Best dungeon in p5?

>Music
Casino > Bank > Art Gallery = Pyramid > Ship > Castle > Space Station
>Theme/aesthetic
Bank > Art Gallery > Casino > Space Station > Ship > Castle > Pyramid
>Quality
Bank > Castle = Casino > Art Gallery > Ship > Space Station > Pyramid

I'm a Harufag, so don't think its bias

>>376591771
I thought the Casino was one of the most generic dungeons, honestly

Anything that isn't the Space Station or Ship

>>376592041
>I don't like challenge

>>376592118
>guess the weakness or waste your turns on resistances
>oh nice you finally got it

>misleading tips are good for constantly moving objective bosses

The negotiations you made in that place were good but the "puzzle" maze afterwards was ass

>>376592118
I liked ship, but Space Station was just boring, and i say that as a /m/an who loves spess and sci-fi.

Casino was the best. Spaceship is weak and made worse because it's sandwiched between the two strongest palaces.

I really don't get why people love the Casino the most, it was one of the least interesting dungeons in terms of mechanics.

I also don't get why people dislike the Space Station which is clearly one of the best dungeons in my mind

>>376592551

Casino had a great visual aesthetic with catchy music, which can go a long way towards making hours of putzing around enjoyable. I also enjoyed the boss, though maybe some people got burned on the luck aspect and didn't care for it that much.

Space Station had unpleasant music, those three switch "puzzle" rooms that were just boring, and a boss fight that was 60% fighting the same shit you just killed in the dungeon.

>>376592551
Casino is saved by having an interesting location, good music, and having Akechi temporarily along with a good boss fight at the end

Space Station is mixed in quality by having a really strong start with the breaks/talks finding the one guy you need ending with a weak maze.

Plotwise the Space Station has Morgana and Ryuji being complete assholes, Haru is rushed, and a really boring part of the story in general, whereas the Casino is when shit goes down.

I hate all of them, but Space Station was easily the worst one.

File: 1432884758846.jpg (35KB, 468x317px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 468x317px

>>376592759
>>376592734
>>376592713
>Tfw im the only space station fan in the thread

>>376592903
it's ok i liked it

File: 1494357101770.jpg (591KB, 2000x2000px) Image search: [Google]

591KB, 2000x2000px

>>376592903
It's ok it's your opinion anon

I liked the art gallery the best solely for the heist moment at the end.

File: 1494226728289.jpg (79KB, 720x774px) Image search: [Google]

79KB, 720x774px

Absolutely despise the ship

Pacing was garbage, it was literally shitty mouse puzzle into mini boss 4 times in a row, with a few search quests in between. Talk about tedious and shit.

>>376593184
Nice

Really dug the bank and the casino both feel like you're pulling a major heist. Gallery is also really good and castle is striking.

Art gallery has the best little moments. Ship is alright built up the boss pretty good.

Space station and pyramid are the weakest in my opinion.

File: 1492822863887.png (163KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]

163KB, 512x512px

>>376591449
In descending order,
>Casino
>Castle
>Museum
>Pyramid
>Bank
>Mementos/Qliphoth
>Ark
>Space Station

Okumura's palace is easily the game's low point. I wouldn't consider mini-bosses out the ass, timed encounters, and a glorified game of Simon for a final boss to be interesting mechanics, just tedium. The issue is further compounded by the general sense of fatigue that comes with the escalation in shit-flinging between Ryuji and Morgana, the hurried introduction of Haru, and the simple fact that the Phantom Thieves only went after Okumura because he was there.

There's no buildup and there's little in the way of payoff - it's just there.

File: 1492810075920.png (153KB, 350x344px) Image search: [Google]

153KB, 350x344px

>>376592118
The Space Station isn't a challenge, it's an exercise in patience. The entire palace is designed to waste as much of your time and resources as possible.

Music wise, the art gallery. It has the best music in the entire game.

Design wise, both the vault and the space station were good because they felt like actual dungeons with keys and puzzles and so on rather than a simple sequence of rooms which the others suffered from.

Worst dungeon: the final dungeon. What a joke.

>>376592118
>>376592041
Ship is fine. Space Station can go gargle a mountain of dicks.

>>376593346
>>376592041
I liked the Ship, the mouse puzzles were fine in my opinion. I guess I liked it so much since you were getting back at the guy who ruined your life and was connected to every Palace before except Kamoshida.

>>376594526
Is it just me or did Mementos Depths didn't really feel like a dungeon? You just went down a corridor, do a puzzle and fight some enemies until you get towards The Temple.

>>376591449
>museum looked most stylish
>pyramid had best music
>bank and museum for best bosses
Worst dungeon goes to Mementos' Core. It looked random generated as fuck even though it was decently mapped. It's boss was also complete garbo.

Who does the Deadly Sin of Sloth go to?

I thought it'd be Futaba but somehow Wrath is acquainted with hers?

>>376592118
It's not even challenging. Just tedious and test the limit of patience. Doesn't help the robots have an extremely annoying voice.

>>376595517
She is not technically slothful, her palace was actually the twisted idea that her mother was wrathful and hated her, wanting her dead

>>376595332
Pyramid was so comfy

>>376595517
sloth is the final dungeon. It's very obvious if you talk to the prisoners.

>>376595517
The people of Tokyo.

>>376595987
>>376595936
Yeah that does makes sense when the prisoners don't want to do anything and want the end of the world.

File: Sigh.png (446KB, 849x477px) Image search: [Google]

446KB, 849x477px

>>376594215
>Awakened Sae in her Shadow attire will never join your party in place of Akechi as Light/Dark/Almighty Mage
>Morgana will never cuck off forever and allow Kawakami to join your party as Becky in his place as Windmage/Healer

>>376591449
I really liked the Pyramid, mostly because of the music, the puzzles (yeah they were easy but I like those types of puzzles) and the fact that it was the only palace created by someone who isnt an evil dick and needed help.

>>376592713
Is there a luck aspect? Every time the wheel spun I picked my bet at random and got what I wanted, and I managed to die close to the end and had to do it twice, all successful.

>>376596454
i wish we could keep futaba in those clothes though

>>376595332
>bank [...] for best bosses

What? Unless you're including mini-bosses, because I don't remember most of them. The bank boss didn't stand out much to me.