So which is worse?

File: why.jpg (18KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 480x360px

Sonic 06.

Sonic 06 at least has some fun bits to it.

Sonic Boom is entirely a fucking drag from beginning to end.

There aren't any bad sonic games its just redditors spouting shit they heard on youtube. You have to play the games to complain fag.

>>375776835
this

They're both pretty terrible games, but Sonic 06 definitely takes the cake

Sonic and the secret rings is the worst

06 at least has that "so bad it's good" appeal.

Boom may be a better game on a technical level, but it rides that line of mediocrity just well enough to also be boring.

>>375776850
Funny. I think the opposite is true. Sonic Boom has funny bits. Sonic 06 its just a drag and your opinion seens based solely on the sonic 06 meme.

>>375776659
Sonic Boom has some genuine "I chuckled" moments. It is also an almost ok game, which sonic 06 never came close.

>>375776659
06
>Made by Sonic Team
>Reboot of the franchise
>Anniversary game

Sonic 06 is an unmitigated disaster.

Sonic Boom is just mediocre.

>>375776659
sa2

>>375776659
Sonic boom by far is worse. I played Sonic 06 when it first came out, and thought it was pretty good (definitely not as good as SA2B, but still pretty good). Sonic boom, however, was 100% unplayable

>>375776879
There are most definitely bad games and fanboys are the worst for defending shit. Stop dragging the series through the mud and let a real fan like taxman fix the franchise.

>>375776659
Boom is mediocre and glitchy throughout whereas 06 is downright unplayable during certain segments.

So 06 I guess, although Boom comes awfully close. I wouldn't recommend anyone touch these games unless they're masochistic, and I'm a fucking idiot for having played them.

>>375777489
Terrible opinion. Sonic 06 at least had some fun parts (such as running away from the tornado in crisis city). Sonic boom starts off low and literally stays low the entire time (gets worse at some points even)

>>375777379
This kinda. Sonic Adventure was pretty meh at best and bad at worse Big And instead of getting better it just kept getting worse. 06 was just so bad that people forget how bad the Adventure games were. Genesis and some of the Advance games were really the only good Sonic games. And even with those there are better 2D platforming games.

>>375776835
Personally, I'd say this.

but it really depends on how you look at it. As >>375776850 said, Boom could end up being worse if you look at it like that.

>>375776659
Sonic Boom is 'technically' a better game. Its glitchiness doesn't actively hurt your ability to beat it. But I enjoy 06 more because it is such a huge train wreck in every way that it becomes fascinating. Just the idea that they thought to have Sonic in a love story, nonsensical time shenanigans, and all those fucking Silver levels baffles me, Plus the glitches are so game breaking that it joins Big Rigs at the level of being so broken that finding glitches becomes fun.

File: boostshit v2.png (170KB, 1370x792px) Image search: [Google]

170KB, 1370x792px

>>375776879
this. Sonic 06 is actually better than boostshit generations/colors30fps/unleashed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yu2XhWSvjMo

If both games had been completed properly then 06 would've turned out to be the better game because it would've at least had consistent and inoffensive gameplay, whereas 06 would've still had garbage mach speed sections, garbage Silver gameplay, and the garbage last story.

Boom since Sonic 06 has good music, and had good graphics for it's time.

Outside of the hub world, 06 is an average platformer. Sonic Boom has literal zero appeal to it.

>>375776659
Boom by a fucking mile. You can have some fun with 06 since it's a broken half-finished mess of a game. It plays like a half-finished SA1, and at its best can be genuinely enjoyed.

Boom is just bad, monotonous, and incredibly tedious. There is not a single part to the game that is worth playing.

>>375778206
>Sonic 06 had good graphics for its time
Pre-rendered cutscenes don't count. 06 looks worse than a good PS2 game.

Boom is. Sonic 06 is basically just Sonic Adventure 3 with a retarded story and absolutely zero improvements to the platforming/camera; it would have been fun okay in 2000 maybe. Sonic Boom is just a genuinely terrible game.

>>375776659
>Tfw the original reason you bought a 7th gen console was to play Sonic 06

>>375778424
Sup B.

>>375778182

>06 would be a better game than 06

???

File: f1fbdd79-ec44-487f-80b0-3c84f185a47d.png (732KB, 922x703px) Image search: [Google]

732KB, 922x703px

>>375776879

>>375776659
nothing is worst than 06

>>375778561
Boom would've been better is what I meant. Boom had plenty of questionable design choices but the gameplay, if it was finished, would've at least been inoffensive, if bland. 06 had too many bad design choices at the gameplay level, and those are things that can't simply be fixed with more dev time.

File: 14733458_1819581304992775_160862579822952448_n.jpg (34KB, 480x480px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 480x480px

>there have literally only been about 6 good sonic games out of over 50 releases in its 26 year existence
>this series continues to exist and make yearly releases despite being consistently awful

>>375776659

Sonic Boom is worse. But 06 was made by SEGA themselves. I mean at least the guys who made Boom were amateurs.

File: boostshit.png (33KB, 1360x1216px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 1360x1216px

>>375777016
>>375777249
>>375777250
>>375777748
>>375777969
>>375778935
FUCK YOU DUMB NIGGERS, YOU DIDN'T EVEN PLAY THE GAME! YOU ARE JUST REGURGITATING WHATEVER SHIT YOU SAW SOME YOUTUBER SPOUT. TELL ME ONE (1) THING WRONG WITH SONIC 06 RIGHT NOW INSTEAD OF SAYING
>meheheheheh so bad!! bad gem!! meheheheh!!!
>meheheheh111 its so terrible full of BUG! meheheh!
>mehehehe i like boostshit games memeheheheh!!
>>375777379
kill yourself subhuman trash

>>375776659
Boom has no redeeming qualities. At least 06 has a good soundtrack.

>>375776659
Sonic Boom was made as a spin-off to the Sonic franchise and doesn't drag the main games down. Sonic 06 on the other hand will always be a main Sonic entry

>>375776659
Boom

I had fun with 06 in some parts and when the game is stable its just sort of average and inoffensive. Some levels have a nice aesthetic even if the GIA is shit because the hedgehog engine was still in development

Sonic boom is playable but it just sucks. The game is heavy on combat, yet doesn't have a varied setlist of different combos to use. And the constant dialogue is reminiscent of the heroes and shadow days when everyone would NEVER SHUT THE FUCK UP

>>375776879
>tripfaggot calling anyone else reddit

Sonic 06 is probably worse but it's kind of funny.

Sonic Boom is just irredeemably bad.

>>375776659

>One is a side-game made by gaijins, terrible framerate and glitches but still playable but at least the cartoon is good.

>The other one is an attempt of a AAA game and a reinvention of the series, the debut of Sonic in the "new-gen", with a lot of talent behind it, made in glorious nippon by SEGA themselves but is full of shit that's not welcome in a Sonic game, namely a shitload of "sidequests", talking and fucking loading screens, full of glitches too, a dissapointment.

I think we all know which is worse.

>>375776659
Wasn't Boom at least patched and made relatively playable? 06 was just a complete mess

>>375779657
>least the cartoon is good
That's just putting it mildly.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HFJwoVL9sAE

>>375776659
sonic 06 was basically watching a huge budget play/performance that not only was beyond shit in the story department, and the set kept falling apart constantlly
that the fact it was going to be shit aside from cynicism and doubt
which means it an amazing spectacle

Sonic Boom on the other hand had all the makings it was going to be shit after the first bit of gameplay was shown

Tie in game to a tv show
"reimagination"
done by a literally who team instead of sonic team
Cry engine on the Wii U
Gameplay looked mediocre from the start

File: 1493462786672.png (307KB, 680x800px) Image search: [Google]

307KB, 680x800px

>>375776659
Boom twisted Sonic into something else entirely and raped it dead. 06 was a failure in that it didn't succeed in any of the ways it tried to experiment.

They're both bad, but 06's heart was in the right place, and I could honestly see some minor fixes turning it into something pretty enjoyable (loading screen fix, tweaked physics, improvements to homing attack, general bugfixing, etc.). Boom is not salvageable and is terrible on a fundamental level.

>>375776659
06 is a worse game but Boom is boring.
06 is broken as fuck and can be laughed at. Boom is just a boring and bland game.

06 also has good music.

File: shadow-the-hedgehog-xbox-pal-medium-poster.jpg (71KB, 500x707px) Image search: [Google]

71KB, 500x707px

>>375776659
There's literally nothing worse than this

Sonic 06 is worse for what it represents. Sonic Boom is mechanically worse.

>>375779819
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c1nFnykGu14
I barely followed chris but the fact that this is in an official cartoon is hilarious

How could you say Boom is worse when '06 is all stupid bullshit and loading screens
Boom is just a mediocre licensed game

>>375780191
the music was good and the branching storyline was a nice idea if it actually mattered

>>375780191
Hating Shadow is a meme. It's laughably edgy but its the last decent 3D Sonic game we got that isn't boostshit.

>>375777710
>Sonic 06 at least had some fun parts

Yeah but they were few and far between, plus 06's lows are lower than anything in Rise of Lyric because they actively impede on your ability to complete the game.

But whatever, it doesn't matter, this is a stupid argument because they're both shit and the bottom of the barrel for Sonic.

>>375780191
better than boostshit trash generations/colors/unleashed tho

>>375780410

Shadow is so edgy it almost seems like they were trying to write a parody at points.

>this is like stealing candy from a baby, which is fine by me!

>>375777379
WHAT GOES UP MUST COME DOWN

File: Clorox.jpg (238KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

238KB, 1000x1000px

>>375779386
Butthurt Sonic Adventure fag detected! Here this will make you feel better!

>>375780191
06 is worse than shadow in basically every way except, funnily enough, Shadow's character.

>>375780027
>06 was a failure in that it didn't succeed in any of the ways it tried to experiment.

Did you play 06?

Because it was a failure in more ways than just "failing at what it tried to do".

>>375780628
great argument boostshit faggot
hope u drown in ur own vomit while u sleep, fat piece of shit faggot

File: sonic_heroes_wallpaper_024.jpg (75KB, 800x640px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 800x640px

>hello, I'm the last good 3D sonic game

>>375780827
no

File: (you).png (142KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]

142KB, 223x311px

>>375779386

>>375780827
No you weren't

>>375780770
Its experimentation is what led to key parts of the game breaking. That's what made it bad.
A lack of understanding of the new hardware that just became available is a big part of this.

06 has good music and at least has faithful character designs

You also actually GOTTA GO FAST when the game isn't glitching.

BOOM is just an utter piece of shit no matter where or how you slice it.

>>375779386
>story is needlessly serious for a sonic game
>features interspecies relationships for no reason
>continues the tradition of barely even playing as sonic in a sonic game and without warning in a stage, you can be forced to start playing as tails, knuckles or someone else
>stages carry on way longer than necessary and the segments in the sonic levels where you have to run forward at super high speed reduces a game about precision platforming and speed to trial and error
>silver stages are slow and most of the time in those stages are spent waiting for your stamina meter to fill back up
>notable slowdown when more than 2 enemies are on the screen
>if you stand on a box as sonic and do that leg sweep move, you can launch the box into the air and out of the skybox
>pointless side quests for pointless characters in a empty hubworld that arbitrarily keep you from progressing in the story
>loading screens out the wazoo

>>375780027
>Boom twisted Sonic into something else entirely and raped it dead. 06 was a failure in that it didn't succeed in any of the ways it tried to experiment.
I would say the opposite. Boom was failed experiment, 06 was a culmination of what was wrong with the series.

File: 1493178118296.jpg (59KB, 717x880px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 717x880px

>>375781741
>Dislikes the interspecies relationships

>>375780268
>Never played any Sonic game outside of a small handful of times over my friends with Sonic 2
>Only really knows the memes
>Been watching the cartoon since it started and loving every moment
>Actually excited about Mania
Fucking Sonic cartoon and the Twitter account is the best thing to ever happen to him in 20 god damn years.

Sonic Boom looks boring to play.

>>375781846
>06 was a culmination of what was wrong with the series.
What was wrong with the series was the fact that they always loved to do half baked experiments instead of building on what worked

>>375777250
So Boom is worse, then.

>>375777969
This. Finding glitches in 06 is hilarious, at least.

Sonic '06 was supposed to be some big comeback after the lackluster reception of the past few titles.

Meanwhile from the moment it was announced no one expected anything from Boom.

>>375776659
06 at least graced us with the Game Grumps golden age.

>>375779386
It's ok to love the game, you were a retarded kid when you played it, you didn't know any better. Just don't try to replay it, or you'll realise how shit SA2 actually is.

And don't argue that it's good on a korean backpacking forum. It's rude to tell lies.

File: 1492646795363.png (21KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 900x900px

>>375781741
>>story is needlessly serious for a sonic game
Who gives a fuck about story? I want gameplay. This game has good, non boostshit gameplay.

>continues the tradition of barely even playing as sonic in a sonic game and without warning in a stage, you can be forced to start playing as tails, knuckles or someone else
That's good if you like variety, but I guess if you are too autistic and need a warning for everything I guess this could be a con. This is subjective.

>stages carry on way longer than necessary and the segments in the sonic levels where you have to run forward at super high speed reduces a game about precision platforming and speed to trial and error
Better than generations 30sec stages. I loved Heroes because of stage length. This is subjective.

>silver stages are slow and most of the time in those stages are spent waiting for your stamina meter to fill back up
no1 care, treat silver stages as a minigame

>notable slowdown when more than 2 enemies are on the screen
this is a problem with console gaming that you have to live with. Devs try to impress people with graphics and end up affecting the game. Sure w/e, this is technically a con, but it doesn't ruin the whole game.

>if you stand on a box as sonic and do that leg sweep move, you can launch the box into the air and out of the skybox
then don't stand on a box as sonic and do that leg sweep move

>pointless side quests for pointless characters in a empty hubworld that arbitrarily keep you from progressing in the story
ok

>loading screens out the wazoo
put an SSD on your console & get digital version, problem solved

File: eat shit.jpg (8KB, 200x252px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 200x252px

>>375782680
>This game has good, non boostshit gameplay.
>06 has good gameplay
stop any time

File: Untitled-11-Recovered.jpg (26KB, 493x493px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 493x493px

Sonic Team at least tried to make a good game with Sonic 2006, and you could at least tell they put some soul into it in spite of the complete disaster it ended up become. Sonic Boom, meanwhile, is an absolute monstrosity of corporate and artistic cynicism; every aspect of its design is a clear and present insult to the player and a desecration of video gaming itself along with betrayal of the joy thereof. It is, for want of an accurate summation, rape in video game form.

File: 1493294156298.jpg (27KB, 296x385px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 296x385px

>>375776659
Do you really want me to tell you? because i can

>>375778206
>>375778079
>>375776850
>>375779249
>>375779512
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oq8AgIS3ZgU
Defend this.

File: PERSPECTIVE.png (3KB, 315x280px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 315x280px

>>375783054
hurr its not boostshit ree

Metal Sonic's one attack in Sonic Boom makes no sense and makes my head hurt.

>>375782808
the fact that when you move your control stick in any direction and sonic actually moves to that direction makes it infinitely better than generations/colors/unleashed. see >>375778079

>>375779386
boostshit sucks but so does sa2

>>375783154
There's absolutely nothing wrong with gradual turning. Especially when you're moving fast.

In fact, too tight turning can be a detriment at high speeds.

>>375783054
the way tails moves looks very good. Put generations next to it and you'll see

File: 1357858794580.jpg (91KB, 361x277px) Image search: [Google]

91KB, 361x277px

Sonic 2006 is certainly worse overall given that it is nearly unplayable, the 2srs5u story insults your senses, the pages and pages of documented technical problems encountered in a standard play through, and that everything about the game design is a crime against nature. However it loops around into 'its bad that its good' territory since you can have moments of seeing how low it can go and the ease of completely breaking the game on a regular basis.

Boom is just a middling piece of crap that's more half baked and sloppy. It's like a modern version of the generic shitty PS2 platformer and ultimately everything about the gameplay is boring as fuck. The game at least functions despite its technical problems, lack of production values, horrible music, and stapled on Sonic elements. Is it the better game? Yes since basic movement works more often than not. Will you have more fun with 2006 because its just that awful? Probably.

>>375783278
yes there is. You can't platform properly with generations physics. you'll be boostshitting into walls all the time, whereas in adventrue/heroes you'd smoothly & precisely jump over and then go on.

>>375783154
does it bother you that Sonic builds up speed when turning in the 2D games?

>>375783503
>turning in 2D games
are you memeing me, or did I not understand your post?

>>375783597
>or did I not understand your post?
probably this. Stop and press left, sonic turns around. Now hold left. He gradually builds up to running speed instead of instantly zooming off like in Adventure/Heroes/06.

There's too much acceleration in the Adventure era games and they feel twitchy as a result.

>>375780827
No but you were a decent entry though. At least you were better than Sonic Adventure 1 & 2!

>>375783968
Heroes is the best 3D Sonic.

>>375783849
>Stop and press left, sonic turns around. Now hold left. He gradually builds up to running speed instead of instantly zooming off like in Adventure/Heroes/06.
>There's too much acceleration in the Adventure era games and they fee
I prefer fast acceleration, in generations unless you boost, it takes you a good 8 seconds to reach top speed.

>>375776835
Not for the reason you're implying.

Sonic 06 was bad because it was unfinished.
I didn't play Sonic Boom. Why was that one bad?

>>375780191
This game isn't awful though, its average but its competently made. The side missions kind of suck and it has an awful color palette which is a pretty big sin for a sonic game but besides that its alright

The worst games in the series is all that shovelware trash from the 90s, 06, secret rings, and boom

>>375784391
Because it wasn't finished either.

>>375784578
Sega isn't the kind of company to learn from its mistakes, huh?

>>375780785
>being this mad
kys

>>375784716
>you indirectly tell me to kms
>I reply with the same and you say im mad
kys

>>375784005
This!!!!!!
And maybe Sonic Adventure 2

>>375779386
>t. agendaman thread

>>375782610
dumb nigger, I play SA2b every day on steam version. Got all A-ranks from 0 to finish many times. I'm not speaking with nostalgia glasses. Mech levels are bad. Hunting is ok. But Sonic/Shadow's gameplay is the best it's ever been on 3D sonic.

>>375776659
Sonic Boom isn't even a Sonic game, nor does it play like one.

>>375776659
Boom is worse. If Sonic 06 was finished and optimized it wouldn't have been bad.

Boom was always going to be bad.

>>375780827
>10 minute long borefest levels
>Bosses you can only hit once every minute or longer on giant boring loops

It coulda been good if level and enemy design was better. Go play the first levels and boss of the hero team and tell me that's a good game.

>>375787238
Heroes is fine until mystic mansion

Which sucks because how cool hang castle was

The last 2 levels of heroes though feel like they were vomitted up, so many random paths and rails and platforms leading to who fucking knows

>>375776659
sonic boom is worse by a fucking landslide

06 is an eternal blunder made extra spicy by the fact that they had the balls to reboot the name.

>>375786312
Well then I guess you just have shit taste.

Sonic was never good.

File: received_1277058945743585.gif (2MB, 331x245px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 331x245px

>>375776659