Witcher 3 is a bad game

Well I think Witcher 3 is a good game

Okay, thank you for your opinion. Now please kindly kys.

>>376716128
Best game

It's quite unremarkable but the graphics leave a very good impression and there's a lot of dialogue.

Press your Witcher Senses button to type your rebuttal

>>376716128
false

>>376716219
This.

>>376716128
>overrated
yes
>bad
no

though ill say my experience was about a year after it was released and because of the hype it was underwhelming for me but with such shit games lately it was still very fun

Witcher 3 is an overrated game.

It has alot of great aspects to it, but the combat and general character movement is too wonky for it to deserve all that critical acclaim.

The main story was also very weak.

>>376716583
>>376716557
Overrated is a fucking stupid word.
>People like this thing more than I think they should
People like something as much as they do, that's that.

>>376716583
>The main story was also very weak.

>have dedicated book author and script writer
>W1 is amazing story wise
>fire him for W2 decide to westernize the story
>classical hurrr monster hunter
>whatever the W3 was

>>376716649
that's not what i was saying i said with all the praise it had gotten my experience would never be able to live up to it

>>376716649
Does it surprise you that people who don't like TW3 use blanket terms?
There's really not much shitposters can get on with it. Since even fans agree that the combat is a weakness. And everything else needs to be covered by blanket statements, because it has no footing.

>>376716649

No.

My tastes are more objective and reasonable.

Witcher 3 got praised for all the wrong reasons, but people still fawn over it because it's the little franchise that could.

>see what all the hype is about
>10/10 game according to fucking EVERYONE
>/v/ says it's bad but don't listen because everythig /v/ says is wrong
>buy game a year late
>play it
>100% daughterfu/waifu pandering
>100% wonky movement
>it sucks
it sucks

>>376716806
Not him but I only started a week ago and all the hype seems to be justified so far. I've never seen a game designed so coherently and ripe with detail and attention.

File: solomon in the shitter.jpg (17KB, 454x276px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 454x276px

Is it red or is it dead?
Better to just remove the nightmare
Pumpkin soup no problem
On the other hand there's lobotomy
Don't mind the bird floating above your head
It's not like Jesus ever give you a green hand

Yennefer is incredible. She's ALL pussy.

>>376717015
She's a sour pussy yeah

>>376716991
*sigh

i didn't say i didn't think its a good game it was my 2015 goty but if i had just picked it up without hearing about it i would have been surprised by everything

>>376716936
Post coherent b8 next time plz

>>376717232
I get that, I was just stating that it depends on the person. For me the hype didn't deflate the experience. Thats all.

Too bad quest design is absolute garbage and there's not a single challenging quest because the game handholds you through everything.

No, Witcher 3 is a good game.

Disclaimer: This shillpost has been paid for by CD Projekt S.A. and the views and opinions expressed may not reflect those of the poster.

>>376717416
>Too bad quest design is absolute garbage
>he didn't like following the flying fetus
Opinion discarded. Not that there was much to go with anyway.

Probably a bit overrated, but still an amazing game imo. Great quests, great story, great world. Honestly the only thing dragging it down is the combat against human enemies. All their fucking blocking and parrying is really annoying. good thing you can break the combat and be a walking/spinning death machine

The game is very good. Numerous 10/10 and GOTY awards are a proof of that.

>>376717416

quest were supposed to be immersive as fuck in this game, not challenging. what did you expect, puzzles? it's a story focused game first and foremost

>>376716128
Pretty much the only game I've played that deserved every bit of praise it gets.
I'm glad I forced myself through the slog that was TW1 and that "play once never touch again" thing that TW2 was supposed to be, so that I could feel the improvement. TW3 is rightfully regarded as a master piece. And I'm glad that it is. Even the fucking side quests are amazing and feature more detail than other games' main stories. Contrarians like you don't even bother me much.
TW3 is on the safe side in history.

>>376717717
>All their fucking blocking and parrying is really annoying
Press L2 and done.

The combat is mediocre, but works well enough
Graphics are pretty nice
Main story is good
Really good sidequests
Expansions are nice

Overall a good game

>>376716128

It's a good game. DLC is exceptional.

>>376717642
literally guides you to your next objective

Best

File: 1478744845312.gif (2MB, 380x340px)

2MB, 380x340px

Witcher 3 was the second best game of it's year.

>>376718010
Are you saying that following the fetus actually had a purpose? Ayo hold up! So let me get this straight; you followed something to actually get somewhere? Huh.... well I never...

>>376716128
8/10
If it had cuhrayzee combat then it would be 10 but I give 8 because it is a game and not a movie and gameplay in a game is the most important part
Story and ost is a 10/10

>>376718151
>inb4 fallout 4

>>376718180
it's still bad game design

>>376718282
>following someone leads somewhere
>bad game design
Well of course. What was I expecting?

File: FEikw3bXVHdMk.gif (2MB, 200x150px)

2MB, 200x150px

>>376716128
Nope.

>>376717860
>immersive
What the fuck does this even mean.
And how the fuck is analyzing red clues and following red footsteps for 120 hours immersing?

>>376717642
No, not really.

>>376717860
What?
So, if a game is focused on story, it can't have anything remotely challenging?
What the fuck?

File: 29c[1].jpg (39KB, 649x480px)

39KB, 649x480px

>>376716726
>W2
>classical hurr monster hunter
???

>>376716128
They actually did it. They actually fucking made a game about Reddit. No dog whistles, no allusions, just pure straight Reddit pleb shit. Every fucking line is a meme. EVERY SINGLE ONE. There isn't one joke or quote in this game that wouldn't get you at least 50 upvotes. If you were a Bernie Sanders supporter, this game is for you. If you own a fedora this game is for you. If you like taking turns with your girlfriend getting rammed in the ass by imported black cock this game is for you. If you're a normal fucking person who votes Republican and enjoys games about ideas, characters, and interesting settings this piece of shit game is not for you and given the fact that there are no games like that anymore because critics and audiences can't get enough of the meme mary sue medieval fantasy shit you're better off just finding another hobby or killing yourself.
Fuck Reddit, fuck memes, and fuck whoever likes this piece of shit game.

>>376718512
>the state of consciousness where an immersant's awareness of physical self is diminished or lost by being surrounded in an engrossing total environment

>>376717717
>abusing boring whirl instead of bombs and potions
>not being behind two decoctions and at least 4 potions at all times

>>376718776
And how is TW3's completely unchallenging and boring quest design ''immersive''?

>>376716219
fpbp

>>376718576
>No, not really.
Oh yes.

>>376717717
>Great quests
Yeah, remember this one where you analyze red clues in a cave?
And where you analyze red clues in a house?
And when you follow red footsteps in a forest?
God, so awesome.

File: 1494449413289.png (12KB, 108x108px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 108x108px

>>376716128

Heres your (you) you desperately want with complimentary reaction image

>>376718818
Did you even read the post, or could you just not comprehend it? Because your question couldn't be more besides the point.

>>376718857
What is fun about following things?
You followed that blue flying baby, you found a drowner or a wolf every couple of minutes.
That's it.
That's the definition of fun to you?
Did you enjoy Mass Effect Andromeda too?

>>376716128
It's just your opinion.

>>376718895
>big smelly willy

>>376718819
>le first le post le best le post

When did reddit take over?
Why do people speak like redditors in here?
What's next?
'Sigh'? '*action*'? 'HMMMMM'?

>>376718873
Remember that part in Doom where you walk and shoot? Remember that part in Tetris where you rotate the pieces around one axis and move them along another?

>>376718279
No it was Undertale

>>376719031
>not the first post by this IP
>still replies to the OP
Someone's mad.

>>376719050
And those requiered a semblance of skill, unlike getting close to red stuff and pressing a button.
Where are the challenging quests?
Is there a single quest that doesn't completely handhold you and tell you exactly what to do, where to go and how to solve ''puzzles''?
Seriously, I was yesterday doing one in Novigrad exploring some house for Djikstra.
It told me to solve the puzzle to open the secret passage in it.
You know what it was?
Using my Batman vision to find a book in a small room with pretty much nothing else in it, and putting it exactly where it told me to.
That's a puzzle according to TW3.

>>376718950
>What is fun about following things?
Are you asking if it was fun to find out whats happened to the Red Baron's wife? Yes it was. We dug out the fetus, did a ritual and I followed it to the site where she was dragged off. Then I went to Novigrad(took my time riding slow to marvel at the amazingly designed open world) and found out that she joined the witch hunters and that her mother was dragged off by a fiend, as it turned out later, because she made a pact with the crones. Yes anon, that was quite a lot of fun.
>Did you enjoy Mass Effect Andromeda too?
wut?

>>376716128
One of the best games I've played desu. Really enjoyed the main storyline and the latest dlc. I hope they allow you to have some of those vampire powers in their next game.

>>376719230
>Is there a single quest that doesn't completely handhold you and tell you exactly what to do, where to go and how to solve ''puzzles''?
No, because that shit is outdated grandpa. We don't want to artificially turn a +80hr game into an 800hr game just so we can pat ourselves on the back walking around aimlessly for hours and solving a McDonalds Happy Meal tier puzzle ourselves.
Get on with the times.

>/v/: UGHH I MISS WHEN GAMES WERE ALL ABOUT GAMEPLAY AND NOT MOVIES UGH
>*consistently cream their jeans over games where the writing/characters/story take precedent over the actual gameplay like TW3, Persona 5, MGS and GTA*
Kek, drown yourselves in bleach you little cocksuckers.

>>376719249
>Are you asking if it was fun to find out whats happened to the Red Baron's wife?
Videogames that rely on story because their gameplay are completely uninteresting are failures. Mainly because those stories are always trash due to the fact that good writers never touch this industry.
No, a guy hitting his wife because that wife cucked him and her leaving is not interesting, yet the game wastes about 7 hours on that.
Doesn't help that is followed by Novigrad where the entire game slows down to a crawl.

>wut?
It's a videogame made for you.
An open world where everything is marked perfectly on the map to make exploration pointlesswith an incredibly simple, retard-proof quest design.
You even have a version of the Batman vision that you need to use to scan things, you'll probably love it.

>>376719458
Ah yes, forgot that now it's the time for casuals that simply don't want to put any effort into anything, you need to be given everything in a silver plate because if not it's just too hard.

>>376719465
Oh boy, a fat as fuck redditor unironically describing actions with asterisks, as predicted in here >>376719030
Where do you come from, scum?
Which one is your favourite subreddit?

File: Jerry-Seinfeld-No-Thanks-and-Leave.gif (567KB, 295x207px)

567KB, 295x207px

>>376719478
>Videogames that rely on story because their gameplay are completely uninteresting are failures.
>failures
>TW3
Well good luck with that one buddy.

>>376719557
>casuals
>muh normies destroying muh escapism reeeeeeee! why dont they design games around me?

>>376719641
It failed at being a good videogame, I mean, look at this, the only defense you have is this >>376719458
>WOAH DUDE WHY WOULD I WANT A NON-CASUAL GAME LIKE, HELLO, IT'S 2017 XD

But yes, analyzing red clues was epic as fuck.
You know what was even more epic than that?
Doing hours and hours of boring and uninteresting fetch quests in order to get some armor that didn't look like pijamas.

>>376719775
Amazing lack of arguments and inability to defend this videogame.
Then again, can't be hard defending the Battlefield of RPGs.

>>376719636
Don't you EVER fucking talk to me like that again you little SHIT.

>>376716806
What you're saying is
>The games quality depends on its praise
Rather than
>The games praise depends on its quality

Stop being stupid.

>>376719778
>greentexting in all caps
Yep, thats your niveau alright. Also
>It failed at being a good videogame
>TW3
As said before, good luck with that one buddy. You don't have to try to convince me, so I'm not sure why you're parroting the same things in every post. Do you value my opinion so much anon? I'm sorry but I don't care.

>>376719465
Why are you here.

>>376716128
If you complain about Skyrim and like Witcher 3 you're a hypocrite and the same type of person as you complain about "ruining the industry".
Witcher 3 is the most casual "RPG" released in history, it has no stats, NO FUCKING STATS, NO FUCKING CLASSES, NO BUILDS

>>376720046
You do care since you are replying.
And now you are trying to desperately move goalposts because you can't refute absolutely anything.
As I said, could someone actually mention a quest here where you got stuck and had to think in order to progress?

>>376719871
Thats right it doesnt need defending.

>Game
Movie. And yes, it's a poorly written movie.

>>376719050
Yup. And both those things were fun.

>>376720163
You may repeat yourself that over and over since you can't defend it.
I mean, you are replying to me, so if you could defend it, you would.
Don't worry anon, this journey of doing favors to do favors to do favors to know where the biggest Mary Sue in vidya could have been before the very evil guy who does evil stuff and has a very evil looking skull mask was mind-blowing.

>>376720195
Visual novel*

>>376720151
No I don't care about your opinion about TW3. I do care about you sperging out though.
I'm also not sure what you mean by refuting. Your opinion? Because as stated, I don't care about it. You don't like the quest design. So?
If I said I like it, it would be "refuted" already. Because you don't say anything more than that.

>>376720453
I didn't say I didn't like it, I said it was casualized garbage made for the Skyrim audience.

File: 1491249269078.jpg (26KB, 656x465px)

26KB, 656x465px

>>376720092

>>376720282
>>376720151
>>376719871
This is the same guy right?

>>376720542
Yes anon, and this
>>376720453
>>376720163
>>376719775
is also the same guy.
It seems these two individuals are holding a conversation.

>>376720517
>I said it was casualized garbage made for the Skyrim audience.
And?

>>376720662
And that's a fact.
If we agree, then perfect, if not, you are wrong.

>>376720608
Actually not quite. There's only one (you) for me out of three in there.

>>376718576
>So, if a game is focused on story, it can't have anything remotely challenging?

define challenging instead of spewing buzzwords

>>376720530
> I have no argument so I'm going to resort to reaction images

Nice. Witcher 3 is a casual piece of shit. Horrendous "story" with a generic edgy villain with no motive and no continuing arcs except the Bloody Baron. Absolutely horrendous gameplay with no depth to speak of, copy-pasted quests about opening treasure chests with shit look and chasing reskinned enemies with the same fucking animation set and skeleton with a different colour schemes, what choices you make don't matter, and there's a whole load of nothing in the open world.

>>376720754
Something that isn't completely given to you in a silver plate.
If they drop you into a cave, no need to tell me exactly where to go, when to use my Batman vision, and when to use some powers.

how do i git gud at this game and not get BTFO instantly in velen right after i leave white orchard?

>>376720693
I wouldn't say agree because things like "casualized garbage for the Skyrim audience" doesn't really have any substance to it. It means literally nothing. There is no assertion in that statement.

File: 1474992374141.png (85KB, 680x680px)

85KB, 680x680px

>>376720795

>>376719478
>No, a guy hitting his wife because that wife cucked him and her leaving is not interesting, yet the game wastes about 7 hours on that.

opinions are not facts, faggot

>>376720867
Yes, it means it's a game built around the idea of wanting that audience to buy the game, thus, making it as simple and easy as possible, and ensure that you'll never get stuck in a quest, that you always complete it easily because they tell you exactly where to go and what to do once there.

The game is basically a 120 hour long tutorial.

>>376720845

I don't know what did you expect. you wanted real trapping or something? how do you suppose they would design that mechanic without you bitching? also, you don't have to use the fucking senses

>>376720904
I'm sure this generic and predictable family drama story would make Hemingway weep.

>>376720795
Nice. Witcher 3 is a masterpiece with an amazing story and great characters and great arcs like the Bloody Baron. Absolutely fluid gameplay with three different major approaches, lots of detailed quests about the people in the world and interestingly designed enemies, choices you make matter a lot and there's a whole world to explore.
Anything else?

>>376721032
>you don't have to use the fucking senses
Yes you do, you can't scan clues unless you look at them with Batman vision, and you won't be able to see footsteps and smell trails without it.

>>376721041

opinions are not facts, faggot

I will reply like that to every post without a valid argument

>>376721041
>Wife makes a pact with witches to miscarry her baby just to spite him.
>Generic
Someone skipped through all the dialogue.

>>376720864
This game is the easiest piece of shit in the world. Death March is a fucking cakewalk. You want actual difficulty play Oblivion on 100%
>>376721113
Except these statements are blatantly false you fucking degenerate casual piece of shit. Don't fucking reply to me if you can't formulate your own opinion.

>>376720940
>it means it's a game built around the idea of wanting that audience to buy the game
Well I dont think thats true anon. I really dont think CDPR wanted the Skyrim audience. Is a quest marker and the supposedly missing challenge really anything you go by to make that statement?

File: to.png (266KB, 540x547px) Image search: [Google]

266KB, 540x547px

>>376721205
>can't refute my points
>resorts to ad hominem

>>376721185
Woah, that sounds gripping and epic as hell.
Truely a masterpiece of storytelling.

>>376721223
>I really dont think CDPR wanted the Skyrim audience
https://www.vg247.com/2013/02/18/witcher-3-dev-looks-to-skyrim-for-inspiration/
>The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt draws inspiration from the gorgeous open-world of The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, but CD Projekt aims to top the Bethesda RPG’s “generic” quests and characters.
Very interesting claims.
Too bad they didn't manage to avoid making generic quests and characters.

>>376716128
It is.

>>376721205
>I don't have the attention span to keep up with the story
>I'm too stupid to know how to make a proper talent build
>I didn't do any side quests
>I rushed everything
>It's the game's fault I didn't have fun
Nice job, retard

>>376721120

again, how do you expect it to work? and yeah, although they were neccessary for the smells, you didn't have to use them for trails. I don't remember if they were needed to actually flag the trail first, but you could follow it without the super duper batman vision

>>376721113
If you consider the Bloody Baron a great character and a great arc, maybe it's time you start watching other movies other than Marvel superhero ones.

File: Witcher 2.png (2MB, 1662x1608px)

2MB, 1662x1608px

>>376718668
Literally too deep for me

>>376721337
You don't have to like it. But I've just proven that your criticism of 'generic story is is factually incorrect

>>376721337
Taking inspiration from something doesnt mean that they want the same audience anon. Like wtf?
Electronic musicians take inspiration from Jazz and classic, yet its a different audience. You gotta actually think things though man

>>376721385
>how do you expect it to work?
You mean you have no idea how an RPG without Batman vision would work?

>>376716128
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

File: 029997FE031199376580238348288_SW_WEBM_1428927870547_image.jpg (18KB, 480x480px)

18KB, 480x480px

>>376721417
>can't refute my points
>resorts to ad hominem

>>376721492

don't try to reflect the question at me, faggot, because you're shit at it

>>376716128
Its not bad but it is boring

>>376721337
>Woah, that sounds gripping and epic as hell.
>Truely a masterpiece of storytelling.
ikr?

>>376721362
>I don't have the attention span to keep up with the story
Fuck off you absolute faggot, there was no fucking story, just chase some useless bitch around for 70% of it then fight some generic black knights with no motive or origin. Also the world has no lore what so ever
>I'm too stupid to know how to make a proper talent build
Those are spells, not builds. There's no abilities, no stats, no weapon variety, no dedicated classes, it's shit
>I didn't do any side quests
I did, nearly all of them were as I described, the rest were variations of it where you run around a boring city talking to tropes or riding your fucking horse to a bandit camp
>I rushed everything
120 hours, because I was trying to find a use of the 50gb it wasted
>It's the game's fault I didn't have fun
Guess that applies to every game then right? Don't complain about Skyrim then.

>>376721492
>>376721417
>>376721337
>>376721205
>>376721120
>>376720940
Man, the 60second cooldown between making posts must drive you crazy by now

>>376721532
Fuck off, you copy pasted my comment and made every point the opposite.
>>376721113
The difference is I'm actually right, you added no individual input

>>376721641
>Fuck off you absolute faggot, there was no fucking story, just chase some useless bitch around for 70% of it then fight some generic black knights with no motive or origin. Also the world has no lore what so ever

you just confirmed what the guy you replied to said, congratulations. fucking consolfaggots, I swear. I bet you didn't even read books and other texts lying around everywhere that actually contribute to the lore even if you didn't read the actual fucking novels

>>376721641
Skyrim is one of the best sandbox RPGs ever made. Whats your point?

>>376721758
The atrocious Twilight tier "novels" that the retarded author directly states conflict with Witcher 3's complete abortion of a story?

File: chris_farley.jpg (100KB, 750x500px)

100KB, 750x500px

>>376721754
>can't refute my points
>resorts to ad hominem

File: 1493327701112.png (1MB, 1000x1141px)

1MB, 1000x1141px

>>376721641
>Todd is upset that a bunch of slavs paid 3 potatoes a week made a better rpg than he could ever hope to
Maximum kek.

File: 18119005_1022452307891338_3907317878363580612_n.png (107KB, 240x301px)

107KB, 240x301px

>>376721859

>yfw making that post and realizing you have no arguments

opinions are not facts, faggot

>>376716219
fpbp
>>376721113
This.

File: 1465313896646.jpg (62KB, 395x401px)

62KB, 395x401px

>people posting valid points against TW3
>only defense is ''THAT'S YOUR OPINION'' and ''FUCK YOU THIS STORY WAS LITERALLY SHAKESPEARE''

I think the most hilarious part of this thread is the people implying videogames are capable of having good stories.

>>376721970

stop samefagging, OP

>>376721954
Why do people keep trying to downplay TW3?
It was an 80 million videogame, it's the 19th most expensive videogame ever made and had a team of almost 400 people.
TW2 was more impressive because the budget was minimal, plus the writing was far better than TW3's.

>>376721970
>A single assblasted faggot makes sweeping criticisms
>His points are proven factually incorrect
>He resorts to ad hominem
I love these threads

>>376721970
all games should be open world open ended games where your only objective is to kill everything that moves with no motive or reason to blow off steam right

>>376721957
In this case they are.
I mean, considering how you are desperately replying, I bet you wish you had some sort of argument.
But you don't.

>>376722084
>His points are proven factually incorrect
Where?
I have seen not a single argument defending TW3, just desperate namecalling.

>>376722141
>I didn't read the thread
Please do that before posting again

>>376722137
I think if you are going to bother with the story, you should hire someone with more experience than Sonic and MLP fanfiction, which is what every single videogame writer is.

>>376722183
Mind pointing at those, of course, non-existing arguments?
Or are you just going to keep moving that goalpost at 200 miles per hour until the thread dies?

File: 7c9ef54c86a0201fc66434e7d2c6e713.jpg (17KB, 236x236px)

17KB, 236x236px

final fantasy xv > witcher 3

>>376721954
>>376721957
No argument, every point I make is met with reaction images and "YOU'RE TODD LOL". Kill yourselves

>>376722141
>In this case they are.

I have only one thing to tell you. you ready? here it goes

xD
ecks dee
small x and capital D

>>376722393
Average modern RPG apologist, everyone.

>>376722141
>>376721641
>>376721754
>>376721859
>>376722358
You need to calm down a bit dude. I can almost hear your heart rate at this point. So what? You dislike a huge popular game and one of the best games ever made. Its not your fault, its your right. You dont have to justify yourself to us. That insecurity of yours is really misplaced

>>376722273
He claims the characters have no motive. There are 8 novels worth of motive and character
He claims there are no builds. You can play the game with alchemy. A spellcaster build or throwing bombs at everything.
And his final criticism
>Generic
Holds absolutely no water because had he actually bothered to pay attention (which we have seen he didn't pay attention and skipped through dialogue like a typical console pleb) then he'd know himself that calling it generic is retarded. What other fucking game has you follow around a flying fetus? None.

>>376721970
>people posting valid points against TW3
>people
>one guy throwing a shitfit

File: Untitled.png (24KB, 1677x144px)

24KB, 1677x144px

>>376722460
Poor guy.
And yes, TW3 is a casualized videogame that has nothing to offer and does nothing new.

File: xD.jpg (131KB, 960x644px)

131KB, 960x644px

>>376722432
>>376722141

>my phone when replying to this fag

>>376722314
no

>>376716128
Ok, and?

>>376722554
>>376722393
This is the kind of 'people' who defend post-2006 videogames.

>>376722546
>Phoneposting to dodge the (yous)
Pathetic

File: 1449715535-6c1c9695f8996a6f8e8923e902846988.png (186KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

186KB, 500x281px

>40 posters
>151 replies

>>376722668
So yes, no arguments.
Good to see we all agree that TW3 is a very casualized videogame that has nothing to offer.

>>376722546
So there's two of you. I'm actually surprised but okay. Point still stands though. No need to justify yourself to us and act so defensively.

File: 1494558931881.png (146KB, 671x519px)

146KB, 671x519px

>>376722736
(You)

>>376722760
I do.
I like people who try, and of course, fail, to defend modern videogames.
Even more the people who pretend videogames can have good stories.

>>376722668
Oh shit I didn't even think about this. But you're right. I always forget how desperate shitposters really are.

>>376722654

I've got more where that came from, just for you

I also fucked your mom and I'm it's embarrasing to see my son is this retarded
:^)

>>376722668
Ah yes, forgot that newfag redditors forced the ebin as fug maymay of referring toi replies as LE (YOU)S XDDD

>>376722460
>You dislike a huge popular game and one of the best games ever made.
You have no fucking idea what constitutes a good game you worthless subhuman piece of shit, every fucking SBIT)(+ 09opj{ISJ{ [pei90df piece ofs fucik fuck you every "trait" of modern RPG's you complain about is 10 times more prevalent in Witcher 3. You have NO FUCKING RIGHT to complain about any of those characteristics if you like it.

File: xDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD.jpg (155KB, 575x676px)

155KB, 575x676px

>>376722862
>>376722654

forgot to post pic

xD

>>376722803
>>376722862
>>376722393
>>376721957
>>376722942
And these are the arguments offered to defend The Witcher 3.
Been a while since i've seen this kind of anger-induced meltdown.

>>376722808
>Wow look at me I'm making baseless criticisms against a legitimately good game.
You must feel so proud. You have been refuted at every turn. You have provided no legitimate criticism. All you do is sit there and say buzzwords 'casual' 'generic' you have quite literally no argument

File: 1494046817300.jpg (326KB, 996x1500px)

326KB, 996x1500px

>>376722967
You have to go back Todd

>>376716219
Fpbp

>>376722967

>arguments

I made 4 of those posts and I'm already done with arguments, now I'm just insulting you. you mad, you little bitch?

>>376722973
> You have been refuted at every turn.
And yet, you can't point at those posts, of course.
And how is this a good videogame?
It's a story-focused, unchallenging videogame where the story is fluff and handholds your through the 120 hours of analyzing red clues and following red footsteps.

>>376722967
defend this dick, cuck

File: wewlad.png (6KB, 115x62px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 115x62px

It's not a perfect game, sure it has it's issues but it's a really good game.

witcher senses make the game easy according to /v/ even though they make literally no difference in combat & are only used to immersively make you move between points during quests

>>376723072
>>376722527
>I didn't read the thread
Stop skipping the dialogue. You only make yourself look worse

>>376723069
And you started insulting out of pure rage because you have not a single valid argument to defend this legitimately bad videogame, of course.
Absolutely delicious thread.
Too bad the Witcher general is dead, I would go there otherwise just to experience these meltdowns more often.

>>376723172
>b-b-but you didn't read the thread
The goalpost moving has accelerated to 300 miles per hour bud.
I mean, if those arguments existed, you wouldn't have a problem pointing at them.
But you can't, because there's none, you just hope i'll get tired and stop replying and let this thread die.

File: witcher3gotyimage1.jpg (331KB, 1586x1048px)

331KB, 1586x1048px

>>376722808
>>376722967
>>376722939
Why does this intimidate you so?

File: 1493485912672.jpg (32KB, 540x547px)

32KB, 540x547px

>>376723176
Todd calm down plz

>>376723272
It doesn't.
TW3 does deserve to be in the same spot that Overwatch and Dragon Age 3 have been.

>>376723072
See
>>376721113

File: noose.jpg (246KB, 1000x1502px)

246KB, 1000x1502px

>>376723176

no, I insulted you for fun. I already gave you arguments, but you replied with opinions and think they are arguments. you also wasted 150h on a game you hate. you are pathetic. you are a failure. your parents hate you and you will never have a meaningful relationship in your life. you will never leave your basement. it's time to do the right thing, anon

>>376723268
>Literally points to an argument
>If you had one you would point to one
I can't even breathe. You aren't even trying at this point

File: pic-10242.jpg (586KB, 2200x1200px)

586KB, 2200x1200px

>>376723353
Then why do you act so scared?

>>376722527
>He claims the characters have no motive. There are 8 novels worth of motive and character
Which were atrocious entry level "novels" with walking tropes for characters. Also interesting how you mentioned no fucking character in the game itself
>He claims there are no builds. You can play the game with alchemy. A spellcaster build or throwing bombs at everything.
Except they're all useless except for signs and the sword, because you can excel in all of those at a low level and never need to use them because POTIONS REPLENISH ON THEIR OWN
> What other fucking game has you follow around a flying fetus?
The story is, as I said, generic. There's nothing innovative in it what so ever. Generic villains, generic characters lusting after your cock, nothing of interest. What games have you play as a hang rolling around on a ball, or a blue hedgehog that runs fast? None. That's not a legitimate argument because following that foetus was boring as fuck.

File: 2017-04-30_0005_1.png (3MB, 1920x1080px)

3MB, 1920x1080px

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WeE9AisvMY

Who comfy here ?

>>376723361
404: arguments not found.
I mean, there's no justification as to why following red footsteps is good game design, how Ciri being the biggest mary sue ever who can stop the White Frost, even though this should be impossible, makes any sense, or anything.

>>376723374
>I already gave you arguments
No, you haven't.

>you are pathetic. you are a failure. your parents hate you and you will never have a meaningful relationship in your life. you will never leave your basement
Feeling impotent always comes with rage, so i'm glad you are squirming while you try to defend this laughable 'game'

>>376723353
>TW3 does deserve to be in the same spot that Overwatch and Dragon Age 3 have been.
Widely successful? Its already in that spot. Not sure what you mean here.

>>376723361
You copypasted my comment faggot, that's not an argument, especially since it was originally against Witcher shilling while your reply just changed a few words to suit your agenda.

File: important.jpg (43KB, 800x540px)

43KB, 800x540px

>>376723493

follow your dreams anon

File: stokl.png (151KB, 312x307px) Image search: [Google]

151KB, 312x307px

>>376723493
>can't refute my points
>resorts to ad hominem

>>376723468
None of these claims are correct. You're throwing out buzzwords again. Also
>Other builds
>Useless
Just because you suck doesn't make them useless.
Once again. You provide nothing of substance, merely your own impotent rage

>>376723468
>Also interesting how you mentioned no fucking character in the game itself
Probably because the characters in the game are from the books you idiot
>Except they're all useless except for signs and the sword
>he doesnt know that alchemy is OP
>What games have you play as a hang rolling around on a ball, or a blue hedgehog that runs fast?
None of this has anything to do with story

File: 5f2eb563abb902d1663ffca7f748d8a5.jpg (9KB, 272x170px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 272x170px

>>376723576
>still can't refute a single thing
>still resorts to ad hominem

File: 1487192331298.png (156KB, 330x319px)

156KB, 330x319px

Arguments against TW3
>terrible and repetitive quest design
>overuse of Witcher sense
>bad armor design unless you are willing to grind like mad and complete countless fetch quests
>repetitive enemies
>Novigrad makes the game slow down to a crawl
>Ciri is terribly written
>story falls apart completely after finding Ciri
>Skellige is underused
>Eredin was both underused, and a Saturday morning cartoon villain
>Radovid became a Saturday morning cartoon villain too
>terrible, rushed ending

Arguments defending TW3
>FUCK OFF WITH YOUR OPINIONS
>WTF FUCK OFF GRANDPA WHO WANTS ANY KIND OF COMPLEXITY
>HAHA YOU ARE A FAILURE AND A BASEMENT DWELLER XD PLS KILL YOURSELF
>AD POPULUM YOU FUCKING FAGGOT
>FUCK OFF TODD

>>376723473
>tfw you ride through Skellige and the vocals hit

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gokhBJWSjeM

>>376723647
What points?
You just said the game is good.
Could you please adress how analyzing red clues and following red footsteps for over 120 hours is good?
No?
Then we agree.

>>376723663
Crossbow=Useless
Bombs=useless
Sword=Useful
Quen/Igni=Useful

That's it, you can't make a thief, you can't make a mage, you can't make a sword and board warrior or someone wielding a two handed weapon. Every "build" is the fucking same. The difference between your idea of a "build" is the difference between a ball spell and a beam spell, minimal.
>Just because you suck doesn't make them useless.
I already stated earlier why this game was fucking easy on the highest difficulty and what FUCKING GAME YOU SHOULD FUCKING PLAY IF YOU WANT A HARD GAME YOU WORTHLESS FAGGOT LOSER BITCH GAY
>Probably because the characters in the game are from the books you idiot
So they're from terrible books and have nothing to do with the game everyone's defending? So I guess you gave up on defending the games arguments
>None of this has anything to do with story
READ THE FUCKING COMMENT I REPLIED TO YOU FUCKING RETARD
>>376723784
Hang yourself weeb

File: you.jpg (13KB, 480x360px)

13KB, 480x360px

>>376723860

OP

File: 1480181112191.png (4MB, 1240x4772px)

4MB, 1240x4772px

>>376723993
See?
This is the average argument used to defend The Witcher 3.
It's so sad that such simple arguments can cause such anger.
Must be sad living in so much denial.

>>376716128
Bad gameplay for sure.

>>376718809
This. Throwing gas bombs at some nilfgaardian jews and lighting it up with igni never gets old. W3 gives you so many ways to murder people and half of /v/ just buttonmashes on easy difficulty and keep whining how combat is broken.

File: ngbbs4f47afcd4d944.jpg (29KB, 324x286px)

29KB, 324x286px

>>376724067

OP after being so butthurt about a video game that he literally lost 3% of his fat

I'm amazed that no one ITT has even mentioned horse riding.
It's so fucking terrible that the horse riding itself is a feature in this game, not to mention that he will always choose the path that you DON'T want to follow.
Seriously, I think it's legitimately the worst horse riding mechanics i've ever played, aside from Paladins.

>>376723860
>repetitive
it isn't, you can call the game a lot of things. repetitive is not one of them
>overused witcher sense
literally optional
>bad armor design
completely opinion based, discarded
>repetitive enemies
>52 different monsters with unique properties and strategies to deal with them
>repetitive
this is just untrue
>novigrad makes the game slow to a crawl
opinion, completely discarded
>Ciri is terribly written
there is no substance in this statement, discarded
>story falls apart after finding her
No, it doesn't it picks up
>Skellige is underused
No, it isn't
>Eredin is underused
Correct, this is valid
>Radovid became a saturday morning cartoon villain
Correct, this is valid
>Rushed ending
yes
>terrible
no
dlc is what really makes it a 10/10
fantastic characters and environments

>>376723860
Arguments for TW3
>amazingly detailed quest design
>makes actual use of Witcher senses
>great and varied armor design with 4 tiers looking differently
>almost no fetch quests
>Novigrad is the best designed city in any game so far
>Ciri is a great character
>Story picks up after findinf Ciri
>Skellige is a great variation
>Eredin and Radovid are both great villains
>great endings
>DLC better than other developers main games

Arguments against TW3
>floaty combat system
>taking all the above things and turning them into negative for shits n giggles

>>376724190
>Throwing gas bombs at some nilfgaardian jews and lighting it up with igni never gets old
It does when you see that it barely does any damage.

>>376723951
>What points?
see
>>376721113

File: 1793823481.jpg (60KB, 500x495px)

60KB, 500x495px

>>376724302
>he didn't go with sign/bomb hybrid build
>he doesn't even know about the self replicating dancing star

>>376724348
see
>>376723576

File: 1485116874875.png (425KB, 1080x1920px) Image search: [Google]

425KB, 1080x1920px

>>376724279
>amazingly detailed quest design
You mean using your Batman vision to solve everything while following red clues?

>makes actual use of Witcher senses
This is a negative.

>great and varied armor design with 4 tiers looking differently
That's only Witcher armor because the rest look like pijamas.

>almost no fetch quests
Funny because you have to do hours and hours of fetch quests if you want one of those armors that don't look like pijamas.

>Novigrad is the best designed city in any game so far
Too bad it contains the most boring part of the game.

>Ciri is a great character
Pic related.

>Story picks up after findinf Ciri
You fight the Wild Hunt, you fuck it up, you prepare, you fight it again and you win.
That's it.

>Skellige is a great variation
Too bad there's nothing in it aside from the 1 hour of main quests and the 3 hour long quest about choosing the king.

>Eredin and Radovid are both great villains
Explain.

>great endings
Yes, that slideshow where you may have Ciri survive because you threw snowballs at her is very good.

>DLC better than other developers main games
They are expansions, and only stand out nowadays.
15 years ago nobody would have minded them.

>taking all the above things and turning them into negative for shits n giggles
No, for a very valid reason.

>>376724067
>example of good quest
>devs let you fail upfront just for the sake of shoving an """alternative"" solution down your throat.
Horrible quest design. I'm glad CDPR avoided that shit and let the decisions and branches in where it matters: in the dialogue.

The reasons people praise it for makes me wonder why that "game" isn't a HBO series.
The gameplay is only a hindrance at this point, especially considering how bad it is.
Could've at least been a Telltale game.

>>376724570
Too bad dialogue matters very little in this game.
So you have quests that are always completely linear except you sometimes choose a different dialogue quest, instead of having actual different ways to complete it.
Then again, that would requiere you to think, wouldn't it?

Nilfgaard is way scarier in the books when Dandelion finally starts acting like a normal person when he talks about how scary they are. Anyone who makes Dandelion stop being a retard for more than five seconds is pretty spooky. Also their helmets are sexy.

>>376724504
So you still can't refute them? Because all you did was take positive things and turned them into negatives in the first place. I simply reversed it. You still haven't refuted them tho. For good reason I guess, since you cant.

>>376724570
Yeah, why would you want quests that can be completed in many different ways when you can just always play the same linear one and then choose a different sentence?

>>376724253
>no you wrong and bad hate you
There, summarised your worthless reply.

>>376724659
>instead of having actual different ways to complete it.
But you have.
>Too bad dialogue matters very little in this game.
It does. Almost every dialogue has different outcomes.

>>376724279
Abridged version:

Arguments for TW3
>Great cutscenes
>Lots of cutscenes
Arguments against TW3
>Bad gameplay (every gameplay element, combat, exploration, pressing the interact button to interacting with interactable objects in the environment)
>Too many fucking cutscenes

>>376724279
>Eredin and Radovid are both great villains
I agree.
btw, I recommend you Avengers Age of Ultron, Ultron was so fucking epic.

>>376720092
>game has no stats and builds

The numbers on the items and on the mutations altering these further werent a indicator for all the dicks you sucked m8. It is not on Baldurs Gate or any other DnD level but come on. There are different builds and some sets were meant to be used by different playstyles.

>>376724702
THE ORIGINAL FUCKING COMMENT WAS NEGATIVE YOU FUCKING RETARD YOU REPLIED AND WARPED THE POINTS, ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS FUCKING SCROLL DOWN
>>376721113
>>376720795
WOW TAKE A FUCKING LOOK AT THOSE POST NUMBERS AND TIME ZONES

>>376724253
>literally optional
Outright false.
If you don't use Witcher sense you won't be able to see footsteps or to see smell trails.
I do understand that in order to defend such a bad videogame you need to lie, though.

File: a1e7cede6a5dc0c81cf682a21c222575.jpg (78KB, 600x429px)

78KB, 600x429px

rare pic of OP when he went out of his basement and 2 women trying to perform CPR due to a shock-induced heart attack

I bought it two days ago

>"play it anon, it is the best game!!"
>buy it for 25 fucking euros
>expect the best game
>beautiful world, detailed villages and shit
>mfw you can't do shit in this world
>mfw you can talk to maybe 1% of all NPCs
>mfw it's an RPG, but you can't even fish or cook or hunt
>mfw combat is just dodging and fast-attack-smash
>mfw the whole game is just questing, no roleplay whatsoever
>mfw Skyrim was much better

I should've listened to you guys, this game is not bad, but definitely not good.
It's just... not bad.

>>376724969
>Skyrim was much better
Not really.
I'd say you could compare Skyrim with Call of Duty and TW3 with Battlefield.
COD is a game for casuals, and Battlefield is a game just as casual for people who think they are above that.

>witcher senses are too good, they ruin gameplay
>in the previous game, Geralt is shown to be able to point out several ambushes by hearing elves breathing in the bushes and see clearly in dim light
>but finally being able to use witcher sense is a bad thing
really activates my almonds

File: 1486440585751.jpg (20KB, 473x309px)

20KB, 473x309px

>>376725079
>justifying terrible gameplay with narrative-related reasons

>>376725179

kill yourself. not even the same guy

>>376724553
>You mean using your Batman vision to solve everything while following red clues?
No I mean the varied stories and detail in terms dialogues and setting.
>This is a negative.
No it isn't because he's a Witcher. Those are his senses. Its literally what he sees. Those things should be on by default actually.
>That's only Witcher armor because the rest look like pijamas.
Medieval history isn't your strength it seems.
>Funny because you have to do hours and hours of fetch quests if you want one of those armors that don't look like pijamas.
Optional content and not a fetch quest. Its a treasure hunt. There's no NPC you fetch something for. Use your head.
>Too bad it contains the most boring part of the game.
One of the most exciting parts you mean
>Pic related.
Oh no the character isnt a defenseless women, how dare they!
>You fight the Wild Hunt, you fuck it up, you prepare, you fight it again and you win.
And the actual execution is some of the best direction in games
>Too bad there's nothing in it aside from the 1 hour of main quests and the 3 hour long quest about choosing the king.
Besides all the side quests and events of course...
>Explain.
Read the books
>Yes, that slideshow where you may have Ciri survive because you threw snowballs at her is very good.
ikr?
>They are expansions, and only stand out nowadays. 15 years ago nobody would have minded them.
That doesnt even make sense
>No, for a very valid reason.
Shitposting due to insecurity is not a valid reason

>>376725079
So, story matters more than gameplay?
Is TW3 a game played only by the Uncharted and Heavy Rain audience?

>>376725079
So having good hearing and being able to see better in the light constitutes a floating red aura that stretches for 50000000 miles magically to a quest location?

>>376724808
Abridged version:
>>376721113

>>376725053
seems appropriate, but Skyrim can at least go far more in dephts. I loved to deactivate the compass and GPS in Skyrim, never fast travel and find my way through the signs and the world itself, it was amazing.
Witcher 3 is just another Quest-Marker-Grinding game.
"go here and there, THIS is the shortest way to point A" and so on.
This is not what an RPG should offer in regards of exploration, especially if the world is pretty well done.

>>376724869
Reading compehension much? As said, you simply took positive things from the game and turned them into negatives in the first place. It was simply reversed back to normal.

If you can't even read a simple comment on /v/, I'm not surprised you were overwhelmed with the winner of over 160 GOTY awards, TW3.

It is a good game but the most obvious flaws come out when you're in combat and since that is 85% of what you do in the Witcher 3 then you're bound to run into bugs and shit like that. Also why the fuck is everything so expensive?

>>376725268
>No I mean the varied stories and detail in terms dialogues and setting.
So, gameplay being bad is justified because of story?
This is a videogame, not a movie.

>No it isn't because he's a Witcher
That justifies terrible quest design?

>Medieval history isn't your strength it seems.
Well, I doubt women in medieval times walked around in skin-tight pants, so I think they could ignore that part of history too, even more when this is a fantasy setting.

>Optional content
Sure, unless you want to wear pijamas throughout the entire game.

>not a fetch quest. Its a treasure hunt.
Oh boy, that changes everything, it's fucking epic.

>There's no NPC you fetch something for
Ah, okay, it playing like a fetch quest is irrelevant because you are fetching something for yourself instead of someone else.

>One of the most exciting parts you mean
Oh yeah, walking up and down the same streets for about 10 hours aiding some redhair with letting some mages leave and rescuing some purple-wearing retard was very exciting.

>Besides all the side quests and events of course...
Oh yeah, you have a lot of witcher contracts of killing random monsters.
And a lot of fetch quests, of course.

>That doesnt even make sense
It does, actually.

>Shitposting due to insecurity is not a valid reason
No, the reason is that the game is bad, you having no arguments to defend it proves that.

>>376725483
You know what, kill yourself, everyone else can see the fucking time

>>376725572
>Also why the fuck is everything so expensive?
Really? I actually had the problem of getting rich extremely quick. I actually started going on buying sprees every now and then to counter that.

>>376725627
>This is a videogame, not a movie.

your mom is a movie and I fapped to it

>>376725773
wtf I love TW3 now

>>376725816

good

>>376725627
Let me skip to the point that isn't just you acting like a child saying "no!"
>No, the reason is that the game is bad, you having no arguments to defend it proves that.
Oh wait, its just you saying "no!" again! But seriously, there are 166 arguments in this image: >>376723272

>>376725973
It's hilarious that you actually tried defending the game writing such a long post and now you gave up and just went for ad populum.

>>376725717
Oh boy. I pity you at this point... How can someone be so bad at reading comprehension.

>>376725728
When I first played it, and wasn't running around doing question marks obsessively and selling all the shit, I remember having money issues and thinking the same thing. But even if you do a tenth of them and sell all that bullshit you should be pretty flush.

On a sidenote: Witcher contracts should pay like ten times as much as they do, and haggling is fucking useless. Why?

>The combat is dogshit and floaty as fuck that I stopped playing and went to refund it
>The world is uninteresting, forest, swamp, forest, swamp etc
>The characters are one dimensional and just want to fuck Geralt
>The fanbase is absolute cancer and think the games the second coming of Jesus Christ

>>376726065
Not responding to obvious shitposting isnt giving up anon. Its taking the high road :^)
Also, still waiting for you to refute those 166 points. Or are you giving up?

>>376726112
Economy in the game is completely fucked up.
Witcher contracts pay absolute garbage and they are only there for completion sake since they don't give either experience nor money.
It's weird, but the most reliable way to make money is grabbing all the loot you find from killed enemies and selling all the weapons.

>>376726137
>The fanbase is absolute cancer and think the games the second coming of Jesus Christ

you misspelled prophet lebioda

>>376725627

So your argument of why it's bad is because you don't like it?

Are you telling me all the people who enjoy the game are missing something only your enlightened skeptic mind can figure out to realise that all the fun they're having isn't actual, real fun and we should all stop enjoying ourselves?

Thanks for opening my eyes. No more fake fun for me.

Memeing aside, what do you consider a good game?

[300 replies]

>>376726215
So yes, you've given up because you can't refute this
>>376725627

Which means we agree.
Good day.

>>376726236
If you got like 3-5k for doing the witcher contracts, especially considering how high leveled many are, they would have been more motivating.

And amping up experience gain by like, 1.5 would be a nice touch too.

>>376726329
First you gotta refute this though >>376721113

>Which means we agree.
No we dont.

>>376726236
>Witcher contracts pay absolute garbage

witcher contracts do pay like shit and geralt frequently walks around hungry in the books

>>376726473
Yes, of course we do, you completely moved goalposts.
You tried posting arguments which means you want to defend the game, they got completely refuted and your only argumentl eft is ad popylym.

>>376726449
>>376726236
And what would you do with that money though? I thought contracts where actually fine since they give you rare ingredients. And you dont have to take the contract to get them either. I completed a lot of them by accident walking into the enemies and finding out later that its a contract(or because its obvious since there's more to it than simply an enemy appearing)

>>376726486
How many times have people ITT said that X bad gameplay element is there because of the story?
Why would anyone prioritize story before fun in a videogame?

>>376726536
You still haven't refuted the points though. Here little boi, take it >>376721113
You also havent come up with one legitimate reason why the game is bad.

>>376726661

story is fun, kill yourself

>muh-muh go watch a movie if you want story argument

>>376726661
>Why would anyone prioritize story before fun in a videogame?
They don't? They just realize that things are there for a reason.

>>376716128
No

>>376726661
Just because you don't enjoy something doesn't mean it isn't fun for other people you sperg.

>>376726743
So, a game with a fun story and fun gameplay at the same time are not possible?
And in a videogame, why would I choose story above gameplay?

This is simply bad game design.
I have zero motivation to do Witcher contracts when selling ONE weapon looted from a random bandit is going to pay me more than 10 minutes of fighting against some monster.

>fuck
>faggot
>piece of shit
>fucking casual
>fucking generic
>degenerate
>reddit

Where do all those swear words come from? Oh right, it's another Witcher thread

>>376726612
I wouldn't scoff at the fact that I'm killing a level 35 whatever and they're trying to pay me 300 sheckels. The game scales the cost of things, and should therefore scale the rewards. It just feels disjointed and disappointing to me. But It's really just a little thing that irritated me.

>>376726875
>So, a game with a fun story and fun gameplay at the same time are not possible?
It is. Witcher 3 comes to mind.

>>376726996
No, the gameplay is pretty bad.
Plus, movement feels terrible.
Why are there only two walking speeds in this game?

>>376726932
Well I guess. I just didn't focus much on the money since as said, I already had tons of it and was glad to get it out.

>>376726875

your dad did bad game design when he fucked your mom and that's how you were born

>>376726932
That's the thing, it scales enemies, it scales loot and cost of loot, but it doesn't scale rewards.
So now i'm in NG+, where selling one random sword from those thiefs that randomly attack you in Novigrad earns me about twice what you usually get paid for a Witcher contract.

>>376727074

Opinions: the post.

>>376726897
Some people can't deal with the fact that other people on /v/ actually like a game for once. Thus the excessive insults every time witcher 3 is brought up.

>>376727074
>No, the gameplay is pretty bad.
Thats what you think. I think its actually pretty good.
>Why are there only two walking speeds in this game?
What do you need more for?

>>376727167
This is pretty much true.
Not only is TW3 a huge succes. No, its also a game that the majority of /v/ likes. Which triggers the contrarians.

File: 3073462-6780343819-Peezl.jpg (71KB, 707x500px)

71KB, 707x500px

>>376716128
NO! You take that back!

>>376727229
>What do you need more for?
It feels better, MGSV is a good example of well made controls. (too bad about the rest of the game)
Plus, when there's an NPC walking that I need to follow, walking normally is too slow, and normal running is too fast.
What's even worse is that originally there were more walking speeds, you could walk slowly like when you are in a tabern, and yet they randomly removed that in a patch.

>Witcher 3 is ALWAYS criticized for having weak gameplay

>Dark Souls is NEVER criticized for having bad story telling
>in fact, people generally defend it and try to sell it as DEEPEST LORE

Hmm...

its not fucking fair how did this garbage win so many goty awards the same year bloodborne and fallout 4 came out what the fuck is wrong with this corrupt industry

>>376727525
Modern RPGs in general are all absolute trash, no matter if they are TW3, Fallout 4 or Bloodborne.

>Hmm...
Please, avoid talking like a redditor.

>>376727510
>Plus, when there's an NPC walking that I need to follow, walking normally is too slow, and normal running is too fast.
Uh, in TW3 NPCs are set to your pace. If you go slow, they go slow. If you run, they run. And if you stop, they stop too.

>>376727510
>comparing Witcher 3 to MGSV
I must have forgotten that TW3 was a stealth/shooter game

>>376727694
I didnt play the game Im just reading about why the game is shit. your probably lying tho fucking autistic witchercuck

>>376727621
If there were contrarian awards, you'd be eligible at this point.

>>376727731
Nice reading comprehension.
No, it's an open world game, and I bet in both TW3 and MGSV you have gameplay mechanics called walking and running.
If TW3 had controls that felt like MGSV, except combat, of course, it would be much better.

>>376727525
>Dark Souls story telling
http://vocaroo.com/i/s0BO32eDoyzs

>>376727787
Yep that sums up the anti-witcher crowd perfectly.

File: Geralt.png (257KB, 299x519px)

257KB, 299x519px

>>376716128
>HURR DURR LOOK AT ME ANOTHER CONTRARIAN WHY DO OTHER PEOPLE LIKE WHAT I DON'T LIKE
There were very few contrarians during 2015 but after the fucking Game Awards happened, these faggots grew in number

>mfw when remembering Witcher threads after the release of TW2
>people discussing the games and their great writing
>in depth discussion of the pros and cons of letting Letho live, or choosing Iorveth or Roche.
>generally chill and happy

>TW3 releases
>has some good writing like the baron
>has some atrocious writing like Eredin/Ciri/The frost
>group of people who refuse to admit that the writing is fucked
>group of people who say that everything about the game is bad
>perpetual shit storm

I hate this, I wish the witcher 3 never released because now all discussion is forever ruined by you extremist faggots

>>376727789
Ah yes, contrarian, the buzzword used to try to deny any opinion that isn't popular.
Hope you are hyped for COD WW2 and that you liked Overwatch and Battlefield 1, anon.

>>376727826
>it would be much better.
But you just said that you didnt play it >>376727787

>>376727694
No, if you walk normally they always go faster than you, eventually stop, wait, and then walk and get ahead of you again.

File: Untitled.png (11KB, 391x94px)

11KB, 391x94px

>>376727992
No, I didn't.

>>376727924
Seems like the quality of discussion is tied to the quality of the games.

File: lads.png (2MB, 1374x1198px)

2MB, 1374x1198px

>#1 in PC Gamer's best PC games of all time list
>#5 in Game Informer's best RPG's of all time list
>#10 in IGN's best RPG's of all time list


Keep in mind it was only released 2 years ago and it's already considered to be one of the best games of all time.

Checkmate soulscucks and biodweebs.

>>376727924
> I wish a game I enjoyed didn't exist rather than having a bunch of trolls hating on it

why are the opinions of others so important? why can people just enjoy things without wanting everyone else to enjoy it too?
are they so insecure?

>>376728194
>Checkmate soulscucks and biodweebs.
Reminds me of the COD and Battlefield fanboy fights over which shooter is more cancerous.

>>376727925
>contrarian
>buzzword
Oh jeez... well I can also call you an ODD boy if you'd prefer that one. All about political correctness these days I guess.
>Hope you are hyped for COD WW2 and that you liked Overwatch and Battlefield 1, anon.
Haven't played them, but thanks anon. I might check them out.

File: Geralt.png (1MB, 737x919px)

1MB, 737x919px

>>376728174
more like the quality of discussion is tied to popularity and the passage of time

>>376728324
>Haven't played them, but thanks anon. I might check them out.
Hopefully.
Bad videogames need support in order to endorse the crash of the videogame industry.

>>376728095
Okay so I got rused by a shitposter posing as you. But then you still failed to realize that in TW3 the NPCs are paced to you so that line
>Plus, when there's an NPC walking that I need to follow, walking normally is too slow, and normal running is too fast.
Is complete bullshit.

>>376728378
No, not really.
TW2 was far better than TW3, plus it didn't have a pointless open world.
Far better story, too.

>>376728391
You're welcome. Try not to rage too much when you feel left out again though. Remember its just video games :3

>>376728454
Except they don't adapt to you walking slowly, only to running and sprinting, which can look weird, for example, in Skellige when you go to that banquet.

>>376728467
threadwise they all devolved into BROCHE VS LITERALLY WHO

>TW2 was far better than TW3
TW2 was nothing but a beta test run for TW3 though. Literally everything is improved in TW3.

>>376728539
No, i'll be here to enjoy it's incoming demise.
Will be fun seeing talentless hacks like Kojima, Yoko Taro or Todd Howard losing their jobs and having to work in some fast-food restaurant.

>>376728556
Except that the line in question is still absolute bullshit.

>>376728708
So we are now arguing semantics?
Goodbye then.

>>376728647
>Will be fun seeing talentless hacks like Kojima, Yoko Taro or Todd Howard losing their jobs and having to work in some fast-food restaurant.
Yeah that'll be fun. Can you tell what parallel universe this is happening in? I'd like to see that too.

>>376728750
Semantics? I'm sorry what? This has nothing to do with semantics. The line:
>Plus, when there's an NPC walking that I need to follow, walking normally is too slow, and normal running is too fast.
Is factually wrong. Everyone who played the game knows this.

>>376728792
It will happen within the next decade due to quality of videogames dropping like a rock, and videogame sales stagnating.
Look at big franchises, costs keep going up yet, for example, Battlefield 3 is still the best selling BF or MW3 is still the best selling COD.
This is what will eventually cause it's demise.

File: Untitled.png (163KB, 1206x144px) Image search: [Google]

163KB, 1206x144px

>>376728903
He's right.

>>376716128
"kjhuifhaishasushas" here is your response

>>376728916
And is that the same parallel universe that Kojima and Howard are working at a fast food restaurant? Just making sure, so I dont miss it.

>>376729051
Well, I'm sure someone could argue that the future, and the past, are parallel universes.

>>376728991
Wtf is that screenshot supposed to say? No he isn't.
Normal walking isnt too slow and running isnt too fast. The NPC pace is set to those two paces.

>>376727525
They both have shit gameplay and shit stories

>>376729132
No just making sure on what level of retardation you're actually on.

File: 1494323587011.jpg (140KB, 732x701px)

140KB, 732x701px

>>376716128
it is objectively the best game every released stop being a contrarian faggot Michael, you're 30 now, grow up

Really sad shit to see how some of you care so much about video games (a video game being bad). Must be hard to know that the only thing in life that you got is video games.

>>376716854
>my tastes are better

holy shit this is pure autism

the game is O K

>>376716128
lol

TW3 is shit.