
I don't waste the good stuff on small fry.
I love the series but they really don't do much of anything better than other games, especially not MM, WW and TP

File: 1480727155958.jpg (226KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

226KB, 1920x1080px

>>376950238
>2000-2008
>totally fine and understandleble GOTYs
>2009+
>not a single western game

>>376951604
2 > 3 > 1 >>> V > PW > 4

Kojima should've stopped after 2 but I can't complain too much since Snake Eater is god tier but everything after that was a mistake, glad he's moved on.

>>376951890
botw and your yearly replay of bloodborne

Persona 5. Doubt anything will take the spot.

>>376951923
Why would there be western games?

File: Typ56_collapsed.webm (3MB, 1024x576px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1024x576px

>>376951890
WELCOME TO THE JUNGE

>>376951904
MM does but not WW orTP, I agree.

>>376951872
Do they use the Apartment Window twist often? I really liked that from the demo and it caught me completely off guard, but I immediately thought to myself that they'll pull shit like this every time somebody begins an exposition dump.

>>376951923
>not a single western game post 2009+
what did he mean by this?

>>376951923
>implying that isn't totally fine and understandable

>>376952028
>western game
I'm a retard

>>376950794
Yep. The game i had most fun with since june 2015 probably was Dragons Dogma. When i say that every game i played since W3 was either disappointing or bad i'm obviously comparing it to the enjoyment i got from W3 + expansions and nothing comes even somewhat close to that.

>>376951923
I would ask you to name good western games but I would already know what you are going to say so don't bother with that shit

>>376951306
Anyone who likes System Shock most likely hates every single thing about Bioshock. Prey looks like it falls closer to Bioshock, making it garbage.

>>376952043
MM just does atmosphere and character driven sidequests.

Like that didn't exist 20 years before MM existed, or in books. MM should've been delayed so at the very least the art style and graphics could've been updated, never mind the gameplay.

Of course I'm still waiting for the gameplay to improve, 17 years later

File: EZ.jpg (107KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

107KB, 1280x720px

>>376950238
>2017 NieR Autism
WRONG
>2017 Yakuza 0
RIGHT

Prey desu, not even a shill

>>376952038
>it ain't me starts playing

File: P5_portrait_of_Morgana_Angry.png (88KB, 349x440px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 349x440px

>>376950238
>>376952246
>2017
>Not Persona 5

>>376951923
>>376952028
>>376952072
>>376952115
>>376952204
Freedom Planet and OneShot are both Western games

>>376952246
I love both desu

>>376950238
your taste is so shit im not even sure most of these are actual games

>>376952345
At least they aren't picking western trash.

>>376952345
>Persona 5
>was gonna shit on it
>still better than NieR Automata

>>376951824
And cRPGs are trash.

File: qt3.14.png (3MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1920x1080px

>>376950238
Prey.

>>376952214
>looks
luckily it's closer to System Shock

>>376950682
>now
Where have you been for the last twelve years you fucking doughnut?

>>376952214
no, surprisingly the game doesn't pull many twist except for the end and it's not the apartment window sorta twist. Overall the narrative is pretty linear except for a choice at the end, but I will say your actions with the side stuff do come up later. It's not a very story driven game, you can spend hours just wandering around the station without the game getting on your back

File: Prey-Bad-Review.jpg (29KB, 1024x512px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 1024x512px

>>376952753
I prefer my games not have to have gamebreakinig bugs that prohibit me from playing.

>>376952898
>bug fixed before review published
>update review to an 8.0

>>376951127
Uh... Pretty sure BOTW should have been the first reply.

>>376952425
Majora's Mask is a fantasy oriented action adventure game.
Stronghold is an RTS game with a heavy emphasis on base building based on Medieval Europe.
Metroid Prime is a third person shooter where you explore a dead alien planet.
Windwaker is an action adventure game where you travel the seas.
Cave Story is a sidescrolling shooter where you explore a cave to stop an evil doctor from killing bunny people.
Digital Devil Saga is a JRPG based on Hindu and Christian lore where you turn into cannibalistic demons to eat other demons in order to reach Nirvana.
Twilight Princess is an action adventure game.
MGS4 is a futurisitic third person shooter with an emphasis on stealth.
Devil Survivor is a turn-based strategy game where you get locked into Tokyo for 7 days and have to find a way to save things before demons ruin everything.
Nier is an action/adventure game where you play a father trying to get his kidnapped daughter back.
Solatorobo is an action RPG with a heavy emphasis on worldbuilding and dialogue about furries piloting giant robots.
Xenoblade Chronicles is a JRPG with MMO style gameplay where you fight mecha using a magical sword to keep them from killing everyone.
Pandora's Tower is an action/adventure game where you go through 13 dungeons to find flesh to feed a cursed princess.
Freedom Planet is a sidescroller that's like Sonic x Mega Man X.
Super Mystery Dungeon is a roguelike.
OneShot is a walking simulator where you try to bring a cat back home.
Nier Automata is an action RPG where you play androids fighting robots.

>>376953080
At least we know what Autism looks like

File: My Personal Favorites.jpg (676KB, 1894x910px) Image search: [Google]

676KB, 1894x910px

Prey.

But it's been hard to decide. I mean I love Nioh. Yakuza 0 is great. Persona 5 is wonderful. Battle Brothers is the kind of strategy game I wanted. Zelda BOTW and RE7 were also better than I anticipated.

Love me some immersive sims, though.

>>376953187
>Metroid Prime
>RE4
>MGR
>Shovel Knight
>Rocket League
>Stardew Valley
Pretty gud
>RE6
why tho

File: 1300044776986.jpg (34KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 600x600px

>>376953187
>Love me some immersive sims, though
>Puts Resident Evil 6, an insult to the series, over Dishonored for 2012

>>376950682
>Witcher 3 ruined gaming now that everyone wants to emulate the brainless story driven open world formula.

yeah gta v dont exist and another faggot dont do it before,

>>376950773
This. There's no competition.

File: giraffe blow job.jpg (16KB, 421x500px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 421x500px

>>376953187
>Re6
what the fuck is wrong you?

>>376953372
Dishonored kind of sucked tho

It had a great premise, it just wasn't really well executed. I couldn't find a reason to care about a single character in the game.

not him btw

File: 1491789534867.jpg (101KB, 728x636px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 728x636px

>>376951487
>puzzle/exploration is now know as walking simulators

File: 15320.png (80KB, 316x300px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 316x300px

>>376953187
>Deus Ex
>Saints Row 2
>Resident Evil 6
>Uncharted 2
>Prey

Holy shit taste.
And yes, Deus Ex is shit. Terrible everything, from gameplay to story, and shitty fake """"choice"""" is overrated and not something difficult or even good to do, since it makes the game easy as fuck.

>>376953372
>implying Dishonored isn't an even bigger insult to Thief and Looking Glass.

>>376953571
Forgot about Half-life 2 too, a.k.a basically the creator of the generic FPS.

>>376953545
Most of the time you're just walking around though. You have to spend a good while exploring to find those parts. It has puzzle solving elements, but they're few and far between. Its not like you're constantly solving puzzles for most of the time playing

File: True 2011 GOTY.png (93KB, 638x564px) Image search: [Google]

93KB, 638x564px

>>376950238

What's even that shit on 2011?. Literally who?.

>>376953187
>My Personal Favorites
>implying it's not just "Games /v/ will think I'm cool for liking, except I have RE6 in there to seem somewhat original"

>>376953830
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solatorobo:_Red_the_Hunter

>>376953728
>>376953571
It's one thing to have shitty bait opinions, it's another to take pride in it.

>>376953771
Eh, I just think that putting it on the same category as stuff like gone home gives off the wrong idea. Like, when I think jrpg, I don't think of dork souls.

File: 0z8102.png (273KB, 532x630px) Image search: [Google]

273KB, 532x630px

>>376954015
Where's the fucking argument?

>>376953989

>furries
>RPG

Yeah, no. Not my GOTY by any chance.

>>376950238
It's Breath of the Wild, but I genuinely enjoyed Nioh and Nier as well. I was underwhelmed by Persona despite a great sense of style.

>>376953830
>what is YOUR goty?
>THATS NOT THE GOTY

Are you actually retarded?

>>376954158
That you're a lesser being for taking pride in saying things with the sole motive to get (You)s.

>>376950238
>says NieR was the best game of 2010
>also says NotnieratalL: A Ton of Shit is best game of 2017

You never played NieR don't fucking lie.

>>376954163
>implying a non-licensed Cyberconnect2 game isn't the hypest shit
Every game by that company that isn't a licensed anime game is gold.
If Solatorobo is too furry for you to enjoy, try Asura's Wrath

>>376954356
true goty right here

File: 1160084511.png (117KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

117KB, 500x500px

>>376954258
Not really seeing the argument here.

>>376950238
Tough call as I haven't started persona 5 or Bier and I know I'll enjoy both.


Of what I've played so far it would be prey.

>>376954469
Sorry for your autism.

File: Untitled.jpg (646KB, 1912x890px) Image search: [Google]

646KB, 1912x890px

shitty editing but i guess it can be worse

File: __niijima_makoto_persona_and_persona_5_drawn_by_ryokucha_i_cobalt__29243eb96914da06367d18729e8c8922.jpg (481KB, 2144x3369px) Image search: [Google]

481KB, 2144x3369px

anyone saying anything but persona 5 has shit taste and the brain of a chimpanzee

>>376954469
are you retarded or something?

>>376954015
Half-life 2 had cinematic moments, all those dumb vehicle sections, and several parts were a straight walk from A to B. Obviously nowhere near as linear as a call of duty campaign, but still. The physics puzzles were the only really strong aspect of the game.

>>376954562
>no weeb games
nice list

>>376953359
Resident Evil had gone off the rails with RE4. 5 Couldn't fully commit to the batshit insanity of a Third-Person action shooter, and had a stupid co-op partner.

RE6 is a really solid and fun to play Third Person Shooter

They're all shit

>>376954330
I did
Automata isn't nearly as good as OG Nier but its still a great game. And I haven't played Persona 5, Prey, or BOTW this year so its not like I've played anything that has the potential to be better.

Automata's boss fights aren't nearly as good as OG Nier's, and it doesn't give a purpose to its story quite as well as OG Nier did where you very quickly gained the goal of saving your daughter, and it doesn't change its genre so much as it just goes back and forth between being a shmup and being an ARPG unlike OG Nier which actually did change things up, but it made up for all of this by having better actual combat. It was much faster and smoother and its balancing was a little bit better, where you didn't have hour long boss fights derived from setting the game on Hard like you did on the original Nier.

>>376954564
>weeb friend/waifu simulator
>good

File: 1492566329660.png (159KB, 872x632px) Image search: [Google]

159KB, 872x632px

gotta be honest i immediately close the image and ignore any of the anon's opinions the very moment i see a western game rated highly

>>376954672
>if its Japanese its weeb and thus bad

File: 1123554431001.png (289KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

289KB, 800x800px

>>376954535
>>376954567
I think you don't have the intelligence to make an argument against a simplistic post i made. You may be retarded, sorry.

>>376954672
i like japanese games, mgr almost made it but far cry 3 bd was just too good to ignore, fps, fps/rpg hybrids and rts are my favorites, and since japs can't into these genres..

BOTW

>>376954865

You got that right. The only good japanese games cater to western tastes, like Ninja Gaiden or Resident Evil. The rest is trash.

File: P5-AOA.webm (3MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1920x1080px

>>376954769
>Most stylish game of all time
>Good risk/reward combat
>Solid dungeons
>GOAT soundtrack

>Bad

>>376952854
this is how u know they only played bioshock. they start goin on about about the story. gameplay nigga. SS has a specific gameplay style and setup and a certain kind of map

>>376950238
>Bioshock came out 10 years ago

Christ

File: GOTYs.png (2MB, 1894x848px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1894x848px

30 mins in MSPaint.

>>376954907
I'm with you. Next to Fantasy ARPG/Action-Adventure games, singleplayer FPS games are my jam.

I was about to mention that Shadow Warrior 2 is coming to consoles in response to Nipponland, but it's developed by a fuckin' Polish indie studio of all people.

>>376954872
I'll bite. You know that constantly asking where the argument is also isn't an argument, right?

File: IMG_8227.gif (879KB, 245x230px) Image search: [Google]

879KB, 245x230px

>>376955559

File: 10101010.png (2MB, 1280x1280px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x1280px

i didnt played much games this year.

probably BOTW from what i seen. the gameplay looks so fucking fun

>>376952898
cool, you might want to try out Prey, since it doesn't have that

>>376951928
>2 fanboy
Doesnt Make sense disliking 4, all the faults in 4 are the same on 2.

File: pETazjW.png (108KB, 702x386px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 702x386px

>>376955559
>>376955806
>MGSV

>>376956106
story is shit and gameplay is amazing, get over it

>>376956106
400 hours and I fancy doing my 3rd 100% run soon.

>>376955806
To each his own, but this is pretty much it.

https://youtube.com/watch?v=ABWkPVkOCvk

>>376956257
>get over it
I wish I could.

>>376956257
Level design and A.I. negate the gameplay.

File: tumblr_nj7sxgrrMF1u0tpkho3_1280.png (749KB, 793x588px) Image search: [Google]

749KB, 793x588px

monster girl gamu!

>>376951049

>pirate
>test
>buy/don't buy

in that order

File: 1493742328526.jpg (84KB, 781x1035px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 781x1035px

>>376950238
I think the best game was Yakuza 0, but my favorite is P5. I know neither of them actually came out this year, but I'm counting them both anyway.

>>376950238
shit taste central

>>376956436
>Level design
been able to enter by any level?

>>376956436
A.I
>playing with camo
>playing with assistance
>playing with tranq guns

its your own fault

>>376956257
>stealth/combat mechanics are amazing
FTFY

bad enemy design, bad level design, shit A.I., a myriad of useless features, and countless loading screens don't lead to good gameplay

I've only been playing Elder Scrolls Online so probably that.

>>376956654
>bad enemy design
Enemies literaly change when you use the same tatic again and again
>bad level design
you cant say something that doesnt exist is bad

> shit A.I
Only on easy mode. also infinity heaven can fix that
> a myriad of useless features
you literaly hating on the thing that makes Metal gear games unique
> and countless loading screens
You can skip then on infinity heaven so who cares

>>376954872
Why do I have to argue with you to call you a shithead?

>>376950238
Tales of Berseria - Actually fucking well-written on both a macro and micro level, with great care paid to every aspect of the storytelling that shows itself in the consistency of the characterization and narrative goals.

>>376954564
I am very, very tired of everything the P5 narrative has to offer me. I'm tired of protagonists being rewarded, even celebrated for enforcing their will on the world through violent means, I'm tired of half-assed social links that exist in a state of subservience to the overarching plot, and I'm tired of fucking fighting god at the end. I sunk 110 hours into this game, and I can't say it was worth it. Look elsewhere if you want something that actually enriches your soul or brings joy into your life, because all I felt after spending all that time on P5 was a sense of overbearing fatigue. Any given subplot (say, Eleanor's character arc about her learning to question the system she's a part of) in Berseria is far more nuanced, and, dare I say, relevant, than anything that Persona 5 has to offer. But since Persona is the darling of the media and gaming fanbase, it's the one that gets time in the limelight. Also, the dungeons aren't as good as they're made out to be; there's never really a brain-bending puzzle that stops you in your tracks or a devious trap that sets you back in any meaningful way. This single screen is more challenging than anything in Persona 5's dungeons, and it's just one part of the third to last dungeon: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iet-dBT2G7Q

>>376956991
>enemies literal change when you use the same tactic again and again
Never knew that, but I didn't vary my playstyle that much and I breezed past them
>you can't say something that doesn't exist is bad
>pretending to be retarded
level design means the layout of the bases and the environment in this case
>Only on easy mode
There's an easy mode? The A.I. is still shit on regular
>you literally hating on the thing that makes metal gear unique
No, I appreciate having options. MGSV has guns on top of guns that outdate other ones. It's not a matter of choice then because there are clearly better xyz, in other games weapons are limited to 1-2 of the same type. In MGSV there are like 10 of each type
>Using a mod to fix two major issues
Yes, if you mod shit it can be better, but you have to recognize the actual state the game is in without them. It has glaring flaws that easily make it the worst MGS

File: 2708326-peace-walker-poster.png (2MB, 1440x893px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1440x893px

>>376957517
>make it the worst MGS
Let's not get hasty here.

>Xenoblade
>Pandora's Tower
I like you OP

>>376958043
>there are people that actually played and enjoyed Pandora's Tower
This alone makes me happy
Pandora's Tower is one of the best Zelda games there is

File: 1489520495531.jpg (692KB, 2152x1860px) Image search: [Google]

692KB, 2152x1860px

>>376950980
Because it was the Hillary Cuckton to based Horizon's Donald Trump

>>376950773
Honestly I've been leaning more and more to this

>inb4 bethesdashill.

>>376957623
Should have said worst in the mainline. The side games are definitely worse than all of the mainline games

>>376950238

what kind of pussyass weeb animenigger made that gay fucking image

>>376958214
>Zelda: blue eyed blond hero saving damsel in distress
>Horizon: feminist action game featuring female jesus saving New Tehran

Huh, I wonder which one is more like Hillary...

>>376950238
its gonna be a toss up between Nier A, Digimon Next World Order and Gravity Rush 2,

but then again this year isnt over.

also you're boring as fuck if you pick zelda

File: GOTY, 2012-2017.jpg (347KB, 648x2183px) Image search: [Google]

347KB, 648x2183px

Been a good half a decade so far.

>>376956546
Couldn't you just
>buy
>test
>refund/don't refund

>>376958554
I'm sorry ACfag.

Whats everyone's 2004 game of the year?

and why is it Symphonia?

>>376958750
Jedi Academy.

>>376958750
Snake Eater or KotoR II

File: 1393018756624.jpg (47KB, 386x426px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 386x426px

>>376951660
>MGS3 worst

>>376958659

For what?

>>376955806
MVC2 came out in 2000 ya dingus

>>376958872
>>376959024
>Star Wars games
Is this some meme I'm not in on?

>>376959246
Both Knights of the Old Republics are considered to be two of the finest RPGs ever made.

>>376959223
ps2 version anon

>>376950238
>nier automata
this list was obviously made before it released.

>>376950238
persona FIVE, hopefully Ace Combat 7 comes out this year and is good

2000 - Deus Ex
2001 - Aliens vs Predator 2
2002 - Mafia
2003 - Prince of Persia Sands of Time
2004 - GTA San Andreas
2005 - Psychonauts
2006 - Okami
2007 - Mario Galaxy
2008 - Portal
2009 - Assassin's Creed II
2010 - Lara Croft and the Guardian of the Light
2011 - Rayman Origins
2012 - Legend of Grimrock
2013 - Metal Gear Rising Revengeance
2014 - Alien: Isolation
2015 - Dying Light
2016 - Doom

2017 - haven't played many, but Hollow Knight is up there

>>376950238
>2000-2009
Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn
Ace Combat 04: Shattered Skies
The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
FIFA Football 2004
The Sims 2
Battlefield 2
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
Spore
Dragon Age: Origins

>2010-2017
Fallout: New Vegas
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Guild Wars 2
Grand Theft Auto V
Dragon Age: Inquisition
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
fifa 2017
Red Dead Redemption 2 (?)

File: 1334871127274.jpg (32KB, 467x325px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 467x325px

>it's a GOTY thread
The best threads on /v/ are /vr/worthy threads. Really makes you think.

>>376959673
Norrrrrrmieeeeeee

>>376958554
Can you post your whole chart, I need a good look at it again.

>>376959246
Jedi Knight games were great you underage fuck, a lot better than many SW games that get attention like Republic Commando, any Dark Forces or JK game shits all over that game.

>>376950872
Including Witcher 3 though, but 4chan just right place for shit eaters of the world.

Persona 5

Prey 2nd

>>376960260

Which year?

>>376960613
This year

Here's mine

2000 - FF IX
2001 - Advance Wars
2002 - Don't know
2003 - Fire Emblem
2004 - Metroid ZM
2005 - DQ 8
2006 - Don't know
2007 - Phoenix Wright T&T
2008 - Don't know
2009 - Pokemon Platinum
2010 - Pokemon HG/SS
2011 - Ghost Trick
2012 - Xenoblade
2013 - Super Mario 3D World
2014 - DKC TF
2015 - Splatoon
2016 - AM2R
2017 - BOTW

>>376953187
How do you go from having great taste 2000-2007, and then just end up having massive shit taste continuously throughout 10 years

>>376952242
>at the very least the art style and graphics could've been updated
That's exactly what happened, my dude.

File: 1490565922284.jpg (81KB, 1024x576px) Image search: [Google]

81KB, 1024x576px

>>376950238

Gravity Rush 2. Kat's mai waifu though so of course her game is the best. Certainly doesn't hurt that said game allows for all sorts of gravity shenanigans and that I thought the original was a diamond in the rough back on Vita. It's more of what I loved but bigger and better - works for me.

File: GotY.png (914KB, 1348x601px) Image search: [Google]

914KB, 1348x601px

>>376950238

Nier Automata, so far. Don't see it staying there though.

File: best of 2017.jpg (977KB, 2472x2140px) Image search: [Google]

977KB, 2472x2140px

>>376960729

>>376954356
Underrated post
Should've added Moonbase Alpha at the end though

>stronghold

YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

File: 1490817807562.jpg (515KB, 1000x2984px) Image search: [Google]

515KB, 1000x2984px

>>376950238
either Nier tomato or Persona 5 for me

>>376961229
>1993
>Kirby's Adventure better than Doom
Considering your other choices on the list, this is fucking flabergasting.

>>376951836
you have to remember. most of the people who call 4 shit never even played it. they are just little bitches

>>376961287
>this much autism

>>376961412
he likes dark souls, of course he has shit taste

File: 1442801738870.png (240KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

240KB, 640x480px

>>376961287
Thanks, I needed that today.

>>376954562
>Ass Creed on any GOTY list
Seriously where are all you normalfags coming from, and coincidentally you all have Prey on your (((GOtY))) list. Really making me fire up those synapses.

>>376950238
For Honor

>>376960730
>AM2R
He said Game not romhack

File: GOTY 2000-2017.png (2MB, 1680x772px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1680x772px

>>376950238

>>376962069

It's not even in the same engine, genius.

>>376961739
What happened to that game anyways?
>>376962113
Very good.

File: second.jpg (34KB, 468x351px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 468x351px

>>376962113

>>376962171
It's still not a game.

>>376962192
they removed maps out of nowhere and haven't attempted to fix the connection issues

File: 1494746824963.png (169KB, 375x375px) Image search: [Google]

169KB, 375x375px

>>376961657
Both games are solid, don't cry over someone's opinion.

File: Collection.jpg (4MB, 4592x7048px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 4592x7048px

Rose in the Twilight

>>376950794
Souls/borne saga > Witcher 3
kill me if you want

>>376950238
Dawn of War 3

File: 1447440584476.jpg (19KB, 293x190px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 293x190px

>>376953187
>Rocket League
>Prey
>MGR
you, I like yo-
>RE6

>>376962492
Wrong
>>376962192
They've fixed most connection issues but it's still mediocre in that regard. They had to remove two maps to patch them, but they've been back in for a while. Season two is starting so the console population is growing, PC population isn't changing much. Has around 60k on PS4, 15k on Xbone and 5k on PC.

>>376962485

By what metric? Not enough funding from a corporate boardroom executive?

File: vomit from all holes.jpg (46KB, 312x312px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 312x312px

>>376962747
Utterly pathetic

File: 1494375218342s.jpg (4KB, 250x140px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 250x140px

Either BotW, Persona 5, or Puyo Puyo Tetris. Completely honest with that last one.

my game :3

Its honestly BoTW. That comfy level is insane. There's still over 7 months to go though.

>>376954562
pretty much EA games. No. it can't get any worse than this, anon.

>>376950238
nothing worth getting has come out yet.

Breath of the Wild

Super Mario Brothers 2

>>376963541
GOTY 12 YEARS RUNNING LADIES AND GENTLEMEN

>>376963541
this

>>376950238

that was clearly made by a furfag

and i can't decide between P5, Zelda, and Nier Automatictomato. probably Nier, I played it first of the three and yet its stuck with me a little better that the other two

File: 1462923419285.png (439KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

439KB, 400x400px

2000 - Thief 2
2001 - Soul Reaver
2002 - Arx Fatalis
2003 - Prince of Persia Sands of Time
2004 - Unreal Tournament 2k4
2005 - FEAR
2006 - The adventures of Sir Kickalot and the slippery floor
2007 - Super Mario Galaxy
2008 - DMC 4
2009 - Bayo
2010 - Fallout NV
2011 - Dark Souls
2012 - Dustforce
2013 - Metal Gear Rising
2014 - The Talos Principle
2015 - Rocket League
2016 - Dishonored 2
2017 - Prey

look at all these nerds putting nier as their 2010goty even though none of them even heard of it before automata

>>376958554

>the desolate hope

good taste, my friend

Night in the Woods

File: C6LWXuzXMAQAvwj.jpg (55KB, 719x771px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 719x771px

>>376950238
At least finish Automata before you rank it chili

File: 1490547290726.jpg (521KB, 2048x1384px) Image search: [Google]

521KB, 2048x1384px

>>376950238
good taste you got there OP Nier Automata is goty

>>376963336
Thanks for pointing that out, it seems that EA actually made plenty of great games in the past.

Automata

Any other year, Nioh or GR2 would have taken it. OR maybe Specter of Torment.

This has been a wonderful year.

>>376963113

hey that's pretty good

>>376963541

gtfo dunkey

File: 1493326006945.jpg (119KB, 989x1200px) Image search: [Google]

119KB, 989x1200px

Gravity Rush 2.

Didn't like NieR or Zelda so far. The year started off great, but man, it's not going so great.

>>376964553
I'm sorry you have such shit taste

File: 20170429091136_1.jpg (71KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

71KB, 1920x1080px

Tales of Berseria. Easily. I haven't given a shit about characters in a JRPG in too damn long and chaining Demon Hand combos was more fun that I could have expected.

>>376956539
OwO wat's dis

>>376964553

i didn't play GR2 but the second half of 1 when it starts to focus on combat was utter garbage. i heard the second game didn't improve on that aspect very much beyond a few different attacks, so I don't see how you could like it better than zelda or nier unless you didn't play them.

i mean, shit, both of those games even have better waifus than GR2. literally no excuse

>>376964553
Shit tastes

>>376964987
he hasn't played them, I fucking guarantee it. he's trying too hard to fit in

Amorous

File: goty_list.jpg (666KB, 1894x907px) Image search: [Google]

666KB, 1894x907px

Definitely Prey for me. I just like these type of games and it was really solid.

Does it have to be from this year?

>>376965373
I must commend you for being the first anon to put Silent Hill 2 under the 2001 slot in this thread.

>>376961287
>games that arent even out yet
?????

This board's tastes have truly gone to absolute shit. I don't know what's worse, that no one has listed Hollow Knight or that people are unironically suggesting tripe like persona and BotW.

>>376965649
>Reasoning with ACfag
He calls Bayonetta and DMC cinematic experiences.

>>376964987
>i heard the second game didn't improve on that aspect very much beyond a few different attacks

Not him but what? It absolutely improved combat by fucking miles.

It's a far cry from Bayo or something but that's not really the point of GR anyways

File: 1493268456466.jpg (83KB, 1024x1024px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 1024x1024px

>>376965191
>>376964775
>>376964987
GR combat ain't special, but I dunno why anyone would say NieR or BotW has better combat.

NieR
>fancy, deep, and useless mechanics
Zelda
>muh WiiU physics and whoa I didn't know you could do that in the game combat when you can just pull, drag, spin around and kill

Also
>better waifus

Nah.

>>376965521
I was going to put MGS2 but I just like SH2 more honestly. 2001 was a great year

>>376958646
Couldn't you just
>pirate
>
>

File: gamesIlike.jpg (1MB, 1894x910px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1894x910px

Pardon my unrefined taste but.. what about games where you had fun?

File: mea.gif (3MB, 440x243px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 440x243px

>>376958214
>Horizon, a game that is feminist/SJW love letter is like trump
>BOTW, Doesn't pander much
Sure.

>>376952214
Both of those games are awesome. I lean towards Bioshock, but both are great.

>>376966004
MGS2 would be my pick but SH2 is a close second.

>>376966206
Fun is just a buzzword when you can't actually think of any real reasons as to why the game is good, don't use it.

>>376962828
Resident Evil 6 is a guilty pleasure, but it really is a solid action game.

File: SS Von Braun.png (329KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

329KB, 640x480px

So I hope Prey 2 takes place aboard an FTL starship controlled by an AI, now that we explored a space station in Prey

>>376965649

>corporate entity releases nonstop trash for a decade
>"but I'm sure this time it'll be gold!"

File: opinions.png (1MB, 1912x890px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1912x890px

Yeah I'm a normie who likes stories.

Wanna fight about it?

>>376966617
Well_memed.jpeg

But really, what about games that give you that visceral feeling of "Aw yeah! This is good!" when you play them? Mass Effect 3 was fucking burning trash but playing the multiplayer with friends was fun.

>>376965929
>muh meme
>assuming i like nier
>waifufaggotry

kill yourself

File: Shadow-Tactics-Blades-of-the-Shogun[1].jpg (283KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

283KB, 1920x1080px

I haven't played that many games this year, but I enjoyed Shadow Tactics. Shame it's the kind of game that you play just once (for me, anyway). I got my $30 out of it though, was dying for a Commandos fix.

>>376967037
>Halo over Final Fantasy X
>Metal Gear Solid 4

>Likes stories

>>376965929
>GR combat ain't special, but I dunno why anyone would say NieR or BotW has better combat.

um no. GR combat is a shitty slog. it's literally just about positioning yourself to gravity kick shit over and over, the same 5 or 6 enemies. i really like the first half of GR with those separate levels that you'd explore with just a little combat mixed in, but the second half was genuinely shit, I almost dropped the game after the time skip thing because there was literally no exploration anymore, all combat.

>i dunno why anyone would say Nier or BotW has better combat

ok now i know you're trolling. GR combat is garbage without even comparing it to anything, let along competent games.

>>376950238
Zelda

>>376965929

>Also
>>better waifus
>Nah
>but i'm gonna keep posting Kat dressed as the superior waif

Kat is flat. FLAT!

>>376965929
um, you're wrong sweety

>>376950238

Holy fucking shit OP your taste is so fucking bad, literally shit tier. Your only non bad choice is 2001, because Stronghold is a good series, but fuck even then there were much better games in 2001.

OP I seriously recommend suicide. It might help you with your bad taste condition.

>>376968017
All of his choices 2001-2007 are good though.

File: 1486213935140.jpg (45KB, 1024x1024px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 1024x1024px

>>376967065
>>376967421
That's her charm point.

>>376967293
I didn't compare its combat to other games. I did compare GR2 to NieR and Zelda in that I liked GR2 and not the other two. And NieR's a shitty open world game with empty barren areas you have to go find shit to do in, just like Zelda. If their combat is better, which I don't think they are, you are actually restrained in how much of that combat you can do. Which is a weird thing to limit something a game apparently does well. As for competence, they all seem competent enough.

>>376967772
And here I was about to bess post.

>>376950238
>NieR
>a good game
You're a fucking mongoloid if you believe this. It had good writing but pretty much everything about the gameplay was horrendous. I agree with Automata being here though.

>>376950238
Dark Souls 3

File: 1474975623735.gif (447KB, 500x333px) Image search: [Google]

447KB, 500x333px

>>376953187
>I like this anon he's got good ta-

>RE6

>>376967037
>likes stories
>Overwatch

You beat yourself

>>376950238

>2000
Dues Ex/Spyro 3
>2001
MGS2/Return to Castle Wolfenstien
>2003
R&C2/Jak 2
>2004
MGS3/VtMB
>2005
God of War/SW Battlefront 2
>2006
Company of Heroes/Lego Star Wars 2
>2007
God of War 2/Stalker SoC
>2008
Dead Space/COD World at War
>2009
Demon's Souls/Men of War
>2010
God of War 3/Bioshock 2
>2011
Men of War: Assault Squad/Lego Star Wars 3
>2012
Hard Reset/COD Black Ops 2
>2013
RO2 Rising Storm
>2014
Men of War Assault Squad 2
>2015
Nothing
>2016
Nothing
>2017
Nothing

>>376968240

No they are fucking garbage choices, his 2000-2007 choices are actually the most offensive ones there, excluding 2001.

2008 was a really fucking bad choice too though. The bottom row is less offensive because at least he has the excuse that the golden age was over and there were less good games released on those years, the entire top row is just unexcusable bad taste however.

File: a69637042006bf89a3e9f0d8d8e1262e25ff3dc78bfe55bbd9be34232de57d68.jpg (57KB, 525x503px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 525x503px

>>376950773
This. Honestly dont see how others can compete. The only other one I would consider is Nier Automata.

>>376950885
Yes. Most of the hate on /v/ comes from people wanting to bitch about how it's not Prey 2. The game is pretty damn good but it's not like it's the second coming of christ.

>>376969486
>No they are fucking garbage choices
No they aren't.

>>376956257
>Amazing gameplay
>Tranq weapons turn every mission into a boring cakewalk

Nah

>>376969798

There were so many god tier games released between 2000 and 2007, and those are the ones he picks. Garbage taste.

>>376969928
I know it's really hard to deal with when someone likes something popular that you don't like Anon, but I'm going to have to ask you to take a shower, put on pants and a belt, wear deodorant for once, and leave the house.

I'm only asking this because it's mothers day and I'm sure you could give yours a moment to drink too much wine and forget that you exist for a couple hours because watching the desperate housewives of orange county is infinitely more comforting than your presence.

I hear mcdonalds has super mario toys this time of year, why don't you go out and get a happy meal?

>>376950238
Yakuza Zero. It's also the only thing I've played from 2017 but I did like it a lot

>>376970382

Kek. Mothers day was yesterday you disgusting overweight burger, or did you pass out in the mart again after walking into the whiff of a particularly bad shart.

I drove to my mums yesterday after buying her a gift. Today my girlfriend is visiting me and I am shitposting here while waiting for her to drive over.

>>376950497
Witcher 3 is the most overrated game of the decade

>>376969284

I don't exclusively like RPG's, and besides

2016 was a REALLY bad year for games

File: Screenshot (447).png (2MB, 1600x900px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1600x900px

Im about to get hated on so much for this.

>>376970828
>forgetting that multiple time zones exist on the planet earth

I know it's really really tough when someone says something you don't like Anon, but I'm going to have to ask you to put on some acne cream, put away the fleshlight and astroglide, and go out for a little bit.

I'm only asking this because it's mothers day and I'm sure you could give the government a bit of a break by getting a job instead of relying on neetbux and buying old games so you can capture a false sense of "old school importance".

I hear mcdonalds is hiring this time of year, why don't you go out and apply?

>>376971390

Despite having Bioshit Infinite in it, the bottom row is actually better selected than the top row.

>>376954564
P5 treats the player like it has a brain of a chimp.

>>376969821
then dont use then?

>>376971647
Don't know whether to take that as an insult or not, also eh Infinite isnt as good as the first, but that year it just stood out the most and was the most enjoyable so.

>>376971390
>Banjo Tooie
Gonna need an explanation on this steaming pile of mediocrity when games like Majora's Mask and Deus Ex launched in 2000 as well.

>>376971390
i cant tell if this is bait or not

>>376955138
>shit story

>>376971852
B-BUT ANON IT EXISTS IN THE GAME SO I HAVE TO USE IT! IT MAKES THE GAME TOO EASY IN A WAY THAT I DON'T LIKE BUT GOD DAMN IT I HAVE TO USE IT

THE GAME FORCES ME TO USE IT

BAD GAME

>>376971942
Never played MM and i never liked Deus Ex much.
>>376971943
Nope. I said i knew i was gonna get hated on but i dont care cause i still enjoy those games, just be glad i didnt put Starfox Adventures on there.

>>376969928
>Being this much of a contrarian
What would your picks be for 2000-2007 then?

>>376972109
starfox adventures would had been the least of your problems pal

>>376962485
>>It's still not a game.
/v/ users are some of the dumbest motherfuckers on the planet.

File: GOTY.png (11KB, 273x317px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 273x317px

>>376950238

>>376972126

Why, so you can shit on them?

Well go ahead. >>376969351 That's me.

File: Casual Taste.jpg (605KB, 1957x891px) Image search: [Google]

605KB, 1957x891px

>>376950238

I did my best

>>376972607

What the fuck went wrong anon, you started off so strong and then descended into pleb shit faggotry halfway through, doesn't really look like you recovered either though 2014 looked like you were starting a recovery.

RIP in piss anons tastes.

File: Edward Kelley.jpg (20KB, 220x232px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 220x232px

Nioh, I guess. I wanna try Prey and P5, but haven't gotten around to them yet.

>>376950238
Was 2009 really such a shitty year Devil Survivor is at the top?

>People saying Yakuza Zero or Persona 5

Those games did not come out this year.

>>376973012

Pretty impressive, only one shit game on your list.

File: 1454126242297.jpg (281KB, 560x582px) Image search: [Google]

281KB, 560x582px

>>376973012
>casual
nah man that's some prime taste right there

>>376972939
>Three God of War games
>No DMC, God Hand, Ninja Gaiden or Bayonetta
Rest is fine though.

>>376950238

lmfao what a shit collection.

File: 1489670814_save the world2.png (396KB, 1100x1074px) Image search: [Google]

396KB, 1100x1074px

>>376950238
Nioh. I applaud your 2015 and 2016 choices, though.

>>376973301
It's only important when it comes out in the west

>>376973442

Just curious, which one do you think was shit? Some years I really struggled with (lots of good shit in 2003 and 2010).

I will fully admit Forza 4 isn't that good, but I spent pretty much the entire year playing Tag mode with my friends while learning about cars from Jeremy Clarkson. I'd never even watched Top gear before that, it kinda got me into cars. As SP game it's horrible though.

I was very close to picking Dark souls, Battlefield 3 (another game colored by my MP experiences though) or Bastion, which might have had the best soundtrack of any game.

>>376973897

I've never played Forza for longer than a few minutes so I can't comment, but it was Red Dead Redemption.

I just don't get the love for that game. It was just another empty open world. I got bored of that genre a long time ago, maybe I was already bored with it by 2010 and that's the game that broke the camels back, I don't think I've even bothered with another open world game since RDR either.

Also people overrate the story and setting, and the gameplay is just stock and underpar, even for a rockstar game. Gun is a much better open world game (because it has literally 0 padding and the map is just the right size with no excess travel, and it's certainly not empty like RDR was) and a western, and Call of Juarez is a better western as well though not really open world.

The rest of your list is good though. FEAR and Dark Messiah are especially fantastic as well as KOTOR.

File: 1255745485210.jpg (367KB, 1280x960px) Image search: [Google]

367KB, 1280x960px

2000- Majora's Mask
2001- Castlevania: Circle of the Moon
2002- Eternal Darkness
2003- Prince of Persia: Sands of Time
2004- Doom 3
2005- Timesplitters: Future Perfect
2006- Gears of War
2007- Halo 3
2008- Dead Space
2009- Borderlands
2010- Fallout New Vegas
2011- Alice: Madness Returns
2012- Harvest Moon: A new Beginning
2013- Nothing
2014- Just Cause 3
2015- Shovel Knight
2016- Far Cry Primal
2017- Nothing so far

For some reason I couldn't think of a single 2013 game I liked.

>>376950238
Has anyone ever made a list like this going back all the way to even the 80's?

>>376970936
Wish people could see this. Is it good? Yes. Is it Christ's second coming? No.

File: 1450911345401s.jpg (7KB, 216x250px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 216x250px

>>376974808
>Not liking A Link Between Worlds

>>376974590

>it was Red Dead Redemption

I get that. The game is overrated but I was really into western shit at the time, I really liked the gun fights on horseback too. It was kind of a toss up, I nearly went with a bunch of different games like Mass Effect 2 or Metro 2033. Even Dante's Inferno was a close call just for that crazy art style.

I agree with you about Gun though, I loved that shit.

File: Banjo-Tooie-3.jpg (32KB, 464x450px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 464x450px

>>376971390
It's kind of a weird list but I can't hate on a fellow Banjo Tooie fan.

>>376975467
Never got around to playing it

>>376950497
No sweetie, you just have bad taste.

>>376950238
>2000
Majora's Mask
>2001
MGS2
>2002
GTA Vice City
>2003
Prince of Persia: Sands of Time
>2004
MGS3
>2005
Shadow of the Colossus
>2006
Twilight Princess
>2007
Mass Effect
>2008
Saints Row 2
>2009
Uncharted 2
>2010
Deadly Premonition
>2011
Sonic Generations
>2012
Spec Ops: The Line
>2013
Saints Row IV
>2014
South Park: The Stick of Truth
>2015
Mortal Kombat X
>2016
Final Fantasy XV
>2017
Nothing

I've barely played any newer games.

>>376950497
What a sad view of gaming

File: Animorphs.jpg (171KB, 1920x1030px) Image search: [Google]

171KB, 1920x1030px

>>376951848
>Xenoblade X
my nigga knows

>>376950238
>stronghold
Finally a man with taste

>>376951890
BotW, but honestly of every game this year BotW is going to age like wine, so take your time cus it'll always be there. You will be missing out on the water cooler conversations of "I didn't even know I could do that!" which is what has sold it as my GOTY 2017

>>376950682

>story driven open world formula

But Zelda BOTW is the complete opposite of that

File: 4.jpg (157KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

157KB, 600x600px

>>376950238
Yakuza 0

>>376950817
>>376950823
>>376952246
>>376953187
>>376956552
>>376970492
>>376973301