Wait, we all do agree that SMW is the best Mario game, right?

I like it a lot but I'm not in a position to call it the best

The best 2D one for sure.

No, the best 2D Mario game is SMB3.

Hard to decide between this and the third.

>>376705128

Content wise yes, but SMW has more mechanical depth which makes it the superior game in my opinion.

>>376703927
It is a hard choice between SMW and MB3

>SMW has more mechanical depth
is this why I prefer SMW to SMB3, and why I prefer 64 and sunshine to the Galaxy games?

>>376703927
no it sucks, 3 is much better

>>376703927
It's not SMB3, so I'm afraid that disqualifies it for position of best.

>>376705371
>SMW has more mechanical depth

Are you referring to the spin jump, feather cape, and Yoshi? That's an interesting perspective I haven't heard before. I feel like disagreeing with you because I prefer SMB3, but I don't have any solid counterarguments, so I'll just back off.

>>376703927
I agree, only because of the sound it makes when you spin jump on a saw. I wish I knew you could spin jump on saws as a kid.

Depends if Yoshi Island is considered a Mario game.

Outside that yeah with Mario 2 USA being a close second.

>playing platformers
I thought you had to be 18 to post on this board.

>>376708237

>Implying people under 18 have played SMW.

*bing*
*bing*
*1up*
Wa-hoo!

>>376703927
NO
I AGREE WITH NOTHING
NOOOOOOOOOOOTHING

>>376705985

>Being this reasonable.

Stop it, Anon. This is irritating.

It wazs one of the first games I ever played, didn't even have internet and had so much fun.
My top game though would be either smb2 or mario & luigi superstar saga.
>TFW you'll never play Mario & Luigi SSS for the first time when your country is being blown to oblivion again.